What do you think?
Rate this book
In the Shadow of No Towers
Catastrophic, world-altering events like the September 11 attacks on the United States place the millions of us who experience them on the "fault line where world history and personal history collide." Most of us, however, cannot document that intersection with the force, compression, and poignancy expressed in Art Spiegelman's In the Shadow of No Towers. As in his Pulitzer Prize-winning Maus, cartoonist Spiegelman presents a highly personalized, political, and confessional diary of his experience of September 11 and its aftermath. In 10 large-scale pages of original, hard-hitting material (composed from September 11, 2001 to August 31, 2003), two essays, and 10 old comic strip reproductions from the early 20th century, Spiegelman expresses his feelings of dislocation, grief, anxiety, and outrage over the horror of the attacks—and the subsequent "hijacking" of the event by the Bush administration to serve what he believes is a misguided and immoral political agenda. Readers who agree with Spiegelman's point of view will marvel at the brilliance of his images and the wit and accuracy of his commentary. Others, no doubt, will be jolted by his candor and, perhaps, be challenged to reexamine their position.
The central image in the sequence of original broadsides, which returns as a leitmotif in each strip, is Spiegelman's Impressionistic "vision of disintegration," of the North Tower, its "glowing bones...just before it vaporized." (As downtown New Yorkers, Spiegelman and his family experienced the event firsthand.) But the images and styles in the book are as fragmentary and ever-shifting as Spiegelman's reflections and reactions. The author's closing comment that "The towers have come to loom far larger than life...but they seem to get smaller every day" reflects a larger and more chilling irony that permeates In the Shadow of No Towers. Despite the ephemeral nature of the comic strip form, the old comics at the back of the book have outlasted the seemingly indestructible towers. In the same way, Spiegelman's heartfelt impressions have immortalized the towers that, imponderably, have now vanished. —Silvana Tropea
The central image in the sequence of original broadsides, which returns as a leitmotif in each strip, is Spiegelman's Impressionistic "vision of disintegration," of the North Tower, its "glowing bones...just before it vaporized." (As downtown New Yorkers, Spiegelman and his family experienced the event firsthand.) But the images and styles in the book are as fragmentary and ever-shifting as Spiegelman's reflections and reactions. The author's closing comment that "The towers have come to loom far larger than life...but they seem to get smaller every day" reflects a larger and more chilling irony that permeates In the Shadow of No Towers. Despite the ephemeral nature of the comic strip form, the old comics at the back of the book have outlasted the seemingly indestructible towers. In the same way, Spiegelman's heartfelt impressions have immortalized the towers that, imponderably, have now vanished. —Silvana Tropea
48 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2004
28 people are currently reading
3,284 people want to read
About the author
Art Spiegelman
176Ìýbooks3,193ÌýfollowersArt Spiegelman (born Itzhak Avraham ben Zeev) is New-York-based comics artist, editor, and advocate for the medium of comics, best known for his Pulitzer Prize-winning comic memoir, .
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 343 reviews
April 29, 2012
I have read several reviews on here that mock Art Spiegelman as "The King" or call his book pretentious or get angry over the fact that it's short or too large in size. But let's get one thing straight here: Art Spiegelman is, without a doubt, just as important as he thinks he is. And this book is further evidence of that.
Other complaints have centered on his strong political beliefs: but, let's face it, he is right. That tragedy WAS highjacked by the right, and the American public was hoodwinked into a costly war that killed far more innocent people than September 11th did, and it lasted over 10 years. So, to be mad at him for that is to be in denial and discomfort of reality.
And even though Spiegelman may be well aware of his genius in the realm of comics and politics, he is never, ever pretentious with his readers: he is honest about his flaws, his insecurities, his paranoia, his obsessions, his weaknesses, his sadness--and that honesty translates into a beautiful and undeniably truthful work of art that captures the chaos and the fear of that historical event brilliantly.
Visually, the artwork is stunning--full color, cardboard pages--rich with symbolism, varied artistic styles, and textured, carefully rendered vignettes about the experiences and his reactions being so close to the event. Every page you turn evokes a breathtaking awe and a gut wrenching reaction.
As for the size of the book, it is HUGE! At first, I got it and thought: oh no! It won't even fit on my bookshelf! I'm going to have to lower one of my shelves just for this book. Why so big? And then I thought about it: September 11th, as an historical event has forced its way into our subconscious--and it's big, bulky, difficult to carry, demanding more and more space in the trajectory of American history and identity as the years go on. For a New Yorker, this must be even more true. The bulk and heft of this book seems appropriate. I made the space for it on my shelf.
Finally, I thought the supplementary material that inspired this work was really interesting for any fan of comics--you can see the way the form has evolved to be imbued with high quality craftwork and social commentary, and in these comics Art gracefully shows how history repeats itself and how comics have been a medium for grappling with complex human emotions for decades.
It's a beautiful piece of art that you can hand to future generations to teach them about the chaos of the moment, the saturated media around the event, and the displacement that occurred afterward that led to many Americans feeling a deep cynicism and shame. It's an important work. Long hail King Spiegelman!
Other complaints have centered on his strong political beliefs: but, let's face it, he is right. That tragedy WAS highjacked by the right, and the American public was hoodwinked into a costly war that killed far more innocent people than September 11th did, and it lasted over 10 years. So, to be mad at him for that is to be in denial and discomfort of reality.
And even though Spiegelman may be well aware of his genius in the realm of comics and politics, he is never, ever pretentious with his readers: he is honest about his flaws, his insecurities, his paranoia, his obsessions, his weaknesses, his sadness--and that honesty translates into a beautiful and undeniably truthful work of art that captures the chaos and the fear of that historical event brilliantly.
Visually, the artwork is stunning--full color, cardboard pages--rich with symbolism, varied artistic styles, and textured, carefully rendered vignettes about the experiences and his reactions being so close to the event. Every page you turn evokes a breathtaking awe and a gut wrenching reaction.
As for the size of the book, it is HUGE! At first, I got it and thought: oh no! It won't even fit on my bookshelf! I'm going to have to lower one of my shelves just for this book. Why so big? And then I thought about it: September 11th, as an historical event has forced its way into our subconscious--and it's big, bulky, difficult to carry, demanding more and more space in the trajectory of American history and identity as the years go on. For a New Yorker, this must be even more true. The bulk and heft of this book seems appropriate. I made the space for it on my shelf.
Finally, I thought the supplementary material that inspired this work was really interesting for any fan of comics--you can see the way the form has evolved to be imbued with high quality craftwork and social commentary, and in these comics Art gracefully shows how history repeats itself and how comics have been a medium for grappling with complex human emotions for decades.
It's a beautiful piece of art that you can hand to future generations to teach them about the chaos of the moment, the saturated media around the event, and the displacement that occurred afterward that led to many Americans feeling a deep cynicism and shame. It's an important work. Long hail King Spiegelman!
July 5, 2015
Art Spiegelman & his family witnessed the attack on the World Trade Center Twin Towers at close range from their lower Manhattan neighborhood and his panic, rage, fear, mourning and his overall emotional state just after the 9/11 attacks can be perceived from the following extract taken from the introduction of the book:
His teenage daughter was in her school � which was directly below the towers � when the attack happened. The personal horrors that his family experienced and his torment and panic over those chaotic days soon turns into white-hot anger at the U.S. Government, which utilized the events for their own predetermined agendas. Spiegelman who was spending more than a decade before these incidents avoiding creating comix responds with a collection of cartoon strips illustrated in large scale format depicting the 9/11 and it’s aftermath drawn from 2002 till September 2003 in a self imposed journey to find solace from the PTSD � Post Traumatic Stress Disorder � that he suffered after witnessing the attacks. His artworks brims with his personal take on the event, his feelings on the horrors of the attack, and his indignation over the �hijacking� of 9/11 events by the Bush administration which he personally believe was for their own imprudent and often morally wrong political agenda.
In order to capture the enormity of the theme he chose to present his works in double spread large-scale pages and found the broadsheet newspaper medium of �Die Ziet� the perfect platform to fully express his emotions. In 2004 these collection of original artworks, along with 2 of his essays and 10 old American newspaper comic strip reproductions from early twentieth century where published in a beautifully crafted, over-sized book which opens vertically, and each page made using heavy board stock paper which perfectly confines the work by Spiegelman. This is not a book which describes a linear story, but it is a collection or rather a collage made out of a selection of artworks and cartoon strips which allows the reader a level of interaction where he can follow the narrations in any order chosen by his own comfort and like a puzzle piece by piece the big picture slowly emerges in front of his eyes.
In �In the Shadow of No Towers� Spiegelman brilliantly mixes international and local contexts in the cartoon panels to effectively bring out the personal and political realities of post 9/11 atmospheres. One of the recurring sequences that can be found through out the book is his �vision of disintegration� conveyed through the illustrations of the skeleton of the North Tower just before getting disintegrated, and this shows the feeling of haunting that these events have over the author. The large-scale format of the paper allows Spiegelman to juxtapose his fragmentary thoughts on the event in different visual renderings and styles, which are full of outrage, wit and aggravation. The non-linear way of narration also adds to the depth of the experience. He also inspects the aftermath of the event on the very foundation of American democracy in the form of post 9/11 national security policies through some of the cartoon panels.
Some of the cartoon panels and accompanying text in the book have sharp hints of humor with an undercurrent of melancholy. The panel, which shows a chain-smoking, post 9/11 cartoon mouse version of the author with the following comment is a brilliant example for this.
�I’m not even sure I’ll live long enough, for cigarettes to kill me.�
‘In the Shadow of No Towers� is a perfect example of how graphic novels breaks the shackles of common misconceptions about the genre and makes a powerful statement by bringing personal emotions of the author blended honestly with historical or political viewpoints in a clear, representational manner. The straightforward nature of drawn images and localized narratives that are offered by the graphic narrative space makes complex socio-political cataclysms more controllable and presentable for the author and this strength of the graphic medium is utilized to the most by Art Spiegelman in this book. ‘In the Shadow of No Towers� effectively captures the events and aftermath of the tragic 9/11 attacks in a clever and moving form.
Note: Physically this is a very large book and weighs a lot � almost 1.3 kilograms or 3 pounds � and storage will be a definite issue as slotting it up in a normal bookshelf wont work due to it’s dimensions. Readers will also find it difficult to hold the book and handle it during reading.
I tend to be easily unhinged. Minor mishaps–a clogged drain, running late for an appointment–send me into a sky-is-falling tizzy. It’s a trait that can leave one ill-equipped for coping with the sky when it actually falls. Before 9/11 my traumas were all more or less self-inflicted, but outrunning the toxic cloud that had moments before been the north tower of the World Trade Center left me reeling on that faultline where World History and Personal History collide–the intersection my parents, Auschwitz survivors, had warned me about when they taught me to always keep my bags packed.
His teenage daughter was in her school � which was directly below the towers � when the attack happened. The personal horrors that his family experienced and his torment and panic over those chaotic days soon turns into white-hot anger at the U.S. Government, which utilized the events for their own predetermined agendas. Spiegelman who was spending more than a decade before these incidents avoiding creating comix responds with a collection of cartoon strips illustrated in large scale format depicting the 9/11 and it’s aftermath drawn from 2002 till September 2003 in a self imposed journey to find solace from the PTSD � Post Traumatic Stress Disorder � that he suffered after witnessing the attacks. His artworks brims with his personal take on the event, his feelings on the horrors of the attack, and his indignation over the �hijacking� of 9/11 events by the Bush administration which he personally believe was for their own imprudent and often morally wrong political agenda.
In order to capture the enormity of the theme he chose to present his works in double spread large-scale pages and found the broadsheet newspaper medium of �Die Ziet� the perfect platform to fully express his emotions. In 2004 these collection of original artworks, along with 2 of his essays and 10 old American newspaper comic strip reproductions from early twentieth century where published in a beautifully crafted, over-sized book which opens vertically, and each page made using heavy board stock paper which perfectly confines the work by Spiegelman. This is not a book which describes a linear story, but it is a collection or rather a collage made out of a selection of artworks and cartoon strips which allows the reader a level of interaction where he can follow the narrations in any order chosen by his own comfort and like a puzzle piece by piece the big picture slowly emerges in front of his eyes.
In �In the Shadow of No Towers� Spiegelman brilliantly mixes international and local contexts in the cartoon panels to effectively bring out the personal and political realities of post 9/11 atmospheres. One of the recurring sequences that can be found through out the book is his �vision of disintegration� conveyed through the illustrations of the skeleton of the North Tower just before getting disintegrated, and this shows the feeling of haunting that these events have over the author. The large-scale format of the paper allows Spiegelman to juxtapose his fragmentary thoughts on the event in different visual renderings and styles, which are full of outrage, wit and aggravation. The non-linear way of narration also adds to the depth of the experience. He also inspects the aftermath of the event on the very foundation of American democracy in the form of post 9/11 national security policies through some of the cartoon panels.
Some of the cartoon panels and accompanying text in the book have sharp hints of humor with an undercurrent of melancholy. The panel, which shows a chain-smoking, post 9/11 cartoon mouse version of the author with the following comment is a brilliant example for this.
�I’m not even sure I’ll live long enough, for cigarettes to kill me.�
‘In the Shadow of No Towers� is a perfect example of how graphic novels breaks the shackles of common misconceptions about the genre and makes a powerful statement by bringing personal emotions of the author blended honestly with historical or political viewpoints in a clear, representational manner. The straightforward nature of drawn images and localized narratives that are offered by the graphic narrative space makes complex socio-political cataclysms more controllable and presentable for the author and this strength of the graphic medium is utilized to the most by Art Spiegelman in this book. ‘In the Shadow of No Towers� effectively captures the events and aftermath of the tragic 9/11 attacks in a clever and moving form.
Note: Physically this is a very large book and weighs a lot � almost 1.3 kilograms or 3 pounds � and storage will be a definite issue as slotting it up in a normal bookshelf wont work due to it’s dimensions. Readers will also find it difficult to hold the book and handle it during reading.
September 24, 2017
"MISSING
ART SPIEGELMAN'S BRAIN
last seen in lower Manhattan, mid-September 2001"
"DISCLAIMER:
No creatures, other than the artist, were abused in the creation of this strip."
ART SPIEGELMAN'S BRAIN
last seen in lower Manhattan, mid-September 2001"
"DISCLAIMER:
No creatures, other than the artist, were abused in the creation of this strip."
May 16, 2024
Some of this is really sharp and poignant and satirical. Some of this went fully over my head. Spiegelman is a cynic and he was ahead of his peers in media on the skepticism around Bush and nationalism etc. I just don’t think I got it as a complete book/collection.
May 18, 2013
Let's terrorize the terrorists!
Yes, I did that. I started off a review about 9/11 with a Family Guy quote. You all saw it. Take my goodreaders badge away.
Too late? When did the satire on 9/11 begin? Is it still acceptable? Let's ask the hipsters.
okaay...
Yes, I laughed at the Family Guy episode. GW refounding the confederacy and starting a 2nd Civil War that resulted in 17 million dead including Cesar Millan.. it puts a nice spin on the 'what happened if 9/11 was thwarted'idea.
I guess I'm just feeling...uncomfortable? lax? unworthy? about reviewing this... I also feel that everything has been said. Jaded. I think that fits. I'm jaded.
Last year I visited the 9/11 Memorial with my two daughters, then 16 and 13.. The line was one of those bank sort of lines where the nylon rope is zigzagged and you're carried like a mouse looking for cheese until you get to the airport like security circus at the end, and through all this, all you see is a baracade. No glimpses of what to come.. My daughters complained about the line to which I gave them my evil stare and then used all my guilt tactics... then ended up telling them to shut the hell up. The mood of the crowd was light... kids were skipping and people were snapping photos... I just stared. I tried to imagine where I used to sit when my husband and I would take nightly walks to the towers. I tried to recall how repulsive I thought they looked at night, big.. well SHADOWS blocking out the sky. I tried to remember hugging one of them and staring straight up and getting dizzy. It wasn't happening. I stared at the two square holes in the ground and saw two square holes. I didn't even take in the installation, the cascading water, the names etched on the side. I do remember the trees. They were so tiny.. and the one tree that had survived the attack and then later survived a hurricane so that it could be replanted and memorialized.. it was tethered with wires, kids were trying to touch it and people were posing in front of it smiling. Jaded.
Spiegelman's story seems just as jaded in his paranoid, neurotic, disillusioned, horrorific take on the attacks. He constantly refers to his pivotal image.. "The image of the looming north tower's glowing bones just before it vaporized" It is present in each piece and it's beautiful.
He talks about visiting small town America a month after the attack--"Still the small town I visited in Indiana--draped in flags that reminded me of the garlic one might put on a door to ward off vampires--was at least as worked up over a frat house's zoning violations as with threats from the 'raghead terrorists.' It was as if I'd wandered into an inverted version of Saul Steinberg's famous map of America seen from Ninth Avenue, where the know world ends at the Hudson; in Indiana everything east of the Alleghenies was very, very far away."
His references to early twentieth century comics is astute, in a conspiratoral sort of way.. how there are allusions to falling towers...Sometimes I had to put aside my cynicism and see this for what it was.. a scared, but prolific writer, trying to figure out what all of this means and how to survive it.
"Still time keeps flying and even the New Normal gets old. My strips are now a slow-motion diary of what I experienced while seeking some provisional equanimity--though three years later I'm still ready to lose it all at the mere drop of a hat or a dirty bomb. I still believe the world is ending, but I concede that it seems to be ending more slowly than I once thought... so I figured I'd make a book."
Yes, the sky is falling.
Yes, I did that. I started off a review about 9/11 with a Family Guy quote. You all saw it. Take my goodreaders badge away.
Too late? When did the satire on 9/11 begin? Is it still acceptable? Let's ask the hipsters.
okaay...
Yes, I laughed at the Family Guy episode. GW refounding the confederacy and starting a 2nd Civil War that resulted in 17 million dead including Cesar Millan.. it puts a nice spin on the 'what happened if 9/11 was thwarted'idea.
I guess I'm just feeling...uncomfortable? lax? unworthy? about reviewing this... I also feel that everything has been said. Jaded. I think that fits. I'm jaded.
Last year I visited the 9/11 Memorial with my two daughters, then 16 and 13.. The line was one of those bank sort of lines where the nylon rope is zigzagged and you're carried like a mouse looking for cheese until you get to the airport like security circus at the end, and through all this, all you see is a baracade. No glimpses of what to come.. My daughters complained about the line to which I gave them my evil stare and then used all my guilt tactics... then ended up telling them to shut the hell up. The mood of the crowd was light... kids were skipping and people were snapping photos... I just stared. I tried to imagine where I used to sit when my husband and I would take nightly walks to the towers. I tried to recall how repulsive I thought they looked at night, big.. well SHADOWS blocking out the sky. I tried to remember hugging one of them and staring straight up and getting dizzy. It wasn't happening. I stared at the two square holes in the ground and saw two square holes. I didn't even take in the installation, the cascading water, the names etched on the side. I do remember the trees. They were so tiny.. and the one tree that had survived the attack and then later survived a hurricane so that it could be replanted and memorialized.. it was tethered with wires, kids were trying to touch it and people were posing in front of it smiling. Jaded.
Spiegelman's story seems just as jaded in his paranoid, neurotic, disillusioned, horrorific take on the attacks. He constantly refers to his pivotal image.. "The image of the looming north tower's glowing bones just before it vaporized" It is present in each piece and it's beautiful.
He talks about visiting small town America a month after the attack--"Still the small town I visited in Indiana--draped in flags that reminded me of the garlic one might put on a door to ward off vampires--was at least as worked up over a frat house's zoning violations as with threats from the 'raghead terrorists.' It was as if I'd wandered into an inverted version of Saul Steinberg's famous map of America seen from Ninth Avenue, where the know world ends at the Hudson; in Indiana everything east of the Alleghenies was very, very far away."
His references to early twentieth century comics is astute, in a conspiratoral sort of way.. how there are allusions to falling towers...Sometimes I had to put aside my cynicism and see this for what it was.. a scared, but prolific writer, trying to figure out what all of this means and how to survive it.
"Still time keeps flying and even the New Normal gets old. My strips are now a slow-motion diary of what I experienced while seeking some provisional equanimity--though three years later I'm still ready to lose it all at the mere drop of a hat or a dirty bomb. I still believe the world is ending, but I concede that it seems to be ending more slowly than I once thought... so I figured I'd make a book."
Yes, the sky is falling.
September 18, 2017
Cannot emphasize enough how interesting this work was.
A huge book, the material is more like strong cardboard and the pages are huge 'planks'.
In the first part Spiegelman recounts his emotions during the bombing of the WTC towers on 9/11 and what it all meant to him.
We even get a little glimpse of Maus!
The second part is Spiegelman's picks of comics from the past. To me they are a gateway to the past and a real reflection on today's world.
I can't think of another comic artist to have done such a work before so really Spiegelman created something ground-breaking here.
It just really made me think.
A huge book, the material is more like strong cardboard and the pages are huge 'planks'.
In the first part Spiegelman recounts his emotions during the bombing of the WTC towers on 9/11 and what it all meant to him.
We even get a little glimpse of Maus!
The second part is Spiegelman's picks of comics from the past. To me they are a gateway to the past and a real reflection on today's world.
I can't think of another comic artist to have done such a work before so really Spiegelman created something ground-breaking here.
It just really made me think.
August 29, 2020
Visual refinement in various styles. Including a surprise delight of gorgeous pages convincingly emulating the style of .
October 26, 2012
I am sad rather disappointed that Art Spiegelman who like million other readers (of Maus) before me had almost started worshipping - wrote this.
As it is - it is so difficult to find a work by this gentleman - and then when you finally get it - it turns out to be no more than a personal document - almost like a diary entry - wavering - intoxicated by paranoia - beautiful in pieces but tremendously shapeless and direction less as a whole.
The book (if one might attempt to call giant size newspaper pages put together in a compendium that) is a personal version of what happened to a John Doe's psyche in America post 9/11.
The first few pages build it up well and just when you thought your fork's going to hit the meat - you find more veggies (no disrespect to vegetarians around the world) and even before I am done understanding that my plate's cleared and the second and the third course of appetizers are again served instead of the main course.
All the appetizers (pages post the mid half of the book) are interesting on their own but do nothing to take the narrative forward.
And then you realize this was not meant to take a narrative forward either.
This is too personal a book for me to like or appreciate.
Sorry Art !
I will forever keep a copy of Maus with me but this I am not so sure about.
As it is - it is so difficult to find a work by this gentleman - and then when you finally get it - it turns out to be no more than a personal document - almost like a diary entry - wavering - intoxicated by paranoia - beautiful in pieces but tremendously shapeless and direction less as a whole.
The book (if one might attempt to call giant size newspaper pages put together in a compendium that) is a personal version of what happened to a John Doe's psyche in America post 9/11.
The first few pages build it up well and just when you thought your fork's going to hit the meat - you find more veggies (no disrespect to vegetarians around the world) and even before I am done understanding that my plate's cleared and the second and the third course of appetizers are again served instead of the main course.
All the appetizers (pages post the mid half of the book) are interesting on their own but do nothing to take the narrative forward.
And then you realize this was not meant to take a narrative forward either.
This is too personal a book for me to like or appreciate.
Sorry Art !
I will forever keep a copy of Maus with me but this I am not so sure about.
August 6, 2011
This is a massive book. Large, almost A3 size planks of cardboard which, when you actually count them, only add up to 10 (albeit huge) pages of Spiegelman talking about his experience of 9/11. What happens is his daughter goes to a school in the WTC. Then the attacks happen. He and his wife run around screaming trying to find their kid and they do. They get to safety. The attacks frazzled Spiegelman and he ended up drawing this vastly overproduced book.
Hardly inspirational or even insightful into that day is it? Lots of people running around screaming, lots of anxiety during and afterwards, and Spiegelman at centre stage talking as if nobody else realises, it was a scary time to be in NY. Really Art? That's it? Rubbish. If he'd never bothered I'd still have what knowledge I know of 9/11. If you saw any news that day you'd have more knowledge before and after you start reading this.
And worst of all, besides the fact that it's 10 pages - 10 pages!! - of Spiegelman's work, the rest of the book is padded out with old newspaper cartoons from the early 20th century. The book looks thick because the pages are printed from thick cardboard. Believe me, get this out of the library like I did before you shell about £20 on this as you'll think twice before you do.
Hardly inspirational or even insightful into that day is it? Lots of people running around screaming, lots of anxiety during and afterwards, and Spiegelman at centre stage talking as if nobody else realises, it was a scary time to be in NY. Really Art? That's it? Rubbish. If he'd never bothered I'd still have what knowledge I know of 9/11. If you saw any news that day you'd have more knowledge before and after you start reading this.
And worst of all, besides the fact that it's 10 pages - 10 pages!! - of Spiegelman's work, the rest of the book is padded out with old newspaper cartoons from the early 20th century. The book looks thick because the pages are printed from thick cardboard. Believe me, get this out of the library like I did before you shell about £20 on this as you'll think twice before you do.
July 24, 2016
Incomprehensibly neurotic and strange. Which I can understand, given the subject matter. But also, what did I just read?
The art is beautiful, of course. Just as one would expect from Spiegelman. Here, he pushes the boundaries of graphic novels to create an oversized board book, with intricate frames of Spiegelman's spiral into darkness.
Again, I can see where the neurosis is coming from. I can understand the fragmentation, to a degree. There is a thread of a narrative, as Spiegelman and Francoise rush to find Nadja at her Manhattan school.
But, then, things get REALLY weird. Spiegelman's story is displaced, warped, augmented, what-have-you by vintage (i.e. racist) cartoons from the early 20th Century, and eventually just switches to full-page reprints. Spiegelman explains how he took comfort in the timelessness (?!) of these political cartoons in the aftermath of 9/11, and explains their merits briefly.
And I'm just left scratching my head.
The art is beautiful, of course. Just as one would expect from Spiegelman. Here, he pushes the boundaries of graphic novels to create an oversized board book, with intricate frames of Spiegelman's spiral into darkness.
Again, I can see where the neurosis is coming from. I can understand the fragmentation, to a degree. There is a thread of a narrative, as Spiegelman and Francoise rush to find Nadja at her Manhattan school.
But, then, things get REALLY weird. Spiegelman's story is displaced, warped, augmented, what-have-you by vintage (i.e. racist) cartoons from the early 20th Century, and eventually just switches to full-page reprints. Spiegelman explains how he took comfort in the timelessness (?!) of these political cartoons in the aftermath of 9/11, and explains their merits briefly.
And I'm just left scratching my head.
September 23, 2013
This book was too disjointed and chaotic to really enjoy. It's more a bunch of snippets bound together than it is a story.
However, perhaps that's the point? NYC after Sept. 11th must have been chaotic, unsure, paranoid, surreal. There must have been no flow to one's reality or new expectations of what's going on. In that case, this is an exceptional book. It follows completely along these lines.
The graphics are terrific. I especially liked the use of upside down strips: part of a strip is right side up, then it switches to upside down. The world of New Yorkers was turned upside down, so why not the graphic novel telling the story?
This is a book worth checking out but don't expect a straight forward story.
However, perhaps that's the point? NYC after Sept. 11th must have been chaotic, unsure, paranoid, surreal. There must have been no flow to one's reality or new expectations of what's going on. In that case, this is an exceptional book. It follows completely along these lines.
The graphics are terrific. I especially liked the use of upside down strips: part of a strip is right side up, then it switches to upside down. The world of New Yorkers was turned upside down, so why not the graphic novel telling the story?
This is a book worth checking out but don't expect a straight forward story.
September 27, 2018
So, yeah. I liked it, but I didn't like it.
Don't get me wrong, I can understand what Spiegelman try to do, and the story about how he lived 11S, but I really prefer that part, and not when he talks about the fact itself, 'cause all of us know the story, but how it truly affect to the ones who lived it, and that 's the part that touch me and make me continue reading.
Don't get me wrong, I can understand what Spiegelman try to do, and the story about how he lived 11S, but I really prefer that part, and not when he talks about the fact itself, 'cause all of us know the story, but how it truly affect to the ones who lived it, and that 's the part that touch me and make me continue reading.
August 1, 2007
Like other reviewers I wanted to like this, but ended up feeling as though it was a bit unfinished. Excellent bits, but I'm not sure they work as a coherent whole. Then again, I don't believe an artistic response to 9/11 is required to be coherent.
August 2, 2023
The author’s personal view on the terrible events of 9/11.
January 21, 2022
This book contains the following:
An introduction from Spiegelman. I'm rarely excited at the prospect of an introduction, but Spiegelman's words here are necessary context for the subsequent comics. He concisely describes his mental state after 9/11 and his thoughts now looking back at the work he did then.
Spiegelman's 10 pages of In The Shadow of No Towers comics. Beautiful. Vibrant. This formatting-- a massive book with extremely thick pages-- is perfect for showing off the detail and care Spiegelman put into every page.
As someone who was a child in 2001, these pages are the best I've seen in terms of explaining what it was like. Spiegelman's connections to the Holocaust also mark this as necessary reading. Frankly, this should be as beloved as Maus-- it's a tragedy that I haven't seen this lauded half as much.
The choices in terms of literary comparisons and parody... they're just perfect. You can enjoy them even without the context in the rest of the book, but they are especially powerful when you understand the references. Couldn't possibly ask for more of a single page.
Spiegelman's discussion of the comics that inspired him, also serving as a brief history of early 20th century comics. Again, invaluable for the book overall. This allows even someone with no knowledge of comics history (me) to pick up on the smallest nuances of the previous pages, as well as puts the information into an accessible and entertaining format.
Color plates of all comics mentioned by Spiegelman prior. Again, a great use of the large and vibrant formatting-- there's no better way to read these comics, which is perfect for Spiegelman's explanation of how and why he referenced them. You really get to compare the originals with Spiegelman's references in his work.
--
I note the contents because each require specific praise, and whenever I look at the book I marvel at how simultaneously large and small it is. It's about as thick as your average novel, but the height is incredible. And then you look at the thick pages, and you think about the fact that only 10 (well, 20, since they're sideways-- another great choice) are the comics, and you wonder what in the world is happening there. Well, this is your answer.
In general, I read through the book generally I thought often of the unique and creative design/ I'm still looking for an opportunity to buy this and make it a part of my home collection. I would recommend it to just about anyone, but especially to those who weren't around for 9/11. This book is beautiful, fascinating, and perfected by Spiegelman's trademark raw honesty.
An introduction from Spiegelman. I'm rarely excited at the prospect of an introduction, but Spiegelman's words here are necessary context for the subsequent comics. He concisely describes his mental state after 9/11 and his thoughts now looking back at the work he did then.
Spiegelman's 10 pages of In The Shadow of No Towers comics. Beautiful. Vibrant. This formatting-- a massive book with extremely thick pages-- is perfect for showing off the detail and care Spiegelman put into every page.
As someone who was a child in 2001, these pages are the best I've seen in terms of explaining what it was like. Spiegelman's connections to the Holocaust also mark this as necessary reading. Frankly, this should be as beloved as Maus-- it's a tragedy that I haven't seen this lauded half as much.
The choices in terms of literary comparisons and parody... they're just perfect. You can enjoy them even without the context in the rest of the book, but they are especially powerful when you understand the references. Couldn't possibly ask for more of a single page.
Spiegelman's discussion of the comics that inspired him, also serving as a brief history of early 20th century comics. Again, invaluable for the book overall. This allows even someone with no knowledge of comics history (me) to pick up on the smallest nuances of the previous pages, as well as puts the information into an accessible and entertaining format.
Color plates of all comics mentioned by Spiegelman prior. Again, a great use of the large and vibrant formatting-- there's no better way to read these comics, which is perfect for Spiegelman's explanation of how and why he referenced them. You really get to compare the originals with Spiegelman's references in his work.
--
I note the contents because each require specific praise, and whenever I look at the book I marvel at how simultaneously large and small it is. It's about as thick as your average novel, but the height is incredible. And then you look at the thick pages, and you think about the fact that only 10 (well, 20, since they're sideways-- another great choice) are the comics, and you wonder what in the world is happening there. Well, this is your answer.
In general, I read through the book generally I thought often of the unique and creative design/ I'm still looking for an opportunity to buy this and make it a part of my home collection. I would recommend it to just about anyone, but especially to those who weren't around for 9/11. This book is beautiful, fascinating, and perfected by Spiegelman's trademark raw honesty.
August 1, 2010
Only His High Holiness Art Shpeegleman could get away with something like this: he goes for years without publishing a whit of comics, drums up all sorts of hype and excitement, and then leaves us with what? Why, a board book! A fancily-printed pamphlet of newspaper pages, 38 cardstock pages total (including the frontispiece, introduction and everything), only 20 pages of which contain his actual original creations. Of course, those 20 pages are all newspaper-style double-page fold-out spreads, so it's really only 10 pages oversize. That means I spent two dollars per newspaper-sized page of comics on this. Mr. Spiegelman loves to be an ego, chain-smoking on stage while he gives lectures in smoke-free lecture halls, and I feel like this format is just another way for him to proclaim his self-importance.
That being said, the book is not without merit. His layouts can be pretty freaking excellent - very communicative, very inventive - and here, they did a smashing job of conveying his paranoia and capturing the general upendedness and gullibility of the nation at the time of the attacks. He seems to be a bit more okay with his own generally assish (I'm coining that word as of now) behavior than I would like, but I suppose that's to be expected. The pages do string together, but they don't really form a story; this book is more a mood-capture than anything.
Spiegelman always says that he views sequential communication skill as being of primary importance, and drawing as secondary. To a good extent, I agree; however, I feel that his work - not just in The Shadow of No Towers, but the rest of it as well - really does suffer from that assumption. He is not a bad illustrator, and had he simply put more effort and care into the drawings, he would have communicated the emotion behind his beautifully constructed pages that much better.
Last but not least, I thought the padding - in the form of vintage newspaper comics reprints - was unnecessary. His evolving relationship with vintage funnies around the time of 9/11 was better communicated by the (frankly well-executed) incorporation of those classics into the body of the comics themselves than by including them at the back in an attempt to make the book a bit thicker.
Both Spiegelman's talent and Spiegelman's hubris are quite present in this collection - the latter unfortunately moreso than the former.
That being said, the book is not without merit. His layouts can be pretty freaking excellent - very communicative, very inventive - and here, they did a smashing job of conveying his paranoia and capturing the general upendedness and gullibility of the nation at the time of the attacks. He seems to be a bit more okay with his own generally assish (I'm coining that word as of now) behavior than I would like, but I suppose that's to be expected. The pages do string together, but they don't really form a story; this book is more a mood-capture than anything.
Spiegelman always says that he views sequential communication skill as being of primary importance, and drawing as secondary. To a good extent, I agree; however, I feel that his work - not just in The Shadow of No Towers, but the rest of it as well - really does suffer from that assumption. He is not a bad illustrator, and had he simply put more effort and care into the drawings, he would have communicated the emotion behind his beautifully constructed pages that much better.
Last but not least, I thought the padding - in the form of vintage newspaper comics reprints - was unnecessary. His evolving relationship with vintage funnies around the time of 9/11 was better communicated by the (frankly well-executed) incorporation of those classics into the body of the comics themselves than by including them at the back in an attempt to make the book a bit thicker.
Both Spiegelman's talent and Spiegelman's hubris are quite present in this collection - the latter unfortunately moreso than the former.
July 12, 2014
Art Spiegelman is a worthy link in the chain of self-examining, socially concerned, cartoonists that includes R. Crumb and Jules Feiffer. Having said that, In the Shadow of No Towers (the aftermath of 9/11) is a special case.
Three word review: Triumphant Paranoid Screed
Having escaped "ground zero" just in time, but having to live in its neighborhood during the aftermath gives Spiegelman a relevant perspective that those of us, at a distance, could benefit by reading. He uses all his cartoonist chops and borrows from the formats of previously popular cartoonists to bring us into his world. Not easy, not pleasant, but for me, a way to viscerally gain understanding of how one who had to come to grips with his father's survival of the holocaust sees the events surrounding the attack on the World Trade Center.
Now, I need to decide whether to give this to someone (and what to say to get them to read it) or hold on to it for years until some one asks, "Hey Gramps, what was it like living through 9/11?"
Three word review: Triumphant Paranoid Screed
Having escaped "ground zero" just in time, but having to live in its neighborhood during the aftermath gives Spiegelman a relevant perspective that those of us, at a distance, could benefit by reading. He uses all his cartoonist chops and borrows from the formats of previously popular cartoonists to bring us into his world. Not easy, not pleasant, but for me, a way to viscerally gain understanding of how one who had to come to grips with his father's survival of the holocaust sees the events surrounding the attack on the World Trade Center.
Now, I need to decide whether to give this to someone (and what to say to get them to read it) or hold on to it for years until some one asks, "Hey Gramps, what was it like living through 9/11?"
September 12, 2017
Looking for something else in the library, I saw this and thought: "hey, it's 9/11, what better way to mark the anniversary than by reading this book!" So I did, and it is every bit as good as I thought it would be, and more. Art Spiegelman is a genius, and part of his genius is to transform horrible trauma into brilliant art. Another reason to love him is his celebration of the great comic strip artists of the past, which is given magnificent space in the second part of this gorgeous oversize book.
Highly recommended!
P.S. It doesn't take long to read, but you could spend a long time studying these amazing pages.
Highly recommended!
P.S. It doesn't take long to read, but you could spend a long time studying these amazing pages.
February 29, 2008
Art Spiegelman uses his considerable talent to illustrate the fear and confusion of September 11, 2001 -- and of the months following, when he (like many other Americans) felt the Bush administration had hijacked the tragedy. The second half showcases the weird and political world of early full-page newspaper comics, his model for his own works in this book. An excellent, important book that moved me to tears.
December 2, 2024
I read this for a graduate history course on 9/11. I am a huge fan of Maus and was very intrigued when I heard Spiegelman had published a graphic novel about his September 11th experience. I borrowed it from the library (good call) and read it through twice. The book is an interesting, though (and partially because it is) very disorganized. The book serves as a visual medium for Spiegelman to process his own thoughts and feelings on both the day itself, and more often the political response which followed. He alternates between shock and fear and anger, and the giant broadsheet pages feel like various ideas placed alongside each other, very much like a newspaper of one man's brain.
The book succeeds as a portrait of the scattered and conflicted thoughts, opinions, anxieties, and narratives that were made in the two years following the tragedy. The events are at times minimized, at others magnified. Spiegelman was ahead of the curve on publicly criticizing the Bush administration's military and political response to the attacks, and he readily admits that he was rather conspiratorial from 2000-2003. When you consider the work as a public working-out of his own thoughts, it all is rather interesting.
However, as a complete and published product, it leaves much to be desired. The scattered nature never coalesces into a meaningful idea or developed narrative. Not that Spiegelman (or any survivor) has an obligation to have a cookie-cutter takeaway and belief about that day or the many days to come - certainly, the globe still has scattered thoughts a quarter-century later. Yet at the same time, I expected more coherence and consideration for a published book. I don't have many critiques for his main argument, the primary themes, or the graphic approach, but only because the book never really finds one to stick with. And frankly, the disparate parts don't blend together that well either.
Overall, a very interesting, though not particularly good, public self-interrogation in the aftermath of September 11. Though it fails at the exceptional discussion of memory, faith, grief, and trauma that made Maus so impactful, it succeeds as a brief look into the rambling, messy process of making sense of such things. I would recommend this book to other students in my class but no-one outside of that context.
The book succeeds as a portrait of the scattered and conflicted thoughts, opinions, anxieties, and narratives that were made in the two years following the tragedy. The events are at times minimized, at others magnified. Spiegelman was ahead of the curve on publicly criticizing the Bush administration's military and political response to the attacks, and he readily admits that he was rather conspiratorial from 2000-2003. When you consider the work as a public working-out of his own thoughts, it all is rather interesting.
However, as a complete and published product, it leaves much to be desired. The scattered nature never coalesces into a meaningful idea or developed narrative. Not that Spiegelman (or any survivor) has an obligation to have a cookie-cutter takeaway and belief about that day or the many days to come - certainly, the globe still has scattered thoughts a quarter-century later. Yet at the same time, I expected more coherence and consideration for a published book. I don't have many critiques for his main argument, the primary themes, or the graphic approach, but only because the book never really finds one to stick with. And frankly, the disparate parts don't blend together that well either.
Overall, a very interesting, though not particularly good, public self-interrogation in the aftermath of September 11. Though it fails at the exceptional discussion of memory, faith, grief, and trauma that made Maus so impactful, it succeeds as a brief look into the rambling, messy process of making sense of such things. I would recommend this book to other students in my class but no-one outside of that context.
January 3, 2023
[Read in August 2022]
“I still believe the world is ending, but I concede that it seems to be ending more slowly than I once thought…so I figured I’d make a book."
Thank you to Penguin Random House and Pantheon Books for the gifted copy! This is one of the most interesting books I’ve ever read, and is so heavy (in multiple ways) that I had to read it laying on the floor. When you think about it, it really is so appropriate that the book is so overwhelming and demanding.
In the Shadow of No Towers is written and illustrated by Art Spiegelman, author of the often-banned and deeply essential Maus. Published in 2004, this is his processing of the trauma from three years prior that is truly burned into his memory. Not only does it retell what he and his family experienced, but it also recounts the paranoia, hatred, and fear that ravaged the minds of his fellow Americans as well as the government as a whole.
Spiegelman and his family lived in close proximity to Ground Zero in lower Manhattan; his daughter was in school when the whole thing started to unfold. After the initial panic and reunion, Spiegelman’s focus shifts to a seething contempt for the U.S. government and the way in which it handled and manipulated the aftermath. His artwork is brilliant, and if that weren’t enough, he has an impressive way with words.
After the first 10 massive panels done by Spiegelman, the second half of the book is made up of old comic strips from the early 1900s with plenty of annotations explaining why they were chosen for the book. I can’t stress how impressive this is; an exemplary piece that combines melancholy, bitterness, humor, and honesty. If you can get your hands on it, it’ll be worth the read even if you just skim through it.
“I still believe the world is ending, but I concede that it seems to be ending more slowly than I once thought…so I figured I’d make a book."
Thank you to Penguin Random House and Pantheon Books for the gifted copy! This is one of the most interesting books I’ve ever read, and is so heavy (in multiple ways) that I had to read it laying on the floor. When you think about it, it really is so appropriate that the book is so overwhelming and demanding.
In the Shadow of No Towers is written and illustrated by Art Spiegelman, author of the often-banned and deeply essential Maus. Published in 2004, this is his processing of the trauma from three years prior that is truly burned into his memory. Not only does it retell what he and his family experienced, but it also recounts the paranoia, hatred, and fear that ravaged the minds of his fellow Americans as well as the government as a whole.
Spiegelman and his family lived in close proximity to Ground Zero in lower Manhattan; his daughter was in school when the whole thing started to unfold. After the initial panic and reunion, Spiegelman’s focus shifts to a seething contempt for the U.S. government and the way in which it handled and manipulated the aftermath. His artwork is brilliant, and if that weren’t enough, he has an impressive way with words.
After the first 10 massive panels done by Spiegelman, the second half of the book is made up of old comic strips from the early 1900s with plenty of annotations explaining why they were chosen for the book. I can’t stress how impressive this is; an exemplary piece that combines melancholy, bitterness, humor, and honesty. If you can get your hands on it, it’ll be worth the read even if you just skim through it.
September 16, 2022
THE SHADOW OF NO TOWERS|
Thank you to Pantheon for the gifted copy💗
It took Spiegelman about 5 weeks to do each two page comic spread and many years in reflection to create this book, about the moments when the towers fell and the years after when his paranoia of the world ending and his outrage of how the govt diverted attention and media was bamboozled, and he was seemingly the only one who cared amongst new yorkers who were eager to get back to normal.
Sounds about right with where we are now too, two years into the pandemic. I can't imagine what's been running through his head...
I appreciated the latter half's inclusion of older comic plates from the turn of the century, showing politicized comics, the beginnings of the medium, and some a bit slapstick. I can't imagine a world without comics since I remember fondly reading them (the only thing I grabbed in the Sunday paper as a kid), I was obsessed with Calvin and Hobbes, Garfield, and of course Maus later.
Its interesting to consider the reception that comics forks have received as "low art" in a time When it was new. But how emotive and seemingly simple it is too convey so so much!
You can tell how gifted Spiegelman is, and I am happy he pours his sweat and time into his work that shows as much.
Thank you to Pantheon for the gifted copy💗
It took Spiegelman about 5 weeks to do each two page comic spread and many years in reflection to create this book, about the moments when the towers fell and the years after when his paranoia of the world ending and his outrage of how the govt diverted attention and media was bamboozled, and he was seemingly the only one who cared amongst new yorkers who were eager to get back to normal.
Sounds about right with where we are now too, two years into the pandemic. I can't imagine what's been running through his head...
I appreciated the latter half's inclusion of older comic plates from the turn of the century, showing politicized comics, the beginnings of the medium, and some a bit slapstick. I can't imagine a world without comics since I remember fondly reading them (the only thing I grabbed in the Sunday paper as a kid), I was obsessed with Calvin and Hobbes, Garfield, and of course Maus later.
Its interesting to consider the reception that comics forks have received as "low art" in a time When it was new. But how emotive and seemingly simple it is too convey so so much!
You can tell how gifted Spiegelman is, and I am happy he pours his sweat and time into his work that shows as much.
February 28, 2023
I am once again in awe of Art Spiegelman he never ceases to make incredibly poignant artwork about "taboo" topics which is necessary in order to get the ball rolling on making it public discussion worthy. This comic shows the true trauma and feels of everyday New Yorkers but also everyday communities (sometimes we just want to see our homeless Russian lady cursing at us to feel normal- I work at a public library I get the peacefulness of this). I also enjoyed looking at the old plate comics and see what inspired Spiegelman with this comic strip, but that being said I wanted more of his original stuff.
I also loved the irony on the barcode of the book as the subject is 'current affairs' and now over two decades later you could classify this comic as history. This comic may be the only way some people may learn about this event.
I also loved the irony on the barcode of the book as the subject is 'current affairs' and now over two decades later you could classify this comic as history. This comic may be the only way some people may learn about this event.
November 14, 2020
I loved it! I loved every details! That is the way how Art Spiegelmann can go on after 09/11. His art, his incredibly awesome way to self-explain are unbelievable. I did feel his paranoidal fear and misery! I am already reading "Maus" and I can imagine how good he is with this stuffs. He has amazing talent.
June 8, 2017
art spiegelman deserves his place in the graphic novel canon and can get away with all kinds of pretentiousness (like only giving presentations when he can smoke the entire way through and making a book so big it wouldn't fit in my backpack) bc he's just that good, ok.
November 30, 2019
I enjoy Art Spiegelman quite a bit. And I'm always happy to spend time with an artist's obsessions. The last third of this book is an essay on comics of the early newspaper days in America with a bunch of full-size plates. So that was an exciting little bonus.
September 11, 2021
A searing vision of the burning skeletal remains of the towers before they fell inspired this incredible account of the events of that dark day and its aftermath. A deeply emotional retelling of a lower Manhattan resident's experiences that day.
October 8, 2017
Wow. Just find a copy of this book in your library - you don't even have to check it out, as it takes less than an hour to read. Beautiful.
February 24, 2019
Would give this graphic novel about 9/11 3.5 stars. This is from a series of pieces Spiegelman had done right after this event and was an interesting read.
February 22, 2023
Was even schrikken toen de reservering binnenkwam, groooot formaat. De schrijver doet zijn verhaal als getuige en emotioneel slachtoffer. Af en toe wat verwarrend maar met duidelijke statements vwb zijn politieke denkrichting.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 343 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.