What do you think?
Rate this book
We Are the Goldens
Nell knows a secret about her perfect, beautiful sister Layla. If she tells, it could blow their world apart.
When Nell and Layla were little, Nell used to call them Nellayla. Because to Nell, there was no difference between where she started and her adored big sister ended. They're a unit; divorce made them rely on each other early on, so when one pulls away, what is the other to do? But now, Nell's a freshman in high school and Layla is changing, secretive. And then Nell discovers why. Layla is involved with one of their teachers. And even though Nell tries to support Layla, to understand that she's happy and in love, Nell struggles with her true feelings: it's wrong, and she must do something about it.
When Nell and Layla were little, Nell used to call them Nellayla. Because to Nell, there was no difference between where she started and her adored big sister ended. They're a unit; divorce made them rely on each other early on, so when one pulls away, what is the other to do? But now, Nell's a freshman in high school and Layla is changing, secretive. And then Nell discovers why. Layla is involved with one of their teachers. And even though Nell tries to support Layla, to understand that she's happy and in love, Nell struggles with her true feelings: it's wrong, and she must do something about it.
208 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2014
23 people are currently reading
2,482 people want to read
About the author
Dana Reinhardt
14books230followersWhy don't you have a bio section?
Because I hate writing about myself.
But wouldn't that be easier than answering a whole bunch of FAQs?
Maybe. Probably. Go on...
So where are you from?
I'm from Los Angeles, but now I live in San Francisco. Except for the summers where I go back to Los Angeles in search of the sun.
What are you doing when you aren't writing?
Laundry, usually. Sometimes dishes. And I really like to walk near the Golden Gate Bridge.
Why don't you run instead of walk?
Running is hard. And I'm sort of lazy.
Have you ever had a real job?
Yes. Of course I have. I've waited tables, worked with adolescents in foster care, read the slush pile at a publishing house, and fact checked for a movie magazine. I also worked for FRONTLINE on PBS and Peter Jennings at ABC. I went to law school, which I know doesn't count as a job, but hey, that was a lot of work.
What's your writing day like? Do you stick to a routine?
I like to write in the mornings. Sometimes that means I have to get up really early. I try to write 700 words a day -- about three pages. I know there are lots of writers out there who can write way more than that. I know this because writers like to tell you about how many words they've written on FACEBOOK. So I try not to look at FACEBOOK when I'm writing. And anyway, I've learned that 700 words are about all I'm good for on any given day, and if I write more than that I usually end up getting rid of most of it later.
What, are you lazy or something?
I already told you I'm lazy. But seriously, 700 words are a lot of words. 700 of them, to be precise.
Where do you get your ideas?
From someplace inside my head.
That's not really an answer.
Yes, it is. And it's as honest an answer as I can give.
Are your books autobiographical?
Not really. I'm not adopted, I've never told a lie that sent someone to jail, I've never built a house or had a brother go to war. But there are always things in my books that come from my life or from the lives of the people around me. It would be impossible to make up everything.
Why do you write young adult fiction?
Because I was a young adult when I fell in love with reading and I can remember how books made me feel back then. How they provided both comfort and escape. That might make me sound like a shut-in, but I wasn't. I was just open to the experience books offered, probably more open than I am now as an adult. And I like writing for that sort of audience.
What exactly is young adult fiction?
Lots of people have thought long and hard about this question and have had many intelligent things to say about voice and how YA books can't spend too much time on adult characters, etc. I don't have anything to add to the debate except to say that YA should be a place to go in the bookstore or library if you are looking for a coming of age story, no matter how old you are.
Do you have a favorite book?
Yes.
Don't be coy, what is it?
To Kill a Mockingbird.
How come there aren't any vampires or wizards in your books?
Hmmmm... good question. Maybe I should write about vampires and wizards.
No, you shouldn't. You wouldn't be very good at that.
Thanks for the vote of confidence.
Did you wear a Soupy Sales sweatshirt when you were seven?
Does anybody even know who Soupy Sales is?
That's what the Internet is for. Don't avoid the question.
I'm sorry, is this really a Frequently Asked Question?
No. But, c'mon, tell us anyway.
Yes, I did. But I'm trying to portray myself as someone who wasn't a total loser. So maybe you shouldn't bring that up. And it also makes me sound ancient, which I'm not. Yet I had a Soupy Sales sweatshirt. And I loved it. It was yellow. And really soft.
You're right. It does make you sound like a loser.
Because I hate writing about myself.
But wouldn't that be easier than answering a whole bunch of FAQs?
Maybe. Probably. Go on...
So where are you from?
I'm from Los Angeles, but now I live in San Francisco. Except for the summers where I go back to Los Angeles in search of the sun.
What are you doing when you aren't writing?
Laundry, usually. Sometimes dishes. And I really like to walk near the Golden Gate Bridge.
Why don't you run instead of walk?
Running is hard. And I'm sort of lazy.
Have you ever had a real job?
Yes. Of course I have. I've waited tables, worked with adolescents in foster care, read the slush pile at a publishing house, and fact checked for a movie magazine. I also worked for FRONTLINE on PBS and Peter Jennings at ABC. I went to law school, which I know doesn't count as a job, but hey, that was a lot of work.
What's your writing day like? Do you stick to a routine?
I like to write in the mornings. Sometimes that means I have to get up really early. I try to write 700 words a day -- about three pages. I know there are lots of writers out there who can write way more than that. I know this because writers like to tell you about how many words they've written on FACEBOOK. So I try not to look at FACEBOOK when I'm writing. And anyway, I've learned that 700 words are about all I'm good for on any given day, and if I write more than that I usually end up getting rid of most of it later.
What, are you lazy or something?
I already told you I'm lazy. But seriously, 700 words are a lot of words. 700 of them, to be precise.
Where do you get your ideas?
From someplace inside my head.
That's not really an answer.
Yes, it is. And it's as honest an answer as I can give.
Are your books autobiographical?
Not really. I'm not adopted, I've never told a lie that sent someone to jail, I've never built a house or had a brother go to war. But there are always things in my books that come from my life or from the lives of the people around me. It would be impossible to make up everything.
Why do you write young adult fiction?
Because I was a young adult when I fell in love with reading and I can remember how books made me feel back then. How they provided both comfort and escape. That might make me sound like a shut-in, but I wasn't. I was just open to the experience books offered, probably more open than I am now as an adult. And I like writing for that sort of audience.
What exactly is young adult fiction?
Lots of people have thought long and hard about this question and have had many intelligent things to say about voice and how YA books can't spend too much time on adult characters, etc. I don't have anything to add to the debate except to say that YA should be a place to go in the bookstore or library if you are looking for a coming of age story, no matter how old you are.
Do you have a favorite book?
Yes.
Don't be coy, what is it?
To Kill a Mockingbird.
How come there aren't any vampires or wizards in your books?
Hmmmm... good question. Maybe I should write about vampires and wizards.
No, you shouldn't. You wouldn't be very good at that.
Thanks for the vote of confidence.
Did you wear a Soupy Sales sweatshirt when you were seven?
Does anybody even know who Soupy Sales is?
That's what the Internet is for. Don't avoid the question.
I'm sorry, is this really a Frequently Asked Question?
No. But, c'mon, tell us anyway.
Yes, I did. But I'm trying to portray myself as someone who wasn't a total loser. So maybe you shouldn't bring that up. And it also makes me sound ancient, which I'm not. Yet I had a Soupy Sales sweatshirt. And I loved it. It was yellow. And really soft.
You're right. It does make you sound like a loser.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 549 reviews
April 6, 2017
This book is about two sisters. The younger one Nell is supposedly writing it in letter form to her older sister Layla. They used to be inseparable. They were Nellayla.*gag*
Nell (who is fourteen) is finally going to high school with her worshipped older sister..she will be the other half of the Goldens. It's going to be 'awesome.'
Then she realizes that Layla is pulling away from her.
Nell becomes almost stalkerish in her adulation of Layla. (I though Layla was an idiot.)
Then the big reveal of the super sekret secret. That happens early in the book.
*double gag*
The only redeeming thing about the whole silly book? The best friend of Nell..Felix. The standard funny little nerd.
Booksource: Netgalley in exchange for review
Nell (who is fourteen) is finally going to high school with her worshipped older sister..she will be the other half of the Goldens. It's going to be 'awesome.'
Then she realizes that Layla is pulling away from her.
Nell becomes almost stalkerish in her adulation of Layla. (I though Layla was an idiot.)
Then the big reveal of the super sekret secret. That happens early in the book.
*double gag*
The only redeeming thing about the whole silly book? The best friend of Nell..Felix. The standard funny little nerd.
Booksource: Netgalley in exchange for review
April 13, 2014
WE ARE THE GOLDENS is a recounting of events that took place between two sisters and is told from Nell's pov. Nell takes us through her freshman year and Layla's junior year. Having hero worshiped her sister her whole life Nell is struggling with how to handle the knowledge of Layla's secret.
Nell and Layla have always been close with their lives being intertwined. The Goldens even had a family joke; as a toddler when Nell learned to talk she called herself Nellayla because they were so much apart of each other Nell didn't know where one of them ended and the other one started.
My husband and I were both invited by the publisher to read this book. After Jay finished he asked me to read it so we could discuss the ending because the ending was left wide open for interpretation. Or so I thought because I came up with a totally different conclusion to the ending than Jay. After listening to Jay's reasoning on how it ended I would have agree with him. My original conclusion to the ending probably is a result of all the ya/na genre that have major drama and climatic endings.
TWO SISTERS...ONE SECRET
Standalone
**Complimentary copy pre-approved by Random House Children's Books, Wendy Lamb Books, via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**
Nell and Layla have always been close with their lives being intertwined. The Goldens even had a family joke; as a toddler when Nell learned to talk she called herself Nellayla because they were so much apart of each other Nell didn't know where one of them ended and the other one started.
My husband and I were both invited by the publisher to read this book. After Jay finished he asked me to read it so we could discuss the ending because the ending was left wide open for interpretation. Or so I thought because I came up with a totally different conclusion to the ending than Jay. After listening to Jay's reasoning on how it ended I would have agree with him. My original conclusion to the ending probably is a result of all the ya/na genre that have major drama and climatic endings.
TWO SISTERS...ONE SECRET
Standalone
**Complimentary copy pre-approved by Random House Children's Books, Wendy Lamb Books, via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**
May 23, 2014
4 STARS
I just love that exchange. It so perfectly captures what this book is about.
I probably have the least credibility in discussing a book about two sisters. I’ve never had the pleasure of having one. And while there are definite perks in being an only child, I can’t deny that I’ve always wanted to have a Jessica to my Elizabeth (because of course, I’m that Wakefield). So I’m finding it a little strange to find how much this book spoke to me. How often I’ve found myself in Nell’s shoes and, sad as it may be, how many Laylas I have (figuratively speaking) in my life right now.
The Goldens are Nell and Layla, and the book is told from Nell’s perspective speaking to her sister. She is recounting the events of the year when she joined her sister in school: a freshman on Layla’s Junior year in high school. There’s a sense of foreboding in Nell’s narrative that draws one’s curiosity early on but it didn’t have the heaviness of a mystery, the point I felt it was trying to make doesn’t lie on the shock value of a big reveal or a plot twist. Instead this was about a 15-year old girl who has happily lived her life in the loving shadow of her sister, a faithful devotee of their oneness. This tells the painful process of that spell being broken, when the spectator from the crowd realizes she’s her own person and the Emperor she so cheered on and adored for so long, is so obliviously naked.
This book had all the usual suspects in contemporary YA fiction: the likeable heroine who looks up to her prettier, smarter and all around awesome-r older sister who has a secret; the funny (but this time, straight) best friend; the mysterious and brooding boy who has caught likeable heroine’s fancy; the separately charming Mom and Dad. It had all the ingredients that always makes this genre reliably entertaining to me: the effortless and un-purple narrative; the quirky little details (i.e. the Fakespeare, the buffalos and the inside jokes); the believable dialogue that endears the characters to me further.
That formula is just so very hard to not work for me.
I really liked how very age-appropriate Nell’s thought process came across. At 15, as a freshman in a school that looks up to her sister along with her, it was refreshingly honest how this presented the conflict of her reality disentangling from that of Layla’s. I love how this depicted their love for each other, how it made me believe and empathize with Nell in carrying the burden of Layla's secret. The struggle of playing the supportive sister while keeping her best interest at heart is one that was believably difficult and worth a lengthy discussion over alcohol.
The drama was thankfully kept to the barest minimum, the gratuity kept in check. I’m impressed how this presented a young girl learning her lessons without pretense: rejection doesn’t always stem from a garish confrontation, most of the times its in the quiet shame of an unresponsive cellphone, or the second-hand gossip one watches to complete its trajectory of natural death. I found it very smart and respectful in presenting teenagers beyond the hormones but not to the point of castrating them.
I have two minds about how Nell and Felix’s relationship was handled. Because on the one hand it grazes on several levels of On the other hand, Which is such a heartbreaker because I really like Felix and it’s such a shame that characters like him has to either be
An angle that could easily be overlooked in this story is the actual dynamic between The Goldens. It’s interesting how this book pointed out, however briefly in the end, the underlying pathos to all that adorable togetherness of a family ambling along as though they’ve not been ripped apart. It’s an issue that is often glossed over in YA contemporary fiction in exchange for mom and dad jokes. But I like how this reflected on how that heartbreak filters into belated tangents of unpredictable consequences.
I was definitely taken aback with how much I enjoyed We Are The Goldens, it felt like revisiting an old genre, one that has now been twisted, complexed and overhauled in creative infinity, stripped to (most) of its best working parts.
And it still hits the spot for me.
ARC courtesy of the publishers thru Netgalley. Quotes taken from an uncorrected proof.
”I love you tons,� you said.
“I know.�
“And, Nell?�
“Yeah, I know.�
“You do?�
“Of course.�
“Pdz?�
“Don’t insult me.�
I closed your door.
That’s how I vowed to keep your secret.
I just love that exchange. It so perfectly captures what this book is about.
I probably have the least credibility in discussing a book about two sisters. I’ve never had the pleasure of having one. And while there are definite perks in being an only child, I can’t deny that I’ve always wanted to have a Jessica to my Elizabeth (because of course, I’m that Wakefield). So I’m finding it a little strange to find how much this book spoke to me. How often I’ve found myself in Nell’s shoes and, sad as it may be, how many Laylas I have (figuratively speaking) in my life right now.
The Goldens are Nell and Layla, and the book is told from Nell’s perspective speaking to her sister. She is recounting the events of the year when she joined her sister in school: a freshman on Layla’s Junior year in high school. There’s a sense of foreboding in Nell’s narrative that draws one’s curiosity early on but it didn’t have the heaviness of a mystery, the point I felt it was trying to make doesn’t lie on the shock value of a big reveal or a plot twist. Instead this was about a 15-year old girl who has happily lived her life in the loving shadow of her sister, a faithful devotee of their oneness. This tells the painful process of that spell being broken, when the spectator from the crowd realizes she’s her own person and the Emperor she so cheered on and adored for so long, is so obliviously naked.
This book had all the usual suspects in contemporary YA fiction: the likeable heroine who looks up to her prettier, smarter and all around awesome-r older sister who has a secret; the funny (but this time, straight) best friend; the mysterious and brooding boy who has caught likeable heroine’s fancy; the separately charming Mom and Dad. It had all the ingredients that always makes this genre reliably entertaining to me: the effortless and un-purple narrative; the quirky little details (i.e. the Fakespeare, the buffalos and the inside jokes); the believable dialogue that endears the characters to me further.
That formula is just so very hard to not work for me.
I really liked how very age-appropriate Nell’s thought process came across. At 15, as a freshman in a school that looks up to her sister along with her, it was refreshingly honest how this presented the conflict of her reality disentangling from that of Layla’s. I love how this depicted their love for each other, how it made me believe and empathize with Nell in carrying the burden of Layla's secret. The struggle of playing the supportive sister while keeping her best interest at heart is one that was believably difficult and worth a lengthy discussion over alcohol.
The drama was thankfully kept to the barest minimum, the gratuity kept in check. I’m impressed how this presented a young girl learning her lessons without pretense: rejection doesn’t always stem from a garish confrontation, most of the times its in the quiet shame of an unresponsive cellphone, or the second-hand gossip one watches to complete its trajectory of natural death. I found it very smart and respectful in presenting teenagers beyond the hormones but not to the point of castrating them.
”Is this what it’s like?�
“W?�
“Being a boy. Do you just sit around all the time thinking about naked girls? Isn’t there more to it?�
“Of course there is. We care about things like your intellect and your sense of humor and your capacity for kindness, but we also really like how you look naked.�
I have two minds about how Nell and Felix’s relationship was handled. Because on the one hand it grazes on several levels of On the other hand, Which is such a heartbreaker because I really like Felix and it’s such a shame that characters like him has to either be
An angle that could easily be overlooked in this story is the actual dynamic between The Goldens. It’s interesting how this book pointed out, however briefly in the end, the underlying pathos to all that adorable togetherness of a family ambling along as though they’ve not been ripped apart. It’s an issue that is often glossed over in YA contemporary fiction in exchange for mom and dad jokes. But I like how this reflected on how that heartbreak filters into belated tangents of unpredictable consequences.
I was definitely taken aback with how much I enjoyed We Are The Goldens, it felt like revisiting an old genre, one that has now been twisted, complexed and overhauled in creative infinity, stripped to (most) of its best working parts.
And it still hits the spot for me.
ARC courtesy of the publishers thru Netgalley. Quotes taken from an uncorrected proof.
June 5, 2014
You might find this story exhilarating and entertaining, like an old friend whispering over your right shoulder, or then again you might not. You might find it moving and breathtaking, and it might caress you like the wind whispering against your face. You might remember the combination to your old high school locker and attempt to visit it in a moment of nostalgia, before the local authorities come to arrest you, and take you up to the big house on the hill—the one overlooking the water through a set of bars that will keep you contained for the next twenty-four hours. Or then again, you might remain unmoved and curse the heavens at this story of sisters who were seventeen months apart. The closeness these sisters shared, and the bond that held them together might as well have been superglue, even if it ended up a bit chipped around the edges.
I’d say it’s nearly impossible not to feel some sort of emotion upon the completion of WE ARE THE GOLDENS, but that would be mere conjecture and projection, and I want you to live your own life. Make your own mistakes, and dream the impossible dream…even if it blows up in your face faster than an M-80 and leaves you scarred from the nose down. For these chances and mistakes lead to opportunities and promises and hopes that might fill your body to its breaking point with desire and adrenaline, or then again, maybe you’d prefer to remain anonymous and stand behind the curtain, and let someone else make all the mistakes.
What I can tell you, though, is this tale moved me. I was inserted and transported to the heart of this story, and I found the little voice whispering behind my right ear and talking to me like an old friend who had just plopped down beside me on the sofa. And as I hugged my Kindle against my chest and read page after page, I couldn’t stop the movement as it rumbled through my body and poured out of my pores, and astonished me at its sheer bravado when all I had asked was to be entertained for a few short hours of my life.
Second tense never sounded so intense and mature, even if Nell was only fifteen years old. And her sister Layla with her golden locks and skimpy frocks made all the heads of the high school boys turn. Her fair share of golden hair made me smile with pleasure and glee, and at seventeen years she was the perfect one, or so it would initially seem. But this tale has more depth and despair than its adolescence would lead you to believe.
But you’ll have to find out yourself if this is a story you want to read, because all I can say is that it moved yesterday and made me particularly happy to have discovered it. With a gleam in my eye, and my eyes pointed to the sky, I reached the end of this piece. But the ending of this youthful lass, as it came to pass, left me with more questions than answers. So it can be said with the slightest hint of dread that I would have liked a slightly more definitive conclusion than the slightly open-ended one I was offered, even as I know when I have met life’s strife I often have more questions than answers.
I received this book for free through NetGalley.
I’d say it’s nearly impossible not to feel some sort of emotion upon the completion of WE ARE THE GOLDENS, but that would be mere conjecture and projection, and I want you to live your own life. Make your own mistakes, and dream the impossible dream…even if it blows up in your face faster than an M-80 and leaves you scarred from the nose down. For these chances and mistakes lead to opportunities and promises and hopes that might fill your body to its breaking point with desire and adrenaline, or then again, maybe you’d prefer to remain anonymous and stand behind the curtain, and let someone else make all the mistakes.
What I can tell you, though, is this tale moved me. I was inserted and transported to the heart of this story, and I found the little voice whispering behind my right ear and talking to me like an old friend who had just plopped down beside me on the sofa. And as I hugged my Kindle against my chest and read page after page, I couldn’t stop the movement as it rumbled through my body and poured out of my pores, and astonished me at its sheer bravado when all I had asked was to be entertained for a few short hours of my life.
Second tense never sounded so intense and mature, even if Nell was only fifteen years old. And her sister Layla with her golden locks and skimpy frocks made all the heads of the high school boys turn. Her fair share of golden hair made me smile with pleasure and glee, and at seventeen years she was the perfect one, or so it would initially seem. But this tale has more depth and despair than its adolescence would lead you to believe.
But you’ll have to find out yourself if this is a story you want to read, because all I can say is that it moved yesterday and made me particularly happy to have discovered it. With a gleam in my eye, and my eyes pointed to the sky, I reached the end of this piece. But the ending of this youthful lass, as it came to pass, left me with more questions than answers. So it can be said with the slightest hint of dread that I would have liked a slightly more definitive conclusion than the slightly open-ended one I was offered, even as I know when I have met life’s strife I often have more questions than answers.
I received this book for free through NetGalley.
September 15, 2022
Wow, this book was a trip and a half. It started off very slow and a bit confusing. This was written from the younger sister Nell's point of view and she is talking to her older sister, Leyla Golden. I was very eager to finish because I perceived a tragedy like suicide and Nell speaking to her sister over her grave or a car accident resulting in the older Golden being in a comatose state listening as the younger Golden explains her thoughts or Leyla running away/kidnapped and never being found. Nell, making peace with her secret by going to their favorite childhood spot and just spilling all of her thoughts. I had to reread the first two or three chapter because although eager to proceed, I was quite confused. Kept on forming my own thoughts and attempting to implement them instead of just reading the story. Loved it when a book sticks with me and makes me think and this book did it within the first few chapters.
May have been slow initially but the younger sister's admiration of her older sister and her struggles starting of her freshman year and her infatuation with a popular theater guy really propelled the story forward.
I love any story where the main character is finding her true voice in the midst of conflicting emotions while trying to please other which may at times be so chaotic and overwheming but very loved because it is so true to life.
This was my first time reading this author and can't wait to read other works by this author.
May have been slow initially but the younger sister's admiration of her older sister and her struggles starting of her freshman year and her infatuation with a popular theater guy really propelled the story forward.
I love any story where the main character is finding her true voice in the midst of conflicting emotions while trying to please other which may at times be so chaotic and overwheming but very loved because it is so true to life.
This was my first time reading this author and can't wait to read other works by this author.
April 9, 2014
WARNING:SPOILERS
We are the Goldens!
This story was way better than I expected. I mean way better I actually thought I was going to have to force myself to get through it. But it wasn't that long so I decided to just read the whole thing today.
This story is told from Nell's pov. But it's about how she deals with finding out that her sister Layla is in a relationship with one of their teachers. I can tell you right now if it was me I would have told right when I found out. I'm very iffy with books about teacher and student relationships. They really put me on edge (of course I'm talking about teachers and underage students). The story has to be really good for me to be okay with the relationship and the only story I can think of without cringing is Slammed by Colleen Hoover. I was kinda pissed that Nell didn't tell right away. But she just loved her sister's approval too much to say anything. Even though she knew it was wrong.
Layla really got on my nerves! I don't get how she thought that their relationship was okay. She knew it was wrong that's why she didn't want to say anything. She wants her sister to take up for her and lie with her but she feels like she can get mad whenever she wants and say rude things to her. She should have been happy that Nell was taking up for her instead of trying to make her feel bad. But instead of being the older mature sister she only cared about how she and Mr. B felt! This bitch really pissed me off.
The only thing that really sucked about the story was that we don't know what happens when Nell tells. The whole story is written as if Nell is telling her sister that she's going to tell their parents and why. But that's all we get. I really wanted to know how her parents reacted and what happened after. But I guess we have to just come up with what we think would happen.
There haven't been alot of books that came out this year that I've rated more than 3 stars. I'm really surprised that this is one of them but I'm glad I gave it a chance.
We are the Goldens!
This story was way better than I expected. I mean way better I actually thought I was going to have to force myself to get through it. But it wasn't that long so I decided to just read the whole thing today.
This story is told from Nell's pov. But it's about how she deals with finding out that her sister Layla is in a relationship with one of their teachers. I can tell you right now if it was me I would have told right when I found out. I'm very iffy with books about teacher and student relationships. They really put me on edge (of course I'm talking about teachers and underage students). The story has to be really good for me to be okay with the relationship and the only story I can think of without cringing is Slammed by Colleen Hoover. I was kinda pissed that Nell didn't tell right away. But she just loved her sister's approval too much to say anything. Even though she knew it was wrong.
Layla really got on my nerves! I don't get how she thought that their relationship was okay. She knew it was wrong that's why she didn't want to say anything. She wants her sister to take up for her and lie with her but she feels like she can get mad whenever she wants and say rude things to her. She should have been happy that Nell was taking up for her instead of trying to make her feel bad. But instead of being the older mature sister she only cared about how she and Mr. B felt! This bitch really pissed me off.
The only thing that really sucked about the story was that we don't know what happens when Nell tells. The whole story is written as if Nell is telling her sister that she's going to tell their parents and why. But that's all we get. I really wanted to know how her parents reacted and what happened after. But I guess we have to just come up with what we think would happen.
There haven't been alot of books that came out this year that I've rated more than 3 stars. I'm really surprised that this is one of them but I'm glad I gave it a chance.
February 26, 2016
**Please note: a 2 star rating does NOT mean I hated the book. For me it means it was "okay".**
This read just didn't do it for me. The blurb of the book is mysterious and gives nothing away which is why I figured I should give it a try. Unfortunately, I felt little to no connection with the characters. Even more, I found the writing style to be plain and unappealing. The premise behind the book is very promising but because I couldn't enjoy the way it was written it was hard to get into. Essentially, the book is told from Nell's point of view and the entire time she is literally talking to her sister and not the readers. Also, this writing style muffles the underlying meaning of the book. I wish I could say I liked it more but frankly its just not my cup of tea. And the ending... don't even get me started. WTH...
This read just didn't do it for me. The blurb of the book is mysterious and gives nothing away which is why I figured I should give it a try. Unfortunately, I felt little to no connection with the characters. Even more, I found the writing style to be plain and unappealing. The premise behind the book is very promising but because I couldn't enjoy the way it was written it was hard to get into. Essentially, the book is told from Nell's point of view and the entire time she is literally talking to her sister and not the readers. Also, this writing style muffles the underlying meaning of the book. I wish I could say I liked it more but frankly its just not my cup of tea. And the ending... don't even get me started. WTH...
January 29, 2014
Dana Reinhardt's books always remind me of the soaring happiness that boy-girl friendships in adolescence make you feel. It's such a good, grounded, empowering sensation to be a girl in a friendship with a guy at 15 or 16, to take all the stress of "Does he like me?" out of the equation. It was one of the most adult experiences I had, and the most unspoiled. But Reinhardt is also incredibly skilled at showing what happens when you pick the wrong guy for your first love (oh, the agony), and at getting the voice of the younger sibling just right, and at showing the way out of the mess afterwards. The way out of the mess is through your true friends and your family, the ones who speak Fakespeare and know all your favorite snacks. Lastly, read WE ARE THE GOLDENS to experience the second-person point-of-view done right. From the very first words, "Don't be mad," Nell's voice comes to life.
September 20, 2014
THIS REVIEW IS ORIGINALLY POSTED ON
"There’s something I need to tell you. Don’t be mad. Please don’t be mad. I hate it when you’re mad at me."
Layla and Nell are the Goldens, their parents are divorced, they’re only 9 months apart and Nell knows a secret about her sister. Her sister is involve with their art teacher!! THIS IS NOT A SPOILER. It’s written in the Blurb already, the real question here is what will Nell do about this information? Will she tell it? Keep it to herself? Maybe just share it to her bestfriend, Felix?
We Are The Goldens is shorter than I expected. But even though it left me wanting more, I thoroughly enjoyed it. I don’t have a sister, and this book made me long for one. It made me emotional.. I was sad and happy and my chest ached a little after I finished it. I know, my feelings doesn’t really makes sense.. But that’s what I loved about the book. Even though it’s too short for my liking, it made an impact.
The story is written in second person tense. Nell is narrating and me (you) as a reader will feel like you’re Nell. Usually, this bothers me. But I’m totally immersed at Layla’s storytelling that I am willing to overlook it. It’s so easy to be invested which is really surprising for me because it’s usually hard for a First Chapter to caught my attention. But Nell is an awesome character. I can see her as one of my best friends, her words are easy to get into and the way she narrates her story will make you feel for her. Even though we’re not getting into the other character’s head, I feel like I know them all deeply! In other words, the book is well written.
"We are the Goldens, but we aren’t perfect. We’re going to have some hard times, and I wanted to calmly and wisely say some version of this to you: I’m here to help, we’re close, our lives are intertwined, you can trust me."
Does this remind you of Elsa and Anna feels? Because this book really is about sisterhood. Layla, the big sister, has some issues and Nell, the little sis, who loves her unconditionally, struggles to help her. Layla got on my nerves a lot of times, for being the first child and older than Nell, she’s pretty stupid. And she’s kind of cruel. I mean, you can see the love there. You can feel that she loves Nell, but there’s manipulations and she’s making Nell feel guilty a lot of times. There’s no romance here, except maybe the
relationship between Layla and the art professor, but no, let’s not count that. But there IS an awesome friendship here. Awesome and epic that I envy it.
”Is this what it’s like?�
“W?�
“Being a boy. Do you just sit around all the time thinking about naked girls? Isn’t there more to it?�
“Of course there is. We care about things like your intellect and your sense of humor and your capacity for kindness, but we also really like how you look naked.�
Did I mention Felix already? Because you’ll love him. I do believe that we all need a Felix in our life, he’s one of the most awesome character I’ve ever encountered. I love how his relationship with Nell shifted from super-duper-mega-ultra-bestfriend to.. something more.
I feel pretty sad about this review, I feel like I didn’t do the book justice. It’s well written, the characters are real and everything is realistic. From the plot to the relationships to the conclusion. It is short, yes, but it has a story that will really play at your heartstrings and it has a message. I absolutely recommend this. Now go hug your sisters!
"There’s something I need to tell you. Don’t be mad. Please don’t be mad. I hate it when you’re mad at me."
Layla and Nell are the Goldens, their parents are divorced, they’re only 9 months apart and Nell knows a secret about her sister. Her sister is involve with their art teacher!! THIS IS NOT A SPOILER. It’s written in the Blurb already, the real question here is what will Nell do about this information? Will she tell it? Keep it to herself? Maybe just share it to her bestfriend, Felix?
We Are The Goldens is shorter than I expected. But even though it left me wanting more, I thoroughly enjoyed it. I don’t have a sister, and this book made me long for one. It made me emotional.. I was sad and happy and my chest ached a little after I finished it. I know, my feelings doesn’t really makes sense.. But that’s what I loved about the book. Even though it’s too short for my liking, it made an impact.
The story is written in second person tense. Nell is narrating and me (you) as a reader will feel like you’re Nell. Usually, this bothers me. But I’m totally immersed at Layla’s storytelling that I am willing to overlook it. It’s so easy to be invested which is really surprising for me because it’s usually hard for a First Chapter to caught my attention. But Nell is an awesome character. I can see her as one of my best friends, her words are easy to get into and the way she narrates her story will make you feel for her. Even though we’re not getting into the other character’s head, I feel like I know them all deeply! In other words, the book is well written.
"We are the Goldens, but we aren’t perfect. We’re going to have some hard times, and I wanted to calmly and wisely say some version of this to you: I’m here to help, we’re close, our lives are intertwined, you can trust me."
Does this remind you of Elsa and Anna feels? Because this book really is about sisterhood. Layla, the big sister, has some issues and Nell, the little sis, who loves her unconditionally, struggles to help her. Layla got on my nerves a lot of times, for being the first child and older than Nell, she’s pretty stupid. And she’s kind of cruel. I mean, you can see the love there. You can feel that she loves Nell, but there’s manipulations and she’s making Nell feel guilty a lot of times. There’s no romance here, except maybe the
relationship between Layla and the art professor, but no, let’s not count that. But there IS an awesome friendship here. Awesome and epic that I envy it.
”Is this what it’s like?�
“W?�
“Being a boy. Do you just sit around all the time thinking about naked girls? Isn’t there more to it?�
“Of course there is. We care about things like your intellect and your sense of humor and your capacity for kindness, but we also really like how you look naked.�
Did I mention Felix already? Because you’ll love him. I do believe that we all need a Felix in our life, he’s one of the most awesome character I’ve ever encountered. I love how his relationship with Nell shifted from super-duper-mega-ultra-bestfriend to.. something more.
I feel pretty sad about this review, I feel like I didn’t do the book justice. It’s well written, the characters are real and everything is realistic. From the plot to the relationships to the conclusion. It is short, yes, but it has a story that will really play at your heartstrings and it has a message. I absolutely recommend this. Now go hug your sisters!
May 2, 2014
Advance copy provided by publisher via Net Galley.
4/7/14 -
This one sounds like it's outside of my norm. Synopsis a little vague so we shall see!
5/1/14
3.5 Stars!
I found this to be a pleasant surprise! We Are the Goldens is a tale told from Nell's point of view. She the younger sister of two, and she idolizes her older sister, Layla. And Layla has a secret.
Nell has a best friend, Felix De La Cruz. They lean on each other for comfort and support. He's who she tells everything to. Except Layla's secret. Because that's her sister, her role model, and you don't want your role model to be mad at you, do you?
Nell's journey into 'adulthood' was fascinating to experience. She got to learn some things the easy way, and some things she had to learn the hard way. Through it all she was fighting to stay loyal to her sister.
I found this book to be very intriguing. There was this buildup of "will she tell?" "what's there to tell?" "what is and isn't the truth?" It all led to...an open end.
There may be some out there who hate open-ended stories, but I liked it in this case. It leaves you wanting more, constantly thinking about the book, instead of 'story's over, close the book and move on'. I'll be thinking about this YA for quite some time after this. It's got me very curious and it's fun to put my own twist to the story. (Kind of like how she and Felix used to do with the buffalos!) It's a definite read for someone looking for a journey through a teen's not so simple, yet not too complicated life.
4/7/14 -
This one sounds like it's outside of my norm. Synopsis a little vague so we shall see!
5/1/14
3.5 Stars!
I found this to be a pleasant surprise! We Are the Goldens is a tale told from Nell's point of view. She the younger sister of two, and she idolizes her older sister, Layla. And Layla has a secret.
Our lives are intertwined.
Nell has a best friend, Felix De La Cruz. They lean on each other for comfort and support. He's who she tells everything to. Except Layla's secret. Because that's her sister, her role model, and you don't want your role model to be mad at you, do you?
Nell's journey into 'adulthood' was fascinating to experience. She got to learn some things the easy way, and some things she had to learn the hard way. Through it all she was fighting to stay loyal to her sister.
I found this book to be very intriguing. There was this buildup of "will she tell?" "what's there to tell?" "what is and isn't the truth?" It all led to...an open end.
There may be some out there who hate open-ended stories, but I liked it in this case. It leaves you wanting more, constantly thinking about the book, instead of 'story's over, close the book and move on'. I'll be thinking about this YA for quite some time after this. It's got me very curious and it's fun to put my own twist to the story. (Kind of like how she and Felix used to do with the buffalos!) It's a definite read for someone looking for a journey through a teen's not so simple, yet not too complicated life.
June 19, 2014
I went back and forth between love and hate with this book. The ending really didn't help me pick a side either. I mean that ending! Gah! However when I think about what to rate this novel, I start at the basics. This is a young adult novel and it genuinely reads like young adult(the younger side of young adult anyways). The writing style is not for everyone, it's basically one long rambling letter/diary entry but the writing is still of good quality. The relationships felt realistic.
I'm not sure whether I actually liked the main character or not. I liked her as herself, who she was when she was with her best friend. However I didn't like her as a sister. I know that she was put in an impossible situation but she was just so clingy and whiney and I know that her sister was being a little mean to her but geez. Her suffocating love for her sister was hard to read at times. Even I wanted to push her away and yell "Jeez Nell back off"!
Overall, although the main character was a little annoying at times this book was impossible to put down. The ending was a massive cliff hanger but I can understand why the author did it. My only true complaint is a superficial one, which is the horrendous cover. Maybe it's just me but whenever I look at it I just see one girl with a floating head next to her? Apart from my tiny qualm I would recommend this book. 4/5
Note: I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
July 1, 2017
”We are the Goldens, but we aren’t perfect. We’re going to have some hard times, and I wanted to calmly and wisely say some version of this to you: I am your sister. I’m here to help, we’re close, our lives are intertwined, you can trust me.�
You know how sometimes, when you’re at a dinner engagement or a party, there’s that one person who tries to be extremely pretentious? They use pretentious language and big words to make them see more intelligent then they are? And how in the process of doing that, they can come off as pompous or conceited? If this book were a person, they’d be that pretentious person at the party.
Layla and Nell have always been close. The sisterly bond usually broken by adolescence has only grown stronger between the two. If you see one of them, the other is not too far behind. They’ve done everything together; share their toys, bicker over who’s hogging the backseat, shared all their secrets
Senior year was supposed to be the time of their lives. But Layla becomes withdrawn, distant from the sister who adores her. And what happens next may be the breaking point of their bond altogether.
Again, I think the main problem with this book was that it tried way too hard to be more intelligent than the writing style let it on to be. The simple, basic plot of it all (two sisters drifting apart), became more a philosophical study of purple prose, metaphors, and deep thinking. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, but it felt so out of place in this book it was hard to believe.
With pretentious sounding writing, characters as dull as dishwater, and a cliffhanger ending that was both totally unnecessary and rage inducing, this book just didn’t hit the right spots for me. However, I could see this appealing to fans of John Green or E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars, as the writing style is similar to theirs.
You know how sometimes, when you’re at a dinner engagement or a party, there’s that one person who tries to be extremely pretentious? They use pretentious language and big words to make them see more intelligent then they are? And how in the process of doing that, they can come off as pompous or conceited? If this book were a person, they’d be that pretentious person at the party.
Layla and Nell have always been close. The sisterly bond usually broken by adolescence has only grown stronger between the two. If you see one of them, the other is not too far behind. They’ve done everything together; share their toys, bicker over who’s hogging the backseat, shared all their secrets
”Layla, you have a crazy power over me I can’t even begin to understand. I was so hurt, so wounded, and then, after we got home and passed Dad’s smell test and brushed our teeth side by side in the mirror, you reached over and put your lips to my forehead. ‘Good night. I love you.�Until the day they didn’t.
Everything was forgiven.
Nothing else mattered.�
Senior year was supposed to be the time of their lives. But Layla becomes withdrawn, distant from the sister who adores her. And what happens next may be the breaking point of their bond altogether.
Again, I think the main problem with this book was that it tried way too hard to be more intelligent than the writing style let it on to be. The simple, basic plot of it all (two sisters drifting apart), became more a philosophical study of purple prose, metaphors, and deep thinking. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, but it felt so out of place in this book it was hard to believe.
”I think we all fall back into our patterns. Play our parts when we don’t know what else to do. So as you went back to Layla, the girl with the world on a string, I went back to playing Nell, adoring sister, keeper of the peace.The said big secret Layla’s keeping? The same old cliché big secret that most YA girls in contemporary books seem to be keeping: she’s having an affair with a teacher.
The sister who lies for you.�
”’You really think Mr. B is the answer? A teacher? An adult?�’It’s true love,� she says. ‘He loves me,� she says. ’GIRL, HE DOES NOT!�, I say. And the affair doesn’t really go anywhere at all. It was more in the background than in the actual forefront of the supposed conflict these two girls are having.
‘I know he is.’�
With pretentious sounding writing, characters as dull as dishwater, and a cliffhanger ending that was both totally unnecessary and rage inducing, this book just didn’t hit the right spots for me. However, I could see this appealing to fans of John Green or E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars, as the writing style is similar to theirs.
July 11, 2014
"I wanted to twinkle underwater like the lights of the city."
This was one of mine and even Buzzfeed's most anticipated books of 2014. When I found it at the library a few weeks after it was published on May 27, I ran straight for it and grabbed it with my all-mighty strength. (LOL, yeah right.)
After reading, I'm very glad that I've decided to read it. It was a novel of change, change from all of the mainstream books that are out there. This was a very well-written book. It's not the type that you'll want to re-read (at least I don't think so) but it's a pretty fun read that's sure to get you enticed in reading more from this splendid author.
I just wanted to let you know that this isn't your average fluffy contemporary read. We Are the Goldens is more of a darker contemporary read. In some ways, it has the aspects of those that deal with abuse and rape (especially because how the characters were feeling at times, *cough*Layla*cough.* We usually never get those type of books in the stores.
The concept of this book was very well planned out. The author made the characters deal with very harsh problems that really affected them. A very naughty teacher, signs of depression, obsession, this book was full of everything.
Second-person narratives aren't my favourite. I wasn't really glad that this book was written that way, Nell speaking to Layla through diary entries/letters/whatever it was, but we all have our favourite ways of books being written. With that said, the plot was kind of dull as well at times.
I don't know. Did some people think that this book was a roller coaster? Because for me, it wasn't.
For some people, I could see why they gave it a 5 star rating or a 4.5 one. This book stood out for some people because they have different tastes in drama contemporaries. For this book, it basically matters on what you like the whole time. The story was written extremely well, yes, but the plot at times didn't seem to get anywhere. There were no plot twists until the end and I found that this was dragging to much onto Nell's side when her sister is the main story here. The romance between Nell and Felix in the end just shouldn't have been added. We all know that we liked them JUST as friends! What was this, "Friends With Benefits?"
My utterly most favourite thing about this book was the relationships and friendships. The author absolutely made this the most BRILLIANT part of the book. She just mastered an A+ in friendship here.
The way Nell looked up to Layla really shows the truth behind the way most little siblings look up to the oldest ones. I'm the oldest sibling, and this book really gave us an idea from the minds of the youngsters.
I liked Nell, a lot. She was very independent and smart. In fact, she was more wiser and smarter than her bitch of a sister, let me tell you that. I'm not going to begin ranting on why I hate Layla, but by the end of the book, you'll realize that she was a s*ut and just went in the way of everything and messed everything up for everyone. She really showed that life isn't fair.
The parent-child relationships in this book was wonderful. For once, we had a wrecked-but-beautiful family over here, which rarely occurs in books. In a lot of novels, when the protagonist is going through something, the parent isn't even spoken of!
Overall, this book had its flaws and imperfections and all, but it was worth it to read without any doubts. If you liked anything by Carol Lynch Williams, then this will be a much-lighter breeze for you.
This was one of mine and even Buzzfeed's most anticipated books of 2014. When I found it at the library a few weeks after it was published on May 27, I ran straight for it and grabbed it with my all-mighty strength. (LOL, yeah right.)
After reading, I'm very glad that I've decided to read it. It was a novel of change, change from all of the mainstream books that are out there. This was a very well-written book. It's not the type that you'll want to re-read (at least I don't think so) but it's a pretty fun read that's sure to get you enticed in reading more from this splendid author.
I just wanted to let you know that this isn't your average fluffy contemporary read. We Are the Goldens is more of a darker contemporary read. In some ways, it has the aspects of those that deal with abuse and rape (especially because how the characters were feeling at times, *cough*Layla*cough.* We usually never get those type of books in the stores.
The concept of this book was very well planned out. The author made the characters deal with very harsh problems that really affected them. A very naughty teacher, signs of depression, obsession, this book was full of everything.
Second-person narratives aren't my favourite. I wasn't really glad that this book was written that way, Nell speaking to Layla through diary entries/letters/whatever it was, but we all have our favourite ways of books being written. With that said, the plot was kind of dull as well at times.
I don't know. Did some people think that this book was a roller coaster? Because for me, it wasn't.
For some people, I could see why they gave it a 5 star rating or a 4.5 one. This book stood out for some people because they have different tastes in drama contemporaries. For this book, it basically matters on what you like the whole time. The story was written extremely well, yes, but the plot at times didn't seem to get anywhere. There were no plot twists until the end and I found that this was dragging to much onto Nell's side when her sister is the main story here. The romance between Nell and Felix in the end just shouldn't have been added. We all know that we liked them JUST as friends! What was this, "Friends With Benefits?"
My utterly most favourite thing about this book was the relationships and friendships. The author absolutely made this the most BRILLIANT part of the book. She just mastered an A+ in friendship here.
The way Nell looked up to Layla really shows the truth behind the way most little siblings look up to the oldest ones. I'm the oldest sibling, and this book really gave us an idea from the minds of the youngsters.
I liked Nell, a lot. She was very independent and smart. In fact, she was more wiser and smarter than her bitch of a sister, let me tell you that. I'm not going to begin ranting on why I hate Layla, but by the end of the book, you'll realize that she was a s*ut and just went in the way of everything and messed everything up for everyone. She really showed that life isn't fair.
The parent-child relationships in this book was wonderful. For once, we had a wrecked-but-beautiful family over here, which rarely occurs in books. In a lot of novels, when the protagonist is going through something, the parent isn't even spoken of!
Overall, this book had its flaws and imperfections and all, but it was worth it to read without any doubts. If you liked anything by Carol Lynch Williams, then this will be a much-lighter breeze for you.
September 1, 2014
Invitation from the publisher for an honest review, via Netgallery.
3.5 Stars.
After about seventeen straight months and nearly 800 books later, I figured it was time to take a step out of the typical romance themed reads and venture into something a bit different. We Are The Goldens is a young adult novel that does not revolve the relationship of a love interest, but rather the relationship of two sisters. The story is told in a way that had me jumping to all sorts of conclusions about how this was going to play out. Nell, the younger sister is the narrator of this tale, but the main character in some aspects is really her older sister, Layla.
Only a small age gap exist between these girls, but in the hopes of ensuring they would grown into their own personalities (given how close they were), one was pushed to start school early while the other was held back. This places Nell entering her Freshmen year at high school, while Layla begins her Junior. As anyone who has a sister knows, this gap although small, can seem like a decades when it comes to the emotional state of teenage girls. When Nell starts to see the change in Layla she can't seem to figure out at first what is to blame, but that secret doesn't last long and Nell is forced to either remain the keeper of her sister's secrets and keep her relationship close or to tell and risk losing the one person she has idolized her entire life.
The way this story was told, I felt like a connection was made with Nell, she was struggling to not disappoint her sister, to ensure that their bond did not fail. She was so certain that she could turn a blind eye to the truth if it meant that Layla was truly happy. She tried convincing herself that Layla, the perfect sister that she always looked up to, couldn't be the one to make this big of a mistake. That connection sort of ended with Nell and did not carry over to Layla though. Layla's secret and her emotional state during most of this was something that I needed to read first had, from her lips to really feel.
In the end the story was left pretty open, I am sure in the author's eyes there is a perfectly reasonable ending - but there is room to explore several avenues as to how this truly ends. For being a story that is a bit out of my comfort zone as to what really keeps my attention, this book and author did a fantastic job doing just that. Nell narrating the story but speaking it to Layla, took a little getting used to, especially when it would go from Nell speaking directly to Layla to dialogue with Nell and others; but once you get into the flow of the story the rhythm is easily picked up. Typically when I finish a story that ends like this one did, I can quiet my mind of the lingering questions about just how did it truly end... for some reason I feel like not knowing for 100% is going to drive me a little bit crazy.
If you enjoy the young adult genre, that is a little more PG-13ish, that forces you to really think about what you are reading, this would be an excellent selection. But be warned, it is not a romance even though there are relationships involved. This is a story about sisters and having to choose between keeping a secret and protecting them. The hard choices you're forced to make when you love someone.
My own thoughts as to how this ended .... If you have any inclination to read this book do not sneak a peek at this spoiler.
3.5 Stars.
After about seventeen straight months and nearly 800 books later, I figured it was time to take a step out of the typical romance themed reads and venture into something a bit different. We Are The Goldens is a young adult novel that does not revolve the relationship of a love interest, but rather the relationship of two sisters. The story is told in a way that had me jumping to all sorts of conclusions about how this was going to play out. Nell, the younger sister is the narrator of this tale, but the main character in some aspects is really her older sister, Layla.
Only a small age gap exist between these girls, but in the hopes of ensuring they would grown into their own personalities (given how close they were), one was pushed to start school early while the other was held back. This places Nell entering her Freshmen year at high school, while Layla begins her Junior. As anyone who has a sister knows, this gap although small, can seem like a decades when it comes to the emotional state of teenage girls. When Nell starts to see the change in Layla she can't seem to figure out at first what is to blame, but that secret doesn't last long and Nell is forced to either remain the keeper of her sister's secrets and keep her relationship close or to tell and risk losing the one person she has idolized her entire life.
The way this story was told, I felt like a connection was made with Nell, she was struggling to not disappoint her sister, to ensure that their bond did not fail. She was so certain that she could turn a blind eye to the truth if it meant that Layla was truly happy. She tried convincing herself that Layla, the perfect sister that she always looked up to, couldn't be the one to make this big of a mistake. That connection sort of ended with Nell and did not carry over to Layla though. Layla's secret and her emotional state during most of this was something that I needed to read first had, from her lips to really feel.
In the end the story was left pretty open, I am sure in the author's eyes there is a perfectly reasonable ending - but there is room to explore several avenues as to how this truly ends. For being a story that is a bit out of my comfort zone as to what really keeps my attention, this book and author did a fantastic job doing just that. Nell narrating the story but speaking it to Layla, took a little getting used to, especially when it would go from Nell speaking directly to Layla to dialogue with Nell and others; but once you get into the flow of the story the rhythm is easily picked up. Typically when I finish a story that ends like this one did, I can quiet my mind of the lingering questions about just how did it truly end... for some reason I feel like not knowing for 100% is going to drive me a little bit crazy.
If you enjoy the young adult genre, that is a little more PG-13ish, that forces you to really think about what you are reading, this would be an excellent selection. But be warned, it is not a romance even though there are relationships involved. This is a story about sisters and having to choose between keeping a secret and protecting them. The hard choices you're forced to make when you love someone.
My own thoughts as to how this ended .... If you have any inclination to read this book do not sneak a peek at this spoiler.
October 31, 2014
Sisterhood is complex. And complicated. That much I know even without having a sister. Although I've frequently wondered what it would be like to have one. Especially one really close in age. (when we were kids my little brother and I used to pester my mom - of course always Mom - to "give" us a sister...she vehemently refused...hmmm wonder if we were really that "bad")
Nell and Layla have always been very close. So much so that Nell used to consider them "one entity" when she was a kid. (and hence referred to both of them by one name - Nellayla) Layla is 17 months older. The levelheaded, reliable one. The popular and beautiful one. The star soccer player. But Nell doesn't mind. Because it's Layla and Nell against the world. Until Nell starts her freshman year at the same high school as Layla. And starts noticing all the little ways in which Layla is starting to change. Withdrawing. Keeping secrets.
We Are The Goldens reads like a letter Nell wrote to Layla. About what that distance between them feels like for her. About boys. And navigating the tricky world of teenagehood and high school. About Duncan and Parker, teen sons of family friends. About their parents. About falling in love. About missing her sister.
"But I guess I was imposing a Hollywood version of falling in love onto a high school where there really isn't much use for love, or even dating. There's hookups and people who hang out and all sorts of variations, but the actual boyfriend/girlfriend is a rare breed at City Day."
It was a quick and fairly engaging read for me. I tend to enjoy YA literature of this kind. And while I was reading We Are The Goldens I really did enjoy it. All the characters came to life and it made me care about both girls. However the entire time it felt like the story is building towards something significant and emotionally impactful, there was a sense of anticipation that kept moving the story forward. And then the ending fell short for me. I was left looking at the last sentence thinking "Really? That's it?" I feel that with a different ending I would've given this story a higher rating.
If there was a book telling the story from Layla's point of view I would definitely pick it up. I'd recommend this one to YA lovers who are looking for a fast read and are drawn to the subject matter.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Nell and Layla have always been very close. So much so that Nell used to consider them "one entity" when she was a kid. (and hence referred to both of them by one name - Nellayla) Layla is 17 months older. The levelheaded, reliable one. The popular and beautiful one. The star soccer player. But Nell doesn't mind. Because it's Layla and Nell against the world. Until Nell starts her freshman year at the same high school as Layla. And starts noticing all the little ways in which Layla is starting to change. Withdrawing. Keeping secrets.
We Are The Goldens reads like a letter Nell wrote to Layla. About what that distance between them feels like for her. About boys. And navigating the tricky world of teenagehood and high school. About Duncan and Parker, teen sons of family friends. About their parents. About falling in love. About missing her sister.
"But I guess I was imposing a Hollywood version of falling in love onto a high school where there really isn't much use for love, or even dating. There's hookups and people who hang out and all sorts of variations, but the actual boyfriend/girlfriend is a rare breed at City Day."
It was a quick and fairly engaging read for me. I tend to enjoy YA literature of this kind. And while I was reading We Are The Goldens I really did enjoy it. All the characters came to life and it made me care about both girls. However the entire time it felt like the story is building towards something significant and emotionally impactful, there was a sense of anticipation that kept moving the story forward. And then the ending fell short for me. I was left looking at the last sentence thinking "Really? That's it?" I feel that with a different ending I would've given this story a higher rating.
If there was a book telling the story from Layla's point of view I would definitely pick it up. I'd recommend this one to YA lovers who are looking for a fast read and are drawn to the subject matter.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
May 3, 2015
3.5 Stars
This book was actually much better than I had expected. For me, YA titles can be really hit or miss. Although not exceptional, this book was a pretty good read.
Meet the Golden sisters, Layla & Nell.
Written in first person, past tense from Nell's pov. The story is Nell's letter? confession? apology? to her sister Layla. This style of narrative is not original, but I found it perfectly suited this storyline - adding depth and a sense of discovery.
The sisters are close. So close that, as a toddler Nell thought her name was Nellayla. Layla is older and Nell has always been like her shadow - and has often felt like she was living in her sister's shadow - a space she happily occupies. Children of a broken home, they have relied on each other for strength and stability.
So what would it take to interfere with this type of bond? What extreme? This question is what really kept me reading.
Being a YA novel, there is a wonderful sense of self-discovery and growth in this book. Nell learns some very tough lessons and makes some very mature - and some very immature decisions. I loved the quiet struggle she felt moving into adulthood ... the sadness of leaving behind childhood. But most of all I really loved the development of her relationship with her best friend Felix. For me, he was by far the best character in this book. The way he sets Nell straight on her sister:
The ending is left open to interpretation &/or imagination. For some readers this may sound like a deal breaker ... I know many prefer to have their stories all neatly wrapped up ... but in this case it's not required. I honestly really liked that I don't know what came next - it somehow feels more realistic.
Overall a really nice read.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth.
~ Marcus Aurelius ~
This book was actually much better than I had expected. For me, YA titles can be really hit or miss. Although not exceptional, this book was a pretty good read.
Meet the Golden sisters, Layla & Nell.
Written in first person, past tense from Nell's pov. The story is Nell's letter? confession? apology? to her sister Layla. This style of narrative is not original, but I found it perfectly suited this storyline - adding depth and a sense of discovery.
The sisters are close. So close that, as a toddler Nell thought her name was Nellayla. Layla is older and Nell has always been like her shadow - and has often felt like she was living in her sister's shadow - a space she happily occupies. Children of a broken home, they have relied on each other for strength and stability.
Our lives are intertwined
So what would it take to interfere with this type of bond? What extreme? This question is what really kept me reading.
Being a YA novel, there is a wonderful sense of self-discovery and growth in this book. Nell learns some very tough lessons and makes some very mature - and some very immature decisions. I loved the quiet struggle she felt moving into adulthood ... the sadness of leaving behind childhood. But most of all I really loved the development of her relationship with her best friend Felix. For me, he was by far the best character in this book. The way he sets Nell straight on her sister:
Why does the devil always need an advocate? Don't you think he can argue things for himself?
The ending is left open to interpretation &/or imagination. For some readers this may sound like a deal breaker ... I know many prefer to have their stories all neatly wrapped up ... but in this case it's not required. I honestly really liked that I don't know what came next - it somehow feels more realistic.
Overall a really nice read.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
January 17, 2021
Grade: A-
Nell lives in the shadow of her older, perfect sister Layla, at least in her own mind. But Layla's life isn't so perfect. She's hiding a secret and she makes Nell complacent in that secret, even though Nell knows how wrong it is.
Nell's narration, with the unique second person POV to Layla, is a unique, intelligent and breathtakingly insightful look at high school, peer pressure, rumors, sisters, and love. She's a complex character, a good kid who sometimes breaks the rules. Her vision is that of a young girl biased by insecurity and hero-worship of her big sister. At times the dialogue is a bit mature for high school students, the witty banter too intellectual for even bright teenagers.
WE ARE THE GOLDENS is a fast paced, short read, but one that gripped me from page one and didn't let up even when I finished the book. This YA novel is interesting for both teens and adults. I will certainly look for more novels by Dana Reinhardt.
ETA: I enjoyed the audiobook as much as reading the story.
Nell lives in the shadow of her older, perfect sister Layla, at least in her own mind. But Layla's life isn't so perfect. She's hiding a secret and she makes Nell complacent in that secret, even though Nell knows how wrong it is.
Nell's narration, with the unique second person POV to Layla, is a unique, intelligent and breathtakingly insightful look at high school, peer pressure, rumors, sisters, and love. She's a complex character, a good kid who sometimes breaks the rules. Her vision is that of a young girl biased by insecurity and hero-worship of her big sister. At times the dialogue is a bit mature for high school students, the witty banter too intellectual for even bright teenagers.
WE ARE THE GOLDENS is a fast paced, short read, but one that gripped me from page one and didn't let up even when I finished the book. This YA novel is interesting for both teens and adults. I will certainly look for more novels by Dana Reinhardt.
ETA: I enjoyed the audiobook as much as reading the story.
May 7, 2014
This book was awesome right from the beginning. The pages were flying and i couldn't get enough. I loved how it was narrated and how Nell talked to us as if we were her older sister. It was very relatable to those who have siblings. The ending was great as well. I only wished to be invited to more of the family drama, so I'm hoping there's a sequel. I look forward to reading more from this author. Thank you netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read something fantastic!
June 19, 2017
4 STARS
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
I was surprised by much I ended up enjoyed this book. I think that the cover threw off my expectations. If the cover is in any way deterring you from reading it, just know the cover does not accurately reflect the book.
I think one of my favorite things about this book was the writing. It's written in 2nd person and in a very straightforward way. However there are a lot of subtleties in the overall story-line that I liked, mostly in regards to how the relationships between characters were written.
As I said, the characters were great! I think that every character was multifaceted and fleshed-out. A lot of the side characters were complex and that made them feel more realistic. It also helped me root for or understand them when they were acting annoying or downright insufferable. I appreciated how there was an emphasis on both family and friendship and the balance between the two.
The plot was very character-driven and slow, but I liked it. Everything was set up very well and the pacing was perfect for the feeling and content of the book. While I've seen that other people disliked where and how the story ended, I think that was the perfect ending. I think there were enough hints as to how all the loose ends would tie up, but it still had an open ending. I think that sort of ending was the only way to go for this story.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to anyone looking for a short, slightly different contemporary.
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
I was surprised by much I ended up enjoyed this book. I think that the cover threw off my expectations. If the cover is in any way deterring you from reading it, just know the cover does not accurately reflect the book.
I think one of my favorite things about this book was the writing. It's written in 2nd person and in a very straightforward way. However there are a lot of subtleties in the overall story-line that I liked, mostly in regards to how the relationships between characters were written.
As I said, the characters were great! I think that every character was multifaceted and fleshed-out. A lot of the side characters were complex and that made them feel more realistic. It also helped me root for or understand them when they were acting annoying or downright insufferable. I appreciated how there was an emphasis on both family and friendship and the balance between the two.
The plot was very character-driven and slow, but I liked it. Everything was set up very well and the pacing was perfect for the feeling and content of the book. While I've seen that other people disliked where and how the story ended, I think that was the perfect ending. I think there were enough hints as to how all the loose ends would tie up, but it still had an open ending. I think that sort of ending was the only way to go for this story.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to anyone looking for a short, slightly different contemporary.
May 3, 2014
Provided by the publisher for review via NetGalley.
Review has spoilers, but I think I hid them.
We are the Goldens is about two very close sisters who drift apart after the older sister, Layla starts seeing one of her teachers. The book is written from the younger sister, Nell’s point of view as she has to navigate life after her sister starts to pull away because of the secret she is keeping.
I wanted to read this book because it seemed like an interesting read. I always enjoy a good sister story and was intrigued by the synopsis. However, while I think I understand what the author was trying to accomplish with this book, I can’t say I really enjoyed it. The writing is fine but the voice was off for me. It is written from Nell’s POV but she’s directing all of it to Lena in the past tense (mostly). It seemed to go back and forth between past and present. It was just hard for me to read. I also found Nell’s inner dialogue brought out by imaginary conversations with brothers who died in the past to be very disjointed. There really wasn’t enough information there for me to understand why she felt so connected to them (other than the fact that she feels they were as close to each other as she is to her sister). I couldn’t find it super believable.
On a positive note, I really liked Nell’s relationship with Felix. It was sweet and very genuine.
So even though I wasn’t feeling the book all the way through, I did finish it and the ending was so disappointing it made me upset that I didn’t just stop reading earlier. So in the beginning I said, “I think I understand what the author was trying to accomplish with this book,� but now that I’ve thought about it more, I feel like I don’t know. Is it a problem novel, a book about sisters, a personal growth story? I’m not sure, because it just seems to fall short on all levels. Yeah, I’m still kind of mad about wasting my time on this book.
Would I actively recommend this book to my teens? Probably not. It’s an ok book, but I can think of outstanding books I’d rather recommend to them first.
Review has spoilers, but I think I hid them.
We are the Goldens is about two very close sisters who drift apart after the older sister, Layla starts seeing one of her teachers. The book is written from the younger sister, Nell’s point of view as she has to navigate life after her sister starts to pull away because of the secret she is keeping.
I wanted to read this book because it seemed like an interesting read. I always enjoy a good sister story and was intrigued by the synopsis. However, while I think I understand what the author was trying to accomplish with this book, I can’t say I really enjoyed it. The writing is fine but the voice was off for me. It is written from Nell’s POV but she’s directing all of it to Lena in the past tense (mostly). It seemed to go back and forth between past and present. It was just hard for me to read. I also found Nell’s inner dialogue brought out by imaginary conversations with brothers who died in the past to be very disjointed. There really wasn’t enough information there for me to understand why she felt so connected to them (other than the fact that she feels they were as close to each other as she is to her sister). I couldn’t find it super believable.
On a positive note, I really liked Nell’s relationship with Felix. It was sweet and very genuine.
So even though I wasn’t feeling the book all the way through, I did finish it and the ending was so disappointing it made me upset that I didn’t just stop reading earlier. So in the beginning I said, “I think I understand what the author was trying to accomplish with this book,� but now that I’ve thought about it more, I feel like I don’t know. Is it a problem novel, a book about sisters, a personal growth story? I’m not sure, because it just seems to fall short on all levels. Yeah, I’m still kind of mad about wasting my time on this book.
Would I actively recommend this book to my teens? Probably not. It’s an ok book, but I can think of outstanding books I’d rather recommend to them first.
April 2, 2017
WE ARE THE GOLDENS was an amazing read and I enjoyed it thoroughly. It's in a genre I don't normally choose, but good writing will suck me in every time and I thought Dana Reinhardt did a fabulous job giving life and voice to the Golden sisters.
We didn't need anybody else. But more than that, we were better without anybody else.
The story is about Nell and Layla, their family and friends. They are sisters who are very, very close. Layla's the older sister. She's one of those girls whose life seems charmed. She's smart, talented, loving and athletic. A sensible teen who has her act together. Nell is her little sister. Nell appears to be every bit as gifted and smart as her sister, but she's at an age and a place in her life where she can't see that yet. And for the time being she's in Layla's shadow. But she's okay with that. She loves Layla fiercely.
I'll probably always remember where I was and what I wore and all that, it was that kind of moment.
I could no longer pretend.
Something was happening.
Something that shouldn't be.
And I had absolutely no idea what to do.
WE ARE THE GOLDENS is about love and betrayal and the basic human condition. Our inability, on the one hand, to see our own doom racing towards us. And our total freaking cluelessness as to what to do when we see disaster poised to strike someone we love.
~
This book worked for me on so many levels. The writing was excellent. Nell's voice was a perfect blend of intelligence and innocence. It made her dilemmas believable. I also loved Nell's relationship with Felix, her BFF. Adorable isn't strong enough a word.
What I don't understand was Dana Reinhardt's having Nell converse with the dead boys. They were probably there to underscore some subtle point, but I wasn't smart enough to figure it out.
I don't have a lot of books in my repertoire to compare this to. But if you enjoyed Swati Avasthi's SPLIT, or Francisco Stork's LAST SUMMER OF THE DEATH WARRIORS, or even Green's FAULT IN OUR STARS, you might want to pick this up.
I think the 'undetermined' ending is going to throw some readers. (Lady or the Tiger?) But I also think it's part and parcel of what is going to make WE ARE THE GOLDENS a fabulous book club read. There is just going to be so much to discuss.
4.5 Stars for me
We didn't need anybody else. But more than that, we were better without anybody else.
The story is about Nell and Layla, their family and friends. They are sisters who are very, very close. Layla's the older sister. She's one of those girls whose life seems charmed. She's smart, talented, loving and athletic. A sensible teen who has her act together. Nell is her little sister. Nell appears to be every bit as gifted and smart as her sister, but she's at an age and a place in her life where she can't see that yet. And for the time being she's in Layla's shadow. But she's okay with that. She loves Layla fiercely.
I'll probably always remember where I was and what I wore and all that, it was that kind of moment.
I could no longer pretend.
Something was happening.
Something that shouldn't be.
And I had absolutely no idea what to do.
WE ARE THE GOLDENS is about love and betrayal and the basic human condition. Our inability, on the one hand, to see our own doom racing towards us. And our total freaking cluelessness as to what to do when we see disaster poised to strike someone we love.
~
This book worked for me on so many levels. The writing was excellent. Nell's voice was a perfect blend of intelligence and innocence. It made her dilemmas believable. I also loved Nell's relationship with Felix, her BFF. Adorable isn't strong enough a word.
What I don't understand was Dana Reinhardt's having Nell converse with the dead boys. They were probably there to underscore some subtle point, but I wasn't smart enough to figure it out.
I don't have a lot of books in my repertoire to compare this to. But if you enjoyed Swati Avasthi's SPLIT, or Francisco Stork's LAST SUMMER OF THE DEATH WARRIORS, or even Green's FAULT IN OUR STARS, you might want to pick this up.
I think the 'undetermined' ending is going to throw some readers. (Lady or the Tiger?) But I also think it's part and parcel of what is going to make WE ARE THE GOLDENS a fabulous book club read. There is just going to be so much to discuss.
4.5 Stars for me
April 26, 2014
What do you do when the older sister you idolize is flirting with danger and a broken heart and you are sworn to keep quiet? Nell has worshipped her older sister from the cradle, they have always shared everything. Layla is changing, becoming introverted, secretive and has become blind to the common sense she has always been known for. How can young Nell save her sister from herself, she knows she should talk to an adult, but she made a promise to Layla. Their family has had enough upheaval through the years, their parents are loving, but self-absorbed and Nell knows what her sister is doing is wrong and she should tell someone, but who would listen? How would Layla feel?
We Are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt is a coming of age story, a tale of the relationship between two sisters, love and trust during those painful teen years. Told through the voice of high school freshman, Nell Golden, we are invited by the author to journey through the turmoil and confusion of a young girl’s mind and heart as she struggles with things she does not quite understand while trying to decide whether to hold the secrets she has been told or follow her gut and talk to her parents.
Dana Reinhardt has done a wonderful job of drawing the reader into the very heart of her tale. Nell is an amazing character, her struggle is painful to watch. If you’ve ever had to maintain silence in the name of love and loyalty, all while knowing the secret you hold is dangerous, you will understand this young girl completely. Does Nell do the right thing? Will it be too late for her sister? Ms. Reinhardt has written a must read that younger readers will identify with and enjoy.
I received an ARC edition from Wendy Lamb Books in exchange for my honest review.
Publication Date: May 27, 2014
Publisher: Wendy Lamb Books
ISBN: 9780385742573
Genre: Teens|YA Fiction
Print Length: 208 pages
Available from: |
We Are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt is a coming of age story, a tale of the relationship between two sisters, love and trust during those painful teen years. Told through the voice of high school freshman, Nell Golden, we are invited by the author to journey through the turmoil and confusion of a young girl’s mind and heart as she struggles with things she does not quite understand while trying to decide whether to hold the secrets she has been told or follow her gut and talk to her parents.
Dana Reinhardt has done a wonderful job of drawing the reader into the very heart of her tale. Nell is an amazing character, her struggle is painful to watch. If you’ve ever had to maintain silence in the name of love and loyalty, all while knowing the secret you hold is dangerous, you will understand this young girl completely. Does Nell do the right thing? Will it be too late for her sister? Ms. Reinhardt has written a must read that younger readers will identify with and enjoy.
I received an ARC edition from Wendy Lamb Books in exchange for my honest review.
Publication Date: May 27, 2014
Publisher: Wendy Lamb Books
ISBN: 9780385742573
Genre: Teens|YA Fiction
Print Length: 208 pages
Available from: |
May 12, 2014
For a full and edited review go to
� As you went back to Layla, the girl with the world on a string, I went back to playing Nell, adoring sister, keeper of the peace.
The sister who lies for you.�
As someone who has an older sibling whose only 13.5 months older than me this book hit pretty close to home. I’ve never blindly adored my brother but one word from him can change my whole mood and I’ve covered for him a lot. Although I’ve never had to cover up something as bad as Nell had too.
I liked Nell, she was strong and we were able to see how she started to rely on more on herself than she did on her sister. Layla on the other hand was a basket case, maybe because we had such a limited view of her but she didn’t seem like the popular goody two-shoes. It would be great to get a second book or a novella with her point of view. I mean how do you drop a bombshell of a secret on your little sister and then go � By the way you can’t tell anybody and if you do you’ll ruin my life�. Not exactly the kindest older sister..
As for supporting characters, Nell’s best friend Felix has become one of my favorite besties! He was sensitive, sassy, and funny. The trifecta that all best friends should have.
“Jesus, Felix.�
“It’s Hey-soos. Don’t go forgetting your Spanish.�
One of my favorite things about their relationship was that it wasn’t just one sided. It wasn’t Nell complaining endlessly about her problems and Felix having a perfect life. Instead they supported each other and shared their problems so they wouldn’t have to carry them alone.
What I hated the most about this book was the ending. It just stopped. Just when we were getting to the juicy big blow up scene it was over. I mean none of our questions were answered and it ended up in a limbo.
Overall it’s a great story, especially if you have a sibling and even if you don’t theres still enough mystery and romance to keep you interested.
� As you went back to Layla, the girl with the world on a string, I went back to playing Nell, adoring sister, keeper of the peace.
The sister who lies for you.�
As someone who has an older sibling whose only 13.5 months older than me this book hit pretty close to home. I’ve never blindly adored my brother but one word from him can change my whole mood and I’ve covered for him a lot. Although I’ve never had to cover up something as bad as Nell had too.
I liked Nell, she was strong and we were able to see how she started to rely on more on herself than she did on her sister. Layla on the other hand was a basket case, maybe because we had such a limited view of her but she didn’t seem like the popular goody two-shoes. It would be great to get a second book or a novella with her point of view. I mean how do you drop a bombshell of a secret on your little sister and then go � By the way you can’t tell anybody and if you do you’ll ruin my life�. Not exactly the kindest older sister..
As for supporting characters, Nell’s best friend Felix has become one of my favorite besties! He was sensitive, sassy, and funny. The trifecta that all best friends should have.
“Jesus, Felix.�
“It’s Hey-soos. Don’t go forgetting your Spanish.�
One of my favorite things about their relationship was that it wasn’t just one sided. It wasn’t Nell complaining endlessly about her problems and Felix having a perfect life. Instead they supported each other and shared their problems so they wouldn’t have to carry them alone.
What I hated the most about this book was the ending. It just stopped. Just when we were getting to the juicy big blow up scene it was over. I mean none of our questions were answered and it ended up in a limbo.
Overall it’s a great story, especially if you have a sibling and even if you don’t theres still enough mystery and romance to keep you interested.
April 9, 2015
I like Dana Reinhardt's work. I loved and really enjoyed . So I was really looking forward to and was slightly disappointed.
One reason I didn't like this as much as I thought I would was because I couldn't connect with any of the characters. Nell wasn't annoying or anything, but she seemed kinda bland compared to heroines from Reinhardt's other books, like Simone (from A Brief Chapter in my Impossible Life). Layla seemed like the character with the most potential, but we never get to see things from her perspective. POV from both Nell and Layla would have been nice.
Felix was a nice character, but towards the end a slight romance cropped up between him and Nell, and I really preferred when they were just friends. At least their romance isn't present much in the story, but still the story would've been better off without it completely.
The biggest problem with We are the Goldens is that the ending is very cliffhanger-esque. I hate when books ended with the conflict being unresolved. I wanted more closure. I was unsatisfied.
But, I do like Dana Reinhardt's writing, as always, and the book wasn't completely unenjoyable. It wasn't bad, just lackluster and disappointing. Three stars
One reason I didn't like this as much as I thought I would was because I couldn't connect with any of the characters. Nell wasn't annoying or anything, but she seemed kinda bland compared to heroines from Reinhardt's other books, like Simone (from A Brief Chapter in my Impossible Life). Layla seemed like the character with the most potential, but we never get to see things from her perspective. POV from both Nell and Layla would have been nice.
Felix was a nice character, but towards the end a slight romance cropped up between him and Nell, and I really preferred when they were just friends. At least their romance isn't present much in the story, but still the story would've been better off without it completely.
The biggest problem with We are the Goldens is that the ending is very cliffhanger-esque. I hate when books ended with the conflict being unresolved. I wanted more closure. I was unsatisfied.
But, I do like Dana Reinhardt's writing, as always, and the book wasn't completely unenjoyable. It wasn't bad, just lackluster and disappointing. Three stars
May 14, 2014
Ok, where to start? This book was moving and powerful and creepy and I really liked it.
The creepy first. Spoilers will follow, please be warned.
1) Nell's obsession with her sister is just this side of normal and crosses that line often. I think her issue with her sister's lover was more jealousy than a true concern for right and wrong.
2) DUDE, who her sister's lover was is GROSS.
3) Not creepy, but annoying, that ending was WAAAAY too "lady or the tiger". This is a book, not a short story, there are multiple ways that last sentence could spin things. Not writing a proper ending is rude to the readers and just makes the writer look lazy.
That being said, this was a well written book, until the ending or lack thereof. The narrator and tone of voice was different, in an interesting way. The issues in the book seemed to be natural for a high schooler, though I admit, the friendship between Nell and Felix didn't seem very real.
I LOVED Felix. He was the badly needed comic relief and balancing act between the two sisters' drama. He seemed to disappear a bit towards the end of the book when the inner turmoil was taking Nell over. Also, other reviewers didn't like the Creed brothers' ghosts, but I liked them. It was an interesting way for Nell to interact with her subconsciousness, a way for her to come to realizations that weren't very comfortable for her to acknowledge.
If the book had an actual ending, I would have given it four stars instead of three.
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC copy to review.
The creepy first. Spoilers will follow, please be warned.
1) Nell's obsession with her sister is just this side of normal and crosses that line often. I think her issue with her sister's lover was more jealousy than a true concern for right and wrong.
2) DUDE, who her sister's lover was is GROSS.
3) Not creepy, but annoying, that ending was WAAAAY too "lady or the tiger". This is a book, not a short story, there are multiple ways that last sentence could spin things. Not writing a proper ending is rude to the readers and just makes the writer look lazy.
That being said, this was a well written book, until the ending or lack thereof. The narrator and tone of voice was different, in an interesting way. The issues in the book seemed to be natural for a high schooler, though I admit, the friendship between Nell and Felix didn't seem very real.
I LOVED Felix. He was the badly needed comic relief and balancing act between the two sisters' drama. He seemed to disappear a bit towards the end of the book when the inner turmoil was taking Nell over. Also, other reviewers didn't like the Creed brothers' ghosts, but I liked them. It was an interesting way for Nell to interact with her subconsciousness, a way for her to come to realizations that weren't very comfortable for her to acknowledge.
If the book had an actual ending, I would have given it four stars instead of three.
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC copy to review.
August 31, 2016
Provided by the Publisher via NetGalley
At one point when I was reading this book, I thought it was going to be one of those books that would blow my mind. Not that the book was not interesting or anything, but the slow, dragging pace really got on my nerves.
The writing which was done very nicely, actually. And that was one of the reasons for me to read and finish this book. It was full of questions that needed answers and I just couldn't put it down until I knew what the heck was going on. I guess the slow pace was because of this book was too overly descriptive. Nell went on and on before getting to the point. I liked her character, but the girl sounded insane at times.
Now on to the characters. I loved that Nell and Layla were not ones of those one-dimensional characters. At the beginning of the book, I was touched by how much Nell loved her big sister. Later, her love became a little too creepy. Though, I liked that she tried to protect her sister and all that.
The ending was not too bad, but I wasn't satisfied being left in the unknown. A bit on what was going to happen afterward would have been more than appreciated.
Blog:
June 26, 2016
Want to see more bookish things from me? Check out my YouTube channel:
Nell and Layla are sisters and best friends, they're basically inseparable. When Nell starts school at City Day, she starts to notice that Layla begins to pull away from her and she doesn't know why. When Nell discovers Layla is hiding a big secret, she has to decide whether to keep the secret or tell someone in order to save her sister from herself.
Right from the start I was hooked, I loved the writing style and I could not put the book down! The book was almost written as a letter to the older sister Layla and it was an interesting concept! I loved Nell's voice and thought the author did an amazing job portraying the inner struggle she was feeling. I was able to call what the big secret was, but I still could not put the book down, I NEEDED to know how it all played out. I dropped a star because of how quickly the ending came, I was a little disappointed, I want to to know what came out of Nell's decision. I loved Felix and totally shipped him and Nell the entire time, screw Sam! Overall I think the book was suspenseful and exciting but it also taught a deeper lesson.
Nell and Layla are sisters and best friends, they're basically inseparable. When Nell starts school at City Day, she starts to notice that Layla begins to pull away from her and she doesn't know why. When Nell discovers Layla is hiding a big secret, she has to decide whether to keep the secret or tell someone in order to save her sister from herself.
Right from the start I was hooked, I loved the writing style and I could not put the book down! The book was almost written as a letter to the older sister Layla and it was an interesting concept! I loved Nell's voice and thought the author did an amazing job portraying the inner struggle she was feeling. I was able to call what the big secret was, but I still could not put the book down, I NEEDED to know how it all played out. I dropped a star because of how quickly the ending came, I was a little disappointed, I want to to know what came out of Nell's decision. I loved Felix and totally shipped him and Nell the entire time, screw Sam! Overall I think the book was suspenseful and exciting but it also taught a deeper lesson.
April 13, 2014
Foxy and I were invited to read this book via NetGalley. The synopsis intrigued me enough to give it a shot, not to mention, it was a shorter book and that always appeals to me. After finishing the book, I asked Foxy to read it so we could compare notes on the ending.
From the beginning, the author has you guessing what the outcome of the story will be. The book is narrated by Nell, younger sibling to Layla by about a year and a half. Nell has always looked up to Layla and the two of them were always close
...until Nell's Freshman year. Layla has a secret, Nell knows the secret and and has agreed to keep it to herself. Could the secret be enough to sever the bond between them?
Foxy and I each came to different conclusions regarding the ending. To each their own!
From the beginning, the author has you guessing what the outcome of the story will be. The book is narrated by Nell, younger sibling to Layla by about a year and a half. Nell has always looked up to Layla and the two of them were always close
...until Nell's Freshman year. Layla has a secret, Nell knows the secret and and has agreed to keep it to herself. Could the secret be enough to sever the bond between them?
Foxy and I each came to different conclusions regarding the ending. To each their own!
June 17, 2014
ARC for review.
Excellent YA - love the voice of Nell, the narrator as she navigates problems, both her own and the serious problem her sister Layla has become involved in - divorced parents, pressures of sex, sisterhood and best friend relationships are all touched on in an incredibly realistic way and I completely appreciated the ending. And Felix. Love me some Felix.
Recommended for fans of YA "problem novels" and YA stand alones. I'll definitely be looking for more Reinhardt in the future.
*Edited to add - this book was just prominently visible in a scene in one of the first two episodes of season 2 of "Orange is the New Black". I love the way this show is constantly showing the characters reading AND what books they are reading. "Lost" was good about this too.
Excellent YA - love the voice of Nell, the narrator as she navigates problems, both her own and the serious problem her sister Layla has become involved in - divorced parents, pressures of sex, sisterhood and best friend relationships are all touched on in an incredibly realistic way and I completely appreciated the ending. And Felix. Love me some Felix.
Recommended for fans of YA "problem novels" and YA stand alones. I'll definitely be looking for more Reinhardt in the future.
*Edited to add - this book was just prominently visible in a scene in one of the first two episodes of season 2 of "Orange is the New Black". I love the way this show is constantly showing the characters reading AND what books they are reading. "Lost" was good about this too.
Read
May 31, 2014I really liked this! Beautiful writing. Takes a topic that could go melodramatic and tawdry and makes it a concise but moving story about sisters and secrets and loyalty and trust. I wasn't sure about the dead brothers thing, but the hybrid first/second person tense and even that frustrating ending actually worked for me. Longer review soon!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 549 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.