What do you think?
Rate this book
螣喂 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼
欧宝娱乐 Choice Award
Winner for Readers' Favorite Historical Fiction (2024), Nominee for Readers' Favorite Audiobook (2024)螣喂 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 碌蟺慰蟻慰蠉谓 谓伪 纬委谓慰蠀谓 畏蟻蠅委未蔚蟼. 螌蟿伪谓 畏 蠁慰喂蟿萎蟿蟻喂伪 谓慰蟽畏位蔚蠀蟿喂魏萎蟼 桅蟻维谓蟽喂蟼 芦桅蟻维谓魏喂禄 螠伪魏螕魏蟻维胃 伪魏慰蠉蔚喂 伪蠀蟿维 蟿伪 位蠈纬喂伪, 魏维蟿喂 伪位位维味蔚喂 碌苇蟽伪 蟿畏蟼. 螠蔚纬伪位蠅碌苇谓畏 蟽蟿慰谓 畏位喂蠈位慰蠀蟽蟿慰, 蔚喂未蠀位位喂伪魏蠈 魏蠈蟽碌慰 蟿畏蟼 螡蠈蟿喂伪蟼 螝伪位喂蠁蠈蟻谓喂伪蟼, 蟽蟿慰 蟺蟻慰蟽蟿伪蟿蔚蠀碌苇谓慰 蟺蔚蟻喂尾维位位慰谓 蟺慰蠀 苇蠂慰蠀谓 未畏碌喂慰蠀蟻纬萎蟽蔚喂 慰喂 蟽蠀谓蟿畏蟻畏蟿喂魏慰委 纬慰谓蔚委蟼 蟿畏蟼, 苇谓喂蠅胃蔚 蟺维谓蟿伪 蟺蔚蟻萎蠁伪谓畏 蔚蟺蔚喂未萎 苇魏伪谓蔚 蟿慰 蟽蠅蟽蟿蠈. 螒位位维 蟿慰 1965 慰 魏蠈蟽碌慰蟼 伪位位维味蔚喂. 螌蟿伪谓 慰 伪未蔚蟻蠁蠈蟼 蟿畏蟼 蠁蔚蠉纬蔚喂 纬喂伪 谓伪 蠀蟺畏蟻蔚蟿萎蟽蔚喂 蟽蟿慰 螔喂蔚蟿谓维碌, 蔚魏蔚委谓畏 魏伪蟿伪蟿维蟽蟽蔚蟿伪喂 蔚胃蔚位慰谓蟿喂魏维 蟽蟿慰 危蠋碌伪 螡慰蟽慰魏蠈碌蠅谓 蟿慰蠀 危蟿蟻伪蟿慰蠉. 螒蟺蟻慰蔚蟿慰委碌伪蟽蟿畏 魏伪喂 维蟺蔚喂蟻畏, 畏 桅蟻维谓魏喂 苇蟻蠂蔚蟿伪喂 伪谓蟿喂碌苇蟿蠅蟺畏 碌蔚 蟿慰 蠂维慰蟼 魏伪喂 蟿畏谓 魏伪蟿伪蟽蟿蟻慰蠁萎. 螝维胃蔚 碌苇蟻伪 蔚委谓伪喂 苇谓伪 蟽蟿慰委蠂畏碌伪 味蠅萎蟼 萎 胃伪谓维蟿慰蠀, 蔚位蟺委未伪蟼 萎 蟺蟻慰未慰蟽委伪蟼.
螌碌蠅蟼 慰 蟺蠈位蔚碌慰蟼 蔚委谓伪喂 碌蠈谓慰 畏 伪蟻蠂萎 纬喂伪 蟿畏 桅蟻维谓魏喂 魏伪喂 蟿慰蠀蟼 尾蔚蟿蔚蟻维谓慰蠀蟼 蠁委位慰蠀蟼 蟿畏蟼. 螚 伪位畏胃喂谓萎 碌维蠂畏 蟿慰蠉蟼 蟺蔚蟻喂碌苇谓蔚喂 蟽蟿畏谓 蟺伪蟿蟻委未伪, 蟽蔚 碌喂伪 螒碌蔚蟻喂魏萎 伪位位伪纬碌苇谓畏 魏伪喂 未喂蠂伪蟽碌苇谓畏, 蟺慰蠀 胃苇位蔚喂 谓伪 尉蔚蠂维蟽蔚喂.
螣喂 螕蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蔚委谓伪喂 畏 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 碌喂伪蟼 纬蠀谓伪委魏伪蟼 蟺慰蠀 蟺萎纬蔚 蟽蟿慰谓 蟺蠈位蔚碌慰, 伪位位维 蠁蠅蟿委味蔚喂 魏伪喂 蟿喂蟼 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委蔚蟼 蠈位蠅谓 蟿蠅谓 纬蠀谓伪喂魏蠋谓 蟺慰蠀 伪蟺慰蠁伪蟽委味慰蠀谓 谓伪 蟻喂蠂蟿慰蠉谓 蟽蟿畏 碌维蠂畏 魏伪喂 蟿蠅谓 慰蟺慰委蠅谓 慰喂 胃蠀蟽委蔚蟼 魏伪喂 畏 伪蠁慰蟽委蠅蟽畏 蟽蟿畏谓 蟺伪蟿蟻委未伪 蟺慰位蠉 蟽蠀蠂谓维 位畏蟽碌慰谓慰蠉谓蟿伪喂.
螆谓伪 碌蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏碌伪 纬喂伪 蟿喂蟼 尾伪胃喂苇蟼 蠁喂位委蔚蟼 魏伪喂 蟿慰谓 蟿慰位碌畏蟻蠈 蟺伪蟿蟻喂蠅蟿喂蟽碌蠈, 碌蔚 碌喂伪 畏蟻蠅委未伪, 蟿畏蟼 慰蟺慰委伪蟼 慰 喂未蔚伪位喂蟽碌蠈蟼 魏伪喂 蟿慰 胃维蟻蟻慰蟼 胃伪 魏伪胃慰蟻委蟽慰蠀谓 碌喂伪 慰位蠈魏位畏蟻畏 蔚蟺慰蠂萎.
芦螚 围维谓伪 蟽蟿伪 魏伪位蠉蟿蔚蟻维 蟿畏蟼禄.
(The New York Times)
芦螆谓伪 蟽蠀纬魏喂谓畏蟿喂魏蠈, 蟽蠀谓伪蟻蟺伪蟽蟿喂魏蠈 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏渭伪禄.
(Booklist)
芦螚 围维谓伪 伪蠁畏纬蔚委蟿伪喂 蟿畏谓 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 伪位畏胃喂谓蠋谓, 伪蠁伪谓蠋谓 畏蟻蠅委未蠅谓禄.
(Washington Post)
芦螌蟽慰喂 伪纬伪蟺慰蠉谓 蟿伪 喂蟽蟿慰蟻喂魏维 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿慰蟻萎渭伪蟿伪 渭蔚 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蟺蟻蠅蟿伪纬蠅谓委蟽蟿蟻喂蔚蟼 胃伪 伪蟺慰位伪蠉蟽慰蠀谓 伪蠀蟿萎 蟿畏 蟽蠀谓伪蟻蟺伪蟽蟿喂魏萎 蟺慰位蔚渭喂魏萎 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪禄.
(Publishers Weekly)
芦螚 围维谓伪 纬喂伪 维位位畏 渭委伪 蠁慰蟻维 蠁苇蟻谓蔚喂 蟽蟿慰 蟺蟻慰蟽魏萎谓喂慰 蟿喂蟼 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蟺慰蠀 畏 螜蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 伪纬谓蠈畏蟽蔚禄.
(People Magazine)
芦螤慰蟿苇 蟽蟿慰 蟺伪蟻蔚位胃蠈谓 苇谓伪 蟺慰位蔚渭喂魏蠈 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏渭伪 未蔚谓 苇蠂蔚喂 渭蔚蟿伪渭慰蟻蠁蠅胃蔚委 蟿蠈蟽慰 蟻喂味喂魏维 蟽蔚 渭喂伪 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 纬喂伪 蟿畏谓 伪谓胃蟻蠋蟺喂谓畏 魏伪蟻未喂维禄.
(Delia Owens, 蟽蠀纬纬蟻伪蠁苇伪蟼 蟿慰蠀 螘魏蔚委 蟺慰蠀 蟿蟻伪纬慰蠀未维谓蔚 慰喂 魏伪蟻伪尾委未蔚蟼)
螌碌蠅蟼 慰 蟺蠈位蔚碌慰蟼 蔚委谓伪喂 碌蠈谓慰 畏 伪蟻蠂萎 纬喂伪 蟿畏 桅蟻维谓魏喂 魏伪喂 蟿慰蠀蟼 尾蔚蟿蔚蟻维谓慰蠀蟼 蠁委位慰蠀蟼 蟿畏蟼. 螚 伪位畏胃喂谓萎 碌维蠂畏 蟿慰蠉蟼 蟺蔚蟻喂碌苇谓蔚喂 蟽蟿畏谓 蟺伪蟿蟻委未伪, 蟽蔚 碌喂伪 螒碌蔚蟻喂魏萎 伪位位伪纬碌苇谓畏 魏伪喂 未喂蠂伪蟽碌苇谓畏, 蟺慰蠀 胃苇位蔚喂 谓伪 尉蔚蠂维蟽蔚喂.
螣喂 螕蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蔚委谓伪喂 畏 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 碌喂伪蟼 纬蠀谓伪委魏伪蟼 蟺慰蠀 蟺萎纬蔚 蟽蟿慰谓 蟺蠈位蔚碌慰, 伪位位维 蠁蠅蟿委味蔚喂 魏伪喂 蟿喂蟼 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委蔚蟼 蠈位蠅谓 蟿蠅谓 纬蠀谓伪喂魏蠋谓 蟺慰蠀 伪蟺慰蠁伪蟽委味慰蠀谓 谓伪 蟻喂蠂蟿慰蠉谓 蟽蟿畏 碌维蠂畏 魏伪喂 蟿蠅谓 慰蟺慰委蠅谓 慰喂 胃蠀蟽委蔚蟼 魏伪喂 畏 伪蠁慰蟽委蠅蟽畏 蟽蟿畏谓 蟺伪蟿蟻委未伪 蟺慰位蠉 蟽蠀蠂谓维 位畏蟽碌慰谓慰蠉谓蟿伪喂.
螆谓伪 碌蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏碌伪 纬喂伪 蟿喂蟼 尾伪胃喂苇蟼 蠁喂位委蔚蟼 魏伪喂 蟿慰谓 蟿慰位碌畏蟻蠈 蟺伪蟿蟻喂蠅蟿喂蟽碌蠈, 碌蔚 碌喂伪 畏蟻蠅委未伪, 蟿畏蟼 慰蟺慰委伪蟼 慰 喂未蔚伪位喂蟽碌蠈蟼 魏伪喂 蟿慰 胃维蟻蟻慰蟼 胃伪 魏伪胃慰蟻委蟽慰蠀谓 碌喂伪 慰位蠈魏位畏蟻畏 蔚蟺慰蠂萎.
芦螚 围维谓伪 蟽蟿伪 魏伪位蠉蟿蔚蟻维 蟿畏蟼禄.
(The New York Times)
芦螆谓伪 蟽蠀纬魏喂谓畏蟿喂魏蠈, 蟽蠀谓伪蟻蟺伪蟽蟿喂魏蠈 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏渭伪禄.
(Booklist)
芦螚 围维谓伪 伪蠁畏纬蔚委蟿伪喂 蟿畏谓 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 伪位畏胃喂谓蠋谓, 伪蠁伪谓蠋谓 畏蟻蠅委未蠅谓禄.
(Washington Post)
芦螌蟽慰喂 伪纬伪蟺慰蠉谓 蟿伪 喂蟽蟿慰蟻喂魏维 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿慰蟻萎渭伪蟿伪 渭蔚 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蟺蟻蠅蟿伪纬蠅谓委蟽蟿蟻喂蔚蟼 胃伪 伪蟺慰位伪蠉蟽慰蠀谓 伪蠀蟿萎 蟿畏 蟽蠀谓伪蟻蟺伪蟽蟿喂魏萎 蟺慰位蔚渭喂魏萎 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪禄.
(Publishers Weekly)
芦螚 围维谓伪 纬喂伪 维位位畏 渭委伪 蠁慰蟻维 蠁苇蟻谓蔚喂 蟽蟿慰 蟺蟻慰蟽魏萎谓喂慰 蟿喂蟼 纬蠀谓伪委魏蔚蟼 蟺慰蠀 畏 螜蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 伪纬谓蠈畏蟽蔚禄.
(People Magazine)
芦螤慰蟿苇 蟽蟿慰 蟺伪蟻蔚位胃蠈谓 苇谓伪 蟺慰位蔚渭喂魏蠈 渭蠀胃喂蟽蟿蠈蟻畏渭伪 未蔚谓 苇蠂蔚喂 渭蔚蟿伪渭慰蟻蠁蠅胃蔚委 蟿蠈蟽慰 蟻喂味喂魏维 蟽蔚 渭喂伪 喂蟽蟿慰蟻委伪 纬喂伪 蟿畏谓 伪谓胃蟻蠋蟺喂谓畏 魏伪蟻未喂维禄.
(Delia Owens, 蟽蠀纬纬蟻伪蠁苇伪蟼 蟿慰蠀 螘魏蔚委 蟺慰蠀 蟿蟻伪纬慰蠀未维谓蔚 慰喂 魏伪蟻伪尾委未蔚蟼)
608 pages, Paperback
First published February 6, 2024
78.2k people are currently reading
847k people want to read
About the author
Kristin Hannah
139听books271k听followersKristin Hannah is the award-winning and bestselling author of more than 20 novels including the international blockbuster, The Nightingale, which was named 欧宝娱乐 Best Historical fiction novel for 2015 and won the coveted People's Choice award for best fiction in the same year. It was named a Best Book of the Year by Amazon, iTunes, Buzzfeed, the Wall Street Journal, Paste, and The Week. In 2018,
The Great Alone became an instant New York Times #1 bestseller and was named the Best Historical Novel of the Year by 欧宝娱乐.
The Four Winds was published in February of 2021 and immediately hit #1 on the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, USA Today, and Indie bookstore's bestseller lists. Additionally, it was selected as a book club pick by the both Today Show and The Book Of the Month club, which named it the best book of 2021.
Firefly Lane, her beloved novel about two best friends, was the #1 Netflix series around the world, in the week it came out. The popular tv show stars Katherine Heigl and Sarah Chalke and Season Two is currently set to conclude the series on April 27, 2023.
Her new novel, The Women, about a young woman coming of age during the turbulent 1960's in America, who joins the Army Nurse Corps and serves in Vietnam will be published February 6th, 2024.
A former attorney, Kristin lives in the Pacific Northwest.
The Great Alone became an instant New York Times #1 bestseller and was named the Best Historical Novel of the Year by 欧宝娱乐.
The Four Winds was published in February of 2021 and immediately hit #1 on the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, USA Today, and Indie bookstore's bestseller lists. Additionally, it was selected as a book club pick by the both Today Show and The Book Of the Month club, which named it the best book of 2021.
Firefly Lane, her beloved novel about two best friends, was the #1 Netflix series around the world, in the week it came out. The popular tv show stars Katherine Heigl and Sarah Chalke and Season Two is currently set to conclude the series on April 27, 2023.
Her new novel, The Women, about a young woman coming of age during the turbulent 1960's in America, who joins the Army Nurse Corps and serves in Vietnam will be published February 6th, 2024.
A former attorney, Kristin lives in the Pacific Northwest.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129,211 reviews
May 14, 2025
Don鈥檛 believe the lie if somebody insists that there were no women in Vietnam. They were there! They served their country, struggling with tragedies, PTSD, and casualties as well. But there was one crucial difference for them: they were never considered war heroes. Nobody applauded them for the sacrifices they made or awarded them medals. They didn't receive praise for their service, and when they attempted to speak about the psychologically consuming experiences they went through, they were silenced, as they weren't even recognized as veterans. This work is dedicated to the women who served their country both militarily and as civilian women stationed in Vietnam 鈥� heroines who need to be remembered, praised, and admired.
This time, Kristin Hannah takes us back to the mid-sixties, shortly after JFK was shot in Texas. The country's primary focus is battling communism, and in pursuit of this mission, numerous troops comprising young Americans are sent to Vietnam.
I highly recommend keeping some napkins, handkerchiefs, or tissues close by, as you'll need them during your reading experience. Another word of caution: don't plan anything extensive for your day, because once you start reading this book and tell yourself you'll only read a few pages before setting it down, that plan might not hold. From the moment you dive into Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath鈥檚 story, you'll become engrossed. It's almost as if you're under a spell 鈥� you won't be able to put it down. Her story will grip you, tearing at your heartstrings and evoking numerous tears, as you connect with her fears, heartbreaks, pains, anger, and frustrations. You can practically hear her internal screams and the words she's forced to bottle up because nobody wants to listen. She might be the most honest, poignant, tough, and resilient heroine the author has ever created. So, my advice is to clear your schedule, go with the flow, and allow the story to transport you to the jungles of Vietnam, where the echoing sound of helipads reverberates in your ears, and you find yourself in a hospital surrounded by young soldiers uttering their final messages to their loved ones.
The book commences at a house party on Coronado Island, celebrating Frankie鈥檚 brother's enlistment. Frankie decides to take a break in her father's study, where a "hero鈥檚 walk" is displayed, featuring photos of the family's men who served in various wars. Now, her brother will be added to this wall. But why can't she be included too? It's in this moment that she realizes her brother's best friend, Rye, is also hiding in the room, questioning her: why can't a woman be a hero as well? This question alters everything for Frankie and challenges the life plans her family has set out for her. They expect her to marry and have children, conforming to the norms of the early sixties. However, she decides that she, too, can be a hero, serving her country and making her family proud, just like her brother did. She applies to the Army Nurse Corps to follow in her brother's footsteps.
Her conservative and highly respected family doesn't support her decision, and when a tragic piece of news arrives unexpectedly, Frankie's life takes a sharp turn before she embarks on her earth-shattering journey.
Soon, she finds herself amidst chaos and destruction, realizing that as a young, innocent, and inexperienced woman, she's like a fish in a bottle tossed into a dangerous ocean teeming with sharks. Within a short span of time, she becomes terrified, numb, and exhausted, navigating days where her heart breaks as she witnesses soldiers younger than her brother losing their lives and civilians becoming expendable amidst the chaos. As Frankie edges closer to collapse, nearly drowning in sorrow, her friends Barb and Ethel extend a lifeline, offering enough emotional support to keep her from giving up.
The book takes us on a 20-year journey with Frankie, spanning two terms of her life as she struggles to save herself. She risks her life in the process, and upon her return, she realizes that she's not regarded as a war hero like the men who fought in combat. People avoid discussing the war, and even her own family treats her as though she's done something to embarrass them, something they'd rather not acknowledge. During the day, she's compelled to blend into the community, resuming where she left off before the war, while at night, she battles her nightmares and the clutches of PTSD. She comes to understand that she's not the proud, ideal girl her family wanted her to be and never can be. Eventually, she gives in.
Frankie's painful journey, marked by her substantial losses, her battles with addiction, and her anger toward those who betrayed and disrespected her, is portrayed with remarkable realism. You can feel her emotions; they're everywhere. You ache, you cry, you feel resentment, and you sigh. You experience every pain she carries as if it's a blow to your own face.
She's one of the women from the war whose stories need to be told, remembered, cherished, and respected. Will she overcome her inner demons? Will she learn to heal from her pain, forgive those who worsened her suffering, embrace her flaws, and confront her fears that she's afraid to share with others? Will she ultimately find the peace she's searching for? Read her story to uncover the answers.
I'm still recovering from the impact of this book. My heart is a whirlwind of different emotions. While some characters may seem fictional initially, as you delve into their stories, you'll develop an immediate connection that makes these characters a part of you, lingering in your life indefinitely. Frankie is one such character 鈥� unforgettable, courageous, vulnerable, tarnished but not broken, poignant, and dependable.
I believe this might be my favorite work by Kristin Hannah. After reading her closing note, I gained a deeper appreciation for the years of hard work she put into creating these vivid characters and crafting realistic descriptions of war zones, leading us on this unforgettable journey. This book will likely be one of the standout reads of 2024, and I consider myself fortunate to have had the opportunity to read it.
Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin鈥檚 Press for providing me with a digital review copy of this amazing book in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
This time, Kristin Hannah takes us back to the mid-sixties, shortly after JFK was shot in Texas. The country's primary focus is battling communism, and in pursuit of this mission, numerous troops comprising young Americans are sent to Vietnam.
I highly recommend keeping some napkins, handkerchiefs, or tissues close by, as you'll need them during your reading experience. Another word of caution: don't plan anything extensive for your day, because once you start reading this book and tell yourself you'll only read a few pages before setting it down, that plan might not hold. From the moment you dive into Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath鈥檚 story, you'll become engrossed. It's almost as if you're under a spell 鈥� you won't be able to put it down. Her story will grip you, tearing at your heartstrings and evoking numerous tears, as you connect with her fears, heartbreaks, pains, anger, and frustrations. You can practically hear her internal screams and the words she's forced to bottle up because nobody wants to listen. She might be the most honest, poignant, tough, and resilient heroine the author has ever created. So, my advice is to clear your schedule, go with the flow, and allow the story to transport you to the jungles of Vietnam, where the echoing sound of helipads reverberates in your ears, and you find yourself in a hospital surrounded by young soldiers uttering their final messages to their loved ones.
The book commences at a house party on Coronado Island, celebrating Frankie鈥檚 brother's enlistment. Frankie decides to take a break in her father's study, where a "hero鈥檚 walk" is displayed, featuring photos of the family's men who served in various wars. Now, her brother will be added to this wall. But why can't she be included too? It's in this moment that she realizes her brother's best friend, Rye, is also hiding in the room, questioning her: why can't a woman be a hero as well? This question alters everything for Frankie and challenges the life plans her family has set out for her. They expect her to marry and have children, conforming to the norms of the early sixties. However, she decides that she, too, can be a hero, serving her country and making her family proud, just like her brother did. She applies to the Army Nurse Corps to follow in her brother's footsteps.
Her conservative and highly respected family doesn't support her decision, and when a tragic piece of news arrives unexpectedly, Frankie's life takes a sharp turn before she embarks on her earth-shattering journey.
Soon, she finds herself amidst chaos and destruction, realizing that as a young, innocent, and inexperienced woman, she's like a fish in a bottle tossed into a dangerous ocean teeming with sharks. Within a short span of time, she becomes terrified, numb, and exhausted, navigating days where her heart breaks as she witnesses soldiers younger than her brother losing their lives and civilians becoming expendable amidst the chaos. As Frankie edges closer to collapse, nearly drowning in sorrow, her friends Barb and Ethel extend a lifeline, offering enough emotional support to keep her from giving up.
The book takes us on a 20-year journey with Frankie, spanning two terms of her life as she struggles to save herself. She risks her life in the process, and upon her return, she realizes that she's not regarded as a war hero like the men who fought in combat. People avoid discussing the war, and even her own family treats her as though she's done something to embarrass them, something they'd rather not acknowledge. During the day, she's compelled to blend into the community, resuming where she left off before the war, while at night, she battles her nightmares and the clutches of PTSD. She comes to understand that she's not the proud, ideal girl her family wanted her to be and never can be. Eventually, she gives in.
Frankie's painful journey, marked by her substantial losses, her battles with addiction, and her anger toward those who betrayed and disrespected her, is portrayed with remarkable realism. You can feel her emotions; they're everywhere. You ache, you cry, you feel resentment, and you sigh. You experience every pain she carries as if it's a blow to your own face.
She's one of the women from the war whose stories need to be told, remembered, cherished, and respected. Will she overcome her inner demons? Will she learn to heal from her pain, forgive those who worsened her suffering, embrace her flaws, and confront her fears that she's afraid to share with others? Will she ultimately find the peace she's searching for? Read her story to uncover the answers.
I'm still recovering from the impact of this book. My heart is a whirlwind of different emotions. While some characters may seem fictional initially, as you delve into their stories, you'll develop an immediate connection that makes these characters a part of you, lingering in your life indefinitely. Frankie is one such character 鈥� unforgettable, courageous, vulnerable, tarnished but not broken, poignant, and dependable.
I believe this might be my favorite work by Kristin Hannah. After reading her closing note, I gained a deeper appreciation for the years of hard work she put into creating these vivid characters and crafting realistic descriptions of war zones, leading us on this unforgettable journey. This book will likely be one of the standout reads of 2024, and I consider myself fortunate to have had the opportunity to read it.
Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin鈥檚 Press for providing me with a digital review copy of this amazing book in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
April 8, 2024
Well, I am going to be That Person. That Person who does not rate the book everyone is raving about 5 stars. I just can鈥檛. And here鈥檚 why鈥�
First of all, I do want to say that I very much appreciate that Kristin Hannah chose to write a novel about something other than World War 2. It was refreshing to read about the Vietnam War, a war about which very few novels have been written. Furthermore, I appreciate that she focused on the women. Women鈥檚 contributions and experiences in history are often overlooked and probably more so in regards to the Vietnam War. I, for one, honestly never thought about it.
Secondly, Hannah does capture the setting very vividly. There are a lot of gory war scenes, you can feel the heat of the jungle, the stress, the exhaustion, etc. Similarly, she captured the experience of PTSD well (as far as I know, not having experienced it myself). I think it鈥檚 important to have this experience vividly exposed both for the sake of empathy as well as for those who have gone through it to feel heard and seen. She clearly did a ton of research on PTSD as well as on the war and the time period.
So why not the raving 5 stars? Quite simply, because Kristin Hannah likes to jerk people around emotionally and because the romance in this is obnoxiously awful.
First things first - and I don鈥檛 have anything else to say about this - I despise the title. Moving on鈥�
**A few spoilers ahead.**
Emotionally, this book is seriously 鈥渆verything but the kitchen sink鈥�. Just throw in every tragic thing you can think of, it鈥檚 there. Just when you think something good might happen, nope. The tragedy gets almost repetitive and boring. Like, how many times do I want to read about wanting her father鈥檚 approval or about how cold her mother is? How many times do I want to read about her bloody clothes and the mud and men鈥檚 gaping wounds? How many times do I want to read about her drunken pill popping 脿 la Valley of the Dolls? In a few cases, tragedy conveniently disposed of some plot points and characters which I found annoying. For instance, rather than Frankie having an honest conversation with another character, something traumatic occurs so she doesn鈥檛 have to. Do I get that the war trauma (both during and at home)was unending? Absolutely. That鈥檚 not really my issue. Kristin Hannah likes to pile on the tragedy and trauma in many of her books; it鈥檚 her formula and it gets tiresome after awhile.
And the romance. Ugh, don鈥檛 get me started. I predicted basically what would happen every single time a love interest was introduced and I was right. She falls in love suddenly with no real reason other than feelings like 鈥渉e brought her back to life鈥�. Gag me. That鈥檚 not real, especially not after a 5 minute conversation. Why do any of these men deserve to be adored? I can鈥檛 see it. None of them were particularly stellar specimens. You can tell me these relationships were realistic all you want but I鈥檓 not obligated to like these guys or just gloss over the repeated adultery (that continues after the war). Hannah鈥檚 presentation of the romances is sentimental, cheesy and predictable. She does this in her books a lot. And I鈥檓 sorry but nothing will compel me to be ok with not one but two men coming back from the dead.
This is a highly readable book and you鈥檒l be turning the pages fast. I hope that we continue to hear more about underappreciated women in history (and this book did make me want to know more). However, I would have preferred less piled on tragedy and fewer contrived, sentimental plotlines.
Pub date: Feb 6, 2024
First of all, I do want to say that I very much appreciate that Kristin Hannah chose to write a novel about something other than World War 2. It was refreshing to read about the Vietnam War, a war about which very few novels have been written. Furthermore, I appreciate that she focused on the women. Women鈥檚 contributions and experiences in history are often overlooked and probably more so in regards to the Vietnam War. I, for one, honestly never thought about it.
Secondly, Hannah does capture the setting very vividly. There are a lot of gory war scenes, you can feel the heat of the jungle, the stress, the exhaustion, etc. Similarly, she captured the experience of PTSD well (as far as I know, not having experienced it myself). I think it鈥檚 important to have this experience vividly exposed both for the sake of empathy as well as for those who have gone through it to feel heard and seen. She clearly did a ton of research on PTSD as well as on the war and the time period.
So why not the raving 5 stars? Quite simply, because Kristin Hannah likes to jerk people around emotionally and because the romance in this is obnoxiously awful.
First things first - and I don鈥檛 have anything else to say about this - I despise the title. Moving on鈥�
**A few spoilers ahead.**
Emotionally, this book is seriously 鈥渆verything but the kitchen sink鈥�. Just throw in every tragic thing you can think of, it鈥檚 there. Just when you think something good might happen, nope. The tragedy gets almost repetitive and boring. Like, how many times do I want to read about wanting her father鈥檚 approval or about how cold her mother is? How many times do I want to read about her bloody clothes and the mud and men鈥檚 gaping wounds? How many times do I want to read about her drunken pill popping 脿 la Valley of the Dolls? In a few cases, tragedy conveniently disposed of some plot points and characters which I found annoying. For instance, rather than Frankie having an honest conversation with another character, something traumatic occurs so she doesn鈥檛 have to. Do I get that the war trauma (both during and at home)was unending? Absolutely. That鈥檚 not really my issue. Kristin Hannah likes to pile on the tragedy and trauma in many of her books; it鈥檚 her formula and it gets tiresome after awhile.
And the romance. Ugh, don鈥檛 get me started. I predicted basically what would happen every single time a love interest was introduced and I was right. She falls in love suddenly with no real reason other than feelings like 鈥渉e brought her back to life鈥�. Gag me. That鈥檚 not real, especially not after a 5 minute conversation. Why do any of these men deserve to be adored? I can鈥檛 see it. None of them were particularly stellar specimens. You can tell me these relationships were realistic all you want but I鈥檓 not obligated to like these guys or just gloss over the repeated adultery (that continues after the war). Hannah鈥檚 presentation of the romances is sentimental, cheesy and predictable. She does this in her books a lot. And I鈥檓 sorry but nothing will compel me to be ok with not one but two men coming back from the dead.
This is a highly readable book and you鈥檒l be turning the pages fast. I hope that we continue to hear more about underappreciated women in history (and this book did make me want to know more). However, I would have preferred less piled on tragedy and fewer contrived, sentimental plotlines.
Pub date: Feb 6, 2024
September 2, 2023
easiest 5 stars ever!!! it will be nearly IMPOSSIBLE for readers to not love this book. Kristin Hannah is BACK and she has done it again 馃憦馃徏馃檹馃徏馃槶鉂わ笍
and to answer everyone鈥檚 question to me so far鈥� THE NIGHTINGALE is my fave book of all time and therefore my favorite KH book. but鈥� THE WOMEN is right beside it 鉂わ笍馃檶馃徏
a full review is over on my IG, but my quick thoughts:
馃挃 heartbreaking subject matter. very specific and real stories about The Vietnam War and also life post-war and what that was like for the Vets that returned home
馃摉 the pacing is on fire. the first half of the book has you flipping pages so fast鈥攖he action is page after page after page. it鈥檚 450+ pages but moved QUICK鈥攊 finished in 24 hours and could have binged it in one sitting if i had the time
馃摉 Frankie is one of my fave MCs ever. she鈥檚 badass and flawed and tough and inspiring and emotional and an absolutely beautiful woman. she does some bad things but again, she is human and flawed and she is suffering
馃摉 the female friendships and themes in this book will make your heart so happy
馃摉 the research KH must have done for this book is INSANE. like so many other hisfic novels, it鈥檚 incredibly eye opening and educational. it shows you sides of the Vietnam War you probably have never seen or heard of before, and also brings things you have heard of to light in a very real way
馃摉 the ending will ruin you in the best way. the tears were definitely flowing but i wouldn鈥檛 have changed a single thing 馃槶鉂わ笍鉂わ笍鉂わ笍馃憦馃徏 i cried the entire last 10 pages. each paragraph hit me harder than the one previously 馃ス馃槀馃槶
馃摉 the love stories are very prevalent but try not to get caught up in them鈥攊t鈥檚 so much more than a woman and her love interests
in her author鈥檚 note she mentions how long she鈥檚 wanted to write this book but how she wanted to build the courage and strength to do the story justice and boy oh boy did she ever. as someone (like so many others) with a very close family member who fought in Vietnam鈥� this really hits close to home. so much of what is explained and illustrated in this book is what really happened in Vietnam and how some of the veterans really felt and it鈥檚 heartbreaking and an important story to be told. it makes me want to be able to call my relatives and talk about what they went through and relive those stories again with them, but they are now at peace 馃檹馃徏馃挃
THANK YOU to my friends at St Martins Press for gifting me this early. all opinions and thoughts as always are my own.
i know we don鈥檛 want to wait until Feb 2024 to have this out in the world (i want to talk to everyone about it right now鈥�), but i promise it will be WELL worth the wait.
thank you, Kristin, for telling this story of The Women during the Vietnam War 鉂わ笍
*EDIT: adding in my fave quotes from the book! 馃毃 potential spoilers ahead 馃毃
鉂わ笍鉂わ笍鉂わ笍
鈥淲omen can be heroes.鈥�
鈥淣o fear, McGrath. You can do this.鈥�
鈥淢aybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. Happy forever seems like a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鈥�
鈥淭here are no women in Vietnam, dear.鈥�
鈥淪he needed to do as everyone suggested and forget.鈥�
鈥淪he was never exactly sure what she was ashamed of, jsut that she was weak, or had somehow done something bad, been a part of something bad, something no one wanted to talk about.鈥�
鈥淲e don鈥檛 really talk about it.鈥�
鈥淭he war no one wants to remember.鈥�
鈥淭hank you for finally remembering us.鈥�
鈥淵ou and me, McGrath. Finally.鈥�
and to answer everyone鈥檚 question to me so far鈥� THE NIGHTINGALE is my fave book of all time and therefore my favorite KH book. but鈥� THE WOMEN is right beside it 鉂わ笍馃檶馃徏
a full review is over on my IG, but my quick thoughts:
馃挃 heartbreaking subject matter. very specific and real stories about The Vietnam War and also life post-war and what that was like for the Vets that returned home
馃摉 the pacing is on fire. the first half of the book has you flipping pages so fast鈥攖he action is page after page after page. it鈥檚 450+ pages but moved QUICK鈥攊 finished in 24 hours and could have binged it in one sitting if i had the time
馃摉 Frankie is one of my fave MCs ever. she鈥檚 badass and flawed and tough and inspiring and emotional and an absolutely beautiful woman. she does some bad things but again, she is human and flawed and she is suffering
馃摉 the female friendships and themes in this book will make your heart so happy
馃摉 the research KH must have done for this book is INSANE. like so many other hisfic novels, it鈥檚 incredibly eye opening and educational. it shows you sides of the Vietnam War you probably have never seen or heard of before, and also brings things you have heard of to light in a very real way
馃摉 the ending will ruin you in the best way. the tears were definitely flowing but i wouldn鈥檛 have changed a single thing 馃槶鉂わ笍鉂わ笍鉂わ笍馃憦馃徏 i cried the entire last 10 pages. each paragraph hit me harder than the one previously 馃ス馃槀馃槶
馃摉 the love stories are very prevalent but try not to get caught up in them鈥攊t鈥檚 so much more than a woman and her love interests
in her author鈥檚 note she mentions how long she鈥檚 wanted to write this book but how she wanted to build the courage and strength to do the story justice and boy oh boy did she ever. as someone (like so many others) with a very close family member who fought in Vietnam鈥� this really hits close to home. so much of what is explained and illustrated in this book is what really happened in Vietnam and how some of the veterans really felt and it鈥檚 heartbreaking and an important story to be told. it makes me want to be able to call my relatives and talk about what they went through and relive those stories again with them, but they are now at peace 馃檹馃徏馃挃
THANK YOU to my friends at St Martins Press for gifting me this early. all opinions and thoughts as always are my own.
i know we don鈥檛 want to wait until Feb 2024 to have this out in the world (i want to talk to everyone about it right now鈥�), but i promise it will be WELL worth the wait.
thank you, Kristin, for telling this story of The Women during the Vietnam War 鉂わ笍
*EDIT: adding in my fave quotes from the book! 馃毃 potential spoilers ahead 馃毃
鉂わ笍鉂わ笍鉂わ笍
鈥淲omen can be heroes.鈥�
鈥淣o fear, McGrath. You can do this.鈥�
鈥淢aybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. Happy forever seems like a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鈥�
鈥淭here are no women in Vietnam, dear.鈥�
鈥淪he needed to do as everyone suggested and forget.鈥�
鈥淪he was never exactly sure what she was ashamed of, jsut that she was weak, or had somehow done something bad, been a part of something bad, something no one wanted to talk about.鈥�
鈥淲e don鈥檛 really talk about it.鈥�
鈥淭he war no one wants to remember.鈥�
鈥淭hank you for finally remembering us.鈥�
鈥淵ou and me, McGrath. Finally.鈥�
February 12, 2024
Women can be heroes.
4 1/2 stars. certainly knows how to take a sledgehammer to your heart and she is NOT afraid to do it.
Hannah's reads are so powerful and harrowing that I can forgive a few negatives, like here I think the major plot points of the story are quite predictable-- yet they still hit me like a ton of bricks, their impact not lessened by the fact I'd seen them coming. Maybe this one was easier to predict as I'm getting used to the author's formula. Her novels take us to vastly different times and places but she uses similar tricks to engage the reader. I鈥檓 not complaining: it works.
This book is an epic on women in the Vietnam War. Hannah introduces us to bright-eyed and naive nurse Frances "Frankie" McGrath, who longs for a place on her father's "Hero's Wall" and so volunteers for service in Vietnam.
It is an understatement to say she didn't know what she was getting into. Frankie finds herself in hell on Earth, struggling to help put together men who have been blown apart, watching Vietnamese children die from napalm burns, losing friends for a cause none of them even understand. Those sensitive to graphic depictions of injuries should steer clear-- as a nurse in Vietnam, Frankie witnesses some of the most horrific things in our world.
"We've developed the skills to save their bodies, but not their lives," Captain Smith said.
But this is not just a story about the war itself. It is a story of a young woman's growth, aging impossibly in a short amount of time. Her friends, Barb and Ethel, keep her spirits up at the worst times, and the funny dialogue between them is a major highlight of the novel. She falls in love and this, too, gives her hope for the future.
How could she go from red alert sirens and saving lives to butter knives and champagne?
Only half of this story is set in Vietnam; the other half is about coming home and living afterwards. It's not easy to say which one is more difficult. There was no hero's welcome for those returning from Vietnam. Veterans were cursed at and spat on. Many were left with irreparable damage from their time in the war. For some, it was the loss of a limb. For many, it was the loss of something harder to explain. While psychiatric help began to be offered, it was typically for male veterans.
As with several of Hannah's other books, she once again shines a light on the women who have been erased from history. The female veterans she spoke with for this book told her how they often heard "There were no women in Vietnam." I cannot imagine how it must feel to risk your life, sacrifice your youth and peace of mind, and be told that it didn't even happen.
Another horrible, ugly, powerful book from one of my must-read authors.
As well as graphic injuries, this may not be suitable to those sensitive to depictions of substance abuse and .
August 17, 2024
Hot Take: This book would never end
The Women details Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath鈥檚 experience serving in the Vietnam War as a nurse. And her transition into civilian life.
This book had no plot鈥攊t is based on one character. The problem is鈥�.Frankie isn鈥檛 likeable. She is an entitled, spoiled rich girl. She has everything handed to her, and her reason for going to war was to be on the hero鈥檚 wall and not wanting to work her way up at the hospital. Although she constantly pulls on her veteran roommates, she couldn鈥檛 be bothered to provide support to nurses that arrived after her. Apparently, she hasn鈥檛 heard of paying it forward.
Hannah also never gets into what makes Frankie so unique, what makes her special, what drives her. What about her would the world miss if she was gone?
My favorite author says it best: 鈥淓very sentence I write is surrounded by the ghosts of the sentences I could have written at that point but chose not to.鈥� In The Women, I wanted to hear about the other servicewomen. After Part 1, it was time to transition to someone else. How did Major Goldstein, the chief nurse, get to her position and how did she cope with placing the nurses, determining their fates? Why didn鈥檛 we shift to Ethel and Barb and what happened before Frankie?
Additionally, Hannah is far too verbose, leaving the reader to wade through needless paragraphs, inserting uninteresting details. Sorry, I just don鈥檛 care about the cheap motel especially at the end of the book. Not sorry.
The foreshadowing is so heavy that the book becomes predictable, and there are far too many characters鈥攁ll of them are undeveloped. The author did far too much telling instead of showing. Show us memories of Finley and Frances. Give us the backstory on Ethel and Barb. Don鈥檛 tell us. Show us.
Although I greatly enjoyed learning more about the brave women who valiantly served our country, this book was a chore to read.
*Thanks, NetGalley, for a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and unbiased opinion.
How much I spent:
Electronic text 鈥� Free/Nada/Zilch through NetGalley provided by publisher
2025 Reading Schedule
Jan A Town Like Alice
Feb Birdsong
Mar Captain Corelli's Mandolin - Louis De Berniere
Apr War and Peace
May The Woman in White
Jun Atonement
Jul The Shadow of the Wind
Aug Jude the Obscure
Sep Ulysses
Oct Vanity Fair
Nov A Fine Balance
Dec Germinal
Connect With Me!
The Women details Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath鈥檚 experience serving in the Vietnam War as a nurse. And her transition into civilian life.
This book had no plot鈥攊t is based on one character. The problem is鈥�.Frankie isn鈥檛 likeable. She is an entitled, spoiled rich girl. She has everything handed to her, and her reason for going to war was to be on the hero鈥檚 wall and not wanting to work her way up at the hospital. Although she constantly pulls on her veteran roommates, she couldn鈥檛 be bothered to provide support to nurses that arrived after her. Apparently, she hasn鈥檛 heard of paying it forward.
Hannah also never gets into what makes Frankie so unique, what makes her special, what drives her. What about her would the world miss if she was gone?
My favorite author says it best: 鈥淓very sentence I write is surrounded by the ghosts of the sentences I could have written at that point but chose not to.鈥� In The Women, I wanted to hear about the other servicewomen. After Part 1, it was time to transition to someone else. How did Major Goldstein, the chief nurse, get to her position and how did she cope with placing the nurses, determining their fates? Why didn鈥檛 we shift to Ethel and Barb and what happened before Frankie?
Additionally, Hannah is far too verbose, leaving the reader to wade through needless paragraphs, inserting uninteresting details. Sorry, I just don鈥檛 care about the cheap motel especially at the end of the book. Not sorry.
The foreshadowing is so heavy that the book becomes predictable, and there are far too many characters鈥攁ll of them are undeveloped. The author did far too much telling instead of showing. Show us memories of Finley and Frances. Give us the backstory on Ethel and Barb. Don鈥檛 tell us. Show us.
Although I greatly enjoyed learning more about the brave women who valiantly served our country, this book was a chore to read.
*Thanks, NetGalley, for a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and unbiased opinion.
How much I spent:
Electronic text 鈥� Free/Nada/Zilch through NetGalley provided by publisher
2025 Reading Schedule
Jan A Town Like Alice
Feb Birdsong
Mar Captain Corelli's Mandolin - Louis De Berniere
Apr War and Peace
May The Woman in White
Jun Atonement
Jul The Shadow of the Wind
Aug Jude the Obscure
Sep Ulysses
Oct Vanity Fair
Nov A Fine Balance
Dec Germinal
Connect With Me!
February 21, 2024
2 soap opera stars.
Too cutesy and romance focused.
No one is more surprised (and disappointed) than me to be giving a 2 star rating for this much loved and highly anticipated book. I started this novel thinking it would be an easy 5 star read. My rating quickly lowered to 3 stars by the halfway mark and then slowly dwindled down to 2 stars by the end.
This novel follows a young womans harrowing journey as a nurse in the Vietnam war.
The main character was likeable enough, but she lacked any sort of grit or believability for me. She felt very surface level and cutesy from start to finish, giving the overall tone a soap opera feel. Unfortunately I do not enjoy cute stories, especially when it comes to historical fiction. The lighter tone of this novel made it easy to fly through but neglected to leave any sort of lasting impression on me (other than disappointment).
When I read historical fiction, I want grit, heaviness, atmosphere, rip-my-heart-out emotions along with the factual detail. The only aspect I received from this novel was the educational component of learning about this time in history. It had some atmosphere , but my detachment from the characters had me distanced from the plot altogether. There was no grit or emotion to pull me in. There were a couple of heart wrenching moments, but they didn鈥檛 truly move or impact me in any way.
Romance is a heavy theme throughout this book. Unfortunately romance is a genre I do not enjoy reading. The main characters鈥� love interests had me confused and distanced from the storyline as none of it was even remotely believable. I think most of my lack of connection is that I wasn鈥檛 bought into any of the romance pieces and this is an integral part of what makes the storyline work.
I also found this book extremely predictable and very cheesy at times. My eyes rolled a lot in the second half. I predicted several large plot points in the second half which took away any sort of shock factor or enjoyment I may have received from those reveals. The author also included an extreme amount of hot topics, like she was trying to touch on too many things without truly fleshing her ideas out.
Overall, this was a complete miss for me. I am thankful to have read it solely for learning about this time period but I received zero enjoyment from an entertainment perspective. I have loved all of this authors previous historical fiction work, so if you are looking for a gritty, heavy, impactful historical fiction book, I encourage you to read those before picking this up. Please note, I am the outlier with my thoughts so make sure to read the countless raving reviews before deciding on this one.
Too cutesy and romance focused.
No one is more surprised (and disappointed) than me to be giving a 2 star rating for this much loved and highly anticipated book. I started this novel thinking it would be an easy 5 star read. My rating quickly lowered to 3 stars by the halfway mark and then slowly dwindled down to 2 stars by the end.
This novel follows a young womans harrowing journey as a nurse in the Vietnam war.
The main character was likeable enough, but she lacked any sort of grit or believability for me. She felt very surface level and cutesy from start to finish, giving the overall tone a soap opera feel. Unfortunately I do not enjoy cute stories, especially when it comes to historical fiction. The lighter tone of this novel made it easy to fly through but neglected to leave any sort of lasting impression on me (other than disappointment).
When I read historical fiction, I want grit, heaviness, atmosphere, rip-my-heart-out emotions along with the factual detail. The only aspect I received from this novel was the educational component of learning about this time in history. It had some atmosphere , but my detachment from the characters had me distanced from the plot altogether. There was no grit or emotion to pull me in. There were a couple of heart wrenching moments, but they didn鈥檛 truly move or impact me in any way.
Romance is a heavy theme throughout this book. Unfortunately romance is a genre I do not enjoy reading. The main characters鈥� love interests had me confused and distanced from the storyline as none of it was even remotely believable. I think most of my lack of connection is that I wasn鈥檛 bought into any of the romance pieces and this is an integral part of what makes the storyline work.
I also found this book extremely predictable and very cheesy at times. My eyes rolled a lot in the second half. I predicted several large plot points in the second half which took away any sort of shock factor or enjoyment I may have received from those reveals. The author also included an extreme amount of hot topics, like she was trying to touch on too many things without truly fleshing her ideas out.
Overall, this was a complete miss for me. I am thankful to have read it solely for learning about this time period but I received zero enjoyment from an entertainment perspective. I have loved all of this authors previous historical fiction work, so if you are looking for a gritty, heavy, impactful historical fiction book, I encourage you to read those before picking this up. Please note, I am the outlier with my thoughts so make sure to read the countless raving reviews before deciding on this one.
February 28, 2024
If Meredith Grey served in Vietnam and came home鈥his would be her story.
May 25, 2024
In a Nutshell: Expected far more from my very first Kristin Hannah book. 馃様 Loved the intent, liked the content, disliked the writing. This is, as is obvious, an outlier review.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
Bookish Yays:
馃槉 The intent deserves credit: to focus on the women veterans of the war, to depict what women can do, even if they aren鈥檛 allowed to.
馃槉 The war-related scenes are as gruesome as expected. Felt like I was right there in the war zone with Frankie.
馃槉 The focus on the importance of and the struggles faced by nurses and the secondary treatment they are given compared to doctors.
馃槉 The details about the mental struggles and health issues faced by returning veterans, which went much beyond typically shown in fiction.
Bookish Mixed Bags:
馃槓 Frankie starts as a great character. Even when she is a na茂ve fresher, she has the right approach towards her work. But as the book progresses, her decisions start turning more and more impulsive and short-sighted. I don鈥檛 mind books with unlikeable characters as they add a nuance of realism to the story, but in this case, Frankie鈥檚 behaviour, especially in the second half, was more frustrating than understandable.
馃槓 The Vietnam war is not called the 鈥楢merican War鈥� by Vietnam without a reason. I appreciate the author鈥檚 decision to highlight even the American atrocities and the lies spun by American politicians. Though these negatives are not covered in as much detail as I would have liked, they are still enough to shed light on the truth. However, the depiction of the American troops in Vietnam is white-saviour in approach for the most way, focussing more on the medical aid offered by the Americans to the locals than talking about why the locals needed the aid in the first place.
馃槓 Most war books stop at the end of the war without showing the aftermath. That is one aspect in which this novel excelled; it went much beyond the timeline of the war and shows the reception of the Americans to the returning veterans, and the protests. However, the depiction of these events seems a bit exaggerated. I am obviously not privy to what happened in 1970s America, but I find it hard to believe that not even one person knew about women serving in Vietnam, or that not a single person showed sympathy to Frankie鈥檚 mental situation. The author鈥檚 note mentions that women veterans often met with dismissal, but 鈥榦ften鈥� doesn鈥檛 equate to 鈥榓lways.鈥� The balance is missing.
馃槓 Frankie鈥檚 downward spiral in the second half is, in one way, a good creative call as it shows us the darker side of PTSD. However, the events get tedious and repetitive after a while. Plus, the hyper-drama level is way too high in this section.
馃槓 While there are some interesting secondary characters in the book, they barely get proper detailing. Most of what we know about their background is the little we get from passing references in conversations. Many characters disappear without a trace as soon as their purpose is served in the plot. The one I am most curious about is the senior nurse who greets Frankie on her arrival in Vietnam. What happened to her? There were at least three skilled nurses that we know of (Ethel, Barb, and the senior nurse), but we hardly get to see them in action. Why does Frankie have to be the one to save the day, every time? The character decisions also induce much eyerolling. Whenever there is a party, the nurses drop everything and rush off, without asking or informing anyone. How is that possible in the army?
馃槓 For the first time ever, I, a big fan of author鈥檚 notes, have mixed feelings about the note in this novel. I appreciate the clarity the author provides about her intention behind this book and her research sources. Two issues, though: 1. She has no first-hand experience of Vietnam (which is very evident in her writing about its weather), and 2. She said that she wanted to change the place names and war unit details for ease of writing, but changed her mind only after veterans told her not to. I find it very odd that an accomplished writer of historical fiction even considered falsifying factual details just to make her task easier.
Bookish Nays:
馃槪 The writing was the biggest disappointment. This book is much overwritten. At 470+ pages, I thought we would hear multiple women鈥檚 perspectives and experiences in the war. But unlike what the title suggests, 鈥淭he Women鈥� is mainly the story of only ONE WOMAN 鈥� Frankie. Moreover, there is too much of telling in the writing. Every single outfit worn by Frankie and the others is described in elaborate detail. Actions are narrated step by step. Every now and then, we see the time mentioned in army style 鈥� 鈥淎t 20:15鈥� 鈥� as if to remind us that Frankie is now a military member. The foreshadowing is too blatant. One phrase that comes up multiple times is 鈥淗ow long had it been since鈥︹€�. The worst of it is the character resurrections 鈥� yes, plural! The effect is repetitive and annoying.
馃槪 The romance is cheesy and unappealing. Every single guy who has a proper role in the story falls in love with Frankie. We are expected to believe that this is common during the war time because of the low number of American women around, but in that case, how come Ethel and Barb and the other nurses didn鈥檛 have anyone falling for them? As it is, I don鈥檛 like romance popping in non-romance books, but it is even worse when the writing is so corny and the situations so lopsided. The lack of appeal in the male characters doesn鈥檛 help.
馃槪 There is not a single Vietnamese character of importance in the whole book. Moreover, the representation of Vietnam is, as expected, focussed on the problems: rats, malaria, heat, lack of potable water,鈥� Though the Americans enjoy water-skiing and swimming and so on in the local lakes, the beauty of the location is rarely described. The funniest to me was the finger-pointing at Vietnam鈥檚 monsoon for causing Frankie鈥檚 travel bag to stay musty and stink even eight years later. Sorry! But if your travel bag is odoriferous, it鈥檚 probably because you haven鈥檛 washed it, ever! Don鈥檛 blame the monsoon!
馃帶 The Audiobook Experience:
The audiobook, clocking at almost 15 hours, is narrated by the inimitable Julia Whelan. Need I say anything more? Everyone who knows audiobooks knows that she is among the best narrators. If you still want to try this book, the audio version is definitely a fabulous way to check it out, especially considering its length.
All in all, I do appreciate the author鈥檚 efforts and the intention that made her write this book. I even liked certain aspects of the storyline, and loved learning about the nurses who gave so much to the fruitless war. But the writing and the plot development were not to my liking. The problems are exacerbated in the audio version as it feels like an endless journey through monotonous situations.
As is evident from the current rating on 欧宝娱乐, mine is very much an outlier opinion. Most other readers have not just loved the book but are positively gushing about it. So please go through their reviews before taking a final call. If you are the kind of reader who prioritises sentiments over plot and writing, you might love this novel way more than I did.
2.25 stars.
My thanks to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the ALC of 鈥淭he Women鈥�. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the audiobook.
Content warning: War-related brutalities and deaths, infidelity, miscarriage, drug abuse, alcohol abuse, PTSD, gender discrimination, racial discrimination.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
|| || || || ||
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
1966, Coronado Island. Twenty-year-old Frances McGrath, known to all as 鈥楩rankie鈥�, belongs to a wealthy family of navy veterans. At the send-off party for her elder brother who has enlisted for Vietnam, someone tells her, 鈥淲omen can be heroes, too.鈥� This sparks a desire in Frankie鈥檚 mind to serve her country through the armed forces, something she never considered before.
As the only corps willing to take a freshly-graduated nurse is the army, Frankie, against her family鈥檚 wishes, registers with the Army Nurse Corps and sets off to Vietnam. There, she sees the true picture of war, where every day is a fight for survival. But will this struggle end with the end of the war? With war protestors becoming stronger by the day, the Vietnam veterans might not be coming home to the open arms of their country. What lies ahead?
The story comes to us in Frankie鈥檚 third person perspective.
Bookish Yays:
馃槉 The intent deserves credit: to focus on the women veterans of the war, to depict what women can do, even if they aren鈥檛 allowed to.
馃槉 The war-related scenes are as gruesome as expected. Felt like I was right there in the war zone with Frankie.
馃槉 The focus on the importance of and the struggles faced by nurses and the secondary treatment they are given compared to doctors.
馃槉 The details about the mental struggles and health issues faced by returning veterans, which went much beyond typically shown in fiction.
Bookish Mixed Bags:
馃槓 Frankie starts as a great character. Even when she is a na茂ve fresher, she has the right approach towards her work. But as the book progresses, her decisions start turning more and more impulsive and short-sighted. I don鈥檛 mind books with unlikeable characters as they add a nuance of realism to the story, but in this case, Frankie鈥檚 behaviour, especially in the second half, was more frustrating than understandable.
馃槓 The Vietnam war is not called the 鈥楢merican War鈥� by Vietnam without a reason. I appreciate the author鈥檚 decision to highlight even the American atrocities and the lies spun by American politicians. Though these negatives are not covered in as much detail as I would have liked, they are still enough to shed light on the truth. However, the depiction of the American troops in Vietnam is white-saviour in approach for the most way, focussing more on the medical aid offered by the Americans to the locals than talking about why the locals needed the aid in the first place.
馃槓 Most war books stop at the end of the war without showing the aftermath. That is one aspect in which this novel excelled; it went much beyond the timeline of the war and shows the reception of the Americans to the returning veterans, and the protests. However, the depiction of these events seems a bit exaggerated. I am obviously not privy to what happened in 1970s America, but I find it hard to believe that not even one person knew about women serving in Vietnam, or that not a single person showed sympathy to Frankie鈥檚 mental situation. The author鈥檚 note mentions that women veterans often met with dismissal, but 鈥榦ften鈥� doesn鈥檛 equate to 鈥榓lways.鈥� The balance is missing.
馃槓 Frankie鈥檚 downward spiral in the second half is, in one way, a good creative call as it shows us the darker side of PTSD. However, the events get tedious and repetitive after a while. Plus, the hyper-drama level is way too high in this section.
馃槓 While there are some interesting secondary characters in the book, they barely get proper detailing. Most of what we know about their background is the little we get from passing references in conversations. Many characters disappear without a trace as soon as their purpose is served in the plot. The one I am most curious about is the senior nurse who greets Frankie on her arrival in Vietnam. What happened to her? There were at least three skilled nurses that we know of (Ethel, Barb, and the senior nurse), but we hardly get to see them in action. Why does Frankie have to be the one to save the day, every time? The character decisions also induce much eyerolling. Whenever there is a party, the nurses drop everything and rush off, without asking or informing anyone. How is that possible in the army?
馃槓 For the first time ever, I, a big fan of author鈥檚 notes, have mixed feelings about the note in this novel. I appreciate the clarity the author provides about her intention behind this book and her research sources. Two issues, though: 1. She has no first-hand experience of Vietnam (which is very evident in her writing about its weather), and 2. She said that she wanted to change the place names and war unit details for ease of writing, but changed her mind only after veterans told her not to. I find it very odd that an accomplished writer of historical fiction even considered falsifying factual details just to make her task easier.
Bookish Nays:
馃槪 The writing was the biggest disappointment. This book is much overwritten. At 470+ pages, I thought we would hear multiple women鈥檚 perspectives and experiences in the war. But unlike what the title suggests, 鈥淭he Women鈥� is mainly the story of only ONE WOMAN 鈥� Frankie. Moreover, there is too much of telling in the writing. Every single outfit worn by Frankie and the others is described in elaborate detail. Actions are narrated step by step. Every now and then, we see the time mentioned in army style 鈥� 鈥淎t 20:15鈥� 鈥� as if to remind us that Frankie is now a military member. The foreshadowing is too blatant. One phrase that comes up multiple times is 鈥淗ow long had it been since鈥︹€�. The worst of it is the character resurrections 鈥� yes, plural! The effect is repetitive and annoying.
馃槪 The romance is cheesy and unappealing. Every single guy who has a proper role in the story falls in love with Frankie. We are expected to believe that this is common during the war time because of the low number of American women around, but in that case, how come Ethel and Barb and the other nurses didn鈥檛 have anyone falling for them? As it is, I don鈥檛 like romance popping in non-romance books, but it is even worse when the writing is so corny and the situations so lopsided. The lack of appeal in the male characters doesn鈥檛 help.
馃槪 There is not a single Vietnamese character of importance in the whole book. Moreover, the representation of Vietnam is, as expected, focussed on the problems: rats, malaria, heat, lack of potable water,鈥� Though the Americans enjoy water-skiing and swimming and so on in the local lakes, the beauty of the location is rarely described. The funniest to me was the finger-pointing at Vietnam鈥檚 monsoon for causing Frankie鈥檚 travel bag to stay musty and stink even eight years later. Sorry! But if your travel bag is odoriferous, it鈥檚 probably because you haven鈥檛 washed it, ever! Don鈥檛 blame the monsoon!
馃帶 The Audiobook Experience:
The audiobook, clocking at almost 15 hours, is narrated by the inimitable Julia Whelan. Need I say anything more? Everyone who knows audiobooks knows that she is among the best narrators. If you still want to try this book, the audio version is definitely a fabulous way to check it out, especially considering its length.
All in all, I do appreciate the author鈥檚 efforts and the intention that made her write this book. I even liked certain aspects of the storyline, and loved learning about the nurses who gave so much to the fruitless war. But the writing and the plot development were not to my liking. The problems are exacerbated in the audio version as it feels like an endless journey through monotonous situations.
As is evident from the current rating on 欧宝娱乐, mine is very much an outlier opinion. Most other readers have not just loved the book but are positively gushing about it. So please go through their reviews before taking a final call. If you are the kind of reader who prioritises sentiments over plot and writing, you might love this novel way more than I did.
2.25 stars.
My thanks to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the ALC of 鈥淭he Women鈥�. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the audiobook.
Content warning: War-related brutalities and deaths, infidelity, miscarriage, drug abuse, alcohol abuse, PTSD, gender discrimination, racial discrimination.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
|| || || || ||
no
March 10, 2024I have a beautiful big paper arc written by a writer whom I've never read before, but I know she is a NYT bestselling author, and that her books are deeply loved.
I open the book.
The first sentence is: The walled and gated MacGrath estate was a world unto itself, protected and private.
And I think: Gosh, isn't this a slightly uninspired way to begin a book, I mean, couldn't she have tried a little harder than to call something "a world unto itself," which was probably a little on the clich茅d side even before the first time anyone wrote it down?
Ok, moving on, the next two sentences are: On this twilit evening, the Tudor-style home's mullioned windows glowed jewel-like amid the lush, landscaped grounds. Palm fronds swayed overhead... and okay okay that's enough, because my brain is saying: "On this twilit evening?" "windows glowed?"..."Palm fronds swayed?"
I'm just talking about my own experience, here.
Speaking solely from my own point of view, this writing makes me feel bored and irritable at the same time. It feels so bland. It's as if someone is slapping me with wet cardboard. It's not exactly hurting me but I want to get away from it.
But: Should I care so much about the prose style? Because, maybe it's a good story.
But I do care. I want to read a story that is written with care.
So, most people would keep reading for several more pages at least, even if they felt the same way about these first sentences--I mean, can you really tell anything at all from two or three sentences?--but for me I'm already thinking that, if this is how a book begins--if the beginning is, indeed, the place where a writer must capture my attention--then I'm done.
And this is normally where I would put a book down.
But this time, because I've heard so much about this writer's books, I open a few pages at random, just to see if I can find just one sentence to fall in love with, anywhere, or some phrase, at least, that catches my eye.
And I read:
Frankie felt a heaviness in her heart, a sorrow that she knew would stay with her...
Jamie was there instantly, holding her steady. She reached for his hand, held it, not daring to look at him...
She looked up in surprise...
He shrugged, as unable to find the words as he'd been to process the grief...
He looked at her a long moment...
That's all I have to say about this book, except to add that clearly I am way, way an outlier on why I read, which is at least 90% for the sound of the language, for the jolt of reading a sentence that is both describing something completely familiar to my human experience and at the same time is said in a completely new and revelatory way, and whenever I begin a book that does not do these things, both of them simultaneously, I think of all the books waiting to be read, and I move on.
I open the book.
The first sentence is: The walled and gated MacGrath estate was a world unto itself, protected and private.
And I think: Gosh, isn't this a slightly uninspired way to begin a book, I mean, couldn't she have tried a little harder than to call something "a world unto itself," which was probably a little on the clich茅d side even before the first time anyone wrote it down?
Ok, moving on, the next two sentences are: On this twilit evening, the Tudor-style home's mullioned windows glowed jewel-like amid the lush, landscaped grounds. Palm fronds swayed overhead... and okay okay that's enough, because my brain is saying: "On this twilit evening?" "windows glowed?"..."Palm fronds swayed?"
I'm just talking about my own experience, here.
Speaking solely from my own point of view, this writing makes me feel bored and irritable at the same time. It feels so bland. It's as if someone is slapping me with wet cardboard. It's not exactly hurting me but I want to get away from it.
But: Should I care so much about the prose style? Because, maybe it's a good story.
But I do care. I want to read a story that is written with care.
So, most people would keep reading for several more pages at least, even if they felt the same way about these first sentences--I mean, can you really tell anything at all from two or three sentences?--but for me I'm already thinking that, if this is how a book begins--if the beginning is, indeed, the place where a writer must capture my attention--then I'm done.
And this is normally where I would put a book down.
But this time, because I've heard so much about this writer's books, I open a few pages at random, just to see if I can find just one sentence to fall in love with, anywhere, or some phrase, at least, that catches my eye.
And I read:
Frankie felt a heaviness in her heart, a sorrow that she knew would stay with her...
Jamie was there instantly, holding her steady. She reached for his hand, held it, not daring to look at him...
She looked up in surprise...
He shrugged, as unable to find the words as he'd been to process the grief...
He looked at her a long moment...
That's all I have to say about this book, except to add that clearly I am way, way an outlier on why I read, which is at least 90% for the sound of the language, for the jolt of reading a sentence that is both describing something completely familiar to my human experience and at the same time is said in a completely new and revelatory way, and whenever I begin a book that does not do these things, both of them simultaneously, I think of all the books waiting to be read, and I move on.
May 17, 2024
Not enough stars to rate this book. I never could鈥檝e imagined myself being sucked into a historical fiction but here we are. I am ashamed to admit I had no idea what truly went on. I feel like blinders have been taken off & the storytelling in this one is 10/10. Add this to the top of your TBR, you may surprise yourself.
February 6, 2024
***HAPPY PUBLICATION DAY - ONE OF MY TOP 5 BOOKS OF 2023 ***
There have been books written about some things that occurred in the 60鈥檚 鈥� the music, the activism, the 鈥渟ummer of love鈥�, the protests over the war, but this is the first book that I鈥檝e read that has touched my heart so deeply.
If not for a high lottery number, my husband would have been one of the thousands of young men who fought in this senseless war.
Women have been largely ignored in most wars and it seems the same was the case in the Vietnam War (the Vietnamese called it the American war). The government misinformed the public about so much, including the fact that WOMEN WERE THERE TOO!
Frankie McGrath鈥檚 brother has just enlisted and she decides to follow him, she enlists in the Army. Just out of nursing school and only 20 years old, she has no idea what to expect. She had lived a sheltered life on Coronado island, her parents were well off and she had an idyllic childhood.
Once in Vietnam she is thrust into taking care of severely wounded men, horrible living conditions and a lack of trained staff. She is unprepared for what is ahead. She will not only learn nursing in extreme conditions but eventually taught how to do surgical procedures. Her base camp had one doctor and three nurses along with medics to care for the hundreds of injured men. Frankie came to dread the sound of helicopters approaching!!
She is fortunate to have incredible roommates who will be her friends for life. She learns love and heartache, loss, anger and frustration.
Upon returning home, there is no welcome, not even from her parents. After all of the parades and sit-ins to protest the war, no one seems to want to SEE THOSE WHO FOUGHT FOR THEIR COUNTRY.
Eventually with lots of help Frankie carves out a life. She had to hit rock bottom before she got help. She struggled with PTSD, depression, alcoholism and betrayal on her path to a new life.
The author states that this was a book that she had wanted to write for a long time. I applaud you Ms. Hannah for putting your heart and incredible research into this book.
鈥淲omen can be heroes too鈥� 鈥� and they so often are even though their voices aren鈥檛 always heard.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss. It was my pleasure to read and review this title.
There have been books written about some things that occurred in the 60鈥檚 鈥� the music, the activism, the 鈥渟ummer of love鈥�, the protests over the war, but this is the first book that I鈥檝e read that has touched my heart so deeply.
If not for a high lottery number, my husband would have been one of the thousands of young men who fought in this senseless war.
Women have been largely ignored in most wars and it seems the same was the case in the Vietnam War (the Vietnamese called it the American war). The government misinformed the public about so much, including the fact that WOMEN WERE THERE TOO!
Frankie McGrath鈥檚 brother has just enlisted and she decides to follow him, she enlists in the Army. Just out of nursing school and only 20 years old, she has no idea what to expect. She had lived a sheltered life on Coronado island, her parents were well off and she had an idyllic childhood.
Once in Vietnam she is thrust into taking care of severely wounded men, horrible living conditions and a lack of trained staff. She is unprepared for what is ahead. She will not only learn nursing in extreme conditions but eventually taught how to do surgical procedures. Her base camp had one doctor and three nurses along with medics to care for the hundreds of injured men. Frankie came to dread the sound of helicopters approaching!!
She is fortunate to have incredible roommates who will be her friends for life. She learns love and heartache, loss, anger and frustration.
Upon returning home, there is no welcome, not even from her parents. After all of the parades and sit-ins to protest the war, no one seems to want to SEE THOSE WHO FOUGHT FOR THEIR COUNTRY.
Eventually with lots of help Frankie carves out a life. She had to hit rock bottom before she got help. She struggled with PTSD, depression, alcoholism and betrayal on her path to a new life.
The author states that this was a book that she had wanted to write for a long time. I applaud you Ms. Hannah for putting your heart and incredible research into this book.
鈥淲omen can be heroes too鈥� 鈥� and they so often are even though their voices aren鈥檛 always heard.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss. It was my pleasure to read and review this title.
November 15, 2024
Eeeek. This will undoubtedly be one of my most disappointing reads of '24! I am baffled by all the 5 star ratings that it's getting.
After "The Nightingale" and "Four Winds," both of which were 5 star reads for me, I was really looking forward to "The Women." I started it immediately the day it was released. I was excited, to say the least.
But ugh.
The premise: Frankie McGrath is not your traditional girl, wanting more out of life than the traditional domestic roles. When the U.S. goes to war in Vietnam, her brother Finley, who is also her best friend, enlists and her parents are brimming with pride. Her father came from a "Navy house" and has a "hero wall" in their home where he puts up pictures of "heroes." His father was a veteran, and his own generation of men all went to war during WWII, but he was not able to go and overcompensated for his subsequent feelings of inadequacy by going overboard on the patriotism. His children are raised believing that serving your country is the highest honor. So when her brother Finley enlists & is deployed, it occurs to Frankie that as an R.N., she should follow in his footsteps. She winds up joining the army bc it's the only military branch that will accept her fresh out of college with no experience, she envisions proud parents, meeting up with her brother in 'Nam, coming home to accolades and a heroes welcome. Reality is nothing even close to that.
So it started off alright. I am not particularly knowledgable about the Vietnam War so I figured I'd learn a thing or two. Things escalate quickly. Before Frankie's plane even lands in Vietnam, she's getting shot at by "Charlie" & cowering in fear bc of all the loud, terrifying gunshots & explosions happening in the vicinity. She's quickly thrust into wartime nursing, exposed to death, missing limbs, & other horrific injuries within minutes of reporting for duty. There is no learning curve, there is no training, she's forced to sac up & buckle down & WORK.
So this was as far as I got while still thinking that I would enjoy this. At this point, things started to go awry.
The best bits IMO were the bits about the friendships Frankie made while nursing. Going through something as traumatizing as a war together has a way of solidifying relationships & bringing people much closer together than the average friendship. The way that Frankie relied on them & the way they showed up for her time & time again warmed my heart, but tbh even these parts highlighted how lacking the whole book was bc again, they lacked any substantial characterizations. We got no real backstories on either of the women, even the bits & pieces of their present lives were quickly glossed over. They were props, devices plugged in just to get Frankie out of whatever man-induced hole she was currently in. It also validated my opinion about Frankie being self absorbed & selfish, for all the support & love she鈥檚 given by these women, she gave almost none of it herself. For example, it takes her a very long time to be open minded about the cause her 鈥渂est friend鈥� has devoted her life to bc she鈥檚 too busy wallowing, & then when one of them gets engaged Frankie is jealous. Everything ties back to whatever is going on in her love life, it was annoying. For a book titled "The Women鈥� which supposedly was intended to be something that gave distinction & a voice to a group that history has all but forgotten, a lot of this was about the men.
Historical fiction is not my favorite genre, but when written well (according to my preferences) they can still be some of my favorite books. But when I pick up a piece of historical fiction, I want to learn something about a time or a place or a people. Often after or while reading HF I find myself reading up on that topic, watching documentaries, searching out facts. Kate Quinn, John Boyne, Emma Donoghue are a few that come to mind that have consistently provided me with what I want in my historical fiction. What I don鈥檛 want is to read a romance within a historical setting. In 鈥淭he Women,鈥� reading about the experiences of a nurse in a time of war DID interest me, but it could have just as easily been any other place or time or war. Other than a few mentions of the heat & of 鈥淐harlie鈥� one would hardly be able to differentiate between this & any other wars. It was ultimately a hollow construction of the war, a backdrop for the romantic exploits of our MC. I could have written this book with what little I knew about the Vietnam war. I got through just shy of 500 pages without learning a single thing. The title 鈥淟ove In A Time Of War鈥� would have mo
To be fair, I didn鈥檛 completely despise this book, it was readable, I was never bored. It was just that I had such high expectations & the result was disappointing. I have not read any of Kristin Hannah鈥檚 earlier works to know firsthand whether this is actually true or not, but I had gotten the sense that she had begun to deviate a bit from her previous chick-lit/romance with more literary work with "Nightingale," and "Four Winds," but it feels like she鈥檚 reverted back to her former M.O. with "The Women." (Which no shame to readers of chick-lit, some of it is great, but it鈥檚 just not what I was looking for in this instance.) Ordinarily I might have rated this 3 stars, but because my disappointment was so severe I had to go with 2. That doesn't mean that I'm giving up on Kristin Hannah, I still plan to one day read the "Great Alone," and I will likely continue to read whatever she comes out with.
It is also worth noting that so far the reaction to 鈥淭he Women鈥漢as been so positive that it leaves me feeling like I might be alone in my feelings about it. I鈥檓 getting the typical 鈥渨hat did I miss?!鈥� feeling. To each their own I guess 馃し馃徎鈥嶁檧锔忦煠佛煆烩€嶁檧锔�
After "The Nightingale" and "Four Winds," both of which were 5 star reads for me, I was really looking forward to "The Women." I started it immediately the day it was released. I was excited, to say the least.
But ugh.
The premise: Frankie McGrath is not your traditional girl, wanting more out of life than the traditional domestic roles. When the U.S. goes to war in Vietnam, her brother Finley, who is also her best friend, enlists and her parents are brimming with pride. Her father came from a "Navy house" and has a "hero wall" in their home where he puts up pictures of "heroes." His father was a veteran, and his own generation of men all went to war during WWII, but he was not able to go and overcompensated for his subsequent feelings of inadequacy by going overboard on the patriotism. His children are raised believing that serving your country is the highest honor. So when her brother Finley enlists & is deployed, it occurs to Frankie that as an R.N., she should follow in his footsteps. She winds up joining the army bc it's the only military branch that will accept her fresh out of college with no experience, she envisions proud parents, meeting up with her brother in 'Nam, coming home to accolades and a heroes welcome. Reality is nothing even close to that.
So it started off alright. I am not particularly knowledgable about the Vietnam War so I figured I'd learn a thing or two. Things escalate quickly. Before Frankie's plane even lands in Vietnam, she's getting shot at by "Charlie" & cowering in fear bc of all the loud, terrifying gunshots & explosions happening in the vicinity. She's quickly thrust into wartime nursing, exposed to death, missing limbs, & other horrific injuries within minutes of reporting for duty. There is no learning curve, there is no training, she's forced to sac up & buckle down & WORK.
So this was as far as I got while still thinking that I would enjoy this. At this point, things started to go awry.
The best bits IMO were the bits about the friendships Frankie made while nursing. Going through something as traumatizing as a war together has a way of solidifying relationships & bringing people much closer together than the average friendship. The way that Frankie relied on them & the way they showed up for her time & time again warmed my heart, but tbh even these parts highlighted how lacking the whole book was bc again, they lacked any substantial characterizations. We got no real backstories on either of the women, even the bits & pieces of their present lives were quickly glossed over. They were props, devices plugged in just to get Frankie out of whatever man-induced hole she was currently in. It also validated my opinion about Frankie being self absorbed & selfish, for all the support & love she鈥檚 given by these women, she gave almost none of it herself. For example, it takes her a very long time to be open minded about the cause her 鈥渂est friend鈥� has devoted her life to bc she鈥檚 too busy wallowing, & then when one of them gets engaged Frankie is jealous. Everything ties back to whatever is going on in her love life, it was annoying. For a book titled "The Women鈥� which supposedly was intended to be something that gave distinction & a voice to a group that history has all but forgotten, a lot of this was about the men.
Historical fiction is not my favorite genre, but when written well (according to my preferences) they can still be some of my favorite books. But when I pick up a piece of historical fiction, I want to learn something about a time or a place or a people. Often after or while reading HF I find myself reading up on that topic, watching documentaries, searching out facts. Kate Quinn, John Boyne, Emma Donoghue are a few that come to mind that have consistently provided me with what I want in my historical fiction. What I don鈥檛 want is to read a romance within a historical setting. In 鈥淭he Women,鈥� reading about the experiences of a nurse in a time of war DID interest me, but it could have just as easily been any other place or time or war. Other than a few mentions of the heat & of 鈥淐harlie鈥� one would hardly be able to differentiate between this & any other wars. It was ultimately a hollow construction of the war, a backdrop for the romantic exploits of our MC. I could have written this book with what little I knew about the Vietnam war. I got through just shy of 500 pages without learning a single thing. The title 鈥淟ove In A Time Of War鈥� would have mo
To be fair, I didn鈥檛 completely despise this book, it was readable, I was never bored. It was just that I had such high expectations & the result was disappointing. I have not read any of Kristin Hannah鈥檚 earlier works to know firsthand whether this is actually true or not, but I had gotten the sense that she had begun to deviate a bit from her previous chick-lit/romance with more literary work with "Nightingale," and "Four Winds," but it feels like she鈥檚 reverted back to her former M.O. with "The Women." (Which no shame to readers of chick-lit, some of it is great, but it鈥檚 just not what I was looking for in this instance.) Ordinarily I might have rated this 3 stars, but because my disappointment was so severe I had to go with 2. That doesn't mean that I'm giving up on Kristin Hannah, I still plan to one day read the "Great Alone," and I will likely continue to read whatever she comes out with.
It is also worth noting that so far the reaction to 鈥淭he Women鈥漢as been so positive that it leaves me feeling like I might be alone in my feelings about it. I鈥檓 getting the typical 鈥渨hat did I miss?!鈥� feeling. To each their own I guess 馃し馃徎鈥嶁檧锔忦煠佛煆烩€嶁檧锔�
September 12, 2023
I love books that not only teach me something but are thought provoking and evoke emotion. This book fits that bill to a "T" and then some. I don't think it is possible for Kristin Hannah to write a bad book. As with her other books, is well written, well thought out, and gripping. I was instantly absorbed in this book and had a hard time putting it down. I felt as if I were a fly on the wall, traveling to Vietnam with Frankie, and observing what life as a nurse was like during that time. The devastating injuries of the soldiers, the choices the medical staff had to make (who could be saved, who not to treat), the explosions, the living conditions, the lack of supplies and the relationships that were formed, left an impression on me.
Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath was raised Coronado Island, California by her conservative parents. In the beginning of the book, she is a twenty-year-old nursing student living at home with her conservative, country club member parents. After her older brother goes to Vietnam, Frankie recalls the words of one of his friends 鈥淲omen can be heroes, too.鈥� , Frankie joins the Army Nurse Corps and after training, she is sent to Vietnam to work as a nurse. What she sees and experiences is shocking, traumatizing, heartbreaking and ultimately life changing. When not treating the horrifically injured soldiers, Frankie has formed close bonds with her fellow nurses. Bonds that will also change her life. Upon coming home, Frankie is shocked by being spit on, yelled at, and told repeatedly that women were not in Vietnam.
I was shocked to learn that the Nurses who provide medical care to soldiers were not considered Veterans even though they signed up with the Army. That they could not go to the VA for help with PTSD. It was appalling and heartbreaking.
Besides the beautiful writing, I loved how Hannah showed the strength of female friendship. How the women supported each other and formed a family unit amongst themselves. This was one of the highlights for me. They lifted each other up, loved each other, accepted each other鈥檚 faults, celebrated their strengths, and when everyone else was letting them down, they knew they could count on each other.
This book also shows how PTSD affected nurses, doctors, and soldiers. How many self-medicated with drugs and alcohol. This book also depicts scenes of great bravery, political upheaval, war protests, the effects of PTSD, self-medication with drugs, friendships, family dynamics, sexism, and growth.
The characters are fully fleshed out and feel real. I felt for them, rooted for them, and cried with them.
Well written, gripping, shocking, and thought provoking.
*Traveling Friends buddy read with Mary Beth
#KristinHannah #NetGalley #StMartinsPress
Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at
Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� McGrath was raised Coronado Island, California by her conservative parents. In the beginning of the book, she is a twenty-year-old nursing student living at home with her conservative, country club member parents. After her older brother goes to Vietnam, Frankie recalls the words of one of his friends 鈥淲omen can be heroes, too.鈥� , Frankie joins the Army Nurse Corps and after training, she is sent to Vietnam to work as a nurse. What she sees and experiences is shocking, traumatizing, heartbreaking and ultimately life changing. When not treating the horrifically injured soldiers, Frankie has formed close bonds with her fellow nurses. Bonds that will also change her life. Upon coming home, Frankie is shocked by being spit on, yelled at, and told repeatedly that women were not in Vietnam.
I was shocked to learn that the Nurses who provide medical care to soldiers were not considered Veterans even though they signed up with the Army. That they could not go to the VA for help with PTSD. It was appalling and heartbreaking.
Besides the beautiful writing, I loved how Hannah showed the strength of female friendship. How the women supported each other and formed a family unit amongst themselves. This was one of the highlights for me. They lifted each other up, loved each other, accepted each other鈥檚 faults, celebrated their strengths, and when everyone else was letting them down, they knew they could count on each other.
This book also shows how PTSD affected nurses, doctors, and soldiers. How many self-medicated with drugs and alcohol. This book also depicts scenes of great bravery, political upheaval, war protests, the effects of PTSD, self-medication with drugs, friendships, family dynamics, sexism, and growth.
The characters are fully fleshed out and feel real. I felt for them, rooted for them, and cried with them.
Well written, gripping, shocking, and thought provoking.
*Traveling Friends buddy read with Mary Beth
#KristinHannah #NetGalley #StMartinsPress
Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at
February 6, 2024
When Frances "Frankie McGrath's brother ships out to serve in Vietnam, she joins the Army Nurse Corps and follows his path when she hears that women can be heroes too. Frankie is overwhelmed by the chaos and destruction of war as well as the unexpected trauma of coming home to a changed and politically divided America.
Every time I open up a Kristin Hannah novel I get so excited. I have loved all of her books. This story is all about the women, the nurses in the Vietnam War. I think this is the first book that actually is about the women in the Vietnam War. It's about the women who puts themselves in harms way to help others. Women whose sacrifice and commitment to their country has all too often been forgotten. It's an emotional story.
Frankie is so brave and strong and has dealt with so much death. Many of the women ended up with PTSD, flashbacks, and nightmares but they couldn't get the help that was needed like the men could.
I loved all of the characters. They were all done so well. I loved the women's friendship. They all had each other's backs. They all were a good support group with each other. This was such a great book.
I want to thank St. Martin's Press for the copy of this book.
Every time I open up a Kristin Hannah novel I get so excited. I have loved all of her books. This story is all about the women, the nurses in the Vietnam War. I think this is the first book that actually is about the women in the Vietnam War. It's about the women who puts themselves in harms way to help others. Women whose sacrifice and commitment to their country has all too often been forgotten. It's an emotional story.
Frankie is so brave and strong and has dealt with so much death. Many of the women ended up with PTSD, flashbacks, and nightmares but they couldn't get the help that was needed like the men could.
I loved all of the characters. They were all done so well. I loved the women's friendship. They all had each other's backs. They all were a good support group with each other. This was such a great book.
I want to thank St. Martin's Press for the copy of this book.
June 8, 2024
One of the most interesting aspects of 鈥淭he Women鈥� is the themes Kristin explores, such as courage, resilience, and the lasting impact of military service on those who serve. Hannah writes vividly about the camaraderie between the women, their battles, and their triumphs, and together the stories are a rich tapestry of human emotions and experiences.
I discovered that there is audiobook format of this book and I can honestly say that audiobook it was an enlightening and fascinating experience. You can find audiobook version here:
There is also a societal aspect to the book that looks at the challenges that these women faced when they returned, fighting to be recognized and honored in a society that often devalued their contributions. The development of Frankie character and her bonds with the other nurses is powerfully hopeful and devastating.
This book is perfect for readers who have an interest in historical fiction and will be particularly appreciated for those interested in hearing a fuller story of women during the Vietnam War. Kristin Hannah has written a truly meaningful tribute to these silent heroes, and this story will touch its readers in lasting ways.
Not only is it a captivating story with strongly developed characters, but it also recognizes the value, strength, and resilience of women. Highly recommended.
I discovered that there is audiobook format of this book and I can honestly say that audiobook it was an enlightening and fascinating experience. You can find audiobook version here:
There is also a societal aspect to the book that looks at the challenges that these women faced when they returned, fighting to be recognized and honored in a society that often devalued their contributions. The development of Frankie character and her bonds with the other nurses is powerfully hopeful and devastating.
This book is perfect for readers who have an interest in historical fiction and will be particularly appreciated for those interested in hearing a fuller story of women during the Vietnam War. Kristin Hannah has written a truly meaningful tribute to these silent heroes, and this story will touch its readers in lasting ways.
Not only is it a captivating story with strongly developed characters, but it also recognizes the value, strength, and resilience of women. Highly recommended.
February 21, 2024
The Women was divine. Hannah鈥檚 writing has matured much like a fine wine. Each of her stories becoming richer, more complex, multi-layered.
The Women is a tribute to the many unsung female nurses who served in the Vietnam War. Frankie, 20, has graduated nursing school and has enlisted. Although green, her nursing skills sharpen during her 2 tours. However when she returns home, the welcome isn鈥檛 a warm one.
The brevity and courage these veterans had. Not only fighting for their lives over seas, but fighting for their own recognition at home amid a storm of protests and division. The sacrifices made. The lies told.
Hannah masterly develops a character from a young naive girl, to a professional combat nurse, to a veteran returning home experiencing many of the symptoms men did- except many unaware women even served. Grief, PTSD, shame, addiction and healing.
5猸愶笍 Hannah, you knocked it out of the park.
The Women is a tribute to the many unsung female nurses who served in the Vietnam War. Frankie, 20, has graduated nursing school and has enlisted. Although green, her nursing skills sharpen during her 2 tours. However when she returns home, the welcome isn鈥檛 a warm one.
The brevity and courage these veterans had. Not only fighting for their lives over seas, but fighting for their own recognition at home amid a storm of protests and division. The sacrifices made. The lies told.
Hannah masterly develops a character from a young naive girl, to a professional combat nurse, to a veteran returning home experiencing many of the symptoms men did- except many unaware women even served. Grief, PTSD, shame, addiction and healing.
5猸愶笍 Hannah, you knocked it out of the park.
March 1, 2024
The Women by Kristin Hannah is a Blend of Historical, Literary, and Women's Fiction!
I'll be honest, I was expecting more finesse from Kristan Hannah's writing style and storytelling...
The Women transports the reader, along with the main character, Frances "Frankie" McGrath, to the Thirty-Sixth Evac Hospital in Vietnam, sixty miles from Saigon, within the first four chapters. By the end of the sixth chapter, I shed my first tears. This is an emotional read and, for those of us who remember those years during the Vietnam War, it stirs different memories in each of us...
Overall, the pace of this story is slow, allowing repetition to sneak in. This is especially true after Frankie's return from Vietnam. Her homecoming was heart-wrenching but carried on, chapter after chapter, making the story too long. Perhaps the length would have been better justified if backstories were included for the primary characters. Very little to nothing was provided for any of them.
Early in, the writing felt cumbersome and overly descriptive with flowery prose. The narration sounded throaty, stilted, sometimes monotone, and at other times exaggerated. The story had more telling than showing by the author's use of the story's narrative, rather than focusing on creative writing skills to allow the story to flow naturally. The writing style was my least favorite aspect of this book. It felt clumsy, overdramatic, and at times, snarky.
This was an immersion read with a Kindle copy and an Audible audiobook, narrated by Julia Whelan.
I love the female-focused premise and how the author allows the reader's imagination to proceed beyond the ending of the story. The story is emotional, true to the era, and well-researched. I cried, relived the memories and the music from that time, and appreciated the feeling of authenticity.
The Women has many positive reviews and high ratings and I respect those viewpoints. As in all of my reviews, this critique is my honest opinion. Outlier Island, here I come. It's going to be a lonely place this time around...
2猸�
I'll be honest, I was expecting more finesse from Kristan Hannah's writing style and storytelling...
The Women transports the reader, along with the main character, Frances "Frankie" McGrath, to the Thirty-Sixth Evac Hospital in Vietnam, sixty miles from Saigon, within the first four chapters. By the end of the sixth chapter, I shed my first tears. This is an emotional read and, for those of us who remember those years during the Vietnam War, it stirs different memories in each of us...
Overall, the pace of this story is slow, allowing repetition to sneak in. This is especially true after Frankie's return from Vietnam. Her homecoming was heart-wrenching but carried on, chapter after chapter, making the story too long. Perhaps the length would have been better justified if backstories were included for the primary characters. Very little to nothing was provided for any of them.
Early in, the writing felt cumbersome and overly descriptive with flowery prose. The narration sounded throaty, stilted, sometimes monotone, and at other times exaggerated. The story had more telling than showing by the author's use of the story's narrative, rather than focusing on creative writing skills to allow the story to flow naturally. The writing style was my least favorite aspect of this book. It felt clumsy, overdramatic, and at times, snarky.
This was an immersion read with a Kindle copy and an Audible audiobook, narrated by Julia Whelan.
I love the female-focused premise and how the author allows the reader's imagination to proceed beyond the ending of the story. The story is emotional, true to the era, and well-researched. I cried, relived the memories and the music from that time, and appreciated the feeling of authenticity.
The Women has many positive reviews and high ratings and I respect those viewpoints. As in all of my reviews, this critique is my honest opinion. Outlier Island, here I come. It's going to be a lonely place this time around...
2猸�
January 6, 2025
鈥滒潛ｐ潛别潛� 饾攢饾摳饾摱饾摦饾摲 饾摫饾摢饾摥 饾摢 饾摷饾摻饾摳饾摶饾攤 饾摻饾摳 饾摻饾摦饾摰饾摰, 饾摦饾摽饾摦饾摲 饾摬饾摨 饾摻饾摫饾摦 饾攢饾摳饾摶饾摰饾摥 饾攢饾摢饾摷饾摲'饾摻 饾摵饾摼饾摬饾摻饾摦 饾攤饾摦饾摻 饾摶饾摦饾摢饾摥饾攤 饾摻饾摳 饾摫饾摦饾摢饾摶 饾摬饾摻, 饾摢饾摲饾摥 饾摻饾摫饾摦饾摬饾摶 饾摷饾摻饾摳饾摶饾攤 饾摣饾摦饾摪饾摢饾摲 饾攢饾摬饾摻饾摫 饾摻饾摫饾摶饾摦饾摦 饾摷饾摬饾摱饾摴饾摰饾摦 饾攢饾摳饾摶饾摥饾摷. 饾摝饾摦 饾攢饾摦饾摶饾摦 饾摻饾摫饾摦饾摶饾摦.鈥�
藯藦藡 鈽� 藥藠藯 3 饾晩饾暐饾晵饾暎饾暏 藯藦藡鈽呪€匡傅鈥� 藲 鈧娾姽
The first half of the book we follow Frances aka 鈥淔rankie鈥� to Vietnam after she leaves her comfort and sheltered life of Southern California. She is a squeaky new nursing student who decides to follow her brother to the war torn country.
We follow Frankie鈥檚 journey as she is overwhelmed, terrified and second guessing herself on the daily. Frankie forms relationships that feel like they will last forever.
The second half of the book brings us back to Southern California, where we continue to follow Frankie after her return from Vietnam. We learn of her sadness and heartbreak and her attempt to get her life back on track.
This was a good read, don't get me wrong... Kristin Hannah has amazing and strong storytelling capability.
I've only read a few KH books now, but... and maybe it's just me, but it seems the two war books I've read from her are so heavy on the foreshadowing that the story becomes predictable.
I always chalked it up to the fact that I'd read too many WWII stories. And maybe that's true as well, but this did seem foreshadow heavy to me.
I was not a fan of Frankie's POV. At all.
There was a lot of romantic entanglements in this one. More than I really care to have in a historical fiction. Frankie was super boy crazy and made the worst decisions ever.
If you typically enjoy Kristin Hannah books, it's worth the read. If you're just starting to dip your toe into historical fiction and would like a little more emphasis on romance, give this one a try.
I enjoyed it, it just isn't my favorite KH book.
鈥滒潛曫潛火潛葛潛� 饾摫饾摦饾摶饾摦, 饾摻饾摫饾摦 饾攢饾摢饾摶 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摢饾摰饾摱饾摳饾摷饾摻 饾摣饾摦饾摢饾摼饾摻饾摬饾摨饾摼饾摰. 饾摐饾摢饾攤饾摣饾摦 饾摻饾摫饾摢饾摻 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摢 饾摨饾摼饾摲饾摥饾摢饾摱饾摦饾摲饾摻饾摢饾摰 饾摻饾摶饾摼饾摻饾摫: 饾摝饾摢饾摶 饾摰饾摳饾摳饾摯饾摦饾摥 饾摳饾摲饾摦 饾攢饾摢饾攤 饾摨饾摳饾摶 饾摻饾摫饾摳饾摷饾摦 饾攢饾摫饾摳 饾摷饾摢饾攢 饾摬饾摻 饾摨饾摶饾摳饾摱 饾摢 饾摷饾摢饾摨饾摦 饾摥饾摬饾摷饾摻饾摢饾摲饾摤饾摦. 饾搾饾摰饾摳饾摷饾摦 饾摼饾摴, 饾摻饾摫饾摦 饾摽饾摬饾摦饾攢 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摥饾摬饾摨饾摨饾摦饾摶饾摦饾摲饾摻鈥�
鈰嗏湸锔幩氾健鈰� 藯藦藡鈽呪€匡傅鈥� 藲 鈧娾姽
藯藦藡 鈽� 藥藠藯 3 饾晩饾暐饾晵饾暎饾暏 藯藦藡鈽呪€匡傅鈥� 藲 鈧娾姽
The first half of the book we follow Frances aka 鈥淔rankie鈥� to Vietnam after she leaves her comfort and sheltered life of Southern California. She is a squeaky new nursing student who decides to follow her brother to the war torn country.
We follow Frankie鈥檚 journey as she is overwhelmed, terrified and second guessing herself on the daily. Frankie forms relationships that feel like they will last forever.
The second half of the book brings us back to Southern California, where we continue to follow Frankie after her return from Vietnam. We learn of her sadness and heartbreak and her attempt to get her life back on track.
This was a good read, don't get me wrong... Kristin Hannah has amazing and strong storytelling capability.
I've only read a few KH books now, but... and maybe it's just me, but it seems the two war books I've read from her are so heavy on the foreshadowing that the story becomes predictable.
I always chalked it up to the fact that I'd read too many WWII stories. And maybe that's true as well, but this did seem foreshadow heavy to me.
I was not a fan of Frankie's POV. At all.
There was a lot of romantic entanglements in this one. More than I really care to have in a historical fiction. Frankie was super boy crazy and made the worst decisions ever.
If you typically enjoy Kristin Hannah books, it's worth the read. If you're just starting to dip your toe into historical fiction and would like a little more emphasis on romance, give this one a try.
I enjoyed it, it just isn't my favorite KH book.
鈥滒潛曫潛火潛葛潛� 饾摫饾摦饾摶饾摦, 饾摻饾摫饾摦 饾攢饾摢饾摶 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摢饾摰饾摱饾摳饾摷饾摻 饾摣饾摦饾摢饾摼饾摻饾摬饾摨饾摼饾摰. 饾摐饾摢饾攤饾摣饾摦 饾摻饾摫饾摢饾摻 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摢 饾摨饾摼饾摲饾摥饾摢饾摱饾摦饾摲饾摻饾摢饾摰 饾摻饾摶饾摼饾摻饾摫: 饾摝饾摢饾摶 饾摰饾摳饾摳饾摯饾摦饾摥 饾摳饾摲饾摦 饾攢饾摢饾攤 饾摨饾摳饾摶 饾摻饾摫饾摳饾摷饾摦 饾攢饾摫饾摳 饾摷饾摢饾攢 饾摬饾摻 饾摨饾摶饾摳饾摱 饾摢 饾摷饾摢饾摨饾摦 饾摥饾摬饾摷饾摻饾摢饾摲饾摤饾摦. 饾搾饾摰饾摳饾摷饾摦 饾摼饾摴, 饾摻饾摫饾摦 饾摽饾摬饾摦饾攢 饾攢饾摢饾摷 饾摥饾摬饾摨饾摨饾摦饾摶饾摦饾摲饾摻鈥�
鈰嗏湸锔幩氾健鈰� 藯藦藡鈽呪€匡傅鈥� 藲 鈧娾姽
July 22, 2024
I really wanted to love this but it's the same white American savior view of the Vietnam War that we鈥檝e seen many times before. Despite some well-researched details, Kristin Hannah doesn鈥檛 seem to care as much about historical or cultural accuracy when it comes to writing Vietnam or Vietnamese people. It feels as if Hannah's research stopped at looking up stock images of Vietnam. Nothing too egregious but it definitely took me out of the story and created many eyeroll moments. (For example, Hannah assumed Vietnamese women only wore 谩o d脿i for every situation - working in the fields, carrying baskets of fruits, serving Jack Daniels in an American bar - they didn't.)
The fast pace and melodramatic turn of events also force the characters to remain one-dimensional and rush the natural development and chemistry of Frankie's friendships and relationships. The "telling instead of showing" writing style is also not for me, so I had no reason to finish this sadly.
*updated Feb 2024
The fast pace and melodramatic turn of events also force the characters to remain one-dimensional and rush the natural development and chemistry of Frankie's friendships and relationships. The "telling instead of showing" writing style is also not for me, so I had no reason to finish this sadly.
*updated Feb 2024
August 23, 2023
Another fantastic book by Kristin Hannah
I haven鈥檛 read much about the Vietnam War.. but, I was born in 鈥�58 and as a young girl I remember seeing the horrific video and images on the nightly news and.. fortunately for me.. I only knew of one older cousin who got drafted to go to war.
Most everything we saw before, during, and after the war was about the men who were there.. of course it was the men who saw combat.. but women were there too鈥� the nurses trying to patch up mutilated bodies, being alongside the dying as they took their last breaths..the women also endured a lot!
This is the story of the WOMEN鈥� a few of them.. mostly about a young girl Frankie, who after her brother enlisted.. she followed him and was a war nurse in the Army.
I loved the story, mostly the first half that took place in Vietnam during wartime.
So much about this story took me back to those days.. the riots, the political landscape, the war protests, the mention of certain songs.
Wonderful!
Thank you to Netgalley and St Martins Press for the ARC!
I haven鈥檛 read much about the Vietnam War.. but, I was born in 鈥�58 and as a young girl I remember seeing the horrific video and images on the nightly news and.. fortunately for me.. I only knew of one older cousin who got drafted to go to war.
Most everything we saw before, during, and after the war was about the men who were there.. of course it was the men who saw combat.. but women were there too鈥� the nurses trying to patch up mutilated bodies, being alongside the dying as they took their last breaths..the women also endured a lot!
This is the story of the WOMEN鈥� a few of them.. mostly about a young girl Frankie, who after her brother enlisted.. she followed him and was a war nurse in the Army.
I loved the story, mostly the first half that took place in Vietnam during wartime.
So much about this story took me back to those days.. the riots, the political landscape, the war protests, the mention of certain songs.
Wonderful!
Thank you to Netgalley and St Martins Press for the ARC!
April 1, 2024
In this devided world run by men , you can count on women.
This quote felt like a perfect background for the overlooked story of the women serving their country in Vietnam. I for one hadn鈥檛 thought about the people who went there as nurses or other professions to help any way they could. I knew how important the war was when it came to recognizing how trauma can stay in the body and wreak havoc, and this book also showed how much society can make it harder to heal by not recognizing people who partake in war. In addition to being a convincing portrayal of war and PTSD, it was a love story that made me cry at the end. At one point I had to take a pause from listening because it was hard to process all the pain the main character suffered. When that happens, you know a story has affected you deeply.
This quote felt like a perfect background for the overlooked story of the women serving their country in Vietnam. I for one hadn鈥檛 thought about the people who went there as nurses or other professions to help any way they could. I knew how important the war was when it came to recognizing how trauma can stay in the body and wreak havoc, and this book also showed how much society can make it harder to heal by not recognizing people who partake in war. In addition to being a convincing portrayal of war and PTSD, it was a love story that made me cry at the end. At one point I had to take a pause from listening because it was hard to process all the pain the main character suffered. When that happens, you know a story has affected you deeply.
February 13, 2025
.路:*篓 4.25 stars 篓*:路.
in typical kristin hannah fashion, this book was equally devastating + addicting. you know those books you could universally recommend to anyone despite their age, genre taste, and personality? this is one of those.
鈮€⑩棪 鉂� she鈥檇 begun believing that she was stupid and learned slowly that she was just human.鉂� 鈼︹€⑩壂
鈺攬鈹坵hat to expect鈹堚攬鈺�
銉烩潵銉籥n army nurse鈥檚 POV during her service in the Vietnam war
銉烩潵銉籥n in-depth look into America as it was protesting the Vietnam war and veterans were coming home to a divided America
銉烩潵銉籔TSD, love + loss, alcohol/substance abuse, depression, intense war descriptions (somewhat explicit injury scenes during war) 鈥� AKA lots of emotional turmoil
銉烩潵銉籪amilial misunderstanding, love, forgiveness, and hurt
銉烩潵銉�a woman losing herself, finding herself, and then doing it all over again and again
銉烩潵銉籥n absolute emotional ROLLERCOASTER
銉烩潵銉�strong female friendships <3 (no one writes these better than kristin hannah!)
鈮€⑩棪 鉂�maybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. happy forever seems a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鉂� 鈼︹€⑩壂
this was honestly such a heavy read (i was also on my period, so that didn鈥檛 help) and it made me emotional multiple times. this author is one of the few that i can count on to upend my emotions every single time because her characters just feel so HUMAN. they are imperfect, make mistakes, struggle, and then find happiness where they can.
this isn鈥檛 my favorite book by her (鈥榝irefly lane鈥� is a 6 star and absolutely destroyed me)... but take that with a grain of salt PLEASE. i don鈥檛 give out 4+ star ratings lightly and kristin hannah continues to deliver every time.
her books make me enjoy historical fiction without ever getting bored or being overwhelmed from excessive info dumping. this one will sit on my shelf for a very long time and it鈥檚 one i鈥檇 recommend to literally anyone. 鈰� 鈽�
in typical kristin hannah fashion, this book was equally devastating + addicting. you know those books you could universally recommend to anyone despite their age, genre taste, and personality? this is one of those.
鈮€⑩棪 鉂� she鈥檇 begun believing that she was stupid and learned slowly that she was just human.鉂� 鈼︹€⑩壂
鈺攬鈹坵hat to expect鈹堚攬鈺�
銉烩潵銉籥n army nurse鈥檚 POV during her service in the Vietnam war
銉烩潵銉籥n in-depth look into America as it was protesting the Vietnam war and veterans were coming home to a divided America
銉烩潵銉籔TSD, love + loss, alcohol/substance abuse, depression, intense war descriptions (somewhat explicit injury scenes during war) 鈥� AKA lots of emotional turmoil
銉烩潵銉籪amilial misunderstanding, love, forgiveness, and hurt
銉烩潵銉�a woman losing herself, finding herself, and then doing it all over again and again
銉烩潵銉籥n absolute emotional ROLLERCOASTER
銉烩潵銉�strong female friendships <3 (no one writes these better than kristin hannah!)
鈮€⑩棪 鉂�maybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. happy forever seems a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鉂� 鈼︹€⑩壂
this was honestly such a heavy read (i was also on my period, so that didn鈥檛 help) and it made me emotional multiple times. this author is one of the few that i can count on to upend my emotions every single time because her characters just feel so HUMAN. they are imperfect, make mistakes, struggle, and then find happiness where they can.
this isn鈥檛 my favorite book by her (鈥榝irefly lane鈥� is a 6 star and absolutely destroyed me)... but take that with a grain of salt PLEASE. i don鈥檛 give out 4+ star ratings lightly and kristin hannah continues to deliver every time.
her books make me enjoy historical fiction without ever getting bored or being overwhelmed from excessive info dumping. this one will sit on my shelf for a very long time and it鈥檚 one i鈥檇 recommend to literally anyone. 鈰� 鈽�
December 15, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up.
I was I high school when the Vietnam War started and I have to admit that I didn鈥檛 pay much attention until several years later in college when I found myself in a protest march on campus. I was more aware then or at least I thought I was. I had learned that a high school friend was killed there. The focus then was on the young men killed, the innocents of the region bombed, the insanity of the war. I never gave a thought about the women who served in the military as nurses, who saved so many, who experienced the trauma of seeing mutilated bodies, held the hands of those who wouldn鈥檛 come home. I never thought of the nurses who worked tirelessly under horrible conditions, who through their stamina and skill made it possible for so many to come home. Had I thought about them I never would have imagined that they would not be considered veterans. Kristin Hannah in this novel though the character of Frankie McGrath and her two best friends brings light and honor to the women who served.
It鈥檚 a stunning read, not for the faint of heart, with vivid descriptions of the wounds and loss of limbs and loss of life. It portrays the grueling days and nights of these women as well as the doctors vividly. Their physical and emotional exhaustion and how they cope with sometimes heartbreaking effect. Frankie鈥檚 life after she returned home is heart wrenching. Highly recommend for those who remember the times and for those who don鈥檛. It鈥檚 an eye opener that will punch you in the gut, but it鈥檚 worth it.
I received a copy of this book from St. Martin鈥檚 Press through NetGalley.
I was I high school when the Vietnam War started and I have to admit that I didn鈥檛 pay much attention until several years later in college when I found myself in a protest march on campus. I was more aware then or at least I thought I was. I had learned that a high school friend was killed there. The focus then was on the young men killed, the innocents of the region bombed, the insanity of the war. I never gave a thought about the women who served in the military as nurses, who saved so many, who experienced the trauma of seeing mutilated bodies, held the hands of those who wouldn鈥檛 come home. I never thought of the nurses who worked tirelessly under horrible conditions, who through their stamina and skill made it possible for so many to come home. Had I thought about them I never would have imagined that they would not be considered veterans. Kristin Hannah in this novel though the character of Frankie McGrath and her two best friends brings light and honor to the women who served.
It鈥檚 a stunning read, not for the faint of heart, with vivid descriptions of the wounds and loss of limbs and loss of life. It portrays the grueling days and nights of these women as well as the doctors vividly. Their physical and emotional exhaustion and how they cope with sometimes heartbreaking effect. Frankie鈥檚 life after she returned home is heart wrenching. Highly recommend for those who remember the times and for those who don鈥檛. It鈥檚 an eye opener that will punch you in the gut, but it鈥檚 worth it.
I received a copy of this book from St. Martin鈥檚 Press through NetGalley.
April 26, 2024
鈥淭he women had a story to tell, even if the world wasn鈥檛 quite yet ready to hear it, and their story began with three simple words. We were there.鈥�
The Women by Kristin Hannah follows twenty-one-year-old Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� Grace McGrath, a sheltered young woman from an affluent family, who enlisted as a nurse during the Vietnam War. The narrative follows Frankie through the years of the war and the decades that follow.
There is a lot to like about this novel. The author writes with compassion and the narrative flows well. The fact that the author wanted to tell the story of the women who served in the Vietnam War, giving those whose contributions have been ignored a voice, renders this novel remarkable in its scope and intention. I loved how the author describes the camaraderie between friends and colleagues, their support for one another, the resilience, compassion and bravery of the women who served and the sacrifices they made. I also liked how the author incorporated the public outcry and protests back home - the mixed feelings about the war and those who served and the politics of the time - into the narrative. The author鈥檚 unflinching depiction of PTSD and how so many people could not find the help they needed to cope with the trauma they carried back home was heartbreaking was realistic and thought-provoking as were the descriptions of the horrors of war (some of which were more than a little difficult to read). Despite the story being set in years of the Vietnam War and its aftermath, the issues that she has raised are both crucial and relevant even in today鈥檚 world.
Unfortunately, there are a few issues that prevent me from giving this novel a higher rating. I was invested in Frankie鈥檚 journey and was eager to see how she evolved from a privileged young woman whose sheltered upbringing could not have prepared her for what she would have to endure. The weak character development, the focus on her love life, and the stereotypical and slightly disrespectful representation of the men (with whom she gets romantically involved) who serve their country did not make for pleasant reading and detracted from the overall experience. The ending was poignant, but again, the author鈥檚 choice to provide a 鈥渉appy鈥� (melodramatic) ending lessened the overall impact.
Both Ethel and Barb were well thought out characters ( in fact, I found them more interesting than Frankie). Though we do get to know their stories in segments interspersed throughout the novel, mostly through Frankie鈥檚 interactions with them, I feel the author has missed an opportunity to further enrich the narrative. In my humble opinion, focusing on one woman鈥檚 perspective and relegating the other characters to supporting roles, defeats the purpose of this novel. All three women, each with their distinct convictions and motivations, deserved to have their voices woven into the narrative. The perspectives of all three of these women from diverse backgrounds, each of whom embark on their respective journeys facing their own set of challenges, would have provided much-needed depth to the narrative.
Given the strong historical context and the premise of the novel, I鈥檇 expected to enjoy this novel more than I actually did. Overall, while l did not dislike The Women, I can鈥檛 help feeling a tad disappointed with certain aspects of the story. However, many have enjoyed this novel more and I would request you to read those reviews before deciding on whether to read this one.
Many thanks to St. Martin's Press for the digital review copy via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The Women was published on February 06, 2024.
Connect with me! 鉁� 鉁� 鉁�
The Women by Kristin Hannah follows twenty-one-year-old Frances 鈥淔rankie鈥� Grace McGrath, a sheltered young woman from an affluent family, who enlisted as a nurse during the Vietnam War. The narrative follows Frankie through the years of the war and the decades that follow.
There is a lot to like about this novel. The author writes with compassion and the narrative flows well. The fact that the author wanted to tell the story of the women who served in the Vietnam War, giving those whose contributions have been ignored a voice, renders this novel remarkable in its scope and intention. I loved how the author describes the camaraderie between friends and colleagues, their support for one another, the resilience, compassion and bravery of the women who served and the sacrifices they made. I also liked how the author incorporated the public outcry and protests back home - the mixed feelings about the war and those who served and the politics of the time - into the narrative. The author鈥檚 unflinching depiction of PTSD and how so many people could not find the help they needed to cope with the trauma they carried back home was heartbreaking was realistic and thought-provoking as were the descriptions of the horrors of war (some of which were more than a little difficult to read). Despite the story being set in years of the Vietnam War and its aftermath, the issues that she has raised are both crucial and relevant even in today鈥檚 world.
Unfortunately, there are a few issues that prevent me from giving this novel a higher rating. I was invested in Frankie鈥檚 journey and was eager to see how she evolved from a privileged young woman whose sheltered upbringing could not have prepared her for what she would have to endure. The weak character development, the focus on her love life, and the stereotypical and slightly disrespectful representation of the men (with whom she gets romantically involved) who serve their country did not make for pleasant reading and detracted from the overall experience. The ending was poignant, but again, the author鈥檚 choice to provide a 鈥渉appy鈥� (melodramatic) ending lessened the overall impact.
Both Ethel and Barb were well thought out characters ( in fact, I found them more interesting than Frankie). Though we do get to know their stories in segments interspersed throughout the novel, mostly through Frankie鈥檚 interactions with them, I feel the author has missed an opportunity to further enrich the narrative. In my humble opinion, focusing on one woman鈥檚 perspective and relegating the other characters to supporting roles, defeats the purpose of this novel. All three women, each with their distinct convictions and motivations, deserved to have their voices woven into the narrative. The perspectives of all three of these women from diverse backgrounds, each of whom embark on their respective journeys facing their own set of challenges, would have provided much-needed depth to the narrative.
Given the strong historical context and the premise of the novel, I鈥檇 expected to enjoy this novel more than I actually did. Overall, while l did not dislike The Women, I can鈥檛 help feeling a tad disappointed with certain aspects of the story. However, many have enjoyed this novel more and I would request you to read those reviews before deciding on whether to read this one.
Many thanks to St. Martin's Press for the digital review copy via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The Women was published on February 06, 2024.
Connect with me! 鉁� 鉁� 鉁�
July 4, 2024
Five stars with a minor quibble
It鈥檚 a fine art to write a story that immediately immerses the reader in a different world. Once again, Hannah has done it with The Women. I felt I was right there with Frankie, a new nurse in Vietnam. My heart was beating just as quickly as hers, feeling just as helpless, questioning the decision that brought her there. She鈥檚 quickly forced out of her comfort zone, having to take on responsibilities she never imagined. Hannah gets the immediacy of the relationships, how quickly they become deep. But just as quickly dear friends are gone, hopefully because they鈥檝e fulfilled their obligations. Other times, because they鈥檝e died.
I hadn鈥檛 realized how few of the nurses in Vietnam were women. She is one of only nine female nurses at the triage hospital where she鈥檚 initially sent. I also hadn鈥檛 realized how their very presence in Vietnam was denied. Frankie is repeatedly told 鈥渢here were no women in Vietnam鈥�.
The second half of the story tackles Frankie鈥檚 return to the States. Again, Hannah does a great job presenting the PTSD, the failure to recognize her service, the protests, especially the Veteran protests. My one quibble was that the romance part of the story started coming across as more soap opera than real.
This one grabbed me and never let me go. I was finding all sorts of reasons to continue to read/listen to this. I finished this 15 hour book in two days.
The story is incredibly well researched. Right down to the little things, like nurses not being allowed to wear pantyhose with their dress uniform but forced to wear a girdle and hose. Or how prevalent rats were. I am curious to know if studies back up the idea that the Vietnam vets suffered more PTSD because their service, unlike other war time vets, was not acknowledged - that they weren鈥檛 lauded when they returned home, that they were forced to keep silent about their experiences.
The audio book was narrated by Julia Whelan who did a fabulous job. She truly enhanced the story.
My thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin鈥檚 Press and Macmillan Audio for an advance copy of this book.
It鈥檚 a fine art to write a story that immediately immerses the reader in a different world. Once again, Hannah has done it with The Women. I felt I was right there with Frankie, a new nurse in Vietnam. My heart was beating just as quickly as hers, feeling just as helpless, questioning the decision that brought her there. She鈥檚 quickly forced out of her comfort zone, having to take on responsibilities she never imagined. Hannah gets the immediacy of the relationships, how quickly they become deep. But just as quickly dear friends are gone, hopefully because they鈥檝e fulfilled their obligations. Other times, because they鈥檝e died.
I hadn鈥檛 realized how few of the nurses in Vietnam were women. She is one of only nine female nurses at the triage hospital where she鈥檚 initially sent. I also hadn鈥檛 realized how their very presence in Vietnam was denied. Frankie is repeatedly told 鈥渢here were no women in Vietnam鈥�.
The second half of the story tackles Frankie鈥檚 return to the States. Again, Hannah does a great job presenting the PTSD, the failure to recognize her service, the protests, especially the Veteran protests. My one quibble was that the romance part of the story started coming across as more soap opera than real.
This one grabbed me and never let me go. I was finding all sorts of reasons to continue to read/listen to this. I finished this 15 hour book in two days.
The story is incredibly well researched. Right down to the little things, like nurses not being allowed to wear pantyhose with their dress uniform but forced to wear a girdle and hose. Or how prevalent rats were. I am curious to know if studies back up the idea that the Vietnam vets suffered more PTSD because their service, unlike other war time vets, was not acknowledged - that they weren鈥檛 lauded when they returned home, that they were forced to keep silent about their experiences.
The audio book was narrated by Julia Whelan who did a fabulous job. She truly enhanced the story.
My thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin鈥檚 Press and Macmillan Audio for an advance copy of this book.
February 12, 2024
It鈥檚 perfect.
馃槶馃槶馃槶馃槶馃槶
馃槶馃槶馃槶馃槶馃槶
May 13, 2024
鈥淭he women had a story to tell, even if the world wasn't quite yet ready to hear it, and their story began with three simple words. We were there.鈥�
Kristen Hannah is quickly becoming my favorite author. This is my third book by her and she is a wonderful storyteller. She knows how to captivate her audience.
鈥淭hat was the starting and ending point in life: love. The journey was everything in between.鈥�
In The Women you follow Frankie who is combat nurse durning The Vietnam War. She tells her story about her time before and after the war.
鈥淭hank God for girlfriends. In this crazy, chaotic, divided world that was run by men, you could count on the women.鈥�
I LOVED this book so much. I learned so much about the Vietnam War. Kristen had me googling info like I was back in High School and honestly I loved it. This book is more than just a war story. It captures female friendships, ptsd representation a world we used to live in not too long ago. I loved how much music was mentioned in this book as well. That time era I think had the best Rock N Roll so I loved to see it get the recognition it deserved.
I have like 300 quotes from this book that will stay with me for a lifetime.
鈥淢aybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. Happy forever seems a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鈥�
The Nightingale- 4.5 猸愶笍
The Great Alone- 5 猸愶笍
The Women- 5 猸愶笍
鈥淲e were the last believers, my generation. We trusted what our parents taught us about right and wrong, good and evil, the American myth of equality and justice and honor. I wonder if any generation will ever believe again. People will say it was the war that shattered our lives and laid bare the beautiful lie we鈥檇 been taught. And they鈥檇 be right. And wrong. There was so much more. It鈥檚 hard to see clearly when the world is angry and divided and you鈥檙e being lied to.鈥�
Playlist
馃幎Like A Rolling Stone- Bob Dylan
馃幎Jockerman- Bob Dylan
馃幎Fortunate Son- Creeedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Free Bird- Lynyrd Skynyrd
馃幎Have You Ever Seen The Rain- Creedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Stand By Me- Ben E King
馃幎Daniel- Elton John
馃幎Oh, Pretty Woman- Roy Orbison
馃幎Stairway To Heaven- Led Zeppelin
馃幎American Pie- Don Mclean
馃幎Unchained Melody- The Righteous Brothers
馃幎Brown Eyed Girl- Van Morrison
馃幎Bad Moon Rising- Creedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Simple Man- Lynyrd Skynyrd
馃幎I Can See Clearly Now- Johnny Nash
馃幎With A Little Help From My Friends- Joe Cocker
馃幎Here Comes The Sun- The Beatles
Thanks for Buddy Reading with me, I had a great time crying and screaming haha PalmPages 馃槶馃挅
Kristen Hannah is quickly becoming my favorite author. This is my third book by her and she is a wonderful storyteller. She knows how to captivate her audience.
鈥淭hat was the starting and ending point in life: love. The journey was everything in between.鈥�
In The Women you follow Frankie who is combat nurse durning The Vietnam War. She tells her story about her time before and after the war.
鈥淭hank God for girlfriends. In this crazy, chaotic, divided world that was run by men, you could count on the women.鈥�
I LOVED this book so much. I learned so much about the Vietnam War. Kristen had me googling info like I was back in High School and honestly I loved it. This book is more than just a war story. It captures female friendships, ptsd representation a world we used to live in not too long ago. I loved how much music was mentioned in this book as well. That time era I think had the best Rock N Roll so I loved to see it get the recognition it deserved.
I have like 300 quotes from this book that will stay with me for a lifetime.
鈥淢aybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we really get. Happy forever seems a shitload to ask in a world on fire.鈥�
The Nightingale- 4.5 猸愶笍
The Great Alone- 5 猸愶笍
The Women- 5 猸愶笍
鈥淲e were the last believers, my generation. We trusted what our parents taught us about right and wrong, good and evil, the American myth of equality and justice and honor. I wonder if any generation will ever believe again. People will say it was the war that shattered our lives and laid bare the beautiful lie we鈥檇 been taught. And they鈥檇 be right. And wrong. There was so much more. It鈥檚 hard to see clearly when the world is angry and divided and you鈥檙e being lied to.鈥�
Playlist
馃幎Like A Rolling Stone- Bob Dylan
馃幎Jockerman- Bob Dylan
馃幎Fortunate Son- Creeedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Free Bird- Lynyrd Skynyrd
馃幎Have You Ever Seen The Rain- Creedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Stand By Me- Ben E King
馃幎Daniel- Elton John
馃幎Oh, Pretty Woman- Roy Orbison
馃幎Stairway To Heaven- Led Zeppelin
馃幎American Pie- Don Mclean
馃幎Unchained Melody- The Righteous Brothers
馃幎Brown Eyed Girl- Van Morrison
馃幎Bad Moon Rising- Creedence Clearwater Revival
馃幎Simple Man- Lynyrd Skynyrd
馃幎I Can See Clearly Now- Johnny Nash
馃幎With A Little Help From My Friends- Joe Cocker
馃幎Here Comes The Sun- The Beatles
Thanks for Buddy Reading with me, I had a great time crying and screaming haha PalmPages 馃槶馃挅
December 11, 2023
Kristin Hannah's upcoming release, The Women, left me in a severe love-hate conundrum. I can only give it three stars, an average of the five stars it deserves for the parts set in Vietnam and the one star it deserves for the backstories and romances.
I loved the section of the book set in Vietnam. This part of the book was well-researched, action-packed, and took me as close as I wanted to be to a combat medical evacuation unit. Vietnam War literature has not covered the nurse's perspective much, so I especially valued this content. The Vietnam writing was gritty and sometimes challenging to read but written very well (trigger warnings for some readers, though, so be forewarned).
However, the book chapters preceding Frankie's tour in Vietnam were slow and plodding. Frankie seemed devoid of personality - a cardboard caricature of "the good girl." I came close to DNFing the book before it even took off. The last half of this overly long book covered Frankie's return home and her struggles with PTSD. Aspects of these sections had decent content, covering the abysmal treatment of returning vets, the complete dismissal of women serving in combat zones, and the range of issues Vietnam Vets had adapting to life back home.
All good, but then there were the intertwined romances and backstories, and these were, in my opinion, just horrible. I've watched soap operas with more feasible plot lines. I don't want to include spoilers, but there were way too many times I rolled my eyes in dismay. It wasn't even that the romance aspect was too swoony (people familiar with my reviews know I have a low tolerance for swooniness), but the plot devolved into the ludicrous. The ridiculousness of some of the events in Frankie's relationships detracted from the seriousness of the rest of the story. Given the book was almost 500 pages long, much of this could have (should have) been edited out.
Some details in the book's second half would have benefitted from better research. As written, they detracted from the good parts of the story and came off as just plain lazy. It's small stuff, but it piled up and was sometimes so frustrating I wanted to give up reading. Here are a few of my issues (that won't give away the plot). First, one nurse friend wants to be a veterinarian. OK, good for her, but in the late 1960s, few women were getting into vet school and, indeed, were mostly blocked from becoming large animal vets as this woman aspired to (I am a veterinarian, and vet school did not open broadly to women until the early 1980s). So this friend comes home from her tour in, I think, March and enrolls in vet school during the middle of the school year because, of course, a nurse can just do that without taking any prerequisites or entrance exams or even applying. Then this same friend, more than once, drops everything, including vet school, to fly out at the last minute and spend weeks helping Frankie, who is dealing with one melodramatic romantic crisis after another. Because you can do that in the middle of vet school with no apparent repercussions. This isn't the vet school I remember. And what regular folks just flew around the country on a whim in the 1960s? Flying was a big deal then, not done on a day's notice. Later in the book, a character living in rural Montana decides to become a clinical psychologist and does so while living in rural Montana because they have so many clinical psychology programs (yes, this is sarcasm).
I understand I am an outlier here, but I'm also not alone in my criticisms of the non-Vietnam aspects of the novel. You'll enjoy the book if melodrama, lack of historical accuracy, and telenovela-level romances don't bother you.
Thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an eBook version of the novel in return for a review.
I loved the section of the book set in Vietnam. This part of the book was well-researched, action-packed, and took me as close as I wanted to be to a combat medical evacuation unit. Vietnam War literature has not covered the nurse's perspective much, so I especially valued this content. The Vietnam writing was gritty and sometimes challenging to read but written very well (trigger warnings for some readers, though, so be forewarned).
However, the book chapters preceding Frankie's tour in Vietnam were slow and plodding. Frankie seemed devoid of personality - a cardboard caricature of "the good girl." I came close to DNFing the book before it even took off. The last half of this overly long book covered Frankie's return home and her struggles with PTSD. Aspects of these sections had decent content, covering the abysmal treatment of returning vets, the complete dismissal of women serving in combat zones, and the range of issues Vietnam Vets had adapting to life back home.
All good, but then there were the intertwined romances and backstories, and these were, in my opinion, just horrible. I've watched soap operas with more feasible plot lines. I don't want to include spoilers, but there were way too many times I rolled my eyes in dismay. It wasn't even that the romance aspect was too swoony (people familiar with my reviews know I have a low tolerance for swooniness), but the plot devolved into the ludicrous. The ridiculousness of some of the events in Frankie's relationships detracted from the seriousness of the rest of the story. Given the book was almost 500 pages long, much of this could have (should have) been edited out.
Some details in the book's second half would have benefitted from better research. As written, they detracted from the good parts of the story and came off as just plain lazy. It's small stuff, but it piled up and was sometimes so frustrating I wanted to give up reading. Here are a few of my issues (that won't give away the plot). First, one nurse friend wants to be a veterinarian. OK, good for her, but in the late 1960s, few women were getting into vet school and, indeed, were mostly blocked from becoming large animal vets as this woman aspired to (I am a veterinarian, and vet school did not open broadly to women until the early 1980s). So this friend comes home from her tour in, I think, March and enrolls in vet school during the middle of the school year because, of course, a nurse can just do that without taking any prerequisites or entrance exams or even applying. Then this same friend, more than once, drops everything, including vet school, to fly out at the last minute and spend weeks helping Frankie, who is dealing with one melodramatic romantic crisis after another. Because you can do that in the middle of vet school with no apparent repercussions. This isn't the vet school I remember. And what regular folks just flew around the country on a whim in the 1960s? Flying was a big deal then, not done on a day's notice. Later in the book, a character living in rural Montana decides to become a clinical psychologist and does so while living in rural Montana because they have so many clinical psychology programs (yes, this is sarcasm).
I understand I am an outlier here, but I'm also not alone in my criticisms of the non-Vietnam aspects of the novel. You'll enjoy the book if melodrama, lack of historical accuracy, and telenovela-level romances don't bother you.
Thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an eBook version of the novel in return for a review.
![Profile Image for laurel [the suspected bibliophile].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1645808644i%2F7494844._UX200_CR0%2C6%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
June 7, 2024
Saccharine sweet drivel.
Like a Hallmark movie with the tear-jerkers amped up to one million.
Seriously. This was every single steaming Vietnam veteran stereotype and 1960s cliche shat into a heaping pile of excrement and left to chill overnight. Stinky and unpleasantly cold and squishy when you try to pick it up the next morning.
The writing is shit. All tell, absolutely no show. The foreshadowing is a constant palm strike to the face. It is trying way too hard to be legit, and it's super duper obvious Hannah is not a vet, because while she did a shit ton of research and wants the reader to know that, there are small things that are just...obnoxiously bad.
If you want to read about women serving in Vietnam and are dying to read a fiction book and not one of the handful (so few!) memoirs, do yourself a favor and read * instead.
Here are nonfiction books about military women in Vietnam I recommend instead of this book:
*I think one of the reasons I'm SO salty about this book is because it kinda rips off the plot of The Road Home (the basics, anyways). Like, I cannot tell you how few original ideas The Women contains. When I say that it has every single Vietnam War stereotype in existence mashed into one book, I am not lying, served with a heaping side of white saviorism.
Like a Hallmark movie with the tear-jerkers amped up to one million.
Seriously. This was every single steaming Vietnam veteran stereotype and 1960s cliche shat into a heaping pile of excrement and left to chill overnight. Stinky and unpleasantly cold and squishy when you try to pick it up the next morning.
The writing is shit. All tell, absolutely no show. The foreshadowing is a constant palm strike to the face. It is trying way too hard to be legit, and it's super duper obvious Hannah is not a vet, because while she did a shit ton of research and wants the reader to know that, there are small things that are just...obnoxiously bad.
If you want to read about women serving in Vietnam and are dying to read a fiction book and not one of the handful (so few!) memoirs, do yourself a favor and read * instead.
Here are nonfiction books about military women in Vietnam I recommend instead of this book:
*I think one of the reasons I'm SO salty about this book is because it kinda rips off the plot of The Road Home (the basics, anyways). Like, I cannot tell you how few original ideas The Women contains. When I say that it has every single Vietnam War stereotype in existence mashed into one book, I am not lying, served with a heaping side of white saviorism.
December 1, 2024
This book changed my life (no shock)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129,211 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.