What do you think?
Rate this book
袧褨泻芯谢懈 薪械 斜褉械褕懈
袉薪芯写褨 锌褉邪胁写邪 胁斜懈胁邪褦.. 校 锌芯褕褍泻邪褏 斜褍写懈薪泻褍 褋胁芯褦褩 屑褉褨褩 屑芯谢芯写褟褌邪 孝褉褨褋褨褟 褌邪 袝泄褌邪薪 芯锌懈薪褟褞褌褜褋褟 胁 褉芯蟹泻褨褕薪芯屑褍 屑邪褦褌泻褍 薪邪 袣械写褉芯胁褨泄 袗谢械褩, 胁懈褋褌邪胁谢械薪芯屑褍 薪邪 锌褉芯写邪卸. 袨谐谢褟写邪褞褔懈 泻褨屑薪邪褌懈, 胁芯薪懈 褉芯蟹褍屑褨褞褌褜, 褖芯 褋邪屑械 褌褍褌 卸懈谢邪 写芯泻褌芯褉泻邪 袗写褉褨邪薪邪 袚械泄谢, 胁褨写芯屑邪 褎邪褏褨胁褔懈薪褟 蟹 锌褋懈褏褨邪褌褉褨褩, 褟泻邪 蟹邪谐邪写泻芯胁芯 蟹薪懈泻谢邪 屑邪泄卸械 褔芯褌懈褉懈 褉芯泻懈 褌芯屑褍. 校 锌芯褕褍泻邪褏 褉芯蟹胁邪谐懈 褔懈 斜芯写邪泄 褟泻芯褩褋褜 泻薪懈卸泻懈 孝褉褨褋褨褟 薪邪褌褉邪锌谢褟褦 薪邪 褌邪褦屑薪褍 泻褨屑薪邪褌褍, 写械 蟹斜械褉褨谐邪褞褌褜褋褟 邪褍写褨芯蟹邪锌懈褋懈 褉芯蟹屑芯胁 写芯泻褌芯褉泻懈 袚械泄谢 蟹 褍褋褨屑邪 锌邪褑褨褦薪褌邪屑懈. 袙懈褉褨褕懈胁褕懈 锌芯褋谢褍褏邪褌懈 褩褏, 泻邪褋械褌邪 蟹邪 泻邪褋械褌芯褞, 胁芯薪邪 薪械芯褔褨泻褍胁邪薪芯 写褨蟹薪邪褦褌褜褋褟 锌褉芯 薪懈蟹泻褍 锌芯写褨泄, 褟泻褨 锌械褉械写褍胁邪谢懈 蟹薪懈泻薪械薪薪褞 锌褋懈褏褨邪褌褉懈薪褨. 些芯褋褜 卸邪褏谢懈胁械 褋褌邪谢芯褋褟 胁 褑褜芯屑褍 斜褍写懈薪泻褍鈥�
304 pages, Hardcover
First published September 19, 2022
78391 people are currently reading
563202 people want to read
About the author
Freida McFadden
50听books186k听followers#1 New York Times, USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Publisher's Weekly, and Amazon Charts bestselling author Freida McFadden is a practicing physician specializing in brain injury who has penned multiple Kindle bestselling psychological thrillers and medical humor novels. She lives with her family and possessed cat in a centuries-old three-story home overlooking the ocean, with staircases that creak and moan with each step, and nobody could hear you if you scream. Unless you scream really loudly, maybe.
Note that I am maxed out on friends, so I apologize in advance that I can't friend anyone back!
Note that I am maxed out on friends, so I apologize in advance that I can't friend anyone back!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96,096 reviews
February 22, 2024
I read this as part of a group buddy read on Instagram which is why I didn't yeet it into outer space.
One sentence review: L M F A O you're joking
SYNOPSIS
Newlyweds Tricia and Ethan are snowed in during their viewing at the creepy, dusty, secluded mcmansion once owned by Dr. Adrienne Hale, who mysteriously disappeared without a trace four years ago. When Tricia finds her secret tapes of her sessions, she starts listening to get to the bottom of the doctor's disappearance.
MY OPINION
BUCKLE TF UP. THIS IS ABOUT TO BE A LONG ONE.
Where to start, where to start? Ok let's do the writing. I truly believe there are sixth graders who can write more compelling sentences. Here's an excerpt that nearly gave me an aneurysm:
But my attention goes back to that white cashmere sweater I had been slobbering over last night. I love cashmere. I mean, everyone does. What sort of freak doesn鈥檛 like cashmere? And the sweater is so white. Like unblemished snow. I grab the sweater and pull it off the hanger. I throw it over my head, almost groaning in ecstasy at how nice the fabric feels against my skin. I love cashmere.
I wish I was joking. Yep, she writes "I love cashmere" twice in a matter of sentences. I was almost hoping the cashmere was going to be laced with some kind of toxin that would kill Tricia and her four brain cells just so something interesting could happen, but nah, homegirl just looooooOOOOves cashmere.
Then we have the aggressive spoon-feeding. I felt like I was being choked to death with the flashing neon sign foreshadowing that Freida deployed. Here's a sample:
I don鈥檛 know why my friends don鈥檛 like him. Whenever we talk about him, they always say, this is a red flag, or that鈥檚 a red flag. But Ethan is a genuinely good guy. What does it matter that he hasn鈥檛 had many girlfriends before me? And why should the fact that he lost his parents and doesn鈥檛 have much family be a reason I should avoid him?
The author repeats this train of thought so many times that even Ray Charles could see what was coming.
Next, we have the "click baity writing" where the author mentions a secret (in this case, many, many times) but won't reveal the secret until much later in a lazy attempt to create suspense. See: I hope he still feels that way after what I have to tell him this weekend. I have a terrible feeling that the conversation will not go well.
Ok and if by the grace of Beyonce you can get past this amateur hour writing, the characters are asstastic and plot has more holes than a cheese grater. Yes, yes, I know this is a popcorn thriller, so yeetage of disbelief is required. But I refuse to yeet my logic just for some Hallmark-grade entertainment. And once again, stop inserting "intelligent" and "highly educated" psychiatrists into these books if they're gonna have the logic of a bloated dead fish. Just stick with the naive mom of three who works in a craft store.
SPOILERS SO SCROLL TO THE BOTTOM
At first Freida makes sure we know the house is very dusty, much dust, dust everywhere. And this dustiness grosses Tricia out because it totally clashes with Ethan's BMW (it's not a car, it's a BMW), her Manolo Blahnik boots and Ralph Lauren wool coat. But then she's okay with sleeping in her undies and bra in a bed that has been empty for THREE years?? And puts on a dead woman's RED FUZZY ROBE AND SLIPPERS?????? The real mystery is how the house was selectively dusty.
Another one of my pet peeves is the unreliable narrator that lies for funsies, which of course we have in this shitshow of a book. Surprise, Tricia actually has a history with the house even though the readers are led to believe she's shooketh. And she had been stalking Ethan beforehand. Now why did she lie about these things? No reason, just trying to force a twist where there isn't one.
Tricia's behaviour doesn't even make sense. So homegirl comes back to the house to find the bodyodyody that Dr. Hale left in the house (need that chemical spray she ordered off Amazon for my dog's bed tbh) but instead of searching the house, she decides to listen to recorded sessions... for what? Was she hoping that EJ would say "hey, if you decide to murk me, can you bury me under your living room floor??? Tysm." Priorities!!!!! This would've made more sense if ETHAN listened to the tapes and then put 2+2 = Tricia is a crazy bish together.
Lastly, tell me how Tricia can get away with murdering nearly ten people that are all intimately known to her. So her grammy and fiance and besties all die and no one bats an eye? Even Detective Pikachu could make the connections. Cmon now.
Ok, I'm going to cut myself off, but overall, this book was STANKY. I've read two others by her: The Locked Door was ight and The Housemaid was not ight in the slightest. Adding her to my avoid list lol.
PROS AND CONS
Pros: funny rants with the buddy readers, she did have some good red herrings in there tbh
Cons: ... did I stutter? 馃槀
___
October 14, 2024
4/5 鈽呪€檚
鈦赌鉃� everybody lies.
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
i鈥檝e never had so many trust issues in my life. freida鈥dk how you do it. i seriously want to crawl inside this woman鈥檚 head, but i fear i鈥檇 lose my mind within the first hour of living in there. freida is my go-to author when i want to get out of a reading slump because all of the books i read by her so far鈥鈥檝e read in less than 7 hours. once you start, you can鈥檛 stop. since it鈥檚 so hard to write a spoiler free review for a mystery/thriller, i鈥檓 going to keep it short and sweet馃き
鉂� 饾搨饾搸 饾搲饾捊饾憸饾搳饾憯饾捊饾搲饾搱:
my rating for this book went from a 2.5 to a 4 star rating after reading the last 100 pages of the book. my only reasoning for the possible 2.5 rating was simply because i thought i knew everything going on. i thought i finally had freida鈥檚 mind figured out. i was so excited, but at the same time was bothered because i was thinking that if all my theories i had were right鈥hen it was all pretty predictable. i seriously thought i ate and left no crumbs, turns out i was missing my mouth the entire time and left a complete mess馃榾
鉂� 饾搮饾搧饾憸饾搲:
the plot was plotting鈥ompletely plotting against me. freida鈥檚 plots: 3. me: 0. why 3 you ask? because i read 3 of her books and freida made a fool out of me 3 times. the setting of the book was aaaaaaa so good!!! gave all the spooky vibes and i loved it. the best way to go into a mystery/thriller is completely blind, i promise it gives you the best experience. the plot twist鈥 would seriously like to know who saw that one coming because it sure as hell wasn鈥檛 me. the way my jaw dropped. freida really said fuck you and your theories and i was like okay slay. the only thing i can trust freida to do is write a good plot and i can鈥檛 wait to read the rest of her books. the more books of hers i read, the more i鈥檒l have her like figured out鈥�*nervously laughs* right?? freida if she read this: wrong bitch.
鉂� 饾搶饾搰饾捑饾搲饾捑饾搩饾憯:
the writing is so descriptive and i just can鈥檛 get enough of it. the chapters are short, the writing is really easy to read/follow, and her books are just overall really fast paced. you鈥檒l be on page one, blink, and then all of a sudden you鈥檙e closing the book with your jaw on the floor. i always get chills while reading a freida book and that鈥檚 the power of a well written story.
鉂� 饾捀饾捊饾挾饾搰饾挾饾捀饾搲饾憭饾搰饾搱:
my main reason for not being able to give this book 5 stars. i just didn鈥檛 really have a connection to any of the characters鈥hile the plot was amazing, the characters were just meh. there鈥檚 two in particular that i really couldn鈥檛 stand. it was just the things they鈥檇 do or say that had me like鈥lease close your mouth and never open it again馃檪i鈥檓 definitely comparing these characters to the one鈥檚 in the housemaid by freida. i has such a strong connection with the fmc, millie, and didn鈥檛 feel that kind of connection with any character here.
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
10/10 recommend reading this book if you鈥檙e a fan of mystery/thrillers that鈥檒l have you wowed at the end.
the only way two people can keep a secret is if one of them is dead.
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
鉂�03/05/24
饾搮饾搰饾憭 饾搰饾憭饾搵饾捑饾憭饾搶:
i told shei every single theory of mine and was wrong about every single one of them. THAT IS SO EMBARRASSING. i鈥檓 embarrassed. i thought i ate馃様
i finished this book in 4 hours and 29 minutes. i鈥檓 flabbergasted. rtc soon!
鉂� 02/25/24
my baby shei told me this was her favorite freida book and i trust her with my entire being馃ス馃馃徏
鈦赌鉃� everybody lies.
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
饾摷饾摴饾摳饾摬饾摰饾摦饾摶 饾摨饾摶饾摦饾摦 饾摶饾摦饾摽饾摬饾摦饾攢
i鈥檝e never had so many trust issues in my life. freida鈥dk how you do it. i seriously want to crawl inside this woman鈥檚 head, but i fear i鈥檇 lose my mind within the first hour of living in there. freida is my go-to author when i want to get out of a reading slump because all of the books i read by her so far鈥鈥檝e read in less than 7 hours. once you start, you can鈥檛 stop. since it鈥檚 so hard to write a spoiler free review for a mystery/thriller, i鈥檓 going to keep it short and sweet馃き
鉂� 饾搨饾搸 饾搲饾捊饾憸饾搳饾憯饾捊饾搲饾搱:
my rating for this book went from a 2.5 to a 4 star rating after reading the last 100 pages of the book. my only reasoning for the possible 2.5 rating was simply because i thought i knew everything going on. i thought i finally had freida鈥檚 mind figured out. i was so excited, but at the same time was bothered because i was thinking that if all my theories i had were right鈥hen it was all pretty predictable. i seriously thought i ate and left no crumbs, turns out i was missing my mouth the entire time and left a complete mess馃榾
鉂� 饾搮饾搧饾憸饾搲:
the plot was plotting鈥ompletely plotting against me. freida鈥檚 plots: 3. me: 0. why 3 you ask? because i read 3 of her books and freida made a fool out of me 3 times. the setting of the book was aaaaaaa so good!!! gave all the spooky vibes and i loved it. the best way to go into a mystery/thriller is completely blind, i promise it gives you the best experience. the plot twist鈥 would seriously like to know who saw that one coming because it sure as hell wasn鈥檛 me. the way my jaw dropped. freida really said fuck you and your theories and i was like okay slay. the only thing i can trust freida to do is write a good plot and i can鈥檛 wait to read the rest of her books. the more books of hers i read, the more i鈥檒l have her like figured out鈥�*nervously laughs* right?? freida if she read this: wrong bitch.
鉂� 饾搶饾搰饾捑饾搲饾捑饾搩饾憯:
the writing is so descriptive and i just can鈥檛 get enough of it. the chapters are short, the writing is really easy to read/follow, and her books are just overall really fast paced. you鈥檒l be on page one, blink, and then all of a sudden you鈥檙e closing the book with your jaw on the floor. i always get chills while reading a freida book and that鈥檚 the power of a well written story.
鉂� 饾捀饾捊饾挾饾搰饾挾饾捀饾搲饾憭饾搰饾搱:
my main reason for not being able to give this book 5 stars. i just didn鈥檛 really have a connection to any of the characters鈥hile the plot was amazing, the characters were just meh. there鈥檚 two in particular that i really couldn鈥檛 stand. it was just the things they鈥檇 do or say that had me like鈥lease close your mouth and never open it again馃檪i鈥檓 definitely comparing these characters to the one鈥檚 in the housemaid by freida. i has such a strong connection with the fmc, millie, and didn鈥檛 feel that kind of connection with any character here.
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
10/10 recommend reading this book if you鈥檙e a fan of mystery/thrillers that鈥檒l have you wowed at the end.
the only way two people can keep a secret is if one of them is dead.
猡穙kay pretty little liars, pop off馃拝馃徏
掳鉂赌鈰�.喑冟繑*:锝ワ渐:*.喑冟繑鈰嗏潃掳
鉂�03/05/24
饾搮饾搰饾憭 饾搰饾憭饾搵饾捑饾憭饾搶:
i told shei every single theory of mine and was wrong about every single one of them. THAT IS SO EMBARRASSING. i鈥檓 embarrassed. i thought i ate馃様
i finished this book in 4 hours and 29 minutes. i鈥檓 flabbergasted. rtc soon!
鉂� 02/25/24
my baby shei told me this was her favorite freida book and i trust her with my entire being馃ス馃馃徏
October 22, 2022
What is with all these 4 star+ rated thrillers being so awful?
I mean, I get that this book is quite compelling, especially with the use of short chapters and the psychiatrist's tape recordings to keep the pacing up... but, come on, go back and reread the first few chapters after finishing this book and tell me the twist makes sense. Because it really doesn't.
So many people have recommended McFadden to me. I actually went and picked up this book and at the same time, but now I'm reluctant to start her other stuff because parts of this were laughably bad.
It's hard to say which was the worst thing. The repetition of the same thing over and over?
The way the author hammered us over the head with a red herring to the point that I felt a little insulted?
Or the ludicrous twists that may have worked if this book had been written in third person, but in first person are utterly absurd?
Also, the author does this weird thing where a character will say something via dialogue, then the narrator will make an extremely obvious observation about it in their inner monologue. For example:
No shit! She does this multiple times.
In some ways, two stars feels generous, but then I did blast through this with a need to know what the hell was going on. Not many authors manage to keep the suspense going like that.
I mean, I get that this book is quite compelling, especially with the use of short chapters and the psychiatrist's tape recordings to keep the pacing up... but, come on, go back and reread the first few chapters after finishing this book and tell me the twist makes sense. Because it really doesn't.
So many people have recommended McFadden to me. I actually went and picked up this book and at the same time, but now I'm reluctant to start her other stuff because parts of this were laughably bad.
It's hard to say which was the worst thing. The repetition of the same thing over and over?
It was a worrying reminder of the fact that I鈥檝e only known my husband for a little over a year.
It鈥檚 yet another reminder that I鈥檝e only known this man for a little over a year.
The way the author hammered us over the head with a red herring to the point that I felt a little insulted?
Or the ludicrous twists that may have worked if this book had been written in third person, but in first person are utterly absurd?
Also, the author does this weird thing where a character will say something via dialogue, then the narrator will make an extremely obvious observation about it in their inner monologue. For example:
鈥淒on鈥檛 let him manipulate you,鈥� Ethan says. 鈥淗e isn鈥檛 a good person. He killed [spoiler]. He killed one of the people closest to him. What kind of person does that?鈥�
Ethan doesn鈥檛 have a clue that [spoiler] isn鈥檛 the one who killed [spoiler].
No shit! She does this multiple times.
In some ways, two stars feels generous, but then I did blast through this with a need to know what the hell was going on. Not many authors manage to keep the suspense going like that.
October 15, 2022
Ok, I鈥檓 an outlier based on the reviews so far. I don鈥檛 think the book is bad or not worth reading, it has the Freida trademark suspense vibe with a crazy twist. It actually reminded me a bit of one of her previous book that I also had trouble with for the same reason as this one. Without going into too much detail my problem was that the ending made some of the previous events unlikely. There were too many inconsistencies. The author was clever when it came to leading you in a direction that might or might not be the right one, but that is because some reactions should have been different based on what you learned later.
I also have an observation; Why did he go to work when they had no internet access in the house ?
I also have an observation; Why did he go to work when they had no internet access in the house ?
July 4, 2024
3.75 stars! Fun quick twisty easy read. I did not see the twist coming at all which was really fun. I also loved the dual timeline and dual pov. It felt like two stories in one! And it was cool to see the two stories come together. I also really liked that one of the main characters is a psychiatrist. It was really interesting to hear psychiatrist's fun facts and hear the stories of her patients. Definitely gave me the creeps at many points!
The only reason I didn't rate it higher is I've just read other thrillers I liked more and I didn't feel super attached to the characters. But! Overall a really fun twisty read. And the ending was so perfect and unpredictable.
The only reason I didn't rate it higher is I've just read other thrillers I liked more and I didn't feel super attached to the characters. But! Overall a really fun twisty read. And the ending was so perfect and unpredictable.
October 22, 2022
A book that could鈥檝e been so so good, if the author wasn鈥檛 desperate to throw in a twist that absolutely nobody could guess.
The only problem is - no one guessed it because it made no sense. If I read it again, knowing the twist, about 85% of the book wouldn鈥檛 add up.
Makes me feel like I just wasted my time reading this.
The only problem is - no one guessed it because it made no sense. If I read it again, knowing the twist, about 85% of the book wouldn鈥檛 add up.
Makes me feel like I just wasted my time reading this.
October 27, 2022
If you like horrible writing and a plot that makes no sense then this is for you
September 23, 2022
***5 STARS***
What a ride! I couldn鈥檛 put this book down until I read the last word.
Edge of your seat suspense! A captivating psychological thriller that has twists and turns galore. I thought I had it figured out but I was so wrong.
Very well written with an intricate plot and well developed characters. A must read.
What a ride! I couldn鈥檛 put this book down until I read the last word.
Edge of your seat suspense! A captivating psychological thriller that has twists and turns galore. I thought I had it figured out but I was so wrong.
Very well written with an intricate plot and well developed characters. A must read.
January 19, 2023
鈽� 1 star
Absurd.
Not to mention dry and tedious.
Anytime someone goes house shopping and set their eyes on the people-may-or-may-not-have-died-here-but-you-can-get-it-for-a-low-low-price-of-uhmm-say-your-eternal-soul it's a plot hole for sure.
It's also very possible that this was written by two people who had very different ideas. You write the intro and the middle and I'll do the ending then we'll call it a book! Exciting!
Did the writer actually read the first 200 pages before she published it? 鈥攁sking for a friend.
This book's saving grace is that these two dysfunctional human beings ended up together, saving the world from their chaos. Well done, they deserve each other.
Also, in this economy I can totally understand the urgency to close on a real estate property on a steal price and 100% get on board with living in a mcmansion in the middle of nowhere even if it's with dead corpses.
鈥淓veryone dies eventually, right? So unless we buy a brand new house, you鈥檙e kind of guaranteed somebody has lived in it who鈥檚 now dead. So what?鈥�
It's a good financial move. I can totally respect that.
Poor writing. If this tried to be a read-it-again-for-a-different-story type of book, it failed. Mood setting is lousy. And I never appreciated the inner dialogues that just keeps on going in circles which only serves to make the characters look dumber but I get it, it does help fill the word count. For once, if the floor creaks I'd want someone to actually investigate and not be like 'it be like that sometimes', 'that's just how it be' or not dismiss it with 'maybe that's just 鈥� ', 'i guess it's 鈥�', if not, you best believe I'll be rooting for your character to dies first.
I don't know about you but when I read psychological thrillers I crave for my brain to be challenged! I want it to be engrossing enough that I analyze everything and actually care about what happens next.
I believe that precisely to be the hallmark of attentive reading/listening 鈥� it's when your audience comprehend the story enough that they are able to make solid assumptions and predictions as the story progresses. Don't you love it when you try to figure the mystery out? It's gratifying when you're right and incredibly disappointing when you don't. That in itself I think is a rewarding feeling as an author/creator/producer, to have your audience care about your work enough to be feel satisfaction in experiencing your stories/art. And I believe that is how the author and their readers communicate through the pages 鈥� forgive me for saying this but I believe that's the magic of books!
Unfortunately, some thriller writer have become so invested in surprising their audience 鈥� so many twist!, woahhh the twist!, wait for the twist!鈥� they try outmaneuver their audience that they messed up the story they had been building. This is exactly what happened here. Even worse is the story completely ignored earlier events and details to fit the twist into its narrative! That's just mean and disrespectful.
A good twist rewards the most attentive audience and while it's true that the most satisfying twist are the ones you figure out seconds before it's revealed, it's also imperative that the details and foreshadowing clicks into its place otherwise it's all just a big fat scam. As they say, the devil is in the detail.
It's dark-lite. Not exactly addictive. It's a psychological thriller by virtue of it being sensational. Popcorn thriller for sure.
Good thing it's short.
I rated it 2 star and I explained my whys in great details. Avid fans can be so rabid sometimes.
Edit: I was being generous by giving it a 2-star rating. It's a 0-star. I'm sorry but everything she puts out deteriorates my braincells from the cosmic amount of stupidity. Pure lazy stupid writing.
Absurd.
Not to mention dry and tedious.
Anytime someone goes house shopping and set their eyes on the people-may-or-may-not-have-died-here-but-you-can-get-it-for-a-low-low-price-of-uhmm-say-your-eternal-soul it's a plot hole for sure.
It's also very possible that this was written by two people who had very different ideas. You write the intro and the middle and I'll do the ending then we'll call it a book! Exciting!
Did the writer actually read the first 200 pages before she published it? 鈥攁sking for a friend.
This book's saving grace is that these two dysfunctional human beings ended up together, saving the world from their chaos. Well done, they deserve each other.
Also, in this economy I can totally understand the urgency to close on a real estate property on a steal price and 100% get on board with living in a mcmansion in the middle of nowhere even if it's with dead corpses.
鈥淓veryone dies eventually, right? So unless we buy a brand new house, you鈥檙e kind of guaranteed somebody has lived in it who鈥檚 now dead. So what?鈥�
It's a good financial move. I can totally respect that.
Poor writing. If this tried to be a read-it-again-for-a-different-story type of book, it failed. Mood setting is lousy. And I never appreciated the inner dialogues that just keeps on going in circles which only serves to make the characters look dumber but I get it, it does help fill the word count. For once, if the floor creaks I'd want someone to actually investigate and not be like 'it be like that sometimes', 'that's just how it be' or not dismiss it with 'maybe that's just 鈥� ', 'i guess it's 鈥�', if not, you best believe I'll be rooting for your character to dies first.
I don't know about you but when I read psychological thrillers I crave for my brain to be challenged! I want it to be engrossing enough that I analyze everything and actually care about what happens next.
I believe that precisely to be the hallmark of attentive reading/listening 鈥� it's when your audience comprehend the story enough that they are able to make solid assumptions and predictions as the story progresses. Don't you love it when you try to figure the mystery out? It's gratifying when you're right and incredibly disappointing when you don't. That in itself I think is a rewarding feeling as an author/creator/producer, to have your audience care about your work enough to be feel satisfaction in experiencing your stories/art. And I believe that is how the author and their readers communicate through the pages 鈥� forgive me for saying this but I believe that's the magic of books!
Unfortunately, some thriller writer have become so invested in surprising their audience 鈥� so many twist!, woahhh the twist!, wait for the twist!鈥� they try outmaneuver their audience that they messed up the story they had been building. This is exactly what happened here. Even worse is the story completely ignored earlier events and details to fit the twist into its narrative! That's just mean and disrespectful.
A good twist rewards the most attentive audience and while it's true that the most satisfying twist are the ones you figure out seconds before it's revealed, it's also imperative that the details and foreshadowing clicks into its place otherwise it's all just a big fat scam. As they say, the devil is in the detail.
It's dark-lite. Not exactly addictive. It's a psychological thriller by virtue of it being sensational. Popcorn thriller for sure.
Good thing it's short.
I rated it 2 star and I explained my whys in great details. Avid fans can be so rabid sometimes.
Edit: I was being generous by giving it a 2-star rating. It's a 0-star. I'm sorry but everything she puts out deteriorates my braincells from the cosmic amount of stupidity. Pure lazy stupid writing.
January 2, 2023
The problem I have with this book is that it's dishonest. If you reread it from the beginning, it doesn't make any sense. The MC is the killer and very familiar with the house, yet when reading from HER perspective in her own thoughts, she acts like she has never seen the house before and it's her first time inside it. Even though she gifted the painting to the psychiatrist, in her own head she acts like she's never seen it before. In her thoughts, she pretends to be suspicious of her own husband even though she knows his past and she also knows that she herself is the killer?
This is deceptive and lazy writing.
I gave it three stars because I couldn't put it down and read it in less than a day. However, I won't be reading any more books by this author. When I read a mystery/thriller/whodunit, I want the facts to add up in the end. This book has more plot holes than Swiss cheese.
This is deceptive and lazy writing.
I gave it three stars because I couldn't put it down and read it in less than a day. However, I won't be reading any more books by this author. When I read a mystery/thriller/whodunit, I want the facts to add up in the end. This book has more plot holes than Swiss cheese.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 5, 2023
This book makes me mad, it makes no sense and I don鈥檛 understand how the reviews are so high.
February 17, 2024
HOLLY SH*T!!! The ending ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! I had theories let me tell you, but THAT, UMMM WOW!! I ate that shit up and left no crumbs behind, NONE WHATSOEVER!
July 9, 2024
4.50!
Never lie imo is Freida McFadden's finest work because the way it managed to surprise me in a way that I had most definitely not expected and how well written it was for me + the level of enjoyment I got and how fast I finished it on one go. Just wow!! I really did not expect that twist and how everything tied up to it was 馃く
Tricia and Ethan were the two characters we follow, both of them marry after only knowing each other for 6 months and decide to move to house far away from the city which was previously owned by Adrienne Hale antoher main character in this book who's pov follows the events that took place before tricia and Ethan move in. I would say I was expecting so many people but I just couldn't get any right 馃槶 and the way the pov switched and how tricias emotions, dialogues and the way she acted was described was truly amazing.
The plot overall was very enjoyable because this was only 270 pages long but the way they alternated betweent he past and the present and the whole secret room with tapes scene and how every tape had a story and was explored in depth was amazing. The portrait scene was also so creepy 馃槶 + hiw Adrienne had a different story and how good it was and how everything intertwined together was amazing and ngl the atmosphere that this book created was 馃挴馃挴
Now SPOILERS AHEAD鈥硷笍
I was buddy reading this with Roxy and my first words to her were what kind of weird ass name is Tricia (sorry to anyone named Tricia) and she says thank god it's not named Patricia 馃槶馃槶馃槶 and the way Tricia was Patricia and she was also the one who killed everyone?? Like I did not see that coming, her being a murderer and killing Adrienne as well?? Wow! And the fact that I wanted to read this book again just to see how Tricia acted because the way she acted I was so sure that she was going to be the protagonist not the fucking antagonist. Also her husband also being a killer and them killing Adrienne's bf?? WOW 馃く馃槶 THIS BOOK WAS INSANE.
SPOILERS END鈥硷笍
Overall, one of the best thrillers that I've read!!
___
Continuing my buddy thriller marathon with Roxy. Super excited for this one because it has the best plot twist I heard. 馃槍
Never lie imo is Freida McFadden's finest work because the way it managed to surprise me in a way that I had most definitely not expected and how well written it was for me + the level of enjoyment I got and how fast I finished it on one go. Just wow!! I really did not expect that twist and how everything tied up to it was 馃く
Tricia and Ethan were the two characters we follow, both of them marry after only knowing each other for 6 months and decide to move to house far away from the city which was previously owned by Adrienne Hale antoher main character in this book who's pov follows the events that took place before tricia and Ethan move in. I would say I was expecting so many people but I just couldn't get any right 馃槶 and the way the pov switched and how tricias emotions, dialogues and the way she acted was described was truly amazing.
The plot overall was very enjoyable because this was only 270 pages long but the way they alternated betweent he past and the present and the whole secret room with tapes scene and how every tape had a story and was explored in depth was amazing. The portrait scene was also so creepy 馃槶 + hiw Adrienne had a different story and how good it was and how everything intertwined together was amazing and ngl the atmosphere that this book created was 馃挴馃挴
Now SPOILERS AHEAD鈥硷笍
I was buddy reading this with Roxy and my first words to her were what kind of weird ass name is Tricia (sorry to anyone named Tricia) and she says thank god it's not named Patricia 馃槶馃槶馃槶 and the way Tricia was Patricia and she was also the one who killed everyone?? Like I did not see that coming, her being a murderer and killing Adrienne as well?? Wow! And the fact that I wanted to read this book again just to see how Tricia acted because the way she acted I was so sure that she was going to be the protagonist not the fucking antagonist. Also her husband also being a killer and them killing Adrienne's bf?? WOW 馃く馃槶 THIS BOOK WAS INSANE.
SPOILERS END鈥硷笍
Overall, one of the best thrillers that I've read!!
___
Continuing my buddy thriller marathon with Roxy. Super excited for this one because it has the best plot twist I heard. 馃槍
July 4, 2023
if someone asks me why i have trust issues, i鈥檓 just gonna tell them to read this.
June 19, 2023
this is so stupid.
April 16, 2023
4.5 猸愶笍 FREIDA MCFADDEN CAN DO NO WRONG.
this is my fourth book by her in a week and i鈥檓 quite literally obsessed. idk what she puts in these but GIVE MEEE MOREEE.
that ending!!!!!!!!! i never saw any of this coming. obsessed.
this is my fourth book by her in a week and i鈥檓 quite literally obsessed. idk what she puts in these but GIVE MEEE MOREEE.
that ending!!!!!!!!! i never saw any of this coming. obsessed.
November 3, 2022
You can tell when an author seems to be trying to hit a specific word count. A lot of words like 鈥渋t鈥檚鈥� and 鈥渉asn鈥檛鈥� become 鈥渋t is鈥� and 鈥渉as not鈥� and so on. It makes it feel very choppy. Also why do we need entire paragraphs describing turning on a light or other mundane things? Lol 鈥here were also many repetitive inner dialogues. At one point the characters inner dialogue said 鈥渢his room is about the size of a walk in closet鈥� 鈥� then two paragraphs later says 鈥淚 was right about the size of the room, it鈥檚 about the size of a walk in closet鈥� 鈥nother paragraph describing a bathtub and letting us know it had separate handles for hot and cold. Suffering through overly explaining the use of putting a tape in a cassette player, 鈥淚 blow some dust off the tape recorder, then I pick up the tape I found. I remove the tape from the case and shake it out, then slide it into the tape deck. With one quick movement, I push the tape deck closed鈥� 鈥t just gives the vibe of trying to hit a specific word count rather than tell a story that flows.
And how many times do we have to hear her tell us her friends think her husband she married that she barely knew has red flags but they are clearly wrong because he鈥檚 just 鈥渟o sweet鈥�? Or how many times do we have to hear that he wants this house and her thinking to herself 鈥渘ope! Not going to happen!鈥�? How many times do we have to hear that they saw a light on upstairs as they approached the house? We get it!!
It鈥檚 so hard to concentrate on anything with the juvenile-esque writing style. It would be different if any of the characters were interesting or had a personality, but we don鈥檛 have that here either. Unless you count the female MC being utterly vapid as having a personality. Not my jam. I鈥檝e given two books a shot now and am not even a little impressed.
If you like books that are repetitive, glaringly obvious red herrings and that lack plot, I have a book recommendation for you!
And how many times do we have to hear her tell us her friends think her husband she married that she barely knew has red flags but they are clearly wrong because he鈥檚 just 鈥渟o sweet鈥�? Or how many times do we have to hear that he wants this house and her thinking to herself 鈥渘ope! Not going to happen!鈥�? How many times do we have to hear that they saw a light on upstairs as they approached the house? We get it!!
It鈥檚 so hard to concentrate on anything with the juvenile-esque writing style. It would be different if any of the characters were interesting or had a personality, but we don鈥檛 have that here either. Unless you count the female MC being utterly vapid as having a personality. Not my jam. I鈥檝e given two books a shot now and am not even a little impressed.
If you like books that are repetitive, glaringly obvious red herrings and that lack plot, I have a book recommendation for you!
June 16, 2023
I've never read a book faster in my life...
This review was long overdue.
There's not much you can say about a thriller without spoiling it but let's try!
PLOT A young couple goes to take a look at the house they possibly want to purchase. But, there's a snow storm and they're stuck in the house. From the first moment, the house seems kind of weird. In the living room, there's this portrait of a woman with piercing green eyes that covers the whole wall. And also, there's this huge bookshelf filled with many copies of the same book, "Anatomy of Fear" written by a psychiatrist who was murdered three years ago. Is this her home? Did she die here? Are they alone in this house? Not likely.
THOUGHTS I often tell a book is fast-paced (everything is when you have ADHD). BUT THIS, THIS WAS OVER IN A HEARTBEAT. It was simply written, just how I like my thrillers, I don't need good descriptions, just give me the creeps. And it SURE DID DELIVER. I want to read everything this author has put out and I'm so glad I jumped on this band wagon.
And of course it ended on such a plot twist, I simultaneously started screaming and banging my head CUZ HOW HAVEN'T I NOTICED THAT BEFORE?
AMAZING, GO READ IT!!!
This review was long overdue.
There's not much you can say about a thriller without spoiling it but let's try!
PLOT A young couple goes to take a look at the house they possibly want to purchase. But, there's a snow storm and they're stuck in the house. From the first moment, the house seems kind of weird. In the living room, there's this portrait of a woman with piercing green eyes that covers the whole wall. And also, there's this huge bookshelf filled with many copies of the same book, "Anatomy of Fear" written by a psychiatrist who was murdered three years ago. Is this her home? Did she die here? Are they alone in this house? Not likely.
THOUGHTS I often tell a book is fast-paced (everything is when you have ADHD). BUT THIS, THIS WAS OVER IN A HEARTBEAT. It was simply written, just how I like my thrillers, I don't need good descriptions, just give me the creeps. And it SURE DID DELIVER. I want to read everything this author has put out and I'm so glad I jumped on this band wagon.
And of course it ended on such a plot twist, I simultaneously started screaming and banging my head CUZ HOW HAVEN'T I NOTICED THAT BEFORE?
AMAZING, GO READ IT!!!
October 14, 2024
This book had me staring at the wall for a full 5 minutes after I finished it. I鈥檓 simply unwell. Freida, you make my trust issues 10x worse, but I eat these books up every time! 馃檪鈥嶁啎锔忦煫娥煆�
May 26, 2023
*audiobook*
I got cocky after predicting the plot of the inmate, and honestly thought I had this one figure out too. then Frida was like BITCH YOU THOUGHT.
I got cocky after predicting the plot of the inmate, and honestly thought I had this one figure out too. then Frida was like BITCH YOU THOUGHT.
November 19, 2022
Oh the potential of this book, and then the epic letdown... The book starts off well, gets you hooked, then makes you angry at how ridiculously bad it is. I never give one star ratings, and I typically enjoy Frieda's books. I especially loved Housemaid and recommended it to everyone I know, but this...
*spoilers below*
The first 50ish% of the book is great and hooks you. Then suddenly there's this twist, but the thing is, the twist makes no sense. Imagine reading someone's thoughts, and based on those thoughts, you know this person is pretty much as vanilla as can be. Next thing you know, they're a psychopathic murderer who has killed multiple people. And is ready to go kill some more. Sounds interesting, right? But now imagine the same scenario, but the thoughts are from a random lady who is viewing a missing/potentially dead psychiatrist's home and is snowed in with her husband. Her thoughts make her sound pretty wimpy and, again, very vanilla. She's always thinking about the missing psychiatrist and wondering about her. Next thing you know, turns out this vanilla lady is the one who killed the psychiatrist some odd years ago. There's more too. She was a patient of the psychiatrist. Her husband was another patient. And the psychiatrist murdered someone too. What is this, Oprah? You're a murderer. You're a murderer. Oh, YOU'RE A MURDERER TOO! It's... so bad? And don't get me wrong, it could have been great, had it made any sense... It doesn't.
Oh and there's some "random" man hiding somewhere in the house too, which is creepy, but pretty much entirely useless to the plot, lol.
Would not recommend. Read Housemaid instead!
*spoilers below*
The first 50ish% of the book is great and hooks you. Then suddenly there's this twist, but the thing is, the twist makes no sense. Imagine reading someone's thoughts, and based on those thoughts, you know this person is pretty much as vanilla as can be. Next thing you know, they're a psychopathic murderer who has killed multiple people. And is ready to go kill some more. Sounds interesting, right? But now imagine the same scenario, but the thoughts are from a random lady who is viewing a missing/potentially dead psychiatrist's home and is snowed in with her husband. Her thoughts make her sound pretty wimpy and, again, very vanilla. She's always thinking about the missing psychiatrist and wondering about her. Next thing you know, turns out this vanilla lady is the one who killed the psychiatrist some odd years ago. There's more too. She was a patient of the psychiatrist. Her husband was another patient. And the psychiatrist murdered someone too. What is this, Oprah? You're a murderer. You're a murderer. Oh, YOU'RE A MURDERER TOO! It's... so bad? And don't get me wrong, it could have been great, had it made any sense... It doesn't.
Oh and there's some "random" man hiding somewhere in the house too, which is creepy, but pretty much entirely useless to the plot, lol.
Would not recommend. Read Housemaid instead!
November 5, 2023
鉃� 饾煋/饾煋 饾櫒饾櫓饾櫀饾櫑饾櫒
鉂烉潤� 饾櫁饾櫄饾櫋饾櫈饾櫄饾櫕饾櫄 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫀饾櫓 饾櫀饾櫍饾櫘 饾櫇饾櫔饾櫌饾櫀饾櫍 饾櫁饾櫄饾櫈饾櫍饾櫆 饾櫈饾櫒 饾櫂饾櫀饾櫏饾櫀饾櫁饾櫋饾櫄 饾櫎饾櫅 饾櫓饾櫄饾櫑饾櫑饾櫈饾櫁饾櫋饾櫄 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫈饾櫍饾櫆饾櫒 饾櫈饾櫅 饾櫘饾櫎饾櫔 饾櫏饾櫔饾櫒饾櫇 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫄饾櫌 饾櫇饾櫀饾櫑饾櫃 饾櫄饾櫍饾櫎饾櫔饾櫆饾櫇.鉂�
"Never Lie" is a captivating story that centers on the lives of Tricia and Ethan, a couple deeply immersed in the honeymoon phase of their relationship, as they embark on the exciting journey of finding their ideal home. Their plans take an unexpected turn when they find themselves stranded in the midst of a relentless snowstorm, compelling them to seek refuge in the seemingly deserted home of Adrienne Hale, a psychologist who mysteriously vanished without a trace.
As the narrative progresses, it peels back the layers of this perplexing mystery, unveiling a web of intricate and sometimes twisted plotlines. Each revelation adds a new dimension to the story, keeping the reader utterly engaged and often taken by surprise. It's a narrative that gradually builds to a crescendo, leaving you with an ending that is not just jaw-dropping but also thought-provoking, resonating with you long after you've turned the final page.
I really enjoyed this book because my friends had raved about the author so much that they practically forced me to read it. The writing was straightforward and easy to follow, and the pacing was just right. What stood out the most was the plot's unpredictability. Unlike previous thrillers where I could often guess the twists early on, this book kept me guessing right up to the end. It was a refreshing change from the usual predictability I've encountered in the genre.The pace at which the story unfolds is perfectly balanced, keeping my interest piqued throughout.
The author's ability to seamlessly interweave both timelines added a beautiful dimension to the book, rendering it a truly accessible and engaging read. However, I encountered a writing style quirk that didn't quite align with my personal taste. It felt as if the narrative had a distinct influence from the Wattpad era, characterized by a prevalence of short, punchy sentences that often concluded rather abruptly. While this stylistic choice might appeal to many readers, I found it somewhat irksome. The lack of full sentences and the frequent terseness in the writing gave the prose a staccato quality, which, in my opinion, disrupted the fluidity of the narrative. This, of course, is a matter of personal preference, and others may not share the same sentiment.
鈥�
Overall, if you're in the mood for a thrilling read that keeps you engaged from start to finish and delivers a jaw-dropping twist that you won't see coming, this book should be on your must-read list.
鉂烉潤� 饾櫁饾櫄饾櫋饾櫈饾櫄饾櫕饾櫄 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫀饾櫓 饾櫀饾櫍饾櫘 饾櫇饾櫔饾櫌饾櫀饾櫍 饾櫁饾櫄饾櫈饾櫍饾櫆 饾櫈饾櫒 饾櫂饾櫀饾櫏饾櫀饾櫁饾櫋饾櫄 饾櫎饾櫅 饾櫓饾櫄饾櫑饾櫑饾櫈饾櫁饾櫋饾櫄 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫈饾櫍饾櫆饾櫒 饾櫈饾櫅 饾櫘饾櫎饾櫔 饾櫏饾櫔饾櫒饾櫇 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫄饾櫌 饾櫇饾櫀饾櫑饾櫃 饾櫄饾櫍饾櫎饾櫔饾櫆饾櫇.鉂�
"Never Lie" is a captivating story that centers on the lives of Tricia and Ethan, a couple deeply immersed in the honeymoon phase of their relationship, as they embark on the exciting journey of finding their ideal home. Their plans take an unexpected turn when they find themselves stranded in the midst of a relentless snowstorm, compelling them to seek refuge in the seemingly deserted home of Adrienne Hale, a psychologist who mysteriously vanished without a trace.
As the narrative progresses, it peels back the layers of this perplexing mystery, unveiling a web of intricate and sometimes twisted plotlines. Each revelation adds a new dimension to the story, keeping the reader utterly engaged and often taken by surprise. It's a narrative that gradually builds to a crescendo, leaving you with an ending that is not just jaw-dropping but also thought-provoking, resonating with you long after you've turned the final page.
I really enjoyed this book because my friends had raved about the author so much that they practically forced me to read it. The writing was straightforward and easy to follow, and the pacing was just right. What stood out the most was the plot's unpredictability. Unlike previous thrillers where I could often guess the twists early on, this book kept me guessing right up to the end. It was a refreshing change from the usual predictability I've encountered in the genre.The pace at which the story unfolds is perfectly balanced, keeping my interest piqued throughout.
The author's ability to seamlessly interweave both timelines added a beautiful dimension to the book, rendering it a truly accessible and engaging read. However, I encountered a writing style quirk that didn't quite align with my personal taste. It felt as if the narrative had a distinct influence from the Wattpad era, characterized by a prevalence of short, punchy sentences that often concluded rather abruptly. While this stylistic choice might appeal to many readers, I found it somewhat irksome. The lack of full sentences and the frequent terseness in the writing gave the prose a staccato quality, which, in my opinion, disrupted the fluidity of the narrative. This, of course, is a matter of personal preference, and others may not share the same sentiment.
鈥�
Overall, if you're in the mood for a thrilling read that keeps you engaged from start to finish and delivers a jaw-dropping twist that you won't see coming, this book should be on your must-read list.
September 25, 2024
藯藦藡 鈽� 藥藠藯 3.5 饾摙饾摻饾摢饾摶饾摷 藯藦藡 鈽� 藥藠藯
喑冣伓拟灧 鈰喫氞繑 饾摖饾摼饾摬饾摤饾摯 饾摙饾摼饾摱饾摱饾摢饾摶饾攤 嗉勨媶猸捤氾健鈰�
Newlyweds Tricia and Ethan get stuck in a blizzard on their way to meet a realtor at a house showing. Luckily, they are within walking distance of the house and find the spare key outside. Although the house is abandoned and formerly belonged to a psychiatrist who went missing, Tricia and Ethan settle in.
While looking for a book to read, Tricia finds a hidden room that contains cassette tapes for all of Dr. Adrienne Hale鈥檚 patients. The more she listens, the more shocking truth comes out about Dr. Hale鈥檚 disappearance.
喑冣伓拟灧 鈰喫氞繑 饾摐饾攤 饾摚饾摫饾摳饾摼饾摪饾摫饾摻饾摷 嗉勨媶猸捤氾健鈰�
Ya'll - I honestly let out the biggest sigh and rolled my eyes thinking I had the twist figured out. I didn't. This is probably my favorite Freida book next to The Housemaid.
Fast paced, short chapters, surprising twists - definitely recommend.
喑冣伓拟灧 鈰喫氞繑 饾摖饾摼饾摬饾摤饾摯 饾摙饾摼饾摱饾摱饾摢饾摶饾攤 嗉勨媶猸捤氾健鈰�
Newlyweds Tricia and Ethan get stuck in a blizzard on their way to meet a realtor at a house showing. Luckily, they are within walking distance of the house and find the spare key outside. Although the house is abandoned and formerly belonged to a psychiatrist who went missing, Tricia and Ethan settle in.
While looking for a book to read, Tricia finds a hidden room that contains cassette tapes for all of Dr. Adrienne Hale鈥檚 patients. The more she listens, the more shocking truth comes out about Dr. Hale鈥檚 disappearance.
喑冣伓拟灧 鈰喫氞繑 饾摐饾攤 饾摚饾摫饾摳饾摼饾摪饾摫饾摻饾摷 嗉勨媶猸捤氾健鈰�
Ya'll - I honestly let out the biggest sigh and rolled my eyes thinking I had the twist figured out. I didn't. This is probably my favorite Freida book next to The Housemaid.
Fast paced, short chapters, surprising twists - definitely recommend.
August 19, 2024
听 "饾檴饾櫍饾櫋饾櫘 饾櫖饾櫀饾櫘 饾櫓饾櫖饾櫎 饾櫏饾櫄饾櫎饾櫏饾櫋饾櫄 饾櫂饾櫀饾櫍 饾櫊饾櫄饾櫄饾櫏 饾櫀 饾櫒饾櫄饾櫂饾櫑饾櫄饾櫓 饾櫈饾櫒 饾櫈饾櫅 饾櫎饾櫍饾櫄 饾櫈饾櫅 饾櫓饾櫇饾櫄饾櫌 饾櫈饾櫒 饾櫃饾櫄饾櫀饾櫃."
My opinion may be in the minority, but hear me out.
When I first started this book, I was thoroughly invested and enjoying it. I continued to enjoy it in the middle and was eagerly awaiting the twist.
But when I got to it, nothing made sense at all.
If this book had been written in the third person, it might have made more sense, but it wasn鈥檛.
There were so many plot holes plot holes.
For example, why would Tricia feel uncomfortable in the house (spoilers ahead: she literally murdered the woman and five or six others, yet she still jumps at every sound in the house)?
Also,she repeatedly mentions how her husband is such a good person, even though she barely knows him. Her constant reiteration made him seem like a red flag. Don鈥檛 worry; this isn鈥檛 a spoiler; it鈥檚 what the author wants you to think.
Now, about my theory, which what I was thinking when I was reading would have earned this book a 4 stars rating if it were true because it makes more sense than what the author wrote:
EJ shares the same first initial as Ethan, right? They both have extensive knowledge of wine and share a love for it. Ethan seemed unusually comfortable in the house and appeared to know his way around a large place, suggesting he might have been there before. EJ had been there many times and was fascinated by the house, mentioning it repeatedly.
So, one might think that EJ is actually Ethan, and poor Tricia is stuck with a narcissistic psychopath.
If the story had ended with him killing her or her escaping, it would have made the book so much better. I can imagine keeping the first and middle parts of the book unchanged and only altering the plot twist; it would have made more sense.
I can鈥檛 reveal the plot twist because I don鈥檛 want to spoil it, but I found it to be very disappointing, in my opinion.
I understand why many enjoyed it, and I鈥檓 genuinely happy for those who gave it five stars, but it just doesn鈥檛 make sense to me and never will.
My opinion may be in the minority, but hear me out.
When I first started this book, I was thoroughly invested and enjoying it. I continued to enjoy it in the middle and was eagerly awaiting the twist.
But when I got to it, nothing made sense at all.
If this book had been written in the third person, it might have made more sense, but it wasn鈥檛.
There were so many plot holes plot holes.
For example, why would Tricia feel uncomfortable in the house (spoilers ahead: she literally murdered the woman and five or six others, yet she still jumps at every sound in the house)?
Also,she repeatedly mentions how her husband is such a good person, even though she barely knows him. Her constant reiteration made him seem like a red flag. Don鈥檛 worry; this isn鈥檛 a spoiler; it鈥檚 what the author wants you to think.
Now, about my theory, which what I was thinking when I was reading would have earned this book a 4 stars rating if it were true because it makes more sense than what the author wrote:
EJ shares the same first initial as Ethan, right? They both have extensive knowledge of wine and share a love for it. Ethan seemed unusually comfortable in the house and appeared to know his way around a large place, suggesting he might have been there before. EJ had been there many times and was fascinated by the house, mentioning it repeatedly.
So, one might think that EJ is actually Ethan, and poor Tricia is stuck with a narcissistic psychopath.
If the story had ended with him killing her or her escaping, it would have made the book so much better. I can imagine keeping the first and middle parts of the book unchanged and only altering the plot twist; it would have made more sense.
I can鈥檛 reveal the plot twist because I don鈥檛 want to spoil it, but I found it to be very disappointing, in my opinion.
I understand why many enjoyed it, and I鈥檓 genuinely happy for those who gave it five stars, but it just doesn鈥檛 make sense to me and never will.
March 8, 2024
鈥淭he only way two people can keep a secret is if one of them is dead.鈥�
Freida, this was so fucked up. Please, do it again.
Freida, what did you put in this book? It was so addicting. The perfect thriller and mystery book I have ever read and this is my new favourite by Freida. This was fast paced and the story is told in dual pov from Adrienne and Tricia's. I was HOOKED from the very first page. I couldn't stop listening to the audiobook because the narrator "Leslie Howard" did an astounding job!
The plot was twisted and confusing with jaw droping plot twist in the last five chapters. I NEVER SAW IT COMING! LIKE NEVER! The story starts when newlywed Tricia and her husband Ethan has to stay at Dr. Adrienne's house because of the blizzard. Tricia discovered the tapes of sessions that Adrienne recorded with her patients and soon Tricia can't stop listening to the tapes and to figure out the mystery as to why Adrienne disappeared three years ago without any trace.
There were some mind-blowing and jaw-dropping revelations. Seriously, you all have to read this because it is one of the best works of Freida in my opinion.
I can not talk about these characters without spoiling anything so I won't. But one thing that I always say after reading Freida's books is that NEVER TRUST ANYONE! But it's so hard when she writes her character with such sweet and incredible personality only to fuck it up later in the end. I have some serious trust issues because of reading her books.
The ending? I have never read such a fucked up and yet a happy ending in my life.
Freida, this was so fucked up. Please, do it again.
Freida, what did you put in this book? It was so addicting. The perfect thriller and mystery book I have ever read and this is my new favourite by Freida. This was fast paced and the story is told in dual pov from Adrienne and Tricia's. I was HOOKED from the very first page. I couldn't stop listening to the audiobook because the narrator "Leslie Howard" did an astounding job!
The plot was twisted and confusing with jaw droping plot twist in the last five chapters. I NEVER SAW IT COMING! LIKE NEVER! The story starts when newlywed Tricia and her husband Ethan has to stay at Dr. Adrienne's house because of the blizzard. Tricia discovered the tapes of sessions that Adrienne recorded with her patients and soon Tricia can't stop listening to the tapes and to figure out the mystery as to why Adrienne disappeared three years ago without any trace.
There were some mind-blowing and jaw-dropping revelations. Seriously, you all have to read this because it is one of the best works of Freida in my opinion.
I can not talk about these characters without spoiling anything so I won't. But one thing that I always say after reading Freida's books is that NEVER TRUST ANYONE! But it's so hard when she writes her character with such sweet and incredible personality only to fuck it up later in the end. I have some serious trust issues because of reading her books.
The ending? I have never read such a fucked up and yet a happy ending in my life.
September 10, 2024
wow that was crazy 馃き
possible rtc
possible rtc
February 10, 2024
nah like I loved this and need to talk about it immediately. maybe 5 stars is a bit ambitious cause I鈥檓 coming down from the reading high. this book took less than 4 hours, I couldn鈥檛 stop reading. It was so easy.
what I loved about it, was that I thought I knew where it was going, I thought I knew exactly what was happening and I was connecting all the dots. 50 pages in I literally remember thinking 鈥渙kay I know how this ends鈥� but also kept second guessing myself - it was almost TOO easy. But the rest of the book gaslit me into thinking I was on the right track. Until page 245/246.
when I tell you my jaw dropped, I sat up, I was gasping for air. like deadass HEADSPINS at that plot twist. I forgot to breathe. It was immaculate.
I was genuinely scared at times at the beginning of the book, the 鈥渉aunted鈥� house was definitely freaking me out. I do love Freida books, but usually give around 3 stars, because they鈥檙e fun, good, quick reads that don鈥檛 have much substance. This one was definitely above par.
I am just so stoked with this book - maybe if I revisited my rating in a week it would be 4 stars. But YOLO - I鈥檓 giving it 5 cause that was EPIC. So clever.
what I loved about it, was that I thought I knew where it was going, I thought I knew exactly what was happening and I was connecting all the dots. 50 pages in I literally remember thinking 鈥渙kay I know how this ends鈥� but also kept second guessing myself - it was almost TOO easy. But the rest of the book gaslit me into thinking I was on the right track. Until page 245/246.
when I tell you my jaw dropped, I sat up, I was gasping for air. like deadass HEADSPINS at that plot twist. I forgot to breathe. It was immaculate.
I was genuinely scared at times at the beginning of the book, the 鈥渉aunted鈥� house was definitely freaking me out. I do love Freida books, but usually give around 3 stars, because they鈥檙e fun, good, quick reads that don鈥檛 have much substance. This one was definitely above par.
I am just so stoked with this book - maybe if I revisited my rating in a week it would be 4 stars. But YOLO - I鈥檓 giving it 5 cause that was EPIC. So clever.
October 31, 2024
3.75 stars 猸愶笍
猡� spoiler-free review!! 鈰嗋报唰幩氣煛藮 啵�
this book was fast-paced, and i had a fun time trying to piece things together. it started off with a really creepy vibe, but as the story progressed, it felt less eerie, and by the end, i realized it wasn鈥檛 actually that scary LOL. i don鈥檛 know how freida manages to pull it off every time, but the plot twists were twisting once again, though a few were fairly predictable. just when i thought i had everything figured out, i was proven wrong 馃う馃徎鈥嶁檧锔� that said, one thing i consistently dislike about her books is her fmcs. i swear they don鈥檛 use their brains and can be downright insufferable 馃槶
pre-read 馃摷:
it鈥檚 the perfect time to dive into another mystery/thriller book with halloween just around the corner 馃懟
猡� spoiler-free review!! 鈰嗋报唰幩氣煛藮 啵�
this book was fast-paced, and i had a fun time trying to piece things together. it started off with a really creepy vibe, but as the story progressed, it felt less eerie, and by the end, i realized it wasn鈥檛 actually that scary LOL. i don鈥檛 know how freida manages to pull it off every time, but the plot twists were twisting once again, though a few were fairly predictable. just when i thought i had everything figured out, i was proven wrong 馃う馃徎鈥嶁檧锔� that said, one thing i consistently dislike about her books is her fmcs. i swear they don鈥檛 use their brains and can be downright insufferable 馃槶
pre-read 馃摷:
it鈥檚 the perfect time to dive into another mystery/thriller book with halloween just around the corner 馃懟
May 4, 2025
ok freida mcfadden you know you ate with that ending
April 29, 2025
Bawi艂am si臋 wy艣mienicie!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96,096 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.