I was hesitant between 1 and 2 stars although I wanted to give it 1.5 but i had to resort to 2 because of the good Arabic lexical choices.. Let's go to the most pressing point which is the content of the book which was so clich茅d and reminded me of many things has been written and others were similar to movie scenes (and I don't mean the ones the author actually acknowledged) I mean the others which were like dejavu for me at least.. The final part were written in a hurry that seemed so rushed... As for the most annoying matter was the misconception of the main character between the atheists and the irreligious or those who don't believe in religions but believe in a diety and pray to Him/Her... Also the author has been paving the way from the very start that the main character is "very religious" and yet when he met the witch or that fearful being he seemed to have forgot all about his pious side which constitutes the fact that it was a facade nothing more and he even created that main character through its approach to the other as the stereotypical character which thinks that he holds righteousness between his hands One final point it might be stupid or genious either way what is the evidence for every thing the author has been describing concerning the djin world.. I mean real materialistic evidence.. I am not talking about their existence but how the things are being done in their world and what do they believe in..