Madonna hangs up her material-girl cloak to teach children the importance of looking beyond a surface sheen. In The English Roses, the superstar's children's book debut, four little girls (the roses in question) "play the same games, read the same books, and like the same boys." Nicole, Amy, Charlotte, and Grace all love to dance the monkey and the tickety-boo聟 and they all are horribly jealous of Binah, the perfect, beautiful, smart, kind girl who lives nearby. Even though they know Binah is lonely, she makes them sick. They would say, "Let's pretend we don't see her when she walks by." And even, "Let's push her into the lake!" The pleasantly bossy narrator explains, "And that is what they did. No, silly, not the lake part, the pretending not to see her part." One night, however, the four girls all have the same dream that sets them straight. A fairy godmother sprinkles them with fairy dust and takes them to spy on Binah. When they see that she lives alone with her father, slaving away night and day at household chores, the four girly grumblers feel very sorry for her. The fairy scolds them, "聟 in the future, you might think twice before grumbling that someone else has a better life than you." And they do. This morality tale is nothing new under the sun, but it is cleverly told, with many teaspoonfuls of good humor. Jeffrey Fulvimari's illustrations are no less than stunning--filling every page with vivacious black ink lines and gorgeous watercolor reminiscent of 1960s fashion sketches. Children will enjoy this "don't hate me because I'm beautiful" story that celebrates friendship as much as it teaches compassion. (Ages 6 and older) --Karin Snelson
Madonna Louise Ciccone is an American pop singer-songwriter. Through her music career, she has also gained some notability as a dancer, record producer, film producer, actress, author and a fashion icon. She is a multiple Grammy- and Golden Globe-award winner, known for her ambitious music videos, stage performances and use of sexual and religious themes in her work.
First, let me just say I decided to try this book to see if it would be as dreadful as I'd feared. Also, I've always really liked the cover illustration! I had low-low-low expectations of Madonna's story and I admit they were not completely fulfilled--the story was okay. I have read worse in children's lit, believe me ("Goldilicious" comes to mind!) The concept is actually cute, but overall it's a bit too in-your-face and didactic for my taste, and there really is no "style" to speak of. Basically, I think most parents with an ounce of creativity could come up with a similar bedtime story for their kids, and the fact that Madonna (whether you like her or not, her creativity cannot be denied!) seemed lack any originality reinforces my soapbox oratory that not just ANYONE can write a GOOD children's book, and being a celebrity does not automatically give you the gift.
Also, parents of young children who wish to keep them "young" should be advised that the girls in this story look to be ten going on eighteen and are very chic and appear to be wearing make up and fashionable clothing. Not placing a value judgment here, but I know some girls in the target audience for this book and their moms would NOT want anything to encourage the girls' budding interest in wearing lipstick, etc.
What I REALLY hated about this book was the celebrity treatment it is given. I really, really liked the illustrations (the largest part of my three-star rating) and went to look at the back flap of the book to see what else he had done. But, the bio was nowhere to be seen! Just a big spread about Madonna blah-blah-blah. I double-checked the cover for his name. Nope! One would think that Madonna did the illustrations herself!!! Only on the inside cover page does it mention (way below MADONNA) our poor neglected illustrator Jeffrey Fulvimari. This is SOOO RUDE!!!! Children's picture books are supposed to be a marriage between words and pictures, author and illustrator (assuming they are not one in the same). Let us hope that the fat royalty checks from this needlessly popular series are some consolation for Fulvimari.
A surprisingly sweet story about friendship which is raised above the ordinary by the lovely illustrations which certainly captured my daughter's attention. The group of girls embrace all the nice character types you'd expect at school - studious, sporty, etc, so everyone can easily pick a favourite. Like Lauren Child's Clarice Bean books which started out as picture books, Madonna has now produced a series of chapter books (with a matching website) for confident readers and we're finding them a cut above some of the other celeb offerings for young girls.
As far as children's-books-by-celebrities go, the good, the bad, and the ugly, The English Roses is merely bad. Which is rather high praise, all things considered. I expected the book to be downright ugly.
Instead, it's mostly harmless. The four "main characters," the group of girlfriends known as "the English Roses," are featureless and interchangeable. They have lots of fun dancing, talking about boys, and having sleepovers.
They are also united in their hatred of the prettiest girl in school (the drawings of this girl look suspiciously like Madonna), having drawn the conclusion that all pretty girls are stuck up.
Enter a fairy godmother who offers the Roses a chance to trade places with the pretty girl, to see what her life is really like. Once the Roses find out the truth about the pretty girl, they feel more kindly toward her, and invite her to be their friend.
The message -- don't judge people by their looks -- is heavy-handed. No, wait...it's HEAVY-HANDED. I mean REALLY HEAVY. And this is to blame for most of the book's badness.
If you are a nitpicky reader, like me, other things contribute to the badness, like the fact that there are no characters -- nobody has any distinct characteristics. There's also no real story; this could hardly even be called a fable. All of it is rote and not terribly deeply-felt.
It's also not a picture book. Even a "story" as trite as this one would have been better served in a middle-reader or chapter book format. No wonder the four Roses have no personalities -- there's hardly enough time to develop those personalities or the dynamic of the group in a mere 32 pages.
Given the age of the Roses, also -- I figure they must be preteens, since they talk about boys, yet they still have sleepovers -- this should have been a middle-reader.
I know it's Madonna, and people of all ages are going to buy the book for people of all ages. But droves of people would have bought it anyway if it was an illustrated chapter book. Chapter books, however, are not cute, and picture books are.
Speaking of cute, I loved the illustrations in this book. They're girly and sweet and cheeky all at once. The illustrator captured a unique spirit that belongs solely to the English Roses. If they have any personality at all, it's because of him.
Gwendolyn: 4 Eleanor: 5 G: 4 E: 5 G: 4 E: 5 G: 4! E: 5! G: 4! E: 5! G: 4! YOU CHOSE LAST TIME! E: DADDY! I wish there was a way we could both choose! G: 4! E: 5! G: 4! E: 5! *this continues for some time, with some breaks to explain why each should get to choose... also, Gwendolyn got confused at one point and said "5." ...Eleanor didn't catch it.
E: (crying) Gwendolyn's making it seem like I don't like it a little bit. And I really liked it.
G: BUT I WANT 4!
D: Can I give it 4 and a half?
Both: NOOO!!! (And they're both now crying...)
E: Dad? Can you help solve this problem?
D: I'll try... lets just start the review, ok? Who should I ask about the book?
G: ME! ME! ME! ME!
D: Ok, Gwen go ahead.
G: The book was about the Eng-galish Roses.
E: Dad, I never get to say what the book was about.
D: So, Eleanor, what are the English Roses?
E: Four little girls. That's also what the book was about. (Laughing) Dad. I found a spoon under the bench. Heh.
D: So, the book was about 4 little girls. What happened to them?
E: They didn't like Binah.
D: We don't want to give anything away, so why don't we just say your favorite parts.
E: My favorite part was when the fairy-godmother sat on a sandwich, and she pulled the sandwich off her bum and when they... when they... and my favorite part was also when they (laughing) STUFFED. THEIR. FACES. How did they stuff their faces?
G: 4.4.4.4.4.4.
E: Now I'm never going to like the book. Why does Gwen keep making it seem like I don't like it?
D: She's not, Eleanor. We're not talking about that right now, we're talking about what we liked.
E: Gwen, what was your favorite part?
G: Bread.
E: WHAT WAS YOUR FAVORITE PART?
G: BREAD! BREAD! I liked the part with the bread.
D: I think we all agree that that part with the pumperknickel was pretty good, right?
Both: Yeah.
D: So, do you guys think other kids would like this book?
E: Mmm-hmm
G: Yeah.
D: Me too. That Madonna... She's a pretty good author, huh?
E: Owwww! POPPY! STOP! STOP! STOOOOOOOP!!!!
*Poppy has now climbed up the bench and is pulling Eleanor's hair, ruining my joke about Madonna being famous for being an author... It was going to be really funny.*
ATTENTION! ATTENTION! GWENNIE HAS NOW LEFT!!!!! THAT MEANS ELEANOR GETS TO DECIDE HOW MANY STARS TO GIVE THE BOOK!
D: Eleanor, how many stars do you want to give it?
E: 5!
D: Gwennie got to go downstairs to have fun.
(She just came running back up, looking scared, yelling "4.")
D: Gwennie wants me to say, that officially she gives it "4" stars, even though the top says "5." Should I say anything else about the book, guys?
G: No. I want 4.
E: Hey, GWEN!!! Maybe, if you close one eye, you can make it look like it only has 4 stars...?
D: Isn't the point of this book that you should be nice?
E: Mmm-hmmm.
D: So how can you guys be nice to each other?
E: If Gwennie says, "it's ok that you can have 5..."
D: But how can you be nice to Gwennie?
E: ... ... ...Not how Gwen can be nice to me?
D: Right.
E: Ummm... I can say, "it's ok that you have 4."
D: So, do you want to do that?
E: ... Oh dear. But it was so amazing. Dad, it was very amazing.
D: But you know what? I think Madonna would rather have you be nice, than have her book get 5 stars from you.
E: But the book was SO AMAZING.
D: Well, she'll know that when she reads the review.
E: No. Daddy. She'll read the review and think, "That girl wants 4 stars." But I don't. I want 5. How can I ever get 5 now? Gwen always lets me have 5.
D: Oh... I think you've made it pretty clear that you think it deserves 5 stars.
E: Hey! DAD! I have a great idea! How about you write the words "4 and a half in the review."
Dad: I'll do that right at the beginning of the review, that way you can call it 5 and Gwen can call it 4.
G: Yay! 4!
E: Yay! 5!
E: (Conspiratorially): Hey... Dad... maybe tomorrow we can write a review on our own, ok?
This book is so bad, I can't even review it from work on my phone. I feel like I need to go home, put on a pot of tea, and give this book my undivided contempt.
I have to say I was pleasantly surprised by this one! The story I would give 4 stars to and I had to add a star for the beautiful illustrations! I honestly didn't know Madonna had written a book and I am glad I got the chance to read it. My two year old loved the pics and I actually laughed a couple times during it. Very cute and sweet with a good message!
Madonna'dan feminist bak谋艧 a莽谋l谋 iyi bir 莽ocuk kitab谋 bekliyordum. Ama maalesef feci basmakal谋p bir hikaye okudum. "Ba艧kalar谋n谋n ne ya艧ad谋臒谋n谋 bilmeden onlar谋 yarg谋lama" temas谋n谋 o kadar k枚t眉 bir yerden i艧liyor ki anlatamam.
Daha k枚t眉s眉 hepi topu 45 sayfal谋k bu resimli kitab谋n hangi ya艧a hitap etti臒i de belli de臒il. Karakterleri liseli olan bu kitap e臒er ortaokul d眉zeyi i莽inse neden bu kadar k谋sa. E臒er okumaya yeni ba艧layanlar i莽inse neden 枚zde艧lik kuramayacaklar谋 karakterler var.
Hele 莽izimleri... S谋rf farkl谋 olsun diye bu denli karman 莽orman bir 莽izim tekni臒ine ne gerek vard谋?
Kitab谋n gelirleri de sa莽ma sapan bir yere gidiyormu艧.
These books remind me so much of my child hood. They are a great read and i still find my self reaching for these books every once in a while. As children we would always pick out who we were and try and replicate some scenes. I would read these books from age 8-14 it is not too difficult for age 8 but it is very easy but still enjoyable for age 12+. Overall i really enjoy these books. :)
It's a beautiful book, I love Maddona's way of storytelling, and Jeffrey Furimari is a very talented illustrator! I found this book in a second-hand bookshop owned by my friend from a book club. So glad I did 鉂わ笍馃彺鬆仹鬆仮鬆仴鬆伄鬆仹鬆伩馃尮!
Auch dies ist wieder ein sch枚nes Kinderbuch. Dieses mal geht es um Ausgrenzung. Ich hoffe nun nur, dass man nicht wie das M盲dchen im Buch ein schweres Schicksal habe muss, um akzeptiert zu werden. Hier m眉ssen Mama, Papa oder Oma beim Mitlesen erkl盲rend eingreifen.
Bardzo lubi艂am t臋 ksi膮偶k臋 jak by艂am ma艂a, g艂贸wnie przez kolorowe obrazki (czyta艂 mi kto艣 inny, bo wtedy sama nie potrafi艂am). Uwa偶am, 偶e mia艂a na mnie dobry wp艂yw. W najprostszy spos贸b t艂umaczy czym jest uprzedzenie i uczy o akceptacji.
Bener banget deh kata Gabrielle Zevin dalam bukunya The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry. "Terkadang buku tidak menemukan kita di saat yang tepat."
Saya tahu buku ini sejak dengar kabar Madonna mau menulis buku anak. Terus Gramedia menerbitkan pada tahun 2003. Sudah pengen banget beli dan baca, apalagi lihat covernya yang segar dan ceria. Entahlah, seperti ada penghalang :'D. Bayangkan, baru hampir 20 tahun kemudian saya beli buku ini. Dapat seken di Pasar Buku Kenari, di sebuah kios yang sudah mau tutup!
Jadi, begitulah. Dan, buku ini memang bagus sih. Ceritanya bagus, meski tidak terlalu istimewa dan temanya sudah banyak diangkat. Tapi penulisannya menarik. Suka sama Ibu Peri yang nyentrik :D. Oh ya, ilustrasinya juga seru, ceria, segeerrr.
I disliked this book so much that I posted a review video of it on YouTube. You can find it on my channel, "Don't Read This To My Kids". Basically, I felt that it portrayed the main character, Binah, as perfect, and the "English Roses", four other girls, were only jealous of her because she was so perfect. When they found out her mother was dead, they realized only then that their jealousy was unfounded. So the main character's only flaw is that she has a dead mother, and shunning people is bad because... they might have dead mothers. Or something. My video goes into more detail.
I'm so amazed?? Is there nothing Madonna can't do?
Though it's short, The English Roses tackles some heavy hitters: squashing out girl hate, promoting female friendships and self-love, highlighting that not everyone has the privileges they seem to.... While still being funny and wholesome. And those ILLUSTRATIONS <33333 I really loved it and it was a perfect way to kick my butt out of my reading slump.
I listened to my dear friend Averie read this book , so if you want to give it a try, just click that link!
First off, it's too long for a picture book. Second, the narrative stutters. The asides to the reader don't flow and trip up any flow that might happen. The story is trite. All of the characters are the same girl and they learn nothing in the end except that Binah has a tough life so they should include her in their exclusivity. Not the message I want my daughter to hear.
Review : Alles wat de Amerikaanse zangeres Madonna (1958), die in het werkelijke leven eigenlijk Madonna Louise Veronica Ciccone blijkt te heten, aanraakt, schijnt in goud te veranderen. Zij debuteerde in 1983 met de lp Madonna. Verschillende nummers hiervan werden internationale hits, wat meteen het begin van een zeer succesvolle loopbaan werd, niet alleen als zangeres maar ook als filmactrice, o.a. in Desperately seeking Susan (1985), Who's that girl? (1987), Dick Tracy (1990) en Snake eyes (1994)
Haar succes is in hoge mate gebaseerd op het tot de verbeelding sprekende imago van onafhankelijke en toch sexy vrouw dat zij zich aanmeet en haar manipulatie van de media. Zij komt ook heel sterk op voor minderheden. Zo kon het gebeuren dat Madonna aan alle vooraanstaande bladen een exclusief interview weigerde. Maar datzelfde interview wel spontaan aanbood aan het prominente homoblad 'The Advocate', dat dan ook nog eens de wereldrechten kon doorverkopen. Madonna houdt geen blad voor haar mond, jaagt de conservatieve meute tegen zich in het het harnas, maar is na al die jaren nog altijd een wereldvedette waar men storm voor loopt, getuige hiervan zij haar Europese tournee.
Mediageniek als ze is heeft ze inmiddels ook wel door dat er in het kinderboek, sinds de grote doorbraak van de inmiddels bijna mythische Harry Potter, toekomstmuziek zit. Madonna, ondertussen zelf moeder van flinke spruiten, vond dat het hoog tijd werd dat ze haar intrede zou kunnen doen in de wereld van het kinderboek. En zoals altijd doet ze dat op haar eigen dwarse manier. Ze vertelt een eigentijds verhaal over vier hippe Engels meisjes die van dezelfde kleren, dezelfde muziek en dezelfde jongens en van dansen houden. Ze zijn opperbeste vriendinnen en lopen met een grote boog rond een meisje heen dat Binah heet. Ze zijn razend jaloers op Binah, omdat ze heel mooi is en alle andere mogelijke kwaliteiten heeft waarnaar een ambitieus meisje verlangt. Binah is echter heel ongelukkig en heel eenzaam omdat er zoveel verdriet in haar leven is waar de meisjes geen enkel idee over hebben.
Gelukkig bestaan er nog petemoeien die in de dromen van jaloerse meisjes kunnen binnendringen. En zo bestaat het dat er op een nacht een gezellige dikkerd van een petemoei in de dromen van de meisjes infiltreert om over het leven Binah te vertellen.
Via een flinterdun verhaal geeft Madonna het signaal door aan jonge mensen dat je niemand mag beoordelen v贸贸r je hem of haar kent. De angst voor het onbekende of uiterlijke schijn mag je er nooit toe brengen om iemand links te laten liggen, dat is de boodschap die Madonna haar lezers influistert. Persoonlijk vind ik De Engelse Rozen een heel lief, eigentijds verhaal dat het vooral moet hebben van de schitterende tekeningen van de modeontwerper Jeffrey Fulvimari, die het geheel op een originele manier ondersteunen.
The picture book, The English Roses is the first picture book written by Madonna (published September 2003). A beautiful story of friendship. The story begins with four of the girls: Charlotte, Amy, Grace, and Nicole. They were the best of friends, they were inseparable. The girls had a lot of things in common, including their jealousy for another girl, Binah. They were jealous of what they thought they knew about her. But, Binah was not that girl. One night, the four BFF's began to learn the truth about Binah and decided that they were not jealous of her any longer which led to some changes within the group of girls.
I highly suggest having this book read aloud or made available for students to read in your classroom. This clearly portrays a story of not judging a book by its cover and making sure that you know the details about a person before deciding if you would like to be friends with them.
Una historia s煤per bonita con una ense帽anza muy especial sobre los prejuicios, la envidia y la amistad; acompa帽ada de ilustraciones muy tiernas y coloridas, definitivamente un libro que se debe leer m铆nimo una vez en la vida.