From what I'd heard, or rather read, through my friend's reviews, that this novella isn't that great: I would partially disagree. Stephen King is such a skillful writer: he can make any ordinary story sound incredible; and not everyone can do that. It's true, I agree, that the story, at first, doesn't seem to be that promising/interesting; but The Breathing Method is a story so well told that you get immersed in it that you don't even know it.
What would have been an ordinary story, King has made an unforgettable one!
Brilliant novella by the master story teller. David, a lawyer, is invited to join his superior to a mysterious club where stories are told by the members. The location is very impressive (books you don't find elsewhere) and Steven is a very special butler. There seems to be no fee. The week before Christmas a horror story has to be told. This time it's about the Breathing Method used by a wife when giving birth to a child. An old doctor tells the story. What is so special about this story and makes it that creepy? Why is that club in the brownstone so uncanny? The novella read like a movie. It was very sinister and the inset story about the Breathing Method was extremely exciting. The story is included in the Different Season anthology of four novellas. Absolutely recommended.
One of four novellas that make up the Different Seasons collection, The Breathing Method is the moving tale of a young woman鈥檚 extreme dedication to her unborn child, set amidst the backdrop of the festive season.
The main concern for the bulk of page count is the narrative related by elderly physician Emlyn McCarron, which details a bizarre phenomena he experienced while treating Sandra Stansfield, a single pregnant woman.
As part of his treatment of Stansfield and her baby, McCarron prescribes the 鈥渂reathing method鈥� designed to assist mothers through childbirth. Together, the pair seem destined to successfully deliver Stansfield鈥檚 baby, and it is only thanks to the foreshadowing provided early on by McCarron鈥檚 narration that we know things will end in tragedy.
鈥淭here is no comfort without pain; thus we define salvation through suffering鈥�
The weakest among the 4 from Different Seasons, though more due to its length than due to the plot. I felt it should either have been a bit shorter, in which it would鈥檝e been more focused on that story, or longer, so that the other stories could鈥檝e been completed. I would鈥檝e preferred the latter, somehow I feel Stephen King could鈥檝e handled that better.
The story is pretty amazing, but with King, it鈥檚 never what the story is, but how the story鈥檚 told. It starts off with a usual slow pace, and then, in the last few pages, makes a not-fully-realized attempt at horror. To be honest, it doesn鈥檛 quite feel like horror, more like a grotesque take on tragedy, the hidden metaphor being the unconditional love of a mother for her would-be child. It鈥檚 devourable and all that, and I don鈥檛 ask much more from so short a novella. But SK being one of my all-time favourites, there always remain certain expectations鈥�
Hmm, might change to a 4. Right now it's about a 3.5 I thought it had a slow start... it ended really strongly, though. Once the actual story-within-a-story got up and running, the novella really picked up and was so creepy!
Description: There is a strange club in New York where men tell each other stories. The years pass but no one looks any older. One night a doctor tells the story of a young woman who gives birth to a baby in the most horrible way! Evil psychic powers, obsession and the supernatural in the most ordinary, everyday places. A spine-chiller from the master of horror.
From 'A Winter's Tale' section of the 'Different Seasons collection released in 1982, so this was by way of a re-visit for me. Great storytelling.
3* * A Death 3.5* Finders Keepers 3* Joyland 3* Mr Mercedes 4* The Shining 3* The Stand 4* It 5* Misery 3* Carrie 5* The Gunslinger 3* Pet Sematary 4* 11/22/63 3* 'Salem's Lot 3* The Green Mile 3* Needful Things 3* Cujo 4* Different Seasons 3* The Drawing of the Three 3* Firestarter 5* The Waste Lands 3* Wizard and Glass 4* Insomnia 2* Dreamcatcher 3* Desperation 4* Four Past Midnight 2* The Tommyknockers 4* Dr Sleep 2* The Mist 4* Hearts in Atlantis 3* Rose Madder 4* Full Dark, No Stars 3* From a Buick 8 3* Just After Sunset 3* Blaze 3* Storm of the Century screenplay 1* UR 3* Children of the Corn The Breathing Method
I feel a bit like a broken record. I love the writing, the buildup, the background, but didn鈥檛 care for the tale featured in the title. I found all the detail about this Gentlemen鈥檚 Club that was not a club, fascinating. The idea that an entire set of books, previously unpublished anywhere else, could be found on the shelves of this鈥lace, was fascinating to me as a reader. I wish there were a club place like that I could visit.
The fact that the men who 鈥渉ung out鈥� there were not members and paid no dues just sets my mind whirling on crazy spirals. How did the place stay in business, keep the lights on, buy wood for that massive fireplace, all the booze? How did Stevens earn a living? Tips, no matter how generous, at Christmas would not be enough.
When we get to the actual tale, I didn鈥檛 care for the finale at all. I liked reading about a strong and resourceful young woman dealing with the hand she was dealt. I loved how kind her doctor was. I did NOT care for the scene at the end. I can suspend disbelief with the best of them, but that couldn鈥檛 happen and there was no reason it needed to. The story could have ended any number of ways besides that one and I would have been happy with it.
Five stars for everything but the end and two stars for that.
This is a story-within-story. At first there is a mysterious club with regular activities where a member shares a story each evening. One of such stories is "The Breathing Method".
The Club part is the weak part in my opinion. There were only mysteries, and sensations felt by POV character. But at the end, there is no explanations, and nothing really happened.
The Breathing Method part is another thing. Although there is not much explanation at the end, but there are strong characters that could grasp your sympathy.
I don't like the editorial choice to make this story as the closure of Different Season. The opening of the collection was so strong with , it is a pity the ending is considerably weaker. well, it is just my opinion.
The Club is a special place that attracts peculiar men looking to share tales of unexplainable supernatural events that they鈥檝e experienced at some point in their lives. Emlyn McCarron is an old physician that recounts an unbelievable event early in his career where he helped a pregnant woman that was desperate to make sure her unborn child was safely delivered when no one was willing to give her the assistance she needed, even if she had to assure her own child鈥檚 birth from beyond the grave.
A little slow moving but it has a beautifully haunting and melancholy atmosphere. More than anything I found the clubhouse interesting. It seems like a haunted place that attracts paranormal phenomena, but not necessarily in a bad or dangerous way. Almost like the inverse of the Overlook Hotel or a harmlessly strange pocket dimension somewhere in the Dark Tower multiverse. I鈥檇 like to see more of it in other stories.
The Breathing Method is the weakest story in Different Seasons in my opinion, but still really solid. The second half of the story is especially good.
Oh, Stephen King, you are one of my favourite authors. This was a real treat, stumbling across this little novella in audio form while searching the digital library for something for my younger sister. I listened to it in the space of an afternoon, between making lunch and eating it, whilst my child and then my husband napped, and the older kids got home from school. This story is written from the perspective of a man who, by luck, it seems, is invited to a club one night, where the members make a habit of telling stories from time to time. May I just say: Best club EVAR. Seriously. If creating clubs was something the world lent itself to in this modern day and age, I would so create and attend a club just like this, from now until I could no longer physically do so. My only complaint about this story is that it includes brief teasers of stories that we don't get to hear the end of. I wanted VERY MUCH to hear the rest of at least one of the other stories hinted at but not completed. As an added bonus, this audio included a brief afterward by Stephen King which was also thoroughly enjoyable, and definitely worth sticking around to listen to.
Another masterful short and sweet novella by the horror mind of Stephen King. This one takes place at a special Club where gentleman gather to tell stories. All stories culminate in the tale of a pregnant women and her fairy bizarre unfortunate delivery. This is truly a horror story with some some specs of light interspersed in it. If you are a horror genre fan this one is a must-read!
I just re-read The Breathing Method about ten years after my first time through it, and I have to say I found it much more rewarding this time. the novella probably suffers from the fact that it鈥檚 packed into Different Seasons with 3 of King鈥檚 most famous works, The Body, Shawshank Redemption, and Apt Pupil, and it is really the only true Horror story in the bunch. I鈥檇 forgotten that King uses a far different voice than in his other books, almost a H.P Lovecraft tone. His old gentlemen鈥檚 club seems very Victorian, but then it鈥檚 from another place and time, isn鈥檛 it? In fact, this may be the first time King introduces a concept that will become so prominent in his later works: 鈥淭here are other worlds than these.鈥� I Don鈥檛 recommend this for couples who are about to experience their first pregnancy. Still, it鈥檚 a great read. The tragic story of Miss Stansfield鈥檚 pregnancy and the almost supernatural effects of her doctor鈥檚 prescribed breathing exercises are explored for full horrific effect and the accident leading to her tragedy is described as only a world class writer like King can.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is the 2nd story I read in Kings 鈥淒ifferent Seasons鈥� novel and I have to say I liked it more than the previous story.
I liked the chilly, cold NYC setting. It was a bit morbid too. Imagining what happened to that poor woman and the imagery of her death was very macabre. This was a short story that definitely was effective though.
This one gave me the creeps alright.Had to learn the breathing method with bated breath for most part.Successfully annulled the effects of reading four Wodehouses in a row.
Unfortunately, my enjoyment of this novella was marred by the fact my audio copy was a dud. It skipped near-constantly, which meant that I had to keep the e-book open to read the whole paragraphs it missed out. I could and probably should have just switched over and read the whole thing, but instead I kept hoping it would fix itself. It was so short I figured I'd put up with it.
Not much over two hours, "The Breathing Method" is at least half the length of the others in the Different Seasons collection. According to King, it was included because his publishers wanted a familiar touch of horror alongside his less familiar genre writing. And it is familiar. Anyone who's read "The Man Who Would Not Shake Hands" will recognise the framing device used to tell "The Breathing Method". It's set in a mysterious gentleman's club, filled with items made by companies that don't exist, corridors that go on for miles, and an ageless butler. The framing becomes increasingly compelling, but I think King could have done more with it than limiting it to just these two, largely unremarkable stories. "The Breathing Method" itself - about a pregnant woman whose commitment to Lamaze extends beyond death - is gory and shocking, but, I fear, will prove forgettable. It's a not-entirely-satisfying little morsel and sadly one of my least favourites by King in a while.
My opinion isn't aided by the Afterword, in which King self-deprecatingly mentions that he writes "plain tales for plain people", "the literary equivalent of a Big Mac and fries." I think we all know he's no literary genius, but modesty that extends to insulting your reader's taste is rather unpalatable.
A novella of less than a 100 pages, I finished this in one read which is probably why I was so mesmerized by it. There were moments when it got so mysterious that I had to keep the book away from me for 10 seconds to make sure I get to sleep during the night. Although I would not categorize this under horror at all which is exactly why this is a must read. A very ordinary story made so engrossing by the extraordinary writing. I would have preferred the mystery of the club being revealed in the end but the open-endedness makes your heads wrapped around the thrill just a little longer.