ŷ

Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hellbent #2

Pirate Girls

Rate this book
Kade and Hunter Caruthers.

Brothers. Twins.

My cousins.

In a way, they’re my family. Protective. Indulgent. My best friends. But there was something else there, too. That ever-present whisper that reminded me more as I got older that we didn’t actually share any blood.

They used to be inseparable. We all were, but not anymore. I don’t know why Hunter left or why he joined a rival team in Weston—that Rebel town across the river—to stand on the opposite side of the field from his brother, but Kade is out for blood now and Hunter has finally decided to engage.

Rivalry Week.

Parades. Parties. Pranks.

And the Prisoner Exchange.

Weston will send a hostage to our school, and they’re taking me. I’m Hunter’s for two weeks. In a dilapidated brownstone on a nearly abandoned street with almost no supervision.

Ten days in an enemy school. Fourteen nights in a town full of bullies with no curfews and no rules.

And Hunter has no intention of protecting his little cousin anymore.

The Pirates will come for me. How can they not? A Pirate never sits out on the fun.

But I never needed protection or rescue, because a Pirate never runs, either.

*Pirate Girls is a new adult romance suitable for ages 18+.

596 pages, Unknown Binding

First published April 12, 2024

788 people are currently reading
31k people want to read

About the author

Penelope Douglas

48books103kfollowers
Penelope Douglas is a New York Times, USA Today, and Wall Street Journal bestselling author. Their books have been translated into more than twenty languages and include The Fall Away Series, The Devil’s Night Series, and the stand-alones, Misconduct, Punk 57, Birthday Girl, Credence, Tryst Six Venom, and Five Brothers. Please look for The Hellbent Series, coming next.

They live in New England with their husband and daughter.

Would you like to join the reader group? --->

Looking for News?
Text DOUGLAS to 603-519-3800 to be alerted when new releases are live!
Website:
Facebook:
Twitter:
Pinterest:
Amazon:
Instagram:

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
3,381 (38%)
4 stars
3,346 (37%)
3 stars
1,628 (18%)
2 stars
360 (4%)
1 star
117 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,102 reviews
Profile Image for Penelope Douglas.
Author48 books103k followers
Shelved as 'finished-writing'
April 12, 2024
⚡️Available Now!⚡️
“𝑇𝑒� 𝑑𝑎𝑦𝑠 𝑖𝑛 𝑎𝑛 𝑒𝑛𝑒𝑚𝑦 𝑠𝑐ℎ𝑜𝑜�. 𝐹𝑜𝑢𝑟𝑡𝑒𝑒𝑛 𝑛𝑖𝑔ℎ𝑡� 𝑖𝑛 𝑎 𝑡𝑜𝑤𝑛 𝑓𝑢𝑙𝑙 𝑜𝑓 𝑏𝑢𝑙𝑙𝑖𝑒𝑠 𝑤𝑖𝑡� 𝑛𝑜 𝑐𝑢𝑟𝑓𝑒𝑤𝑠 𝑎𝑛𝑑 𝑛𝑜 𝑟𝑢𝑙𝑒𝑠�




Should I Read Anything to Prepare for the Hellbent Series? -->
It's also advisable to read Falls Boys (Hellbent #1) before this.

Amazon US
Amazon UK
Amazon AUS
Amazon CA
Amazon DE
Amazon FR
Amazon IT
Amazon BR

Paperback �
Audio (releasing April 16th)

Pinterest Storyboard
Playlist
Read Chapter 1!

FREE in Kindle Unlimited!
*Pirate Girls is suitable for readers 18+.
Profile Image for audelia.
473 reviews121 followers
April 26, 2024
Update #3 (finally post-reading):

4.25 Stars

Omg??? I had high expectations for this one, obviously, but I am shooketh it did not disappoint!! (cannot say the same about the first book since that one was a dnf for now). Hunter is by far one of my most favorite Heroes of all time and if Dylan didn’t want him, I’d gladly snatch him up and keep him for myself. But I’m SO GLAD Dylan is not loony enough to let him go 😮‍� or am I�? Lol anyway, I’ll try to write a more detailed review when I get the time but for now� IT IS A HELL YES for this one 💯🔥

_______________

Update #2:

Wait what - the release date got pushed back again?? This wait is literally maxing out my patience huhu

_______________

Update #1:

Omg a release date finally??? March 21, 2024 can’t come soon enough I’m so ready for some HunterxDylan action LFG!!


What I'm excited for in this series:

1. Quinn and Lucas' love story

2. Dylan choosing Hunter ♥️ (ugh FOR ONCE, let the intense, quiet, broody guy (aka Hunter) get the girl! And not the mean, overbearing, bullying asshole dude (aka Kade) because quite frankly, that would just be like a remake of and I've already read that book and tons more like it so I would pass if so. It would be so damn boring, predictable, and done-so-many-times if Dylan ended up with Kade 🙄 Besides, Hunter has that intensity and broodiness about him that you can’t help but find so damn hot! 🥵🔥 I totally fell for him in and I am hella excited for him and Dylan to get it onnnn (and I would bet my curvy white ass it would be e.x.p.l.o.s.i.v.e. considering all of Hunter’s pent up energy 😏) and get their HEA 😍.
-- Yes, I will only read Dylan's/Hunter's book if they do end up together. If Dylan ends up with someone else (aka Kade) then sorry, but I shall pull an Ari and say, "thank u, next!". I've read a thousand other books wherein the heroine chooses the alphahole and this gal is looking for somethin' new k? thanks bye.

3. Hawke. He is a very interesting man and I want more of him. And I mean� a VIRGIN HERO who actually CARES about who he’s bangin� and is oh so picky on where he’s sticking his patootie in?? UGH COME TO MAMA! My ovaries are so ready to explode for this man 🥵🔥

4. Someone who will knock Kade off his spoiled, arrogant ass -- NOT Dylan though; Dylan belongs to Hunter in my most humble opinion. Lol

5. The awesome family/friends dynamics that PD always seem to nail.
Profile Image for پԲ𲹻୨ৎ.
594 reviews3,492 followers
April 15, 2024
The Pirates and Rebels are here, and with them comes Dylan & Hunter in this throwback of a feeling story that will keep you on your toes...



So here we are, once again at the spot where it all started. Where started and a whole new universe was introduced by . Only now, we are being introduced to Jared and Tate's daughter, Dylan. And Madoc and Fallon's sons; Hunter and Kade. And my gosh is this the book to bring you back to the OG couples. I squealed every time Jax and Juliet were mentioned, they just brought out the feels in me and made my feet kick back and forth. And here we are in the present, now with the bad ass heroine that is Dylan. I knew from reading , that Dylan was going to be one of my favorites and anticipated her book. Now that it's here, I can officially say that Penelope did her thing, and did her thing spectacularly!

After reading , you know that the twins, Kade and Hunter had a falling out. Which then led to Hunter transferring schools and living a different life than the one he had before with Dylan and Kade. He now attends a rivalry school. But all this time being gone, has made Dylan miss Hunter more and more;
"I've been homesick for him since he left..."

Dylan, being part of the Rivalry Week and Prisoner Exchange program gets to see Hunter once again after a year of being apart. And that's when the games begin. The Pirates and the Rebels... and what a sweet two weeks it is! Counting down until it's time for the final football game between the rivalry schools, Dylan and Hunter learn more about each other and the things that they have kept from each other. Hunter being the one who is pulling and pushing Dylan away and forward with his mixed emotions is what truly made me love his character and the development process he goes through this story. His adoration and obsession with Dylan, even after time being apart, never diminished. His thoughts about Kade and Dylan were just never in the right place until the time that the truth comes to light;
"It's not her fault. As Hunter, I want her so badly. I always have. As her family and her friend, I would tell her to get the hell way from both of us and meet new people..."

But even though Hunter's inner battles are there, he will never EVER stop being obsessed with Dylan. This kind of writing is the type of writing that I have missed from Penelope. She brings out the darkest of fantasies of all her characters. And we definitely get some kinky scenes in this book. The best kind of steam and action that made me want more. Hunter's WANT for Dylan goes to a level of fire, and addiction. I LOVE IT;
"The idea of her falling in love... Of her wanting anyone else... 'You were never anyone else's but mine,' I tell her..."

All in all, Penelope has brought out the same feelings I felt when I first started reading the Fall Away series. And bringing the OG characters back to life in this one has made this book extra special. With that being said, I am already anticipating the next book. And you DO NOT want to miss out on the small excerpt she releases at the end of this story. A highly anticipated couple that I am sure a lot of us have been craving for! Penelope, you already know that I need the like now ;)

The Hellbent Series:
Falls BoysPirate GirlsQuiet OnesNight ThievesFire FallsParade Alley

ARC kindly provided by the Penelope in exchange for an honest review...

Follow Me On:
❶ ❶ ❶
Profile Image for Lacey (laceybooklovers).
2,141 reviews12k followers
March 25, 2024
You have NO idea how happy I am to be back in a Penelope Douglas world. I've missed the Hellbent and Fall Away characters so much! Pirate Girls is a long-awaited sequel featuring Jared's baby girl Dylan, and Hunter, one of the Caruthers twins. It's childhood friends to lovers and my heart was so full the whole time I read reading Dylan and Hunter's romance 🥹 It's messy, angsty, dramatic, but through it all, you know these two are IT for each other.

I was born for her.


If you've read Falls Boys (which I highly recommend you read first), then you know Hunter and Kade had a falling out, and now Hunter attends a different high school from everyone. Hunter and his twin are rivals, attending rival schools and eventually they'll play against each other on the football field. There's so much the twins need to deal with and uncover before they can find their way back to each other but first... there's Rivalry Week.

Pirate Girls opens up with Rivalry Week and the Prisoner Exchange, and Hunter's school decides to take Dylan as their prisoner. So for two weeks, Dylan belongs to the town of Weston... and to Hunter. She stays in the haunted house right next to him, where they'll be neighbors for the exchange. He's not going to make it easy for her while she's on his side of town, but thankfully Dylan is just like her father: headstrong, stubborn, and fully capable of standing on her own.

I loved the push and pull between Dylan and Hunter! Technically, they're step-cousins, but I swear there's nothing weird about it lol. From the very beginning, you can feel how much Hunter has always wanted Dylan, how much he's always loved her since they were kids. This was 'he falls first' perfection. But things have gotten complicated and messy over the past few years, and the only way to unravel things is to confront each other head-on. And all I can say after finishing this book is that Hunter has always been Dylan's perfect match. Kade who????

If you're a Fall Away fan, you'll be VERY happy to know we get a ton of the OG cast in Pirate Girls 🥹 Jared being a girl dad is everything I ever wanted and more. Jared and Dylan have their own complicated relationship because they're just so damn similar to each other. She wants to race for her dad, he thinks it's too dangerous, so she starts learning without him. Of course, we also see Madoc and Fallon, Jax and Juliet, and Hunter's grandfather. We get plenty of Quinn as well � Quinn acts like more of an older sister/cousin to Dylan, and she shows up a good amount while she's on break from college. And for the Credence fans, say hi to Noah here!

Overall, I'm so happy that we have a new release from Penelope Douglas. I've missed their writing, their storytelling, and their romances. If you loved Falls Boys, you'll definitely have a good time with Pirate Girls.

...I'm also screaming, crying, throwing UP over who the next couple will be in Quiet Ones 😭 I literally shrieked when I go to the sneak preview of the 3rd Hellbent book! QUIET ONES CAN'T GET HERE QUICK ENOUGH FOR MEEE.



Jared & Tate’s daughter!!! With one of Madoc & Fallon’s twin boys!!!!!!

THANK YOU Pen for the arc 😭
Profile Image for Lanadia.
40 reviews18 followers
Want to read
March 22, 2022
I think it will be hunter and dylan. Then kade and tommy.
Profile Image for Phuong ✯.
680 reviews8,734 followers
May 15, 2024
� 4 stars

“I can hear your smiles when you talk,� I say. “I love that all of my baseball caps were once yours, and I love that you look for me.� I pause. “Or you used to.�

DYLANHUNTER

dylanhunter my babies � I’ve been waiting forever for their book, even if it wasn’t clear who Dylan would end up, I always knew it would be them and they delivered the teenage angst.

Dylan has always seen Hunter, while he has always felt like second best to his brother and never enough. That made me so sad. The mutual pining was killing me slowly. 😭All their scenes were so good.. that shower scene? TRUE LITERATURE IS BACK! That scene will forever and always live in my mind rent free. That’s how you write tension and longing. Alexa play ‘we can’t be friends� by Ariana Grande.

When Dylan got kidnapped and Hunter pretends to be Kade? First of all.. the self sabotage that Hunter did is INSAAAANEE .. the way I screamed at that dumbass. But Dylan saw right through his shit .. she KNOWS KNOWS him 😌

And I have to say that I’m obsessed with the fact that both of them were virgins and each others first. 🥺this trope never gets done in romance books with all the manwhores out there, so this was such a great change for once. And once we get to dylanhunter’s steamy scenes? the mirror scene? the car scene? The make up sex? I love them all.

“I’ve spent more of my waking hours with you than anyone. You’re in all of my history, Hunter.�

Dylan & Hunter were so perfect for each other. Both of them feel like the underdogs and lonely in their own way. Dylan, because she’s a girl wanting to do all these male dominated hobbies and Hunter, because he always feels like invisible compared to his twin brother. And they just get each other. Their love is so pure. 🥺👉👈

HUNTERKADE

“You’re right.� I swipe my baseball hat off the ground, having lost it at some point when they grabbed me from the car. “Leaving the Falls didn’t help a lot. I still think about you too much, and why you were such a godawful prick to me for so long.� His eyebrows dig deeper, and I fit the hat on my head, the bill at the back. “But the thing I just realized is that you’re obviously thinking about me, too, aren’t you?�

reading all the flashback scenes what Kade did to Hunter had me seeing red. I hated him and just wanted him to respectfully drown. Unpopular opinion, but after this book I still don’t like Kade.. I tolerate him and I’m happy Hunter has his brother back, but I can hold a grudge ✨�

I’ve been calling the reason why Kade acted like that towards Hunter from the beginning, cause I’ve read too many bully romances and just know the signs when the bully just wants the attention of their victime no matter if it’s the positive or negative kind 😂that loser should have communicate better tho.. as a kid I understand not knowing how, but they aren’t kids anymore. Hunter was not completely innocent in this conflict for not seeing it from his brother’s perspective, but how could he know. As he said he can’t read Kade’s mind. SPEAK UP BOY! 🗣�

The way Hunter felt like Farrow had his back more than his own twin is just sad. So the only Caruthers kid I acknowledge is Hunter and AJ Caruthers. Honestly AJ Caruthers for president I love her already <3

SIDE CHARACTERS

Jared and Maddoc as parents ahhh I’m screaming. It feels like a decade ago since I read their books, but seeing them back as parents and still bickering and fighting with each other made me unbelievably happy.

I liked the Rebels a lot. Especially Farrow always had Hunter and Dylan’s back. He was #1 dylanhunter shipper which was so cute. Or everytime he wanted to beat Kade when that shithead was doing sth again to provoke Hunter. Farrow is the best. I hope he gets a book.

PLOT

I have to say that I absolutely HATE the plot in Penelope Douglas� book. Not only in this series, but it already started in the Devil’s Night series. What is this mystery plot she always inserts in her books. I don’t give a fuck about the folklore and mystery surrounding these people who disappeared 20 years ago 😭I just want to read my cute little romance books with no plot, only romance and found family. That’s all.. But instead I had to read or better skimmed through so many pages of this stupid rivalry between Pirates and Rebels, the mystery about Deacon, Conor and Winslet. That’s the only thing I complain about this book, because the plot took too much from the book.

CONCLUSION

dylanhunter, you will always be loved by me! They were cute together 💕 Now, the next couple I’m excited about will be AJ & Christian that will we probably get in 2030 lmao. Please give me all the forbidden romance.
Profile Image for Iqra.
602 reviews5,259 followers
April 16, 2024
I realised i did in fact disappear for two days lmao but omfds this was soooo good! It had me staying up till five am just for that one last chapter.

DylanHunter were one of my most anticipated ship from Penelope � along with QuinnLucas � after finishing the fall away series and it deliveredddd on the angst 💅💅💅

There were certain scenes where I was like whatever and started skimming � the racing scenes (which happened too much unfortunately) and the “plot� with the mystery twins?? I genuinely couldn’t be bothered with it lollll it kinda ate out a lot of pages which could’ve been used for better development between Hunter and Kade.

Other than that I was eating up the back and forth with Dylan and Hunter. It did get a teeny bit tiring at the end but that’s mostly bc I was over the miscommunication happening every two seconds.

Kade can eat shit for the grief he put Hunter and Dylan thru. Like I genuinely wanted to force a pillow over his face while he slept.

This is definitely a book u have to read in one sitting or within two/three days to enjoy it or you’ll 100% become annoyed with the characters & plot. It’s rlly dense with drama, a lot is happening all the time and it’s so easy to find it tiring so yeah� all that to say, I’m rlly glad I finished it within a couple days lol.

ALSO OMG WE ARE BEING FEDDD- PENELOPE IS GIVING US QUINNLUCAS NEXT IM LITERALLY BOUNCING OFF THE WALLS IN EXCITEMENT AAHHHH
That Quiet Ones chapter was so good omfds I’m readyyyyyyyy

***

IVE BEEN WAITING TWO YRS FOR THEM AND I DIDNT EVEN REALISE THIS RELEASED TODAY 🙏

ONE OF TWO THINGS WILL HAPPEN, IM EITHER GNA DISAPPEAR FOR TWO DAYS OR IM GNA SPAM EVERYONE W UPDATES� BUT I JUST KNOW IMMA BE EATING GOOD TNIGHT 🤭✨�
Profile Image for Zekpie.
8 reviews3 followers
March 21, 2021
Hopefully it’s Kade and Dylan! 💖
Profile Image for vee!.
128 reviews3,825 followers
Want to read
July 22, 2023
i need a release date please 😭
Profile Image for ♡Gabi♡ [life & work is chaotic hiatus].
207 reviews356 followers
April 20, 2024
4.25 �

hunter caruthers and dylan mf trent supremacy! 🫶🏼🤭

love me a good childhood friends-to-lovers story with so much pining, tension, chemistry, and development. these two were so hot when they finally got together. 🫦 i love them!

i was so happy hunter and kade made so much progress in their very rocky relationship. all because they didn’t communicate with each other smh. those twins have my heart and had me emotional towards the end there. 😭

can’t wait to see kade meet his match with tommy! i can already tell she’s gonna be a firecracker with a headstrong personality. 😈

also, i need lucas and quinn’s story so bad omfg.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Samantha (bookgramsaga reviews).
826 reviews1,056 followers
April 17, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

''You were never anyone else's but mine''

Safety warnings:
- No cheating
- OW/OM drama
- Violence
- Mention of su*cide/r*pe
- Kidnapping
- Manipulation
- HFN (but we know it's HEA)

SPOILERS BELOW ⬇️

SPOILERS BELOW ⬇️

SPOILERS BELOW ⬇️

SPOILERS BELOW ⬇️

''And I was never anyone else's, either''

Hunter - I could write a whole ass love letter to this man and still would not be enough to describe how much I loved him. Despite how he has been acting, this boy is the sweetest. He is pure and I can see all the good Dylan sees in him without doubting it.

The mystery of why Hunter left, what pushed him and what has been going on with his twin brother Kade along with Dylan. I know people spend quite a while theorizing the issues and what the end game would be but honestly I was rooting for Hunter x Dylan from the beginning, and I am glad they got their story and their HEA.

I am not going to write the whole plot or summarize everything because this would end up being extremely long.

I'll say that this is one of those books where you need to pay attention to every sentence. Skipping even one can lead to missing out on some key moments and reveals.

Hunter and Kade's relationship have not been the same for years and we see Hunter's POV about what went wrong and how much Kade has destroyed him throughout the years. The constant pushes and keeps Hunter away from Dylan on purpose. Ignoring him and making him the outcast within the friend’s group at school. Also belittling him at every chance he got.

It's a lot. It's even safe to say you will hate Kade a bit, but his reasons will break your heart for the little boy who had to be this way in order to get what he wanted in the end and not let his fears come true.

Kade's reason for pushing Hunter the way he has for years is because he has known for over a decade that Hunter has been in love with Dylan and once they get together, Kade will lose his twin to her. As a child he viewed their moments together with envy and jealousy. He became more erratic with his need to keep them separate and it resulted in his actions.

NOW - Kade has never felt ANYTHING for Dylan beyond the cousin feeling. He does not want her nor has tried anything with her. During the year that Hunter had been gone, Kade barely spent any alone time with Dylan and did not seem to care much about what she was doing.

One thing to keep in mind is that they are teenagers and are immature to a certain degree. The way they go about things is not perfect and it sometimes borders on childishness.
However, everyone’s growth in this book is fantastic to see but it’s Hunter's growth in this book that is beautiful to witness as he came into his own and stopped feeling like he needed to win over Kade at every turn and also Kade’s growth by finally accepting the truth and revealing his faults that makes this story really come together.

Obviously, this is a love story which as so well done as well.

Dylan and Hunter have the slowest angsty moments in this book. She is taken as a ''hostage'' for two weeks per the school’s tradition and spends those two weeks with Hunter....well in the beginning he was an asshole and kept telling her to go home but eventually when he realizes how much she actually wants HIM and not Kade he comes around and wants to show her how much he has craved her too.

Dylan does not want Kade, she has been confused by his attention for years, but it's always been Hunter she yearns for and misses.

THE SEX SCENES: I loved every second. These two were so hot together. The first time anything serious happens (Chapter 15) was just e.v.e.r.y.t.h.i.n.g

FYI on Hunter: He is a virgin. Never seen anyone completely naked until Dylan. Never has wanted anyone else or has done anything with others. His entire life revolves around Dylan.
Dylan is in the same boat concerning her virginity and other guys.

There is a funny scene after the brothers get drunk together where they end up sleeping in the same bed as Dylan (nothing at all happens) and Jared walks in lol this was a great scene.

They will be each other’s first and last.

Another thing to be ready to cry about is the essay Kade wrote. It's heartbreaking. It's confusing at first but it slowly makes sense.

Here are some OW/OM drama info:

OM drama: Hunter believed Dylan and Kade have something going on and they are emotionally connected but it's debunked and these two have NOTHING going on and never have. It's all platonic/family feeling.
OW drama: Dylan believes that Hunter has been with other girls, and she also sees ''Hunter'' sleeping with another girl in his room but it's actually Kade messing with them. Hunter has never wanted anyone else.

This is technically an HFN as we only get a 7-months later epilogue, and they are very much in love BUT this series is not over yet and their interconnected stories will give us more info about their future.

There are also other bits of info that was revealed and explored:
- Farrow is revealed to being Hunter/Kade's uncle and their mother’s half-brother. Though he is the same age as them. Nobody else but Hunter/Farrow and their grandfather knows the truth.
- Tommy is going to be fierce and the perfect match for Kade
- Jared needs to go to therapy after all the shit he had to go through in this book and seeing the three of them in the same bed haha
- We get more info about the legend that surrounds the towns about the girl who was killed and the twin brothers. One of the twins died by suicide and the other is still very much alive with *drum roll* their older brother who was also involved in this chaos who happens to be the teacher we meet in this book but at the end he has disappeared...so this mystery has yet to be fully explained and is probably going to last until the final book?
- James is the MM romance in this series and not Kade as people previously thought
- Quinn and Lucas is official and it is the next book. At the end of this book, we get a preview of their book and it's going to be so good from what just got.

Honestly, this book was just a great way to end the series� center focus on their high school years because the next book and the remaining books will focus on them being older and will be set progressively in a few years� time.

Here are quotes that broke me:

''I've been homesick for him since he left.''

''I've been obsessed with you since we were kids.''

''I didn't want him, I idolized him.''

''Because she won't have me like this. She doesn't love me!''

''I knew you loved her, and whenever you finally...made love to her, it would be over for me. You'd be hers for the rest of your life.''

''I was born for her.''

''It's only been me. And there's only been her. For as long as I can remember.''
Profile Image for Ari.
91 reviews
April 14, 2024
Thoughts before reading book:
Oops nvm. My prediction was wrong. I think Dylan is going to end up with Hunter, and honestly, I’m fine with that. I’m re-reading Next To Never and Hunter was reminding Quinn to have the blueberry swirl brownies cause Dylan likes them. That’s so sweet


Final update/review after finishing book:

AHH THIS WAS GOOD. Dylan and Hunter 😩 don’t even know why I used to want her with Kade. Hunter is literally obsessed and adores her so much. Maybe it’s because it’s been years since the bonus content or maybe I’ve matured, but I would definitely pick Hunter as well. He’s so thoughtful and caring. Ughh he’s such a sweetheart. I also love how he’s always only wanted Dylan. I love how they both were each other’s first too. After reading Hawke’s book, I didn’t really expect any of the other guys to be virgins. But Hunter only ever wanted Dylan. That was really sweet.

Can’t wait to read Quinn and Lucas� book ughhh. I hope we don’t have to wait too long. I don’t really like age gap, but I feel like I will love their book. I need more crumbs from them. I’ve been re-reading any past scenes with them in it but I need more 😭
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for a..
628 reviews118 followers
July 29, 2024
3 star book. The one extra star is for the quinnlucas snippet that I’ve read more than what’s considered to be healthy.

✨✨�
- kade a radley sanatorium escapee (affectionate). the way he had my blood pressure fluctuating throughout the entire book 📈📉.
- dylanhunter were such bears.
- kadehunter are my life. the fighting, taunting, insecurities, and the way they were both obsessed with one another�..pd really served with that sibling relationship.
- chapter 26 had me in tears 😭 pd is very funny.
- love how this story really focuses more on the kids tbh but I do enjoy the glimpses we get at first gen as parents. madocjared ❤️❤️❤️
-
Profile Image for currently being delulu .
455 reviews194 followers
April 12, 2024
1 star for the parents.

Ps horrendous unedited review I’m not in the mood to fix read at your own squinting eyes risk


I was gonna give this three stars bc I’m tired of reading new Releases that I hate and truly parts of this book were fairly entertaining� but I decided to be true to my self and give an honest rating on how I feel.

***

� taps mic, hi my name is Gina and I admit that I would like for all the authors who really don’t want to be writing second gen series’s to admit that they really want to stop writing second gen series � bc it shows�

I think one upon time back when pen first teased abt all of these characters she was excited to write this. but like she said many times in her group it gets harder to deliver promises or ideas she once spoke abt. & then start writing the series� 6 years later. I get she’s a different writer now w different ideas and what she once had excitement & passion .. it probably drifted over the years with other books and ideas and just not being in the mood for it anymore I get it things change.

But I just think authors shouldn’t write second gen series if they really � don’t have any interest in it and are only writing it and finishing out the series bc they promised the readers. I’d rather read a Quality book than a run of the mill book where I couldn’t give less of a fuck abt the characters bc the author obviously didn’t either.


Review abt the book ⬇️ spoilers
****

Look Dylan and hunter don’t have any kind of problems or issues imo they are boring together & boring apart.
Their biggest issue was who was gonna run away from the other crying next bursting into tears instead of having a conversation together or idk .. talking bc who tf does that now a days � GO REBELS & PIRATES � …� shoot me pls wtf is This backdrop for the series pls someone actually explain to me this boring ass stupid fucking sports club wannabe gang theme w Urban fucking legend winslet still haunting everyone from the fucking grave.

The way I kept giggling into my pillow every-time this was brought up OMFG WHO CARES ABT THE URBAN LEGENDS I SURE AF DONT I WANT TO KNOW ABT THE CHARACTERS NOT STUPID FUCKING URBAN LEGENDS �. But then I guess the characters wouldn’t have a story would they?


One way to describe just abt all the characters in this series so far here’s a quote

. “I was a kid, Hunter. I still am in a lot of ways. There are so many feelings, I don’t know what to do with them sometimes.�
..



And look that’s not a bad thing but this series tbh feels very very � YA a lot of the times these kids actions and thoughts feel so kiddish & immature that it feels like I’m reading abt YA rather than new adult minus the weird ass cringe smut. And I get it okay they don’t have any kind of real pain or problems or issues so really how can I blame them for well sounding like kids when that’s exactly what they are .. but me personally idk it felt icky reading abt such emotionally immature ppl w all the sex scenes.



Also really kade? all this fucking started over a fucking dog and that you were jealous bc Dylan was taking hunter’s attention away from you?? I mean I kinda already knew he didn’t have a thing for Dylan it was obvious in falls boys but SERIOUSLY THIS WAS HIS BEEF.

Someone needs to let Penelope Douglas & rina kent know their weird twinsest brotherly love/bickering won’t make their books sell any faster than they already do with their recycled plots.


Look I just don’t vibe with second gen I think it’s a mistake authors tend to make in their writing careers when they get to big they deliver promises that don’t deliver.

Also I wasn’t impressed w Quinn’s appearance in this Penelope teased that she’d be in here but Penelope made it sound like we’d all love Quinn in this book and tbh � she was kinda Blah like I could take her or leave her she didn’t impress me like I was hoping she would have
she’s apparently still stuck in a little girl mindset daydreaming abt Lucas and still wearing his baseball cap from 8 years ago…just what I wanted to see especially after reading next to never and thinking she was gonna start living her life and not be stuck while Lucas came back and would start being obsessed w her while she slowly forget abt him a little bit not still clung to his memory.

Maybe she won’t be but that teaser for quiet ones didn’t really get me excited how tf is she still 21 feeling younger than her cousins bc why exactly? Babe ur older than them and run your own business while they literally think their in rebel without a cause living of their parents money cuz they bad.


I did like seeing farrow & Noah. and kinda loved seeing them look at Quinn tho I think Noah is interested bc she reminds him of Tiernan. farrow?? Not sure I think him & Noah have a pissing contest w each-other in the future� maybe they could be a future couple it would be interesting.


Am I exited abt quiet ones uh not really but hopefully Penelope will actually start liking what she’s writing and we’ll get a decent plot for their story. But I can feel it being the girl obsessed trope and I rebuke that in Jesus name amen 🤞

Also apparently Lucas might be into some rope Kink BDSM .. great kaleb 2.0 I’m being such a little sour puss on this book but it really did suck for me I’m sorry I have to say I hated Dylan & hunter and wished they both kinda .. idk died? Maybe that would have been interesting and they could have joined winslet in a afterlife threesome to put her to rest.

Ngl kade low key made this book interesting w him being a huge asshole for no reason to everyone but then kinda ruined it w his beef w hunter being abt that Dylan took hunter away from him and he didn’t know how to deal w his emotions.


My safety ppl here we go

Both virgins only w each other
No sharing or op of any kind
No ow or om drama � kade doesn’t count�


Also apparently farrow kelly is fallons half sibling I think him & Noah might be a thing .. possibly.

Jarred made that one Scene where he found kade hunter & Dylan a five star for me.
Profile Image for Christy.
4,382 reviews35.5k followers
November 18, 2024
3.5 stars

I was so excited to read a Dylan/Hunter book after reading the first in this series. I did like this one much better than the first, but for some reason it dragged for me. I wish it was faster paced or shorter, but overall it was a good listen.
Audio book source: Hoopla
Story Rating: 3.5 stars
Narrators: Axel Bosley & Shiloh James
Narration Rating: 4 stars
Genre: Romance
Length: 14h 17m




Profile Image for andi ✿.
75 reviews
Want to read
March 21, 2022
I'm even more excited about this than I am for the story of Quinn and Lucas. It doesn't matter to me who Dylan ends up with. However, after reading that Fall Away Christmas bonus scene, I'm leaning towards Hunter. Simply because he gave something to her. His red and black St. Matthew’s Knights shirt and a cassette tape with a note underneath that says "My colors would look good on you, Pirate." Idk, but reading that part just did something to me 🤧
Profile Image for *.
103 reviews89 followers
November 20, 2024
3.9�

3.75 felt too low for how much I enjoyed it. The rivalry, tension, fighting for dominance, battling insecurities, and jealousy were so well written and kept me hooked but 4 stars felt slightly high. The intimate scenes didn't hit the way the first book did. The pacing slowed down in the middle but the plot suspense, parents scenes and HunterKade confrontation was everything.

I'm really curious about the plot. There are a few theories I came up with but everything seems so confusing and I love this thing about the author, you can always count on PD to write a gripping plot.

And of course I'm the only one who shipped DylanNoah 😭.I really love them so much. He was always there for her when she needed it.
Profile Image for Lauren ♡.
208 reviews36 followers
Currently reading
April 12, 2024
Update May 2023:
"Maybe I didn’t realize all of this when he was around—or realize how much I’d miss him—but I always knew I loved him. He and Kade were never a package deal for me. It wasn’t both or nothing. They were always distinguishable from each other. I need Hunter."

I think I might be wrong, it just might be Hunter... and I might just be ok with it. Still no date yet for release.. but I am super excited for this one!
________
I am continuing my re-read of the Fall Away series but thinking about the epilogue from , scenes, and bonus content that Pen posted on her website has me so hyped up for this book. It is assumed that Pirate Girls will be Dylan's book (Jared & Tate's daughter) with one of Madoc & Fallon's twins.

Let's start the great debate: Kade or Hunter?

Team Kade for me, but I won't be terribly upset if it is Hunter either... I just feel what is known so far shows Hunter as a best friend rather than being the soul deep love for Dylan.

Yes, it'll be awhile before it comes out and there is NO release date yet but I am excited to see more on this next gen!

description

HELLBENT SERIES
#1TBR
#2 Pirate GirlsTBR
#3TBR
#4TBR
#5TBR
#6TBR
11 reviews
Read
March 21, 2022
I'm prepared to be wrong, I don't really mind who she ends up with but I have a feeling it's Hunter and Kade is the MM one.

1. I read this is set around rivalry week and Hunter's new school and Dylan + kade school are rivals.

2. Hunter calls her Pirate girl in the letter from the snippets PD released. He also mentioned rivalry week.

Edit: I've changed my mind, I don't think Kade is the MM one , think he'll end up with Tommy and their book is Night Thieves
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for rey.
238 reviews
April 14, 2024
team Hunter for me :)

edit
5/5⭐️

i cannot move on from this book. I am unwelllllll!!!!! i have so many thoughts that i simply dont know how to express them one by one. i read this at 3am the moment it came out (est time zone) and finished it in just a few hours. i've been rereading few of the scenes repeatedly ESPECIALLY THE TEASER AT THE END OMFGGG!!

anywayssss... long story short this was amazing. it had everything i needed and wanted. penelope douglas is an amazing writer. i love how they can just write character dynamics and tension mixed with exciting plot so well. literally their writing is so unique and enticing that it just hits so well ya know. i cannot wait for the other books in the series BECAUSE I'M JUST SO EXCITED. Penelope Douglas is one of the authors that whatever they write I WILL BUY IT!!

forever obsessed!
Profile Image for ivona.
161 reviews5 followers
Read
April 13, 2024
march 2022:the only right answer is dylanhunter and tommykade
april 2024: AND I WAS SO RIGHT
Profile Image for Juana.
137 reviews13 followers
August 5, 2024
DYLAN AND KADE ENDGAME I’M BEGGING YOU PEN (2021)

Ese comentario lo puse hace mucho tiempo, es hora de aceptar la realidad: CAÍ ENAMORADA DE DYLAN Y HUNTER, Taylor Swift escribió Midnight Rain pensando en ellos dos. Muchas cosas de las que hablar, pero primero, la quote:

“I love her. She’s social. I’m not. She loves crowds and noise. I don’t. She hates school, and I could keep going forever. She’d risk her life just to feel a rush, while I consider my choices too much. She’s so much like Kade, but she fits my heart like she was cut from it. It’s always been hers.�

Bueno bueno buenooooo debo decir que Penelope lo hizo, ME HIZO DYLANHUNTER shipper. Este es un libro que me costó MUCHO ponerme a leer, no quería, estaba completamente negada a este ship, yo queria a Dylan y Kade juntos a muerte, me parecian una pareja que re podía matchear y me habia quedado enamorada de ellos cuando eran chicos, igualmente nada me va a sacar de mi teoría sobre que Penelope cuando escribió Fall Away pensó en Dylan y Kade juntos, después con el tiempo fue cambiando de opinión pero se justificó todo muy bien así que no me quejo.
Estaba tan empecinada con Dylan y Kade que incluso llegué a odiar a Dylan, no es chiste, en Falls Boys me acuerdo que se me hacía insoportable. Incluso estaba rogando para que no haya nada rari, ni sentimientos Dylan-Kade, no trios ni nada (Penelope más vale que este universo siga siendo extra monogamico), por suerte escribió el libro perfecto y no tuve problema con eso, para Dylan siempre fue Hunter y para Hunter siempre fue Dylan.
Imaginense mi sorpresa que este libro me encantó desde el principio, ya desde el primer capitulo estaba 100% adentro, amando a los personajes y re metida en la historia, Dylan es por lejos uno de los mejores personajes femeninos que alguna vez leí, una reina.
Como dije recien, Dylan ME ENCANTÓ, tenía las ideas MUY claras con todo, de verdad me sorprendió MUCHÍSIMO su personaje, amo que haya sido toda una bad bitch y dentro de todo la “brooding� de la relación. Es un personaje que se anima a todo, no le tiene miedo a nada y tiene claro lo que quiere y no tiene miedo de conseguirlo i mean la chica estuvo viviendo con esos dos turbios sin darse cuenta (me dio un miedo cuando leí ese capitulo). Pero en fin, Dylan Trent TE REZO, perdón por haberte odiado, no entendía NADA. Ayudó mucho el hecho de que haya dejado claro mil veces que no estaba interesada en Kade igual, las cosas como son.
Hunter Caruthers, puedo tener un Hunter en mi vida? LO NECESITO, es el chabon mas bueno que leí en mi vida, es todo lo que esta bien y este comentario viene de alguien que siempre va a elegir al chico brooding y no al golden pero Hunter- me conquistó, me enamoró. Me dio tanta ternura que se haya guardado para ella, fue un hermoso childhood friends to lovers, perdon por haberte menospreciado Hunter, no super valorarte pero DIOS QUE HOMBRE osea entienden que estaba dispuesto a dejar de lado su felicidad y lo que queria con tal de que Dylan fuera feliz? ESTABA DISPUESTA A ENTREGARSELA A KADE, nono Hunter Caruthers el hombre definitivo, te amo muchisimo. Su lugar DEFINITIVAMENTE es Weston y creo que les hizo bien a todos que el se fuera durante un tiempo, el espacio era lo que necesitaban para darse cuenta que de verdad se querían. Hermanas, le hizo una playlist que se llamaba “Pirate Girl� ya está, de verdad es el hombre definitivo, encima me mataba que el le habia dicho “te amo� como dos veces Y ELLA SEGUÍA SIN DECIRSELO, igual era obvio lo que sentía, se amaron desde toda la vida.
A Kade quise zamarrearlo un par de veces durante la historia, cada vez que me enojaba o me frustraba volvía a leer la carta que le escribió a Thomasin porque la verdad que a veces hacia cosas que me daban ganas de pegarle. Es un fuckboy de pies a cabeza que se garcha todo lo que pase, NO PUEDO ESPERAR a que caiga a los pies de Thomasin. Casi lloro con la carta que escribió para que Hunter entrara a la universidad, el solo quería a su hermano para él y no sabia como expresarlo en palabras, tengo la sensación de que Kade va a ser escritor en un futuro. Pero de verdad me alegro de que haya podido recuperar su relación con Hunter, solo necesitaban HABLARLO, se llevan tan naturalmente bien, me encantó verlos como verdaderos hermanos. Estoy muy ansiosa por conocerlo de verdad, a el en primera persona y no a través de los ojos de los demás porque más allá de que algunas actitudes de él no me gustaron en esta historia, fue el primer personaje de Hellbent que captó mi atención.
Farrow� no entendí mucho por qué meterle tanto misterio a él si al final ese tema quedó en la nada, Fallon merece saber que tiene un hermano, ah y btw, era demasiado obvio que era hijo de Ciaran y me molestó no ver cómo se desarrollaba eso, por qué Hunter sabía? Como que quedó muy abierto ese tema y dudo que se toque en Quiet Ones. En fin, amé a Farrow, quiero tenerlo de bestie. Lo que me lleva a otro tema: QUIERO SER UNA REBEL, algo que diferencia a los Rebels de los Pirates es el sentimiento de comunidad que tienen, Hunter y Dylan se sintieron más en casa ahí que en Falls Y CON RAZÓN, sé que Aro tenía una vida de mierda ahí pero de verdad fue hermoso ver como todos se apoyan entre ellos y lowkey me pone un poco triste no volver a ver tan de primera mano el otro lado del rio, espero que con el libro de Tommy se puedan retomar las historias de ellos, aunque Tommy ahora sea una Pirate pero bueno, de corazón es una Rebel y yo tambien quiero ser una.
Con respecto a la leyenda� me da la sensación que es algo que va a pasar durante todo Hellbent, yo pensé que se iba a cortar acá pero no, me molestó que le diera ese “final�, dónde fue Bastian? Qué pasó con ellos? Se fueron de la casa? Quedó demasiado abierto ese tema para mi gusto, encima no me gustó que hayan hablado de Quinn, A QUINN NO ME LA TOCAN. Pero volviendo, me gusta mucho el contraste de la historia de los protagonistas per se con la leyenda urbana, un muy buen plot twist hubo con lo de Manas, no me lo esperaba, aunque lo de Bastian un poco me lo veía venir aunque pensé que era Conor pero EN FIN, necesito saber que le pasó a Winsley aunque claramente no era ninguna santa, debo admitir igual que ese capitulo narrado por Bastian/Manas me gustó osea no porque la Winsley se cogiera a los dos, sino porque fue inesperado y saber que estaban viviendo con Dylan #miedo.
Me encantó vivir la Rivalry Week, me encantó volver a ver a mis personajes favoritos de Fall Away, a Aro y Hawke, Kade, Tommy, Quinn, los amo MUCHISIMO a todos, incluso a James que está bastante estupidizado ahora de chico y a A.J. que se nota que va a ser un personaje con mucha personalidad. Me encantó también que Jared FINALMENTE confíe en Dylan y la deje correr en motos y que Farrow y Noah la ayuden, mi reina merece ser la mejor corredora de motos, periodooo. Pero volviendo, amé como se desarrolló la historia y la relación de Dylan y Hunter, estaban destinados a estar juntos y se dio todo de manera muy natural, me encantó eso, no se por qué evité tanto leer este libro, me estaba perdiendo una joyita y me está matando el hecho de saber que tengo que esperar (con suerte) hasta el año que viene para volver a verlos, quiero saber como siguen las relaciones de todos y viendolos vivir su mejor vida, me quedé enamorada de la relación y la confianza que se tienen Hunter y Dylan, no super ver el potencial de la pareja pero Penelope si y me convenció al toque de que ellos eran meant to be.
AHORA, dos cositas más:

“Sorry, Dylan,� Thomasin says, wiping off the water under her chin. “But I think I’ll let Kade have his fun, after all.�
She slides the glass door shut and walks away, letting out a long breath.
“I’ll be fun, too, someday,� she whispers.�

TODO EL PUTO LIBRO ESPERANDO UNA INTERACCIÓN THOMASINKADE, ese final� TENES QUE CERRAR EL ESTADIO. La única escena de ellos dos fue cuando Hunter y Kade estaban manejando al baile y la vieron en el puente y Kade le dice todo serio “Get. Down.� diooooos yo dije nono ESA no puede ser la única escena así que quedé gratamente sorprendida cuando la ultima escena de todas fue de ELLA. Dylan dijo que Kade necesita una chica que sea una santa o que rivalice con su personalidad, creo que ya sabemos cual de las dos va a ser Tommy, LO QUE NECESITO el libro de esos dos, me emocionan un montón, tienen MUCHO potencial.

La segunda cosa Y LA MAS IMPORTANTE:

“Lucas Morrow and I are too old to play together now.�

QUINNLUCAS NADIE LOS AMA MÁS QUE YO. Debo admitir que apenas tuve Pirate Girls en mis manos me fui a leer ese adelanto, lo leí hace meses y lo releí BASTANTES veces más. LUCAS ESTÁ DE VUELTA EN FALLS Y MÁS VALE QUE NO SE VAYA. Al fin van a estar los dos en un mismo lugar y ya siendo adultos, Lucas com sogas� nono estos dos PROMETEN. Además espero que ya para su libro le digan a Quinn sobre Carnival Tower, a fin de cuentas está en SU pastelería. Hermanas lo que grité con la gorra, esta pareja promete MUCHISIMO y me entusiasma un montón leerlos, este ship y thomasinkade es por lo que sigo viva, le imploro a Penelope que se apure para escribirlos porque NO AGUANTO MÁS. Me encantan, Quinn está enamorada desde siempre de Lucas, incluso en Pirate Girls Dylan también lo dice. No pueeo esperar para leerlos.

En fin, estoy MUY sorprendida con todo lo que me gustó este libro, tenia expectativas muy bajas pero Penelope Douglas lo hizo de nuevo, es por esto que es una de mis autoras favoritas, su manera de escribir, la quimica de los personajes, las historias de misterio que involucra en la trama, los lugares que crea, es todo impresionante y me vuela la cabeza, te rezo Penelope. Los amo Dylan y Hunter, espero seguir viendolos viviendo su mejor vida a lo largo de todo Hellbent, se lo merecen.
Profile Image for Ꮗ€♫◗☿ ❤️ ilikebooksbest.com ❤️.
2,665 reviews2,537 followers
May 5, 2024
More Fall Away second gen!



The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙🖤💚❤️
Heat/Steam: 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Story/Plot: 📕📗📙📘
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌍
Character development: 😔🤓😘😄
Narration: 🎙🎙
Narration Type: Dual Narration

The heroine: Dylan Trent - she is the daughter of Jared and Tatum Trent from Bully. Dylan is a senior in high school and rivalry week is about to start, though it technically lasts two weeks. She races motorcycles, though her parents don’t know about it, and she would like to keep it that way since her father (who owns a cycle racing team), doesn’t want her racing motorcycles. She grew up next door to her Uncle Jax and his wife and kids. Her best friend Aro lives next door as well and dates her cousin Hawke. She grew up in Shelburne Falls whose rivals are Weston. Shelburne Falls is the wealthy suburb, while Weston is inner-city and filled with kids who grew up in rougher situations.

The Heroes: Hunter Caruthers - Hunter goes to Weston while his twin Kade goes to Shelburne Falls. Kade can’t wait to face his brother on the field during rivalry week. They are cousins with Dylan Trent, though they don’t share any blood. The brothers grew up with Dylan, their fathers are stepbrothers and Hunter hasn’t been around since he moved and enrolled in St. Mathew’s, a Weston school. When they were together at Thanksgiving, Hunter wouldn’t even look at Dylan and rarely speaks to his brother Kade.

The Story: The rivalry between the Shelburne Falls Pirates and the Weston Rebels is exciting and crazy and includes a prisoner exchange. Each school sends a prisoner to the rival school for two weeks. Weston wants Dylan as their prisoner and when she finds out they have a motorcycle she can use, she agrees, though they tell them that Hunter left Weston and doesn’t go there anymore, when Kade asks for Hunter in the prisoner exchange. Dylan is the first woman Shelburne Falls traded since the girl that never came home, story was that she was tied up in the trunk of a car that went over a bridge and she drowned.



I liked this story quite a bit, there were definitely a lot of references to the Fall Away series as Dylans parents were a big part of that series. Hunter and Kade’s parents were Madoc and Fallon, so were a part of that same series. Not to mention the prominence of racing which was a huge theme in that series. I loved that series, so I liked all the references.

I also liked this couple, it was so obvious from the beginning that they had been in love with each other for years, but Kade was in the middle of it, which caused issues with both of them. The only thing I didn’t really like is how innocent both of them were. I wish that Hunter would have been a bit more self assured, and it would have been nice if they both were more sexually experienced.

This audiobook was done in dual points of view via dual narration and was narrated by Shiloh James and Axel Bosley. Shiloh has a nice voice which is soft yet clear and is a good narrator, though not one of my favorites, but she definitely sounded age appropriate for this story. Axel Bosley doesn’t sound age appropriate at all. He sounds too old, and his voice isn’t deep like I like male narrators to be. It was extremely annoying.

|ŷ||||
Profile Image for Sarah.
1,859 reviews1,351 followers
April 3, 2024
4.5 (I go back and forth between 4 and 5 so here we are)

This book was nothing that I was expecting! Yes, there is a romance, but there was also this really interesting dynamic with the brothers as well. Once, I got into the book, I couldn't put it down. To avoid spoilers, I am going to leave it at that.

What did I love:
-Dylan is so much like her dad, and I am sucker for a heroine who is her own person. I love that she found a place of belonging in her book.
-Hunter's evolution as a character was really amazing. I loved the revelation he comes to at the end. It was poignant and really impactful.
-Kade, what a little sh!!!T, but I loved him even when I wanted to throttle him.
-The Weston crew. I loved them all, and I know it is an author's worst nightmare to see this, but I want books for them, Fallow particularly.
- Any cameos of the parents. I live for them and eat them up. Reminds me so much of why I love them.
-I really loved this idea that the your happy ending can look different and change. Your goal and dream will evolve as you evolve, and I think sometimes we hold onto something we think we want vs. considering what we really want. I also love the idea of POV matters. How one person sees and event and feels about it might not be how someone else sees the same exact thing. Both sides are valid and communication is important.
-Pen's writing as always is amazing. There were so many lines that just hit me in my soul and have me being like YESSS, this. I love that they write unique characters and storylines, and their diction and syntax are just always so well done. I will read anything they write.

What I needed more;
-It took a bit for the story to get going. This story is very character / relationship driven vs. plot driven, and while it takes place during rivalry week, I did expect the events to play a bigger role in the story.
-I wish the mystery they are solving or researching was playing a more prominent role. It feels a bit like it always is like the last ending piece. It is really interesting to me and how it connects the two towns, but it doesn't always feel like a part of the story, more a secondary storyline that runs separate from the main couple story.

Pirate Girl solidified what I already knew, I LOVE this world, these characters, Pen's writing. I am already dying for the next one they tease at the end of Pirate Girl.
Profile Image for sasha.
155 reviews94 followers
April 13, 2024
i’m not used to the author writing normal and healthy relationships
Profile Image for Jessica .
2,469 reviews15.6k followers
May 9, 2024
4.5 stars

Reading a new Penelope Douglas book us always so nostalgic and I just love feeling like I was in the Bully and Corrupt worlds again. We have high school kids causing all kinds of antics and the heroine wanting her best friend to talk to her again. So she is "kidnapped" by the other school to see him again and has to spend two weeks on their side of town and going to their school. I really loved this relationship dynamic and how things progressed. I will say there were soooo many characters and it was sometimes hard for me to keep track of them all, but the vibes of this book were so good. There are no rules and the characters just cause all sorts of mayhem. The brother dynamic was adorable in the end and I just had so much fun reading this one!!
Profile Image for ☆K☆.
351 reviews8 followers
Read
January 30, 2023
Okay maybe I'm way way off. Maybe this won't even happen, but do you guys remember the story Hawke was telling Aro about the twins who shared the same girl and that's how the rivalry week was created? This book would be brilliant if the story just repeated itself
Profile Image for lex.
425 reviews350 followers
June 5, 2024
another GENUINELY romantic and healthy couple from pen?! jaws dropped and hell felt a nice, cool breeze this year!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,102 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.