What do you think?
Rate this book
Still Alice
She didn’t want to become someone people avoided and feared. She wanted to live to hold Anna’s baby and know it was her grandchild. She wanted to see Lydia act in something she was proud of. She wanted to see Tom fall in love. She wanted to read every book she could before she could no longer read.
Alice Howland is proud of the life she has worked so hard to build. A Harvard professor, she has a successful husband and three grown children. When Alice begins to grow forgetful, she initially dismisses it. But when she gets lost in her own neighborhood, she realizes that something is terribly wrong. Alice finds herself in the rapid downward spiral of Alzheimer’s disease. She is only 50 years old.
While Alice once placed her worth and identity in her celebrated academic career, she must now re-evaluate her relationship with her husband, her expectations of her children, and her ideas about herself and her place in the world.
Losing her yesterdays, with her short-term memory hanging on by a few frayed threads, she is living in the moment, taking life day by day. But she is still Alice.
Still Alice is as compelling as A Beautiful Mind and as powerful as Ordinary People. This novel provides a moving glimpse into the lives of those affected by early-onset Alzheimer’s and will leave you deeply inspired and reflective long after you’ve finished reading.
Alice Howland is proud of the life she has worked so hard to build. A Harvard professor, she has a successful husband and three grown children. When Alice begins to grow forgetful, she initially dismisses it. But when she gets lost in her own neighborhood, she realizes that something is terribly wrong. Alice finds herself in the rapid downward spiral of Alzheimer’s disease. She is only 50 years old.
While Alice once placed her worth and identity in her celebrated academic career, she must now re-evaluate her relationship with her husband, her expectations of her children, and her ideas about herself and her place in the world.
Losing her yesterdays, with her short-term memory hanging on by a few frayed threads, she is living in the moment, taking life day by day. But she is still Alice.
Still Alice is as compelling as A Beautiful Mind and as powerful as Ordinary People. This novel provides a moving glimpse into the lives of those affected by early-onset Alzheimer’s and will leave you deeply inspired and reflective long after you’ve finished reading.
374 pages, Paperback
First published July 6, 2007
6,022 people are currently reading
206k people want to read
About the author
Lisa Genova
18books10.9kfollowersLisa Genova graduated valedictorian, summa cum laude from Bates College with a degree inBiopsychology and has a Ph.D. in Neuroscience from Harvard University.
�
Acclaimed as the Oliver Sacks of fiction and the Michael Crichton of brain science, Lisa has captured a special place in contemporary fiction, writing stories that are equally inspired by neurological conditions and our shared human condition. She is the New York Times bestselling author of the novels STILL ALICE, LEFT NEGLECTED, LOVE ANTHONY, INSIDE THE O'BRIENS, and EVERY NOTE PLAYED.
�
Her first work of nonfiction, REMEMBER: The Science of Memory and the Art of Forgetting, published March 2021, became an instant New York Times bestseller.
�
STILL ALICE was adapted into a film starring Julianne Moore, Alec Baldwin, Kristen Stewart, Kate Bosworth and
Hunter Parrish. Julianne Moore won the 2015Best Actress Oscar for her role as Alice Howland. Film adaptations for INSIDE THE O'BRIENS, EVERY NOTE PLAYED, and LEFT NEGLECTED are in development.
�
STILL ALICE was adapted for the stage by Christine Mary Dunford and premiered at the Lookingglass Theatre in Chicago in April 2013. It has since toured worldwide.
�
In 2015, Lisa was named one of the U.S. Top 50 Influencers in Aging by Next Avenue. She has appeared on Live with Kelly &Ryan, the TODAY show, CNN, PBS Newshour, Dr. Oz, and NPR and has been featured in the PBS specials Build a Better Memory Through Science and Supercharge Your Brain, as well as the documentary films To Not Fade Away and Have You Heard About Greg.
�
Her first TED talk, "What You Can Do To Prevent Alzheimer's" has been viewed over eight million times. Her most recent TED talk, "How Memory Works--and Why Forgetting is Totally OK" was the sixth most watched TED talk of 2021. A sought-after speaker/edutainer, she has headlined in speaker series alongside Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Gloria Steinem, Jay Leno, Malala Yousafzai, and Goldie Hawn.
She received The Pell Center Prize for Story in the Public Square, for "distinguished storytelling that has enriched the public dialogue," The Sargent and Eunice Shriver Profiles in Dignity Award, The Global Genes RARE Champions of Hope Award, and The American College of Neuropsychopharmacology Media Award for "informing the public about treatment and ongoing research in medical illness."
She has received an Honorary Doctorate of Humane Letters from Bates College, The Alzheimer's Association's Rita Hayworth Award, The Huntington’s Disease Society of America Community Awareness Award, and the Grubby Award for literary excellence.
�
She serves on the Advisory Boards for TheWomen's Alzheimer's Movement, HFC (Hilarity for Charity), and Compassionate Care ALS.
�
Acclaimed as the Oliver Sacks of fiction and the Michael Crichton of brain science, Lisa has captured a special place in contemporary fiction, writing stories that are equally inspired by neurological conditions and our shared human condition. She is the New York Times bestselling author of the novels STILL ALICE, LEFT NEGLECTED, LOVE ANTHONY, INSIDE THE O'BRIENS, and EVERY NOTE PLAYED.
�
Her first work of nonfiction, REMEMBER: The Science of Memory and the Art of Forgetting, published March 2021, became an instant New York Times bestseller.
�
STILL ALICE was adapted into a film starring Julianne Moore, Alec Baldwin, Kristen Stewart, Kate Bosworth and
Hunter Parrish. Julianne Moore won the 2015Best Actress Oscar for her role as Alice Howland. Film adaptations for INSIDE THE O'BRIENS, EVERY NOTE PLAYED, and LEFT NEGLECTED are in development.
�
STILL ALICE was adapted for the stage by Christine Mary Dunford and premiered at the Lookingglass Theatre in Chicago in April 2013. It has since toured worldwide.
�
In 2015, Lisa was named one of the U.S. Top 50 Influencers in Aging by Next Avenue. She has appeared on Live with Kelly &Ryan, the TODAY show, CNN, PBS Newshour, Dr. Oz, and NPR and has been featured in the PBS specials Build a Better Memory Through Science and Supercharge Your Brain, as well as the documentary films To Not Fade Away and Have You Heard About Greg.
�
Her first TED talk, "What You Can Do To Prevent Alzheimer's" has been viewed over eight million times. Her most recent TED talk, "How Memory Works--and Why Forgetting is Totally OK" was the sixth most watched TED talk of 2021. A sought-after speaker/edutainer, she has headlined in speaker series alongside Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Gloria Steinem, Jay Leno, Malala Yousafzai, and Goldie Hawn.
She received The Pell Center Prize for Story in the Public Square, for "distinguished storytelling that has enriched the public dialogue," The Sargent and Eunice Shriver Profiles in Dignity Award, The Global Genes RARE Champions of Hope Award, and The American College of Neuropsychopharmacology Media Award for "informing the public about treatment and ongoing research in medical illness."
She has received an Honorary Doctorate of Humane Letters from Bates College, The Alzheimer's Association's Rita Hayworth Award, The Huntington’s Disease Society of America Community Awareness Award, and the Grubby Award for literary excellence.
�
She serves on the Advisory Boards for TheWomen's Alzheimer's Movement, HFC (Hilarity for Charity), and Compassionate Care ALS.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31,340 reviews
June 22, 2011
After you read this, you will never look at Alzheimer's the same again. Nor will you ever forget it. Oh the irony.
I'd always correlated Alzheimer's disease with old age and heard the best way to combat it was to exercise your brain. I do my fair share of reading, can solve a Sudoku puzzle faster than 98% of the population, and I shun mindless chick flicks for your more intelligent thrillers, but I'll never be as brilliant as Alice, a 50-year-old Harvard professor diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's. If she had been a little shallow to begin with or 20 years older. If my own aunt weren't suffering from an advanced stage of the disease right now. If I weren't feeling a little hazy myself when I'm up half the night with an infant. Maybe then I could have put another barrier between me and Alzheimer's, but I can't. Alice's story scared me. A lot. After all, what are we without the identity of our thoughts? So much for those Sudoku puzzles.
I lived Alice's story right along with her, crying when she cried and smiling at her accomplishments. Telling your story from such an unreliable witness is a tough job and Genova handles it beautifully. As the book progresses, the scenes feel more and more misplaced. As a reader I was thrust into the situation along with Alice, unsure of the setting or the time or what had happened five minutes before. Genova also offers some poignant scenes where we the reader know what Alice has forgotten and our heart breaks for her. When she forgets her daughter, her husband, the layout of her house, how to lick an ice cream cone, we mourn the Alice lost right along with her and her family. I can't imagine losing everything I learned, all the way back to basic needs like how to walk, feed, or even use the bathroom. I felt Alice's frustration at forgetting words and people and most of all being shut out because she was stigmatized with this disease as though she were already dead.
Because the narration is told through Alice, there are a few plot points that get lost, but I think we gain more than we lose from her perspective. And those lost points add to all she loses. Sometimes the descriptions of Boston get a little lengthy and the medical descriptions cold and drawn-out, giving the novel a little bit of a medical journal instead of novel feel, but I was still captivated by Alice and her plight, and I loved that Genova had the background to give us a real look into Alzheimer's, to make it come alive in the pages.
Even though the story is told through Alice's unreliable eyes, I felt for each of the characters in her family as well. When I wanted to be angry at John for avoiding the disease, I couldn't. I felt for him. Having a spouse go through Alzheimer's must be one of the hardest things. Not only do you watch your spouse suffer and take on the role of full-time caretaker, a major life-changing physical and financial burden, but you lose your partner and confidante. And to experience early-onset when you should be experiencing some of the best of life is devastating. I could see why he didn't want to deal with it.
I wouldn't want to see a parent go through this either. I don't know. It's hard to think about. I hope I never have to.
I can't stop thinking about Alzheimer's and hoping they come up with a cure soon. Genova has done a fabulous job bringing attention to this debilitating disease and I love that she self-published because it was too important to wait. Kudos, Genova.
I'd always correlated Alzheimer's disease with old age and heard the best way to combat it was to exercise your brain. I do my fair share of reading, can solve a Sudoku puzzle faster than 98% of the population, and I shun mindless chick flicks for your more intelligent thrillers, but I'll never be as brilliant as Alice, a 50-year-old Harvard professor diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's. If she had been a little shallow to begin with or 20 years older. If my own aunt weren't suffering from an advanced stage of the disease right now. If I weren't feeling a little hazy myself when I'm up half the night with an infant. Maybe then I could have put another barrier between me and Alzheimer's, but I can't. Alice's story scared me. A lot. After all, what are we without the identity of our thoughts? So much for those Sudoku puzzles.
I lived Alice's story right along with her, crying when she cried and smiling at her accomplishments. Telling your story from such an unreliable witness is a tough job and Genova handles it beautifully. As the book progresses, the scenes feel more and more misplaced. As a reader I was thrust into the situation along with Alice, unsure of the setting or the time or what had happened five minutes before. Genova also offers some poignant scenes where we the reader know what Alice has forgotten and our heart breaks for her. When she forgets her daughter, her husband, the layout of her house, how to lick an ice cream cone, we mourn the Alice lost right along with her and her family. I can't imagine losing everything I learned, all the way back to basic needs like how to walk, feed, or even use the bathroom. I felt Alice's frustration at forgetting words and people and most of all being shut out because she was stigmatized with this disease as though she were already dead.
Because the narration is told through Alice, there are a few plot points that get lost, but I think we gain more than we lose from her perspective. And those lost points add to all she loses. Sometimes the descriptions of Boston get a little lengthy and the medical descriptions cold and drawn-out, giving the novel a little bit of a medical journal instead of novel feel, but I was still captivated by Alice and her plight, and I loved that Genova had the background to give us a real look into Alzheimer's, to make it come alive in the pages.
Even though the story is told through Alice's unreliable eyes, I felt for each of the characters in her family as well. When I wanted to be angry at John for avoiding the disease, I couldn't. I felt for him. Having a spouse go through Alzheimer's must be one of the hardest things. Not only do you watch your spouse suffer and take on the role of full-time caretaker, a major life-changing physical and financial burden, but you lose your partner and confidante. And to experience early-onset when you should be experiencing some of the best of life is devastating. I could see why he didn't want to deal with it.
I wouldn't want to see a parent go through this either. I don't know. It's hard to think about. I hope I never have to.
I can't stop thinking about Alzheimer's and hoping they come up with a cure soon. Genova has done a fabulous job bringing attention to this debilitating disease and I love that she self-published because it was too important to wait. Kudos, Genova.
April 17, 2016
Is my identity something that transcends neurons, proteins, and defective molecules of DNA? Is my soul and spirit immune to the ravages of Alzheimer's? I believe it is.
I read this book for three reasons. 1) I have never read a book about Alzheimer's disease, 2) For personal reasons, I have an interest in Alzheimer's, and 3) It has an incredibly high average rating on goodreads. That being said, I have to confess that I didn't really go into this expecting to like it. I picked it up from the library so I wouldn't have to spend money on it and so I could return it quickly when I realised it was nothing more than the regular -style melodramatic chick lit. I started it with a bored sigh, thinking I would soon be putting it aside to distract myself with the internet or any of the million TV shows I'm currently trying to keep up with. But something unexpected happened.
This is not chick lit, whatever you want to interpret that to mean. It isn't melodramatic or emotionally manipulative. It isn't the Alzheimer's equivalent of the standard - forgive me - "cancer book". Instead, this is a deeply moving psychological portrait of a woman's deteriorating mind and how this gradually affects her relationships with the people around her. It's about an intelligent woman suddenly finding that she can no longer rely on her mind, she tries every day to hold onto her memories, her sense of understanding, and we are taken on a terrifying journey into what it must be like to know you are slowly losing pieces of yourself day by day.
I have no desire to trivialize cancer or any other disease, I have lost several people I've loved to cancer and know how horrible it is. But Alzheimer's is a whole different type of monster. There's one part of the book where Alice says she wishes she could swap her disease for cancer and then instantly feels bad about it, but I understand where the feelings come from. With cancer, you can fight. There's chemotherapy, radiotherapy and yes, they don't always work, but you can go down fighting. With Alzheimer's, there's still no way to fight it, no chance of overcoming the disease. The diagnosis carries a tragic hopelessness with it, because all you can do is sit around and wait for your mind to deteriorate.
Sometimes you can really tell when an author knows their subject and, in my opinion, it makes all the difference. I recall by in particular and the way the author's background working with abuse victims helped her have a deeper understanding of the characters she was dealing with and the story she was telling. Genova holds a Harvard PHD in Neuroscience and there is a surety and confidence in her scientific explanations of the disease that makes this fact evident in her writing. She knows the small details of what she's talking about and so the bigger picture is naturally more convincing.
On a personal note, there is a history of Alzheimer's in my family. I don't understand it enough to know whether it's genetic or a coincidence that many of the women on my mother's side have suffered from the disease. I do know my mum is afraid of it, though she doesn't talk about it often. But every time she forgets where she put something she was holding just minutes ago, every time she reaches for a word - a word she uses every day - and it slips away, just out of her grasp, every single time she wonders if it's a sign of something more serious than getting older and having a busy schedule. It's this small scale stuff that makes the novel so terrifying. We could all be Alice. We all forget small things every day, that's just a fact and it happens to everyone, but what if one day those forgotten memories don't come back straight away? And the next time, what if they go a bit longer? The progression from the small things to the more serious stages of the disease is truly scary.
This book is frightening on both a biologial and psychological level. When I think of Alzheimer's, I think of forgotten memories, of faces you can't put a name to, of everyday places that seem unfamiliar. But the author's haunting descriptions of the biological truth are entirely different and frightening on a whole new level. I don't think about what is really happening in the brain, neurons being destroyed bit by bit, dying some more every day, eroding pieces of who you are. Memories, for me, are those things that disappear for a while but come back to you later. But Alzheimer's doesn't make you forget memories, it goes in and completely destroys them. As if they were never there.
And that is the important question for Alice: how much can she lose and still be herself? If our entire personalities are built from memories, sensory experiences, from the things we've said and done, who are we when we no longer remember any of that? How can you make today matter when tomorrow you won't even remember it? It's a sad book but it doesn't fail to leave you with a glimpse of light in the darkness too. But I'll leave you to find out what that is for yourself.
The final comment I'd like to make is not so much a criticism of the book but a comment on what I'd personally like to see on this subject in the future. As I said at the beginning, I've never read a book about Alzheimer's before and I may be missing a very good one that already exists, but I kept thinking while reading this that I'd like to read a story about someone who wasn't as successful as Alice. Alice gains comfort from the fact that she has had a fantastic career, a husband who loves her, and three intelligent children. She's obviously right to cling to all the good things in her life, but I wonder how the story would be different if told about a man or woman without Alice's financial prosperity. There has to be so many different stories and experiences to be told about this disease and I suddenly find myself wanting to read more of them.
| | | | |
March 1, 2009
I give this book 5 stars not because its an amazing piece of literature but because of its impact on me. I can't stop thinking about it and when I was reading it I couldn't put it down. It is the story of Alice, a brilliant professor of cognitive psychology at Harvard and a world-renowned expert in linguistics who discovers she has early onset Alzheimer's disease. This book is beautiful and terrifying - ringing true in every word. To quote a reviewer, "with a master storyteller's easy eloquence, Genova shines a searing spotlight on this Alice's surreal wonderland. You owe it to yourself and your loved ones to read this book. It will inform you. it will scare you. It will change you." It has changed me.
June 8, 2015
Update I just watched the film. It was very moving, an awful depiction of a terrible disease. I forget words. I worry that maybe... I don't even want to think of it. Good as the film was, it wasn't as good as the book. It could stand alone though as a separate work that more just shared names and a title. June 2015
_____
Still Alice reads like a memoir of Alzheimer's disease written by a family member but is in fact the first novel by a neuroscientist who, apart from being a great deal younger, lives the successful life of a top academic, as does Alice.
The book is unputdownable. I read through the night; dawn came and went and still I couldn't put it down but I don't really know why. The writing was ok, a bit heavy-handed at times, the denoument was predetermined and inevitable but still the book was as gripping as any top-ten thriller. Perhaps it was the progress through a disease that strikes at random and about which we know almost nothing from the sufferer's point of view?
Lisa Genova self-published the book and it has reached the rank of 150 in 'books' on Amazon. When I see a self-published book with 10 or 15 glowing reviews, mostly written by people who've never written a review before, I think they are probably the author's friends and dismiss the review in favour of one by an independent publication (if there is one). But when a self-published book attracts 190 reviews and a 5 star rating, I know that the book is definitely worth considering, not just for my own reading pleasure but also to order for my bookshop.
This book is more than worthy of consideration, its ourselves, our families as we might be, and its a good read too.
_____
Still Alice reads like a memoir of Alzheimer's disease written by a family member but is in fact the first novel by a neuroscientist who, apart from being a great deal younger, lives the successful life of a top academic, as does Alice.
The book is unputdownable. I read through the night; dawn came and went and still I couldn't put it down but I don't really know why. The writing was ok, a bit heavy-handed at times, the denoument was predetermined and inevitable but still the book was as gripping as any top-ten thriller. Perhaps it was the progress through a disease that strikes at random and about which we know almost nothing from the sufferer's point of view?
Lisa Genova self-published the book and it has reached the rank of 150 in 'books' on Amazon. When I see a self-published book with 10 or 15 glowing reviews, mostly written by people who've never written a review before, I think they are probably the author's friends and dismiss the review in favour of one by an independent publication (if there is one). But when a self-published book attracts 190 reviews and a 5 star rating, I know that the book is definitely worth considering, not just for my own reading pleasure but also to order for my bookshop.
This book is more than worthy of consideration, its ourselves, our families as we might be, and its a good read too.
January 15, 2022
Still Alice, Lisa Genova
Still Alice is a 2007 debut novel by Lisa Genova, set in Boston. The novel is about a woman who suffers early-onset Alzheimer's disease.
Alice Howland, a 50-year-old woman, is a cognitive psychology professor at Harvard and is a world-renowned linguistics expert. She is married to an equally successful husband, and they have three grown children. The disease takes hold swiftly, and it changes Alice’s relationship with her family and the world.
عنوانهای چاپ شده در ایران: «همیشه آلیس»؛ «من هنوز آلیس هستم»؛ «هنوز آلیس»؛ «هنوز آلیس هستم»؛ نویسنده لیزا جنووا؛ تاریخ نخستین خوانش روز بیست و نهم ماه ژانویه سال2011میلادی
عنوان: همیشه آلیس؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: آرش طهماسبی؛ تهران، افسون خیال؛ سال1389؛ در394ص؛ سال9786009200627؛ موضوع داستانهای نویسندگان ایالات متحده ایالات متحده آمریکا - سده21م
عنوان: من هنوز آلیس هستم؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم حمید یزدانپناه؛ تهران، نشر علم؛ سال1390؛ در322ص؛ شابک9789642242924؛
عنوان: هنوز آلیس؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: شهین احمدی؛ تهران، نشر چشمه؛ سال1390؛ در454ص؛ شابک9786002291158؛
عنوان: هنوز آلیس هستم؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: آمنه مجذوب صفا؛ تهران، موسسه نگارش الکترونیک کتاب، مانا کتاب؛ سال1394؛ در270ص، شابک9786008009283؛ دسترسی از وب
آلیس، استاد زبان شناسی دانشگاه است؛ روزگاری خوب، و زندگی صادقانه و نیکویی دارند؛ ایشان به مرور زمان، درمییابند، که مسائل ساده را، به آسانی فراموش میکنند، و مبحثی را که، باید در کلاس، درس دهند، یادشان میرود؛ نخست، موضوع را، چندان جدی نمیگیرند� اما با افزون شدن دشواری، پیش پزشک میروند، و پس از انجام آزمایشات، درمییابند، که به نوعی بیماری «آلزایمر» بسیار ویژه، مبتلا هستند؛ «آلیس» هرچند از شنیدن خبر، شوکه میشود، ولی تلاش میکند، تا تسلیم بیماری نشود؛ ...؛ فیلمی نیز، با مشخصات زیر و با بازآفرینی، از این رمان ساخته شده است
عنوان فیلم: هنوز آلیس؛ کارگردان: گلن مور؛ واش وستمورلند؛ تهیه� کننده: جیمز براون؛ پاملا کوفلر؛ لکس لوتزوس؛ فیلمنامه نویس: ریچارد گلتزر؛ واش وستمورلند؛ بر پایه داستان: هنوز آلیس، از: لیزا جنوا؛ بازیگران: الک بالدوین؛ هانتر پریش؛ جولیان مور؛ کیت باسورث؛ کریستن استوارت؛ و ...؛
تاریخ بهنگام رسانی 14/11/1399هجری خورشیدی؛ 24/10/1400هجری خورشیدی؛ ا. شربیانی
Still Alice is a 2007 debut novel by Lisa Genova, set in Boston. The novel is about a woman who suffers early-onset Alzheimer's disease.
Alice Howland, a 50-year-old woman, is a cognitive psychology professor at Harvard and is a world-renowned linguistics expert. She is married to an equally successful husband, and they have three grown children. The disease takes hold swiftly, and it changes Alice’s relationship with her family and the world.
عنوانهای چاپ شده در ایران: «همیشه آلیس»؛ «من هنوز آلیس هستم»؛ «هنوز آلیس»؛ «هنوز آلیس هستم»؛ نویسنده لیزا جنووا؛ تاریخ نخستین خوانش روز بیست و نهم ماه ژانویه سال2011میلادی
عنوان: همیشه آلیس؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: آرش طهماسبی؛ تهران، افسون خیال؛ سال1389؛ در394ص؛ سال9786009200627؛ موضوع داستانهای نویسندگان ایالات متحده ایالات متحده آمریکا - سده21م
عنوان: من هنوز آلیس هستم؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم حمید یزدانپناه؛ تهران، نشر علم؛ سال1390؛ در322ص؛ شابک9789642242924؛
عنوان: هنوز آلیس؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: شهین احمدی؛ تهران، نشر چشمه؛ سال1390؛ در454ص؛ شابک9786002291158؛
عنوان: هنوز آلیس هستم؛ نویسنده: لیزا جنووا؛ مترجم: آمنه مجذوب صفا؛ تهران، موسسه نگارش الکترونیک کتاب، مانا کتاب؛ سال1394؛ در270ص، شابک9786008009283؛ دسترسی از وب
آلیس، استاد زبان شناسی دانشگاه است؛ روزگاری خوب، و زندگی صادقانه و نیکویی دارند؛ ایشان به مرور زمان، درمییابند، که مسائل ساده را، به آسانی فراموش میکنند، و مبحثی را که، باید در کلاس، درس دهند، یادشان میرود؛ نخست، موضوع را، چندان جدی نمیگیرند� اما با افزون شدن دشواری، پیش پزشک میروند، و پس از انجام آزمایشات، درمییابند، که به نوعی بیماری «آلزایمر» بسیار ویژه، مبتلا هستند؛ «آلیس» هرچند از شنیدن خبر، شوکه میشود، ولی تلاش میکند، تا تسلیم بیماری نشود؛ ...؛ فیلمی نیز، با مشخصات زیر و با بازآفرینی، از این رمان ساخته شده است
عنوان فیلم: هنوز آلیس؛ کارگردان: گلن مور؛ واش وستمورلند؛ تهیه� کننده: جیمز براون؛ پاملا کوفلر؛ لکس لوتزوس؛ فیلمنامه نویس: ریچارد گلتزر؛ واش وستمورلند؛ بر پایه داستان: هنوز آلیس، از: لیزا جنوا؛ بازیگران: الک بالدوین؛ هانتر پریش؛ جولیان مور؛ کیت باسورث؛ کریستن استوارت؛ و ...؛
تاریخ بهنگام رسانی 14/11/1399هجری خورشیدی؛ 24/10/1400هجری خورشیدی؛ ا. شربیانی
June 29, 2021
The biggest problem with self-published work is the lack of an editor who tells you how to go from good to great. “Still Alice� has a wonderful premise: let’s tell the story of Alzheimer’s from the patient’s point of view, but somehow the book sounds like a professor telling you the Alzheimer’s story from a patient’s point of view, rather than having the patient tell her own story. (Using first-person rather than third would have been more effective.) I felt that I was reading nothing more than an extended patient case study in a research journal.
Additionally, the character of Alice blurred with the author’s identity at times� I found myself asking, “Who’s really telling the story here, Alice or Lisa Genova?� Or, one minute you felt like you were inside Alice’s head, you really knew what she was thinking, but then the frame of reference would shift to being outside of her observing from someone else’s perspective. I never totally felt connected with Alice as a real person.
I thought that the supporting cast around Alice could have been better developed, but her children were fairly one-dimensional people and her conversations with them were about one subject only given that the children had only one thing that defined each of them (i.e., having a baby, auditioning for a play). The one relationship that rang partly true was the one she had with her husband, who waffled between wanting to do his best to support his wife but also feeling that he needed to look after his own interests given that Alice might not be around in his future. His practicality tended to overrule his emotions, which is typical in many men.
Having lived with Alzheimer’s in my family, I felt that the book glossed over some really hard-hitting aspects of Alzheimer’s. {SPOILER ALERT: PLEASE STOP READING IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE BOOK.} While it touched on the concept of suicide, the book sidestepped the issue by making Alice unable to find her pills when she (momentarily) realized that the time had come. Therefore, the book was able to end with Alice presumably slipping away into oblivion in the arms of a warm, loving, happy family. Ha. My own personal experiences with Alzheimer’s would suggest that this is not an accurate portrayal of what it feels like to actually DIE of Alzheimer’s. I felt bad that Alice had been unable to find her pills and therefore would have to go through something that she -- when she was still lucid enough to write her thoughts down -- had adamantly expressed that she did not want to have to deal with.
Additionally, the character of Alice blurred with the author’s identity at times� I found myself asking, “Who’s really telling the story here, Alice or Lisa Genova?� Or, one minute you felt like you were inside Alice’s head, you really knew what she was thinking, but then the frame of reference would shift to being outside of her observing from someone else’s perspective. I never totally felt connected with Alice as a real person.
I thought that the supporting cast around Alice could have been better developed, but her children were fairly one-dimensional people and her conversations with them were about one subject only given that the children had only one thing that defined each of them (i.e., having a baby, auditioning for a play). The one relationship that rang partly true was the one she had with her husband, who waffled between wanting to do his best to support his wife but also feeling that he needed to look after his own interests given that Alice might not be around in his future. His practicality tended to overrule his emotions, which is typical in many men.
Having lived with Alzheimer’s in my family, I felt that the book glossed over some really hard-hitting aspects of Alzheimer’s. {SPOILER ALERT: PLEASE STOP READING IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE BOOK.} While it touched on the concept of suicide, the book sidestepped the issue by making Alice unable to find her pills when she (momentarily) realized that the time had come. Therefore, the book was able to end with Alice presumably slipping away into oblivion in the arms of a warm, loving, happy family. Ha. My own personal experiences with Alzheimer’s would suggest that this is not an accurate portrayal of what it feels like to actually DIE of Alzheimer’s. I felt bad that Alice had been unable to find her pills and therefore would have to go through something that she -- when she was still lucid enough to write her thoughts down -- had adamantly expressed that she did not want to have to deal with.
October 23, 2014
No one understands the high stakes associated with making a book recommendation like a serious reader, especially when it's to a good friend, co-worker, or family member. Books that we love say a lot about our personalities, things that we're passionate about, and even shed light on our past experiences (good and bad). That's a lot to share with someone! Along with that pressure is the fear of introducing the wrong book to the wrong reader, or getting the timing wrong. What if they absolutely hate it?! Where does that leave us?
The flip side is equally scary. When someone you esteem recommends a book that they hold dear, and upon reading it, you find that you hated it, that can make things a little awkward. "How'd you like that book I loaned you?" might just be the subject of your recurring nightmare. I've sometimes found myself wondering, "Why on earth would this person think this book would speak to me? Obviously we're not as close as I thought we were."
I exaggerate, but no one understands these common reading kerfuffles like readers do! It's why I struggle to keep silent when I see someone bypassing a book I thought was brilliant (and on sale, no less) at a bookstore. I want to run after them and say, "Put that corny romance novel back and take this. It changed my life!" It's also why I try to avoid talking to strangers in bookstores who want to unload all their favorites on me without knowing a thing about me. On several occasions, I've dutifully waited until said person cleared out of the store before returning Jimmy Buffet's latest book to its shelf, along with the copy of Zane's current bestseller. I'm not knocking them, I just know what I like...and it's not that!
This summer when I was shopping for books at a local thrift store, a woman shoved Still Alice into my overflowing shopping cart. I was a bit annoyed. She didn't know me! All she kept saying was that if I hadn't read it, I needed to. Apparently, it had changed her life. There in that aisle, a complete stranger started talking to me about caring for her mother who had Alzheimer's, and how this book turned the tables by giving the reader the perspective of the victim of the disease. Before I knew it, I was sharing my story about my grandmother, and her current battle with ALS, an equally progressive degenerative disease with no cure.
Talk about books bringing people together! Though I didn't get her name, I left the store with this book based solely on that woman's recommendation...and I absolutely loved it! I wish I could tell her how right she was. This book hit a raw nerve, and really took me out of the caregiver role in order to focus on the real heroes battling neurological disorders every day. What must it be like to wish for a "logical" disease that one could fight with medication or radiation? One particular question that Alice, the protagonist, asks really struck me to the core:
I'm going to be as equally pushy as my nameless thrift store friend. Read this book! Don't make me chase after you, because I wear my running shoes to the bookstore nowadays. That is all.
The flip side is equally scary. When someone you esteem recommends a book that they hold dear, and upon reading it, you find that you hated it, that can make things a little awkward. "How'd you like that book I loaned you?" might just be the subject of your recurring nightmare. I've sometimes found myself wondering, "Why on earth would this person think this book would speak to me? Obviously we're not as close as I thought we were."
I exaggerate, but no one understands these common reading kerfuffles like readers do! It's why I struggle to keep silent when I see someone bypassing a book I thought was brilliant (and on sale, no less) at a bookstore. I want to run after them and say, "Put that corny romance novel back and take this. It changed my life!" It's also why I try to avoid talking to strangers in bookstores who want to unload all their favorites on me without knowing a thing about me. On several occasions, I've dutifully waited until said person cleared out of the store before returning Jimmy Buffet's latest book to its shelf, along with the copy of Zane's current bestseller. I'm not knocking them, I just know what I like...and it's not that!
This summer when I was shopping for books at a local thrift store, a woman shoved Still Alice into my overflowing shopping cart. I was a bit annoyed. She didn't know me! All she kept saying was that if I hadn't read it, I needed to. Apparently, it had changed her life. There in that aisle, a complete stranger started talking to me about caring for her mother who had Alzheimer's, and how this book turned the tables by giving the reader the perspective of the victim of the disease. Before I knew it, I was sharing my story about my grandmother, and her current battle with ALS, an equally progressive degenerative disease with no cure.
Talk about books bringing people together! Though I didn't get her name, I left the store with this book based solely on that woman's recommendation...and I absolutely loved it! I wish I could tell her how right she was. This book hit a raw nerve, and really took me out of the caregiver role in order to focus on the real heroes battling neurological disorders every day. What must it be like to wish for a "logical" disease that one could fight with medication or radiation? One particular question that Alice, the protagonist, asks really struck me to the core:
"Is the part of my brain that's responsible for my unique 'me-ness' vulnerable to this disease? Or is my identity something that transcends neurons, proteins, and defective molecules of DNA? Is my soul and spirit immune to the ravages of Alzheimer's?"
I'm going to be as equally pushy as my nameless thrift store friend. Read this book! Don't make me chase after you, because I wear my running shoes to the bookstore nowadays. That is all.
March 3, 2021
This was a tough read.
Enjoyed it but I think the movie is better!
Enjoyed it but I think the movie is better!
June 2, 2024
“I encourage you to empower us, not limit us. If someone has a spinal cord injury, if someone has lost a limb or has a functional disability from a stroke, families and professionals work hard to rehabilitate that person, to find ways to cope and manage despite these losses. Work with us. Help us develop tools to function around our losses in memory, language, and cognition. Encourage involvement in support groups. We can help each other, both people with dementia and their caregivers, navigate through this Dr. Seuss land of neither here nor there.�
It is not unheard of for people in their 20s and 30s to be diagnosed with early on-set Alzehimer’s disease, and that terrifies me. Life is highly taken for granted.
I don’t think I can say anything new for this novel that hasn’t been said before. It’s not a new novel, and it’s not super old either, but it’s popular and was adapted to a film for a reason.
Lisa’s writing is outstanding. The medical research and real facts make this read all the more brilliant, adding a very realistic approach to this fictional tale that was inspired by her grandmother’s Alzheimer’s disease. The author does a fantastic job of pulling the reader in, captivating our full attention with every detail related to the main character, Alice. You can tell the author is in the medical field herself and did a fantastic job at researching the correct material to pull this off. Alice’s emotions are vivid and heartfelt. I think the author was a genius for blending in the writing with the emotions the main character was experiencing, such as repeating verses or dialogue, which allows the reader to interpret the feelings of Alice in greater detail. There’s a lot of emotion in this, not only because of what Alice is dealing with but because of the theme overall. It makes you think about how we take the smallest things for granted, and when we’re on the verge of losing it all, we think about it and reflect on how much we missed out on. Alzheimer’s and dementia are cruel, vicious diseases, and it’s heartbreaking to think about how this is something we or anyone close to us can develop without it hope for a cure.
Alice’s journey is a difficult one. Lisa’s emotions are palpable in her descriptive writing, especially from the visuals of what she is painting at the novel's core. I found myself glued to every page from the moment I began, reading 50 pages in one sitting at 3 AM, another 170 at the library, and the rest at home. I did cheat a little, since I watched the film before, but luckily I didn’t remember it all so it didn’t affect my overall reading enjoyment. We experience Alice’s emotions alongside her, which is my favorite kind of storytelling. I loved being able to envision Alice and what she was experiencing, and it wasn’t because I had seen the film before reading this but because the author blends in fiction and reality incredibly well.
“You’re so beautiful,� said Alice. “I’m so afraid of looking at you and not knowing who you are.�
“I think that even if you don’t know who I am someday, you’ll still know that I love you.�
“What if I see you, and I don’t know that you’re my daughter, and I don’t know that you love me?�
“Then, I’ll tell you that I do, and you’ll believe me.�
I think Alice’s characterization is strong. Lisa Genova doesn’t hide the brutal reality of how Alzheimer’s disease slowly kills you, but she doesn’t make Alice an unlikable narrator. The life Alice continues slowly getting through and by is one of pity but out of concern. Her journey from 2003 to 2005 is heartbreakingly real, evoking lots of emotions due to her need and want to remember but inability to do so. She never victimizes herself and doesn’t even want to try, wishing she didn’t need to tell people what she is now officially diagnosed with. I found her to be courageous and strong, as she was someone who wanted to continue doing her best to remember as much as she could and not let the disease take over her. Instead of letting it pull her in, she tried her best to pull out. She didn’t take life for granted anymore and did her best to show that with the people around her. I have to give props to the author for also managing the story well in terms of the timeline. We see how Alice slowly starts losing herself, her memory, her life, and it slowly rips her apart more and more to the point where she doesn’t remember who she is, who her husband is, and the names of her children, which were all the things she remembered the most.
I don’t know much about Alzheimer’s disease and dementia overall. There’s a lot of medical research put into this, and it’s obvious, which makes the reading more compelling, but it did make it difficult to understand. However, it was necessary, and most of the medical relations are things I wouldn’t be able to remember just because it’s not my field of knowledge. My knowledge on dementia diseases goes only to surface level, not ranging widely but stopping only at memory loss. Still, Lisa’s writing is highly emotive, never bordering on boredom and unnecessary divisions. Every fragment of this story was necessary to add to the story.
Truly, my only issue with this was Alice’s family. Sometimes Alice’s children, mostly Anna but also Lydia, also felt a little too selfish for my liking. The way they treated Alice, as if she was dead, talking about her as if she wasn’t there just because she didn’t remember, felt so rude and off-putting. Tom was the more likable family member, as he was usually supportive of Alice and tended to have her back. For me, personally, Alice’s family wasn’t the best support system. There were moments of doubt and concern and other moments of support, making my feelings on them weird and unsure. I just wish they could’ve been there for her more, understanding her more and not making her feel like it was her fault this was all happening. But most important, John was a big issue for me. He never really tried reasoning with Alice and understanding where she was coming from. He victimized himself a lot, as if it was him losing his memory and mind and not Alice, not putting her first. You know how in marriage vows you say “till death do us part?� Yeah, I feel like John was not someone who would be there to support and help Alice till death parted them. He would put his work and lab meetings first, as if his work was more important, claiming it was a way for him to distract himself of what Alice was dealing with. As if Alice wasn’t the one with the disease. As if Alice wasn’t the one slowly dying. Overall, not a fan and I don’t think he was a very good husband.
The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she was no longer capable of thinking analytically. The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she didn’t deserve to sit in that room among them. The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she no longer deserved to be heard.
Lisa’s message is evident. There’s a lot of stigma against patients and victims of Alzheimer's, and sadly many people (me included) don’t know the full ugliness about it. It isn’t until we experience this ourselves or see it for ourselves that we are able to fully relate and understand. But Lisa doesn’t need us to relate to understand; she wants us to sympathize, and I can confidently say I did sympathize 100% with Alice. Thank you Lisa for teaching me something new and letting me experience the life of Alice Howland.
It is not unheard of for people in their 20s and 30s to be diagnosed with early on-set Alzehimer’s disease, and that terrifies me. Life is highly taken for granted.
I don’t think I can say anything new for this novel that hasn’t been said before. It’s not a new novel, and it’s not super old either, but it’s popular and was adapted to a film for a reason.
Lisa’s writing is outstanding. The medical research and real facts make this read all the more brilliant, adding a very realistic approach to this fictional tale that was inspired by her grandmother’s Alzheimer’s disease. The author does a fantastic job of pulling the reader in, captivating our full attention with every detail related to the main character, Alice. You can tell the author is in the medical field herself and did a fantastic job at researching the correct material to pull this off. Alice’s emotions are vivid and heartfelt. I think the author was a genius for blending in the writing with the emotions the main character was experiencing, such as repeating verses or dialogue, which allows the reader to interpret the feelings of Alice in greater detail. There’s a lot of emotion in this, not only because of what Alice is dealing with but because of the theme overall. It makes you think about how we take the smallest things for granted, and when we’re on the verge of losing it all, we think about it and reflect on how much we missed out on. Alzheimer’s and dementia are cruel, vicious diseases, and it’s heartbreaking to think about how this is something we or anyone close to us can develop without it hope for a cure.
Alice’s journey is a difficult one. Lisa’s emotions are palpable in her descriptive writing, especially from the visuals of what she is painting at the novel's core. I found myself glued to every page from the moment I began, reading 50 pages in one sitting at 3 AM, another 170 at the library, and the rest at home. I did cheat a little, since I watched the film before, but luckily I didn’t remember it all so it didn’t affect my overall reading enjoyment. We experience Alice’s emotions alongside her, which is my favorite kind of storytelling. I loved being able to envision Alice and what she was experiencing, and it wasn’t because I had seen the film before reading this but because the author blends in fiction and reality incredibly well.
“You’re so beautiful,� said Alice. “I’m so afraid of looking at you and not knowing who you are.�
“I think that even if you don’t know who I am someday, you’ll still know that I love you.�
“What if I see you, and I don’t know that you’re my daughter, and I don’t know that you love me?�
“Then, I’ll tell you that I do, and you’ll believe me.�
I think Alice’s characterization is strong. Lisa Genova doesn’t hide the brutal reality of how Alzheimer’s disease slowly kills you, but she doesn’t make Alice an unlikable narrator. The life Alice continues slowly getting through and by is one of pity but out of concern. Her journey from 2003 to 2005 is heartbreakingly real, evoking lots of emotions due to her need and want to remember but inability to do so. She never victimizes herself and doesn’t even want to try, wishing she didn’t need to tell people what she is now officially diagnosed with. I found her to be courageous and strong, as she was someone who wanted to continue doing her best to remember as much as she could and not let the disease take over her. Instead of letting it pull her in, she tried her best to pull out. She didn’t take life for granted anymore and did her best to show that with the people around her. I have to give props to the author for also managing the story well in terms of the timeline. We see how Alice slowly starts losing herself, her memory, her life, and it slowly rips her apart more and more to the point where she doesn’t remember who she is, who her husband is, and the names of her children, which were all the things she remembered the most.
I don’t know much about Alzheimer’s disease and dementia overall. There’s a lot of medical research put into this, and it’s obvious, which makes the reading more compelling, but it did make it difficult to understand. However, it was necessary, and most of the medical relations are things I wouldn’t be able to remember just because it’s not my field of knowledge. My knowledge on dementia diseases goes only to surface level, not ranging widely but stopping only at memory loss. Still, Lisa’s writing is highly emotive, never bordering on boredom and unnecessary divisions. Every fragment of this story was necessary to add to the story.
Truly, my only issue with this was Alice’s family. Sometimes Alice’s children, mostly Anna but also Lydia, also felt a little too selfish for my liking. The way they treated Alice, as if she was dead, talking about her as if she wasn’t there just because she didn’t remember, felt so rude and off-putting. Tom was the more likable family member, as he was usually supportive of Alice and tended to have her back. For me, personally, Alice’s family wasn’t the best support system. There were moments of doubt and concern and other moments of support, making my feelings on them weird and unsure. I just wish they could’ve been there for her more, understanding her more and not making her feel like it was her fault this was all happening. But most important, John was a big issue for me. He never really tried reasoning with Alice and understanding where she was coming from. He victimized himself a lot, as if it was him losing his memory and mind and not Alice, not putting her first. You know how in marriage vows you say “till death do us part?� Yeah, I feel like John was not someone who would be there to support and help Alice till death parted them. He would put his work and lab meetings first, as if his work was more important, claiming it was a way for him to distract himself of what Alice was dealing with. As if Alice wasn’t the one with the disease. As if Alice wasn’t the one slowly dying. Overall, not a fan and I don’t think he was a very good husband.
The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she was no longer capable of thinking analytically. The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she didn’t deserve to sit in that room among them. The fact that she had Alzheimer’s didn’t mean that she no longer deserved to be heard.
Lisa’s message is evident. There’s a lot of stigma against patients and victims of Alzheimer's, and sadly many people (me included) don’t know the full ugliness about it. It isn’t until we experience this ourselves or see it for ourselves that we are able to fully relate and understand. But Lisa doesn’t need us to relate to understand; she wants us to sympathize, and I can confidently say I did sympathize 100% with Alice. Thank you Lisa for teaching me something new and letting me experience the life of Alice Howland.
December 25, 2019
Alice Howland is a well-respected Harvard linguistics professor who, at age 50, finds herself starting to lose her mind - forgetting words, not recalling why she walked into a room, unsure of the recipe for a dessert she’s made for several years. Through a series of doctor appointments and tests, Alice learns that she has early onset Alzheimer’s disease.
In Still Alice, she attempts to cope with this new life along with her family, which includes her husband, her two grown daughters, son, and son-in-law. It is tough for all of them to accept and challenging to cope with as the disease progresses over time.
Still Alice was terrifying - I can’t imagine learning this was happening to me or to a loved one. It’s hard to process at any age, but seems especially shocking for a brilliant woman who’s just 50 years old. The story felt realistic, from Alice’s behavior to her family’s differing opinions about the best course of action for her, yet, I also enjoyed how they ultimately came together despite their disagreements.
In Still Alice, she attempts to cope with this new life along with her family, which includes her husband, her two grown daughters, son, and son-in-law. It is tough for all of them to accept and challenging to cope with as the disease progresses over time.
Still Alice was terrifying - I can’t imagine learning this was happening to me or to a loved one. It’s hard to process at any age, but seems especially shocking for a brilliant woman who’s just 50 years old. The story felt realistic, from Alice’s behavior to her family’s differing opinions about the best course of action for her, yet, I also enjoyed how they ultimately came together despite their disagreements.
September 3, 2022
Fascinating and heartbreaking and without a single wasted word. Incredible.
September 30, 2022
I chose to read this book whilst taking a break from a very heavy read. What a great choice.
It seems I'm behind the eight ball again, having only just read my first novel by this outstandingly talented author.
What an inspiring, emotional and ultimately rewarding read, on a topic that is real and wretched and terribly sad.
Alice is a brilliant and gifted Harvard Professor who hits her 50's with early onset Alzheimer's. I was taken in by this lovely lady, a beautiful character that Genova created and told her story with eloquence and grace.
She has created a piece of work that speaks of such a hard topic, with factual information in a way that found to be hauntingly real. This author has shown respect for this topic by researching thoroughly; she's a very clever woman.
If a reader was to have personal experience with this topic, I would understand their having doubts with this one, but I think it actually may be a wise choice?
I loved Alice, I adore a book where I can say that about the central character. I could still see her, thanks to the skilful writing of this fabulous author. I'm a happy reader right now, please read this one, it's so good!
It seems I'm behind the eight ball again, having only just read my first novel by this outstandingly talented author.
What an inspiring, emotional and ultimately rewarding read, on a topic that is real and wretched and terribly sad.
Alice is a brilliant and gifted Harvard Professor who hits her 50's with early onset Alzheimer's. I was taken in by this lovely lady, a beautiful character that Genova created and told her story with eloquence and grace.
She has created a piece of work that speaks of such a hard topic, with factual information in a way that found to be hauntingly real. This author has shown respect for this topic by researching thoroughly; she's a very clever woman.
If a reader was to have personal experience with this topic, I would understand their having doubts with this one, but I think it actually may be a wise choice?
I loved Alice, I adore a book where I can say that about the central character. I could still see her, thanks to the skilful writing of this fabulous author. I'm a happy reader right now, please read this one, it's so good!
August 17, 2012
I wanted to like this book, I really did. I picked it because my mother suffered from dementia and I expected to relate to it.But I almost gave up on it in the first few chapters. Good writing is of paramount importance to me, and the writing here, while not godawful, has first book written all over it. Way too many "information drops," where the author tells us all about something or somebody in a chunk of info instead of just letting it unfold in naturally ocurring parts of the story. I'm glad I stuck with it though, because the book improved considerably as it went on.
I know, of course, that Alzheimer's varies from patient to patient, but I have to say that much of this did not seem to reflect my experience with my mother. My mother was every bit as intelligent and involved in things as Alice. She was Phi Beta Kappa in Zoology,later became a professional landscape designer, read voraciously. Yet she never had the insight that Alice did about what was wrong with her.
As I said, each case is different, but I felt that the author gave Alice too much insight and self-awareness, especially when the disease was pretty far advanced. Granted, Alice couldn't express her articulate thoughts in words to her family, but I had a hard time believing someone as far gone as she was would have such insightful, articulate thoughts at all.
Still, I found the last 1/3 of the book to be interesting and affecting. I especially liked the way the Alice's answers to her self quiz deteriorated without her being aware of it. That was spot on.
I know, of course, that Alzheimer's varies from patient to patient, but I have to say that much of this did not seem to reflect my experience with my mother. My mother was every bit as intelligent and involved in things as Alice. She was Phi Beta Kappa in Zoology,later became a professional landscape designer, read voraciously. Yet she never had the insight that Alice did about what was wrong with her.
As I said, each case is different, but I felt that the author gave Alice too much insight and self-awareness, especially when the disease was pretty far advanced. Granted, Alice couldn't express her articulate thoughts in words to her family, but I had a hard time believing someone as far gone as she was would have such insightful, articulate thoughts at all.
Still, I found the last 1/3 of the book to be interesting and affecting. I especially liked the way the Alice's answers to her self quiz deteriorated without her being aware of it. That was spot on.
June 6, 2017
5�
Read this on my birthday while I still have enough marbles to appreciate how well the author illustrated Alice’s gradual disintegration with Alzheimer’s. Alice tried to leave herself reminders and notes, and I suspect I would do the same, but as you lose your memory, you may not trust your former self or even recognise that person, so perhaps it’s pointless.
Alice Howland is only 50, a Harvard professor of cognitive psychology and in a perfect position, one would think, to chronicle how she will deal with her diagnosis of early-onset Alzheimer’s.
Like many readers, I’ve experienced dealing with dementia in others and wonder if it will strike me, too. This book certainly covers her symptoms, her diagnosis, her test-taking and her reactions, but more than that, it gives us an idea of how a particular family deals with this.
She is one of those hubs around which other family members circle � a scientist husband and three grown children, two of whom are professionals (with degrees, which she values) and one who is an actor. She has opted out of university, much to Alice’s dismay, and studies acting and drama, supported not-so-secretly by Dad. He may be a scientist, but he appreciates The Arts (and her independence).
She gets lost one day, very early in the story, just walking as usual when a woman confronts her with a pamphlet, which unnerves her so she crosses the street. And that was enough to do it. She’s lost her bearings. She walks another block. She can read the signs and the names of the places. She is terrified.
“It all lacked a context. People, cars, buses, and all kinds of unbearable noise rushed and wove around and past her.� But she closes her eyes, opens them, and voila! “Just as suddenly as it had left her, the landscape snapped snugly back into place.�
Later she thinks her brain’s battery is running low and wishes she could give it a zap with jumper cables. What a good idea � if only.
She visits an Alzheimer’s unit by herself to see how the residents are faring. She is appalled, not only at their debilitated state but also at how costly the care is. She wishes she had cancer instead! At least there are treatments and a chance of a positive outcome.
She continues her work at Harvard longer than she should and her husband tries hard to be supportive, but he is a busy and successful scientist, absorbed in his research, and that’s who they have always been. Without her teaching position, who is she? She—who has always valued education and intellect and degrees—who is she?
Meanwhile, her tests show she has inherited a gene for Alzheimer’s, and chances are good her children have it and any grandchildren that eventuate may inherit it too. What to do? Whom to tell? Daughter Anne is trying to get pregnant!
She’s so smart that she manages well for as long as she can, even starting a support group of fellow patients. There are many groups for carers but she found none for those with the condition.
After again urging Lydia, her actor daughter to please go to college, Alice begins to reminisce about her college years:
�. . . the punchy all-nighters before exams, the classes, the parties, the friendships, meeting John—her memories of that time in her life were vivid, perfectly intact, and easily accessed. They were almost a little cocky the way they came to her, so full and ready, like they had no knowledge of the war going on just a few centimeters to their left.�
The book is divided into sections by date, and each section has a place where she asks herself the same five questions she knew the answers to when she was diagnosed (address of office, daughter’s birthday, etc.), and we see her answers gradually grow more vague.
Why this isn’t more depressing than it is, I’m not sure. Genova has done a terrific job of telling a very real story, and my edition contains a conversation with her where she discusses watching her grandmother disappear with Alzheimer’s (not early-onset). Genova was then studying for her PhD in neuroscience at Harvard, so she knows her subject. She understand what it means to say something is going on a couple of centimetres to the left of the memories in Alice's brain.
There is a good general description of the brain and its workings and the medications being used, but I'm aware that this was written in 2007 and things keep changing.
We keep hoping, but it’s not cured yet.
I was also reminded of the 1985 film with Joanne Woodward, "Do You Remember Love", about an English professor going through a similar diagnosis .
I haven't seen Julianne Moore as Alice yet, but she won an Academy Award for it, and I have no doubt I'll enjoy it when it rolls around again.
Wonderful book. Don’t be frightened to read it!
Read this on my birthday while I still have enough marbles to appreciate how well the author illustrated Alice’s gradual disintegration with Alzheimer’s. Alice tried to leave herself reminders and notes, and I suspect I would do the same, but as you lose your memory, you may not trust your former self or even recognise that person, so perhaps it’s pointless.
Alice Howland is only 50, a Harvard professor of cognitive psychology and in a perfect position, one would think, to chronicle how she will deal with her diagnosis of early-onset Alzheimer’s.
Like many readers, I’ve experienced dealing with dementia in others and wonder if it will strike me, too. This book certainly covers her symptoms, her diagnosis, her test-taking and her reactions, but more than that, it gives us an idea of how a particular family deals with this.
She is one of those hubs around which other family members circle � a scientist husband and three grown children, two of whom are professionals (with degrees, which she values) and one who is an actor. She has opted out of university, much to Alice’s dismay, and studies acting and drama, supported not-so-secretly by Dad. He may be a scientist, but he appreciates The Arts (and her independence).
She gets lost one day, very early in the story, just walking as usual when a woman confronts her with a pamphlet, which unnerves her so she crosses the street. And that was enough to do it. She’s lost her bearings. She walks another block. She can read the signs and the names of the places. She is terrified.
“It all lacked a context. People, cars, buses, and all kinds of unbearable noise rushed and wove around and past her.� But she closes her eyes, opens them, and voila! “Just as suddenly as it had left her, the landscape snapped snugly back into place.�
Later she thinks her brain’s battery is running low and wishes she could give it a zap with jumper cables. What a good idea � if only.
She visits an Alzheimer’s unit by herself to see how the residents are faring. She is appalled, not only at their debilitated state but also at how costly the care is. She wishes she had cancer instead! At least there are treatments and a chance of a positive outcome.
She continues her work at Harvard longer than she should and her husband tries hard to be supportive, but he is a busy and successful scientist, absorbed in his research, and that’s who they have always been. Without her teaching position, who is she? She—who has always valued education and intellect and degrees—who is she?
Meanwhile, her tests show she has inherited a gene for Alzheimer’s, and chances are good her children have it and any grandchildren that eventuate may inherit it too. What to do? Whom to tell? Daughter Anne is trying to get pregnant!
She’s so smart that she manages well for as long as she can, even starting a support group of fellow patients. There are many groups for carers but she found none for those with the condition.
After again urging Lydia, her actor daughter to please go to college, Alice begins to reminisce about her college years:
�. . . the punchy all-nighters before exams, the classes, the parties, the friendships, meeting John—her memories of that time in her life were vivid, perfectly intact, and easily accessed. They were almost a little cocky the way they came to her, so full and ready, like they had no knowledge of the war going on just a few centimeters to their left.�
The book is divided into sections by date, and each section has a place where she asks herself the same five questions she knew the answers to when she was diagnosed (address of office, daughter’s birthday, etc.), and we see her answers gradually grow more vague.
Why this isn’t more depressing than it is, I’m not sure. Genova has done a terrific job of telling a very real story, and my edition contains a conversation with her where she discusses watching her grandmother disappear with Alzheimer’s (not early-onset). Genova was then studying for her PhD in neuroscience at Harvard, so she knows her subject. She understand what it means to say something is going on a couple of centimetres to the left of the memories in Alice's brain.
There is a good general description of the brain and its workings and the medications being used, but I'm aware that this was written in 2007 and things keep changing.
We keep hoping, but it’s not cured yet.
I was also reminded of the 1985 film with Joanne Woodward, "Do You Remember Love", about an English professor going through a similar diagnosis .
I haven't seen Julianne Moore as Alice yet, but she won an Academy Award for it, and I have no doubt I'll enjoy it when it rolls around again.
Wonderful book. Don’t be frightened to read it!
August 9, 2022
�... just because [butterflies'] lives were short didn't mean they were tragic... See, they have a beautiful life.� � Lisa Genova, Still Alice
Strong message. Made me cry and think about the life
I would definitely recommend. Just GO read this book.
Strong message. Made me cry and think about the life
I would definitely recommend. Just GO read this book.
August 9, 2018
This book is one that I still think about to this day. It’s so real and scary at the same time. I cried reading so many parts of this book and it left a profound impact on me and my thoughts as I get older of how external fears are not as great as the fear of losing our minds. I recommend this book.
August 5, 2016
It's difficult to write that I really enjoyed Still Alice considering the subject matter, which is not an easy one to read about. Lisa Genova has provided a really insightful and intuitive account into the world of the early onset of Alzheimer's Disease. This is a very well written book and rather than it being told in an overly dramatic way, which could have been the manner some authors may have approached the story, Genova related it in a most respectful, considerate and compassionate manner.
In all honesty, I was quite hesitant about reading this book, although I had read many great and positive reviews about it from friends. Personally this disease is one of my worst nightmares and I think because I am a few years away from the age when Alice was diagnosed with the disease, it kind of hit home with me even more and was probably the reason I put off reading this book for so long. I found myself asking, what if? what would you do? how would you cope? how would your family cope? A lot of these questions were addressed in this book by both Alice and her family and friend’s experience of dealing with the disease. Really, at the end of the day, there is nothing you can do, it is a disease which is out of your control, in the end, unfortunately you just have to accept and hope that someday, with research, a cure will be found.
It was upsetting to read about the slow digression of Alice's state of mind both in connection with her work and her family and friends. Every time Alice checked back to her five answers on her list, to see how far the disease was affecting her, I found myself willing her to remember, it was like a silent shout out loud to her, hoping and wishing for her to recover. It was heartbreaking reading, how Alice, who was such a learned, esteemed and highly regarded academic at Harvard, had to give it all up and sacrifice herself, her family and career to this horrible disease. It was distressing to read how Alice slowly began to not recognise her husband or children as the disease got progressively worse.
Lydia's character, Alice's youngest daughter, in particular, stood out for me in the book. It was emotional and uplifting to see how Alice and Lydia, who initially had a rocky mother-daughter relationship, in the end, found a lot of support, encouragement, comfort and friendship in one another. Initially I thought that Genova should have allowed John, Alice's husband, a voice in the book, allowed him to give his side of the story, tell us how the disease affected him and share his thoughts with us as he made this journey with Alice. However, upon reflection, I think that Genova did actually give John a voice, not directly to the reader as such, but in a more subtle way. We never really knew how John was feeling, never really knew his thoughts. We saw his frustrations and in some ways he appeared to carry on as normal as possible. I think now, that Genova actually got this right in her portrayal of John. John's world was turned on its head by Alice's disease. I would imagine that his thoughts and feelings were a mixture of disbelief and perhaps he didn't fully believe that this disease could just come out of the blue, reach into his world and shatter it...I got the impression that he was trying to avoid reality for as long as he possibly could and continue as normal, because if he let his guard slip, for one moment, then Alice’s situation and therefore his situation, would become a reality, a reality which he would have to face and accept. In my opinion, outwardly he tried to ignore this for as long as he could but on the inside I think he was just shocked and devastated. I felt that John's twisting of his wedding ring many times in the book was quite significant and symbolic. For me, Alice's diagnosis was, in essence, soul-destroying for John. It meant that his marriage, his relationship with his life-long partner, his family life, his world as he previously knew it, was slowly slipping away from him, slowly becoming something he didn't recognise and there was nothing he could do about it. That is something that is difficult to come to terms with for any human being.
I only had an issue with one aspect of the book and that was all of the medical jargon, mostly near the beginning of the book. I realise it was absolutely necessary in the telling of this story and telling the story accurately, but quite honestly, most of it went over my head, due I suppose, to my own ignorance. I became a little bit bored with it, especially when John and the doctor were discussing the different options, trials and medications available to Alice.
In summary, this is a book that you will find hard to put down until you reach the end. You will go on Alice’s journey with her and it is not a pleasant one. It was very educational and I learned a lot. It was an extremely thought-provoking read. I admire anyone going through this illness, their family, friends, those who care for them and those who continue to research for this cause. Hopefully, some day soon, studies in research will find a cure for this most awful disease.
In all honesty, I was quite hesitant about reading this book, although I had read many great and positive reviews about it from friends. Personally this disease is one of my worst nightmares and I think because I am a few years away from the age when Alice was diagnosed with the disease, it kind of hit home with me even more and was probably the reason I put off reading this book for so long. I found myself asking, what if? what would you do? how would you cope? how would your family cope? A lot of these questions were addressed in this book by both Alice and her family and friend’s experience of dealing with the disease. Really, at the end of the day, there is nothing you can do, it is a disease which is out of your control, in the end, unfortunately you just have to accept and hope that someday, with research, a cure will be found.
It was upsetting to read about the slow digression of Alice's state of mind both in connection with her work and her family and friends. Every time Alice checked back to her five answers on her list, to see how far the disease was affecting her, I found myself willing her to remember, it was like a silent shout out loud to her, hoping and wishing for her to recover. It was heartbreaking reading, how Alice, who was such a learned, esteemed and highly regarded academic at Harvard, had to give it all up and sacrifice herself, her family and career to this horrible disease. It was distressing to read how Alice slowly began to not recognise her husband or children as the disease got progressively worse.
Lydia's character, Alice's youngest daughter, in particular, stood out for me in the book. It was emotional and uplifting to see how Alice and Lydia, who initially had a rocky mother-daughter relationship, in the end, found a lot of support, encouragement, comfort and friendship in one another. Initially I thought that Genova should have allowed John, Alice's husband, a voice in the book, allowed him to give his side of the story, tell us how the disease affected him and share his thoughts with us as he made this journey with Alice. However, upon reflection, I think that Genova did actually give John a voice, not directly to the reader as such, but in a more subtle way. We never really knew how John was feeling, never really knew his thoughts. We saw his frustrations and in some ways he appeared to carry on as normal as possible. I think now, that Genova actually got this right in her portrayal of John. John's world was turned on its head by Alice's disease. I would imagine that his thoughts and feelings were a mixture of disbelief and perhaps he didn't fully believe that this disease could just come out of the blue, reach into his world and shatter it...I got the impression that he was trying to avoid reality for as long as he possibly could and continue as normal, because if he let his guard slip, for one moment, then Alice’s situation and therefore his situation, would become a reality, a reality which he would have to face and accept. In my opinion, outwardly he tried to ignore this for as long as he could but on the inside I think he was just shocked and devastated. I felt that John's twisting of his wedding ring many times in the book was quite significant and symbolic. For me, Alice's diagnosis was, in essence, soul-destroying for John. It meant that his marriage, his relationship with his life-long partner, his family life, his world as he previously knew it, was slowly slipping away from him, slowly becoming something he didn't recognise and there was nothing he could do about it. That is something that is difficult to come to terms with for any human being.
I only had an issue with one aspect of the book and that was all of the medical jargon, mostly near the beginning of the book. I realise it was absolutely necessary in the telling of this story and telling the story accurately, but quite honestly, most of it went over my head, due I suppose, to my own ignorance. I became a little bit bored with it, especially when John and the doctor were discussing the different options, trials and medications available to Alice.
In summary, this is a book that you will find hard to put down until you reach the end. You will go on Alice’s journey with her and it is not a pleasant one. It was very educational and I learned a lot. It was an extremely thought-provoking read. I admire anyone going through this illness, their family, friends, those who care for them and those who continue to research for this cause. Hopefully, some day soon, studies in research will find a cure for this most awful disease.
June 12, 2015
What a great heartfelt book. Takes you into the world of dementia and the frustrating lives of those with Alzheimer's, and at the same time, keeps you interested in the characters and plot unable to put the book down.
Update: June 12, 2015 Finally watched the movie......thought book was so much better!
April 3, 2022
I have given almost all of Genova’s novels five well-deserved stars, and this definitely deserved five stars as well. Genova writes beautifully and manages to stir up so many emotions in me. Told from Alice’s perspective, the novel looks at how Alzheimer affects us. It was an utterly convincing portrayal of the disease, and I must admit to shedding some tears. Won’t forget this easily�
May 21, 2024
" أليس " أستاذة علم النفس الإدراكي بجامعة هارفارد ، التي تتمتع بذهن حاضر وذكاء مُتقد ، وقد اجرت العديد من الأبحاث في المجال اللغوي ، وشاركت بمؤتمرات في أنحاء العالم...تعاني من تداعيات بالذاكرة القريبة...هل ذلك النسيان طبيعي ..يرافق سن اليأس ؟...
بعد ان تخضع للعديد من الفحوصات والأختبارات الطبية يتبين أن أعراضها تنطبق على مرض الألزهايمر...
في سرد ناعم ، يرسم الشخصية المُصابة بذلك المرض بصورة حية بمشاعرها المرتبكة والتداعي الإدراكي أمام خلايا الدماغ المُدمرة ، مطاردة الكلمات التي تتلكأ في طريقها اليها ومن ثم اختفاءها في هوة سحيقة ، عدم القدرة على تشكيل الكلمات..لقد باتت اللغة تخذلها...
رأيت الالتفاف حول نفسها في دائرة مغلقة وهى تبحث عن الأشياء وتتساءل أين وضعتها...أم فقدتها ؟...
ان تقف مذهولة فى منتصف الطريق لا تدري اين وجهتها التي اعتادتها لزمن طويل ، سقط قلبي أمام كل سقطة لعدم إدراكها الأبعاد المكانية ، بينما كانت قلقة خائفة من اليوم الذي سيأتي دون أن تتعرف على وجوه من تحب ، لقد تلاقت نظراتنا ، وأخبرتها عيناي بأن تدع القلق فإذا كان عقلها قد خذلها فإن قلبها لن يُخطيء أبداً....
لم تغفل الكاتبة معاناة مرافق المريض ، أن يتأقلم مع هذا الواقع المرير ، كيف يمكن حماية المريض من المداهمة الشرسة العنيفة للمرض على الذكريات والحالة الإدراكية ، أن يتقبل تكرار الأسئلة مراراً ، نسيان اللحظة الماضية ، ترقب حدوث تلك اللحظة التي لن يتعرف عليه من يحب ...
الدموع التي تطفر لعل صورة الكابوس تتلاشى ، القلب الذي يعتصر ألماً ، الاحساس بالتكبيل أمام النهاية المنتظرة والتي لابد منها...
الابتسامات التائهة في طريقها لمن يحب ، كلمات الدعم التي تتساقط من الذاكرة ...ولن يصمد أمام كل ذلك إلا الحب...
عن التشخيص المبكر للمرض ، وإن كانت الأدوية تبطىء دون توقف اجتياح المرض ، مجموعات الدعم التي تخفف من ثقل الواقع ، ومحاولة ملأ الفراغات التي لا تلبث أن تتشكل دون توقف.....
وأخيراً بالرغم من الطفرة الجينية والبروتينات والحمض النووي ، بالرغم من أن " اليس" لم تعد ما تقوله ولا ما تفعله ولا يمكنها استعادة ما تفقده لكن روحها منيعة أمام كل ذلك ولا تزال أليس......�
بعد ان تخضع للعديد من الفحوصات والأختبارات الطبية يتبين أن أعراضها تنطبق على مرض الألزهايمر...
في سرد ناعم ، يرسم الشخصية المُصابة بذلك المرض بصورة حية بمشاعرها المرتبكة والتداعي الإدراكي أمام خلايا الدماغ المُدمرة ، مطاردة الكلمات التي تتلكأ في طريقها اليها ومن ثم اختفاءها في هوة سحيقة ، عدم القدرة على تشكيل الكلمات..لقد باتت اللغة تخذلها...
رأيت الالتفاف حول نفسها في دائرة مغلقة وهى تبحث عن الأشياء وتتساءل أين وضعتها...أم فقدتها ؟...
ان تقف مذهولة فى منتصف الطريق لا تدري اين وجهتها التي اعتادتها لزمن طويل ، سقط قلبي أمام كل سقطة لعدم إدراكها الأبعاد المكانية ، بينما كانت قلقة خائفة من اليوم الذي سيأتي دون أن تتعرف على وجوه من تحب ، لقد تلاقت نظراتنا ، وأخبرتها عيناي بأن تدع القلق فإذا كان عقلها قد خذلها فإن قلبها لن يُخطيء أبداً....
لم تغفل الكاتبة معاناة مرافق المريض ، أن يتأقلم مع هذا الواقع المرير ، كيف يمكن حماية المريض من المداهمة الشرسة العنيفة للمرض على الذكريات والحالة الإدراكية ، أن يتقبل تكرار الأسئلة مراراً ، نسيان اللحظة الماضية ، ترقب حدوث تلك اللحظة التي لن يتعرف عليه من يحب ...
الدموع التي تطفر لعل صورة الكابوس تتلاشى ، القلب الذي يعتصر ألماً ، الاحساس بالتكبيل أمام النهاية المنتظرة والتي لابد منها...
الابتسامات التائهة في طريقها لمن يحب ، كلمات الدعم التي تتساقط من الذاكرة ...ولن يصمد أمام كل ذلك إلا الحب...
عن التشخيص المبكر للمرض ، وإن كانت الأدوية تبطىء دون توقف اجتياح المرض ، مجموعات الدعم التي تخفف من ثقل الواقع ، ومحاولة ملأ الفراغات التي لا تلبث أن تتشكل دون توقف.....
وأخيراً بالرغم من الطفرة الجينية والبروتينات والحمض النووي ، بالرغم من أن " اليس" لم تعد ما تقوله ولا ما تفعله ولا يمكنها استعادة ما تفقده لكن روحها منيعة أمام كل ذلك ولا تزال أليس......�
February 21, 2009
Fifty year old Alice Howland, a world-renowned expert in linguistics and a cognitive psychology professor at Harvard is diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's disease. Still Alice is the story of the unraveling of Alice's life as her disease progresses.
I started out not enjoying this book. The author's main character wasn't very likeable � she seemed too focused on how smart she was and how important and prestigious her job was, but I was quickly won over. Lisa Genova wrote from Alice's perspective so the reader joins in the fear, disorientation, and confusion that come with the progression of Alzheimer's. Alice's relationships with her family and their varying responses to Alice's decline are extremely believable, and the most touching parts of the book are the evolution of Alice's relationships with her husband and children as her disease progresses.
Still Alice is a fantastic book that provides an incredible window into the progression of Alzheimer's disease and is both terrifying and heart-rending. Warning - it will make you question all your middle-age moments of forgetfulness
I started out not enjoying this book. The author's main character wasn't very likeable � she seemed too focused on how smart she was and how important and prestigious her job was, but I was quickly won over. Lisa Genova wrote from Alice's perspective so the reader joins in the fear, disorientation, and confusion that come with the progression of Alzheimer's. Alice's relationships with her family and their varying responses to Alice's decline are extremely believable, and the most touching parts of the book are the evolution of Alice's relationships with her husband and children as her disease progresses.
Still Alice is a fantastic book that provides an incredible window into the progression of Alzheimer's disease and is both terrifying and heart-rending. Warning - it will make you question all your middle-age moments of forgetfulness
April 27, 2018
Intensely readable, relatable, and devastating. I read this when my children were still so little and I distinctly remember rushing off to the other room every chance I got to read a page here and a page there. Thus began my love for Lisa Genova. 5 stars
February 23, 2009
I couldn't put this book down. And, I agree with other reviews of this book that it was heartbreaking. But, I saw something else in this story. Pain and heartache and change comes into everyone's life in some form and not everything that comes from that is bad. Genova does a good job of showing the devastation in Alzheimers but also the beauty in redefined relationships.
November 9, 2014
There are an estimated five hundred thousand people in the United States with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease (as at 2007 when this book was first published). Early-onset is defined as Alzheimer’s under the age of sixty-five. Symptoms can develop in the thirties and forties.
Having worked in the pharmaceutical industry, I’ve always been interested in disease, genetics, clinical trials and finally being able to see, after so many years of research and many failures included, a medicinal product that can help those individuals who have cancer, MS, etc. I keep on hoping that soon a "general" medicinal product will become available that will cure all of these diseases but then I suppose that will put the pharma industry out of business. Am I cynical here? I guess the answer is yes.
So after reading Eve’s review I had to read this book and what an absolutely incredible book it turned out to be. How Lisa Genova could have found such sensitivity in writing this novel I will never know. I guess her background of having a PhD in neuroscience from Harvard University gave her the necessary impetus to write this “million copy bestseller�. She admitted that she had, of course, done a lot of research and well, her end result was perfect. I cannot fault it in any respect.
But where can one possibly begin with this incredible book?
Imagine that you are a fifty year old, apparently healthy and have had a successful twenty-five year career in psycholinguistics and are the “eminent William James� Professor of Psychology at Harvard University; a happily married woman called Alice (Ali to her husband John, a scientist) and three children who on the whole she was very proud of � Anna, Tom and Lydia. Admittedly the latter was a worry to Alice as she wanted to become an actress and had been living in Los Angeles for three years and had missed out on a college education, much to her sibling Anna’s delight. Now that’s not very nice is it? Alice had automatically assumed that Lydia would follow the academic career as her two siblings had but obviously it was not to be.
And then after making a few serious errors such as forgetting a conference in Chicago; on another occasion Alice completely “lost� the word “lexicon� in her main speech; losing her way home whilst out running, to quote just a few examples. Also Alice is beginning to become moody which was not in her nature and she is worried about her memory, is often disoriented and she fears that she may be losing her mind. Surely that would disturb Alice who was so precise in her lifestyle, especially her work? Well naturally it did and she went and had tests, many tests, starting with her primary-care physician, who found nothing untoward, and so she asked to see a neurologist. By this time she was too disturbed and frightened to inform her husband. And the result? Early-onset Alzheimer’s disease which is different to the older form as its cause usually has a strong genetic linkage and it manifests much earlier.
She was positive for the PSI mutation.
So the downward spiral in Alice’s health begins and, of course, as her disease is genetically-linked, her three children come into the equation. Her daughter Anna is trying to become pregnant and both she and Tom have tests to see if they also have the mutation. Lydia declines. If it is positive for Anna, should she have children? It is resolved I’m pleased to say.
Well there’s just pure drama after this. It’s wonderful in fact.
What did remain in my mind was that whenever the husband John is worried, he twirls his wedding ring several times. What does this mean? Is he thinking of until death do us part? Is he worried that his wife Alice’s early-onset Alzheimer’s at the age of fifty makes their future look rather grim? Does he feel sorry for Alice? Does he want an “out�? Well we’ll never know what went on in his mind.
All I can say before I go into overkill with this review is that I’m cutting it short now. I’m lost for words but I must stress that you must read this wonderful book! You’ll actually feel a better person for doing that. Believe me!
Having worked in the pharmaceutical industry, I’ve always been interested in disease, genetics, clinical trials and finally being able to see, after so many years of research and many failures included, a medicinal product that can help those individuals who have cancer, MS, etc. I keep on hoping that soon a "general" medicinal product will become available that will cure all of these diseases but then I suppose that will put the pharma industry out of business. Am I cynical here? I guess the answer is yes.
So after reading Eve’s review I had to read this book and what an absolutely incredible book it turned out to be. How Lisa Genova could have found such sensitivity in writing this novel I will never know. I guess her background of having a PhD in neuroscience from Harvard University gave her the necessary impetus to write this “million copy bestseller�. She admitted that she had, of course, done a lot of research and well, her end result was perfect. I cannot fault it in any respect.
But where can one possibly begin with this incredible book?
Imagine that you are a fifty year old, apparently healthy and have had a successful twenty-five year career in psycholinguistics and are the “eminent William James� Professor of Psychology at Harvard University; a happily married woman called Alice (Ali to her husband John, a scientist) and three children who on the whole she was very proud of � Anna, Tom and Lydia. Admittedly the latter was a worry to Alice as she wanted to become an actress and had been living in Los Angeles for three years and had missed out on a college education, much to her sibling Anna’s delight. Now that’s not very nice is it? Alice had automatically assumed that Lydia would follow the academic career as her two siblings had but obviously it was not to be.
And then after making a few serious errors such as forgetting a conference in Chicago; on another occasion Alice completely “lost� the word “lexicon� in her main speech; losing her way home whilst out running, to quote just a few examples. Also Alice is beginning to become moody which was not in her nature and she is worried about her memory, is often disoriented and she fears that she may be losing her mind. Surely that would disturb Alice who was so precise in her lifestyle, especially her work? Well naturally it did and she went and had tests, many tests, starting with her primary-care physician, who found nothing untoward, and so she asked to see a neurologist. By this time she was too disturbed and frightened to inform her husband. And the result? Early-onset Alzheimer’s disease which is different to the older form as its cause usually has a strong genetic linkage and it manifests much earlier.
She was positive for the PSI mutation.
So the downward spiral in Alice’s health begins and, of course, as her disease is genetically-linked, her three children come into the equation. Her daughter Anna is trying to become pregnant and both she and Tom have tests to see if they also have the mutation. Lydia declines. If it is positive for Anna, should she have children? It is resolved I’m pleased to say.
Well there’s just pure drama after this. It’s wonderful in fact.
What did remain in my mind was that whenever the husband John is worried, he twirls his wedding ring several times. What does this mean? Is he thinking of until death do us part? Is he worried that his wife Alice’s early-onset Alzheimer’s at the age of fifty makes their future look rather grim? Does he feel sorry for Alice? Does he want an “out�? Well we’ll never know what went on in his mind.
All I can say before I go into overkill with this review is that I’m cutting it short now. I’m lost for words but I must stress that you must read this wonderful book! You’ll actually feel a better person for doing that. Believe me!
December 30, 2013
I avoided this book for a long time, though I’m not exactly sure why. I think the premise (or at least what I understood to be the premise) reminded me of a book I read last year that was so horribly executed I felt very little inclination to get into something similar again. Who wants another lousy memory loss story, anyway? Well, put me in the “wrong again, asshole!� category because where the first book failed, converting an otherwise interesting idea into cheesy mindless schlock, this one delivered just fine.
It is the story of Alice Howland, a professor of psychology at Harvard University who, at the height of her research career, slowly begins exhibiting signs of early-onset dementia. Attributing her symptoms to stress or exhaustion at first, she eventually learns that she carries a gene mutation responsible for Alzheimer’s and is already well into the early stages of the disease. Knowing the gene mutation is autosomal dominant (meaning she only needs one copy of the gene to express the disease), each of her three children stands a 50% chance of inheriting the disease as well. The knowledge of this, on top of her own losses of stature, confidence, and ultimately her independence, serves only to compound the agony.
It is not all perfect, of course. The book is fairly breezy, refusing to delve much past the expected feelings of frustration, loneliness, and confusion that accompanies Alzheimer’s, and it often times felt rather clinical and pamphlet-y. But I am a giant nerd—I like clinical and pamphlet-y when the subject matter is in my realm of interests. Regardless, the book serves a purpose. It strikes the reader as remaining fairly true to the experiences of someone beginning to lose the required synapses necessary to retain memory and cognitive function—my second grader would call this “realistic fiction”—and as of its publication, it is in fact the only novel ever to have been endorsed by the Alzheimer’s Association.
And what I’m saying here is that I guess I am endorsing it a little bit, too.
It is the story of Alice Howland, a professor of psychology at Harvard University who, at the height of her research career, slowly begins exhibiting signs of early-onset dementia. Attributing her symptoms to stress or exhaustion at first, she eventually learns that she carries a gene mutation responsible for Alzheimer’s and is already well into the early stages of the disease. Knowing the gene mutation is autosomal dominant (meaning she only needs one copy of the gene to express the disease), each of her three children stands a 50% chance of inheriting the disease as well. The knowledge of this, on top of her own losses of stature, confidence, and ultimately her independence, serves only to compound the agony.
It is not all perfect, of course. The book is fairly breezy, refusing to delve much past the expected feelings of frustration, loneliness, and confusion that accompanies Alzheimer’s, and it often times felt rather clinical and pamphlet-y. But I am a giant nerd—I like clinical and pamphlet-y when the subject matter is in my realm of interests. Regardless, the book serves a purpose. It strikes the reader as remaining fairly true to the experiences of someone beginning to lose the required synapses necessary to retain memory and cognitive function—my second grader would call this “realistic fiction”—and as of its publication, it is in fact the only novel ever to have been endorsed by the Alzheimer’s Association.
And what I’m saying here is that I guess I am endorsing it a little bit, too.
June 12, 2018
Oh my gosh. Why did I do this to myself? Did I just think, "Hey, I haven't cried and felt miserable in a while. I should fix that." Or what?
Yeah, normal Jilly doesn't cry. If I'm really upset I'm more likely to spiral into a dark depression and retreat from everyone and everything. You know, like a well-adjusted person. But tears? No, not a thing. Yet, this book brought a few.
Maybe the old tear ducts need a good cleaning once in a while. It's probably healthy.
Next time, this is how I'll clean them.
Anyway, read this one if you want to cry. Or, if you want to get really scared, because truthfully, all of the early signs of Alzheimer's are there for most of us.
Forgetting words and using "thingy" in place? Check
Forgetting where something is? Check
Forgetting what I was looking for or why I came in that room? Check
Forgetting to go running? Double and Triple Check. Okay, maybe not forgetting to run exactly, but I don't run. Is that a sign? Do I have it?
Hypochondriac kitty shouldn't read this book.
To be honest, I didn't really like Alice all that much before she got diagnosed, but her descent into Early Onset Alzheimer's was brutal. Nobody should have to go through that. The story did a great job showing us the horror of losing your mind. And, scaring the ever-loving crap out of me.
In other words... Unless you really need to clean those tear ducts, or you know someone going through this and want understanding, you should probably stay away. Read something happy and funny instead.
Or, read this story. This looks promising.
Yeah, normal Jilly doesn't cry. If I'm really upset I'm more likely to spiral into a dark depression and retreat from everyone and everything. You know, like a well-adjusted person. But tears? No, not a thing. Yet, this book brought a few.
Maybe the old tear ducts need a good cleaning once in a while. It's probably healthy.
Next time, this is how I'll clean them.
Anyway, read this one if you want to cry. Or, if you want to get really scared, because truthfully, all of the early signs of Alzheimer's are there for most of us.
Forgetting words and using "thingy" in place? Check
Forgetting where something is? Check
Forgetting what I was looking for or why I came in that room? Check
Forgetting to go running? Double and Triple Check. Okay, maybe not forgetting to run exactly, but I don't run. Is that a sign? Do I have it?
Hypochondriac kitty shouldn't read this book.
To be honest, I didn't really like Alice all that much before she got diagnosed, but her descent into Early Onset Alzheimer's was brutal. Nobody should have to go through that. The story did a great job showing us the horror of losing your mind. And, scaring the ever-loving crap out of me.
In other words... Unless you really need to clean those tear ducts, or you know someone going through this and want understanding, you should probably stay away. Read something happy and funny instead.
Or, read this story. This looks promising.
June 30, 2016
What makes a novel truly good is that it can stand on the quality of the writing alone.
To coast along (saleswise or otherwise) on the coattails of subject matter, is, I think, cheating.
That Still Alice is about Alzheimer's Disease is, I would guess, a good part of the reason that so many people have responded so well to it.
Fair enough: Every reader brings their personal history to every book they read. And if they have witnessed lives of dear ones being derailed by Alzheimer's, they will read this book with a sense of familiarity, of kinship even, knowing too intimately well the wounds it has bludgeoned them with.
Fair enough.
Still none of that is enough to excuse the faults that keep this book from being a well-written novel--it simply isn't one. The characters are thin and weakly-defined, and there are too many jarring moments where it merely reads like a helpfully informative brochure about Alzheimer's.
Actually, reading a brochure, or an article about it in a medical journal would've felt more honest.
I suppose I'm informed now.
But somehow I also feel cheated...
To coast along (saleswise or otherwise) on the coattails of subject matter, is, I think, cheating.
That Still Alice is about Alzheimer's Disease is, I would guess, a good part of the reason that so many people have responded so well to it.
Fair enough: Every reader brings their personal history to every book they read. And if they have witnessed lives of dear ones being derailed by Alzheimer's, they will read this book with a sense of familiarity, of kinship even, knowing too intimately well the wounds it has bludgeoned them with.
Fair enough.
Still none of that is enough to excuse the faults that keep this book from being a well-written novel--it simply isn't one. The characters are thin and weakly-defined, and there are too many jarring moments where it merely reads like a helpfully informative brochure about Alzheimer's.
Actually, reading a brochure, or an article about it in a medical journal would've felt more honest.
I suppose I'm informed now.
But somehow I also feel cheated...
February 2, 2021
2011 F.A.B. Bookclub pick # I.❤️. F.A.B.
A very sad view of what it’s like being someone who has Alzheimer’s. Alice is a brilliant professor, so she’s quick to notice her own symptoms. The part where her family is discussing her, right in front of her, but not consulting her was heartbreaking. It’s a sad read!
A very sad view of what it’s like being someone who has Alzheimer’s. Alice is a brilliant professor, so she’s quick to notice her own symptoms. The part where her family is discussing her, right in front of her, but not consulting her was heartbreaking. It’s a sad read!
February 17, 2016
What a read!
This book reduced me to tears, tugged at my heartstrings, and left me emotionally exhausted.
We all forget things....what we were going to say, where we've put things, appointments, people, faces, places. There seems to be a very fine line between what is 'normal' and the onset of Alzheimer's.
I have heard that keeping your brain active and taking regular exercise help's reduce the risk of Alzheimer's. I can't think of anyone who could be more active in both fields than Alice Howland, who is diagnosed with Early Onset Alzheimer's at the age of 50.
She is a psychology professor at Harvard, a runner, a mother of three and wife of another Harvard professor.
My heart bled for Alice on her journey from successful academic to a woman who did not recognise her own children. This is one of the most frightening and yet most beautiful books I have ever read.
Still Alice should be compulsory reading.
I listened to the audio version which was beautifully narrated.
This book reduced me to tears, tugged at my heartstrings, and left me emotionally exhausted.
We all forget things....what we were going to say, where we've put things, appointments, people, faces, places. There seems to be a very fine line between what is 'normal' and the onset of Alzheimer's.
I have heard that keeping your brain active and taking regular exercise help's reduce the risk of Alzheimer's. I can't think of anyone who could be more active in both fields than Alice Howland, who is diagnosed with Early Onset Alzheimer's at the age of 50.
She is a psychology professor at Harvard, a runner, a mother of three and wife of another Harvard professor.
My heart bled for Alice on her journey from successful academic to a woman who did not recognise her own children. This is one of the most frightening and yet most beautiful books I have ever read.
Still Alice should be compulsory reading.
I listened to the audio version which was beautifully narrated.
October 13, 2020
رواية رائعة برغم أنها مؤلمة ومؤثرة للغاية ..
أستاذة جامعية تصاب بمرض ألزهايمر وهي على مشارف الخمسين فتتحول من شخصية مرموقة ومميزة علميا وإجتماعيا إلى إنسانة مشوشة كثيرة النسيان والأخطاء ، ويتغير مجرى حياتها بشكل مأساوي فتفقد وظيفتها الجامعية وتضطرب علاقتها بأفراد أسرتها وأصدقائها والعالم من حولها إلى الأبد.
أستاذة جامعية تصاب بمرض ألزهايمر وهي على مشارف الخمسين فتتحول من شخصية مرموقة ومميزة علميا وإجتماعيا إلى إنسانة مشوشة كثيرة النسيان والأخطاء ، ويتغير مجرى حياتها بشكل مأساوي فتفقد وظيفتها الجامعية وتضطرب علاقتها بأفراد أسرتها وأصدقائها والعالم من حولها إلى الأبد.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31,340 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.