What do you think?
Rate this book
Hierarchy #1
The Will of the Many
Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Choice Award
Nominee for Readers' Favorite Fantasy (2023)At the elite Catenan Academy, a young fugitive uncovers layered mysteries and world-changing secrets in this new fantasy series by internationally bestselling author of The Licanius Trilogy, James Islington.
AUDI. VIDE. TACE.
The Catenan Republic ¨C the Hierarchy ¨C may rule the world now, but they do not know everything.
I tell them my name is Vis Telimus. I tell them I was orphaned after a tragic accident three years ago, and that good fortune alone has led to my acceptance into their most prestigious school. I tell them that once I graduate, I will gladly join the rest of civilised society in allowing my strength, my drive and my focus ¨C what they call Will ¨C to be leeched away and added to the power of those above me, as millions already do. As all must eventually do.
I tell them that I belong, and they believe me.
But the truth is that I have been sent to the Academy to find answers. To solve a murder. To search for an ancient weapon. To uncover secrets that may tear the Republic apart.
And that I will never, ever cede my Will to the empire that executed my family.
To survive, though, I will still have to rise through the Academy¡¯s ranks. I will have to smile, and make friends, and pretend to be one of them and win. Because if I cannot, then those who want to control me, who know my real name, will no longer have any use for me.
And if the Hierarchy finds out who I truly am, they will kill me.
AUDI. VIDE. TACE.
The Catenan Republic ¨C the Hierarchy ¨C may rule the world now, but they do not know everything.
I tell them my name is Vis Telimus. I tell them I was orphaned after a tragic accident three years ago, and that good fortune alone has led to my acceptance into their most prestigious school. I tell them that once I graduate, I will gladly join the rest of civilised society in allowing my strength, my drive and my focus ¨C what they call Will ¨C to be leeched away and added to the power of those above me, as millions already do. As all must eventually do.
I tell them that I belong, and they believe me.
But the truth is that I have been sent to the Academy to find answers. To solve a murder. To search for an ancient weapon. To uncover secrets that may tear the Republic apart.
And that I will never, ever cede my Will to the empire that executed my family.
To survive, though, I will still have to rise through the Academy¡¯s ranks. I will have to smile, and make friends, and pretend to be one of them and win. Because if I cannot, then those who want to control me, who know my real name, will no longer have any use for me.
And if the Hierarchy finds out who I truly am, they will kill me.
639 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 23, 2023
17k people are currently reading
451k people want to read
About the author
James Islington
8?books11.9k?followersJames Islington was born and raised in southern Victoria, Australia. His influences growing up were the stories of Raymond E. Feist and Robert Jordan, but it wasn't until later, when he read Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn series - followed soon after by Patrick Rothfuss' Name of the Wind - that he was finally inspired to sit down and write something of his own. He now lives with his wife and two children on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 18,726 reviews
March 23, 2025
ARC provided by the publisher¡ªSaga Press¡ªin exchange for an honest review.
This is not an exaggeration. The Will of the Many by James Islington is the best fantasy book with a magical school trope I¡¯ve ever read since The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss.
James Islington instantly became one of my favorite authors with The Licanius Trilogy. Since then, I knew I would need to read every new book written by him, and that's why The Will of the Many, together with Light Bringer by Pierce Brown and the four secret novels by Brandon Sanderson, reached the top of my most anticipated releases of this year. It's not a good habit to have high expectations toward any book as that makes us prone to disappointment. But I couldn't resist it here. I didn't know what the story in The Will of the Many would be, and I still entered it with very high expectations because I loved how satisfying Islington completed the complexity of The Licanius Trilogy. And luckily, Islington managed to exceed my unreasonably high expectations with The Will of the Many, the first book in the Hierarchy series. As far as the first book of a series goes, this one tops over The Shadow of What Was Lost in every possible way, and I think many of you know how much I enjoyed The Licanius Trilogy by now. To be more precise, The Will of the Many is Islington's best novel so far in his career. It is, at the very least, even though it is a different kind of book, up there with the quality produced in The Light of All That Falls. This is a contender for the best book of 2023. By the end of this year, the competition is fierce, but I will be shocked if The Will of the Many did not¡ªat least¡ªend up in my top 5 books of the year. And I will tell you why in this review.
The Catenan Republic¡ªthe Hierarchy¡ªmay rule the world now, but they do not know everything. He tells them his name is Vis Telimus. He tells them he was orphaned after a tragic accident three years ago, and good fortune alone gives him a chance to enter their most prestigious school: The Catenan Academy. He tells them that once he graduates, he will gladly join the rest of civilized society in allowing his strength, drive, and focus¡ªwhat they call Will¡ªto be leeched away and added to the power of those above him, as millions already do. As all must eventually do. Vis tells them that he belongs, and they believe him. But the truth is that Vis has been sent to enter the Catenan Academy to find answers. To solve a murder. To search for an ancient weapon. To uncover secrets that may tear the Republic apart. And that he will never, ever cede his Will to the empire that executed his family. To survive, though, Vis will have to rise through the Academy¡¯s ranks. He will have to smile, make friends, pretend to be one of them and win. If he fails, then those who want to control him, who know his real name, will no longer have any use for him. And if the Hierarchy ever finds out who Vis truly is, they will kill him.
This is the blurb for The Will of the Many. If you¡¯re familiar with Pierce Brown¡¯s sci-fi series Red Rising Saga, you might notice the similarities in the premise. For context, in Red Rising, Darrow is a Red, the lowest rank in the hierarchy of labor within the color-coded society of the series. The Gold is the ruler of humanity, and they have done irrevocable actions to Darrow and the Red for many years. So Darrow has to masquerade as a Gold and increase his fame and prestige through the rank of Gold to fulfill his revenge. Red Rising Saga is one of my favorite series of all time, and yes, the similarities with Red Rising can definitely be spotted in The Will of the Many. Even more so because Vis has a personality that is quick to anger like Darrow, and the world-building of these two series is heavily Roman-inspired as well; more on this later. But more importantly, the premise and the Roman-inspired world-building are where the similarities end.
The Will of the Many is a different kind of book compared to Red Rising. This is not like the controversial case that The First Binding by R. R. Virdi has with The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss. This 240,000 words long novel never felt derivative to me. It's the other way around; with more pages read in The Will of the Many, especially after the insane ending, the more I feel The Will of the Many as a whole package, as expected of Islington, is another incredibly distinct, ambitious, and mind-blowing work of art. From my assessment, it would be more exact to say if you love the premise and world-building portrayed in Red Rising Saga, it's very possible you will end up loving The Will of the Many. Especially if you love the magical school or academy setting and trope too.
If you¡¯ve read The Licanius Trilogy, you will know that plotting is one of the finest aspects of the trilogy. I¡¯m pleased to mention Islington¡¯s strength as a mostly planner storyteller (I believe every writer is a mix of both) returns powerfully in The Will of the Many. My mind is still reeling as I write this review. I cannot stop thinking about all the events that transpired in this novel and their crazy implications for the rest of the series. Only a special fantasy series can make me feel this effect right after reading the first¡ªout of the planned three or four¡ªinstallments. I predict The Hierarchy will be more than a trilogy, but that remains to be seen. I am not comparing which is better here as a storyteller: a pantser or a planner. Both have their merits. However, I believe Islington has showcased the best aspects of being a¡ªmostly¡ªplanner type of storyteller in The Licanius Trilogy with his meticulous story structure and well-placed revelations, and I can already see these factors being implemented magnificently here. This is all splendidly realized without any sacrifice in pacing. The pacing was engrossing from cover to cover for me.
The blurb and I have mentioned the enrollment into the prestigious Catenan Academy. I do not think of this as a spoiler; similar to readers talking about Kvothe entering The University in The Kingkiller Chronicle or Harry Potter entering Hogwarts, just a few examples. Both series take place in a magical school setting, the same as The Will of the Many. But to set expectations accordingly, let me be clear that Vis' tale in the Catenan Academy did not start until we reached Part II of the book: Deus Nolens Exituus. (Get Results Whether God likes it or not.) That's 35% into the book, and by approximation, I think about 50% of the story actually takes place in The Catenan Academy. Part I of the story, Imperium Sine Fine (An Empire without an End), was the setup and foundation. This is the introductory section, and it depicts Vis¡¯ merciless training montage and preparation under the tutelage of Lanistia before he enters the Academy. Additionally, the foundational stage and the training montage were never uneventful. Islington efficaciously made the three parts of the narrative here have their own overarching story arc (beginning, middle section, and concluding chapters) while being seamlessly connected to one another. If you already have a great time reading Part I, you will be gripped with the rest of the book. This, of course, comes with a caveat that the magical school or academy trope and setting is one of your favorites.
The Will of the Many is a book about ambition, justice, greed, vengeance, friendship, leadership, loyalty, knowledge, and family. And although these were on some level established since Part I, they were extensively integrated into the narrative in Part II and Part III: In Cauda Venenum (The Poison is in the Tail); once Vis is in The Catenan Academy, an academy that rewards greed and victory above all else. A magic school setting in fantasy is constantly irresistible to me. I have no idea when I will be over this trope, but it is not anytime soon. I am confident in that. I cannot help it, okay? Whether in novels, manga, or video games, I have many of my favorite adult fantasy stories centers or starts in a magical or battle school setting. It is one of my favorite tropes of all time. There is something about training montages, learning new abilities and skills, overcoming challenges, and defeating bullies or horrible teachers while forming friendships that always feel satisfying and relatable. These factors in fantasy novels, paired with the magical school trope, and a main character that earned my investment, have a good chance of becoming one of my favorite books. They are some of my favorite escapism. Assuming they are done right, of course, and The Will of the Many is a good example where all of these were infused incredibly well.
A few comments have stated they did not feel connected to the main characters of The Licanius Trilogy due to its heavily plot-focused storyline, except for Caeden. Although I do not fully agree with this notion, because I liked Davian, Wirr, Asha, and many characters in the trilogy enough, I certainly agree Caeden is the best character in The Licanius Trilogy; Caeden IS one of my favorite characters in the fantasy genre. It is with a heart full of happiness I say it is very likely Vis will become a character I love as much as Caeden in the future. Try not to misinterpret what I said as a criticism toward The Licanius Trilogy. The Licanius Trilogy is one of my favorite trilogies. My point is that Islington has developed further as a storyteller; with more books in the series available in the future, the potential for Hierarchy series to be better than The Licanius Trilogy is strongly evident. If I am already this compelled and invested in Vis and his story just from reading The Will of the Many, what would be the outcome after reading the sequels? I am excited to find out.
I found Vis to be a character reminiscent of Kvothe or Darrow. Forged by his brutal past, the rigorous physical and mental training he partakes from a young age has acted as an eternal fire of motivation that transformed him into a skillful fighter, intelligent, resourceful, a quick learner, and a jack of all trades. In other words, Vis is great at many things. However, he is not flawless. Vis lies a lot for survival and is often blinded by rage. This uncontrollable crimson veil of wrath often leads him toward conflicts or iconic moments, depending on how you look at the situation. His capacity for violence and fury is a weakness he needs to tame, and he soon realizes he cannot do everything by himself. This is why the unlikely friendship he forms in the Academy, especially with Callidus and Eidhin, gives him solace and hope amidst all the loneliness, dangers, and life-threatening allegiances he's juggling. Moments of virtue, loyalty, and solidarity were relatively rare and hard-earned, but the warmth of each one of these occurrences felt palpable; they radiated from the pages. All of these, along with Vis' inspiring courage, determination, and compassion, reinforce the unputdownable narrative for me.
Islington's improved prose was responsible for my immersion and connection with the novel. Islington successfully nailed Vis' personality and voice so damn well. In science fiction & fantasy novels, it is frequently crucial for me to truly feel like the POV character is telling their story, not the author. The narrative has to completely enthrall me in the POV character's narration and inner thoughts. The best kind of SFF authors can do this. Here are some examples of an SFF series with excellent first-person POV narration. Fitz in The Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb, Kvothe in The Kingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss, Darrow in Red Rising Saga by Pierce Brown, and Tomas Piety in War for the Rose Throne by Peter McLean with Tomas Piety. These four characters' narration felt like the author became the messenger with a mission to write and deliver their tales. And that, precisely, is what has been accomplished in The Will of the Many. Islington¡¯s writing style has the ability to conjure vivid imagery in my mind and an engaging reading experience effectively. And these praises are not exclusive to Vis. The entire story is told from the first-person POV narration (in present tense) of Vis, and yet, I still feel like I got to know the supporting characters' motivations and personalities almost as well as Vis. They are all unique with their own qualities.
Finally, before I close this long-enough review, I want to elaborate on the world-building of the series. When I read The Will of the Many, it hit me that I haven¡¯t read as much Roman-inspired epic fantasy series as I thought. I think this is a factor that increased my reading enjoyment. There is Codex Alera by Jim Butcher, a popular Roman-inspired fantasy series. But, in my opinion, The Will of the Many is multiple times superior. The world-building feels relatively fresh. Many aspects of the world-building in The Will of the Many are deeply rooted in its Roman inspiration. The names, clothing, beautiful vistas, settings, in-world game, and more. Every aspect of the Roman-inspired world and Islington's crafted fantasy lore were delivered in detail gradually. I did not feel overwhelmed by the terminologies, there is a character list and glossary at the back of the book every time I need to remind myself of something, and it did not take long for me to feel immersed in this Roman-inspired epic fantasy series. And I loved it. The gladiatorial bouts, the naumachia, the Catenan rankings, and how the magic system (Will, which I'm sure we will see even more of its usage in future sequels) is interweaved into the story. Everything felt so natural to the plotlines. Plus, there is, of course, Islington's own creation in the manifestation of the mystery of the ancient weaponry and Cataclysm, a world-spanning disaster three centuries ago that left less than five people in every hundred alive. Maybe it is more accurate to call The Will of the Many, and the series, an epic science fantasy series due to how the high fantasy aspect and scientific technologies merged and enhanced the narrative. And I, as a fan of having more sci-fi elements in epic fantasy, am totally pleased by all of these combinations.
The characters' development, in-depth lore, technologies, and history established in The Will of the Many have provided possibilities for the Will and mysteries of the Cataclysm and more to be explored further in the next installments. This is also a darker novel than I expected. Explosions, massacres, shredded flesh and blood, and obsidian eyes and blades; the action scenes¡ªthe big action sequences, Labyrinth runs, or duels¡ªwere all tension-packed. Islington displayed the immense terror every second can bring in the lurking presence of disintegration and chaos. Violence begets grief, and grief begets violence. Is it a mistake, or is it righteous, to repay the sorrow caused by the heinous sins of the past with more violence of the present? The Will of the Many closed the magical/battle school/dark academia portion of the series, and that alone was already super satisfying. But oh my god... the mysteries and implications raised after the final chapters were groundbreaking, to say the least. Without spoilers, what Islington did in the epilogue, Ex Uno Plures (Out of One, Many), was nothing short of outstanding. In one chapter, Islington escalated the scintillating novel into something even more extraordinary.
My emotional attachment to the characters and events of this book is undeniable. The Will of the Many by James Islington is a phenomenal achievement. Islington has flourishingly crafted a Roman-inspired science fantasy world with brilliant plotlines that feel believable through the perspective of a talented and flawed main character imbued with a superbly distinct voice. I absolutely loved it. It IS one of the best books I've ever read, and it is also one of the rare books where, upon finishing it, I immediately wanted to reread from the beginning. And I know I will do that when the sequel, The Strength of the Few, is near. The waiting time for the sequel will be one of the worst waiting times I need to endure. How could it not be after the intense and insane culmination of the book? But until then... I will be patient. Audi (Hear). Vide (See). Tace (Be Silent). And read The Will of the Many as soon as possible. A new exceptional science fantasy series destined to become a classic is here. The Will of the Many has everything I love in an epic science fantasy novel, and many scenes here will become eternal moments in my mind.
You can pre-order this book from: |
Most of the quotes I wanted to use in this review were taken out on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ because I ran out of allowed characters.
You can find and the rest of my reviews at | I also have a
Special thanks to my Patrons on for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Aliysa, Anastasia, Andrew, Andrew W, Annabeth, Arliss, Barbara, Brad, Cade, Casey, Chris, Diana, Dylan, Edward, Elias, Ellen, Gary, Hamad, Helen, Jenn, Jesse, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Kristina, Luis, Lufi, Melinda, Meryl, Michael, Michael, Miracle, Nicholas, Radiah, Samuel, Sarah, Sarah, Scott, Shawn, Shawna, Teri, Tori, Tracy, Wendy, Wick, Xero, Yuri, Zoe.
This is not an exaggeration. The Will of the Many by James Islington is the best fantasy book with a magical school trope I¡¯ve ever read since The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss.
¡°The power to protect is the highest of responsibilities¡ When a man is given it, his duty is not only to the people he thinks are worthy.¡±
James Islington instantly became one of my favorite authors with The Licanius Trilogy. Since then, I knew I would need to read every new book written by him, and that's why The Will of the Many, together with Light Bringer by Pierce Brown and the four secret novels by Brandon Sanderson, reached the top of my most anticipated releases of this year. It's not a good habit to have high expectations toward any book as that makes us prone to disappointment. But I couldn't resist it here. I didn't know what the story in The Will of the Many would be, and I still entered it with very high expectations because I loved how satisfying Islington completed the complexity of The Licanius Trilogy. And luckily, Islington managed to exceed my unreasonably high expectations with The Will of the Many, the first book in the Hierarchy series. As far as the first book of a series goes, this one tops over The Shadow of What Was Lost in every possible way, and I think many of you know how much I enjoyed The Licanius Trilogy by now. To be more precise, The Will of the Many is Islington's best novel so far in his career. It is, at the very least, even though it is a different kind of book, up there with the quality produced in The Light of All That Falls. This is a contender for the best book of 2023. By the end of this year, the competition is fierce, but I will be shocked if The Will of the Many did not¡ªat least¡ªend up in my top 5 books of the year. And I will tell you why in this review.
The Catenan Republic¡ªthe Hierarchy¡ªmay rule the world now, but they do not know everything. He tells them his name is Vis Telimus. He tells them he was orphaned after a tragic accident three years ago, and good fortune alone gives him a chance to enter their most prestigious school: The Catenan Academy. He tells them that once he graduates, he will gladly join the rest of civilized society in allowing his strength, drive, and focus¡ªwhat they call Will¡ªto be leeched away and added to the power of those above him, as millions already do. As all must eventually do. Vis tells them that he belongs, and they believe him. But the truth is that Vis has been sent to enter the Catenan Academy to find answers. To solve a murder. To search for an ancient weapon. To uncover secrets that may tear the Republic apart. And that he will never, ever cede his Will to the empire that executed his family. To survive, though, Vis will have to rise through the Academy¡¯s ranks. He will have to smile, make friends, pretend to be one of them and win. If he fails, then those who want to control him, who know his real name, will no longer have any use for him. And if the Hierarchy ever finds out who Vis truly is, they will kill him.
This is the blurb for The Will of the Many. If you¡¯re familiar with Pierce Brown¡¯s sci-fi series Red Rising Saga, you might notice the similarities in the premise. For context, in Red Rising, Darrow is a Red, the lowest rank in the hierarchy of labor within the color-coded society of the series. The Gold is the ruler of humanity, and they have done irrevocable actions to Darrow and the Red for many years. So Darrow has to masquerade as a Gold and increase his fame and prestige through the rank of Gold to fulfill his revenge. Red Rising Saga is one of my favorite series of all time, and yes, the similarities with Red Rising can definitely be spotted in The Will of the Many. Even more so because Vis has a personality that is quick to anger like Darrow, and the world-building of these two series is heavily Roman-inspired as well; more on this later. But more importantly, the premise and the Roman-inspired world-building are where the similarities end.
¡°A man is nothing if he does not honour his debts.¡±
The Will of the Many is a different kind of book compared to Red Rising. This is not like the controversial case that The First Binding by R. R. Virdi has with The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss. This 240,000 words long novel never felt derivative to me. It's the other way around; with more pages read in The Will of the Many, especially after the insane ending, the more I feel The Will of the Many as a whole package, as expected of Islington, is another incredibly distinct, ambitious, and mind-blowing work of art. From my assessment, it would be more exact to say if you love the premise and world-building portrayed in Red Rising Saga, it's very possible you will end up loving The Will of the Many. Especially if you love the magical school or academy setting and trope too.
If you¡¯ve read The Licanius Trilogy, you will know that plotting is one of the finest aspects of the trilogy. I¡¯m pleased to mention Islington¡¯s strength as a mostly planner storyteller (I believe every writer is a mix of both) returns powerfully in The Will of the Many. My mind is still reeling as I write this review. I cannot stop thinking about all the events that transpired in this novel and their crazy implications for the rest of the series. Only a special fantasy series can make me feel this effect right after reading the first¡ªout of the planned three or four¡ªinstallments. I predict The Hierarchy will be more than a trilogy, but that remains to be seen. I am not comparing which is better here as a storyteller: a pantser or a planner. Both have their merits. However, I believe Islington has showcased the best aspects of being a¡ªmostly¡ªplanner type of storyteller in The Licanius Trilogy with his meticulous story structure and well-placed revelations, and I can already see these factors being implemented magnificently here. This is all splendidly realized without any sacrifice in pacing. The pacing was engrossing from cover to cover for me.
The blurb and I have mentioned the enrollment into the prestigious Catenan Academy. I do not think of this as a spoiler; similar to readers talking about Kvothe entering The University in The Kingkiller Chronicle or Harry Potter entering Hogwarts, just a few examples. Both series take place in a magical school setting, the same as The Will of the Many. But to set expectations accordingly, let me be clear that Vis' tale in the Catenan Academy did not start until we reached Part II of the book: Deus Nolens Exituus. (Get Results Whether God likes it or not.) That's 35% into the book, and by approximation, I think about 50% of the story actually takes place in The Catenan Academy. Part I of the story, Imperium Sine Fine (An Empire without an End), was the setup and foundation. This is the introductory section, and it depicts Vis¡¯ merciless training montage and preparation under the tutelage of Lanistia before he enters the Academy. Additionally, the foundational stage and the training montage were never uneventful. Islington efficaciously made the three parts of the narrative here have their own overarching story arc (beginning, middle section, and concluding chapters) while being seamlessly connected to one another. If you already have a great time reading Part I, you will be gripped with the rest of the book. This, of course, comes with a caveat that the magical school or academy trope and setting is one of your favorites.
The Will of the Many is a book about ambition, justice, greed, vengeance, friendship, leadership, loyalty, knowledge, and family. And although these were on some level established since Part I, they were extensively integrated into the narrative in Part II and Part III: In Cauda Venenum (The Poison is in the Tail); once Vis is in The Catenan Academy, an academy that rewards greed and victory above all else. A magic school setting in fantasy is constantly irresistible to me. I have no idea when I will be over this trope, but it is not anytime soon. I am confident in that. I cannot help it, okay? Whether in novels, manga, or video games, I have many of my favorite adult fantasy stories centers or starts in a magical or battle school setting. It is one of my favorite tropes of all time. There is something about training montages, learning new abilities and skills, overcoming challenges, and defeating bullies or horrible teachers while forming friendships that always feel satisfying and relatable. These factors in fantasy novels, paired with the magical school trope, and a main character that earned my investment, have a good chance of becoming one of my favorite books. They are some of my favorite escapism. Assuming they are done right, of course, and The Will of the Many is a good example where all of these were infused incredibly well.
A few comments have stated they did not feel connected to the main characters of The Licanius Trilogy due to its heavily plot-focused storyline, except for Caeden. Although I do not fully agree with this notion, because I liked Davian, Wirr, Asha, and many characters in the trilogy enough, I certainly agree Caeden is the best character in The Licanius Trilogy; Caeden IS one of my favorite characters in the fantasy genre. It is with a heart full of happiness I say it is very likely Vis will become a character I love as much as Caeden in the future. Try not to misinterpret what I said as a criticism toward The Licanius Trilogy. The Licanius Trilogy is one of my favorite trilogies. My point is that Islington has developed further as a storyteller; with more books in the series available in the future, the potential for Hierarchy series to be better than The Licanius Trilogy is strongly evident. If I am already this compelled and invested in Vis and his story just from reading The Will of the Many, what would be the outcome after reading the sequels? I am excited to find out.
¡°Whether the obstacles to our advancement arise from our ties or our actions, we need to learn to overcome them ourselves. It¡¯s not fair, but nor is the world.¡±
I found Vis to be a character reminiscent of Kvothe or Darrow. Forged by his brutal past, the rigorous physical and mental training he partakes from a young age has acted as an eternal fire of motivation that transformed him into a skillful fighter, intelligent, resourceful, a quick learner, and a jack of all trades. In other words, Vis is great at many things. However, he is not flawless. Vis lies a lot for survival and is often blinded by rage. This uncontrollable crimson veil of wrath often leads him toward conflicts or iconic moments, depending on how you look at the situation. His capacity for violence and fury is a weakness he needs to tame, and he soon realizes he cannot do everything by himself. This is why the unlikely friendship he forms in the Academy, especially with Callidus and Eidhin, gives him solace and hope amidst all the loneliness, dangers, and life-threatening allegiances he's juggling. Moments of virtue, loyalty, and solidarity were relatively rare and hard-earned, but the warmth of each one of these occurrences felt palpable; they radiated from the pages. All of these, along with Vis' inspiring courage, determination, and compassion, reinforce the unputdownable narrative for me.
Islington's improved prose was responsible for my immersion and connection with the novel. Islington successfully nailed Vis' personality and voice so damn well. In science fiction & fantasy novels, it is frequently crucial for me to truly feel like the POV character is telling their story, not the author. The narrative has to completely enthrall me in the POV character's narration and inner thoughts. The best kind of SFF authors can do this. Here are some examples of an SFF series with excellent first-person POV narration. Fitz in The Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb, Kvothe in The Kingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss, Darrow in Red Rising Saga by Pierce Brown, and Tomas Piety in War for the Rose Throne by Peter McLean with Tomas Piety. These four characters' narration felt like the author became the messenger with a mission to write and deliver their tales. And that, precisely, is what has been accomplished in The Will of the Many. Islington¡¯s writing style has the ability to conjure vivid imagery in my mind and an engaging reading experience effectively. And these praises are not exclusive to Vis. The entire story is told from the first-person POV narration (in present tense) of Vis, and yet, I still feel like I got to know the supporting characters' motivations and personalities almost as well as Vis. They are all unique with their own qualities.
¡°You would be surprised at how far a combination of coin and favour can go toward silencing whole families.¡±
Finally, before I close this long-enough review, I want to elaborate on the world-building of the series. When I read The Will of the Many, it hit me that I haven¡¯t read as much Roman-inspired epic fantasy series as I thought. I think this is a factor that increased my reading enjoyment. There is Codex Alera by Jim Butcher, a popular Roman-inspired fantasy series. But, in my opinion, The Will of the Many is multiple times superior. The world-building feels relatively fresh. Many aspects of the world-building in The Will of the Many are deeply rooted in its Roman inspiration. The names, clothing, beautiful vistas, settings, in-world game, and more. Every aspect of the Roman-inspired world and Islington's crafted fantasy lore were delivered in detail gradually. I did not feel overwhelmed by the terminologies, there is a character list and glossary at the back of the book every time I need to remind myself of something, and it did not take long for me to feel immersed in this Roman-inspired epic fantasy series. And I loved it. The gladiatorial bouts, the naumachia, the Catenan rankings, and how the magic system (Will, which I'm sure we will see even more of its usage in future sequels) is interweaved into the story. Everything felt so natural to the plotlines. Plus, there is, of course, Islington's own creation in the manifestation of the mystery of the ancient weaponry and Cataclysm, a world-spanning disaster three centuries ago that left less than five people in every hundred alive. Maybe it is more accurate to call The Will of the Many, and the series, an epic science fantasy series due to how the high fantasy aspect and scientific technologies merged and enhanced the narrative. And I, as a fan of having more sci-fi elements in epic fantasy, am totally pleased by all of these combinations.
The characters' development, in-depth lore, technologies, and history established in The Will of the Many have provided possibilities for the Will and mysteries of the Cataclysm and more to be explored further in the next installments. This is also a darker novel than I expected. Explosions, massacres, shredded flesh and blood, and obsidian eyes and blades; the action scenes¡ªthe big action sequences, Labyrinth runs, or duels¡ªwere all tension-packed. Islington displayed the immense terror every second can bring in the lurking presence of disintegration and chaos. Violence begets grief, and grief begets violence. Is it a mistake, or is it righteous, to repay the sorrow caused by the heinous sins of the past with more violence of the present? The Will of the Many closed the magical/battle school/dark academia portion of the series, and that alone was already super satisfying. But oh my god... the mysteries and implications raised after the final chapters were groundbreaking, to say the least. Without spoilers, what Islington did in the epilogue, Ex Uno Plures (Out of One, Many), was nothing short of outstanding. In one chapter, Islington escalated the scintillating novel into something even more extraordinary.
My emotional attachment to the characters and events of this book is undeniable. The Will of the Many by James Islington is a phenomenal achievement. Islington has flourishingly crafted a Roman-inspired science fantasy world with brilliant plotlines that feel believable through the perspective of a talented and flawed main character imbued with a superbly distinct voice. I absolutely loved it. It IS one of the best books I've ever read, and it is also one of the rare books where, upon finishing it, I immediately wanted to reread from the beginning. And I know I will do that when the sequel, The Strength of the Few, is near. The waiting time for the sequel will be one of the worst waiting times I need to endure. How could it not be after the intense and insane culmination of the book? But until then... I will be patient. Audi (Hear). Vide (See). Tace (Be Silent). And read The Will of the Many as soon as possible. A new exceptional science fantasy series destined to become a classic is here. The Will of the Many has everything I love in an epic science fantasy novel, and many scenes here will become eternal moments in my mind.
You can pre-order this book from: |
Most of the quotes I wanted to use in this review were taken out on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ because I ran out of allowed characters.
You can find and the rest of my reviews at | I also have a
Special thanks to my Patrons on for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Aliysa, Anastasia, Andrew, Andrew W, Annabeth, Arliss, Barbara, Brad, Cade, Casey, Chris, Diana, Dylan, Edward, Elias, Ellen, Gary, Hamad, Helen, Jenn, Jesse, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Kristina, Luis, Lufi, Melinda, Meryl, Michael, Michael, Miracle, Nicholas, Radiah, Samuel, Sarah, Sarah, Scott, Shawn, Shawna, Teri, Tori, Tracy, Wendy, Wick, Xero, Yuri, Zoe.
Read
August 4, 2024So you've read The Hunger Games, a bunch of other adventures about teens in deadly contests, along with lots of different takes on schools of magic with all the intrigue and interpersonal drama that goes on behind the scenes as students try to reach the pinnacle of success and graduate alive. You're looking for your next compelling, unputdownable read like that, but you'd also love some good anti-imperialist, anti-colonialist themes woven into the action? Let me recommend The Will of the Many. (Once again, heartfelt thanks to Rebecca Roanhorse for recommending this stellar read with her Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ review.)
Vis Solum has a secret. He is an orphan barely surviving in the city of Letens, a provincial backwater on the outskirts of the Caten Republic. (Think the Roman Empire at its zenith, but with a terrifying magical system of oppressing the masses.) In reality (MILD SPOILER ANSWERED IN THE FIRST FEW CHAPTERS) Vis is the sole heir of a small kingdom that was recently invaded and crushed by Caten. He hates the Caten Republic and longs for vengeance. (END SPOILER) He is incredibly skilled, well trained, intelligent and resourceful, but what can one dispossessed boy do against the world's mightiest empire? You might be surprised . . .
Through a combination of skill and fortune, Vis begins to infiltrate and rise in the ranks of Caten society, until he manages to enter the Academy -- the training grounds for the future leaders of the Republic. There are schemes within schemes, and everyone here is using everyone else for their own motives. (MORE MILD SPOILERS) Vis' adopted family is using him as a spy against a rival faction within the empire. A rebel group is using him to gain information on the empire and hopefully overthrow it. The head of the school is running a shadowy operation that hopes to use Academy students to uncover an unspeakable secret weapon that once destroyed all civilization in the pre-recorded times before Caten. (END SPOILERS)
At first, Vis just wants to survive, to escape the fate of all Caten subjects, which is to be chained to the system of Will that keeps Catenans under the thumb of the empire and props up its power structure. But will he be able to do more? How far can he rise within the system he wants to topple, and what will he be willing to sacrifice to achieve that goal? Is there anyone in the world he can trust with his true identity?
It's not easy to make a seven-hundred-page novel into a quick, breathless read, but Islington makes it look effortless. He has created a world that is horrifying, logical, and absolutely believable. The system of Will is an incredible invention. Briefly, all society is structured into eight ranks, from Octavii (the lowest) to Princeps (the highest). Each caste level 'cedes' part of their Will to the caste above it. Once you are mandatorily conditioned into the system, by visiting an ancient magical structure called an Aurora Columnae before your eighteenth birthday, you have no choice but to be part of the system. Octavii, at the bottom, are required to give up half their energy, strength, soul, life force -- whatever you want to call it -- to the caste above. This means they live lives little better than zombies, always in a fog, dying early, unable to do more than survive and do their required work, but hey, at least they get fed and make the transportation system run on time, right? (sarcasm) The next level, septimi, get to draw on the Will of a few octavii, and cede a little less of their will to the sexti above them, and so on, until at the top of the food chain, the princeps class is able to draw on the Will of thousands of their subjects, making them virtual gods able to do superhuman feats. Will is used to create giant monuments, power machines, destroy enemy nations, and basically do anything to keep Caten in power. It is a literal pyramid scheme that has taken over the world. It is seductive and glamorous and pure evil.
I won't say much more, because I don't want to ruin the many, many surprises, twists and turns, but this is the most haunting and powerful fantasy I've read in quite a while. It took me a couple of chapters to get used to the terminology and world-building, but very quickly after that, I was sucked into the story and simply could not stop reading. Unsettling, gripping, timely, powerful -- this book is highly recommended. I can't wait for the next volume.
Vis Solum has a secret. He is an orphan barely surviving in the city of Letens, a provincial backwater on the outskirts of the Caten Republic. (Think the Roman Empire at its zenith, but with a terrifying magical system of oppressing the masses.) In reality (MILD SPOILER ANSWERED IN THE FIRST FEW CHAPTERS) Vis is the sole heir of a small kingdom that was recently invaded and crushed by Caten. He hates the Caten Republic and longs for vengeance. (END SPOILER) He is incredibly skilled, well trained, intelligent and resourceful, but what can one dispossessed boy do against the world's mightiest empire? You might be surprised . . .
Through a combination of skill and fortune, Vis begins to infiltrate and rise in the ranks of Caten society, until he manages to enter the Academy -- the training grounds for the future leaders of the Republic. There are schemes within schemes, and everyone here is using everyone else for their own motives. (MORE MILD SPOILERS) Vis' adopted family is using him as a spy against a rival faction within the empire. A rebel group is using him to gain information on the empire and hopefully overthrow it. The head of the school is running a shadowy operation that hopes to use Academy students to uncover an unspeakable secret weapon that once destroyed all civilization in the pre-recorded times before Caten. (END SPOILERS)
At first, Vis just wants to survive, to escape the fate of all Caten subjects, which is to be chained to the system of Will that keeps Catenans under the thumb of the empire and props up its power structure. But will he be able to do more? How far can he rise within the system he wants to topple, and what will he be willing to sacrifice to achieve that goal? Is there anyone in the world he can trust with his true identity?
It's not easy to make a seven-hundred-page novel into a quick, breathless read, but Islington makes it look effortless. He has created a world that is horrifying, logical, and absolutely believable. The system of Will is an incredible invention. Briefly, all society is structured into eight ranks, from Octavii (the lowest) to Princeps (the highest). Each caste level 'cedes' part of their Will to the caste above it. Once you are mandatorily conditioned into the system, by visiting an ancient magical structure called an Aurora Columnae before your eighteenth birthday, you have no choice but to be part of the system. Octavii, at the bottom, are required to give up half their energy, strength, soul, life force -- whatever you want to call it -- to the caste above. This means they live lives little better than zombies, always in a fog, dying early, unable to do more than survive and do their required work, but hey, at least they get fed and make the transportation system run on time, right? (sarcasm) The next level, septimi, get to draw on the Will of a few octavii, and cede a little less of their will to the sexti above them, and so on, until at the top of the food chain, the princeps class is able to draw on the Will of thousands of their subjects, making them virtual gods able to do superhuman feats. Will is used to create giant monuments, power machines, destroy enemy nations, and basically do anything to keep Caten in power. It is a literal pyramid scheme that has taken over the world. It is seductive and glamorous and pure evil.
I won't say much more, because I don't want to ruin the many, many surprises, twists and turns, but this is the most haunting and powerful fantasy I've read in quite a while. It took me a couple of chapters to get used to the terminology and world-building, but very quickly after that, I was sucked into the story and simply could not stop reading. Unsettling, gripping, timely, powerful -- this book is highly recommended. I can't wait for the next volume.
December 3, 2023
holy shit.
¨C think dark academia meets the hunger games
¨C so many twists and turns!!
¨C single pov ! (you guys have no idea how much of a relief this was)
¨C cool magic systems & epic world-building (which were so easy to follow)
¨C mic-drop moments
¨C moments where i just wanted to scream because the tension suffocated me
¨C so much politics & scheming (i love it)
¨C featuring poc rep with showing rather than just ¡°telling¡±
i don¡¯t really have much to say but this was so good. i¡¯m looking forward to rereading this when book two comes out because the reveals were chefs kiss & i loved following vis as a main character (even if it was slightly weird that he was 17 going on 18 for most of the book because he seemed too smart to be that young ?). but basically you guys need to read this, like, RIGHT NOW.
¨C think dark academia meets the hunger games
¨C so many twists and turns!!
¨C single pov ! (you guys have no idea how much of a relief this was)
¨C cool magic systems & epic world-building (which were so easy to follow)
¨C mic-drop moments
¨C moments where i just wanted to scream because the tension suffocated me
¨C so much politics & scheming (i love it)
¨C featuring poc rep with showing rather than just ¡°telling¡±
i don¡¯t really have much to say but this was so good. i¡¯m looking forward to rereading this when book two comes out because the reveals were chefs kiss & i loved following vis as a main character (even if it was slightly weird that he was 17 going on 18 for most of the book because he seemed too smart to be that young ?). but basically you guys need to read this, like, RIGHT NOW.
March 12, 2025
The ending of this got me so confused I had to look up reddit posts on what it's about and what happened. Also loved how almost every male character was described as pretty, hot, buff, and or smart. All I got for the girls were their hair color lmao.
For me this started off sooo strong but lost me a bit towards the end. So much supposedly happened and yet.....so little. AND you're telling me Vis is 17??? He acts and talks like he's 40 ?!!!
(read for 200 pages a day reading challenge):
3.5 STARS just for Diago. Seriously everyone would be dead.
| | |
April 9, 2025
let me preface this entire mini review with this: even in the year 2023, the name of the wind is still my favorite book of all time, and the will of the many was the closest book i¡¯ve ever read to capturing the feeling of that book. and i am not saying this because there is a magical school setting in part two of this book, i am saying this because the main character, vis, reminds me so much of kvothe, the main character of the name of the wind, that it casted a magic spell on me while reading. i am also such a character driven reader, and to give me the feeling of one of my favorite characters in all literature? yeah, i fell in love with this one easily, friends. (and yes @ everyone also comparing this setting, world building/caste system, and even a trial/competition feeling like red rising!) but i don't want you all to think i only like this because it reminded me of my favorite book, because i promise you this book and story and main character completely stand on their own and deserve to be celebrated all on their own as well!
also, the prologue of this one will grip you all on its own, i promise. but after the prologue, we see vis, seventeen years old and still orphaned, working in a prison where people are being drugged and their will (or magic) is being siphoned to other people higher in society (or pyramids). But vis catches the eye of one of the visitors, and he finally receives his opportunity to train to go undercover to catena academy and get revenge for the murder of his family.
but this synopsis is really only the tip of theiceberg pyramid of this story. this is also a story about love and how that can take so many different shapes and forms. this is a story about friendship and the beauty of learning to trust after the world has given you so many reasons not to ever again. this is a story about honoring your past while also embracing the hope of what your future might look like.
this was paced so very well - the lead up was everything, but the ending was out of this world phenomenal. this was written so beautifully, from quotes to metaphors, to just being a book that i feel like i could highlight something on every page. this was also so smartly written, and always walked a really tight balance line of dark and light. and the magic system is so complex yet also simple at the same time, and it really impressed me all on its own. this book was truly an accumulation of so many amazing ideas and executed concepts that i was completely immersed from cover to cover.
and the book truly evoked so many feelings (and tears¡ one time even involving a lobster) from me, and it really instantly became a new all time favorite. and in 600 pages, vis really stole my heart and became a new all time favorite character. this really was one of the bright shining lights of all of sff in 2023, and very much a part of my reading year, and i highly recommend this story to you. and I absolutely cannot wait to see where this author takes this story next.
trigger + content warnings: blood, captivity, torture, child abuse, abandonment, violence, slavery, bullying, explosions, needles, mention of suicides in past, drugging, vomit (one time self induced), medical testing without consent, anxiety, ptsd, grief, drowning, claustrophobic setting, manipulation, one sentence mention of homophobia (in a negative light), loss of a limb, loss of a friend/loved one, loss of parents and siblings in past, ableist + dated language for people who have disabilities
| | | | |
also, the prologue of this one will grip you all on its own, i promise. but after the prologue, we see vis, seventeen years old and still orphaned, working in a prison where people are being drugged and their will (or magic) is being siphoned to other people higher in society (or pyramids). But vis catches the eye of one of the visitors, and he finally receives his opportunity to train to go undercover to catena academy and get revenge for the murder of his family.
but this synopsis is really only the tip of the
this was paced so very well - the lead up was everything, but the ending was out of this world phenomenal. this was written so beautifully, from quotes to metaphors, to just being a book that i feel like i could highlight something on every page. this was also so smartly written, and always walked a really tight balance line of dark and light. and the magic system is so complex yet also simple at the same time, and it really impressed me all on its own. this book was truly an accumulation of so many amazing ideas and executed concepts that i was completely immersed from cover to cover.
and the book truly evoked so many feelings (and tears¡ one time even involving a lobster) from me, and it really instantly became a new all time favorite. and in 600 pages, vis really stole my heart and became a new all time favorite character. this really was one of the bright shining lights of all of sff in 2023, and very much a part of my reading year, and i highly recommend this story to you. and I absolutely cannot wait to see where this author takes this story next.
trigger + content warnings: blood, captivity, torture, child abuse, abandonment, violence, slavery, bullying, explosions, needles, mention of suicides in past, drugging, vomit (one time self induced), medical testing without consent, anxiety, ptsd, grief, drowning, claustrophobic setting, manipulation, one sentence mention of homophobia (in a negative light), loss of a limb, loss of a friend/loved one, loss of parents and siblings in past, ableist + dated language for people who have disabilities
| | | | |
June 1, 2024
There is no review I could write worthy of this book. Words aren¡¯t enough. I would sell my soul and my right arm to get book 2 tonight. Period.
February 7, 2025
3 1/2 stars.
I really struggled with how to rate this because parts of it were excellent-- the world and magic system are cool and genuinely interesting --but I just couldn't get past Vis. Extra half star for the ending because that was ?
Vis, the protagonist, is a classic Gary Stu. He is strong, inexplicably defeating those more powerful and better-trained than him, and he is so smart he bests those known for being the most intelligent in their class. There is not a skill that Vis can't master, and in each he quickly becomes better than the most competent students. Not only this, but he is handsome, drawing the attention of the pretty girls, and deeply moral and heroic. *snore*
What are this guy's flaws? He doesn't have any! I was reminded of Darrow from , which is another popular series that I gave up on because the characters bored me.
This is a personal thing, obviously, as the size of the franchises show that many people love a Superman or a James Bond. It's also not always a dealbreaker. Harry Potter is the least interesting character in Harry Potter, except it¡¯s okay because there are dozens of other brilliant characters to outshine him.
Not so much here. I'm curious who other readers thought were standout characters in this book...? I think Eidhan and Callidus showed the most promise, but none of the many characters in the book are actually on page that much. Ulciscor was dull. Emissa was beige. Almost all the characters were forgettable. I don't think the author developed them very well. One example is Veridius, whom we are constantly reminded is "charming", but I never once got a sense of his charm. I can't help comparing to my recent fantasy read-- --where even minor characters stood out.
Also you could do a drinking game with every time the author bridges two scenes or chapters by Vis passing out.
Okay, okay, now I've complained I'll get on with the positives. The world is fairly complex and interesting, even if underneath it¡¯s a familiar concept¡ª those at the top leech from those at the bottom, literally in this case. But there's plenty of detail and a well thought-out geography to the world. The technology and magic system are exciting.
There are some great twists and turns, plenty of action and, as I mentioned, the ending is insane. I just wish I felt more connected to the characters.
I'm not sure at this time if I'll be reading on. A great world + intriguing plotting goes a long way, but without anyone I really care about, I¡¯m not sure I can summon interest for another 600 page volume. But also... wtf that ending??
I really struggled with how to rate this because parts of it were excellent-- the world and magic system are cool and genuinely interesting --but I just couldn't get past Vis. Extra half star for the ending because that was ?
Vis, the protagonist, is a classic Gary Stu. He is strong, inexplicably defeating those more powerful and better-trained than him, and he is so smart he bests those known for being the most intelligent in their class. There is not a skill that Vis can't master, and in each he quickly becomes better than the most competent students. Not only this, but he is handsome, drawing the attention of the pretty girls, and deeply moral and heroic. *snore*
What are this guy's flaws? He doesn't have any! I was reminded of Darrow from , which is another popular series that I gave up on because the characters bored me.
This is a personal thing, obviously, as the size of the franchises show that many people love a Superman or a James Bond. It's also not always a dealbreaker. Harry Potter is the least interesting character in Harry Potter, except it¡¯s okay because there are dozens of other brilliant characters to outshine him.
Not so much here. I'm curious who other readers thought were standout characters in this book...? I think Eidhan and Callidus showed the most promise, but none of the many characters in the book are actually on page that much. Ulciscor was dull. Emissa was beige. Almost all the characters were forgettable. I don't think the author developed them very well. One example is Veridius, whom we are constantly reminded is "charming", but I never once got a sense of his charm. I can't help comparing to my recent fantasy read-- --where even minor characters stood out.
Also you could do a drinking game with every time the author bridges two scenes or chapters by Vis passing out.
Okay, okay, now I've complained I'll get on with the positives. The world is fairly complex and interesting, even if underneath it¡¯s a familiar concept¡ª those at the top leech from those at the bottom, literally in this case. But there's plenty of detail and a well thought-out geography to the world. The technology and magic system are exciting.
There are some great twists and turns, plenty of action and, as I mentioned, the ending is insane. I just wish I felt more connected to the characters.
I'm not sure at this time if I'll be reading on. A great world + intriguing plotting goes a long way, but without anyone I really care about, I¡¯m not sure I can summon interest for another 600 page volume. But also... wtf that ending??
December 15, 2023
Are you KIDDING ME RIGHT NOW?? GIVE ME BOOK 2 RIGHT THIS SECOND. RIGHT NOW. RIGHT NOWWWWWWWWWWWW
Compelling and intelligent, yet flawed protagonist?
Interesting world-building and use of magic?
Involving mysteries that unfold at a good pace ?
Well written and pulse-pumping action?
Plot points that keep you hooked?
IT HAS EVERYTHING MAN. MAGIC SCHOOL. POLITICAL INTRIGUE. HIGH STAKES ACTION. EMOTIONAL MOMENTS. MYSTERIOUS MOTIVATIONS AND WORLD BUILDING.
DUDE. OH MY GOD.
This is easily one of the best books I¡¯ve read all year, and an instant addition to my required reads. Vis is an excellent protagonist, the setting is engrossing, the pacing is immaculate, and the emotional aspect of the story hit me way harder than I expected.
I can¡¯t even write a real review right now. That¡¯s how amped up I am. Holy shit.
100000/10. Give. Me. More.
WHY DID I READ THIS? NOW I HAVE TO WAIT
Compelling and intelligent, yet flawed protagonist?
Interesting world-building and use of magic?
Involving mysteries that unfold at a good pace ?
Well written and pulse-pumping action?
Plot points that keep you hooked?
IT HAS EVERYTHING MAN. MAGIC SCHOOL. POLITICAL INTRIGUE. HIGH STAKES ACTION. EMOTIONAL MOMENTS. MYSTERIOUS MOTIVATIONS AND WORLD BUILDING.
DUDE. OH MY GOD.
This is easily one of the best books I¡¯ve read all year, and an instant addition to my required reads. Vis is an excellent protagonist, the setting is engrossing, the pacing is immaculate, and the emotional aspect of the story hit me way harder than I expected.
I can¡¯t even write a real review right now. That¡¯s how amped up I am. Holy shit.
100000/10. Give. Me. More.
WHY DID I READ THIS? NOW I HAVE TO WAIT
December 22, 2023
Absolutely amazing in every way. Full review coming soon...
August 25, 2024
It seems that the vast majority of people have absolutely loved this book. Allow me to be one of the few.
This was definitely a book. There were definitely words and I definitely read them. Did I feel anything while reading them? No, not really.
Did I love the characters? Was I enthralled by the writing? Was I immersed in the world? Heck, was I even engaged with the plot????
No. No at all.
I've seen people compare this to (a book I love) and honestly, I don't see it. Aside from having Ancient Rome-inspired societies and protagonists going to an academy, there weren't very many similarities.
For starters, Red Rising is nonstop action. The stakes are constantly rising. There is danger and tension in every interaction. People's lives are constantly in danger. The plot and characters all go in a very clear direction. The Will of the Many had none of that.
This book feels extremely YA, which isn't bad, I've loved a lot of YA novels, but that's not how this book is sold and marketed. The book makes promises it does not deliver upon and honestly left me wanting.
The main character, Vis, is a runaway orphan with a secret past and he swears he's all tough and hardened by the world. He believes himself to be an incredible actor, able to mold himself into any situation to survive. In reality, he is a reckless boy constantly on the verge of getting caught in a lie (and often does get caught). Everyone can see his lies don't add up, but it's okay, people will always turn a blind eye to the obvious for some reason.
Vis is also the most brilliant, most special of all the snowflakes. He gets sent to a supposedly prestigious academy with the children of the most powerful people in the empire. Those children are meant to be the smartest, most skilled, and most cunning. Sadly, that's just not true. It can't be, considering how Vis makes his way through the ranks with little to no pushback in a few months. Vis is just naturally smarter, wiser, and plain better than all his classmates and professors. Vis easily and consistently beats people who are champions in their fields, and outsmarts every single person around him. He speaks several dead languages, is a master swordsman, an Olympic swimmer, and a world-class strategist. He's just 'that guy' and I didn't buy it for a second. In part because he's 17, but also because it made no sense.
Then there was the world-building. This world felt incomplete. It fell flat. Also, I don't actually know how Will works and I've decided that I don't need to know. The more the author mentioned Will, the less I understood and the less I cared.
The book was over 600 pages and it didn't need to be. A good 150 pages could have been trimmed to make a more compact, richer story. There were so many training montages and so many unnecessary conversations. So much happened, and yet I felt like nothing happened at all, up until the end.
By the way, that ending was actually really good. The epilogue got me intrigued, but probably not enough for me to read the sequel. Then again, who knows? I just might pick up book two.
Overall, this book was okay. I didn't love it. It left me unimpressed. But it also wasn't horrible. Had it been shorter (and had it been sold as a YA novel) I might have rated it higher. But alas.
This was definitely a book. There were definitely words and I definitely read them. Did I feel anything while reading them? No, not really.
Did I love the characters? Was I enthralled by the writing? Was I immersed in the world? Heck, was I even engaged with the plot????
No. No at all.
I've seen people compare this to (a book I love) and honestly, I don't see it. Aside from having Ancient Rome-inspired societies and protagonists going to an academy, there weren't very many similarities.
For starters, Red Rising is nonstop action. The stakes are constantly rising. There is danger and tension in every interaction. People's lives are constantly in danger. The plot and characters all go in a very clear direction. The Will of the Many had none of that.
This book feels extremely YA, which isn't bad, I've loved a lot of YA novels, but that's not how this book is sold and marketed. The book makes promises it does not deliver upon and honestly left me wanting.
The main character, Vis, is a runaway orphan with a secret past and he swears he's all tough and hardened by the world. He believes himself to be an incredible actor, able to mold himself into any situation to survive. In reality, he is a reckless boy constantly on the verge of getting caught in a lie (and often does get caught). Everyone can see his lies don't add up, but it's okay, people will always turn a blind eye to the obvious for some reason.
Vis is also the most brilliant, most special of all the snowflakes. He gets sent to a supposedly prestigious academy with the children of the most powerful people in the empire. Those children are meant to be the smartest, most skilled, and most cunning. Sadly, that's just not true. It can't be, considering how Vis makes his way through the ranks with little to no pushback in a few months. Vis is just naturally smarter, wiser, and plain better than all his classmates and professors. Vis easily and consistently beats people who are champions in their fields, and outsmarts every single person around him. He speaks several dead languages, is a master swordsman, an Olympic swimmer, and a world-class strategist. He's just 'that guy' and I didn't buy it for a second. In part because he's 17, but also because it made no sense.
Then there was the world-building. This world felt incomplete. It fell flat. Also, I don't actually know how Will works and I've decided that I don't need to know. The more the author mentioned Will, the less I understood and the less I cared.
The book was over 600 pages and it didn't need to be. A good 150 pages could have been trimmed to make a more compact, richer story. There were so many training montages and so many unnecessary conversations. So much happened, and yet I felt like nothing happened at all, up until the end.
By the way, that ending was actually really good. The epilogue got me intrigued, but probably not enough for me to read the sequel. Then again, who knows? I just might pick up book two.
Overall, this book was okay. I didn't love it. It left me unimpressed. But it also wasn't horrible. Had it been shorter (and had it been sold as a YA novel) I might have rated it higher. But alas.
June 6, 2024
I have A LOT to say :D
But the headline is that I found it a very enjoyable book that I was keen to read.
I picked this one up primarily because I saw it was doing so well, saleswise, and had an incredibly high average rating on this site, stratospheric compared to the vast majority of fantasy books with 10,000+ ratings (a book's average rating with number of ratings).
I'm always keen to see what magic sauce successful authors use.
Additionally, James Islington was a semi-finalist in my SPFBO contest with , so I recognised the name and was extra curious.
For marketing purposes books are often described as mixtures of other famous books - my own was described as Stranger Things meets . Whilst reading this book it was easy for me to play the same game and say to myself that this element came from X and this one from Y.
I'm about to tell you what those Xs and Ys are, but first, let's be absolutely clear that this mapping is absolutely not a claim that the contributions were copied from these sources - it's just a fun game to play. Anthony Ryan's book contained insanely close ideas to ones I had written in a book 15 years earlier - but that book was never published and it was simply not possible that he had copied them/been inspired by that book of mine. I note this to show how often similar ideas bubble up wholly independently.
Imagine the book is a fine wine and me the wine sleuth, sipping it, gazing into space, and waxing lyrical about notes of oak, Tuscan sun on eastern slopes, a high zinc content in the soil...
Immediately I saw shades of both and - we have what's effectively a war school (Blood Song) and the son of a royal house now down and out in an empire he wants to learn about &/or destroy (Empire of Silence - which in turn has shades of ).
As the magic system revealed itself I saw strong correlations with David Farland's where individuals sacrifice some of their own power (strength, health etc) to their own detriment, and contribute it to another who sits at the top of a pyramid of contributed power, leading to individuals with superhuman strength, speed etc.
We then learn about a physical game / assault course at the school, with moving parts, which is said to help attune your mind to the magic system -- which of course has parallels with the blade-path in .
All of these story building blocks have bags of potential, and Islington constructs an addictively entertaining tale out of them.
We have a single first-person PRESENT TENSE point of view, which loads of people winge about when other people do it, but everyone seems to buy into without complaint here. Which just goes to show that you can do whatever you like in writing, as long as you do it well...
Our man is - and I say this with zero disrespect intended, a Gary Stu. He's not just good at everything, he's insanely good at everything. Over the course of the book he is lined up against experts in various fields/disciplines, and it doesn't really matter if he studied it briefly ten years ago or has never used the equipment before ... he's going to win. Again, in the hands of a less talented writer this would draw endless complaint. But it's such damn good fun - we/I eat/ate it up.
There are plenty of books where the main character is super good at everything, The Name of the Wind springs to mind, the Gor books (), even Prince of Thorns to a significant degree. I feel our man here, young Vis, also falls into the 'archetype' mould where beyond being disadvantaged and being moral/good, he's a bit of a blank onto which it's easy to project ourselves. So we can more easily share in his victories as he doesn't have a bunch of opinions and flaws etc that get in the way of steering him around as a proxy. And this of course is a guilty pleasure that works well in many books. Characters who are more complex and individual can, in many ways, be harder to identify with than the more generic hero.
I mentioned Gor above (a series with MANY problems) purely because it's a good example of a series that has another element that comes into play here, and that's "fantasy chess". A good number of fantasy books over the years have featured "fantasy chess", which is simply a made up game that is not given to us in too much detail other than it's a proxy for war and played on a board (or with cards). In Gor, our hero, Tarl Cabot (who is GREAT at everything) is also great at Fantasy Chess, and beats people at that in important moments to mix it up a bit.
Vis also has his fantasy chess moment.
And a slightly painful animal companion moment where he stops in the middle of something important in an interlude that feels entirely crafted to give us the "important later" animal friend.
And EVEN THEN with every writer bone groaning at the obvious levers being pulled ... I was loving it :D
Another grouch is that because our man's so good at everything we need everyone to be horrible to him and set against him succeeding. And that's not unusual in these school stories - we need a bully etc, and we get them in The Name of The Wind, in Red Sister etc, so I'm not being holier than thou here... my grouch is simply that the explanations for these people's opposition to our man are so thin, especially given the extraordinary lengths these grudges are taken to.
One teacher "doesn't like his name" - i.e. the family name he's adopted into. The teacher knows our guy was plucked off the streets for a purpose and isn't responsible for any of this, and yet on the strength of this old grudge does outrageous stuff that puts his reputation and career on the line.
Another boy has a grudge that our man didn't save his sister in a scenario where our man had no reasonable expectation of saving anyone, wasn't near the girl in question, didn't know her, and (without being asked and at great personal risk) saved many others.
Again - I'll return to my refrain: if I wasn't enjoying the book so much I might have laid my dissatisfaction at the feet of these issues. But I was enjoying it a lot and I've no reservations about giving it 5*.
At the end things get frantic, emotional, and finally rather complicated. It's a great read. I can see why it's doing so well, and recommend you give it a go. You'll probably love it too!
.
But the headline is that I found it a very enjoyable book that I was keen to read.
I picked this one up primarily because I saw it was doing so well, saleswise, and had an incredibly high average rating on this site, stratospheric compared to the vast majority of fantasy books with 10,000+ ratings (a book's average rating with number of ratings).
I'm always keen to see what magic sauce successful authors use.
Additionally, James Islington was a semi-finalist in my SPFBO contest with , so I recognised the name and was extra curious.
For marketing purposes books are often described as mixtures of other famous books - my own was described as Stranger Things meets . Whilst reading this book it was easy for me to play the same game and say to myself that this element came from X and this one from Y.
I'm about to tell you what those Xs and Ys are, but first, let's be absolutely clear that this mapping is absolutely not a claim that the contributions were copied from these sources - it's just a fun game to play. Anthony Ryan's book contained insanely close ideas to ones I had written in a book 15 years earlier - but that book was never published and it was simply not possible that he had copied them/been inspired by that book of mine. I note this to show how often similar ideas bubble up wholly independently.
Imagine the book is a fine wine and me the wine sleuth, sipping it, gazing into space, and waxing lyrical about notes of oak, Tuscan sun on eastern slopes, a high zinc content in the soil...
Immediately I saw shades of both and - we have what's effectively a war school (Blood Song) and the son of a royal house now down and out in an empire he wants to learn about &/or destroy (Empire of Silence - which in turn has shades of ).
As the magic system revealed itself I saw strong correlations with David Farland's where individuals sacrifice some of their own power (strength, health etc) to their own detriment, and contribute it to another who sits at the top of a pyramid of contributed power, leading to individuals with superhuman strength, speed etc.
We then learn about a physical game / assault course at the school, with moving parts, which is said to help attune your mind to the magic system -- which of course has parallels with the blade-path in .
All of these story building blocks have bags of potential, and Islington constructs an addictively entertaining tale out of them.
We have a single first-person PRESENT TENSE point of view, which loads of people winge about when other people do it, but everyone seems to buy into without complaint here. Which just goes to show that you can do whatever you like in writing, as long as you do it well...
Our man is - and I say this with zero disrespect intended, a Gary Stu. He's not just good at everything, he's insanely good at everything. Over the course of the book he is lined up against experts in various fields/disciplines, and it doesn't really matter if he studied it briefly ten years ago or has never used the equipment before ... he's going to win. Again, in the hands of a less talented writer this would draw endless complaint. But it's such damn good fun - we/I eat/ate it up.
There are plenty of books where the main character is super good at everything, The Name of the Wind springs to mind, the Gor books (), even Prince of Thorns to a significant degree. I feel our man here, young Vis, also falls into the 'archetype' mould where beyond being disadvantaged and being moral/good, he's a bit of a blank onto which it's easy to project ourselves. So we can more easily share in his victories as he doesn't have a bunch of opinions and flaws etc that get in the way of steering him around as a proxy. And this of course is a guilty pleasure that works well in many books. Characters who are more complex and individual can, in many ways, be harder to identify with than the more generic hero.
I mentioned Gor above (a series with MANY problems) purely because it's a good example of a series that has another element that comes into play here, and that's "fantasy chess". A good number of fantasy books over the years have featured "fantasy chess", which is simply a made up game that is not given to us in too much detail other than it's a proxy for war and played on a board (or with cards). In Gor, our hero, Tarl Cabot (who is GREAT at everything) is also great at Fantasy Chess, and beats people at that in important moments to mix it up a bit.
Vis also has his fantasy chess moment.
And a slightly painful animal companion moment where he stops in the middle of something important in an interlude that feels entirely crafted to give us the "important later" animal friend.
And EVEN THEN with every writer bone groaning at the obvious levers being pulled ... I was loving it :D
Another grouch is that because our man's so good at everything we need everyone to be horrible to him and set against him succeeding. And that's not unusual in these school stories - we need a bully etc, and we get them in The Name of The Wind, in Red Sister etc, so I'm not being holier than thou here... my grouch is simply that the explanations for these people's opposition to our man are so thin, especially given the extraordinary lengths these grudges are taken to.
One teacher "doesn't like his name" - i.e. the family name he's adopted into. The teacher knows our guy was plucked off the streets for a purpose and isn't responsible for any of this, and yet on the strength of this old grudge does outrageous stuff that puts his reputation and career on the line.
Another boy has a grudge that our man didn't save his sister in a scenario where our man had no reasonable expectation of saving anyone, wasn't near the girl in question, didn't know her, and (without being asked and at great personal risk) saved many others.
Again - I'll return to my refrain: if I wasn't enjoying the book so much I might have laid my dissatisfaction at the feet of these issues. But I was enjoying it a lot and I've no reservations about giving it 5*.
At the end things get frantic, emotional, and finally rather complicated. It's a great read. I can see why it's doing so well, and recommend you give it a go. You'll probably love it too!
.
January 10, 2025
4.5 Stars ?
I AM SHOOK!!! This book is SO FREAKING GOOD!!! I went into it feeling a bit wary because of all the hype. It¡¯s rare for a hyped book to live up to expectations. But wow, this one absolutely delivered.
A Roman-Inspired Sci-Fi/Fantasy. This story is a perfect mix of genres, with strong elements of:
1:) Dark Academia
2:) An Heir Who Lost His Kingdom
3:) A Complex Magic System
I have not found a book that sparked this feeling in me since reading The rage of dragons, which is one of my all-time favourites so yeah, that¡¯s how good this book is!!! One of the most thrilling parts of the book is how every single character has hidden motivations. You genuinely can¡¯t trust anyone, and that constant tension is what kept me glued to the pages.
There are a million moving pieces, and the story keeps you guessing. Every time I thought I had figured something out, the plot would pivot in a completely unexpected direction. It¡¯s chaotic in the best way.
One thing that annoyed me was how good Vis seemed at everything he does. Don¡¯t get me wrong¡ªhis resourcefulness and skill are impressive, but at times, it felt like he was too good at everything, which made some moments feel a bit predictable.
Final Thoughts:
The Will of the Many is an unforgettable ride. The intrigue, the twists, the emotional depth¡ªit¡¯s all here. Despite a few issues, this book is phenomenal, and I¡¯m already counting down the days until the sequel. (WHY IS IT SOOO FAR AWAY??!!!) If you¡¯re a fan of dark academia, intricate magic systems, and morally complex heroes, this book is a must-read.
Spoilers Ahead??
Favorite Scenes:
? Vis vs. the Sextus: This fight was intense!! Watching Vis outthink and outmaneuver someone who was supposedly so powerful had my jaw on the FLOOR!!!
? Vis and Eriden Completing the Labyrinth in Cymirian: I cannot express how much I LOVED this scene.
? Vis vs. Ianix
? Vis Going Home: This was such an emotional moment. Seeing Vis return after everything he¡¯s endured hit me right in the feels.
? Vis' vision of his father!!!
The Ending (Warning: Confusing but Brilliant)
Okay, so let¡¯s unpack the ending From what I understand:
There are three dimensions:
A:) Vis¡¯s Dimension (Reality)
B:) Obetieum (The Good Place)
C:) Luceum (The Bad Place)
When Vis went into the sword-like artifact, his body was split into three versions: one in his realm, one in Obetieum, and one in Luceum. I think Vis was supposed to die, but Caeror saved him, which is why the dead bodies started chasing him. They were seeking balance. Let me know if I¡¯m wrong, but that¡¯s my interpretation! The layers of complexity in this ending are wild, and I can¡¯t stop thinking about it.
______________________
Pre-Read:
I only bought this book because I heard the cover is changing, and I didn¡¯t want to miss out on the old design. My friend told me I have to read this if I want to be absolutely devastated. ? Apparently, none of the books she¡¯s reading now even compare, and she¡¯s going through severe withdrawals!!! After all that hype, you know I had to see what this one¡¯s all about.
I AM SHOOK!!! This book is SO FREAKING GOOD!!! I went into it feeling a bit wary because of all the hype. It¡¯s rare for a hyped book to live up to expectations. But wow, this one absolutely delivered.
A Roman-Inspired Sci-Fi/Fantasy. This story is a perfect mix of genres, with strong elements of:
1:) Dark Academia
2:) An Heir Who Lost His Kingdom
3:) A Complex Magic System
I have not found a book that sparked this feeling in me since reading The rage of dragons, which is one of my all-time favourites so yeah, that¡¯s how good this book is!!! One of the most thrilling parts of the book is how every single character has hidden motivations. You genuinely can¡¯t trust anyone, and that constant tension is what kept me glued to the pages.
There are a million moving pieces, and the story keeps you guessing. Every time I thought I had figured something out, the plot would pivot in a completely unexpected direction. It¡¯s chaotic in the best way.
One thing that annoyed me was how good Vis seemed at everything he does. Don¡¯t get me wrong¡ªhis resourcefulness and skill are impressive, but at times, it felt like he was too good at everything, which made some moments feel a bit predictable.
Final Thoughts:
The Will of the Many is an unforgettable ride. The intrigue, the twists, the emotional depth¡ªit¡¯s all here. Despite a few issues, this book is phenomenal, and I¡¯m already counting down the days until the sequel. (WHY IS IT SOOO FAR AWAY??!!!) If you¡¯re a fan of dark academia, intricate magic systems, and morally complex heroes, this book is a must-read.
Spoilers Ahead??
Favorite Scenes:
? Vis vs. the Sextus: This fight was intense!! Watching Vis outthink and outmaneuver someone who was supposedly so powerful had my jaw on the FLOOR!!!
? Vis and Eriden Completing the Labyrinth in Cymirian: I cannot express how much I LOVED this scene.
? Vis vs. Ianix
? Vis Going Home: This was such an emotional moment. Seeing Vis return after everything he¡¯s endured hit me right in the feels.
? Vis' vision of his father!!!
The Ending (Warning: Confusing but Brilliant)
Okay, so let¡¯s unpack the ending From what I understand:
There are three dimensions:
A:) Vis¡¯s Dimension (Reality)
B:) Obetieum (The Good Place)
C:) Luceum (The Bad Place)
When Vis went into the sword-like artifact, his body was split into three versions: one in his realm, one in Obetieum, and one in Luceum. I think Vis was supposed to die, but Caeror saved him, which is why the dead bodies started chasing him. They were seeking balance. Let me know if I¡¯m wrong, but that¡¯s my interpretation! The layers of complexity in this ending are wild, and I can¡¯t stop thinking about it.
______________________
Pre-Read:
I only bought this book because I heard the cover is changing, and I didn¡¯t want to miss out on the old design. My friend told me I have to read this if I want to be absolutely devastated. ? Apparently, none of the books she¡¯s reading now even compare, and she¡¯s going through severe withdrawals!!! After all that hype, you know I had to see what this one¡¯s all about.
December 15, 2023
This book deserves much more hype!
Dark Academia + Roman Culture + Unique & Controversial Magic System
Starts slow and yes, the book is long but it's totally worth it.
This is a story full of: intrigue, agony, deviousness, power disputes.
It has a certain complexity to understand not only the magic system but the structure that makes up this society. There is a lot of cruelty, injustice, greed... Basically Machiavellianism in all its unpleasant splendor.
"There are those who see what should be, and complain that they do not get their due. And then there are those who see what is, and figure out how to use it to their advantage. Or at least, overcome it."
Full of plot twists, great world building, lots of political schemes. The characters are tricky and interesting. It is not a light read nor for delicate hearts.
"Death is only meaningless if it does not change us."
I'm really looking forward to the publication date of the next book in this series that promises to be one of my favorites.
---------------------------
Empieza lento y s¨ª, el libro es largo pero merece totalmente la pena.
Academia Oscura + Cultura Romana + Sistema M¨¢gico ?nico & Controversial
Esta es una historia llena de: intriga, agon¨ªa, astucia, disputas de poder.
Tiene cierta complejidad entender no s¨®lo el sistema m¨¢gico sino la estructura que conforma esta sociedad. Hay mucha crueldad, injusticia, avaricia... B¨¢sicamente Maquiavelismo en todo su desagradable esplendor.
"Hay quienes ven lo que »å±ð²ú±ð°ù¨ª²¹ ser y se quejan de que no reciben lo que les corresponde. Y luego est¨¢n los que ven lo que es y se dan cuenta c¨®mo utilizarlo a su favor. O al menos, superarlo."
Lleno de giros en la trama, gran construcci¨®n del mundo, muchas conspiraciones pol¨ªticas. Los personajes son complicados e interesantes. No es una lectura ligera ni para corazones delicados.
"La muerte s¨®lo carece de sentido si no nos cambia."
Tengo muchas ganas de que llegue la fecha de publicaci¨®n del pr¨®ximo libro de esta serie que promete ser una de mis favoritas.
-------------------
Oct. 5th: I promised myself I wouldn't start a series that isn't finished...
But this sounds very tempting.
Dark Academia + Roman Culture + Unique & Controversial Magic System
Starts slow and yes, the book is long but it's totally worth it.
This is a story full of: intrigue, agony, deviousness, power disputes.
It has a certain complexity to understand not only the magic system but the structure that makes up this society. There is a lot of cruelty, injustice, greed... Basically Machiavellianism in all its unpleasant splendor.
"There are those who see what should be, and complain that they do not get their due. And then there are those who see what is, and figure out how to use it to their advantage. Or at least, overcome it."
Full of plot twists, great world building, lots of political schemes. The characters are tricky and interesting. It is not a light read nor for delicate hearts.
"Death is only meaningless if it does not change us."
I'm really looking forward to the publication date of the next book in this series that promises to be one of my favorites.
---------------------------
Empieza lento y s¨ª, el libro es largo pero merece totalmente la pena.
Academia Oscura + Cultura Romana + Sistema M¨¢gico ?nico & Controversial
Esta es una historia llena de: intriga, agon¨ªa, astucia, disputas de poder.
Tiene cierta complejidad entender no s¨®lo el sistema m¨¢gico sino la estructura que conforma esta sociedad. Hay mucha crueldad, injusticia, avaricia... B¨¢sicamente Maquiavelismo en todo su desagradable esplendor.
"Hay quienes ven lo que »å±ð²ú±ð°ù¨ª²¹ ser y se quejan de que no reciben lo que les corresponde. Y luego est¨¢n los que ven lo que es y se dan cuenta c¨®mo utilizarlo a su favor. O al menos, superarlo."
Lleno de giros en la trama, gran construcci¨®n del mundo, muchas conspiraciones pol¨ªticas. Los personajes son complicados e interesantes. No es una lectura ligera ni para corazones delicados.
"La muerte s¨®lo carece de sentido si no nos cambia."
Tengo muchas ganas de que llegue la fecha de publicaci¨®n del pr¨®ximo libro de esta serie que promete ser una de mis favoritas.
-------------------
Oct. 5th: I promised myself I wouldn't start a series that isn't finished...
But this sounds very tempting.
April 9, 2024
i'm a bit underwhelmed i fear.
there were things i enjoyed about this book - and things i didn't. hopefully, i can gather my thoughts coherently.
pros:
- compulsively readable writing style.
- magic that's explained and used in an academic, scientific way - i love in-world theories and scientific concepts and academic classes surrounding a magic system.
- i also liked the concept of the hierarchy and its social classes being built around this magic system.
- the labyrinth is a great competition-style game concept - i can easily see it in a movie or a video game.
- the hunger games-style iudicium (the last 15% of the book) was engaging to read. the rules were pretty interesting so i wish this was a longer section in the book.
cons:
- our protagonist - others have mentioned this and i have to agree to an extent: vis definitely feels like a 'gary stu' character. he has a bland and reactive personality and could almost be a self-insert if it weren't for some frustrating choices he makes. things come a bit too easily to him (although he does have to work for them). no matter what the obstacle is, you know he'll surpass it because the first 14 years of his life were apparently designed for this very plotline to take place (ok that's kinda unfair. his past as a prince training to be a diplomat does explain his skills...the rest are just protagonist superpowers). and look, there is a way to write a protagonist who's better than everyone else and always wins (see: the queen's thief series) but vis has none of the wit, charm, or intrigue to make that kind of character compelling.
- i also struggle to believe how vis barely has any animosity towards his family's murderers and his country's occupiers - sure he's angry and grieving but it all feels rather mild for the context. at one point, he finds out the name of the man who ordered his family's deaths and he decides that "violence is no answer to grief." maybe if vis was a 40 year old whose family died 20 years ago, i'd believe this, but for a 17 year old whose family died 3 years ago? please be for real.
- extremely disappointed by how the author decided to portray the rebellion - they're basically terrorists and don't have the people's best interests at heart because of course. vis's superior attitude towards them was so irritating to me - he kept criticizing the only force opposing his people's occupiers but refused to offer any alternatives (and we're constantly shown just how extraordinarily brilliant he is). the anti-violence stance taken here felt so disingenuous to me (and disconnected from real life resistance).
- in fact, for most of the book, vis isn't interested in truly opposing the hierarchy at all. his goals are incredibly self-serving but i guess it makes sense given his privileged past as a prince.
- side characters were boring and forgettable (except eidhin and maybe lanistia). i'd say vis and eidhin's friendship was the only complex, genuine relationship in the book.
- for all the barrage of information thrown at us regarding 'will' (the magic system), we don't really know much about it. what exactly is will? is it like qi, inner energy or something? what does it mean to imbue? what's conditional imbuing? i know we'll likely learn more in the sequel but it's funny to me that a 600+ page book told us so little about how the magic actually works.
- a lot of hype around the ending - it's intriguing for sure, but at least 3/4 of it was quite predictable too.
overall, interesting concepts, poor character work, disappointing politics. there are enough mysteries in the plot for me to pick up the sequel - i'm just not dying to get my hands on it.
there were things i enjoyed about this book - and things i didn't. hopefully, i can gather my thoughts coherently.
pros:
- compulsively readable writing style.
- magic that's explained and used in an academic, scientific way - i love in-world theories and scientific concepts and academic classes surrounding a magic system.
- i also liked the concept of the hierarchy and its social classes being built around this magic system.
- the labyrinth is a great competition-style game concept - i can easily see it in a movie or a video game.
- the hunger games-style iudicium (the last 15% of the book) was engaging to read. the rules were pretty interesting so i wish this was a longer section in the book.
cons:
- our protagonist - others have mentioned this and i have to agree to an extent: vis definitely feels like a 'gary stu' character. he has a bland and reactive personality and could almost be a self-insert if it weren't for some frustrating choices he makes. things come a bit too easily to him (although he does have to work for them). no matter what the obstacle is, you know he'll surpass it because the first 14 years of his life were apparently designed for this very plotline to take place (ok that's kinda unfair. his past as a prince training to be a diplomat does explain his skills...the rest are just protagonist superpowers). and look, there is a way to write a protagonist who's better than everyone else and always wins (see: the queen's thief series) but vis has none of the wit, charm, or intrigue to make that kind of character compelling.
- i also struggle to believe how vis barely has any animosity towards his family's murderers and his country's occupiers - sure he's angry and grieving but it all feels rather mild for the context. at one point, he finds out the name of the man who ordered his family's deaths and he decides that "violence is no answer to grief." maybe if vis was a 40 year old whose family died 20 years ago, i'd believe this, but for a 17 year old whose family died 3 years ago? please be for real.
- extremely disappointed by how the author decided to portray the rebellion - they're basically terrorists and don't have the people's best interests at heart because of course. vis's superior attitude towards them was so irritating to me - he kept criticizing the only force opposing his people's occupiers but refused to offer any alternatives (and we're constantly shown just how extraordinarily brilliant he is). the anti-violence stance taken here felt so disingenuous to me (and disconnected from real life resistance).
- in fact, for most of the book, vis isn't interested in truly opposing the hierarchy at all. his goals are incredibly self-serving but i guess it makes sense given his privileged past as a prince.
- side characters were boring and forgettable (except eidhin and maybe lanistia). i'd say vis and eidhin's friendship was the only complex, genuine relationship in the book.
- for all the barrage of information thrown at us regarding 'will' (the magic system), we don't really know much about it. what exactly is will? is it like qi, inner energy or something? what does it mean to imbue? what's conditional imbuing? i know we'll likely learn more in the sequel but it's funny to me that a 600+ page book told us so little about how the magic actually works.
- a lot of hype around the ending - it's intriguing for sure, but at least 3/4 of it was quite predictable too.
overall, interesting concepts, poor character work, disappointing politics. there are enough mysteries in the plot for me to pick up the sequel - i'm just not dying to get my hands on it.
October 5, 2023
Check out my Booktube channel at:
[4.5/5 stars] Yep ¨C this solidifies Islington as a personal favorite!
You never know what to expect going into an Islington¡ and you may not always know what the heck is going on while you¡¯re in there. But you can bet it¡¯s always going to be a wild ride! I loved Licanius for its classic fantasy feel (told with a modern writing style) and its wildly dynamic plotting ideas. He brought that same weirdness and creativity to The Will of the Many and amped it up even more.
It had so many elements I love in books ¨C fight/training sequences, school settings, competition, cool magic systems ¨C so many great elements that I was a nervous wreck while reading it. I was so worried he was going to get my hopes up only to dash them by not delivering on all the promises. But have no fear ¨C he completely delivers on every account with everything explored to it¡¯s fullest. It was so satisfying!
Even though it ultimately delivered, this book is a platypus. It has a lot of wild elements that by all accounts shouldn¡¯t work together (and perhaps wouldn¡¯t if handled by a less deft writer), but somehow he pulled it off. I¡¯ve found the key with Islington is to just go with it ¨C trusting that he knows what he¡¯s doing and it¡¯s worth the effort. He certainly hasn¡¯t let me down yet.
The Will of the Many had killer momentum and some of the best mic-drop scenes I¡¯ve read in ages ¨C many of which were so vivid and gut-punching that I¡¯ll remember them for years to come. I loveloveloved the academic aspect and how often the main character put his skills to the test. I loved the cast of characters and the fact that I still want to know more about all of them. I loved the friendships and rivalries and that survival depended on the MC¡¯s ability to navigate socially. I loved the competitions and that none of them were just brushed over. And I loved the epilogue ¨C slamming down my 5-star rating and fangirl status. You¡¯d better believe I¡¯m already clamoring for the next one.
I loved it.
Recommendations: Just go with it! You wont regret it!
Thank you to my : Dave, Katrin, Frank, Sonja, Staci, Kat, Melissa, Tonya, Betsy, Eliss, Mike, and Jen! <3
Via The Obsessive Bookseller at
Other books you might like:
[4.5/5 stars] Yep ¨C this solidifies Islington as a personal favorite!
You never know what to expect going into an Islington¡ and you may not always know what the heck is going on while you¡¯re in there. But you can bet it¡¯s always going to be a wild ride! I loved Licanius for its classic fantasy feel (told with a modern writing style) and its wildly dynamic plotting ideas. He brought that same weirdness and creativity to The Will of the Many and amped it up even more.
It had so many elements I love in books ¨C fight/training sequences, school settings, competition, cool magic systems ¨C so many great elements that I was a nervous wreck while reading it. I was so worried he was going to get my hopes up only to dash them by not delivering on all the promises. But have no fear ¨C he completely delivers on every account with everything explored to it¡¯s fullest. It was so satisfying!
Even though it ultimately delivered, this book is a platypus. It has a lot of wild elements that by all accounts shouldn¡¯t work together (and perhaps wouldn¡¯t if handled by a less deft writer), but somehow he pulled it off. I¡¯ve found the key with Islington is to just go with it ¨C trusting that he knows what he¡¯s doing and it¡¯s worth the effort. He certainly hasn¡¯t let me down yet.
The Will of the Many had killer momentum and some of the best mic-drop scenes I¡¯ve read in ages ¨C many of which were so vivid and gut-punching that I¡¯ll remember them for years to come. I loveloveloved the academic aspect and how often the main character put his skills to the test. I loved the cast of characters and the fact that I still want to know more about all of them. I loved the friendships and rivalries and that survival depended on the MC¡¯s ability to navigate socially. I loved the competitions and that none of them were just brushed over. And I loved the epilogue ¨C slamming down my 5-star rating and fangirl status. You¡¯d better believe I¡¯m already clamoring for the next one.
I loved it.
Recommendations: Just go with it! You wont regret it!
Thank you to my : Dave, Katrin, Frank, Sonja, Staci, Kat, Melissa, Tonya, Betsy, Eliss, Mike, and Jen! <3
Via The Obsessive Bookseller at
Other books you might like:
May 23, 2023
I am such a sucker for stories that involve an ancient cataclysm mystery. I mean, I love it so much and want that kind of plot injected directly into my brain. That is just one of the many intriguing storylines that acclaimed fantasy author James Islington has weaved into his latest upcoming novel THE WILL OF THE MANY. Not only that, Islington has also managed to create one of the more emotional journeys of any main character that I have come across.
Coming off of the brilliant Licanius Trilogy, I wasn't sure just what to expect from this one. Would it still give me that same magical feeling I got when I read that series? Well all I'll say is Islington has proven that he has some of the best ideas and writing chops in the game after finishing this utterly spellbinding first book in the Hierarchy series. It shouldn't have been as effortless as it was for me to fly through this almost 700 page book, but it was. And that's just a testament to the magnificent storyteller that James Islington is.
Part of the excellence of this book stems from just how many layers of mystery are involved. Just when one might look like it is solved, another pops up and often takes the story in a wholly unexpected direction. The Hierarchy is portrayed as yet another group of megalomaniacs who after conquering a weaker kingdom, now rules with absolute and unquestioned authority. They also rule by way of a super cool magic system that enables them to gain power by sucking the "Will" from those they capture and imprison. It kind of reminded me of the magic system in David Farland's Runelords series but with a slightly different and unique twist. Those with the most Will, Princeps, are ranked highest in the Catenan ruling class, followed by Dimidius, Tertius, Quartus, well you get the picture. It is by this transfer of Will that the Hierarchy is able to remain in power and maintain their seemingly invincible stranglehold.
And yet main character Vis believes all is not lost and that by infiltration into the famed Catenan Academy, he might be able to uncover vital information that could reveal potential vulnerabilities in the Hierarchy's armor. This is where the book really had me in its grip as Vis happens upon so many instances of near capture, death, and being exposed as an agent of the resistance that I wasn't sure whether he was going to even survive past the first half of the book to be completely honest. Is this a fool's errand, or can one person really hope to overturn and reverse the forces of tyranny that have taken over a battered and beaten homeland?
Wow, what an extraordinary read this was. I can't get over how many twists and turns this book took and how completely off balance I was for the vast majority of it. The thing that I liked best was not knowing who in the story was truly trying to help Vis and who was just being friendly only to bide their time until they could thrust a short blade in his back. There's so much deception involved and it's the exact type of fantasy book that I love to read. And while Islington reveals small pieces of the larger picture, he tantalizingly leaves so much still hidden and open for conjecture for the story that is still to come.
THE WILL OF THE MANY is a stunning achievement from one of the most talented epic fantasy writers in the game right now. To me this opening book in Islington's brand new series has further shown that he has the staying power to continue to create breathtaking new worlds, brilliantly realized magic systems, and characters who we can both root for and despise. Simply a wonderful book that made me all the more desperate to have the next one in my hand. It's the kind of story that stays with you long after completion and makes you hunger for more. I still have so many questions and cannot wait to continue on with this series. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys a masterfully told tale with all of the elements that constitute a highly compulsive read.
Coming off of the brilliant Licanius Trilogy, I wasn't sure just what to expect from this one. Would it still give me that same magical feeling I got when I read that series? Well all I'll say is Islington has proven that he has some of the best ideas and writing chops in the game after finishing this utterly spellbinding first book in the Hierarchy series. It shouldn't have been as effortless as it was for me to fly through this almost 700 page book, but it was. And that's just a testament to the magnificent storyteller that James Islington is.
Part of the excellence of this book stems from just how many layers of mystery are involved. Just when one might look like it is solved, another pops up and often takes the story in a wholly unexpected direction. The Hierarchy is portrayed as yet another group of megalomaniacs who after conquering a weaker kingdom, now rules with absolute and unquestioned authority. They also rule by way of a super cool magic system that enables them to gain power by sucking the "Will" from those they capture and imprison. It kind of reminded me of the magic system in David Farland's Runelords series but with a slightly different and unique twist. Those with the most Will, Princeps, are ranked highest in the Catenan ruling class, followed by Dimidius, Tertius, Quartus, well you get the picture. It is by this transfer of Will that the Hierarchy is able to remain in power and maintain their seemingly invincible stranglehold.
And yet main character Vis believes all is not lost and that by infiltration into the famed Catenan Academy, he might be able to uncover vital information that could reveal potential vulnerabilities in the Hierarchy's armor. This is where the book really had me in its grip as Vis happens upon so many instances of near capture, death, and being exposed as an agent of the resistance that I wasn't sure whether he was going to even survive past the first half of the book to be completely honest. Is this a fool's errand, or can one person really hope to overturn and reverse the forces of tyranny that have taken over a battered and beaten homeland?
Wow, what an extraordinary read this was. I can't get over how many twists and turns this book took and how completely off balance I was for the vast majority of it. The thing that I liked best was not knowing who in the story was truly trying to help Vis and who was just being friendly only to bide their time until they could thrust a short blade in his back. There's so much deception involved and it's the exact type of fantasy book that I love to read. And while Islington reveals small pieces of the larger picture, he tantalizingly leaves so much still hidden and open for conjecture for the story that is still to come.
THE WILL OF THE MANY is a stunning achievement from one of the most talented epic fantasy writers in the game right now. To me this opening book in Islington's brand new series has further shown that he has the staying power to continue to create breathtaking new worlds, brilliantly realized magic systems, and characters who we can both root for and despise. Simply a wonderful book that made me all the more desperate to have the next one in my hand. It's the kind of story that stays with you long after completion and makes you hunger for more. I still have so many questions and cannot wait to continue on with this series. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys a masterfully told tale with all of the elements that constitute a highly compulsive read.
November 30, 2023
I asked for an unpredictable plot, a hero's journey that shocked me, one so completely original that I couldn't see it coming until it was exploding right in my face. The Will of the Many stepped up and said, "Bitch hold my hoops."
Never in a million years did I see this coming.
Beyond the absolutely wild and captivating ending, this book could school the fantasy genre in plot and pacing, show-don't-tell prose, competent and relatable characters that are so believably strategic they remain enigmatic, and writing a setting that immaculately blurs the lines of fantasy and science fiction, complete with a magic system that's philosophically evocative.
I can hardly believe this story is about teenagers. NOTHING about it is juvenile. The plot is so intricately woven but expertly told, that it's totally accessible while nailing about 20 different technical story-telling tactics with excellence. The story moved easily between sequences of competitive training, espionage, attacks, strategic maneuvering, emotional upheaval, moral conundrums, and backstory reveals at an effortless and constant pace. I got it all, without a single lapse.
It missed nothing. I have no notes. I do have questions and need the next book now! This is easily one of my top three reads of the year. If you consider yourself a fan of science fiction or fantasy, I cannot recommend this more.
Never in a million years did I see this coming.
Beyond the absolutely wild and captivating ending, this book could school the fantasy genre in plot and pacing, show-don't-tell prose, competent and relatable characters that are so believably strategic they remain enigmatic, and writing a setting that immaculately blurs the lines of fantasy and science fiction, complete with a magic system that's philosophically evocative.
I can hardly believe this story is about teenagers. NOTHING about it is juvenile. The plot is so intricately woven but expertly told, that it's totally accessible while nailing about 20 different technical story-telling tactics with excellence. The story moved easily between sequences of competitive training, espionage, attacks, strategic maneuvering, emotional upheaval, moral conundrums, and backstory reveals at an effortless and constant pace. I got it all, without a single lapse.
It missed nothing. I have no notes. I do have questions and need the next book now! This is easily one of my top three reads of the year. If you consider yourself a fan of science fiction or fantasy, I cannot recommend this more.
May 9, 2024
An incredible, unpredictable, and wonderfully twisty fast-paced read that I could not put down. Tense and exciting, this book reminded me of Pierce Brown's Red Rising with its Roman Empire inspired worldbuilding and undercover protagonist surrounded by people he cannot trust, but it has its own style and vibe that separate it from Brown's also phenomenal series. If you're looking for a book to break your reading slump or keep you up until 3am reading, this is the book for you. Great characters, a thrilling plot, and so much fun. Plus, that ending was a serious wtf that made me excited for whatever strange twist comes next. I'm looking forward to book 2.
I received a free ARC which in no way impacted my honest review.
I received a free ARC which in no way impacted my honest review.
March 5, 2024
I¡¯m often complaining how stupid characters that aren¡¯t meant to be inherently stupid sound in most books, but I do understand their ¡°ingenuity¡± is a ploy for the book to be longer, for the plot to be articulated in various stages and not be told all at once. This book, though, had none of it. The main character was so smart it was hard to keep up at times, what he did to help Callidus something I¡¯ll never forget and could have never foreseen. When he wasn¡¯t smart enough to understand the complexity of what was going on around him, then, for sure, nor could be the reader, the politics were as intricate as politics in a roman inspired senate should be, with continuous shifting of weird, but still powered by greed, alliances. It is literally not possible to say that something that happened was predictable, because it was not, my only guide throughout the book was knowing the latin meaning of the characters¡¯ names, as little as it helped.
Each part of the book was as surprising as it could be, it left me gasping in various occasions, and I think it was mostly because the characters themselves were, fundamentally, great, complex and each with their own astonishing secrets to tell.
On a less positive note, I really don¡¯t like the concept of the epilogue and what may come from it, I¡¯ll admit I¡¯d be way more pleased if this was a stand alone because I¡¯ve many doubts on the way things will unravel, but I guess we¡¯ll see, I may be wrong (I hope I am).
Each part of the book was as surprising as it could be, it left me gasping in various occasions, and I think it was mostly because the characters themselves were, fundamentally, great, complex and each with their own astonishing secrets to tell.
On a less positive note, I really don¡¯t like the concept of the epilogue and what may come from it, I¡¯ll admit I¡¯d be way more pleased if this was a stand alone because I¡¯ve many doubts on the way things will unravel, but I guess we¡¯ll see, I may be wrong (I hope I am).
August 12, 2023
Anytime there is consensus among people I follow who don't always enjoy the same fantasy the part of me that enjoys fucking around is tempted to pick up the book, this was no exception. It didn't hurt that this was the book my patrons voted for me to read for a vlog, so in that sense there was a little bit of external pressure for me to pick it up.
Going into this I had heard it compared to a lot of other books already available. The one that comes up the most is [ baby monte's review can be found here ], [ My Review ], and [ My Review ]. If it had just been the first two I might have kept going on with my life because I found both of them lacking, but the idea of another fantasy school book but with a person masquerading as someone they aren't in order to bring down the Empire? That... that I could actually get behind.
Y'all, I should have just kept on with my life.
Back in the day comp title Red Rising would get shelved in the YA section at Barnes and Noble, I have a feeling this is mostly due to the fact that dystopian fiction was in the death rattle but shelving them together felt appropriate to the powers that be. Here we have a case that The Will of the Many is solidly a piece of Young Adult fiction masquerading as an adult work at an adult imprint so that Saga Press can justify charging you 30 USD/40 CAD.
Here we are following Vis, a boy we meet at the start of the book ostensibly an orphan working at what is essentially a prison. We follow him as an upper rank individual visits said prison unexpectedly, overhears something that maybe he shouldn't have, and then follow him to the underground fight club that he participates in to earn money that he won't have to fork over to the woman who runs the orphanage he's currently still residing in. The next thirty percent of the book follows our orphan boy as we learn about his actual past, the reason why the unexpected visitor chooses to adopt him and then train him for the elite school so that the plot of over throwing the Empire that exists on every corner of the landmass of this world can be set in motion...
Only when we finally arrive at the school there's nothing elite about it. There is some throwaway discussions about fairness and how the students at this academy are all the children of Senators or other high ranking officials within the Empire, murmurs of factions already grating against one another now that the military has nowhere left to conquer. But the way that Vis just propels through the academy never hitting a roadblock that Islington won't conveniently shift out of his way was just not fun to read. Not only is there really no sense of struggle, there's no sense of growth or reasoning why this book needed to be set at a school or us to be following a child...
That's to say nothing of Vis, who is truly the worst actor. We are meant to believe that he is invested in this charade that he's been running since he left his old life behind. A life that would definitely make him a wanted man by the Empire and really the only reason he is adopted in the first place, but at every opportunity he has to reveal who he really is and expose himself he does. To the point that at the academy a character I'm meant to believe is his friend is constantly telling him that they've clocked Vis isn't who he says he is and that it's only a matter of time until the other do as well. You'd think that would be used to remind Vis the stakes of what he's doing and that he'd be more careful, but as the story enters the third act he just becomes more and more reckless.
The world building in this one is definitely a mess... You'd think that an author would use the school setting as something of a crutch to guide the reader through history or how the magic is used in the world, but here it was mostly used for us to see how smart Vis was compared to his classmates that he was always calling stupid. What we did get of the world always felt like a wink and a nudge that was reminding the reader how invested Islington was in creating his version of a fantasy Roman Empire. At the end of the day it never felt like a place that existed physically, like it stood on any firm ground or that the people of the book read as people from various parts of a world that had been conquered and united by the Empire in the book...
There were moments that I enjoyed. There was an exchange between Vis and a character he got off on the wrong foot with that he was eventually paired up with in a classic YA trope kind of way, but it was also the only relationship in the book that felt genuine and like care had gone into. So the book isn't entirely terrible... But I still wouldn't recommend. It's part of a series and so maybe once there is more to contextualize this first book with later installments it'll be worth someone's time, but as of now it's definitely not anything you need to rush out and pick up.
Going into this I had heard it compared to a lot of other books already available. The one that comes up the most is [ baby monte's review can be found here ], [ My Review ], and [ My Review ]. If it had just been the first two I might have kept going on with my life because I found both of them lacking, but the idea of another fantasy school book but with a person masquerading as someone they aren't in order to bring down the Empire? That... that I could actually get behind.
Y'all, I should have just kept on with my life.
Back in the day comp title Red Rising would get shelved in the YA section at Barnes and Noble, I have a feeling this is mostly due to the fact that dystopian fiction was in the death rattle but shelving them together felt appropriate to the powers that be. Here we have a case that The Will of the Many is solidly a piece of Young Adult fiction masquerading as an adult work at an adult imprint so that Saga Press can justify charging you 30 USD/40 CAD.
Here we are following Vis, a boy we meet at the start of the book ostensibly an orphan working at what is essentially a prison. We follow him as an upper rank individual visits said prison unexpectedly, overhears something that maybe he shouldn't have, and then follow him to the underground fight club that he participates in to earn money that he won't have to fork over to the woman who runs the orphanage he's currently still residing in. The next thirty percent of the book follows our orphan boy as we learn about his actual past, the reason why the unexpected visitor chooses to adopt him and then train him for the elite school so that the plot of over throwing the Empire that exists on every corner of the landmass of this world can be set in motion...
Only when we finally arrive at the school there's nothing elite about it. There is some throwaway discussions about fairness and how the students at this academy are all the children of Senators or other high ranking officials within the Empire, murmurs of factions already grating against one another now that the military has nowhere left to conquer. But the way that Vis just propels through the academy never hitting a roadblock that Islington won't conveniently shift out of his way was just not fun to read. Not only is there really no sense of struggle, there's no sense of growth or reasoning why this book needed to be set at a school or us to be following a child...
That's to say nothing of Vis, who is truly the worst actor. We are meant to believe that he is invested in this charade that he's been running since he left his old life behind. A life that would definitely make him a wanted man by the Empire and really the only reason he is adopted in the first place, but at every opportunity he has to reveal who he really is and expose himself he does. To the point that at the academy a character I'm meant to believe is his friend is constantly telling him that they've clocked Vis isn't who he says he is and that it's only a matter of time until the other do as well. You'd think that would be used to remind Vis the stakes of what he's doing and that he'd be more careful, but as the story enters the third act he just becomes more and more reckless.
The world building in this one is definitely a mess... You'd think that an author would use the school setting as something of a crutch to guide the reader through history or how the magic is used in the world, but here it was mostly used for us to see how smart Vis was compared to his classmates that he was always calling stupid. What we did get of the world always felt like a wink and a nudge that was reminding the reader how invested Islington was in creating his version of a fantasy Roman Empire. At the end of the day it never felt like a place that existed physically, like it stood on any firm ground or that the people of the book read as people from various parts of a world that had been conquered and united by the Empire in the book...
There were moments that I enjoyed. There was an exchange between Vis and a character he got off on the wrong foot with that he was eventually paired up with in a classic YA trope kind of way, but it was also the only relationship in the book that felt genuine and like care had gone into. So the book isn't entirely terrible... But I still wouldn't recommend. It's part of a series and so maybe once there is more to contextualize this first book with later installments it'll be worth someone's time, but as of now it's definitely not anything you need to rush out and pick up.
September 9, 2023
Wow, this was phenomenal! One of the best high fantasy novels I've read in years! (Think RED RISING meets THE NAME OF THE WIND.) I couldn't put it down!
May 20, 2023
My thanks to Gallery Books, James Islington and Netgalley.
I had planned on doing up one hell of a review. Characters, placement and what all.
Then I noticed Rover. That's my Betta fish. He was giving me the evil eye, and flashing his beautiful fins at me! Sure. I could almost read his thoughts. How could I not? His ? eyes, and his fins..Just giving me the "feed me now" look.
Yeah, he owns me!
O.K. So, in truth we all know that I never give reviews. What I give are feelings of the story.
This story was initially difficult to get into. I think it was mostly because what's his face was a bit much. Superhero a bit? Yes. Well rounded? Yes.
It was too much.
I'll confess that I really didn't like the first half of this story.
Thankfully, it definitely grew on me!
No mucking around here, but I guarantee that I'll be reading the next book.
I had planned on doing up one hell of a review. Characters, placement and what all.
Then I noticed Rover. That's my Betta fish. He was giving me the evil eye, and flashing his beautiful fins at me! Sure. I could almost read his thoughts. How could I not? His ? eyes, and his fins..Just giving me the "feed me now" look.
Yeah, he owns me!
O.K. So, in truth we all know that I never give reviews. What I give are feelings of the story.
This story was initially difficult to get into. I think it was mostly because what's his face was a bit much. Superhero a bit? Yes. Well rounded? Yes.
It was too much.
I'll confess that I really didn't like the first half of this story.
Thankfully, it definitely grew on me!
No mucking around here, but I guarantee that I'll be reading the next book.
February 17, 2024
HOLY FUCKING SHIT I NEED BOOK TWO IMMEDIATELY
9.71 on CAWPILE
9.71 on CAWPILE
January 31, 2024
Wow... James Islington really pulled out all the stops for this one...
So much happened in this book. I read this over about a month and a half, so looking back, I feel like I've read more than just one book in this series. Honestly, the more this story sits with me the more I love it. I'd definitely recommend this to fans of , though I do think that this focused more on intellectual and political warfare.
From the very start, I loved our main character, Vis. He's incredibly smart and skilled, but at they same time, it feels like he's still learning and just doing his best in a rough situation. I loved that he was always thinking 5 steps ahead and that he wasn't na?ve in the slightest. Vis is pulled in so many directions in this book. I loved the friendships he made while in the academy (and how those friendships caused some dissonance in him due to his hate for the Hierarchy). Through the competitive nature of the academy - and just the structure of the Hierarchy in general - Islington was also super successful in creating an atmosphere of suspicion, where you're not sure whether you can fully trust anyone (no matter how much you like them).
I truly had no idea what was going to happen at any point of this, and Islington managed to catch me off guard with multiple plot twists. My only complaint is that the mechanics of the magic system is still a bit murky for me, but I'm hoping we'll get more of that in the future.
This book was incredibly complex and so well done. I now fully understand why many are hailing this as one of their favorite fantasy books of the year (me included), and I cannot wait to see where this series goes in the future!
So much happened in this book. I read this over about a month and a half, so looking back, I feel like I've read more than just one book in this series. Honestly, the more this story sits with me the more I love it. I'd definitely recommend this to fans of , though I do think that this focused more on intellectual and political warfare.
From the very start, I loved our main character, Vis. He's incredibly smart and skilled, but at they same time, it feels like he's still learning and just doing his best in a rough situation. I loved that he was always thinking 5 steps ahead and that he wasn't na?ve in the slightest. Vis is pulled in so many directions in this book. I loved the friendships he made while in the academy (and how those friendships caused some dissonance in him due to his hate for the Hierarchy). Through the competitive nature of the academy - and just the structure of the Hierarchy in general - Islington was also super successful in creating an atmosphere of suspicion, where you're not sure whether you can fully trust anyone (no matter how much you like them).
I truly had no idea what was going to happen at any point of this, and Islington managed to catch me off guard with multiple plot twists. My only complaint is that the mechanics of the magic system is still a bit murky for me, but I'm hoping we'll get more of that in the future.
This book was incredibly complex and so well done. I now fully understand why many are hailing this as one of their favorite fantasy books of the year (me included), and I cannot wait to see where this series goes in the future!
December 20, 2023
I thoroughly enjoy epic fantasy novels, so coming off the heels of the Mistborn trilogy, I had high hopes that The Will of the Many by James Islington would deliver. And boy, did it. In the 30 some odd hours it took me to feverishly read this tome, I felt a range of emotions: amazement at its grandeur, enamored by its complexity, and delighted by the sheer energy of the character journeys. But more than anything, I was in almost constant amazement at its world-building¡ªfrom the many exciting locations, the scope of the framework, the sparse but extremely effective action sequences, and the way the book rewards you for its seemingly endless setup of the first 30% or so. It will probably come as no surprise that this is probably one of my favorite reads of 2023, and I cannot wait until the next book in the series releases.
Our reticent hero is a teenager who resides in an orphanage and earns his mettle by battling foes in an arena and by keeping a watchful eye over prisoners in a dark, dank prison. (do not touch those sappers!)
After a seemingly positive interaction with a Quintus, Vis is plucked from the orphanage and enrolled in a prestigious, albeit infamous, academy. But before he embarks on his epic quest, he must endure the training of Lanistia. A quick-witted and even-tempered character that is tasked with helping Vis go from zero to hero in a few short weeks.
The training consists of all the regular superfluous studies you come to expect, including fighting, book smarts, magical concepts, passion, socialization, and immense puzzle solving. It¡¯s all here, and Vis will need to channel all these teachings in order to succeed atHogwarts the Academy.
At its heart, the book is a coming-of-age story, and I applaud the minimalistic approach to the actual 'scene setting'¡ªthink broad brush strokes instead of illimitable detail. Typically, I usually champion equal parts detail and substance, but this book gives you just enough to flesh out the blueprints for yourself.
The plot deepens and the extensive amount of setup begins to come to light when Vis enrolls in the academy and begins to uncover some of the murky truths surrounding the institution.
But he does not go at it alone. The tone quickly changes from a fish-out-of-water scenario to being thrown into the deep end of the pool. As Vis moves up the class ranks, acquires more knowledge, and gains more friends, he learns that the tense puzzle games the students play may not be operating ¡®above board¡¯ and that the staff members might not be all that trustworthy.
From here on out, it¡¯s a cohesive collection of Enders Game sensibilities, anime puzzler-like twists, a tad bit of Battle Royal, a dash of Red Rising, a pinch of Maze-Runner, and last but certainly not least, a whole lot of fun!
Bottom line is that it's engaging, and the characters are deep and well-rounded. The groundwork is set for more clever bits of story telling, and I will be first in line to get my eyes on the sequel.
?| Soundtrack |?
? Avantasia ¨C The Moonflower Society
? The Beatles ¨C Lucy in The Sky With Diamonds
? Entombed ¨C Left Hand Path
? Journey ¨C Wheel in The Sky
? | Rating | ?
? 5 out of 5 ?
Our reticent hero is a teenager who resides in an orphanage and earns his mettle by battling foes in an arena and by keeping a watchful eye over prisoners in a dark, dank prison. (do not touch those sappers!)
After a seemingly positive interaction with a Quintus, Vis is plucked from the orphanage and enrolled in a prestigious, albeit infamous, academy. But before he embarks on his epic quest, he must endure the training of Lanistia. A quick-witted and even-tempered character that is tasked with helping Vis go from zero to hero in a few short weeks.
The training consists of all the regular superfluous studies you come to expect, including fighting, book smarts, magical concepts, passion, socialization, and immense puzzle solving. It¡¯s all here, and Vis will need to channel all these teachings in order to succeed at
At its heart, the book is a coming-of-age story, and I applaud the minimalistic approach to the actual 'scene setting'¡ªthink broad brush strokes instead of illimitable detail. Typically, I usually champion equal parts detail and substance, but this book gives you just enough to flesh out the blueprints for yourself.
The plot deepens and the extensive amount of setup begins to come to light when Vis enrolls in the academy and begins to uncover some of the murky truths surrounding the institution.
But he does not go at it alone. The tone quickly changes from a fish-out-of-water scenario to being thrown into the deep end of the pool. As Vis moves up the class ranks, acquires more knowledge, and gains more friends, he learns that the tense puzzle games the students play may not be operating ¡®above board¡¯ and that the staff members might not be all that trustworthy.
From here on out, it¡¯s a cohesive collection of Enders Game sensibilities, anime puzzler-like twists, a tad bit of Battle Royal, a dash of Red Rising, a pinch of Maze-Runner, and last but certainly not least, a whole lot of fun!
Bottom line is that it's engaging, and the characters are deep and well-rounded. The groundwork is set for more clever bits of story telling, and I will be first in line to get my eyes on the sequel.
?| Soundtrack |?
? Avantasia ¨C The Moonflower Society
? The Beatles ¨C Lucy in The Sky With Diamonds
? Entombed ¨C Left Hand Path
? Journey ¨C Wheel in The Sky
? | Rating | ?
? 5 out of 5 ?
January 18, 2024
THIS BOOK HERE!! THIS IS WHY I LOVE READING
This read made me forget to eat, sleep, and work (oops). And I know I truly love a book when that happens. This is the most engaging, epic, engrossing, earth-shattering fantasy I¡¯ve read since The Name of the Wind - and I thought I¡¯d never come across a fantasy I¡¯d love as much as that one again.
The Roman Empire setting, the complex and wholly unique magic system, the political intrigue and social commentary, the friendships, the mystery, the magical academy, the animal sidekick (okay it probably shouldn¡¯t be described that way but let me be), the emotion, the layers, the plottwist, the opposing stakes!!! Every time I thought I¡¯d figured something out, everything got turned on its head again.
It is a unique thing for a writer to be able to craft a world that feels real, along with characters that are complex and alive, invent a magic system AND write a plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat for all 620 pages. And that ending¡ it¡¯s just cruel to leave us behind like this.
This book is genius and I need the second one like now. Please god I beg you let this series continue unlike The Name of the Wind that has been broken my heart a little more with each passing year that there¡¯s no third book
This read made me forget to eat, sleep, and work (oops). And I know I truly love a book when that happens. This is the most engaging, epic, engrossing, earth-shattering fantasy I¡¯ve read since The Name of the Wind - and I thought I¡¯d never come across a fantasy I¡¯d love as much as that one again.
The Roman Empire setting, the complex and wholly unique magic system, the political intrigue and social commentary, the friendships, the mystery, the magical academy, the animal sidekick (okay it probably shouldn¡¯t be described that way but let me be), the emotion, the layers, the plottwist, the opposing stakes!!! Every time I thought I¡¯d figured something out, everything got turned on its head again.
It is a unique thing for a writer to be able to craft a world that feels real, along with characters that are complex and alive, invent a magic system AND write a plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat for all 620 pages. And that ending¡ it¡¯s just cruel to leave us behind like this.
This book is genius and I need the second one like now. Please god I beg you let this series continue unlike The Name of the Wind that has been broken my heart a little more with each passing year that there¡¯s no third book
March 5, 2024
No hyperbole at all when I say this is one of the best books I have read. It was so fast paced, so immersive, so tense and exciting and all of that made this book to be one of my favourite reading experiences.
The Will of the Many is like Red Rising and Golden Son merged together with a dash of Blood Song. I couldn't put it down and I felt truly obsessed. The book consumed me, or I consumed it, whichever sounds better.
SO GOOD!
The Will of the Many is like Red Rising and Golden Son merged together with a dash of Blood Song. I couldn't put it down and I felt truly obsessed. The book consumed me, or I consumed it, whichever sounds better.
SO GOOD!
September 21, 2024
¡°Silence is a statement, Diago. Inaction picks a side. And when those lead to personal benefit, they are complicity.¡±
Incredible...absolutely amazing. The writing, the characters, the world, the political intrigue, the action and adventure, the pacing - it was all top-tier.
This was everything you could have asked for in a high fantasy. I was hooked and couldn't let go. The execution was spotless. I was so invested in the main character and his story. I even shed a few tears. Vis was wickedly intelligent, passionate, and dedicated to his beliefs.
¡°There comes a point in every man¡¯s life where he can rail against the unfairness of the world until he loses, or he can do his best in it. Remain a victim, or become a survivor.¡±
This reminded me of Harry Potter but mature and complex. It almost felt nostalgic in a way. I will be thinking about this book for months to come. I also need the sequel ASAP because that ending left me feeling desperate for more.
¡°Death is only meaningless if it does not change us, Vis.¡±
Incredible...absolutely amazing. The writing, the characters, the world, the political intrigue, the action and adventure, the pacing - it was all top-tier.
This was everything you could have asked for in a high fantasy. I was hooked and couldn't let go. The execution was spotless. I was so invested in the main character and his story. I even shed a few tears. Vis was wickedly intelligent, passionate, and dedicated to his beliefs.
¡°There comes a point in every man¡¯s life where he can rail against the unfairness of the world until he loses, or he can do his best in it. Remain a victim, or become a survivor.¡±
This reminded me of Harry Potter but mature and complex. It almost felt nostalgic in a way. I will be thinking about this book for months to come. I also need the sequel ASAP because that ending left me feeling desperate for more.
¡°Death is only meaningless if it does not change us, Vis.¡±
March 26, 2025
i¡¯m so tired of books causing me emotional pain. i¡¯m so tired of sobbing over people who aren¡¯t real. i¡¯ve been crying my eyes out for the last few minutes. ugh well done islington.
amazing. showstopping. an immediate favourite.
rtc
amazing. showstopping. an immediate favourite.
rtc
Read
June 29, 2023Full video review here:
While I liked the book a lot, I didn't quite find it as earth-shattering as the majority of my BookTube peers. However, Mr. Islington continues to be the master of mystery in giving you more questions than answers and leaving you hungry for the next installment; which I am.
Full thoughts in the video linked above.
While I liked the book a lot, I didn't quite find it as earth-shattering as the majority of my BookTube peers. However, Mr. Islington continues to be the master of mystery in giving you more questions than answers and leaving you hungry for the next installment; which I am.
Full thoughts in the video linked above.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 18,726 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.