ŷ

Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Safe-Keepers #3

The Dream-Maker's Magic

Rate this book
In the final novel of Shinn's romantic trilogy, Kellen and Gryffin, the kingdom's new Dream-Maker, build a strong friendship. When Gryffin is whisked away to the castle they wonder if their friendship-turning-into-something-more will endure.

261 pages, Hardcover

First published May 4, 2006

11 people are currently reading
1,085 people want to read

About the author

Sharon Shinn

58books2,257followers
I’ve been writing stories and poems since I was eight years old. My first poem was about Halloween: "What is tonight? What is tonight?/Try to guess and you’ll guess right." Perhaps this inauspicious beginning explains why it took me till I was in my thirties to sell a novel. It occurred to me early on that it might take some time and a lot of tries before I was able to publish any of my creative writing, so I pursued a degree in journalism at Northwestern University so I’d be able to support myself while I figured out how to write fiction.

I’ve spent most of my journalism career at three trade and association magazines—The Professional Photographer (which, as you might guess, went to studio and industrial photographers), DECOR (which went to frame shop and art gallery owners), and BizEd (which is directed at deans and professors at business schools). My longest stint, seventeen years, was at DECOR. Many people don’t know this, but I’m a CPF (Certified Picture Framer), having passed a very long, technical test to prove I understood the tenets of conservation framing. Now I write about management education and interview some really cool, really smart people from all over the world.

I mostly write my fiction in the evenings and on weekends. It requires a pretty obsessive-compulsive personality to be as prolific as I’ve been in the past ten years and hold down a full-time job. But I do manage to tear myself away from the computer now and then to do something fun. I read as often as I can, across all genres, though I’m most often holding a book that’s fantasy or romance, with the occasional western thrown in. I’m a fan of Cardinals baseball and try to be at the ballpark on opening day. If I had the time, I’d see a movie every day of my life. I love certain TV shows so much that knowing a new episode is going to air that night will make me happy all day. (I’m a huge Joss Whedon fan, but in the past I’ve given my heart to shows all over the map in terms of quality: "Knight Rider," "Remington Steele," "Blake’s 7," "Moonlighting," "The Young Riders," "Cheers," "Hill Street Blues," "X-Files," "Lost," "Battlestar Galactica"...you can probably fill in the gaps. And let’s not forget my very first loves, "The Partridge Family," "Here Come the Brides" and "Alias Smith & Jones.")

I don’t have kids, I don’t want pets, and all my plants die, so I’m really only forced to provide ongoing care for my menagerie of stuffed animals. All my friends are animal lovers, though, and someone once theorized that I keep friends as pets. I’m still trying to decide if that’s true.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
934 (31%)
4 stars
1,155 (38%)
3 stars
764 (25%)
2 stars
126 (4%)
1 star
20 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 207 reviews
Profile Image for Insh.
213 reviews74 followers
July 25, 2017
**MIGHT CONTAIN SPOILERS**
what if your gender was doubtful ,
i mean what if your mother strongly believed that you were born a boy,
but yet here you are all girl and no exceptions?

i was hooked from the very first. following Kellen as she tries to find her true identity.


you live a life that brings you down at every turn. your own body lets you down. but here you are viciously fighting it all to bring your dreams into life. and in the very end, a twist of faith ensures that you'd be the one reason why all the other people's dreams become a reality, while your own dreams remains just dreams.

Gryffin- is there any way not to love him?
Profile Image for Olga Godim.
Author12 books82 followers
September 3, 2013
A quiet, enchanting book, The Dream-Maker’s Magic is Shinn’s traditional low-key romantic tale. Although, it’s geared towards YA readers, there is no angst, no battles, and no villains. Just everyday life as we know it, with its ordinary ups and downs, petty disappointments, gentle, pastel victories, and veiled disasters. Or at least, it seems so on the surface, but this novel has several hidden layers, and it touches on many controversial themes.
One of those themes accentuates almost everything this writer has written so far: how to be different. In this novel, both protagonists deviate from the norm of their village, as well as of the romantic genre, but despite the adversity of their lives, they manage to keep their dignity and their sweetness intact.
Unlike most romantic male leads, Gryffin is not a muscled hunk. He is a cripple, unable to walk, but with a brilliant mind and a kind, caring soul. His only living relative, an uncle, hates his disabled nephew and often abuses the boy.
The girl Kellen is able in body but damaged inside. Nobody has ever beaten her, but her father left the family when she was very young, and her mother is crazy: she wouldn’t love or accept her daughter; she wants a son, thinks she should’ve had a son, and raises Kellen as if she were a son.
What does it do to a girl to be unable to express her femininity to the closest woman � her mother? Kellen could’ve become much more bitter and twisted if she didn’t meet Gryffin. The union of these two lonely kids seems inevitable, but they both go through a lot of self-doubts and tribulations before they can trust themselves and each other.
The love that develops between them takes time. It doesn’t spring up fully formed out of desire, nor does it stem from the guy’s wide shoulders or the girl’s perky breasts. No, this love comes out of a long friendship, and it seems much more believable than an average romance novel.
The writing is elegant and sparse, with no unnecessary words and no fluff. The narrative flows like a clear mountain brook, gurgling in delight, sparkling with sunlight and an occasional shadow. Despite the tragic protagonists, there is gladness in this story, the deep belief in humanity, even though the action takes place in an imaginary fantasy world.
The magic system is subtle and original, as in almost everything else this author’s written. The world of this book has three types of magic. The Truth-tellers are only able to tell the truth. They always know the truth. The Safe-keepers are the keepers of secrets. And the Dream-makers make people’s dreams come true. But each type of magic comes with a price. For example, the Truth-tellers are usually unpleasant, grumpy people. Nobody welcomes them; nobody wants to hear the truth. And the Dream-makers are unhappy and often in pain in their personal life, their magic seems only working for others, never for themselves.

Overall, this story is simultaneously simple and sophisticated, with multiple subtexts, told by a master. My only objection: there are some didactic paragraphs toward the end of the book, aimed at teenage audience, no doubt, but they are short and don’t detract from this book’s effortless charm.

Note: The cover art of the edition I own is gorgeous.
Profile Image for Tracy.
686 reviews32 followers
February 8, 2020
Three and a half stars. This was also lovely, a tale of a girl brought up as a boy and her best friend, the disabled boy she meets in school who grows up to become the Dream-maker. This is YA, the romantic elements in it are very muted and while I liked Kellen and Gryffin, I couldn’t help but feel that this story would have been better if it were more adult. That being said I found it had a certain wistful charm that was very appealing.
Profile Image for Anoush.
1,054 reviews
July 19, 2015
In thinking back on this book, I've realized that there doesn't really seem to be much of a plot, nor is there much really to overcome. I felt awful that Kellen had to live in this pseudo androgynous way, neither boy or girl. And yet, with all that, Kellen somehow manages to be quite a nice person and quite a lovely young woman. No problems or anything. Huh.

Perhaps the low rating is because from the very beginning I knew how this book would turn out. Not only that, but there weren't very many twists and turns along the way (if any). It was a straight and clear and easy road, full of easy forgiveness and no conflict. I was pretty glad they didn't talk about rape in this book at all. That was nice.
13 reviews2 followers
February 12, 2013
I really enjoyed this book, and not just because I have a thing for crossdressing heroines. Most of what sold me was the characters and their interactions; the relationship between Kellen and Gryffin motivated both characters' actions and was really a very sweet center to two otherwise rather turbulent lives, and the ways in which they supported and trusted one another stayed the strong emotional center to the book as a whole. The other characters were often engaging as well, and the author put forth an effort (sometimes less successful than others, but still there) to give even the most hated of characters some tiny drop of humanity. The plot mostly focuses on these two, especially Kellen, growing up and finding their own places in the world, which sometimes results in a bit of a start-and-stop feel to the narrative, as entire chapters will go by without much happening before suddenly three or four big events are crammed into fifteen pages. But this did serve a purpose most of the time, and the pacing is easily forgiven because of the enjoyability of the rest of the narrative. Probably my biggest problem came when the book took a bit of an out through a soap-opera-esque twist near the end that I felt negated some of the harsher and more interesting parts of the themes of family that ran through the book. However, I still very much enjoyed the book as a whole and would highly recommend it to anyone who likes character-driven fantasy middle grade.
Profile Image for Beth.
1,206 reviews152 followers
September 6, 2016
I enjoyed this, but it felt weirdly slight for Sharon Shinn. Off to reread Troubled Waters, I think.
Profile Image for Angie.
647 reviews1,108 followers
June 11, 2010
THE DREAM-MAKER'S MAGIC is the third book in 's Safe-Keepers trilogy. This trilogy is YA fantasy set in an unnamed kingdom in which, along with your average, run-of-the-mill people, there are also three sorts of quite special folk. The safe-keepers, the truth-tellers, and the dream-makers. While it is possible to find several safe-keepers and truth-tellers across the land, there is only ever one living dream-maker at any given time. It is a demanding calling and the individual usually resides in the capital, traveling throughout the kingdom making people's dreams come true. Or not. It all depends on the person and the nature of the desires of their heart. I'm featuring the third book in the trilogy, not only because it is my favorite, but because they really don't have to be read in order. Each volume features different characters, different towns, and different problems. And they each focus on one of the three groups of gifted people. I think each book is worth reading, but I also think they get progressively richer and more enjoyable. I'm not sure why these books didn't received as much attention as they deserve. It could be because they were not graced with particularly good covers (though the interior design is lovely). I am an unabashed Shinn fan, though (similar to ) I do end up preferring her "adult" titles to her YA. She's better in larger and longer doses, I think. And I haven't loved her other standalone YA titles. But these three are so very good. Particularly the third one.

Kellen's life has been . . . unconventional. Though she appears in all ways to be a girl, she has been raised her entire life as a boy. Ever since the day she was born her mother has insisted she was born a boy, despite all evidence to the contrary. Her father went along with it as long as he could and then finally left when the stubborn insanity on her mother's part became too much for him to handle. And so it has been just Kellen and her mother ever since. When she goes to school she is met with understandable confusion and suspicion. But for once in her life she is not the worst off. At school she meets a boy by the name of Gryffin who receives worse treatment at the hands of the other kids because of his deformed legs. Perhaps inevitably, these two outsiders become fast friends. United in their struggle against the rest of the world, Kellen helps Gryffin maneuver around the village and serves as a sort of buffer between her friend and his abusive, n'er do well uncle. In turn, Gryffin helps Kellen with her studies and her trials with her increasingly out of touch mother. And together they erect a barrier of kindness and hope between themselves and those who deride or look down upon them. Of course their situations are much more complicated than they at first seem and they only grow more so as they grow up and strike out on their own. They both take jobs at a nearby inn where the owners treat them kindly and take them for who and what they are. Then one day a stranger rides into town and changes their lives within the space of a single afternoon and, just as she felt she was getting a hold on things, Kellen is suddenly very sure things will never be the same again.

I find myself coming back to this one more frequently than its predecessors. The last book in the trilogy, THE DREAM-MAKER'S MAGIC strikes just the right chord with me, I guess. A main character whose mother is convinced she's a boy. A best friend whose legs are crippled but whose mind is razor sharp. A Dream-Maker who is weary of making people's dreams come true. And a first-person narrative that maintains a dogged authenticity amid elements both magical and fantastical. I found myself empathizing with Kellen, trying to carve out a space for herself, her real self, while everyone around her insists on offering their versions. Kellen and Gryffin's friendship is the highlight of the novel. Low on angst and high on the thoughtful exploration of what makes us who we are and what goes into the way we perceive ourselves and those around us, this book is quietly beautiful. My favorite passage:
At first I thought I had guessed wrong about my mother.

"A dress," she said, when I told her the requirement for me to work at the new Parmer Arms. "But you can't wear a dress. That would look silly. That would be indecent. Boys wear trousers."

I sat up straight enough so that my growing breasts made a definite shape against my tattered white shirt. "Girls wear skirts."

She looked at me as if she hadn't noticed my changing figure before, and her eyes slowly filled with tears. "You're not," she whispered. "You're not supposed to be."

"I don't know what I'm supposed to be," I said tiredly. "But this is what I am."

As it turned out, she neither granted permission for me to take the job nor told me outright that I could not. She merely ignored my request, ignored anything that had to do with my new identity. She did not help me cut and sew the three simple gowns I made for myself, following an extremely simple pattern. She did not ask about the work or comment on the money that I handed over at the end of every week. She pretended, as she had pretended my entire life, that I was someone else.

But I rather liked the new Kellen, who was, in many subtle ways, different from the old one. This Kellen was not quite so fierce, so independent, so wary. She smiled much more often--though that might have been to hide her shyness. She was not used to being stripped of disguises, unfamiliar with the casual appraisal a man might turn on a woman of any age on display, vulnerable, pulled out of hiding, a breath or two away from being starkly naked.

But she rather liked it.

I worked at the Parmer Arms four days a week--three evenings after school and one full day when school was not in session. At first, I walked through town, from my house to Sarah's, wearing my old boy's clothes and carrying my dress over my arm; I changed once I arrived. Sarah quickly decided it would make more sense for her to store all of my "restaurant clothes" at the Arms and made herself responsible for keeping them cleaned and mended. She also added two somewhat fancier garments to my small wardrobe, obviously having a seamstress tailor them after the template of the ones I had made myself. These dresses--one a dark navy and one a charcoal gray--were my favorite two things I owned.

Sarah also spent some time teaching me how to style my hair, though both of us tended to wear braids and buns to keep our hair out of the way while we were working. Still, she showed me how to soften my face with a few loose curls, and she trimmed my long, completely neglected locks so they fell with more grace around my cheeks. At times I didn't recognize myself when I looked in the mirror. And I was glad to see a stranger peering back at me from the glass that hung over the front desk at the Parmer Arms.

Most of the people who passed through the restaurant did not recognize me, either. True, the majority were strangers merely stopping briefly for food or a change of horses, but the restaurant had become a popular place for townspeople who wanted to treat themselves to a special night out. The first two months I worked there, I waited on at least a dozen people whom I had known all my life, and not one of them knew who I was.

But there was one person who was not fooled by my new looks or my modulated personality, and that was Gryffin. Or perhaps I put that wrong. He did not seem to notice what I was wearing or how I had arranged my hair, if I was dressed like the most disreputable street urchin or a quietly stylish young lady. Whether I saw him at school, whether I dropped by his uncle's house, or whether I unexpectedly encountered him on the street, he always greeted my with a smile and my name. I did not bewilder or surprise him. He did not think I was trying to be something I was not, as my mother did; he did not think I was trying to break a chrysalis and become something I was meant to be, as Besty and Sarah surely believed. He just thought I was Kellen.

I found this the most comforting thing that had ever happened to me. At times, when I lay awake at night, confused myself about what role I should take and what direction I should try to follow, all that kept me from slipping into tears was knowing that I was not completely lost if Gryffin knew how to find me.

See? Magic. Give it a chance and I have the feeling you'll fall as much in love with Kellen and Gryffin as I did. Pull it out on a night when you want to be especially cozy.
Profile Image for Kari.
923 reviews20 followers
October 20, 2017
Sweet little story. Really enjoy this simple series from Shinn. Excited to share with Lydia when she's older.
Profile Image for Willow Curtis.
67 reviews
April 26, 2012
Nice light read. Probably worth more like 3.5 stars. I picked this up off the library shelf at random, so I had no idea it was the third book in a series. Luckily it seemed to work as a stand-alone story. The idea of the truth-tellers, safe-keepers, and dream-makers was interesting. In this world there are three types of people that can use magic, truth-tellers - they can discern the truth and cannot tell a lie, safe-keepers � they can keep any secret shared with them, and dream-makers � they can grant wishes and dreams for others. Of course, there are downsides. Truth-tellers aren’t well liked and are not good company. Safe-keepers are very quiet people and don’t seem to lead normal lives. Dream-makers cannot make their own wishes come true and lead a life of pain and tragedy. This book focused on the dream-makers, hence the title. There can only be one at any time. The magic chooses who this person will be and it is a very demanding calling. In order to fulfill others' wishes, depending on the desires of their heart, the dream-maker must sacrifice. Despite the magical elements and the fantastical setting, the book seems very real. The story is not driven by the magic. I’m not always a huge fan of first-person narration, but it was done well.

I liked the main characters; however, they were often a bit too likable. They were almost always selfless, kind, and understanding � even as young children. That being said, I appreciated that the author didn't make them too perfect. They were smart, but not overly so. They were not gorgeous or overly idealized. When I read the synopsis on the back of the book, the fact that the main character’s mother raises her as a son and won’t believe that she is really a girl made me a bit nervous. I didn’t know how that would play out. Fortunately it was handled well, didn't overwhelm the rest of the story, and it made the main character more interesting. She is not choosing to dress as a boy voluntarily, at least at first. It is not a Twelfth Night scenario or an in-your-face statement on gender identity. (As a side note, I found an interesting paper written on female cross-dressing in YA fiction . This book was used as an example). The novel was well written, but I had some issues with the plot. It is a coming of age story and follows a predictable pattern. Two young children are ostracized by their peers and end up being outcasts. They become best friends and their friendship eventually turns into love. This didn’t bother me as much as the lack of purpose in the story. It doesn’t build towards anything. There is no overarching problem or goal.

The romance element was very tame. I’m not saying that I need gratuitous sex and violence to keep me interested. In fact, I liked that it was fairly clean, not overly sexualized or full of angst like many YA novels. Somehow this made the romance feel real and organic, more genuine. The main character, Kellen, met her love interest, Gryffin, when they were eleven and it was obvious that they were going to end up together. The fact that Gryffin did throw in an unexpected twist , but not much was done with how this affected their relationship. I enjoyed the first part of the book, when Kellen was dealing with her identity and developing a friendship with Gryffin. Toward the end the book became predictable and everything was resolved and tied up very neatly. It felt rushed.

Overall it was an enjoyable read. The idea that kindness is a type of magic and that everyone has the opportunity to fulfill other’s wishes throughout their lifetime was nice. I’m glad that I ran across this book. I think I might pick up the first two in the trilogy.
Profile Image for Lucy .
344 reviews33 followers
August 14, 2008
When Kellen was born, her mother was sure she was a boy, and she has never stopped believing that she gave birth to a son. So Kellen always dressed in boy’s clothing and did boy activities. She was always the odd one one—never quite a boy, never quite a girl.

Until she met Gryffin. Gryffin, with his twisted legs and sharp mind, didn’t see a boy or a girl—he just saw Kellen. And from the first day she sat with him, Kellen stopped seeing the crippled legs and just saw her best friend.

Life isn’t easy for Kellen or Gryffin—Kellen crippled by her mother’s madness and lack of acceptance, Gryffin crippled both by his legs and the hateful uncle he lived with. But they make each other their family, and together, they thrive. And then, just as their relationship is beginning to blossom into something else entirely, everything changes again.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again—the joy of these books isn’t the gripping plot. The reason I love these books is because there is nothing else like them out there. Jo Walton once talked about the shape of lives being more important and compelling that fighting wizards or dragons (over here: ) In a perfect little snippet of a poem, she wrote:

You say there are no stories in happiness
only the fire burning, the bucket in the well,
the wind in the gables, the crops ripening.
You try to tell those stories and they fall in your hands
into unpatterned incident. The shape of doing
again what was done before is not story-shape
though you have tried and come close.

Stop and be quiet. Listen to the rustling.
Stop looking for invasions and evil wizards.
Until you can see the shapes that life makes
ripening into stories worth your telling
the words that you say are only air
and neither life nor stories have the value
your words say you set upon them.

These lovely little bits show the story in bucket in the well, the crops ripening. These stories are not epic—they’re small. They encompass the span of small village lives. Though world affairs sometimes intrude on the edges of these stories, they are not about global crises—they are about living in a small village with an abusive uncle, or trying to figure out who you are when your own mother is confused about your gender. They are about being a friend.

As one of the characters says in the book, “Kindness is a form of magic. So everyone should be capable of at least a little.�

This is a very quiet book that feels important. It feels like it matters because it’s not about world affairs—it’s about the things that are most important to us—falling in love, getting married, having children, making a living, having friends.

And like the two previous books, the loose ends all get wrapped up neatly—but not in a saccharine way at all. It all fits. It all makes sense. It all feels right.

Don’t read this if you’re looking for high adventure, or for something Important. But if you want to read a fantasy that feels genuine, that feels like it could be true—this is the book for you.
Profile Image for Alice.
196 reviews22 followers
December 20, 2007
There are three kinds of magical people in this nameless community: Safe-keepers (who can keep any secret), Truth-tellers (who cannot tell a falsehood), and Dream-makers. This third book in Shinn's pleasant trilogy focuses on the Dream-maker.

The details of the plot are simple (a boy and a girl who are outcasts make friends with each other and finally realize they have fallen in love). My interest is in the concept of the Dream-maker. It is well known in this community that although a Dream-maker brings fulfilled dreams wherever he or she may go, his own life is full of tragedy. Is this not, in some ways, always true? To help another person means to give of yourself deeply. The more deeply the other person needs you, the deeper the sacrifice that must be given out of love. Ultimately, "by His wounds we are healed."

The message of the book is that, although there may be only one official Dream-maker, in small ways we can all be Dream-makers to those around us as we show small kindnesses--trusting, helping, loving each other. "Looked at in that way, my life was a weave of brightness laid over a trembling black, a scrap of midnight velvet spangled with many jewels."
Profile Image for Natalie.
3,137 reviews180 followers
March 16, 2012
This was hard one. I'd probably have to give it a 2.5. The writing was good but their was something missing. It was sort of like, the story ended and you were left saying "so what?" The whole premise is a little strange too. Kellan is a girl, but her mom believes she's supposed to be a boy and therefore raises and treats her as a boy. Kellan meets Gryffin, a boy with damaged legs, but a good heart. They become inseperable friends.

I liked the characters in this story. I appreciated how tenderly Gryffin and Kellan care for each other. The writing was good, but the plot was lacking that special something. If left me feeling a little empty. I really liked Kellan and Gryffin, but because of the end and the lack of a climax, I don't think I can comfortably rate it any higher.

I didn't realize that this was the third book in a series until it was over. It didn't seem to make any difference.
Profile Image for Janus the Erudite Artist.
702 reviews91 followers
February 11, 2011
This book is a simple tale, with magic and finding love in an unexpected way. At first I found the plot rather strange. I never imagined a mother wanting a son rather than her own daughter then suddenly raising her as a boy. But as the story progressed, it became clear why.

I can’t quite say that it’s some memorable tale for me. It’s a bit tedious although there are interesting events once in a while but mostly readers will be engulfed in the sorrow of the lives of Kellen and Gryffin then a sprinkle of kindness here and there � and that’s it�

The Dream-Maker’s Magic has a good lesson for one to ponder but it’s more of a children’s book rather than a YA or maybe I’m just not that into this sort of tales.

For more of my reviews, please visit my blog:
The Blair Book Project @
584 reviews33 followers
November 10, 2014
Dream makers and truth tellers...these folks provide the makings for a fun fantasy read. Though this is not a genre that I read often, I escaped into this adolescent read founded on friendship, kindness and hard work. Woven through the tale are some not very subtle suggestions that kindness is magic and we determine our fates.

Nice little read for my grandchildren ages probably ten and up. There is even romance thrown in for good measure. Plenty of "suspend disbelief" principles, but then who cares? Happy story simply rendered.
349 reviews35 followers
September 25, 2008
Of all the books in this series, I think this one might be the most poignant. Kellen and Griffyn's journey from being lost and lonely to being part of a community of love just hits me where I live. On the other hand, even though it's related to the themes of the trilogy, I'm getting a bit tired of Shinn's use of the "mistaken identities" plot device.
Profile Image for Nancy.
Author23 books1,081 followers
December 17, 2008
I love Sharon Shinn's YA books in this series. Oh, there's nothing earth-shaking here, nothing to get your pulse pounding, but they're the ultimate in gentle comfort reading and it's a pure pleasure to live in her kind world for the duration of the book.
Profile Image for Marsha Valance.
3,840 reviews59 followers
April 22, 2020
Kellen's mother insisted her only child was born a male and raised her as a boy till she was forced to go to school, where she became friends with crippled Gryffin. When he becomes the new Dream-Maker and is whisked away to the capital, Kellen follows.
Profile Image for Michelle.
232 reviews2 followers
February 13, 2016
2016-02-13: hmmm I guess I've never put in a date read for this book. Oh well. This was a re-read. Still charming. And long enough past since the last time I read it I had forgotten the details.
Profile Image for Cheryl.
12.1k reviews470 followers
December 28, 2021
It's not possible to fairly review these three books separately. Theoretically they can stand-alone, and in the past I've read them separately, but this week I read all three in order and it's a much richer experience.

And so this review is for all three. Readers very sensitive to spoilers may not want to click through, but any spoilers are mild and therefore most of you go right ahead and view.


I think one of the reasons I like this trilogy so much is that they are, in the end, gentler reads. They acknowledge that there is darkness in the world, but the stories are more filled with joy and optimism than drama or conflict.

Also the writing is graceful, lucid, and sometimes downright beautiful.

Notes from third book:

"Kindness is a form of magic."

"Aren't we all strange, in our ways?"

Btw, don't be misled. This is not a book about an androgynous, trans, or "they" person. In fact, if you give it to someone who identifies as something other than sex assigned at birth, they might be offended or hurt, unless they can read carefully & objectively about what the author was really exploring.
Profile Image for Ascolta.
192 reviews6 followers
August 26, 2018
Peculiar pacing structures, these little books - slow and even, w/out any real climax; the Safe-Keepers series seems to tread along like a memoir. Paradoxically, also very quick reads; I can fly right through them, and often am prompted to do so. They are a bit Dickensian [in an unfortunate kind of way]: plenty of clichés and rather-too-convenient crossings of paths.

For all this then, why am I enjoying Shinn so? I usually hate it when things are so trite, but somehow am only mildly eye-rolley in the face of the mildly predictable tropes of the Safe Keepers books.

*Or not all - the premise for was a bit over the top @ first sight, and I've yet to read it.
Profile Image for Liz.
1,754 reviews48 followers
April 25, 2025
The "Thank God Sharon Shinn has a back catalogue" experience continues apace. This is another one of her "How do people become themselves?" stories and it's interesting because, if it wasn't Shinn, I would have expected there to be a lot more gender in this story than there actually was. It feels like there's a lot under the surface of this story, but that's not the story Shinn is telling.


I...should have seen the end coming and I appreciated it, but also....yeah, a surprising lack of gender.
191 reviews2 followers
June 1, 2020
This is the last book in the trilogy and was probably the best one. All of the books are well written with good messages. I just objected to the incest, rape, murder etc. that also went along with the stories of love and sacrifice. Since I teach younger students, these books are not at all appropriate. Given the above atrocities, I'm not sure they are all that great for older readers either. They do have very good plots and characters and good underlying messages. I just get tired of flooding our adolescent readers with such horrors, although most are exposed to worse in their daily viewing habits.
Overall they are well written, but proceed with caution when recommending them.
Profile Image for Alicia.
3,245 reviews33 followers
March 30, 2020


Like its predecessor, the third book in this trilogy is set in the same universe, with cameos from previous characters, but focuses on a whole new town of people. The protagonist here is a young girl whose mother is convinced she's supposed to be a boy, and treats her as such. She ends up befriending a boy with a physical handicap (trigger warning here for child abuse) and their story is really sweet. I liked this trilogy a lot; bad things happened but only briefly, and everything always worked out exactly as it should. A-.
Profile Image for Sarani Rangarajan.
370 reviews4 followers
December 4, 2018
The cliches work

Things work out, and the odd and strange Magic’s make sense and the story remains about people, and relationships, and not the world itself. It’s a hopefully tale with true friendships and this book and author remain some of the best YA (and not just for YA) that I’ve read. I liked the sensitive portrayal of pain and abuse, which didn’t go overboard into torture. Worth your time� as a stand-alone or in series.
Profile Image for Lindsay.
429 reviews3 followers
December 3, 2020
While not groundbreaking, there is something truly charming about this story. Kellen and Gryffin are such easy characters to root for. I read this book in one sitting because I had to know how their story ended.

As a fan of Shinn's writing, I can say that this book had the hallmarks of her best work. Intriguing characters, a developed setting, touching themes, and beautiful writing.

I can see myself giving The Dream-Maker's Magic a second read some day.
1,473 reviews
September 4, 2023
Like the others in this series I loved this book. Some things were a little obvious, and I think it's a little ridiculous that the Truth Teller encountered at the beginning of the book only told part of the truth, which is not like any of the truth tellers encountered before this, but other than that, it was great! the characters were all delightful, and I loved the resolution without it being too perfect or easy.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
449 reviews
November 30, 2021
I read this final volume of the series at the recommendation of a very good friend. I enjoyed this one the most out of the whole series, loved the central characters, and most of all loved that although bad things happened to them the worst was over relatively quickly and they both trended up from there!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 207 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.