欧宝娱乐

Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

袩褉懈锌懈薪懈 褋胁芯褩 胁懈谐邪写泻懈

Rate this book
袣芯谢懈 褟 斜褍胁 写懈褌懈薪芯褞, 屑芯褟 屑邪屑邪 锌芯褋褌褨泄薪芯 泻邪蟹邪谢邪 屑械薪褨: 芦袩械褉械褋褌邪薪褜 斜褉械褏邪褌懈禄. 携 褌邪泻 写芯斜褉械 胁懈谐邪写褍胁邪胁 褨褋褌芯褉褨褩, 褖芯 胁芯薪邪 薪械 屑芯谐谢邪 胁褨写褉褨蟹薪懈褌懈 锌褉邪胁写褍 胁褨写 斜褉械褏薪褨. 袟褉械褕褌芯褞, 褟 蟹邪褉芯斜谢褟胁 褑懈屑 薪邪 卸懈褌褌褟, 褋褌邪胁 锌懈褋褜屑械薪薪懈泻芯屑. 小褜芯谐芯写薪褨 褟 薪邪褉械褕褌褨 褋谢褍褏邪褞褋褟 屑邪屑懈: 泻邪卸褍 锌褉邪胁写褍. 袙锌械褉褕械. 校 褑褨泄 泻薪懈卸褑褨. 袙褨写褉邪蟹褍 锌芯锌械褉械写卸邪褞: 卸芯写薪芯谐芯 蟹胁械写械薪薪褟 褉邪褏褍薪泻褨胁, 卸芯写薪芯谐芯 薪邪褋懈谢褜褋褌胁邪, 卸芯写薪芯谐芯 褋褨屑械泄薪芯谐芯 薪械胁褉芯蟹褍. 袥懈褕械 泻芯褏邪薪薪褟. 袙械谢懈褔械蟹薪械 褨 褌邪褦屑薪械 泻芯褏邪薪薪褟. 携泻械 胁褉械褕褌褨-褉械褕褌 薪邪蟹写芯谐薪邪谢芯 屑械薪械.

袩褉芯褩卸写卸邪褞褔懈 褉褨写薪懈屑 泻褉邪褦屑, 芯锌芯胁褨写邪褔 斜邪褔懈褌褜 薪邪 锌芯胁芯褉芯褌褨 胁褍谢懈褑褨 褋懈谢褍械褌 鈥� 芯斜谢懈褔褔褟, 褋褏芯卸褨褋褌褜 褟泻芯谐芯 蟹 泄芯谐芯 锌械褉褕懈屑 泻芯褏邪薪薪褟屑 胁褉邪卸邪褦 胁 褋邪屑械 褋械褉褑械..

袉褋褌芯褉褨褟, 褖芯 褉芯蟹锌芯褔邪谢邪褋褜 写胁邪写褑褟褌褜 锌'褟褌褜 褉芯泻褨胁 褌芯屑褍 褨蟹 蟹褍褋褌褉褨褔褨 写胁芯褏 邪斜褋芯谢褞褌薪芯 褉褨蟹薪懈褏 锌褨写谢褨褌泻褨胁: 芯写懈薪, 写芯褋懈褌褜 褋芯褉芯屑'褟蟹谢懈胁懈泄, 褋懈薪 胁褔懈褌械谢褟, 褋褌邪褉邪薪薪懈泄 褋褌褍写械薪褌 褨 写芯褋胁褨写褔械薪懈泄 褔懈褌邪褔; 褨薪褕懈泄 鈥� 褋械谢褟薪褋褜泻邪 写懈褌懈薪邪, 斜褍薪褌褨胁薪懈泄, 褏邪褉懈蟹屑邪褌懈褔薪懈泄 褨 蟹邪谐邪写泻芯胁懈泄, 褍谢褞斜谢械薪械褑褜 写褨胁褔邪褌.
袊褏薪褨泄 锌芯褌褟谐 薪械谐邪泄薪懈泄 褨 薪械写胁芯蟹薪邪褔薪懈泄. 袊褏薪褨 褌邪褦屑薪褨 芯斜褨泄屑懈 胁褨写斜褍胁邪褞褌褜褋褟 蟹 褌褉械锌械褌芯屑, 褋锌芯胁薪械薪懈屑 锌芯褔褍褌褌褟屑 锌褉芯胁懈薪懈 褌邪 蟹邪锌械褉械褔械薪薪褟. 孝邪褦屑薪懈褑褟, 褖芯 褩褏 芯褌芯褔褍褦, 谢懈褕械 锌褨写褋懈谢褞褦 锌褉懈褋褌褉邪褋褌褜. 袗谢械 孝芯屑邪 薪械 蟹写邪褌械薪 胁懈褋谢芯胁懈褌懈 褋胁芯褩 锌芯褔褍褌褌褟 褨 锌褉懈泄薪褟褌懈 褋械斜械 褌邪泻懈屑, 褟泻懈屑 胁褨薪 褦. 袙褨薪 蟹薪懈泻邪褦 蟹 卸懈褌褌褟 芯锌芯胁褨写邪褔邪 褌邪泻 褋邪屑芯 薪械褋锌芯写褨胁邪薪芯, 褟泻 褨 蟹'褟胁懈胁褋褟, 蟹邪谢懈褕邪褞褔懈 褞薪芯屑褍 肖褨谢褨锌锌褍 褉邪薪褍 锌械褉褕芯谐芯 泻芯褏邪薪薪褟, 褟泻邪 薪褨褟泻 薪械 蟹邪谐芯褩褌褜褋褟.
袣芯谢懈 褑褟 褨褋褌芯褉褨褟 蟹邪泻褨薪褔褍褦褌褜褋褟, 褔械褉械蟹 褉芯泻懈, 邪胁褌芯褉 蟹 薪械褋泻褨薪褔械薪薪懈屑 褋褍屑芯屑 写褨蟹薪邪褦褌褜褋褟, 褖芯 孝芯屑邪, 褟泻懈泄 斜褍胁 褌邪泻懈屑 褋胁褨褌谢懈屑 胁 褞薪芯褋褌褨, 胁褋械 卸懈褌褌褟 薪邪屑邪谐邪胁褋褟 蟹邪胁邪写懈褌懈 褋胁芯褩泄 薪邪褌褍褉褨, 锌褉懈褏芯胁邪褌懈 褩褩 胁褨写 褍褋褨褏, 褌懈屑 褋邪屑懈屑 锌褉懈褋泻芯褉褞褞褔懈 褋胁褨泄 褌褉邪谐褨褔薪懈泄 泻褨薪械褑褜...

袙 械锌芯褏褍 薪芯胁懈褏 屑芯卸谢懈胁芯褋褌械泄 锌械褉械写 薪邪褕懈屑懈 芯褔懈屑邪 胁懈屑邪谢褜芯胁褍褞褌褜褋褟 写胁褨 写芯谢褨: 芯写薪褨褦褩 屑芯谢芯写芯褩 谢褞写懈薪懈, 褖芯 褋褌芯褩褌褜 薪邪 屑械卸褨 蟹邪锌械褉械褔械薪薪褟 芯褔械胁懈写薪芯谐芯, 卸懈褌褌褟 褍 斜褉械褏薪褨 泄 褋褌褉邪褏芯胁褨, 褌邪 褨薪褕芯褩, 褟泻邪 褋褌邪薪械 褉芯屑邪薪褨褋褌芯屑 褨 芯锌芯胁褨写邪褔械屑 褨褋褌芯褉褨泄.

袉褋褌芯褉褨褟 褩褏薪褜芯谐芯 泻芯褏邪薪薪褟 鈥� 褑械 褋泻谢邪写薪械 褨 谐芯褋褌褉械 褋锌芯褋褌械褉械卸械薪薪褟, 蟹胁褨谢褜薪械薪械 胁褨写 斜褍写褜-褟泻芯谐芯 屑芯褉邪谢褜薪芯谐芯 芯褋褍写褍, 锌褉芯 褌械, 褟泻 胁邪卸泻芯 斜褍褌懈 褋邪屑懈屑 褋芯斜芯褞 胁 锌械胁薪懈褏 褋芯褑褨邪谢褜薪懈褏 褔懈 褋褨屑械泄薪懈褏 褉邪屑泻邪褏. 袉 褔懈 屑芯卸谢懈胁械 褖邪褋谢懈胁械 卸懈褌褌褟 蟹邪 褑懈屑懈 褉邪屑泻邪屑懈?
效芯屑褍 胁邪褉褌芯 锌褉芯褔懈褌邪褌懈 泻薪懈卸泻褍 芦袩褉懈锌懈薪懈 褋胁芯褩 胁懈谐邪写泻懈禄?
袗胁褌芯斜褨芯谐褉邪褎褨褔薪邪 褨褋褌芯褉褨褟 锌褉芯 锌芯褕褍泻 褨 锌褉懈泄薪褟褌褌褟 胁谢邪褋薪芯褩 褨写械薪褌懈褔薪芯褋褌褨.
袚芯褋褌褉芯褋芯褑褨邪谢褜薪邪 芯锌芯胁褨写褜 锌芯斜褍写芯胁邪薪邪 薪邪 褉械邪谢褜薪褨泄 褨褋褌芯褉褨褩 肖褨谢褨锌锌邪 袘械褋褋芯薪邪.
袪芯屑邪薪 蟹写芯斜褍胁 锌褉械屑褨褞 Maison de la Presse 褨 锌褉械屑褨褞 Psychologies 褍 2017 褉芯褑褨.

208 pages, Paperback

First published January 5, 2017

1918 people are currently reading
130119 people want to read

About the author

Philippe Besson

54books1,158followers
In 1999, Besson, who was a jurist at that time, was inspired to write his first novel, In the Absence of Men, while reading some accounts of ex-servicemen of the First World War. The novel won the Emmanuel-Robl猫s prize.

尝'础谤谤颈猫谤别-蝉补颈蝉辞苍, published in 2002, won the Grand Prix RTL-Lire 2003. Un gar莽on d'Italie was nominated for the Goncourt and the M茅dicis prizes.

Seeing that his works aroused so much interest, Philippe Besson then decided to dedicate himself exclusively to his writing.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
25,714 (46%)
4 stars
20,659 (37%)
3 stars
7,569 (13%)
2 stars
1,362 (2%)
1 star
237 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 10,491 reviews
Profile Image for Larry H.
3,006 reviews29.6k followers
February 20, 2019
"This feeling of love, it transports me, it makes me happy. But it also consumes me and makes me miserable, the way all impossible loves are miserable."

Philippe is a famous writer being interviewed at a hotel in Bordeaux when he sees a handsome man walk by. The man jars Philippe's memory, reminding him of his first love, when he was in his last year of high school in 1984.

Philippe is the studious one, shy yet fiercely intelligent. He has already been marked by his peers as "different"; he bears their shouted and whispered insults, and wants nothing more than to blend in. Thomas is quiet, rarely speaks yet is often spoken to, and is popular among his peers. He is handsome, so he catches the attention of many of the female students.

The two have never spoken, yet Philippe is inexplicably drawn to Thomas. He watches him, observes him, but doesn't think Thomas notices him (or even knows who he is), and Philippe is unsure of how he feels about that fact. Does he want Thomas to know what their peers think of him, the names they've called him?

One day, Thomas approaches Philippe. He fears that Thomas might have seen him staring, might want to beat him up. But instead, Thomas asks if he might want to go to lunch in town instead of eat in the school lunchroom. He agrees, but doesn't understand what Thomas wants from him. During lunch, Thomas tells him he is struggling with his sexuality, and he can no longer fight these feelings in silence.

When Philippe asks why Thomas has chosen him, he replies, "Because you are not like all the others, because I don't see anyone but you and you don't even realize it."

The two quickly fall into a secret relationship鈥攎ostly sexual, although there certainly are overtones of romance. Outside of their encounters, they pretend not to know each other, and make no move to declare their feelings for one another. Inherently, Thomas knows that when high school is done, Philippe will leave their small French town to make his way in the world, leaving Thomas behind. And despite the intensity of their unspoken feelings, both know that this is their trajectory.

Can we ever forget the raw emotions, the intensity, the longing of our first true love? How does that relationship affect the rest of our lives? In Lie with Me , Philippe Besson poignantly captures those feelings, the way every fiber of your being is affected, the way you want nothing more than that person and cannot bear the thought of being apart. And how you mourn the end of that relationship, how it feels like no pain you've ever experienced, so much more than your heart can bear.

Besson and Molly Ringwald, who translated the novel from the French, paint a beautiful, emotional picture of a man who has made something of his life as was always expected, but when he is reminded of his first love, reminisces about that glorious yet painful time, and how indelibly their lives have changed in the years since.

Lie with Me has been called "the French Brokeback Mountain ," and while there are no cowboys, and this book didn't quite make me sob the way that movie did, there is a tremendous amount of poignancy, emotion, and beauty to be had in this story. Ringwald's translation felt flawless to me鈥攓uite often when I read translated novels I find some awkwardness in the syntax or the way some expressions are relayed.

"That singular moment. The pure urgency of it. There were circumstances鈥攁 series of coincidences and simultaneous desire. There was something in the atmosphere, something in the time and place, that brought us together."

What a gorgeous, moving book this was.

NetGalley and Scribner provided me an advance copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased review. Thanks for making this available!

To be published April 30, 2019.

See all of my reviews at .

Check out my list of the best books I read in 2018 at .

You can follow me on Instagram at
Profile Image for s.penkevich.
1,525 reviews13.1k followers
January 24, 2025
鈥�He says: I know a place.鈥�

The heart skips to a new beat, seemingly bursting from your chest as you find yourself suddenly tumbling into love, as if taking a step and not finding ground beneath you. It is a plunge that strikes up an overwhelming orchestration of emotions鈥攆rom the stringed hum of desire to the sharp brass of fear鈥攁nd this profuse pulse of life leaps forth from every page of Philippe Besson鈥檚 Lie With Me. It is an elegiac story of first love, of unquenchable desire, of the agony from remaining hidden, of 鈥�intolerable deprivation,鈥� of the stories we tell to survive and the uncertain horizons of life we follow. Or, perhaps, it is 鈥�the story of two inseparable friends who end up being separated by time鈥� as it moves from the first moments of clandestine queer romance in 1980s France to a chance encounter decades later with a face that seems impossibly familiar. Written with a direct, yet poetic minimalism, translated here into English by Molly Ringwald (Yes, that ), its a simplicity that still conjures up sweeping cinematic visuals in sepia tones and sorrowful songs. 鈥�It's the most simple words that destroy us,鈥� writes Besson, and the words of love and loss cut deep on every page. Blurring the line between fiction and memoir while blurring the vision of readers the world over as it tugs the heartstrings toward tears, Lie With Me is a gorgeous portrait of the heart at its most vulnerable in a world that tends to wrest back control no matter how you try to steer your life.

鈥�In later years, I will often write about the unthinkable, the element of unpredictability that determines outcomes. And game-changing encounters, the unexpected juxtapositions that can shift the course of a life.
It starts there, in the winter of my seventeenth year.
鈥�

While Lie With Me is a slim book and a quick read, it resonates with a emotional impulse far greater than it鈥檚 page or word count. 鈥�I wanted to write a sadness,鈥� Besson while in the same cafe the novel begins. Chasing down what appears to be his former, hidden lover from his teens somehow untouched by time and age, the narattor鈥攚ho is also a writer named Philippe with a back catalog bearing the same titles as Besson, yet the book is purported to be fiction鈥攏ot only chases the figure through the streets but down memory lane. Transporting us back to reflect on 1984 鈥�in a place, in a moment, where nearly everyone goes nowhere鈥欌€攁 town called Barbezieux that is also Besson鈥檚 hometown though we are told it 鈥�does not exist鈥欌€攚e learn of the narrator鈥檚 first brush with love: a boy named Thomas Andrieu from another social class and 鈥�wary of anything tender.鈥� The two teens begin to meet and make love in secret, with Thomas afraid to be seen for 鈥�who he is鈥� in a judgemental society with the growing dread of impermanence to their relationship because 鈥�we come from different worlds,鈥� the narrator admits, 鈥�worlds that have nothing to do with each other鈥� and, as Thomas tells him 鈥�you will leave and we will stay.鈥� It鈥檚 a heartbreak per page of a tale.
鈥�This feeling of love, it transports me, it makes me happy. At the same time, it consumes me and makes me miserable, the way all impossible loves are miserable.鈥�

The fictional narrator that both is and isn鈥檛 the author is a style familiar to many other tales of romantic awakenings under conditions deemed taboo in their current society, such as the breathtaking heartache of a fictionalized Jeanette in Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit by or The Lover from French author . The latter, from which the epigraph to Lie With Me is taken, was a major source of inspiration to the novel, Besson admits:
鈥�When I threw myself into writing Lie with Me, I placed [The Lover] in front of me. I knew I was going to write about my seventeen-year-old self, about what happened the year I turned seventeen, and I have never forgotten that was the year I read The Lover. I understood that I was going to call forth my memories, that I was going to write about the memory of adolescence, like Duras.鈥�

But this blurring of fiction and memoir allows there to be a distance between memory that can be refracted through a lens of fiction to better understand it, much like the way said 鈥�art is a lie that makes us realize truth.鈥� It holds us in tension, always questioning just as much as the narrator questions his own judgements on his memory:
鈥�All the same, I wondered if this could be a complete invention. As you already know, I invented stories all the time, with so much authenticity that people usually ended up believing me sometimes even I was no longer able to disentangle the true from the false). Could I have made this story up from scratch? Could I have turned an erotic obsession into a passion? Yes, it's possible.鈥�

However, by not fully allowing us the accept the novel as total fiction, Besson reminds us too that the hurt is authentic, not only from the central relationship but also all those lost to the AIDS crisis that frequently intrudes upon the narrator鈥檚 memory as well, juxtaposing the deaths of friends with the death of a love affair.

鈥�I discover for the first time鈥攑oor idiot鈥攖his stabbing pain of love.鈥�

There is a social class dynamic that adds another frustrated texture to their relationship, with Thomas feeling trapped by circumstances to forever wallow in their hometown while acknowledging Philippe has the social means to escape.
鈥�All of a sudden I see a sort of admiration return to his face, but it鈥檚 a painful admiration; what he likes about me is also what keeps me separate from him.鈥� There are reflections on circumstance and family鈥斺€�I wonder if its the cold fathers who make the sensitive sons鈥欌€攂ut also how Thomas is trapped unable to admit who he is, and here is where the worst pain begins to brew. They even spar opinions of queer art, where Philippe finds awe in the vulnerability yet Thomas, trapped in the horror of internalized homophobia, only finds disgust. A disgust that extends to himself.

鈥�We鈥檙e left stunted, compromised, by the burden of having to always lie and censor ourselves.鈥�

In 鈥檚 heartwrenching Giovanni鈥檚 Room, the narrator is warned 鈥�not many people have ever died of love. But multitudes have perished, and are perishing every hour - and in the oddest places! - for the lack of it.鈥� The novel examines the destructive force of internalized homophobia and here Besson examines how being forced&Mdash;out of necessity or out of fear鈥攖o remain hidden, to remain closeted, is intolerable agony that only spreads and how painful the playacting can be (I must once again recommend 鈥檚 gorgeously heartbreaking Sunburn for a similar tale).
鈥�This passion that can鈥檛 be talked about, that has to be concealed, gives way to the terrible question: if it isn鈥檛 talked about, how can one know that it really exists?鈥�

It feels like a denial of what he holds most dear, and anyone who has been unable to be open, to be given the space to be proud of their love, to be proud of their lover, to be allowed to hold their own happiness, must suffer the ache as if the love they cherish doesn鈥檛 even exist. To feel the heart start up in full tremors of emotional orchestration and muffle it to the world behind an apathetic or professional face, fracturing inside under the pressure of bottling it in, denying desire, smothering yearning. All because you have to believe it is 鈥渇or the best,鈥� the 鈥渞ight thing,鈥� the 鈥渟afe necessity,鈥� against the hearts own loud wishes. What a cruelty, what a crushing burden where joy and freedom of the heart should reside. And it gnaws at you, distorting everything, clawing away any happiness. It makes him feel empty, like he鈥檚 鈥�reduced to a body, a penis, a function,鈥� unable to be fully realized as a human.

鈥�There is the insanity of not being able to be seen together. An insanity that is aggravated in this case by the unprecedented situation of finding ourselves in the middle of a crowd and having to act like strangers. It seems crazy not to be able to show our happiness.鈥�

There is a real vulnerability here and Besson discusses how it is why he writes, because 鈥�writing is a good means of survival. A way of not forgetting the ones who have disappeared, of continuing a dialogue.鈥� It also becomes a way of being open about emotions, and as much as it is wrestling with the longing, with 鈥�the inaccessible other,鈥� and the 鈥�the sadness that eats away at you, making you crazy,鈥� it is about being able to be open about queer identity. He sees it as the only healthy way forward but holds empathy for those who cannot.
鈥�Those who have not taken this step, who have not come to terms with themselves, are not necessarily frightened, they are perhaps helpless, disoriented, lost as one is in the middle of a forest that鈥檚 too dark or dense or vast.鈥�

Books like this can serve as a way to find the courage to not get lost, to remember there are many, to remember there is happiness beyond the pain of moving into acceptance. Writing, we see, is a way of grappling with this.

It is also how Philippe grapples with understanding Thomas. The novel is about him, in many ways, but can only be about the 鈥渋dea鈥� of him, as he has always been elusive to the narrator. The reader is only able to speculate on the goings on within Thomas鈥� head and heart as much as the narrator and while the latter portion of the book implies what might seem like Philippe having an oversized importance over the entirety of Thomas鈥� life, it also makes sense that the narrator assumes such a solipsism over the narrative. If it鈥檚 a novel, it is fictional afterall鈥攈e frequently reminds the reader of this鈥攁nd it is left to us to decide any 鈥渢ruth鈥� in the fiction. Do we take him at face value? Is it a sense of exorcizing his pain. Is it a way of feeling he has gotten the better deal by moving on while Thomas 鈥�resigned himself鈥� to the 鈥�death of his soul.鈥� Does he even know and is that what he鈥檚 seeking by writing?

It reminds me also why it was clever to craft a fictionalized self as the narrator. It opens a space to give Thomas, and himself, grace. This is not unlike the way the son, Lucas, chooses to refer to his father abruptly jettisoning his family as a 鈥�defection,鈥� a term he sees as 鈥�something dangerous and romantic, a manifestation of insubordination, an irrepressible desire for freedom,鈥� because, even if this is a fictional romanticization, he can imagine 鈥�that his father missed him. And this possibility is absolutely necessary to him.鈥� Is the ending a romanticization, and if so, as long as it allows him to heal, does it make it any less valuable? I really enjoy when authors can effectively pull off this distortion into artistic brilliance.

鈥�I鈥檓 convinced that this image is true.鈥�

It also nudges the title and the multiple meanings of 鈥淟ie.鈥� We can imagine the two teens in 鈥�a boyhood I鈥檓 in the process of annihilating鈥� as they lay together in passion, but also the idea of lying both as an author telling fictional stories (the narrator鈥檚 enjoyment for creating characters at a young age received scoldings from his mother as creating 鈥渓ies鈥�) and the two teens lying about who they are by not being open about their love. It works quite well in the English. In an , translator Molly Ringwald was asked about this choice of title considering the title in French, Arr锚te avec tes mensonges, translates more directly as 鈥�stop with your lies.鈥� She says:
鈥�There were a few different ones being considered. Lie with Me felt like the right one鈥攖he double meaning of embracing someone, the romantic mixed with the duplicity implied by being a writer and inventing stories for a living.鈥�

Besson鈥檚 writing is quite lovely and I was intrigued to learn Molly Ringwald was the translator. Ringwald, of or fame, had made a name for herself also as a teen in the 80鈥檚 grappling with identity so she feels fitting for this project. When asked about her aim in translation, she said she borrows from the theories of :
鈥�Should the translator鈥檚 job be to bring the culture to the reader, or should we be bringing the reader to the culture? I feel like I was intuitively the latter. To strip the world of its foreignness feels to me like visiting a foreign country and staying at your hotel eating cheeseburgers and watching all of the television programs you watch at home. There is no revelation about the differences in culture鈥攐r the similarities, for that matter.鈥�

Ringwald said she tries to retain the 鈥淔renchness鈥� of the work as much as possible. It reads quite well, occasionally a bit clunky but I cannot compare it to the original so I鈥檒l take her word for it. I did feel, however, for a gorgeous as the writing is, sometimes the large, flowing metaphors felt a bit out of place amidst the otherwise minimalist and direct writing. There were a few passages where I wondered if, in keeping with his own words that the simple words often hurt most, the bluntness of a full stop would have registered more powerfully than the flowery metaphor that followed. Still, there are some spectacular lines and moments, from absence as a texture or with a 鈥�thickness like night, an indefinite space with no landmarks鈥� or the way my heart ached when, in the awareness of it being their final moments, Thomas 鈥�smiled so that I could take his smile with me.鈥� Gorgeous.

鈥�Nothing touches me more than cracks in the armor and the person who reveals them.鈥�

Philippe Besson鈥檚 Lie With Me packs a powerful punch in a short space. It delivers the tempest of emotions around the frustrations of love so effortlessly and eloquently and one cannot help but get caught up in its turmoil. A moving story of queer love and the agony of remaining hidden that becomes a tale of painful memories in the long aftermath of absence, this is a story that will stick with me for long to come.

4.5/5

鈥�There was something in the atmosphere, something in the time and the place, that brought us together. And then everything broke 鈥� like a firework exploding on a dark night in July that spirals out in all directions, blazing brightly, dying before it touches the ground, so that no one gets burned. No one gets hurt.鈥�
Profile Image for Nataliya.
937 reviews15.4k followers
February 4, 2022
The stories of young star-crossed lovers have sustained popular literature for centuries, speaking to the heart and pushing all the right buttons. And yet something about this acclaimed story rang false and left me a bit unsatisfied.

You see, it quickly veers into the predictable melodrama, preparing for the gut punch ending from the get-go and yet becoming a bit trite and formulaic. Had it been a movie, it would have had the requisite monochrome soulgazing to tinkly music, complete with wistful voiceover.

This is a story of a doomed love affair between two adolescent boys in the mid-1980s France, one of whom is determined to keep it secret and the other one 鈥� well, he鈥檚 destined to become a writer and don鈥檛 you ever dare forget it (I swear, it feels like the narrator needs to bring up that he is a writer on every other page, ad nauseum, lest we forget). We know from the beginning that the two boys part ways, and the story itself begins as one of them 鈥� the writer 鈥� runs into the son of his erstwhile lover and learns the tragic story of the man who had left him in his youth.

And then he gets his long-awaited closure 鈥� in the written form, no less.

You see, this is the book that ultimately rests on the feeling of closure, on validation, on affirming the great human fallacy 鈥� the desire to matter, to be vindicated, to get the answers we crave for that inner peace. After all, losing a great love of your impressionable youth without as much as a goodbye is hard, it eats at you, it brings up all the what-ifs and may-have-beens.
And so this book becomes that closure that we want, the closure that confirms that - yes - you mattered, that - yes - it was all ultimately revolving around you, that - yes - your choices were true and special and right, that - yes - you weren鈥檛 the only one still reeling from the long-lost love, that - yes - it was all reciprocated and real and validated.

The neat closure to show that the impact from the secret affair reverberated through both men鈥檚 lives, and that the one who cruelly left realized his mistake in not staying true to himself, and that the young love remained in his heart, and that denying your desires leads you to solitude and unhappiness, yadda yadda yadda. It鈥檚 an unsubtle moral lesson without taking into much consideration the societal and family and religious and responsibility pressures that led to Thomas鈥� choices - and all those had plenty of room for subtlety.

And this is a disservice to Thomas鈥� character, reducing him to a road not taken, a character in a conventional melodrama, with a quick tearjerker ending on a letter that admits the ultimate guilt of self-deception, with the intention of making the reader wistfully sigh about the fallacy of such choices in the silent stoic tragedy of Thomas鈥� life 鈥� all that added too many visible marionette strings to the story that otherwise could have been touching in its eternal simplicity, told in a bit of a monotone (author鈥檚 or translator鈥檚 鈥� I don鈥檛 know and can鈥檛 really judge as I don鈥檛 speak French).

It鈥檚 not a bad book 鈥� but it鈥檚 also a book that does not add anything new to the story it tells, resting heavily on the final letter of confession and validation, stating yet again that repressing your nature is unhealthy and rife with consequences 鈥� and unfortunately little else. Had it been just a short story consisting only of the first part 鈥� that of the boys鈥� adolescence 鈥� it would have been stronger and sweeter, more impactful and much less unnecessarily melodramatic.

3 stars. Middle-of-the-pack serviceable story, but ultimately easily forgettable.

鈥斺赌斺赌斺赌斺赌�

Oh, and while I鈥檓 at it, let me get these off my chest:

(1) 鈥淏ack then there were no cell phones, so I had to call him at his house.鈥� Who is this story told to 鈥� future generations? I trust we all know about the lack of cell phones in the mid-80s, without the need for explanation.

(2) 鈥淗is was the first male sex I held in my hand, other than my own.鈥� I don鈥檛 know if that鈥檚 the writer鈥檚 fault or the translator鈥檚 鈥� but does anyone else loathe the 鈥渟ex鈥� euphemism for genitalia? Every time you call a penis 鈥渕ale sex鈥�, a cute fluffy kitten dies a gruesome death somewhere.

(3) 鈥淐arnivorous kisses.鈥� I refer you to the placenta cook book after this expression.

鈥斺赌斺赌斺赌斺赌斺€�
Also posted on .
Profile Image for Paromjit.
3,080 reviews26k followers
August 24, 2019
An unforgettable, exquisite and powerful award winning French novel by Philippe Besson, translated by the famous actress, Molly Ringwald, that reads and feels like the most intimate of memoirs. For such a short novel, it is achingly beautiful, lyrical, and intensely heartbreaking, a portrayal of the emotional, heady feelings of first love. A fragile, forbidden, repressed covert gay relationship set in the 1980s in a rural small town in France. Philippe is having a tough time in high school for being smart and perceived as effeminate, and drawn towards the more popular Thomas Andrieu, a farmer's boy with his future life mapped out in front of him. He has little idea that Thomas feels the same way about him until the two have lunch and embark on a sex driven affair that will haunt and have everlasting repercussions.

Philippe and Thomas are under no illusions, they both know right from the very start that their relationship is temporary and will not endure, but this in itself lends a passion, poignancy and urgency to their love. Years later, in the present, Philippe is a well known writer, who encounters a young man that inescapably reminds him of his first love, Thomas's son, Lucas, from whom he learns of Thomas's life after school and his family. This is a painfully tragic, profoundly moving and eloquently expressed story of hatred, thwarted love, loss, homophobia, regrets, masculinity, memory and class that will stay with you long after you have finished reading the last page. Highly recommended big time! Many thanks to Penguin UK for an ARC.
Profile Image for jay.
972 reviews5,613 followers
April 4, 2024
"Later I will write about this longing, the intolerable deprivation of the other. I will write about the sadness that eats away at you, making you crazy. It will become the template for my books, in spite of myself. I wonder sometimes if I have ever written of anything else. It鈥檚 as if I never recovered from it: the inaccessible other, occupying all my thoughts."

just hit me with a brick next time, it will be less painful than reading the beautiful all-consuming prose Philippe Besson has blessed us with

in other words, if you catch me obsessively rereading this in the months to come: no you didn't. mind your own business.

---

"It was love, of course."

aaaand, i'm crying again.

---

This is my favourite book (second place only to A Little Life ).

Maybe I'll write an actual review next time I read it (and we all know I will read it again, probably soon), but today I will just lie down and think about it in silence.

---

4th read:

cette fois en francais. je dois vous dire que mon francais est vraiment mauvais - je suis desol茅.

L'茅criture originale de Besson est encore plus belle. je ne compris tous mais je l'ai quand m锚me appr茅ci茅. j'ai quand m锚me pleur茅. je ne vais jamais 茅crire un 'review' pour cet livre, je ne peux pas, je pense. je n'ai pas les mots pour expliquer ce que ce livre signifie pour moi. - peut-锚tre la prochaine fois.

"Je voulais juste t'茅crire que j'ai 茅t茅 heureux pendant ces mois que nous avons pass茅s ensemble, que je n'ai jamais 茅t茅 aussi hereux, et que je sais d茅j脿 que je ne serai plus jamais aussi heureux."


[translation (approximately):
this time in french. let me preface by saying that my french is really bad - i'm sorry

Besson's original writing is even more beautiful. i didn't understand everything but i still enjoyed it. and it still made me cry. i will never write a review for this book, i don't think i can. i don't have the words to explain what this book means to me. - maybe next time

"I just wanted to write to tell you that I have been happy during these months together, that I have never been so happy, and that I already know that I will never be so happy again."]

- - -

5th read:

god it鈥檚 so beautifully written, how is it so beautifully written.


(the movie sucks though)
Profile Image for Sahil Javed.
361 reviews303 followers
May 11, 2021
Lie With Me is a tender, beautiful novel, written by French author Philippe Besson and translated by Molly Ringwald, that follows the relationship that develops between two teenage boys in 1984 France.
鈥淭he image doesn鈥檛 fit: my thick glasses, my stretched-out blue Nordic sweater, the student head slaps, the too-good grades, the feminine gestures. Why me?

He says: Because you are not like all the others, because I don鈥檛 see anyone but you and you don鈥檛 even realize it. He adds this phrase, which for me is unforgettable: Because you will leave and we will stay."

There's something about books written retrospectively that just call out to me. There鈥檚 a sense of nostalgia trapped within the narrative, that鈥檚 almost always tinged with a sense of melancholy. Lie With Me was exactly like that. The story opens in 2007, with Philippe, a successful author, being interviewed on the release of his latest book. As the interview progresses, Philippe notices a young man exiting the hotel his interview takes place in, a man that bears a striking resemblance to someone from his past. It鈥檚 then that the story goes back to 20 years earlier, where an 18 year old Philippe develops a secret relationship with another boy in his final year of high school 鈥� Thomas.
鈥淲e drive at high speed along back roads, through woods, vineyards, and oat fields. The bike smells like gasoline and makes a lot of noise, and sometimes I鈥檓 frightened when the wheels slip on the gravel on the dirt road, but the only thing that matters is that I鈥檓 holding on to him, that I鈥檓 holding on to him outside.鈥�

The story that's told in this book isn鈥檛 that long. The actual novel is only 150 pages, but it packs such a powerful and emotional punch. The narrator, Philippe, felt so familiar to me that at times it felt like I was reading about myself because I saw so many aspects of my personality in his character. This meant that I related to him massively, which also meant that I knew I was going to love this book from the start. As the story explores Thomas and Philippe鈥檚 relationship, you already know that it doesn鈥檛 end well because that鈥檚 the sense you get when a story is told retrospectively. Like, these events have already happened but yet you still want the characters to have a happy ending and in this case, I desperately wanted Thomas and Philippe to be together. But what makes this novel incredible is that so many important themes are explored such as identity, and life in a small town, the differences between people and how sometimes those differences can change the trajectory of your life, the bravery it takes to proudly be yourself, and how sometimes it鈥檚 really difficult to summon that bravery when you鈥檝e been repressing your identity for so long.
鈥淗e says I鈥檓 a boy of books, from somewhere else. This is important: he sees me in a certain way, a way he will never deviate from. In the end, love was only possible because he saw me not as who I was, but as the person I would become.鈥�

This book made me cry ugly tears, because Philippe Besson really takes you on a journey. Now, I don鈥檛 know just how much of this book is fiction and how much may have been taken from the author鈥檚 own personal life, because the novel itself is dedicated to 鈥楾homas Andrieu鈥� and the main character is also called Philippe. But I don鈥檛 think that鈥檚 important. What鈥檚 important is the journey the characters go on, the relationship that develops between them, and what this relationship tells each of the characters about themselves. But, most importantly, the reason I loved this novel so much is because of what it told me about myself. I felt like I took away so much from this book. It made me cry so much, but it also touched me in a way where I鈥檓 still thinking about it now, weeks after I鈥檝e read it.
鈥淓verything is in its place, everything reassures me. Except that I miss Thomas. I miss him terribly. And that changes everything. Have you noticed how the most beautiful landscapes lose their brilliance as soon as our thoughts prevent us from seeing them properly?鈥�

The writing in this book was absolutely beautiful and poetic, so much so that I can鈥檛 even begin to imagine just how beautiful this novel must be in French, as that鈥檚 how it was first written. Like I said previously, I鈥檓 really drawn to books that are written retrospectively, where characters reflect on their lives and the circumstances that have lead them to where they are when we meet them in the novel. And the author perfectly weaves that sense of nostalgia within his own writing, and it鈥檚 so vivid that I can feel like radiating off the words and enveloping me as I read it. This book is only 150 pages, but each of the words that have been used felt so deliberate and precise. How is it that a book can be so small yet touch you in the biggest ways?
鈥淭his feeling of love, it transports me, it makes me happy. At the same time, it consumes me and makes me miserable, the way all impossible loves are miserable.鈥�

Overall, Lie With Me was a delicately beautiful book about identity and love, but the kind of love that attaches itself to your soul and stays with you, that made me cry but also filled me with a tender appreciation for life. If Philippe Besson is capable of destroying me with a 150 page book, I鈥檓 a little scared to read anything else by him. I hope his other books are translated or I might just have to learn French and read them all. It鈥檚 the least I could do to have the chance to experience something this beautiful again.
鈥淚 know you would have liked for things to be different, for me to say the words that would have reassured you, but I could not, and I never knew how to talk anyway. In the end, I tell myself that you understood. It was love, of course. And tomorrow, there will be a great emptiness. But we could not continue 鈥� you have your life waiting for you, and I will never change. I just wanted to write to tell you that I have been happy during these months together, that I have never been so happy, and that I already know I will never be so happy again.鈥�

There were so many more quotes that I adored that I wanted to include in my review so I鈥檝e left them here:
鈥淚鈥檓 seventeen years old. I don鈥檛 know then that one day I won鈥檛 be seventeen. I don鈥檛 know that youth doesn't last, that it鈥檚 only a moment, and then it disappears and by the time you finally realize it, it鈥檚 too late. It鈥檚 finished, vanished, lost.鈥�

鈥淚 think I love him for this loneliness, that it鈥檚 what pushed me toward him. I love his aloofness, his disengagement with the outside world. Such singularity moves me.鈥�

鈥淚 discover that absence has a consistency, like the dark water of a river, like oil, some kind of sticky dirty liquid that you can struggle and perhaps drown in. It has a thickness like night, an indefinite space with no landmarks, nothing to bang against, where you search for a light, some small glimmer, something to hang on to and guide you. But absence is, first and foremost, silence. A vast, enveloping silence that weighs you down and puts you in a state where any unforeseeable, unidentifiable sound can make you jump.鈥�

鈥淭here is the insanity of not being able to be seen together. An insanity that is aggravated in this case by the unprecedented situation of finding ourselves in the middle of a crowd and having to act like strangers. It seems crazy not to be able to show our happiness. Such an impoverished word. Others have this right, and they exercise it freely. Sharing their happiness makes them even more happy, makes them expand with joy. But we鈥檙e left stunted, compromised, by the burden of having to always lie and censor ourselves.鈥�

鈥淎nd when you鈥檝e been hurt once, you鈥檙e afraid to try again later, in dread of enduring the same pain. You avoid getting hurt in an attempt to avoid suffering.鈥�

鈥淚 had time to think all the way home about how affairs of the body are so much more preferable to affairs of the heart, but that sometimes you don鈥檛 have the choice.鈥�

鈥淵ou can never really let go of your childhood. Especially when it was happy.鈥�

鈥淎bove all, we will no longer find the thing that first pushed us toward one another that day. That singular moment. The pure urgency of it. There were circumstances 鈥� a series of coincidences and simultaneous desire. There was something in the atmosphere, something in the time and the place, that brought us together. And then everything broke 鈥� like a firework exploding on a dark night in July that spirals out in all directions, blazing brightly, dying before it touches the ground, so that no one gets burned. No one gets hurt.鈥�
Profile Image for Kenny.
575 reviews1,421 followers
January 6, 2025
We drive at high speed along back roads, through woods, vineyards, and oat fields. The bike smells like gasoline and makes a lot of noise, and sometimes I鈥檓 frightened when the wheels slip on the gravel on the dirt road, but the only thing that matters is that I鈥檓 holding on to him, that I鈥檓 holding on to him outside.
~~~


1

In memory of Thomas Andrieu (1966-2016)

's is a beautifully, delicate story that traces Besson's first love. The initial part of the story takes place at Barbezieux High School, a small town north of Bordeaux. Thomas Andrieu and maintain a sensual, passionate but totally secretive relationship. Thirty years later, long after the relationship has ended, Philippe crosses paths with the son of Thomas ...

With , Besson lays bare his life as never before, according to him, describing the story of an overwhelming and impossible love that will leave an indelible trace on his life. It is the most honest Besson has ever been in his writing. Besson has come up with something more inventive, and more incredible than any of his fictional writings. He has never dared to create something so honest in the past. This is Besson's most Proustian work to date, a writer he has been heavily influenced by. And yet ...

1

begins in 2007, when the Besson sees a man he thinks is 鈥� but can鈥檛 be 鈥� Thomas Andrieu, a classmate and his first love in 1984. This meeting prompts Philippe to think back on his doomed relationship with Thomas.

The two young men were quite different from one another. Philippe was bookish, a teacher鈥檚 son who was slightly alienated from his classmates in rural Barbezieux, for being so smart and slightly effeminate. Thomas is the shaggy-haired, dark-eyed son of a farmer whose path has been laid out for him from the day he was born. Besson describes Thomas to C. Thomas Howell.

The teens are secretly infatuated with each other, though Philippe thinks it鈥檚 a one sided desire. He鈥檚 shocked when Thomas invites him to lunch. They meet far from town so their meeting won鈥檛 be discovered. Soon these two sneak off together and engage in sex for the first time.

Besson's openness in describing their affair sucks his readers into this world; so intimate are the descriptions that the feels he is in the room with the two of them during their encounters. The sex is often rough, clumsy and very tender, quick, rough and tender sex. During those encounters, Thomas has made a lasting impression on Philippe, one that still haunts him all these years later.

The last third of returns to 2007, when Philippe engages the man who reminds him of Thomas. It is Thomas鈥� son, Lucas ~~ and so begins an exchange that divulges the impact of the teenagers鈥� love decades later. To tell you more than this would spoil the story.

1

My two complaints concerning have to do with the translator. Much has been made of Molly Ringwald translating this book. She does a fine job. However, many reviewers and journalists act as though this book would not exist without Ringwald's being part of this project. She did not write , but you'd never know that from the press surrounding the book. They use Ringwald as the selling point for the book. My other complaint has to do with the title. In French, the title is Stop With Your Lies. Changing the title to eroticizes it and gives a double meaning. But I must admit, punning English title is much more inviting.

So is an autobiography of sorts, a memoir, or is it even true at all? Besson himself writes that he "invented stories all the time, with so much authenticity that people usually ended up believing me (sometimes even I was no longer able to disentangle the true from the false). Could I have made this story up from scratch? Could I have turned an erotic obsession into a passion? Yes, it鈥檚 possible." But this is Bensson's story so may tell it however he likes.

In the end, is a beautifully written book about loss, first love, and the pain and shame of hiding ones true self.

1
Profile Image for dd.
474 reviews316 followers
June 23, 2022
鉁� 鈫� 5 stars

i feel literally empty馃ゲ
but i am genuinely at a loss for how to review a book such as this one. these sad, beautifully written types of books are often my favorite to read, if only to make myself feel something and to try in vain to remember all of the beautiful quotes that i will forget hours later.

to begin with, i will say that although i greatly appreciated this book for everything that it was: beautiful writing, a tragic love affair, and as the blurb on the back states, the heartbreaking passage of time, i think i had put this book on too high of a pedestal before reading it, due to the fact that seeing it and reading the back and maybe the last sentence too oops i could already tell that it was going to be one of those books that would make me think and make me feel and leave an imprint on my soul in a way that many other books do not. it may also have had something to do with the length of the book and that in the time it took for proper characterization to happen, i was already at the stage where i wanted to feel something from all of the gorgeous quotes being thrown my way about a love affair i had yet to wholly see for myself. i think that when i reread this book, (and that鈥檚 a when, not if), i will be able to feel more deeply about it having already been through the story once with the characters and being able to take into context what i know from having read the book before. however, taking into consideration the author鈥檚 awareness of the length of the book and the amount of pages it would have to take to adequately enthrall the reader into feeling such emotion, i think that it is incredibly impressive the amount of sheer emotion this book evokes in the reader in such a short amount of pages.

although, i ask myself, truly, does this little argument with myself matter? would i rate the book any differently if i decided, for example, that the book should鈥檝e evoked more emotion in me that it did? i am fairly sure that the answer is no, as what i take into consideration maybe the most out of everything while reading books (other than how it makes me feel, obviously) is the writing. the writing was so beautiful to me that regardless, i think i would鈥檝e given it an extremely high rating just for that, as ive done so before with other books; poetry, for example.

i won鈥檛 go into the details of the 鈥榩lot鈥� of this book, if you can even call it that, because it feels so much like real life. i think you can probably figure it out by reading the blurb or even just going to it鈥檚 goodreads page. i will tell you that throughout the book, the narrator recounts the story with a kind of melancholic yearning that leaves you anticipating what heartbreaking thing will happen that has left such an impact on the narrator. you could even tell from the sad, nostalgic feeling portrayed by the cover of the book that it won鈥檛 be uplifting in any sense and will most likely be a story of lost love.

while i was expecting, in general, while putting this book on such a high pedestal i thought maybe i would be comparing it to all my favorite books wondering if it would be better, for this book to make me feel that sharp pain that would make me sob as the final page closed, it was more of an emptiness that i felt at finishing the story, hence the first line of this review.

the characterization, in my opinion, of the main character was very well done. i could feel his yearning and infatuation towards thomas nearly the whole time, although i felt at some times he was almost unreliable in the sense that he would claim to be 鈥渙ver鈥� thomas or do something that he claimed he didn鈥檛 do although it was painfully obvious to the reader that he did, in fact, do it for that reason. he himself as an older person looking back on his youth would even correct himself at times. it was probably the fact that the book is entirely from his perspective, but he felt like the character i got to know the best and more than many other protagonists in stories. in some ways i greatly related to the main character too, which left me feeling seen.

additionally, i thought it was exceptional how hard it was for both the reader and the main character to gauge thomas鈥檚 real feelings towards the whole situation, until the end, when it was slowly revealed to us and felt like a gut punch. it realistically portrayed how hard it is to know why someone says things and does things if they are not you.

i did, however, have a slight problem with the characterization of thomas during the last chapters of the book. i felt as though instead of exploring his character further, he was used as a plot device to show that he was a hopeless example of somebody who didn鈥檛 do what they needed to do for themself and let society trap them into a life that they ultimately couldn鈥檛 withstand. i let it slide because i thought that it wasn鈥檛 unrealistic for that to happen to thomas; it didn鈥檛 seem out of character in any way and he seemed to know himself in the beginning of the story how he would end up. i just thought that it dehumanized him a bit at the end, as we never truly got to see his perspective on anything and how his thoughts and his emotions could鈥檝e led to further events, instead of just how people around him saw him and the hopeless despair he ultimately succumbed to.

this book was a true, raw depiction of youthful loving and yearning, and the mark that it leaves on people after the fact. it is about regret and human nature and sexuality and love. i genuinely love books like these.
Profile Image for Judith.
724 reviews2,913 followers
July 15, 2019
This passion that can鈥檛 be talked about, that has to be concealed, gives way to the terrible question: if it isn鈥檛 talked about, how can one know that it really exists? One day, when it鈥檚 over, when it finally comes to an end, no one will be able to attest to what took place.










Is this a memoir or just fiction? Surely it's a memoir and if it is it makes this even more of a compelling read.I was a mess after I finished this.It was always going to be obvious the outcome for Thomas and Philippe wouldn't be the one the reader wanted and that wasn't really the reason I was a mess.It was more about the world we live in where as recently as the 1980's people still have to hide their sexuality and as a result never get to live their lives the way they want to.





Starting in 1984 and finishing in 2017 this one touched me deeply.Two young boys who became lovers for a summer but were never destined to be much more.




I did struggle,initially with the lack of dialogue but the more I read the more I didn't mind although as a result the book had a very melancholy feel to it.The joy and anguish of that first love told in the most beautiful words here.





The majority of the book centres around Thomas and Philippe's youth.How they got together and their subsequent relationship.My heart ached for these boys.Their story was so touching and yet so sad.How many people meet and fall in love and never really stand a chance?





The later part is when Philippe meets Thomas's son by chance one day and finally finds out a little of Thomas's life after the summer of 1984.I say a little of Thomas's life because although his story is told there's so much you don't know in a way.




It's not romance but it definitely was a love story....



Review copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley
Profile Image for persephone 鈽�.
607 reviews3,496 followers
June 4, 2022
i feel like my heart has been run over by a truck
i've been crying non-stop since i started this book and my mental health isn't good enough for me to handle the type of emotional distress that this book delivers :)
Profile Image for Shile (Hazard's Version) on-hiatus.
1,120 reviews1,026 followers
July 7, 2019
5 stars Audiobook

4 stars for the story

-This is the story of Philippe and Thomas, two boys who fall in love while attending high school in France in the 80s.

-In a way it is a memoir, the author denies it. 馃槀馃槉 But i know it is.

-The writing is lyrical and amazing. The author made me feel the way he was feeling.

-Thomas, Thomas, Thomas... Gaaaaah!

It is worth reading.



Profile Image for Lilyya 鈾�.
556 reviews3,480 followers
June 1, 2024
4,5猸愶笍
芦听L'茅criture peut 锚tre un bon moyen pour survivre. Et pour ne pas oublier les disparus. Pour continuer le dialogue avec eux. Mais le manque prend probablement sa source dans cette premi猫re d茅fection, dans une imb茅cile br没lure amoureuse听禄


Ce qui rend une lecture m茅morable, percutante et poignante est le sentiment qui succ猫de les derniers mots qui la cl么turent. Je ne m鈥檃ttendais certainement pas 脿 ressentir tant de sentiments tous aussi contradictoires que vifs pour des personnages qui n鈥檃uront jamais droit 脿 une second chance. C鈥檈st avec un c艙ur un peu plus ab卯m茅, saignant pour un amour perdu, des destins fig茅s et des amants d茅chus que j鈥檈ssaye de formuler tout cela.

芦听脡videmment, je "pr茅f猫re les gar莽ons".
Mais je ne suis pas encore capable de prononcer cette phrase听禄


On suivra le 谤茅肠颈迟 de Philippe d茅taillant trois 茅tapes marquantes de sa vie.
Comment lui et Thomas, deux adolescents essayant de s鈥檃ccepter dans une soci茅t茅 qui pointe du doigt sans cesse ceux qui ne corespondent pas au moule pr茅d茅fini. Alors une question se pose : Comment un jeune homme peut-il 茅pouser sa "diff茅rence" quand cette derni猫re est inlassablement r茅fut茅e par le monde qui l鈥檈ntoure ?

芦听il me regarde d'une certaine mani猫re et n'en d茅viera pas. En fin de compte, l'amour n'a 茅t茅 possible que parce qu'il m'a vu non pas tel que j'茅tais, mais tel que j'allais devenir.听禄


Deux r茅ponses s鈥檕ffrent 脿 nous au fil de l鈥檋istoire; en premier nous avons Philippe de ceux qui embrassent pleinement leur homosexualit茅 afin de mener une vie satisfaisante malgr茅 un chagrin d鈥檃mour de jeunesse jamais estomp茅.

芦听Il dit听: parce tu n'es pas du tout comme les autres, parce qu'on ne voit que toi sans que tu t'en rendes compte.
Il ajoute cette phrase, pour moi inoubliable听: parce que tu partiras et que nous resterons.听禄


Et dans l鈥檃utre camp nous retrouvons Thomas de ceux qui se mentent impun茅ment comme pour se punir dans une existence qu鈥檌ls ne d茅sireront jamais, s茅questr茅s dans une vie qui finira par les suffoquer t么t ou tard.

Peu importe leur chemin ou leur choix de vie, ils n鈥檃uront jamais un "ils v茅curent heureux" peut-锚tre qu鈥檌ls sont n茅s 脿 la mauvaise 茅poque ou dans le mauvais monde..

芦听Je voulais juste t'茅crire que j'ai 茅t茅 heureux pendant ces mois que nous avons pass茅s ensemble, que je n'ai jamais 茅t茅 aussi heureux, et que je sais d茅j脿 que je ne serai plus jamais aussi heureux听禄


Ce dernier passage me hantera tr猫s certainement pour un tr猫s long moment.馃挃


鈥⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌⑩赌斺赌斺赌斺赌�
Cuz lila is a bad influence.
Et que 莽a compl猫te un livre sur deux de mes lectures obligatoires que je me suis inflig茅e en fran莽ais du mois馃槍
Profile Image for 鈽� Todd.
1,416 reviews1,575 followers
July 28, 2019

A beautifully EXHAUSTING story.
"This feeling of love, it transports me, it makes me happy. But it also consumes me and makes me miserable, the way all impossible loves are miserable."
That quote was extremely telling as to the overall tone of the book.

As told, I felt only infatuation from Philippe, and pretty cold indifference from Thomas, so I wouldn't really call this "my type" of romance.

Also, I found neither of the MC's very likeable. Philippe came off as pompous and jaded, while Thomas was generally as affectionate as a pet rock, fresh from the freezer.

We did get somewhat of a bit of closure at the very end, but depressing, depressing, deeeeee-goddamn-pressing.
The first part of that admission truly shocked me, while the second part, the sheer resignation of it, at only 18 years old no less, didn't even make me blink.

The one bright spot in the story was young Lucas, but by the end, even his initial seemingly-happy existence had been decimated.

The writing was without a doubt very good, but Christ, getting through all of the constant descriptions, with very, VERY little actual dialogue (or hope), reading this book felt like trying to swim through peanut butter.

So if you're a fan of doomed romances, without a hint of an HEA, or even more than a brief glimpse of true happiness (from *either* MC everdy-ever), then this may be the book for you.

2.5 *would-more-'happy'-have-freaking-killed-you* stars for my overall enjoyment of the story and MC's.
Profile Image for David.
869 reviews172 followers
November 11, 2023
My third reading comes directly after seeing the recent well-done/well-matched movie "Lie With Me". The book is beautiful as you hear our narrator's inner voice with all its doubts and concerns. While the book has three distinct chapters (1984, 2007, 2016), the movie smoothly combines all of this going back and forth between past and present with perfect timing. There are some details that didn't make the final movie cut, but no impact was lost. The movie worked its own magic as it flipped between 1984 and 2016.

The four main characters are cast flawlessly in the movie (narrator St茅phane past/present, Thomas, and Thomas' son Lucas). I like the expanded role of Lucas in the movie and the capability of the actor (Victor Belmondo).

I see in Wiki that there is even a play that has been performed in Paris to this book.
I'm in the USA and don't see this streaming yet, but easy to order from Peccadillo pix. Couldn't resist.

Just as you need to be careful where you are reading this book (per your emotions showing), so too for this movie.

I expanded my liked quotes vastly with this reading. :)

---------
Previous/original reviews:
For as much as I like to keep reading a novel that captures me, you can hear where this story is going - constantly. Each major character enters happily. My heart eventually hurt for everyone. All because:

"Those who have not taken this step, who have not come to terms with themselves, are not necessarily frightened, they are perhaps helpless, disoriented, lost as one is in the middle of a forest that's too dark or dense or vast."

I quickly got half-way or more through this book, then uncharacteristically slowed myself down. You just know/suspect and just don't want to hear it. I posted a status about "not wanting this book to end" - how foreboding.

I will have to do a quick re-read before I return this library book.

I've seen enough foreign movies to understand, and even like, an ending that might not be happy, since the entire tone/point of the story would be destroyed if the ending were changed.
The ending of this book must remain. It will make me remember.
If only we could say these attitudes are old/out-dated.

Reading this a 2nd time. Emotions have me in tears early.
Looking through the GR Quote section for Philippe Besson and this book, you'll see multi-paragraphs quoted in a single quote. Really necessary to capture the lean dialogue's depth.
Profile Image for benedicta.
423 reviews680 followers
August 25, 2024
No matter how much you want to respect someone鈥檚 freedom (even when you consider it selfish), you still have your own pain, anger, and melancholy to contend with.

I hate how everyone was sad the whole way through the book and summers were slow and it was too hot for words, so obviously 5 stars 猸� 馃し馃徑鈥嶁檧锔�

The book opens with a secret, intensely passionate love affair between main character, Phillipe and his high school classmate, Thomas in 1984 France.

It's all amourousness of a heated summer fling for these seventeen year olds from two different worlds in terms of family status and living in a time a high influence of the Catholic church.

When they turn eighteen, Thomas visits his family in Spain. Twenty-three years later, Phillipe is a popular man of stories and an acclaimed writer but still holds a flame for his first love. One day outside a hotel in Bordeaux, Phillipe runs into a young man who bears a striking resemblance to his first love. What follows is a recollection of fond memories with a beautiful boy named Thomas during their last year of high school and the deep sadness of not realizing that it was to one of their last moments 鉂わ笍
Profile Image for Henk.
1,111 reviews157 followers
January 9, 2025
A tender love story on the cost of hiding oneself and the power class differences still holds on opportunities and life
What he likes about me is also what keeps me separate from him.

With a different, less distant narrator this book could have been even more powerful. Also: after I am a bit numb to emotional stories this month, but is a well written book on teenage love and the impact this has on two very different boys and their lives.

The writer narrator (also called Philippe like author ) is triggered to recall his youth and his relationship with Thomas. Growing up in a rural village in the 1980s he is called out not just for being feminine and near-sighted but also for being the son of the principal and smarter than most of his fellow classmates.
To allow it to be said is to confirm it is something he thinks about call outs about his sexuality. But exactly this reputation is what attracts taciturn Thomas to him.

The distance between both boys, despite some quick escalation in physical intimacy (it goes fast, from hi, sex, to bye), is large:
Because you will leave and we will stay Thomas tells Philippe, referring to the different paths in life he foresees for the both of them. Philippe also reflects on himself, and how his identity is defined in part by how he differs from his fellow classmates:
I go back to what I was, the boy who intrigues, not the boy who satisfies.

In contrast to the half Spanish farmer son Thomas, Philippe has all kinds of hope and expectations projected upon him, with and older mathematician brother looming large above the trajectory his life should have. AIDS picking up is also something prominently at the horizon.
This distance doesn't help in progressing the understanding between Thomas and Philippe: Our relationship was founded on this absence of obligation
However this is a lie in multiple senses.
The conclusion of the book is heartrending:
鈥nd that I already know, I will never be so happy again.

Quotes:
Or otherwise she confuses youth with happiness, as people often do

You get used to everything, even the defection of those that you thought you were bound to forever

I think, in the end he remained hidden all his life
Profile Image for Emily B.
490 reviews518 followers
December 11, 2020
This is a memorable read for me. I found it touching, beautiful, and pure. There is beauty in it鈥檚 simplicity of one person recalling a time in their life, or in this case, a relationship in their life in an honest and unobstructed way without too many other narratives or characters to distract.

I believed every word and felt everything the narrator felt, which shows how beautifully written it is.
Profile Image for Nhi Nguy峄卬.
1,000 reviews1,370 followers
January 14, 2022
Update 2: Ui tr峄漣 啤i b峄� phim d峄眓g t峄� t谩c ph岷﹎ n脿y 膽茫 quay xong v脿 膽ang v脿o giai 膽o岷 h岷璾 k峄� r霉i nghen m峄峣 ng瓢峄漣 啤i!!! H贸ng d峄� s峄� lu么n 谩 :)))

Update 1: 脭i sau bao nhi锚u th峄漣 gian 膽峄 ch峄� d脿i c峄� th么ng tin v峄� b峄� phim d峄眓g t峄� cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 n脿y, cu峄慽 c霉ng c农ng 膽茫 c贸 update v峄� ti岷縩 膽峄� l脿m phim r峄搃. Ph岷 casting ch峄峮 di峄卬 vi锚n 膽茫 xong h矛nh nh瓢 l脿 t峄� cu峄慽 n膬m tr瓢峄沜, m霉a xu芒n n脿y ch煤ng ta s岷� bi岷縯 膽瓢峄 d脿n cast g峄搈 nh峄痭g ai. M霉a h猫 n脿y phim s岷� b岷痶 膽岷 b岷 m谩y t岷 v霉ng Cognac - n啤i l脿m r瓢峄 cognac n峄昳 ti岷縩g c峄 Ph谩p ^^ N岷縰 v岷瓂 th矛 d峄� l脿 s峄沵 l岷痬 c农ng ph岷 t峄沬 cu峄慽 n膬m nay m峄沬 膽瓢峄 xem phim, ho岷穋 s岷� l脿 n膬m sau... Th么i r谩ng ch峄�, v矛 m峄檛 ng脿y mai 膽瓢峄 xem 鈥淎rr锚te avec tes mensonges鈥� he he he

鈥溎愥猾ng t峄� d峄慽 m矛nh鈥� (t峄盿 g峄慶 ti岷縩g Ph谩p: 鈥淎rr锚te avec tes mensonges鈥�, d峄媍h ra 膽煤ng t峄玭g t峄� t峄玭g ch峄� trong ti岷縩g Anh l脿 鈥淪top with your lies鈥�) l脿 cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 mang m脿u s岷痗 h峄搃 k媒 c峄 nh脿 v膬n ng瓢峄漣 Ph谩p Philippe Besson. Cu峄憂 s谩ch l脿 c芒u chuy峄噉 c峄 t谩c gi岷� v峄� th峄漣 tu峄昳 tr岷� n峄搉g nhi峄噒 c峄 m矛nh, khi 么ng 膽茫 g岷穚 v脿 y锚u m峄檛 c岷璾 b岷 h峄峜 c霉ng tr瓢峄漬g nh瓢ng kh谩c l峄沺. K峄� t峄� sau , 膽芒y c贸 l岷� l脿 cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 v峄� 膽峄� t脿i t矛nh y锚u 膽峄搉g t铆nh nam hay nh岷, 岷 t瓢峄g nh岷, s芒u s岷痗 nh岷 m脿 t么i t峄玭g 膽峄峜. 鈥溎愥猾ng t峄� d峄慽 m矛nh鈥� kh么ng d脿i, b岷 d峄媍h ti岷縩g Vi峄噒 c农ng ch峄� c贸 v峄弉 v岷筺 ch峄玭g 200 trang s谩ch, nh瓢ng v峄沬 ch峄玭g 膽贸 dung l瓢峄g v脿 ch峄玭g 膽贸 t峄� ng峄�, Philippe Besson 膽茫 d峄噒 n锚n c岷� m峄檛 kho岷g v霉ng tr峄漣 k媒 峄ヽ v峄玜 h岷h ph煤c v峄玜 bu峄搉 膽au c峄 m峄檛 ch脿ng trai 膽峄搉g t铆nh, m峄檛 ch脿ng trai 膽茫 y锚u say 膽岷痬 v脿 膽茫 tr岷 qua n峄梚 ti岷縞 nu峄慽 c峄 s峄� chia ly.

膼贸 l脿 v脿o n膬m 1984, t谩c gi岷� l煤c b岷 gi峄� 17 tu峄昳 (kho岷g th峄漣 gian v脿 膽峄� tu峄昳 c峄 nh芒n v岷璽 ch铆nh khi c芒u chuy峄噉 di峄卬 ra gi峄憂g v峄沬 鈥淐all me by your name鈥� nh峄�? C农ng gi峄痑 nh峄痭g n膬m 80 c峄 th岷� k峄� 20, c农ng tu峄昳 17 c霉ng s峄� nh岷璶 th峄ヽ 膽岷 膽峄� v峄� gi峄沬 t铆nh th岷璽 c峄 m矛nh鈥�). Philippe Besson v么 t矛nh b岷痶 g岷穚 c岷璾 b岷 Thomas Andrieu tr锚n s芒n tr瓢峄漬g, ng瓢峄漣 l煤c b岷 gi峄� 膽ang 膽峄﹏g gi峄痑 膽谩m b岷 c峄 m矛nh, d瓢峄漬g nh瓢 kh么ng h峄� ch煤 媒 膽岷縩 nh峄痭g g矛 b岷 b猫 m矛nh tr貌 chuy峄噉. B岷眓g nh峄痭g mi锚u t岷� t峄� m峄�, tinh t岷� 膽煤ng ch岷 v膬n ch瓢啤ng Ph谩p, t谩c gi岷� 膽茫 d峄眓g n锚n h矛nh dung c峄 m峄檛 Thomas Andrieu d瓢峄漬g nh瓢 sinh ra l脿 膽峄� y锚u Philippe Besson, m峄檛 Thomas 铆t n贸i, s峄憂g kh茅p k铆n, lu么n c么 膽啤n, 铆t giao thi峄噋 v脿 gh茅t 膽岷縩 nh峄痭g n啤i 膽么ng 膽煤c, 峄搉 脿o.

V脿 nh瓢 th峄� ti岷縩g s茅t 谩i t矛nh gi谩ng xu峄憂g, t谩c gi岷� 膽茫 y锚u c岷璾 b岷 m矛nh ngay t峄� c谩i nh矛n 膽岷 ti锚n. Nh瓢ng c贸 l岷� l煤c 膽贸 Philippe v岷玭 ch瓢a bi岷縯 膽贸 l脿 t矛nh y锚u. Ngay c岷� Thomas c农ng v岷瓂, khi ch脿ng trai m峄漣 t谩c gi岷� 膽岷縩 qu谩n c脿 ph锚, khi hai ng瓢峄漣 b岷痶 膽岷 cu峄檆 t矛nh c峄 m矛nh, m峄檛 m峄慽 t矛nh n峄搉g nhi峄噒, b铆 m岷璽, gi岷 gi岷縨 nh瓢ng l岷 ch岷 膽岷縩 m峄檛 m峄ヽ 膽峄� th芒n m岷璽 m脿 cho d霉 s峄憂g 膽岷縩 bao l芒u, c岷� hai c农ng s岷� ch岷硁g bao gi峄� c贸 th峄� tr岷 nghi峄噈 l岷. Philippe Besson 膽茫 bi岷縯 m矛nh l脿 ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh t峄� khi 么ng ch峄� m峄沬 12 tu峄昳, khi 么ng l脿m t矛nh l岷 膽岷 ti锚n v峄沬 m峄檛 ch脿ng trai g岷 nh脿. Nh瓢ng c贸 l岷� 膽岷縩 t岷璶 khi g岷穚 Thomas Andrieu, 么ng m峄沬 th峄眂 s峄� bi岷縯 y锚u m峄檛 ng瓢峄漣 c霉ng gi峄沬 t铆nh v峄沬 m矛nh l脿 ra sao, m峄沬 th峄眂 s峄� bi岷縯 膽瓢峄 gi峄痑 hai con ng瓢峄漣 l岷 c贸 th峄� t峄搉 t岷 m峄檛 s峄� g岷痭 k岷縯 v峄玜 tr脿n 膽岷 ham mu峄憂, v峄玜 th岷 t岷璶 t芒m h峄搉 nh瓢 v岷瓂.

M峄慽 t矛nh c峄 h峄� h矛nh th脿nh gi峄痑 m峄檛 x茫 h峄檌, m峄檛 th峄漣 k峄� m脿 c谩i nh矛n d脿nh cho ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh v岷玭 c貌n 膽岷 s峄� k峄� th峄� v脿 x煤c ph岷, gi峄痑 m峄檛 ng么i l脿ng thu峄檆 d岷g 鈥渧霉ng s芒u v霉ng xa鈥� c峄 n瓢峄沜 Ph谩p, n啤i ng瓢峄漣 d芒n v岷玭 c貌n mang t瓢 t瓢峄焠g r岷 c峄� h峄� v峄� t矛nh y锚u 膽峄搉g gi峄沬. T谩c gi岷� y锚u c岷璾 b岷 c峄 m矛nh m脿 kh么ng 膽瓢峄 c么ng khai t矛nh y锚u 岷, kh么ng 膽瓢峄 膽峄� h峄� b峄� b岷痶 g岷穚 膽i c霉ng nhau, 峄� ri锚ng c霉ng nhau. Philippe Besson y锚u Thomas Andrieu qua nh峄痭g bu峄昳 h岷筺 h貌 l茅n l煤t, gi岷 cha gi岷 m岷�, gi岷 th岷 c么, trong n峄梚 s峄� b峄� g峄峣 l脿 b锚-膽锚, l脿 鈥渂贸ng鈥�, v脿 th岷璵 ch铆 c貌n c贸 m峄檛 n峄梚 s峄� l峄沶 h啤n n峄痑, 膽贸 l脿 s峄� b峄� nhi峄卪 HIV/AIDS (ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh nam l脿 nh贸m ng瓢峄漣 c贸 nguy c啤 m岷痗 HIV/AIDS cao nh岷, v矛 th岷� m脿 HIV/AIDS c貌n 膽瓢峄 g峄峣 l脿 鈥渂峄噉h ung th瓢 c峄 ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh nam鈥�. L媒 do cho nguy c啤 cao n脿y l脿 do ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh nam n岷縰 mu峄憂 quan h峄� t矛nh d峄 theo ki峄僽 th芒m nh岷璸 (penetration sex) th矛 ch峄� c贸 th峄� l脿 qua 膽瓢峄漬g h岷璾 m么n (anal sex). M脿 theo nghi锚n c峄﹗ khoa h峄峜 th矛 t岷� b脿o 峄� h岷璾 m么n d峄� b峄� nhi峄卪 HIV h啤n l脿 t岷� b脿o 峄� 芒m 膽岷 c峄 ng瓢峄漣 ph峄� n峄�. Ngo脿i ra th矛 tinh d峄媍h v脿 m脿ng nh岷 峄� h岷璾 m么n c贸 th峄� mang trong m矛nh nhi峄乽 vi r煤t HIV h啤n l脿 ch岷 d峄媍h 峄� 芒m 膽岷. V矛 th岷� m脿 gay men d峄� m岷痗 HIV h啤n l脿 straight men).

V脿 t矛nh y锚u 岷 c农ng tr脿n 膽岷 nh峄痭g gi岷眓g x茅, ngh末 suy c峄 m峄檛 Philippe Besson y锚u 膽岷痬 say Thomas Andrieu nh瓢ng lu么n t峄� h峄廼 li峄噓 c岷璾 岷 c贸 y锚u m矛nh, v脿 n岷縰 c贸 th矛 li峄噓 c贸 膽岷痬 say, c贸 谩m 岷h, c贸 nh峄� nhung quay qu岷痶 nh瓢 m矛nh y锚u c岷璾 岷 hay kh么ng. Trong t矛nh y锚u 膽贸 c峄 Philippe Besson c贸 nh峄痭g gi芒y ph煤t 鈥渉岷璵 h峄眂 l貌ng ghen鈥� c峄 m峄檛 ch脿ng trai khi nh矛n th岷 Thomas th芒n m岷璽 v峄沬 m峄檛 c么 g谩i, khi c谩i s峄ヽ 茅p c峄 vi峄嘽 gi峄� b铆 m岷璽 t矛nh c岷 gi峄痑 hai ng瓢峄漣 c峄� d岷 d岷 膽猫 n岷穘g l锚n t芒m h峄搉 t谩c gi岷� c峄 c谩i thu峄� ch瓢a 膽岷 膽么i m瓢啤i. Khi m脿 Thomas Andrieu, ph煤t tr瓢峄沜 c贸 th峄� bao b峄峜 Philippe Besson trong nh峄痭g gi峄� l脿m t矛nh hoang d岷, c贸 th峄� k岷縯 n峄慽 v峄沬 t谩c gi岷� v脿 膽岷 膽岷縩 m峄檛 s峄� th芒n m岷璽 kh么ng c岷 n贸i th脿nh l峄漣, th矛 ph煤t sau l岷 khi岷縩 t谩c gi岷� v峄� 貌a trong s峄� t峄� nh岷璶 th峄ヽ, h贸a ra m矛nh ch岷硁g bi岷縯 g矛 v峄� ch脿ng trai m脿 m矛nh y锚u鈥�

B岷眓g v膬n phong dung d峄�, gi岷 膽啤n nh瓢ng ch芒n th峄眂 v脿 c贸 s峄ヽ g峄 膽岷縩 l岷� k峄�, Philippe Besson 膽茫 ph啤i b脿y l锚n trang gi岷 kh么ng ch峄� m峄檛 m峄慽 t矛nh 膽峄搉g t铆nh c峄 tu峄昳 hoa ni锚n, c谩i th峄漣 v么 瓢u v么 lo, t峄� do t峄� t岷. 脭ng c貌n g贸i gh茅m v脿 n芒ng niu b锚n trong nh峄痭g trang s谩ch c岷� m峄檛 kho岷g th峄漣 gian 膽岷筽 nh岷, r峄眂 r峄� nh岷, h岷h ph煤c nh岷 c峄 c岷� m峄檛 膽峄漣 ng瓢峄漣: tu峄昳 thanh xu芒n, c谩i th峄漣 ng峄搉 ng峄檔 s峄ヽ s峄憂g v脿 t矛nh y锚u kh么ng bao gi峄� quay tr峄� l岷. C贸 m峄檛 n峄梚 ti岷縞 nu峄慽 m啤 h峄� 谩m 岷h c芒u chuy峄噉 ngay t峄� nh峄痭g trang 膽岷 ti锚n, ngay t峄� c谩i d峄� c岷 c峄 Thomas r岷眓g r峄搃 膽芒y, Philippe s岷� bay 膽岷縩 nh峄痭g ch芒n tr峄漣 xa, s岷� tr峄� th脿nh ng瓢峄漣 n峄昳 ti岷縩g, r峄漣 b峄� ng么i l脿ng heo h煤t v岷痭g v岷� ch峄� v峄弉 v岷筺 160 ng瓢峄漣 d芒n n脿y 膽峄� tung ho脿nh kh岷痯 n瓢峄沜 Ph谩p, v脿 Thomas s岷� 峄� l岷 nh瓢 th峄� 膽峄媙h m峄噉h 膽茫 s岷痯 膽岷穞 s岷祅 m峄檛 cu峄檆 chia ly 谩m 岷h nh瓢 th岷� n脿y. T岷 b岷眓g T煤 t脿i c岷� hai 膽岷 膽瓢峄 v峄玜 l脿 s峄� c么ng nh岷璶 tr矛nh 膽峄� h峄峜 v岷 c峄 h峄�, v峄玜 l脿 c谩i thanh ch矛 n岷穘g tr末u 膽谩nh d岷 s峄� k岷縯 th煤c c峄 m峄檛 cu峄檆 t矛nh, r峄檔g ra l脿 c岷� m峄檛 th峄漣 thanh xu芒n m峄檔g m啤 t瓢啤i 膽岷筽:

鈥淭么i ch峄 b峄ヽ 岷h 岷. Trong b峄ヽ 岷h 岷, b岷璶 qu岷 jean, chi岷縞 谩o s啤mi car么 x岷痭 tay, anh c岷 c峄峮g c峄� gi峄痑 nh峄痭g ng贸n tay. V脿 anh m峄塵 c瓢峄漣. M峄檛 n峄� c瓢峄漣 nh岷� nh脿ng, t矛nh t峄�, tr矛u m岷縩, t么i c岷 nh岷璶 v岷瓂. Khi岷縩 t么i chao 膽岷 m茫i m峄檛 th峄漣 gian d脿i sau 膽贸 m峄梚 khi nh矛n l岷 h矛nh 岷h 岷. V岷玭 c貌n khi岷縩 t么i chao 膽岷 khi t么i vi岷縯 l岷 nh峄痭g d貌ng n脿y v脿 t么i ng岷痬 nh矛n b峄ヽ 岷h, 膽岷穞 tr锚n b脿n l脿m vi峄嘽 c峄 t么i, 峄� 膽贸, ngay b锚n c岷h b脿n ph铆m m谩y t铆nh t么i. B芒y gi峄� 膽芒y t么i 膽茫 bi岷縯. T么i bi岷縯 r岷眓g Thomas 膽茫 膽峄搉g 媒 ch峄 b峄ヽ 岷h duy nh岷 n脿y ch峄� b峄焛 v矛 anh 膽茫 hi峄僽 (膽茫 quy岷縯 膽峄媙h) 膽贸 l脿 l岷 cu峄慽 c霉ng ch煤ng t么i 峄� c岷h nhau. Anh m峄塵 c瓢峄漣 膽峄� t么i mang n峄� c瓢峄漣 anh 岷 theo c霉ng t么i.鈥�


S峄� ph岷璶 d岷玭 d岷痶 cu峄檆 膽峄漣 c峄 Philippe v脿 Thomas r岷� ra hai h瓢峄沶g kh谩c nhau, th岷� nh瓢ng nh峄痭g g矛 h峄� 膽茫 c霉ng nhau chia s岷�, c谩i t矛nh y锚u v脿 s峄� th芒n m岷璽 kh峄g khi岷縫 膽贸, v岷玭 c貌n 谩m 岷h h峄� su峄憈 nh峄痭g n膬m sau n脿y. D岷玼 Philippe c贸 tr岷 qua h脿ng lo岷 nh峄痭g cu峄檆 t矛nh m峄檛 膽锚m, ng峄� v峄沬 nhi峄乽 ng瓢峄漣 膽脿n 么ng, c岷穚 k猫 r峄搃 chia tay v峄沬 nh峄痭g ch脿ng trai kh谩c, th矛 h峄搃 峄ヽ c峄 m峄慽 t矛nh 膽岷, c峄 m峄檛 th峄漣 thanh xu芒n kh么ng th峄� k茅o d脿i m茫i v岷玭 v岷瓂, v岷玭 s峄憂g 膽峄檔g trong t芒m tr铆 么ng. V脿 tr峄� tr锚u thay, n岷縰 Philippe l脿 k岷� lu么n t峄� nh岷璶 m矛nh hay n贸i d峄慽, v脿 tr峄� th脿nh nh脿 v膬n - ng瓢峄漣 ki岷縨 ti峄乶 nh峄� b峄媋 ra chuy峄噉 膽峄� vi岷縯 - th矛 么ng l岷 ho脿n to脿n s峄憂g 膽煤ng v峄沬 s峄� th岷璽 v峄� b岷 th芒n m矛nh, khi 么ng t峄� tin th峄玜 nh岷璶 tr锚n m峄檛 show truy峄乶 h矛nh r岷眓g 么ng l脿 ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh. C貌n Thomas, ng瓢峄漣 lu么n l岷 l峄� 铆t n贸i, l岷 ch峄峮 c谩ch s峄憂g m峄檛 cu峄檆 膽峄漣 gi岷� d峄慽 v矛 谩p l峄眂 t峄� k峄� v峄峮g c峄 gia 膽矛nh v脿 x茫 h峄檌.

Thomas kh么ng d谩m v霉ng l锚n 膽峄� ch峄峮 l峄盿 cu峄檆 s峄憂g cho ri锚ng m矛nh, v矛 trong m岷痶 么ng, 么ng kh么ng h峄� c贸 s峄� ch峄峮 l峄盿 膽贸. 脭ng kh么ng d谩m 膽i ng瓢峄 l岷 nh峄痭g g矛 膽茫 膽瓢峄 s岷痯 膽岷穞 s岷祅 cho 么ng, v脿 c霉ng l煤c, 么ng ch岷 nh岷璶 膽峄� c谩i g谩nh n岷穘g v峄� gi峄沬 t铆nh th岷璽 c峄 m矛nh, v峄� m峄檛 t矛nh y锚u kh么ng th峄� k岷縯 th煤c c贸 h岷璾 c脿ng ng脿y c脿ng 膽猫 n岷穘g l锚n t芒m h峄搉. Thomas c农ng gi峄憂g nh瓢 r岷 nhi峄乽 ng瓢峄漣 膽峄搉g t铆nh kh谩c kh么ng d谩m c么ng khai con ng瓢峄漣 th岷璽 c峄 m矛nh, kh么ng d谩m ch岷 nh岷璶 s峄憂g vui v岷� v脿 b岷痶 膽岷 l岷 t峄� 膽岷 膽峄� b岷 th芒n m矛nh 膽瓢峄 h岷h ph煤c. C贸 th峄� h峄� kh么ng 膽峄� d农ng kh铆 nh瓢 Thomas, c农ng c贸 th峄� h峄� v岷玭 c貌n 膽ang hoang mang, l岷 l峄慽 v脿 kh么ng bi岷縯 ph岷 膽峄慽 m岷穞 nh瓢 th岷� n脿o v峄沬 gi峄沬 t铆nh c峄 b岷 th芒n, 膽峄� r峄搃 nh峄痭g bi k峄媍h nh瓢 Thomas c峄� di峄卬 ra, v矛 h峄� l峄盿 ch峄峮 che gi岷 con ng瓢峄漣 m矛nh su峄憈 c岷� 膽峄漣, ch岷 nh岷璶 s峄憂g m峄檛 cu峄檆 膽峄漣 gi岷� t岷 v脿 d峄慽 tr谩.

Bi k峄媍h 岷 c贸 l岷� c貌n 岷h h瓢峄焠g 膽岷縩 c岷� t谩c gi岷� Philippe Besson, ng瓢峄漣 膽茫 t峄玭g c贸 c啤 h峄檌 膽峄� n峄慽 l岷 li锚n l岷 v峄沬 Thomas Andrieu, nh瓢ng r峄搃 nh岷璶 ra m峄峣 th峄� 膽茫 thay 膽峄昳, v脿 d岷玼 c峄� c谩ch m岷, con ng瓢峄漣 ta c农ng kh么ng th峄� n脿o quay tr峄� l岷 c谩i th峄漣 c峄 hai nam sinh 17 tu峄昳, y锚u nhau trong b铆 m岷璽, trong nh峄痭g c谩i 么m 岷 v脿 nh峄痭g cu峄檆 l脿m t矛nh. S峄� ti岷縞 nu峄慽 c峄 ng脿y chia ly kh么ng th峄� n脿o so s谩nh 膽瓢峄 v峄沬 s峄� ti岷縞 nu峄慽 c峄 nhi峄乽 n膬m sau, khi c岷� hai 膽峄乽 膽茫 40 tu峄昳, khi g瓢啤ng v峄� cu峄慽 c霉ng l岷 kh么ng th峄� n脿o l脿nh, khi nh峄痭g g矛 膽茫 thu峄檆 v峄� d末 v茫ng cu峄慽 c霉ng ch峄� c贸 th峄� s峄憂g m茫i trong d末 v茫ng. 峄� tu峄昳 17, h峄� chia ly v矛 s峄� ph岷璶 膽岷﹜ 膽瓢a, v矛 c岷� hai v岷玭 c貌n c岷� cu峄檆 膽峄漣 峄� ph铆a tr瓢峄沜 膽峄� m脿 s峄憂g, 膽峄� m脿 h峄峜 t岷璸, m脿 ph岷 膽岷. Nh瓢ng 峄� tu峄昳 40, h峄� v岷玭 ti岷縫 t峄 chia ly, v矛 膽i峄乽 g矛? Philippe 膽茫 c贸 c芒u tr岷� l峄漣:

鈥淰脿 nh岷 l脿, ch煤ng t么i s岷� kh么ng t矛m th岷 l岷 c谩i 膽i峄乽, 膽茫 th煤c gi峄 ch煤ng t么i ng瓢峄漣 n脿y 膽岷縩 v峄沬 ng瓢峄漣 kia, c峄 ng脿y 岷. S峄� th么i th煤c r岷 tinh kh么i 岷. C谩i kho岷h kh岷痗 duy nh岷 岷. 膼茫 c贸 nh峄痭g t矛nh hu峄憂g 膽瓢a 膽岷﹜, s峄� g岷痭 k岷縯 c峄 s峄� ph岷璶, m峄檛 s峄� s峄� tr霉ng h峄, nh峄痭g ham mu峄憂 膽峄搉g th峄漣, 膽i峄乽 g矛 膽贸 trong kh么ng kh铆, 膽i峄乽 g矛 膽贸 n峄痑 c峄 th峄漣 kh岷痗, c峄 n啤i ch峄憂, t岷 c岷� t岷 l脿m th脿nh m峄檛 kho岷h kh岷痗, t岷 n锚n s峄� g岷穚 g峄�, nh瓢ng t岷 c岷� l岷 膽峄﹖ 膽o岷, m峄峣 th峄� xoay chuy峄僴 nhi峄乽 h瓢峄沶g kh谩c nhau, t岷 c岷� n峄� bung l锚n, gi峄憂g ki峄僽 nh峄痭g tia ph谩o hoa bung ra t峄� ph铆a tr锚n b岷 tr峄漣 膽锚m r峄搃 r峄泃 xu峄憂g nh瓢 m瓢a tu么n, r峄搃 l峄媘 t岷痶 khi c脿ng xu峄憂g th岷 v脿 t岷 ng岷 tr瓢峄沜 khi ch岷 膽岷縩 m岷穞 膽岷, 膽峄� kh么ng thi锚u ch谩y ng瓢峄漣 n脿o, th岷� r峄搃 kho岷h kh岷痗 膽茫 k岷縯 th煤c, 膽茫 m岷, n贸 s岷� kh么ng quay tr峄� l岷; 膽贸 ch铆nh l脿 chuy峄噉 x岷 ra gi峄痑 ch煤ng t么i.鈥�


鈥淪峄� th么i th煤c r岷 tinh kh么i鈥� ch铆nh l脿 c峄 t峄� t么i d霉ng 膽峄� mi锚u t岷� m峄慽 t矛nh c峄 Elio v脿 Oliver trong 鈥淐all me by your name鈥�, c岷� c谩i h矛nh 岷h ph谩o hoa n峄� bung l锚n, 膽岷筽 tuy峄噒 trong kho岷h kh岷痗 膽峄� r峄搃 t岷痶 l峄媘 c农ng v岷瓂. H矛nh nh瓢 nh峄痭g chuy峄噉 t矛nh 膽峄搉g t铆nh n脿o 峄� ch芒u 脗u, v脿o nh峄痭g n膬m 80 c峄 th岷� k峄� 20 膽峄乽 bu峄搉 b茫 v脿 膽峄� l岷 nhi峄乽 ti岷縞 nu峄慽 nhi峄乽 膽岷縩 nh瓢 v岷瓂 hay sao?... 鈥溎愥猾ng t峄� d峄慽 m矛nh鈥� c农ng 膽岷筽 v脿 bu峄搉; n贸 膽茫 khi岷縩 t么i kh贸c r岷 nhi峄乽, kh贸c cho c岷穚 膽么i Philippe - Thomas, cho m峄檛 m峄慽 t矛nh dang d峄�, cho nh峄痭g g矛 l峄� l脿ng v脿 m茫i m茫i l峄� l脿ng, cho m峄檛 kho岷g th峄漣 gian tr么i qua th岷 tho岷痶 nh瓢 thoi 膽瓢a, tay dang ra d岷玼 nhanh c谩ch m岷 c农ng kh么ng th峄� n脿o gi峄� l岷. 脕m 岷h nh岷 v岷玭 l脿 c芒u cu峄慽 c霉ng trong b峄ヽ th瓢 Thomas vi岷縯 cho Philippe nh瓢ng kh么ng bao gi峄� g峄璱, b峄ヽ th瓢 sau nhi峄乽 n膬m r貌ng c农ng 膽茫 膽岷縩 膽瓢峄 tay Philippe:

鈥淢矛nh ch峄� mu峄憂 n贸i v峄沬 c岷璾 r岷眓g m矛nh 膽茫 h岷h ph煤c trong nh峄痭g th谩ng ng脿y ch煤ng ta b锚n nhau, r岷眓g m矛nh ch瓢a bao gi峄� h岷h ph煤c nh瓢 th岷�, v脿 m矛nh bi岷縯 m矛nh s岷� ch岷硁g bao gi峄� h岷h ph煤c nh瓢 v岷瓂 n峄痑.鈥�



P.S.: Cu峄憂 n脿y hay qu谩 tr峄漣 m脿 h矛nh nh瓢 tr锚n Tiki 膽ang b峄� 岷库€� Th岷 gi岷 gi谩 35% b峄痑 gi峄� lu么n m脿 hi岷縨 c贸 ai 膽峄峜 r峄搃 vi岷縯 nh岷璶 x茅t tr锚n tr峄僴鈥� C贸 th峄� v矛 c谩i b矛a s谩ch nh矛n kh么ng m岷 h岷 d岷玭 (m岷穋 d霉 m矛nh hi峄僽 vi峄嘽 NXB Tao 膼脿n l峄盿 ch峄峮 b峄ヽ tranh 鈥淭he Swan鈥� - m么 t岷� m峄檛 con thi锚n nga tr岷痭g v脿 m峄檛 con thi锚n nga 膽en 膽ang c峄� g岷痭g 膽岷 膽岷縩 s峄� h峄 nh岷 - c峄 n峄� danh h峄峚 ng瓢峄漣 Th峄 膼i峄僴 Hilma af Klint l脿m b矛a s谩ch l脿 c贸 d峄g 媒 h岷硁 hoi), c谩i t峄盿 s谩ch c农ng ch岷硁g g峄 膽瓢峄 m岷 may suy ngh末 n脿o r岷眓g 膽芒y l脿 m峄檛 cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 v峄� 膽峄� t脿i t矛nh y锚u 膽峄搉g t铆nh. Haizzz, t峄檌 nghi峄噋 em n贸... Ai th铆ch 膽峄峜 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 t矛nh c岷 膽峄搉g t铆nh bu峄搉 th矛 l锚n Tiki mua 峄g h峄� nha, h峄憈 ngay v峄� 膽峄峜 nha :))

膼峄峜 s谩ch xong m矛nh ngay l岷璸 t峄ヽ l锚n google search th么ng tin xem cu峄憂 s谩ch 膽茫 (ho岷穋 s岷�) 膽瓢峄 chuy峄僴 th峄� th脿nh phim hay kh么ng, v矛 s谩ch hay th岷� n脿y m脿 kh么ng c贸 phim th矛 u峄昻g l岷痬 岷. V脿 m矛nh 膽茫 t矛m 膽瓢峄 m峄檛 b脿i b谩o tr锚n trang Allocin茅 - trang web ti岷縩g Ph谩p chuy锚n v峄� c谩c th么ng tin phim 岷h th岷� gi峄沬 - ph峄弉g v岷 t谩c gi岷� Philippe Besson c霉ng th么ng tin r岷眓g cu峄憂 s谩ch 鈥溎愥猾ng t峄� d峄慽 m矛nh鈥� s岷痯 膽瓢峄 d峄眓g th脿nh phim :D Oh la la qu谩 膽茫!!!! 膼芒y l脿 b脿i b谩o, 膽膬ng v脿o ng脿y 28/8/2017:

膼岷 媒 th矛 l脿 b谩c t谩c gi岷�, k峄� t峄� khi cu峄憂 s谩ch tr峄� th脿nh best-seller v脿 n峄昳 ti岷縩g r岷 r岷, 膽茫 nh岷璶 膽瓢峄 v么 s峄� l峄漣 ch脿o m峄漣 l脿m phim. Nh瓢ng cu峄慽 c霉ng b谩c 岷 l峄盿 ch峄峮 Olivier Peyon - ng瓢峄漣 b谩c 岷 ho脿n to脿n kh么ng h峄� quen bi岷縯 - l脿m 膽岷 di峄卬 cho phim, v矛 Monsieur Peyon 膽茫 膽峄峜 h岷縯 t峄� 膽岷 膽岷縩 cu峄慽 cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 ngay t峄� khi n贸 v峄玜 m峄沬 膽瓢峄 xu岷 b岷, khi v岷玭 ch瓢a bi岷縯 l脿 cu峄憂 s谩ch c贸 th脿nh c么ng n峄昳 ti岷縩g hay kh么ng. N贸i chung 膽岷 di峄卬 Olivier Peyon ti岷縫 c岷璶 cu峄憂 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯 v峄沬 s峄� ch芒n th脿nh, th峄眂 s峄� th岷 hi峄僽 n峄檌 dung quy峄僴 s谩ch, y锚u m岷縩 v脿 mong mu峄憂 膽瓢峄 chuy峄僴 th峄� 鈥溎愥猾ng t峄� d峄慽 m矛nh鈥�, ch峄� kh么ng ph岷 ki峄僽 th岷 s谩ch n峄昳 ti岷縩g r峄搃 m峄沬 mon men t峄沬 xin 膽瓢峄 chuy峄僴 th峄�.

Philippe Besson s岷� giao to脿n quy峄乶 vi峄嘽 l脿m phim cho Olivier Peyon lu么n, b谩c kh么ng d铆nh g矛 t峄沬 b峄� phim h岷縯, k峄� c岷� vi峄嘽 vi岷縯 k峄媍h b岷, v矛 theo quan 膽i峄僲 c峄 b谩c 岷 th矛 b谩c 岷 kh么ng th铆ch 谩p 膽岷穞 suy ngh末 c峄 m矛nh l锚n qu谩 tr矛nh s谩ng t岷 c峄 m峄檛 ng瓢峄漣 kh谩c :)) B岷 th芒n b谩c 岷 tr峄� th脿nh m峄檛 nh脿 v膬n v矛 th铆ch s峄� t峄� do s谩ng t岷, ngh末 g矛 vi岷縯 n岷, v脿 b谩c 岷 kh么ng mu峄憂 c瓢峄沺 膽i s峄� t峄� do 膽贸 c峄 Olivier Peyon khi s谩ng t岷 n锚n b峄� phim, m岷穋 d霉 膽贸 l脿 phim chuy峄僴 th峄� t峄� m峄檛 source material. N锚n l脿 膽峄檆 gi岷� h茫y hy v峄峮g s岷� c贸 m峄檛 b岷 phim kh么ng ph岷 l脿 copy y chang c峄 b岷 ti峄僽 thuy岷縯, nh瓢ng mong l脿 s岷� kh么ng qu谩 kh谩c bi峄噒, v矛 th峄眂 s峄� l脿 b岷 g峄慶 膽茫 qu谩 tuy峄噒 v峄漣 r峄搃 ah ah ah!!!!
Profile Image for Felicia.
254 reviews989 followers
February 10, 2019
_________________________________

"I feel this desire swarming in my belly and running up my spine. But I have to constantly contain and compress it so that it doesn't betray me in front of the others. Because I've already understood that desire is visible."

Philippe Besson is an extraordinary writer with a soul stirring lyrical prose that left me breathless at times.

In Lie With Me, Besson takes the reader into the vulnerable mind of a 17 year old gay boy, Philippe, as he embarks on a clandestine affair with a classmate, Thomas, eventually falling in in love with the boy he knows he can't keep.

Philippe's delicate and pure nature are the heart of this book and the author conveys his pain and confusion exquisitely. Though it is never addressed, I suspect that this book is at least partially autobiographical which only lended to the emotion it invoked in me

My only critique would be that I felt, at times, that the author veered too far off course leaving me wanting more of Philippe's thoughts and his experiences as a gay boy trying to navigate his way through France in 1984.

NOTE: This is a short story, only 90 pages on my Kindle.
_________________________________

I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Richard Derus.
3,646 reviews2,193 followers
August 18, 2023
2023 UPDATE Maybe coming to a North American arthouse near you?

The Publisher Says: The award-winning, bestselling French novel by Philippe Besson about an affair between two teenage boys in 1984 France, translated with subtle beauty and haunting lyricism by the iconic and internationally acclaimed actress/writer Molly Ringwald.

We drive at high speed along back roads, through woods, vineyards, and oat fields. The bike smells like gasoline and makes a lot of noise, and sometimes I鈥檓 frightened when the wheels slip on the gravel on the dirt road, but the only thing that matters is that I鈥檓 holding on to him, that I鈥檓 holding on to him outside.

Just outside a hotel in Bordeaux, Philippe chances upon a young man who bears a striking resemblance to his first love. What follows is a look back at the relationship he鈥檚 never forgotten, a hidden affair with a gorgeous boy named Thomas during their last year of high school. Without ever acknowledging they know each other in the halls, they steal time to meet in secret, carrying on a passionate, world-altering affair.

Dazzlingly rendered in English by Ringwald in her first-ever translation, Besson鈥檚 powerfully moving coming-of-age story captures the eroticism and tenderness of first love鈥攁nd the heartbreaking passage of time.

My Review: I've spoken in previous reviews about the power of the (mostly) French art form, the , an ill-defined, "you'll know it when you see it" form of literary tale-telling. And all those ambiguous layers of the latter phrase, from straightforward "telling a story" to "tattling on someone" to "inventing a lie" are each present in the 谤茅肠颈迟 itself. The qualities I can suss out as being sine qua non for a work to be a 谤茅肠颈迟 are length鈥攂revity is the soul of wit, lingerie, and 谤茅肠颈迟s鈥攁nd interiority. Nothing describable as a 谤茅肠颈迟 can take place in "real time" or include voices not mediated by the narrator and/or author through a single tightly focused lens. If you've read Camus's , you've read a peak-experience 谤茅肠颈迟. If you didn't like reading it, I venture to suggest that you not pay a lot of attention to the genre.

Brevity this book has: In 148pp, Besson tells the oldest gay love story there is: Boy meets boy; boy loves boy, is loved by boy; neither one says the right "wrong" thing to his belov猫d to make the "forbidden" connection happen; and they go their separate, unequal, always intertwined ways. Interiority it simply is: All the words we read are Philippe's or Philippe's reports of conversations recently or distantly past. Philippe-the-narrator tells us several times that, as a novelist, he makes stuff up; he implies that he's done that habitually; so we're left to our own devices to decide about his honesty, his accuracy, and his intentions in telling us this tale.

I'm going to let you read Philippe-the-author and Philippe-the-narrator's words unmediated by my own commentary on them. In my own way, I want to honor the form of the 谤茅肠颈迟 as a review. The book is beautiful for many reasons. Translator Ringwald has made a beautiful thing in this book. I haven't read the French text, but I know enough from previous Besson encounters to believe this is a deft and charming rendering of his original. As to Besson's tale told...well..."is it autobiographical" is the first line of defense against immersion into the unreliability of Memory that this, a beautiful and moving and elegiac 谤茅肠颈迟, invites its readers to experience. I recommend reading it, experiencing it, absorbing its beauties and funnies and rawnesses, without any additional removes from immediacy. Don't, then, place harsh lights on it or look for factual details in it; let it become the limpid waters of Monet's water-lily pond for your inner reader's delight and refreshment.

Chapter One (1984)
I'm not beautiful, but I get attention; that I know. Not because of my appearance, but because of my {good} grades. "He is brilliant," they whisper, "much more advanced than the others, he will go far, like his brother, this family is one to be reckoned with." We are in a place, in a moment, where nearly everyone goes nowhere; it garners me equal parts sympathy and antipathy.
辫辫8鈥�
Upstairs, after climbing a makeshift staircase, you would enter a room full of anything and everything. There was even a mattress. It was on this mattress where I rolled around in {his first love}'s embrace for the first time. We had not gone through puberty yet, but we were curious about each other's bodies. His was the first male sex I held in my hand, other than my own. My first kiss was the one he gave me. My first embrace, skin against skin, was with him. ... Today I'm struck by our creativity because at the time, there was no internet, not even videocassettes or cable TV. We had never seen any porn, and yet we still knew how to do it. There are things one knows how to do even as a child. By puberty, we would be even more imaginative. That would come fast
(p13)
A million questions flash through my mind: How did it begin for him? How and at what age did it reveal itself? How is it that no one can see it on him? Yes, how can it be so undetectable? And then: Is it about suffering? Only suffering? And again: Will I be the first? Or were there others before me? Others who were also secret? And: What does he imagine exactly? I don't ask any of these questions, of course. I follow his lead, accepting the rules of the game.

He says: I know a place.
(p28)
I discover that absence has a consistency, like the dark water of a river, like oil, some kind of sticky dirty liquid that you can struggle and perhaps drown in. It has a thickness like night, an indefinite space with no landmarks, nothing to bang against, where you search for a light, some small glimmer, something to hang on to and guide you. But absence is, first and foremost, silence. A vast, enveloping silence that weighs you down and puts you in a state where any unforeseeable, unidentifiable sound can make you jump.
(p37)
He says that for me things are simple, that everything will be fine, that I will get out of it, it's already written, that there's nothing to worry about, the world will greet me with open arms. Whereas for him there's a barrier, an impenetrable wall, forbidding him to deviate from what has been predetermined.

Whenever he mentions this question of the forbidden I will try in vain to show him that he's wrong.
(辫辫46鈥�47)
A few weeks later he'll take me for a ride. He'll pick me up at the edge of town, with a helmet this time. I don't know if it's as a precaution, to respect the law, or so that we won't be recognized, but I get on the back of the bike and hold on to him. We drive at high speed along back roads, through woods, vineyards, and oat fields. The bike smells like gasoline and makes a lot of noise, and sometimes I'm frightened when the wheels slip on the gravel on the dirt road, but the only thing that matters is that I'm holding on to him, that I'm holding on to him outside.
(p65)
...there is often a staggering intimacy between us, a closeness beyond imagining, but the rest of the time our separateness is absolute. Such schizophrenia could bring even those with the strongest equilibrium to the edge of reason, and let's admit it, I didn't have much equilibrium to begin with.

There is the insanity of not being able to be seen together. An insanity that is aggravated in this case by the unprecedented situation of finding ourselves in the middle of a crowd and having to act like strangers. It seems crazy not to be able to show our happiness. Such an impoverished word. Others have this right, and they exercise it freely. Sharing their happiness makes them even more happy, makes them expand with joy. But we're left stunted, compromised, by the burden of having to always lie and censor ourselves.

This passion that can't be talked about, that has to be concealed, gives way to the terrible question: if it isn't talked about, how can one know that it really exists? One day, when it's over, when it finally comes to an end, no one will be able to attest to what took place.
(p77)
...I hurry to get what I want before he changes his mind. I take the picture. In it, he's wearing jeans, a plaid shirt with rolled-up sleeves. He has the blade of grass between his fingers and he's smiling, a slight, complicit smile, almost tender. This smile devastated me for a long time after, whenever I happened to look at this photograph. It upsets me even now as I write these lines and contemplate the image, resting on my desk, right next to my keyboard. Because now I know. I know that {he} consented to this single picture only because he knew (had decided) that it was our last moment together. He smiled so that I could take his smile with me.
(辫辫89鈥�90)

Chapter Two (2007)
I know that there are those who will object to my refusal to accept that he changed course, switched orientation, simply succumbed to a feeling that was previously unknown to him. I could be seen as upset, jealous, or even obtuse, and yet I persist in thinking that he put the same stubborn application into this as he did to his work. The same desire to forget himself, to return to the righteous path set out by his mother, the only one permissible. Does he end up believing it himself? That's the fundamental question. If the answer is yes, then moving forward in life would be possible. If the answer is no, then it is a life condemned to interminable misery.
(p106)
(I correct myself because I've just been lying. Of course, it took time, a lot of time, before I admitted that everything was lost, before I decided to say goodbye forever. I kept hoping for a sign. I thought of initiating another meeting, I started letters that I never sent. Desire does not go out like a match, it extinguishes slowly as it burns into ash. In the end I gave up on all possibility of a reunion.)
(p112)
...I live with a man with a man who is fifteen years younger than me and doesn't like boys but loves me. Who knows why? It's a vulnerable relationship, and I will be scared to disturb this precarious equilibrium. Calling {him}, talking to him, asking to see him again, would be anything but innocuous. I cannot say: This is only a phone call. I know it's more than that. Even if I were granted immunity, the act of calling him has the allure of betrayal (we come back to that, always we come back to it) or without going to that extreme, a gesture toward {him} would be a gesture of mistrust toward the man I live with鈥攁 decision to put distance between us, to admit to a love that is not enough.
(p120)

Chapter Three (2016)
In that first moment, when he heard me say that I had seen you, he didn't move, but I swear he lost his balance. At that exact moment I was certain that he had been in love with you. That such a thing had existed鈥攎y father in love with a boy. I didn't need to ask him the question. I couldn't have found the courage anyway. Afterward, I said to myself: Maybe it was just a phase. Okay, yes, it existed, but it ended. He moved on to something else鈥攖o a life, a woman, a child...that must happen often, these things. I told myself: when he saw you on TV, it brought back the memory, but it was just nostalgia. A secret from the past...everyone has secrets; besides, it's good to have things that belong only to you. I could have stayed there. It should have stayed there. Except that two days after our conversation, my father brought us together to announce he was leaving.
(辫142鈥�143)
Profile Image for Optimist 鈾癒ing's Wench鈾�.
1,804 reviews3,950 followers
March 6, 2019
I recently saw Ellen Page on The Late Show give an impassioned plea to end the hate against the queer community. I was moved by her words and while reading this novella I kept thinking about them. How long has hatred left its indelible mark and perhaps changed the course of so many lives senselessly? Philippe Besson and Thomas Andrieu can be counted amongst that collateral damage. There was no hate crime or bullying per se but both were victims of a more persistent kind of hatred that relegated them to a clandestine relationship: intolerance.

Philippe and Thomas should've been afforded the same privileges as their heterosexual counterparts without impunity. They should've been allowed the freedom to love and be loved without the need for courage or bravery to do so and Lie With Me is the story of how bigotry stymied that freedom and fear of reprisal stole their innocence.

It seems crazy to not be able to show our happiness. Such an impoverished word. Others have this right, and they exercise it freely. Sharing their happiness makes them even more happy, makes them expand with joy. But we're left stunted, compromised, by the burden of having to always lie and censor ourselves. This passion that can't be talked about, that has to be concealed, gives way to the terrible question: if it isn't talked about, how can one know that it really exists?


Lie With Me is poignant memoir that tells the story of Philippe's first love of a beautiful boy with a tragic soul. Told from memory in three parts, making it difficult to avoid the inclusion of later events and making the specifics of dialogue hazy, thus giving the reader a bit non-linear retelling but an emotive one nonetheless. The first part takes place in 1984 when they are seniors and comprises the bulk of the story. The second part takes place in 2007 when during an interview Philippe sees a boy outside a hotel that's the spitting image of Thomas, a boy who turns out to be his son, and the events of 2016 conclude the story.



Philippe is inquisitive, precocious and gobsmacked when Thomas approaches him. Thomas is popular but quiet and solemn, resigned to a life he knows will never bring him happiness. At 17 he's already incorporated secrecy and deception as his norm and at 18 those habits will forever taint them both. During their time together they do seemingly snatch a few moments of bliss and Besson captured the intensity of his feelings for Thomas as well as the optimism and folly of youth. I truly felt not only his physical desire for him but his steadfast belief that they would find a way to carve out a future together, despite evidence to the contrary.

I'm not sure what I expected from this book but I absolutely did not expect a memoir. That tangible connection tethered me to the reality of the oppressive prejudice that has been globally devastating to so many for far too long. Prejudice robbed these two boys of a life together, a life they deserved and left in its place a life lived inauthentically for one and the other struggling to give his heart to another after having it broken by his first love.



Besson's prose is lyrical, evocative and exceedingly French, in that it encapsulates the essence of experiencing life through the prism of an artistic eye. What fascinates me about this perspective is the uncanny ability to both see and experience life with gusto while also believing it's all going to end disastrously, or at the very least disappointingly. That dichotomous worldview is, in part, what made Lie With Me not only touching but memorable.

Those who have not taken this step, who have not come to terms with themselves, are not necessarily frightened, that are perhaps helpless, disoriented, lost as one is in the middle of a forest that's too dark or dense or vast.


Even though Lie With Me has a melancholy overtone that will probably only appeal to a niche market, I was beguiled by Besson's eloquence and I hope more of his works are translated into English, especially if this is representative of his work. If you are someone who can appreciate that not all romances end happily, give his words a chance to weave their magic.



An ARC was provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for deniz.
137 reviews846 followers
November 14, 2024
4,5 stars

鈥淏ecause you will leave, and we will stay.鈥�

This sentence is so powerful and gut-wrenching; it sums up the whole book. I took a minute or two to understand the meaning. I love when a book makes you just stare at the wall and think. The act of leaving stems from fear. This realization scared me

鈥淚鈥檓 a boy of books, from somewhere else.鈥�

The book made my heart heavy, which I love and find rare in a book. I enjoyed reading each character, but I mostly loved how open-minded and graceful Thomas鈥檚 son was. I loved his acceptance of the situation, even though his father was the one who found the courage to face it.

鈥淚 have been happy during these months together, that I have never been so happy, and that I already know I will never be so happy again.鈥�

The story is like A Little Life, without the tragedy, and has the intensity of Call Me by Your Name. I think it would make an excellent movie adaptation, as I could clearly envision each scene and feel the emotions while reading. Their feelings were relatable, and I understood them deeply.I know what it鈥檚 like to have someone in your life who struggles to find peace with themselves.

鈥淚t was love, of course, and tomorrow there will be a great emptiness.鈥�

The only thing I didn鈥檛 like was that the book was too short; the physical connection happened within the first 50 pages. I usually complain about books being too long, but this time, I wanted more pages. The closure was so clear, and the final note made me cry. This would definitely have been a five-star read if it were a bit longer. Their eyes spoke more than words, and the author captured this beautifully.

鈥淒eath is only a matter between you and yourself?鈥�

ps. thank you philippe besson for the shoutout!

辫濒补测濒颈蝉迟馃拰
Profile Image for Elyse Walters.
4,010 reviews11.7k followers
September 26, 2019
鈥淏ut he had everything planned.

鈥淭he suddenness of the proposition disconcerts me. We were perfect strangers an hour ago鈥�.

And then......
鈥淲e make love without a condom.
AIDS is there though. We even know of it鈥檚 true identity. It鈥檚 no longer refer to as 鈥榞ay cancer鈥欌€�.

By 20% into this short - one sitting - novel .....I already had my judgements.... I also knew how it was going to end.

Two complete High School strangers had sex in a deserted smelling corner of a locker room.

I don鈥檛 care what the sexual
orientation is - but their lust for each other...their hidden-can鈥檛-tell-anybody- sex......was dangerous business.
鈥淎t that moment, I would have followed him anywhere鈥�.....
What we learn about these boys, isn鈥檛 love.
It felt more like a confession about one鈥檚 own stupidity.

They believed they were protected by their youth. They were seventeen years old.
鈥淵ou don鈥檛 die when you are seventeen years old鈥�.
Well, you do!

For a student that had all A鈥檚 in school - the narrator didn鈥檛 think with his brain when he needed to most.

So more than a love story, for me, this novel was more of an important message:
DO NOT HAVE UN-PROTECTED SEX!
And... having sex with strangers is never wise.

There was silence, shyness, desire, and kisses, between the boys.... and eventually more substantial sharing with each other.....
but I never cared for either of them.
Their togetherness wasn鈥檛 love.
I read about the book comparison with Andr茅 Aciman鈥檚 novel,
鈥淐all Me By Your Name鈥�.
But ... the two books aren鈥檛 even in the same league.
There鈥檚 no character development in 鈥淟ie With Me鈥�.
The novel itself felt too short. I was underwhelmed.

Living a hidden life - trapped in shame -
鈥� The impossibility of sharing a love that endures鈥�....
is simply sad.

It鈥檚 a one dimensional story of a bad choice having gone wrong.

The cover is eye-catching beautiful.
The books value is getting the message across about safe sex - and sex with strangers.

First love? I didn鈥檛 buy it.
Profile Image for Axl Oswaldo.
410 reviews246 followers
June 27, 2024
If someone asks me if I have read about my own life in a book, I would say "yes, of course I have found myself in a book, so have many people"; but if someone asks me if I have found my own life so vivid and palpable in a book as if it were literally my own life, my own story but with different names, a different location, and perhaps a different ending, from now on I will say: "yes, reading Lie With Me I found that." Honestly, I was completely surprised once I started reading this novel, when I couldn't put it down since every part of it reminded me of my first love story, just exactly in the way our protagonist is living his. I'm still surprised, if you ask me, since I never lived such an experience reading a novel before, and now I'm really glad to have lived it, not only because of the experience itself, but also because Lie With Me has become an all-time favorite, and probably my favorite contemporary novel of my life.

Lie With Me is a story about hope and loss, about what it means to fall in love for the first time, and what it is to live that love, despite the fact that you have to live it without anyone knowing anything about it. It feels like a real, perhaps innocent first love story, and it is in fact like that: you and the other person, feeling free and being happy together, no matter how hard it might be.
This book, a straightforward yet beautifully written monologue, depicts a specific moment in our protagonist's life, the moment when he is a 17-year-old boy and meets Thomas, the guy who eventually would become his first lover. The novel is a perfect portrait of a beautiful, real relationship, and also describes the protagonist's feelings towards Thomas so vivid that you can almost feel them too; his vulnerability, his fears, his dreams, his future plans, etc. are other elements in the novel that let us know his story much better.
Sometimes the protagonist is also talking about his childhood, specific events which are crucial for us to understand why this or that is happening now, and other times he just shares his opinion on general topics, such as religion, or what living in the province really means (here I felt completely identified with him a lot, firstly because I have also lived in the province for many years, and secondly because his own experience with religion and mine are mostly the same).

As some of you know I have recently been listening to audiobooks almost all the time, and this one was not an exception: it was literally my workout audiobook鈥擨'd highly recommend it鈥攁nd that's why it took me a few days to finish it; otherwise I had read it in just one sitting since the story is really compelling, and once you start, you can't put it down. In fact, once I finished it, I felt the need to reread it right away.
I'm pretty sure I'm not going to forget this story for a long time, especially all those feelings that made me feel while I read it, and of course, the perfect, beautiful ending, that made me shed tears just at the very end of the novel. I almost wanted to call my first lover and asked him what he is up to now, after 8 years without knowing anything at all about his life; should I? (Just for the record, I don't even have his phone number or know where he lives, so it seems to be impossible).
In short, this is another great book you also should read, and I hope you can enjoy it as much as I did. Perhaps in the near future I decide to come back and pick this up again and love it even more than the first time. Who knows.

鈥淭his feeling of love, it transports me, it makes me happy. At the same time, it consumes me and makes me miserable, the way all impossible loves are miserable.鈥�

#PrideMonth Read (3)
Profile Image for Emanuel.
111 reviews74 followers
July 30, 2021
What a mistake. What a mistake to finish this on the first day of my summer holiday. I really wish I hadn't. In fact I wish I hadn't even started it in the first place.

It's not enough to say this is heartbreaking. It's not enough to say it is, of course, written beautifully or that it's given teenage (literary) love a new voice. It's the weight of the sadness that falls on you from the very first pages that I couldn't shake off. The inevitable end that I wanted to stop reading from. I think this has been described as the French 'Call me by your name'; that's not entirely accurate. CMBYN's got obsession and lust in its core; they both tend to fade out with time. This one deals with regrets; you can carry your regrets an entire life.

I wish I hadn't read this because I can't imagine stories like this being true, I can't imagine men having lived - and even living - their lives like this. And because it breaks my heart thinking about those men thinking they "already know they will never be so happy again" when it is all they deserve.

And just to make it clear: this is a book that will speak to your heart because it's a great book. I almost want to beg you not to read it but instead I will say this: at least don't read it on your summer holiday.
Profile Image for George Ilsley.
Author听12 books305 followers
September 5, 2022
Stop with your lies
This short novel has three chapters, labelled with the years 1984, 2007 and 2016. The first chapter (the longest) revolves around the affair between two teenage boys, and is told in the voice of one of them, a writer, looking back at his youth.

There's a saying I often reflected on reading this book: "Youth is wasted on the young." When I was young, I didn't really appreciate what this meant. Another related expression is "If only I knew then what I know now."

This is a first person narrative, told from the perspective of a writer named Philippe, and dedicated to Thomas (the other boy), so this raises questions about what really happened? Is is true? We only see things from Philippe's point of view; Thomas was always someone who couldn't talk about himself or his needs, and remains mysterious. Yet this is often true of relationships, no matter how much talking happens. How much do we truly know ourselves, much less another?

After I finished reading I discovered the original title was Arr锚te avec tes mensonges which throws a whole different light on the text. The English title "Lie With Me" evokes affection, not the telling of lies, but the French title "Stop with your lies" is confrontational. But who would be saying this or hearing this in the book? [Ha! Now I suddenly remember鈥攖his expression is from the very first page, and is something his mother said to Philippe when he made up stories about people鈥攁n obsession that became his career.]

Overall, a remarkable beautiful book about the limits of true storytelling and the true nature of fiction. Now I have to read more from this author!
Profile Image for Doug.
2,443 reviews837 followers
June 30, 2023
Update: 6/30/23 - the book has now received an excellent film adaptation, which I just saw for free through the AARP 'Films for Grownups' program - it should hopefully have a wide release soon. The trailer is here:
. After seeing the film, I decided to reread the book - they have vast differences - the book is more interior and cerebral - they had to 'invent' scenes in the film to capture those, and in some respects the film is actually better. But the book still remains eminently readable - and it only takes about 3 hours since it is so short. I was glad to have occasion to revisit it.

Sincere thanks to Netgalley and Scribner for an ARC of this book, in exchange for my honest review.

4.5, rounded up.

I am not ashamed to admit this left me teary-eyed with the ineffable sadness of the final pages, but the entire book had an almost galvanizing effect on me, since a lot of it hit very close to home ... as I suspect it will for many gay men of my generation. Although it's a story that will be familiar to many, Besson tells it in a perfunctory manner which proves exactly right for the material, and Ms. Ringwald (yes, THAT Molly Ringwald) does a terrific job in translating his prose into unfussy English.

It remains peculiar that the author insists this is a novel, since it is clearly memoir (the book is even dedicated to the 'real' man it is about, and Besson does not even bother to change his name - or his own) ... and I wish that the book had retained the more literal title 'Stop With Your Lies', although I am sure 'Lie With Me' makes it sound sexier. It also made me want to investigate Besson's back catalog, as he mentions several of his works within the book that sound equally intriguing.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 10,491 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.