What do you think?
Rate this book
Lavinia
In a richly imagined, beautiful new novel, an acclaimed writer gives an epic heroine her voice.
In The Aeneid, Virgil's hero fights to claim the king’s daughter, Lavinia, with whom he is destined to found an empire. Lavinia herself never speaks a word. Now, Ursula K. Le Guin gives Lavinia a voice in a novel that takes us to the half-wild world of ancient Italy, when Rome was a muddy village near seven hills.
Lavinia grows up knowing nothing but peace and freedom, until suitors come. Her mother wants her to marry handsome, ambitious Turnus. But omens and prophecies spoken by the sacred springs say she must marry a foreigner--that she will be the cause of a bitter war--and that her husband will not live long. When a fleet of Trojan ships sails up the Tiber, Lavinia decides to take her destiny into her own hands. And so she tells us what Virgil did not: the story of her life, and of the love of her life.
Lavinia is a book of passion and war, generous and austerely beautiful, from a writer working at the height of her powers.
In The Aeneid, Virgil's hero fights to claim the king’s daughter, Lavinia, with whom he is destined to found an empire. Lavinia herself never speaks a word. Now, Ursula K. Le Guin gives Lavinia a voice in a novel that takes us to the half-wild world of ancient Italy, when Rome was a muddy village near seven hills.
Lavinia grows up knowing nothing but peace and freedom, until suitors come. Her mother wants her to marry handsome, ambitious Turnus. But omens and prophecies spoken by the sacred springs say she must marry a foreigner--that she will be the cause of a bitter war--and that her husband will not live long. When a fleet of Trojan ships sails up the Tiber, Lavinia decides to take her destiny into her own hands. And so she tells us what Virgil did not: the story of her life, and of the love of her life.
Lavinia is a book of passion and war, generous and austerely beautiful, from a writer working at the height of her powers.
279 pages, Hardcover
First published April 21, 2008
1,384 people are currently reading
32.7k people want to read
About the author
Ursula K. Le Guin
866books28.3kfollowersUrsula K. Le Guin published twenty-two novels, eleven volumes of short stories, four collections of essays, twelve books for children, six volumes of poetry and four of translation, and has received many awards: Hugo, Nebula, National Book Award, PEN-Malamud, etc. Her recent publications include the novel Lavinia, an essay collection, Cheek by Jowl, and The Wild Girls. She lived in Portland, Oregon.
She was known for her treatment of gender (The Left Hand of Darkness, The Matter of Seggri), political systems (The Telling, The Dispossessed) and difference/otherness in any other form. Her interest in non-Western philosophies was reflected in works such as "Solitude" and The Telling but even more interesting are her imagined societies, often mixing traits extracted from her profound knowledge of anthropology acquired from growing up with her father, the famous anthropologist, Alfred Kroeber. The Hainish Cycle reflects the anthropologist's experience of immersing themselves in new strange cultures since most of their main characters and narrators (Le Guin favoured the first-person narration) are envoys from a humanitarian organization, the Ekumen, sent to investigate or ally themselves with the people of a different world and learn their ways.
She was known for her treatment of gender (The Left Hand of Darkness, The Matter of Seggri), political systems (The Telling, The Dispossessed) and difference/otherness in any other form. Her interest in non-Western philosophies was reflected in works such as "Solitude" and The Telling but even more interesting are her imagined societies, often mixing traits extracted from her profound knowledge of anthropology acquired from growing up with her father, the famous anthropologist, Alfred Kroeber. The Hainish Cycle reflects the anthropologist's experience of immersing themselves in new strange cultures since most of their main characters and narrators (Le Guin favoured the first-person narration) are envoys from a humanitarian organization, the Ekumen, sent to investigate or ally themselves with the people of a different world and learn their ways.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,379 reviews
January 28, 2019
鷡Ñ:
Otro libro de Le Guin que me FASCINA.
Es cierto, quizás no sea tan original y rompedora como otras de sus novelas, pero Lavinia, en su intimismo y ternura logra ser también sorprendentemente insólita.
En este libro asistimos a los acontecimientos de la Eneida pero todo contado desde el punto de vista de una mujer, y las batallas, guerras y peleas pierden importancia (aunque también son narradas) en favor de los ritos, las costumbres, tradiciones.
La primera mitad de la novela me llegó de una manera increíble, no deja de alucinarme la capacidad de esta autora para mostrarnos paisajes y costumbres de una manera que parece tan real y palpable. La segunda mitad me gustó un poquito menos pero aún así la disfruté muchísimo, la voz de Lavinia es maravillosa.
En fin, si os gustan las novelas con base tanto mitológica como Histórica no dejéis pasar la oportunidad de leer esta maravillosa novela, tan tan TAN bien escrita.
Otro libro de Le Guin que me FASCINA.
Es cierto, quizás no sea tan original y rompedora como otras de sus novelas, pero Lavinia, en su intimismo y ternura logra ser también sorprendentemente insólita.
En este libro asistimos a los acontecimientos de la Eneida pero todo contado desde el punto de vista de una mujer, y las batallas, guerras y peleas pierden importancia (aunque también son narradas) en favor de los ritos, las costumbres, tradiciones.
La primera mitad de la novela me llegó de una manera increíble, no deja de alucinarme la capacidad de esta autora para mostrarnos paisajes y costumbres de una manera que parece tan real y palpable. La segunda mitad me gustó un poquito menos pero aún así la disfruté muchísimo, la voz de Lavinia es maravillosa.
En fin, si os gustan las novelas con base tanto mitológica como Histórica no dejéis pasar la oportunidad de leer esta maravillosa novela, tan tan TAN bien escrita.
February 28, 2019
Is it possible that Ursula K. LeGuin can write a bad book?
I guess anything is possible: I could win the lottery, get hit by a meteorite, struck by lightning, etc. All very low probabilities.
As expected, this is beautifully written and crafted with an inspired structure. Telling the story of Lavinia, who in Vergil’s great work , did not speak a word; LeGuin describes the princess’s story in that of an almost pre-historic and pagan setting.
This is really the element of this story that I will take with me: this vision of a simple life when Rome was not yet founded and the hills in what would someday become the greatest city in the world were populated with early tribes, farms and lives that would be legend.
LeGuin creates an unusual narrative device in which Lavinia comes to know “her poet� as Vergil is illuminated as a time travelling specter from the future, mystically visiting his subject as he survived a fever dream in the time of Augustus. Interestingly, almost in an existential awareness of her self as a character in the epic.
Told with unassuming but descriptive language, and with her inimitable style, Lavinia was a pleasure to read.
I guess anything is possible: I could win the lottery, get hit by a meteorite, struck by lightning, etc. All very low probabilities.
As expected, this is beautifully written and crafted with an inspired structure. Telling the story of Lavinia, who in Vergil’s great work , did not speak a word; LeGuin describes the princess’s story in that of an almost pre-historic and pagan setting.
This is really the element of this story that I will take with me: this vision of a simple life when Rome was not yet founded and the hills in what would someday become the greatest city in the world were populated with early tribes, farms and lives that would be legend.
LeGuin creates an unusual narrative device in which Lavinia comes to know “her poet� as Vergil is illuminated as a time travelling specter from the future, mystically visiting his subject as he survived a fever dream in the time of Augustus. Interestingly, almost in an existential awareness of her self as a character in the epic.
Told with unassuming but descriptive language, and with her inimitable style, Lavinia was a pleasure to read.
March 12, 2020
DNF at page 180
I’m sad, I thought I’d love this but there doesn’t seem to be anything different in here than is in The Aeneid. It’s just from Lavinia’s perspective but all the events are the same, and I’m bored 😑
I’m sad, I thought I’d love this but there doesn’t seem to be anything different in here than is in The Aeneid. It’s just from Lavinia’s perspective but all the events are the same, and I’m bored 😑
September 12, 2008
“I am not the feminine voice you may have expected�
When my father told me that Ursula LeGuin had put out a new novel, I was, as I usually am, ecstatic. LeGuin is one of my all time favorite authors, and I can’t think of time when she’s written something that has somehow failed to engage, entertain, or intrigue me. The fact that she was, apparently, riffing off Virgil’s Aeneid was just icing on the cake for this poor excuse for a classical studies major.
When the book arrived, I found myself looking at the cover and suddenly wondering what the heck this book was about. As much as I tried, I could not remember the character of Lavinia from my previous readings of the Aeneid in the slightest (the best I could do was to temporarily confuse her with Dido). My guilt at my poor powers of memory was a bit assuaged when, after some checking, I realized that Lavinia only barely appears within the Aeneid, and never speaks at all. It’s no surprise I don’t remember her. Indeed, it’s a wonder that many people do.
The notion of taking an old story and telling a different side of it is a popular one these days, and I confess I’m not terribly up on the sub-genre (which seems to include things like The Red Tent, Mists of Avalon, and Lady Macbeth, among others), so I can’t compare it fairly to other authors efforts. It is a sub-genre that seems potentially filled with a lot of anger; how easy would it be for Lavinia (or any of these voiceless women) to rage against the world that so long ignored them? How simple would it be to tell a story about how the men screwed everything up, and the women were doing everything right?
Easy though it might be, LeGuin doesn’t do anything of the kind. Her Lavinia (who is curiously aware of her meta-fictional existence) is very, well, ancient Roman. She is strong, but conscious of her duty. She has a strong sense of the importance of family. She genuinely loves Aeneas, and her insights into Aeneas are interesting, and very much in line with what I remember of the Aeneid (which I confess is precious little). The entire story is told by Lavinia herself, a decision that allows LeGuin to really get into her protagonists mind, and produce a very different, interesting, and very real vision of a part of the Aeneid that Virgil did not get to.
I think that is the thing that makes me enjoy Lavinia so much; it is LeGuin’s addition to the myth. Not a refutation, or an attack, but merely another side of part of the story. A side as compelling, powerful, and insightful as the original itself. Unquestionably worth the read.
Next time: I have no idea. Not really sure what to read next, though I’m tempted to read the Aeneid again. I’ll have to go scan the shelves.
July 28, 2008
It's interesting to contrast this with Margaret Atwood's Penelopiad. Both explore one of the Big Classics (The Aeneid in LeGuin's case, the Odyssey in Atwood's) from a female character's perspective. LeGuin and Atwood are both stellar writers, but I enjoyed Lavinia vastly more. LeGuin seems to have a real affection for her characters, and that makes for a warmer, more humane book.
You can't tackle such a project without exploring the constraints placed on women in ancient times, but again, the authors take two very different approaches. Atwood focuses on the oppression of women, but LeGuin (who has always shown an appreciation for the beauties of everyday life) convincingly explores how women could find fulfillment and power within the roles allowed them.
You can't tackle such a project without exploring the constraints placed on women in ancient times, but again, the authors take two very different approaches. Atwood focuses on the oppression of women, but LeGuin (who has always shown an appreciation for the beauties of everyday life) convincingly explores how women could find fulfillment and power within the roles allowed them.
June 11, 2008
I thought this book was boring. There, I said it. Even though it had passion, war, bloodshed, royal intrigue, suicide, I found it boring and it was difficult for me to convince myself to continue reading it. I am a classic history buff, which this novel has loads of, but it still couldn't grip my interest. The tone of the book was quiet and ghostly, very in the past so I never felt anything immediate. It was a story told by someone who remembered facts, places, names, etc. and spoke of emotion, but I never felt it. I think this book was well reviewed, so I am sure many people would have a different experience, I was just not that keen on it.
July 8, 2008
Back when I studied Latin, we were given bits of Virgil's "Aeneid" to translate. I always found it to be a chore, as poetry is more challenging to translate than textbook translating exercises like "Roma est in Italia." Still, I thought I knew the piece sufficiently until hearing that Ursula Le Guin had written a book about a character from "Aeneid" but having no idea who Lavinia was. Having now read "Aeneid" in its translated entirety, I can't really fault myself for not remembering Lavinia. She has no spoken lines, no characterization, and her function in the story is simply to be the prize of quarreling factions. In other words, hers was a story that benefited greatly from being told with care and respect.
Part of the brilliance in Le Guin's book lies in her ability to seamlessly weave a rich and detailed story for Lavinia in the greater fabric of Virgil's epic. Le Guin makes the strange world of Bronze Age Italy a place one can feel and taste, a place where the influence of oracles and gods is clearly felt. She eschews Virgil's humanlike gods for dead that speak through sacred places, which allows for the well-executed meta-conceit of having a dying Virgil learn how egregiously he mistreated Lavinia in his unfinished masterpiece, which Le Guin suggests as a fanciful reason for Virgil's request that the incomplete "Aeneid" be burned upon his death. She takes no liberties with "Aeneid" as it stands- the story is familiar from the point that Aeneas enters the scene to the time that Turnus departs it. As delightful as it is to see Virgil's epic through an Italian princess's more frank and sensible perspective, it's a tragic and brief part of Lavinia's story, both as a person and as a character in a seemingly immortal piece of literature.
In her notes, Le Guin laments that "Aeneid" is rarely taught in its entirety or original language nowadays. Her book is an eloquent and compelling tribute to Virgil and a gentle reminder to the world's readers that the ancient stories are well worth reading. I highly recommend this story to anyone looking for an impetus to revisit early masterpieces of western literature as well as those who enjoy thoughtful historical fiction.
Part of the brilliance in Le Guin's book lies in her ability to seamlessly weave a rich and detailed story for Lavinia in the greater fabric of Virgil's epic. Le Guin makes the strange world of Bronze Age Italy a place one can feel and taste, a place where the influence of oracles and gods is clearly felt. She eschews Virgil's humanlike gods for dead that speak through sacred places, which allows for the well-executed meta-conceit of having a dying Virgil learn how egregiously he mistreated Lavinia in his unfinished masterpiece, which Le Guin suggests as a fanciful reason for Virgil's request that the incomplete "Aeneid" be burned upon his death. She takes no liberties with "Aeneid" as it stands- the story is familiar from the point that Aeneas enters the scene to the time that Turnus departs it. As delightful as it is to see Virgil's epic through an Italian princess's more frank and sensible perspective, it's a tragic and brief part of Lavinia's story, both as a person and as a character in a seemingly immortal piece of literature.
In her notes, Le Guin laments that "Aeneid" is rarely taught in its entirety or original language nowadays. Her book is an eloquent and compelling tribute to Virgil and a gentle reminder to the world's readers that the ancient stories are well worth reading. I highly recommend this story to anyone looking for an impetus to revisit early masterpieces of western literature as well as those who enjoy thoughtful historical fiction.
July 23, 2009
Being a lady classicist often requires willful acts of cognitive dissonance. It's not just that nearly all your extant source material was written by men, about men, for men, it's also that Greek and Roman culture, particularly the culture portrayed in the great epics (the Iliad, the Odyssey, and the Aeneid) is brutally testosterone-fueled and flagrantly anti-woman. In epic, the worst women are pure, unadulterated evil--monsters like Scylla, Charybdis, and the Sirens. Slightly less evil are those who use their sexual wiles to distract men from their noble purposes--Circe, Calypso, Dido. And "good" women are those who simply shut the fuck up, bear legitimate children, and get out of the way--Andromache, Penelope, Creusa. This makes reading epic a challenging experience for any woman who is looking for more than just a rollicking adventure story.
I read the Aeneid in high school, the whole thing in English and about half of it in Latin (skipping around for the best bits, or course), and I was a huge pain in the ass. I was convinced that Aeneas was a douche, that Creusa got screwed over, that Dido got royally screwed over and should have ripped Aeneas's balls off, and that Lavinia was a breed sow with pretty hair. My poor teacher tried again and again to calm me down, to remind me of the historical context and cultural differences that should have been informing my reading of the poem, to point out the elegance of the scansion or the cleverness of various poetic devices, but I just didn't buy it. I absorbed enough to ace the AP test, but the Aeneid left a bad taste in my mouth. When I got to college and read the Greek epics I was a bit better at detaching myself from the content of the poems so that I could appreciate their language and structure, but I still had to work hard to keep a lid on my roiling feminist ire. My biggest flaw as a historian, the reason why I decided to teach Latin to middle schoolers instead of going to graduate school, is that I get too emotionally invested in whatever I am studying, and am unable to confine my judgments to the appropriate historical context. I may acknowledge the fact that Aeneas was the model of pietas for his time and place, but in the here and now he'd be a douche, and I just can't forget that.
This is why Lavinia is such a wonderful book. Le Guin does that forgetting for me. She is able to immerse herself in a different time and place and culture in a way that is judgment-free, and she sells this world in such a way that I buy it. And like it. And enjoy it. The angry feminist pot ceases to boil. I actually like this Aeneas. He seems to be a nice guy. I really like and identify with this Lavinia, and I support her choices, whereas in the Aeneid I simply pitied her for not having any choices. I understand and appreciate a concept of pietas that is completely different from the kind of piety or rightness I seek in my own life, in a way that I was never able to understand it when I was reading the actual Aeneid. Part of what makes this novel work for me is the way she strips the story of Aeneas of its Augustan influences--Vergil originally wrote the poem as a propaganda piece for the emperor (okay, maybe that wasn't his only purpose, but he had to throw it in there to keep the people in charge happy), and the ostentatious wealth and fantastical religion it promotes help divorce it from reality and make it harder to relate to. Le Guin's simpler version feels much more authentic and relatable.
I did find the book a little hard to get into, and I had a hard time wrapping my mind around the relationship between Lavinia and Vergil. But overall, I found it an extremely enjoyable and readable story that left me with warm fuzzies inside. It may actually motivate me to reread the Latin Aeneid sometime soon-ish (if I can find my old book), and to not be full of fiery rage when I do. That's a good thing, right?
I read the Aeneid in high school, the whole thing in English and about half of it in Latin (skipping around for the best bits, or course), and I was a huge pain in the ass. I was convinced that Aeneas was a douche, that Creusa got screwed over, that Dido got royally screwed over and should have ripped Aeneas's balls off, and that Lavinia was a breed sow with pretty hair. My poor teacher tried again and again to calm me down, to remind me of the historical context and cultural differences that should have been informing my reading of the poem, to point out the elegance of the scansion or the cleverness of various poetic devices, but I just didn't buy it. I absorbed enough to ace the AP test, but the Aeneid left a bad taste in my mouth. When I got to college and read the Greek epics I was a bit better at detaching myself from the content of the poems so that I could appreciate their language and structure, but I still had to work hard to keep a lid on my roiling feminist ire. My biggest flaw as a historian, the reason why I decided to teach Latin to middle schoolers instead of going to graduate school, is that I get too emotionally invested in whatever I am studying, and am unable to confine my judgments to the appropriate historical context. I may acknowledge the fact that Aeneas was the model of pietas for his time and place, but in the here and now he'd be a douche, and I just can't forget that.
This is why Lavinia is such a wonderful book. Le Guin does that forgetting for me. She is able to immerse herself in a different time and place and culture in a way that is judgment-free, and she sells this world in such a way that I buy it. And like it. And enjoy it. The angry feminist pot ceases to boil. I actually like this Aeneas. He seems to be a nice guy. I really like and identify with this Lavinia, and I support her choices, whereas in the Aeneid I simply pitied her for not having any choices. I understand and appreciate a concept of pietas that is completely different from the kind of piety or rightness I seek in my own life, in a way that I was never able to understand it when I was reading the actual Aeneid. Part of what makes this novel work for me is the way she strips the story of Aeneas of its Augustan influences--Vergil originally wrote the poem as a propaganda piece for the emperor (okay, maybe that wasn't his only purpose, but he had to throw it in there to keep the people in charge happy), and the ostentatious wealth and fantastical religion it promotes help divorce it from reality and make it harder to relate to. Le Guin's simpler version feels much more authentic and relatable.
I did find the book a little hard to get into, and I had a hard time wrapping my mind around the relationship between Lavinia and Vergil. But overall, I found it an extremely enjoyable and readable story that left me with warm fuzzies inside. It may actually motivate me to reread the Latin Aeneid sometime soon-ish (if I can find my old book), and to not be full of fiery rage when I do. That's a good thing, right?
February 13, 2018
goodreads’in sayısal hedefinin yanısıra bizim büyük challenge’ımız benim için yetip artsa da kendime minik hedefler koymadan duramıyorum. her sene mutlaka bir yaşar kemal ve ursula k. le guin okumak bunlardan bazıları. bu sene de alıp alıp yığdığım ursulalarımdan hangisini okusam diye düşünürken kendisinin vefat haberini alınca elimdeki kitap (ki o da bir yaşar kemal kitabıydı) biter bitmez kütüphanemdeki en eski ursula kitabına gitti ellerim. nisan 2010’da, üniversite son sınıftayken son kez gittiğim izmir tüyap kitap fuarında almışım; “nisan 2010� yazmışım ön sayfasına. kitaba başlar başlamaz sekiz yıldır neyi bekliyordum diye kendime kızsam da, aslında belki de kitap tam zamanını buldu diye düşünmeden de edemedim. koca bir destanın içinde üç mısrayla anılan bir karaktere can vermek de ursula ninemize yakışırdı. o üç mısradan ilham alıp böyle ayrı bir destan doğurmak kelimelerimin yetmeyeceği iltifatları hak ediyor. kadın olmayı her yönüyle o kadar güzel algılamış ve o kadar güzel anlatıyor ki, çok sevdiğim kitaplar hakkında hep söylediğim gibi; “okurken kitabı ısırasım geldi.� sevdiğim yazarlar çoktan ölmüşse zaten kıyamayarak okuyorum ama nasılsa hayatta diye rahat rahat okurken vefat edince iyice panik duygusu sarıyor içimi. böyle de bencilim. lavinia’yla ilgili güzel olan ise, artık okumaya kıyamayacağım ursula k. le guin kitaplarından birini tam zamanında, severek, hatta zevkten ölerek okudum; yani “boşa gitmedi.�
August 18, 2018
"Oh, never and forever aren't for mortals, love."
Le Guin writes wonderful women and stories that honor them. Lavinia is a whole book written from the perspective of a character that never utters a word in Vergil's epic, The Aeneid. It tells of all the life that happens between "the glorious battles", the farming, the herding, hunting and reading of the auspices, caring for the hearth gods, weaving, songs and observances -- the reasons we war in the first place.
Lavinia is presented as an ideal female: a faithful daughter, dedicated wife, and strong mother. The transitions between those phases is beautifully narrated. I especially found the duties depicted, the rituals so natural and comforting. I was wondering how I managed not to have any knowledge of Latium, honestly, I was disappointed in myself, and was relieved to read in the Afterword that there is indeed little to no record of the original Latins. Etruscans, yes and Magna Graecia too, of which I have some understanding. The auspices were rightfully given to an Etruscan character to read, but believably Latinus, Lavinia's father received omens from his forefathers in the sacred places. Overall, it was a delightfully woven tale of life in pre-ancient Rome.
Le Guin writes wonderful women and stories that honor them. Lavinia is a whole book written from the perspective of a character that never utters a word in Vergil's epic, The Aeneid. It tells of all the life that happens between "the glorious battles", the farming, the herding, hunting and reading of the auspices, caring for the hearth gods, weaving, songs and observances -- the reasons we war in the first place.
I think if you have lost a great happiness and try to recall it, you're only asking for sorrow, but if you do not try to dwell on the happiness, sometimes you find it dwelling in your heart and body, silent but sustaining.
Lavinia is presented as an ideal female: a faithful daughter, dedicated wife, and strong mother. The transitions between those phases is beautifully narrated. I especially found the duties depicted, the rituals so natural and comforting. I was wondering how I managed not to have any knowledge of Latium, honestly, I was disappointed in myself, and was relieved to read in the Afterword that there is indeed little to no record of the original Latins. Etruscans, yes and Magna Graecia too, of which I have some understanding. The auspices were rightfully given to an Etruscan character to read, but believably Latinus, Lavinia's father received omens from his forefathers in the sacred places. Overall, it was a delightfully woven tale of life in pre-ancient Rome.
March 4, 2021
"El nombe del mundo es bosque" me impactó tantísimo que no pasaron ni dos semanas cuando ya estaba leyendo "Lavinia". En este caso la temática es completamente opuesta, y es que en esta novela vamos a asistir a una narración apasionante donde Ursula K. Le Guin dota de una nueva vida a los personajes de la Eneida de Virgilio, narrados desde el punto de vista de una mujer, Lavinia. Esta predijo la llegada del troyano Eneas a Lacio, después de 10 años navegando los mares tras huir de la guerra de Troya, y todo lo que cambiaría con esta.
Lo primero que destaca es Lavinia, su gran protagonista. Es ella el eje de toda la historia y todo gira en torno a sus decisiones. A través de las páginas vemos a una mujer apasionada, luchadora y dueña de sus acciones. Me ha encantado ver como la autora dota a la protagonista de ese toque feminista, donde lucha por no ser silenciada por ser mujer. En muchísimas escenas logra darle la vuelta a eso, en una época donde las mujeres nada podían objetar. Un acierto total que la autora haya decidido coger a un personaje secundario dentro de la obra de Virgilio y centrarlo todo desde su óptica.
Otro de sus puntos fuertes es que está mucho más centrado en temas como la tradición y los ritos propios de las costumbres de los pueblos de la época, que en mostrarnos los combates propios de la guerra que se desencadena. También se muestra, pero tiene menos peso. La autora trata de reflejar como pudieron ser todas estas costumbres tanto en referencia a los latinos como a los griegos, y el choque entre las de unos y otros. Por ejemplo, la libertad y los derechos más equitativos de mujeres y hombres en la antigua Italia, chocaba con como los griegos trataban a sus mujeres como seres inferiores. Este choque me ha parecido muy bien tratado a través de Lavinia.
Me he quedado con ganitas de saber algo más de la historia de amor entre Ascanio y Atis, ojalá un libro sobre eso. También he disfrutado mucho de las descripciones de los distintos lugares que aparecen y la naturaleza que les rodea, todo muy evocador. Y por supusto el "detalle" del poeta en la novela y su significado me ha parecido increíble. Ya estoy pensando cual será el tercer encuentro con esta autora maravillosa, que desde ya apunta a convertirse en una de mis predilectas.
Lo primero que destaca es Lavinia, su gran protagonista. Es ella el eje de toda la historia y todo gira en torno a sus decisiones. A través de las páginas vemos a una mujer apasionada, luchadora y dueña de sus acciones. Me ha encantado ver como la autora dota a la protagonista de ese toque feminista, donde lucha por no ser silenciada por ser mujer. En muchísimas escenas logra darle la vuelta a eso, en una época donde las mujeres nada podían objetar. Un acierto total que la autora haya decidido coger a un personaje secundario dentro de la obra de Virgilio y centrarlo todo desde su óptica.
Otro de sus puntos fuertes es que está mucho más centrado en temas como la tradición y los ritos propios de las costumbres de los pueblos de la época, que en mostrarnos los combates propios de la guerra que se desencadena. También se muestra, pero tiene menos peso. La autora trata de reflejar como pudieron ser todas estas costumbres tanto en referencia a los latinos como a los griegos, y el choque entre las de unos y otros. Por ejemplo, la libertad y los derechos más equitativos de mujeres y hombres en la antigua Italia, chocaba con como los griegos trataban a sus mujeres como seres inferiores. Este choque me ha parecido muy bien tratado a través de Lavinia.
Me he quedado con ganitas de saber algo más de la historia de amor entre Ascanio y Atis, ojalá un libro sobre eso. También he disfrutado mucho de las descripciones de los distintos lugares que aparecen y la naturaleza que les rodea, todo muy evocador. Y por supusto el "detalle" del poeta en la novela y su significado me ha parecido increíble. Ya estoy pensando cual será el tercer encuentro con esta autora maravillosa, que desde ya apunta a convertirse en una de mis predilectas.
June 19, 2020
Η σχέση μου με την Le Guin έχει ξεκινήσει από τα πανεπιστημιακά μου χρόνια και έκτοτε διατηρεί την ίδια ένταση. Κι αν πέρασαν τόσοι συγγραφείς από τη ζωή μου και τα γούστα μου άλλαξαν –ενίοτ�- ριζικά μέσα στον χρόνο, αυτή η αγάπη (από τις πρώτες!) παρέμεινε αναλλοίωτη κι εγώ της παρέμεινα πιστός.
Και στην περίπτωση της "Λαβίνια", ενός από τα τελευταία έργα της, όχι μόνο δεν με απογοήτευσε, αλλά πέτυχε να με συνεπάρει ως την τελευταία σελίδα. Εμπνευσμένη από το έπος του Βιργιλίου, διόλου ανταγωνιστικά αλλά μόνο επ' αφορμή, η Le Guin εμφυσά ζωή στη γυναίκα Λαβίνια (μετέπειτα σύζυγο του Αινεία), για να διηγηθεί με τον μοναδικό της τρόπο την ιστορία της. Απολαυστική, αυθεντικά θηλυκή και ακριβώς γι' αυτό αγαπημένη.
Και στην περίπτωση της "Λαβίνια", ενός από τα τελευταία έργα της, όχι μόνο δεν με απογοήτευσε, αλλά πέτυχε να με συνεπάρει ως την τελευταία σελίδα. Εμπνευσμένη από το έπος του Βιργιλίου, διόλου ανταγωνιστικά αλλά μόνο επ' αφορμή, η Le Guin εμφυσά ζωή στη γυναίκα Λαβίνια (μετέπειτα σύζυγο του Αινεία), για να διηγηθεί με τον μοναδικό της τρόπο την ιστορία της. Απολαυστική, αυθεντικά θηλυκή και ακριβώς γι' αυτό αγαπημένη.
April 16, 2020
"In truth he gave me nothing but a name, and I have filled it with myself. Yet without him would I even have a name? I have never blamed him. Even a poet cannot get everything right."
If you were looking for a quote do describe the central concern of this book, the above might do it.
I was deeply moved by this book and the tale it weaves and the respect with which it treats its characters and subjects like love, fate, and the power of stories. I love its intertextuality and how much it is in conversation with its source text (and other works) and how vividly a picture it painted of pre-Roman Italy. (Le Guin, unsurprisingly, really did her research and brought it to bear masterfully.)
I thought this might be a 5-star read in the beginning, but there was a part in the middle that made me tend towards 4 stars. And then the ending once again pushed it back up to 5 stars.
If you were looking for a quote do describe the central concern of this book, the above might do it.
I was deeply moved by this book and the tale it weaves and the respect with which it treats its characters and subjects like love, fate, and the power of stories. I love its intertextuality and how much it is in conversation with its source text (and other works) and how vividly a picture it painted of pre-Roman Italy. (Le Guin, unsurprisingly, really did her research and brought it to bear masterfully.)
I thought this might be a 5-star read in the beginning, but there was a part in the middle that made me tend towards 4 stars. And then the ending once again pushed it back up to 5 stars.
May 29, 2020
I think I'm incapable of disliking a Le Guin book. So, 5 stars it is.
I'm not a huge fan of the retelling of mythological stories and the like from the stand point of a woman. But this was written by Le Guin and here I am. I have had this on my shelf since shortly after it was written. I bought it in hardcover in Missoula, where my brother lives. But the real reason that I've waited so long to read it is because I only discovered UKL in my early to mid twenties. Back then she was already 60-something and after I devoured quite a lot of her core oeuvre, I realized that if I read all of it, I may have quite a lot of my own life during which I wouldn't have a "new' Le Guin to read. So, I've been "hoarding" her books for the past 15 - 20 years. Now I only have 2 more novels to read, plus a couple short story collections, her older poetry collections and most of her non-fiction. So, what does this have to do with this book? Not much, I suppose, but it may explain my unmitigated love for this book. Absence makes the heart grow fonder. And reconnecting with Le Guin's writing made my heart sing.
The story itself follows Virgil's Aeneid, but only the part when he lands in Italy near-ish Rome and settles there, fights a war, and marries a Latin girl named Lavinia. The story is told from Lavinia's perspective. and the conceit that she is someone the Poet created and to whom he gave very little time in the Aeneid. She is self-aware which makes for an interesting twist in the story. She's filling in the details, the structure and what Aeneas does are all set. The beginning and the end, before and after Aeneas are perhaps the most interesting parts for me, but I enjoyed the middle just as well.
That this book is soooo good is no surprise to me. She could've written a grocery list and I'd love it, but I do wonder why this didn't get many awards? Just the Locus award, as far as I can tell.
I'm not a huge fan of the retelling of mythological stories and the like from the stand point of a woman. But this was written by Le Guin and here I am. I have had this on my shelf since shortly after it was written. I bought it in hardcover in Missoula, where my brother lives. But the real reason that I've waited so long to read it is because I only discovered UKL in my early to mid twenties. Back then she was already 60-something and after I devoured quite a lot of her core oeuvre, I realized that if I read all of it, I may have quite a lot of my own life during which I wouldn't have a "new' Le Guin to read. So, I've been "hoarding" her books for the past 15 - 20 years. Now I only have 2 more novels to read, plus a couple short story collections, her older poetry collections and most of her non-fiction. So, what does this have to do with this book? Not much, I suppose, but it may explain my unmitigated love for this book. Absence makes the heart grow fonder. And reconnecting with Le Guin's writing made my heart sing.
The story itself follows Virgil's Aeneid, but only the part when he lands in Italy near-ish Rome and settles there, fights a war, and marries a Latin girl named Lavinia. The story is told from Lavinia's perspective. and the conceit that she is someone the Poet created and to whom he gave very little time in the Aeneid. She is self-aware which makes for an interesting twist in the story. She's filling in the details, the structure and what Aeneas does are all set. The beginning and the end, before and after Aeneas are perhaps the most interesting parts for me, but I enjoyed the middle just as well.
That this book is soooo good is no surprise to me. She could've written a grocery list and I'd love it, but I do wonder why this didn't get many awards? Just the Locus award, as far as I can tell.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 5, 2024
Şimdiye kadar Ursula K. Le Guin’in hep sosyal bilimkurgu ya da fantastik türünde yazdığı kitapları; Yerdeniz serisi ve Hainish Cyle’ın ilk altı kitabını okumuştum. O yüzden Lavinia benim için bir açıdan kendisiyle yeniden tanışma kitabı oldu.
Öncelikle, ben retelling okumayı seviyorum. Tabii bu kitaptan kitaba değişiyor, mesela Troya Savaşı sırasında “enfeksiyondan öldüler� gibi tabirlerle karşılaştığımda göz devirmeden devam edebildiğim anlamına gelmiyor. Ancak genel olarak -iyi uyarlamalarla karşılaştığımda- çok keyif aldığım türlerden birisi. Lavinia da bu türün en iyilerinden. Özellikle de Ursula K. Le Guin’in yeni evrenler ve gerçeklikler kurarken yarattığı mistik ve okurunu ele geçiren yapı burada muazzam bir şekilde ön plana çıkıyor. Mesela Albunea ormanına adeta Lavinia ile birlikte gidiyorsunuz, kükürt kokusunu, ormanın nemini ve taşların soğukluğunu hissediyor, Vergilius ile siz karşılaşıyorsunuz. Aynı anda oldukça gerçekçi ve bir o kadar büyülü bir ortamın içine hiç yadırgamadan çekiliyorsunuz. O yüzden kendisinin elinden çıkmış bir retelling okumanın tatmini eşsiz. Ancak şunu da eklemeden geçemeyeceğim özellikle de sonlarına doğru, anlatı artık Aeneas’tan tamamen ayrıldığında retellinglerin genel yqpısı ortaya çıkıyor. Bilinen varyasyonlarından tamamen farklı bir yönde; insanlığın ortaya çıktığı günden beri var olan sorunlara, yakın dönem bakış açısıyla değiniyor. Ancak kendisinin de sonsözde belirttiği gibi tam olarak gerçeği takip eden bir hikaye yazma gayesi yok. Dünya tarihinin en önemli edebi eserlerinden birisinde bütün hikayenin etrafında geliştiği o kadının sessiz bırakılması üzerinden bu konuyu ele almak istiyor elbette. Ben de bu durumu olumsuz bir kırılım olarak görmedim ben de. Zaten retellinglerde dönemin temel dili ya da yaşam şekli gibi temel konularda bir uyumsuzluk olmadığı sürece temel öyküyü takip etmesi gibi bir beklentim yok benim de. O yüzden beni asla üzmedi açıkcası.
Özetle benim çok sevdiğim, okurken her mekanı ve karakteriyle zihnime işlenen bir kitap oldu. Hazır dönemi bu kadar içselleştirmişken sanırım bir süre daha buralarda olacağım ve yolum Kartaca Kraliçesi, Dido ve Dönüşümler ile devam edeceğim. Umarım finali de Vergilius’un Ölümü ile yapabilirim. Son olarak bana @hinoandthebooks un yaptığı ve gerçekten kitabın keyfini arttıran Aeneis’ten sonra okuma uyarısını eklemeden geçemeyeceğim.
Öncelikle, ben retelling okumayı seviyorum. Tabii bu kitaptan kitaba değişiyor, mesela Troya Savaşı sırasında “enfeksiyondan öldüler� gibi tabirlerle karşılaştığımda göz devirmeden devam edebildiğim anlamına gelmiyor. Ancak genel olarak -iyi uyarlamalarla karşılaştığımda- çok keyif aldığım türlerden birisi. Lavinia da bu türün en iyilerinden. Özellikle de Ursula K. Le Guin’in yeni evrenler ve gerçeklikler kurarken yarattığı mistik ve okurunu ele geçiren yapı burada muazzam bir şekilde ön plana çıkıyor. Mesela Albunea ormanına adeta Lavinia ile birlikte gidiyorsunuz, kükürt kokusunu, ormanın nemini ve taşların soğukluğunu hissediyor, Vergilius ile siz karşılaşıyorsunuz. Aynı anda oldukça gerçekçi ve bir o kadar büyülü bir ortamın içine hiç yadırgamadan çekiliyorsunuz. O yüzden kendisinin elinden çıkmış bir retelling okumanın tatmini eşsiz. Ancak şunu da eklemeden geçemeyeceğim özellikle de sonlarına doğru, anlatı artık Aeneas’tan tamamen ayrıldığında retellinglerin genel yqpısı ortaya çıkıyor. Bilinen varyasyonlarından tamamen farklı bir yönde; insanlığın ortaya çıktığı günden beri var olan sorunlara, yakın dönem bakış açısıyla değiniyor. Ancak kendisinin de sonsözde belirttiği gibi tam olarak gerçeği takip eden bir hikaye yazma gayesi yok. Dünya tarihinin en önemli edebi eserlerinden birisinde bütün hikayenin etrafında geliştiği o kadının sessiz bırakılması üzerinden bu konuyu ele almak istiyor elbette. Ben de bu durumu olumsuz bir kırılım olarak görmedim ben de. Zaten retellinglerde dönemin temel dili ya da yaşam şekli gibi temel konularda bir uyumsuzluk olmadığı sürece temel öyküyü takip etmesi gibi bir beklentim yok benim de. O yüzden beni asla üzmedi açıkcası.
Özetle benim çok sevdiğim, okurken her mekanı ve karakteriyle zihnime işlenen bir kitap oldu. Hazır dönemi bu kadar içselleştirmişken sanırım bir süre daha buralarda olacağım ve yolum Kartaca Kraliçesi, Dido ve Dönüşümler ile devam edeceğim. Umarım finali de Vergilius’un Ölümü ile yapabilirim. Son olarak bana @hinoandthebooks un yaptığı ve gerçekten kitabın keyfini arttıran Aeneis’ten sonra okuma uyarısını eklemeden geçemeyeceğim.
November 9, 2020
"Eneas se había mantenido en la sombra del portal, silencioso e inmóvil, observándome. Al terminar mis ofrendas, me quedé quieta y levanté la mirada hacia él. Formuló entonces la pregunta que se ha de formular:
—¿Quién eres?
Y yo le di la respuesta que se ha de dar:
—Si tú eres Gaio, yo soy Gaia.
Entonces, con una repentina y amplia sonrisa, se adelantó, me cogió en brazos, cruzó conmigo al otro lado del umbral y me depositó allí. De este modo me convertí en su esposa y en la madre de nuestro pueblo, el suyo y el mío."
� Ursula K. Le Guin, 'Lavinia'.
A veces, cuando acabo un libro, no puedo remediar el impulso y lo abrazo. Lo abrazo con cariño en agradecimiento al maravilloso momento de lectura que me ha proporcionado, y en homenaje al escritor que le dio vida.
'Lavinia', mi primera incursión en la obra de Ursula K. Le Guin, ha sido uno de esos libros que he terminado abrazando.
Si conocéis a grandes rasgos la historia de la Eneida, quizá resuenen en vuestra memoria algunos episodios del periplo vivido por Eneas y sus acompañantes, desde que salieran de la destruida Troya, hasta su llegada al enclave del Lacio que más tarde vería nacer a la legendaria Roma.
En 'Lavinia' Ursula K. Le Guin recupera los hechos narrados en los últimos seis cantos del poema épico original, pero dándoles un punto de vista completamente distinto. Si en la Eneida, la joven Lavinia no pronuncia ni una sola frase, ahora es ella quien toma la palabra para narrar, en primera persona, su historia. El resultado es tan hermoso que no creo poder hacerle justicia.
La profecía dijo a Lavinia, hija de un respetado rey latino, que estaba destinada a rechazar a todos sus pretendientes para casarse con un hombre extranjero. Uno de esos hombres que ella misma, a escondidas, ha visto remontando el curso del Tíber. Una guerra estallará entonces entre su propio pueblo y los recién llegados...tras la destrucción llegará un matrimonio y, entonces, la profecía estará cumplida.
Con qué placer he seguido los pasos de Lavinia, desde los días de su niñez, correteando entre colinas, bosques y playas, hasta el momento en que se convierte en esposa, madre y leyenda.
Su precioso testimonio está plagado de vívidas descripciones de la vida cotidiana en el palacio de su padre y de los parajes que lo rodean.
Conforme avanza la narración somos testigos de antiguas creencias y costumbres; de las tareas que cambian con el paso de las estaciones; y, en cada escena, nos perdemos con deleite en una atmósfera única que tiene el aura de las antiguas narraciones míticas.
La vida de Lavinia está marcada por el amor de su padre y de su tierra; por una extraña profecía y por las conversaciones con cierto poeta, que misteriosamente conoce los entresijos de su propia vida y la del hombre que se convertirá en su esposo...un poeta que aparece cada noche entre las sombras para contar a la joven lo que fue, es y será...
No quiero contaros nada más, os dejo el privilegio de adentraros, casi a oscuras, en esta maravillosa novela que ha resultado ser un enorme coup de cœur para mi.
Entre mito, historia y leyenda, Ursula K. le Guin consigue recrear a la vez un tiempo mítico y un tiempo histórico perdidos; el tiempo mítico de la Eneida de Virgilio, que L. Guin alarga más allá de la última línea en que calló el poeta (para así poder narrar la vida completa de Lavinia); y el tiempo histórico de aquellos pequeños reinos y aldeas del Lacio de la Edad del Bronce, por los que andaron dioses y héroes; mujeres y hombres de carne y hueso.
Los antepasados de un gran imperio, que nació en una pequeña aldea dormida entre siete colinas...
—¿Quién eres?
Y yo le di la respuesta que se ha de dar:
—Si tú eres Gaio, yo soy Gaia.
Entonces, con una repentina y amplia sonrisa, se adelantó, me cogió en brazos, cruzó conmigo al otro lado del umbral y me depositó allí. De este modo me convertí en su esposa y en la madre de nuestro pueblo, el suyo y el mío."
� Ursula K. Le Guin, 'Lavinia'.
A veces, cuando acabo un libro, no puedo remediar el impulso y lo abrazo. Lo abrazo con cariño en agradecimiento al maravilloso momento de lectura que me ha proporcionado, y en homenaje al escritor que le dio vida.
'Lavinia', mi primera incursión en la obra de Ursula K. Le Guin, ha sido uno de esos libros que he terminado abrazando.
Si conocéis a grandes rasgos la historia de la Eneida, quizá resuenen en vuestra memoria algunos episodios del periplo vivido por Eneas y sus acompañantes, desde que salieran de la destruida Troya, hasta su llegada al enclave del Lacio que más tarde vería nacer a la legendaria Roma.
En 'Lavinia' Ursula K. Le Guin recupera los hechos narrados en los últimos seis cantos del poema épico original, pero dándoles un punto de vista completamente distinto. Si en la Eneida, la joven Lavinia no pronuncia ni una sola frase, ahora es ella quien toma la palabra para narrar, en primera persona, su historia. El resultado es tan hermoso que no creo poder hacerle justicia.
La profecía dijo a Lavinia, hija de un respetado rey latino, que estaba destinada a rechazar a todos sus pretendientes para casarse con un hombre extranjero. Uno de esos hombres que ella misma, a escondidas, ha visto remontando el curso del Tíber. Una guerra estallará entonces entre su propio pueblo y los recién llegados...tras la destrucción llegará un matrimonio y, entonces, la profecía estará cumplida.
Con qué placer he seguido los pasos de Lavinia, desde los días de su niñez, correteando entre colinas, bosques y playas, hasta el momento en que se convierte en esposa, madre y leyenda.
Su precioso testimonio está plagado de vívidas descripciones de la vida cotidiana en el palacio de su padre y de los parajes que lo rodean.
Conforme avanza la narración somos testigos de antiguas creencias y costumbres; de las tareas que cambian con el paso de las estaciones; y, en cada escena, nos perdemos con deleite en una atmósfera única que tiene el aura de las antiguas narraciones míticas.
La vida de Lavinia está marcada por el amor de su padre y de su tierra; por una extraña profecía y por las conversaciones con cierto poeta, que misteriosamente conoce los entresijos de su propia vida y la del hombre que se convertirá en su esposo...un poeta que aparece cada noche entre las sombras para contar a la joven lo que fue, es y será...
No quiero contaros nada más, os dejo el privilegio de adentraros, casi a oscuras, en esta maravillosa novela que ha resultado ser un enorme coup de cœur para mi.
Entre mito, historia y leyenda, Ursula K. le Guin consigue recrear a la vez un tiempo mítico y un tiempo histórico perdidos; el tiempo mítico de la Eneida de Virgilio, que L. Guin alarga más allá de la última línea en que calló el poeta (para así poder narrar la vida completa de Lavinia); y el tiempo histórico de aquellos pequeños reinos y aldeas del Lacio de la Edad del Bronce, por los que andaron dioses y héroes; mujeres y hombres de carne y hueso.
Los antepasados de un gran imperio, que nació en una pequeña aldea dormida entre siete colinas...
February 2, 2018
The late Ursula K. Le Guin hits it out of the park, as always, with Lavinia.
Our heroine is the human MacGuffin from the second half of Virgil’s Aeneid. The beautiful young princess of Latium (one of many petty kingdoms in the mythic age of pre-Roman Italy), she was betrothed to the warlord Turnus, but an oracle told her father that her rightful husband was in fact Aeneas, the last scion of the royal house of Troy, who had just landed on their shores. These being Greco-Roman mythological figures, what followed was a horrifically bloody war. Virgil’s poem ends abruptly with an uncharacteristically violent act from Aeneas. The poet died with his work incomplete; he asked for his work to be burned, and he was not obeyed.
Le Guin makes Virgil a key character in the novel, a ghostly and wise observer whom only Lavinia, a shrewd and spiritually-minded girl, can see. He tells her what will happen up to a certain point of her life, but cannot see beyond that. He also fusses that he got her hair color wrong and references Dante, the latter being a T.H. White Merlyn moment that had me howling. But Le Guin’s delivery, in Lavinia’s solemn voice, renders the flashes of humor extremely subtle.
In the original Aeneid, Lavinia is given no lines and no hint of personality save that she is a good kid who does what she’s told. Le Guin infuses her with intelligence and courage, but never breaks character with what little was established in Virgil.
There is a lot of woman power in this book—not girl power, which conjures images of a feisty princess on horseback defeating men in battle. There’s a number of books reimagining mythological/legendary characters—Helen, Cassandra, Polyxena, Guinevere—like this, and it is far out of character for any of them. Those roles belonged to Amazons and huntresses; queens and future queens had a different calling. Lavinia emerges from this text with palpable dignity, as a queen, a wife and widow of a king, and a mother of kings and emperors.
About halfway through, the book goes past the point where the original poem ended, but the transition is seamless. Le Guin understands the character well enough that nothing of her doings after the cutoff of the first story seem unreal. To use my favorite Virgilian metaphor, the book could pass through the Horn Gate of true visions, not through the Ivory Gate of false dreams as Aeneas and the Sybil were compelled to do (I will always wonder what that means).
This book is meant for adults, but could easily appeal to teens who are slogging through the Aeneid in English class, so here’s a
Content Advisory
Violence: A fair amount of gory, Virgilian descriptions of battle. Also lots of animal sacrifices, which are upsetting to read about but almost never graphic.
Sex: There are two very brief descriptions of marital sexual activity between Aeneas and Lavinia, poetic and abstract. A kid reading this would learn absolutely nothing about sex that they didn’t already know. There’s fleeting references to sexual rumors about other characters—about a pederastic relationship that continued long past the socially acceptable age back then, and a woman in love with her nephew. A festival is described where the old women sing ditties about male and female private parts—none of the songs are in any part written down. Lavinia notes that kneeling for supplication is degrading, and the nastier warlords might think the supplicant is offering them a sexual favor.
Language: Nothing.
Substance Abuse: Amata and her acolytes get raging drunk for their festival on the mountain, and it causes them to act mad.
Anything Else: There’s a troubling, albeit compassionate, portrayal of a gay male character who hates and mistrusts women. He marries a woman to keep up appearances, but humiliates his wife and accuses her of infidelity to hide his own. This character was a sweet little boy in the Aeneid, and this interpretation is almost unrecognizable—but necessary for the story. Rather like the darkening of Colonel Fitzwilliam’s character in Death Comes to Pemberley.
Conclusion
This is a beautiful companion to one of the best books I ever read for school. I came away inspired by the nobility of Le Guin’s Lavinia. Recommended for adults and mature teens who love the Great Books. You’ll be sorely missed, Ursula K.
Our heroine is the human MacGuffin from the second half of Virgil’s Aeneid. The beautiful young princess of Latium (one of many petty kingdoms in the mythic age of pre-Roman Italy), she was betrothed to the warlord Turnus, but an oracle told her father that her rightful husband was in fact Aeneas, the last scion of the royal house of Troy, who had just landed on their shores. These being Greco-Roman mythological figures, what followed was a horrifically bloody war. Virgil’s poem ends abruptly with an uncharacteristically violent act from Aeneas. The poet died with his work incomplete; he asked for his work to be burned, and he was not obeyed.
Le Guin makes Virgil a key character in the novel, a ghostly and wise observer whom only Lavinia, a shrewd and spiritually-minded girl, can see. He tells her what will happen up to a certain point of her life, but cannot see beyond that. He also fusses that he got her hair color wrong and references Dante, the latter being a T.H. White Merlyn moment that had me howling. But Le Guin’s delivery, in Lavinia’s solemn voice, renders the flashes of humor extremely subtle.
In the original Aeneid, Lavinia is given no lines and no hint of personality save that she is a good kid who does what she’s told. Le Guin infuses her with intelligence and courage, but never breaks character with what little was established in Virgil.
There is a lot of woman power in this book—not girl power, which conjures images of a feisty princess on horseback defeating men in battle. There’s a number of books reimagining mythological/legendary characters—Helen, Cassandra, Polyxena, Guinevere—like this, and it is far out of character for any of them. Those roles belonged to Amazons and huntresses; queens and future queens had a different calling. Lavinia emerges from this text with palpable dignity, as a queen, a wife and widow of a king, and a mother of kings and emperors.
About halfway through, the book goes past the point where the original poem ended, but the transition is seamless. Le Guin understands the character well enough that nothing of her doings after the cutoff of the first story seem unreal. To use my favorite Virgilian metaphor, the book could pass through the Horn Gate of true visions, not through the Ivory Gate of false dreams as Aeneas and the Sybil were compelled to do (I will always wonder what that means).
This book is meant for adults, but could easily appeal to teens who are slogging through the Aeneid in English class, so here’s a
Content Advisory
Violence: A fair amount of gory, Virgilian descriptions of battle. Also lots of animal sacrifices, which are upsetting to read about but almost never graphic.
Sex: There are two very brief descriptions of marital sexual activity between Aeneas and Lavinia, poetic and abstract. A kid reading this would learn absolutely nothing about sex that they didn’t already know. There’s fleeting references to sexual rumors about other characters—about a pederastic relationship that continued long past the socially acceptable age back then, and a woman in love with her nephew. A festival is described where the old women sing ditties about male and female private parts—none of the songs are in any part written down. Lavinia notes that kneeling for supplication is degrading, and the nastier warlords might think the supplicant is offering them a sexual favor.
Language: Nothing.
Substance Abuse: Amata and her acolytes get raging drunk for their festival on the mountain, and it causes them to act mad.
Anything Else: There’s a troubling, albeit compassionate, portrayal of a gay male character who hates and mistrusts women. He marries a woman to keep up appearances, but humiliates his wife and accuses her of infidelity to hide his own. This character was a sweet little boy in the Aeneid, and this interpretation is almost unrecognizable—but necessary for the story. Rather like the darkening of Colonel Fitzwilliam’s character in Death Comes to Pemberley.
Conclusion
This is a beautiful companion to one of the best books I ever read for school. I came away inspired by the nobility of Le Guin’s Lavinia. Recommended for adults and mature teens who love the Great Books. You’ll be sorely missed, Ursula K.
April 21, 2021
★★★☆� (3,5/5)
«Lavinia» fue publicada en 2008, y en ella Úrsula K. Le Guin, basándose en el poema "Eneida" de Virgilio, nos brinda una visión anterior a la fundación de Roma por parte de Lavinia. Dota de una nueva vida y perspectiva de los personajes que formaron parte de los escritos en los que se narraba la llegada de Eneas a Lacio tras huir de la guerra de Troya.
La historia se centra en nuestra protagonista Lavinia, ella nos relatará en un tono confidencial y personal retazos de su pasado y secretos inconfesables que se ofrecerán en un conjunto de armonía y confianza al lector. La mirada hacia su infancia, pasando por la turbia relación con su madre y la singular y especial cercanía con su padre realzan ese poder íntimo que representa la novela.
En un comienzo, la obra nos seduce por su familiaridad y su narración quizá demasiado sencilla pero directa en la que debo destacar esas conversaciones apasionantes entre Lavinia y Virgilio, noches de confesiones, de relatar historias y de evocar un futuro que llegará inevitablemente. La atmósfera que se crea es sencillamente preciosa.
En este retelling mitológico, Úrsula juega con los saltos temporales en varias ocasiones, nos muestra ritos, costumbres y creencias de la época y los contrastes que había entre las culturas de latinos y griegos. Más allá de eso, se centra en las vidas y experiencias de las mujeres de la época; una visión que encierra grandes pensamientos.
Así como sentí fascinación y curiosidad mientras descubría sus primeras páginas, también siento decir que la historia pierde intensidad, centrándose en un ritmo lento y desprovisto de emoción. Llegando a la conclusión y de manera general he disfrutado de conocer la historia de Lavinia, de la magia que envuelve la mitología pero en definitiva no ha sido un libro inolvidable.
«Lavinia» fue publicada en 2008, y en ella Úrsula K. Le Guin, basándose en el poema "Eneida" de Virgilio, nos brinda una visión anterior a la fundación de Roma por parte de Lavinia. Dota de una nueva vida y perspectiva de los personajes que formaron parte de los escritos en los que se narraba la llegada de Eneas a Lacio tras huir de la guerra de Troya.
La historia se centra en nuestra protagonista Lavinia, ella nos relatará en un tono confidencial y personal retazos de su pasado y secretos inconfesables que se ofrecerán en un conjunto de armonía y confianza al lector. La mirada hacia su infancia, pasando por la turbia relación con su madre y la singular y especial cercanía con su padre realzan ese poder íntimo que representa la novela.
En un comienzo, la obra nos seduce por su familiaridad y su narración quizá demasiado sencilla pero directa en la que debo destacar esas conversaciones apasionantes entre Lavinia y Virgilio, noches de confesiones, de relatar historias y de evocar un futuro que llegará inevitablemente. La atmósfera que se crea es sencillamente preciosa.
En este retelling mitológico, Úrsula juega con los saltos temporales en varias ocasiones, nos muestra ritos, costumbres y creencias de la época y los contrastes que había entre las culturas de latinos y griegos. Más allá de eso, se centra en las vidas y experiencias de las mujeres de la época; una visión que encierra grandes pensamientos.
Así como sentí fascinación y curiosidad mientras descubría sus primeras páginas, también siento decir que la historia pierde intensidad, centrándose en un ritmo lento y desprovisto de emoción. Llegando a la conclusión y de manera general he disfrutado de conocer la historia de Lavinia, de la magia que envuelve la mitología pero en definitiva no ha sido un libro inolvidable.
May 26, 2014
Following the resounding success of my , I faced a dilemma: which reading list to follow it up with? Variety is the spice of life, so I’ve decided to diversify and pursue six different lists simultaneously. This book falls into my list.
As the Locus Sci-Fi Award winners list treated me so kindly, I figure I’ll trust those same good folk to pick me some stars in their sister-list, the Locus Fantasy Award winners.
Having never read any Le Guin before, I was a little unsure about where to start. I didn’t want to dive straight in with a big series, which ruled out her most celebrated works, the Earthsea Cycle and the Hainish Cycle, and then popped up on my radar as the 2009 winner of the Locus Fantasy award. At the time I was working my way through every winner of the Locus Sci-Fi award (and loving it) so I decided to branch and I try a couple of the fantasy winners.
With the clarity of twenty-twenty hindsight, I can say that this probably wasn’t the right Le Guin for me to start with. Underwhelmed is the key word.
I was excited by the concept � taking a classic like The Aeneid as a launch point to tell the story of a key, but underexplored character. Dan Simmons� Illium is one of my all-time favourites, and the sci-fi twist he puts on the Illiad is mind-blowing so I guess I was hoping for echoes of that here. Comparing these two books is like comparing chalk and cheese but far more extreme, like comparing chalk and cybernetic A.I.
Words that come to mind around are “meandering�, “dreamy�, “floaty�, and “gentle�. Reading this book is no thrill-ride. It’s like carefully folding paper boats and setting them to sail on a quietly babbling brook, under the serene glow of a late spring sunset, while the breeze whispers through the droopy willow branches.
I can’t fault the writing � Le Guin is a quality wordsmith with a keen eye for character � but the overall experience just wasn’t my thing. It made me drowsy. Once I’ve started a book I always see it through, because even the most mediocre of tales might have a sting in its tail that makes it worthwhile, but no such luck here. It was like listening to pan-pipe music; inoffensive, but basically dull.
There were some very pretty passages of description, and some dramatic tension did creep in as we went along � but by that point I’d already missed my window to emotionally invest in the outcome. There’s some solid research gone into the world building and it’s all very well constructed and convincing � but it just didn’t move me.
The story revolves around Lavinia’s (harridan) mother pressuring her to marry a local lord (who’s a bit of a psycho), but she knows (through dreams and prophecy) that she will marry a foreigner (Aeneus). Low and behold, Aeneus rocks up, she loves him, and war breaks out with the jilted other blah. There are some nice metafic touches with Lavinia talking direct to the reader and chatting with the ghost of Virgil, but not enough to stop my eyes sliding off the page.
2 stars � is not terrible, but I can’t really recommend it.
September 14, 2023
Última novela de Le Guin donde toma uno de los personajes secundarios de la Eneida e imagina su historia. Nos encontramos con una tragedia latina donde la autora no pretende corregir a Virgilio sino contar la historia desde el punto de vista de Lavinia, obligada a casarse con el rey Turno pero se rebela siguiendo una antigua profecía que declaraba que se casaría con Eneas. Es una historia sobre el precio de la guerra y sobre las costumbres y las tradiciones de aquellos pueblos que fueron el origen de Roma. Tiene una influencia bastante fuerte de Fantasía, con el poeta que le va dictando su futuro, y no solo se ciñe a los mitos e historia griega/latina.
He de decir que este tipo de historias no son mi fuerte y lo he acabado por dos motivos: la narración en audiolibro es de 10 y Le Guin demuestra que es una Maestra incluso en sus años finales. Tal vez si lo hubiera leído en papel me hubiera costado mucho más terminarlo.
No me atrevo a recomendarlo a no ser que te guste la tragedia griega/latina, en ese caso lo disfrutarás porque es el libro de una maestra de la literatura.
He de decir que este tipo de historias no son mi fuerte y lo he acabado por dos motivos: la narración en audiolibro es de 10 y Le Guin demuestra que es una Maestra incluso en sus años finales. Tal vez si lo hubiera leído en papel me hubiera costado mucho más terminarlo.
No me atrevo a recomendarlo a no ser que te guste la tragedia griega/latina, en ese caso lo disfrutarás porque es el libro de una maestra de la literatura.
July 1, 2008
I'm a huge fan of Ursula K. LeGuin, but this is not her best book. She is a giant in the fantasy-sci-fi field, with books like The Left Hand of Darkness and The Earthsea Trilogy, but Lavinia is only the second half of a great story. It's a brilliant concept; she takes a character mentioned in passing in Virgil's Aeneid, the wife of Aeneas, and creates a story around her. But she should have jumped in with both feet and defined a whole world, as only she can do. Instead, the story keeps nervously returning to Virgil, and Lavinia is somehow aware she's only a character in a book some of the time and a full character in her own right at other times. The whole thing has a cursory feel, like the treatment for a novel in places. In fact, had she focused on the 3 years that Lavinia and Aeneas were together, and made that the whole novel, she could have created near-unbearable tension as we build up to Aeneas' death. Instead, we get a summary of her life, a nod to Aeneas, and an even quicker summary of her life after. Wonderful idea, not quite a book.
May 7, 2024
This is a bit of an odd book for someone that has always seen Le Guin as a purist in fantasy and sci-fi. It is more along the lines of than her other work or perhaps . She gives us the story of Lavinia and the founding of the Roman Republic following the adventures of the Trojans after their being routed by the Athenians. Aeneas, originally described by Virgil as an answer to Homer's travels of Ulysses, has traveled a long way to marry our heroine and will have to fight his way through throngs of Etruscans and other natives on the Italian peninsula before establishing the empire. This makes for an entertaining read as always for this wonderful author!
Fino's Reviews of Ursula Le Guin
Hainish Cycle
: Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/list...#
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/list...#
Fino Review: /review/show...
Earthsea Cycle
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Annals of the Western Shore
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Other Novels
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Short Stories
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review : /review/show...
Fino's Reviews of Ursula Le Guin
Hainish Cycle
: Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/list...#
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/list...#
Fino Review: /review/show...
Earthsea Cycle
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Annals of the Western Shore
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Other Novels
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review: /review/show...
Short Stories
Fino Review: /review/show...
Fino Review : /review/show...
July 22, 2018
A "Eneida", de Ursula K. Le Guin...
Na í岹, Helena foi causa de uma guerra entre Gregos e Troianos.
Na Eneida, Lavínia foi causa de uma guerra entre Latinos e Troianos.
Enquanto Homero deu importância a Helena, Virgílio menosprezou Lavínia. No entanto, segundo a lenda, serão os descendentes de Lavínia, que criarão uma grande civilização: a Romana.
Os acontecimentos narrados neste romance - que originaram a guerra - são fiéis aos da Eneida, omitindo a participação dos deuses, e resumindo as descrições das batalhas. A vida de Lavínia, dos seus amigos e família, assim como o que sucede após o fim da guerra, são da imaginação de Le Guin.
Na í岹, Helena foi causa de uma guerra entre Gregos e Troianos.
Na Eneida, Lavínia foi causa de uma guerra entre Latinos e Troianos.
Enquanto Homero deu importância a Helena, Virgílio menosprezou Lavínia. No entanto, segundo a lenda, serão os descendentes de Lavínia, que criarão uma grande civilização: a Romana.
Os acontecimentos narrados neste romance - que originaram a guerra - são fiéis aos da Eneida, omitindo a participação dos deuses, e resumindo as descrições das batalhas. A vida de Lavínia, dos seus amigos e família, assim como o que sucede após o fim da guerra, são da imaginação de Le Guin.
November 13, 2018
I don't read a lot of YA books and can't say for sure if they are similar to this book, but during the reading I was thinking - this is how YA should be: with deep meaning, with characters as model roles to learn from, and if it's historical - help to learn something you won't maybe sit down to read yourself.
But bear in mind that this is not a kind of YA only YA readers would read. It's kind of Harry Potter-ish or Lord of the Rings-ish YA that everyone would enjoy.
Actually, the writing was a little difficult. I was catching myself sometimes with thoughts understanding that I had just read about a page or two mechanically. It felt like reading classics. Well, it should be taking into account the background of the story and the source of the writing. What I liked was how the author was showing the role of the woman in society no matter what century it is. It wasn't a kind of book saying women are better, they should rule the world, bla bla bla... No, it was about equality of genders in its own way with strong characters.
Three stars, because maybe I was expecting more...
Ok, updating and rating 4 stars!
But bear in mind that this is not a kind of YA only YA readers would read. It's kind of Harry Potter-ish or Lord of the Rings-ish YA that everyone would enjoy.
Actually, the writing was a little difficult. I was catching myself sometimes with thoughts understanding that I had just read about a page or two mechanically. It felt like reading classics. Well, it should be taking into account the background of the story and the source of the writing. What I liked was how the author was showing the role of the woman in society no matter what century it is. It wasn't a kind of book saying women are better, they should rule the world, bla bla bla... No, it was about equality of genders in its own way with strong characters.
Three stars, because maybe I was expecting more...
Ok, updating and rating 4 stars!
June 6, 2021
I found "Lavinia" dull, despite believing, at the same time, that it's masterfully written. Square that circle, if you can.
About three quarters of the way in, I wondered what was left to tell of the tale, and finished it simply to finish it.
"Lavinia" is a story based on Virgil's "Aeneid" (which I still haven't read) - more precisely, on the story if Aeneas's wife in Italy, when he finishes his epic quest that led his people from Troy to Carthage to the province where his descendants will, eventually, found Rome.
I picked it up because it's written by Ursula K. Le Guin, without bothering to read the summary and see this is yet another retelling of an ancient tale from a feminist perspective (I've read Atwood's "Penelopiad" some years ago, and Madeline Miller's "Circe" a couple of months ago) and was somewhat surprised to open it and see it wasn't science fiction or fantasy. Well, never mind that - it's the best retelling I've read so far, because it stands quite well on its own.
I love what Le Guin did with Lavinia: as Virgil wrote nearly nothing of her, Le Guin was free to write anything she wanted of the princess, later Aeneas's queen. After interacting with so many of the stories told today (on TV, but not only) of women disliking their roles, or being oppressed by virtue of their womanhood in the same way we would feel to be oppressed in their shoes, Lavinia was a breath of fresh air. She's a woman of her culture. She upholds values foreign to us, such as piety. She honors the gods and looks for guidance and tries to follow fate. She doesn't chafe under restraints, nor is she powerless under the heavy boot of the men in her life.
Lavinia is unyielding when she decides something must be done, and she takes gods and men on her side. Her motives are, perhaps, alien - she wants to do the right thing, the preordained thing, the things gods want - and her methods are rarely those of open conflict, but she gets the job done through the means she has, within the role she has, maintaining the respect of those around her. You have to respect that.
Another thing that's interesting is that Lavinia is real, but also aware that she lives in the mythological world of Virgil, while musing on what that means to her and contradicting him about the world he has created.
And yet another thing is the setting: a rural, pretty primitive world of kings who rule over towns and endless small conflicts, while obeying the familiar gods.
About three quarters of the way in, I wondered what was left to tell of the tale, and finished it simply to finish it.
"Lavinia" is a story based on Virgil's "Aeneid" (which I still haven't read) - more precisely, on the story if Aeneas's wife in Italy, when he finishes his epic quest that led his people from Troy to Carthage to the province where his descendants will, eventually, found Rome.
I picked it up because it's written by Ursula K. Le Guin, without bothering to read the summary and see this is yet another retelling of an ancient tale from a feminist perspective (I've read Atwood's "Penelopiad" some years ago, and Madeline Miller's "Circe" a couple of months ago) and was somewhat surprised to open it and see it wasn't science fiction or fantasy. Well, never mind that - it's the best retelling I've read so far, because it stands quite well on its own.
I love what Le Guin did with Lavinia: as Virgil wrote nearly nothing of her, Le Guin was free to write anything she wanted of the princess, later Aeneas's queen. After interacting with so many of the stories told today (on TV, but not only) of women disliking their roles, or being oppressed by virtue of their womanhood in the same way we would feel to be oppressed in their shoes, Lavinia was a breath of fresh air. She's a woman of her culture. She upholds values foreign to us, such as piety. She honors the gods and looks for guidance and tries to follow fate. She doesn't chafe under restraints, nor is she powerless under the heavy boot of the men in her life.
Lavinia is unyielding when she decides something must be done, and she takes gods and men on her side. Her motives are, perhaps, alien - she wants to do the right thing, the preordained thing, the things gods want - and her methods are rarely those of open conflict, but she gets the job done through the means she has, within the role she has, maintaining the respect of those around her. You have to respect that.
Another thing that's interesting is that Lavinia is real, but also aware that she lives in the mythological world of Virgil, while musing on what that means to her and contradicting him about the world he has created.
And yet another thing is the setting: a rural, pretty primitive world of kings who rule over towns and endless small conflicts, while obeying the familiar gods.
March 26, 2021
LeGuin alterna el pasado, el presente y el futuro en una narración en primera persona que es objetiva y, sin embargo, tremendamente emocional. Lavinia se duele por la guerra pero es ecuánime en el tratamiento de los personajes que la rodean. No hay héroes ni villanos en los textos de LeGuin, solo hombres con aciertos y errores, valentías y miedos. Con una majestuosa reina Lavinia observándolos a todos y pidiéndole piedad al poeta.
January 2, 2024
Mitolojik hikayelerin kadın gözünden yeniden anlatıldığı kitaplara bayıldığım için Lavinia ve Margaret Atwood'un Penelope'sini peş peşe okudum. Lavinia'nın ŷ yorumlarında kitabın Penelope'ye kıyasen yazıldığına dair bir yorum görünce iki kitabı ve çok sevdiğim iki yazarı kıyaslamaktan kendimi alamadım.
Atwood ile kocası maceradan maceraya, tanrıçadan tanrıçaya gezerken evinde onu sadakatle bekleyen ve krallığı yöneten Penelope'ye ve bahtsız 12 hizmetçisine 21. yüzyıl mahkemesinde hak ettiklerini vermeye çalışırken, Le Guin bir kraliçe olmasına ve savaşın çıkmasında rol oynamasına rağmen kendisine bir sözcük bile bahşedilmeyen Lavinia'ya hayat üflüyor. Atwood'un kitabında Odysseus'un zekası sinsiliğe, kahramanlığı zalimliğe dönüşürken ve olayların ele alınışı daha keskinken; Le Guin hem şair Virgilius'u hem de kahraman Aeneas'ı suçlamıyor, aksine onları vicdanlı ve erdemli olarak gösteriyor.
ÖԱğ Atwood'un kalemini kelimeleri insanın suratına çarparcasına kullandığını ve feminist bakış açısını daha çok ortaya çıkardığını, Le Guin'in ise anlatımını yumuşak ama etkili bir dilde tuttuğunu, bir isimden bir dünya yaratarak bu dünyada güç ve ego, savaşın ahlaki boyutu gibi başka konularla birlikte feminizmi işlediğini düşünüyorum. Ne yazık ki, her iki yazar da savaşı ve etkilerini anlatma konusunda biraz yetersiz kalmış. Christa Wolf'un yine feminist-mitolojik yeniden anlatım niteliğinde olan 'da bu konuda daha iyi iş çıkardığını söyleyebilirim. Kitapların üçü de okunmaya değer.
PS: Lavinia, Penelope ve Margaret George'un Truvalı Helen'inin "Kadın kurban eden mi yoksa edilen midir?" sorusuyla incelendiği güzel bir tez var. Benim gibi kitabı okuyup, analizini kasıp, üstüne de akademik çalışmasını okumak isteyen manyaklar için ııǰܳ.
PS 2: 2 ay önce ŷ'e katıldığımda tek niyetim okuduğum kitapların takibini yapmak ve arada bir dandik romantik komedi kitaplarına eleştiri yazmaktı. Böyle linkli minkli uzun değerlendirme yapmak bana da sürpriz oldu gerçekten.
Atwood ile kocası maceradan maceraya, tanrıçadan tanrıçaya gezerken evinde onu sadakatle bekleyen ve krallığı yöneten Penelope'ye ve bahtsız 12 hizmetçisine 21. yüzyıl mahkemesinde hak ettiklerini vermeye çalışırken, Le Guin bir kraliçe olmasına ve savaşın çıkmasında rol oynamasına rağmen kendisine bir sözcük bile bahşedilmeyen Lavinia'ya hayat üflüyor. Atwood'un kitabında Odysseus'un zekası sinsiliğe, kahramanlığı zalimliğe dönüşürken ve olayların ele alınışı daha keskinken; Le Guin hem şair Virgilius'u hem de kahraman Aeneas'ı suçlamıyor, aksine onları vicdanlı ve erdemli olarak gösteriyor.
ÖԱğ Atwood'un kalemini kelimeleri insanın suratına çarparcasına kullandığını ve feminist bakış açısını daha çok ortaya çıkardığını, Le Guin'in ise anlatımını yumuşak ama etkili bir dilde tuttuğunu, bir isimden bir dünya yaratarak bu dünyada güç ve ego, savaşın ahlaki boyutu gibi başka konularla birlikte feminizmi işlediğini düşünüyorum. Ne yazık ki, her iki yazar da savaşı ve etkilerini anlatma konusunda biraz yetersiz kalmış. Christa Wolf'un yine feminist-mitolojik yeniden anlatım niteliğinde olan 'da bu konuda daha iyi iş çıkardığını söyleyebilirim. Kitapların üçü de okunmaya değer.
PS: Lavinia, Penelope ve Margaret George'un Truvalı Helen'inin "Kadın kurban eden mi yoksa edilen midir?" sorusuyla incelendiği güzel bir tez var. Benim gibi kitabı okuyup, analizini kasıp, üstüne de akademik çalışmasını okumak isteyen manyaklar için ııǰܳ.
PS 2: 2 ay önce ŷ'e katıldığımda tek niyetim okuduğum kitapların takibini yapmak ve arada bir dandik romantik komedi kitaplarına eleştiri yazmaktı. Böyle linkli minkli uzun değerlendirme yapmak bana da sürpriz oldu gerçekten.
October 21, 2023
yenilen pehlivan güreşe doymazmış tarzı ben de okuduğum 10 retellingden 9'unu beğenmememe rağmen retelling okuyorum. ursula nenemle aramı bozmayı göze alıp lavinia'ya başladım ve gönül rahatlığıyla söyleyebilirim ki it was worth the risk. isimler evi'ndeki eksik kalan hikayeyi tamamlamış gibi hissettirdi ki ursula nenem böyle bir gayesi olmadığını yazmış kitabın sonuna. vergilius'u ve aeneis'i bilerek okuyunca kitabın etkisi ikiye katlanıyor. kitabın mistik havasına, karakterlerin canlılığına bayıldım. kitabı okumak için vergilius ile lavinia'ya yazdığı diyalogun olduğu bölüm tek başına yeterli. şairim de şairim.
August 11, 2024
La rivisitazione del mito riesce molto bene in questo retelling. Il romanzo guarda alle vicende narrate da un punto di vista inedito, ovvero quello di Lavinia, la donna tramite cui Enea è destinato a fondare la sua stirpe.
Così come nell'Eneide il peso del destino sembra incombere implacabile sul suo protagonista, anche qui vediamo la protagonista Lavinia alle prese con una profezia. Se l'eroe virgiliano abbraccia il suo destino per puro senso del dovere, Lavinia al contrario vede nella profezia un modo per prendere in mano la sua vita. Come Enea nel suo poema, anche Lavinia compirà le sue scelte affinché il suo destino si avveri.
Un aspetto importante del libro è che non c'è nessuna forzatura nel racconto di LeGuin. L'autrice affronta la materia quasi come un romanzo storico. È infatti molto attenta a ricostruire il contesto e l'ambiente della narrazione in modo coerente, per quanto le fonti storiche possano permetterlo. Fa rivivere così la cultura e le tradizioni latine, costruendo un quadro molto interessante e affascinante.
Anche i personaggi sono di spessore. L'Enea di LeGuin è molto fedele all'originale, allo stesso tempo però l'autrice riesce a dare complessità a un personaggio che secondo me nel poema originale mostra poco carattere. Anche se rimane un personaggio attaccato al suo senso del dovere, è pieno di dubbi e incertezze.
Riscrivendo questo mito LeGuin fa riflessioni sulla guerra, sul concetto di eroe, sulla famiglia e sul potere con scelte narrative originali e interessanti.
Riesce anche a trasmettere il suo amore per l'opera originale, un amore che purtroppo io non condivido, ma che sa rendere il romanzo interessante.
Così come nell'Eneide il peso del destino sembra incombere implacabile sul suo protagonista, anche qui vediamo la protagonista Lavinia alle prese con una profezia. Se l'eroe virgiliano abbraccia il suo destino per puro senso del dovere, Lavinia al contrario vede nella profezia un modo per prendere in mano la sua vita. Come Enea nel suo poema, anche Lavinia compirà le sue scelte affinché il suo destino si avveri.
Un aspetto importante del libro è che non c'è nessuna forzatura nel racconto di LeGuin. L'autrice affronta la materia quasi come un romanzo storico. È infatti molto attenta a ricostruire il contesto e l'ambiente della narrazione in modo coerente, per quanto le fonti storiche possano permetterlo. Fa rivivere così la cultura e le tradizioni latine, costruendo un quadro molto interessante e affascinante.
Anche i personaggi sono di spessore. L'Enea di LeGuin è molto fedele all'originale, allo stesso tempo però l'autrice riesce a dare complessità a un personaggio che secondo me nel poema originale mostra poco carattere. Anche se rimane un personaggio attaccato al suo senso del dovere, è pieno di dubbi e incertezze.
Riscrivendo questo mito LeGuin fa riflessioni sulla guerra, sul concetto di eroe, sulla famiglia e sul potere con scelte narrative originali e interessanti.
Riesce anche a trasmettere il suo amore per l'opera originale, un amore che purtroppo io non condivido, ma che sa rendere il romanzo interessante.
July 10, 2024
So chi ero, posso dirvi chi sarei stata, ma, ora, sono solo in questa stringa di parole che scrivo... Senza dubbio una persona col mio nome è esistita, ma è probabile che sia stata così diversa dall'idea che il mio poeta ha avuto di me, che pensare a lei mi confonde soltanto. Per quello che ne so è stato il mio poeta a rendermi reale. Prima che scrivesse non ero che la più indistinta delle figure, poco più che un nome in una genealogia. È stato lui a riportarmi alla vita, a me stessa... Se devo continuare ad esistere nei secoli dei secoli, allora almeno una volta devo parlare. Non mi ha permesso di dire una parola. Devo prendermela da sola.
Il romanzo della Le Guin si apre con questa riflessione e il tema del ruolo della donna tornerà diverse volte nel corso del romanzo, sia come riflessione storica poiché è concepito in modo diverso tra Greci, Etruschi e Latini, sia in senso più moderno; tuttavia, a differenza di quanto accade in tanta lettura contemporanea, non si snatura la storia, dandone una visione falsata, e Lavinia risulta un personaggio credibile anche nel contesto della sua epoca.
È anche interessante la riflessione sulla scrittura e sul rapporto autore/personaggio: Lavinia incontra Virgilio, il poeta che ha cantato di lei nell'Eneide, che le ha regalato la vita come personaggio, ma anche che ha "tradito" la sua essenza raccontando di lei poco e non sempre in modo completo. Certo, questo non è un saggio storico, Lavinia non esiste, ma è affascinante la messa in scena del dialogo creatore/creatura, una sorta di Frankenstein a tinte decisamente più dolci.
Non è la morte che ci permette di comprenderci gli uni con gli altri, ma la poesia
Ho preferito la prima metà abbondante del romanzo. L'ho trovata più dinamica e interessante, inoltre le riflessioni di Le Guin su guerra e pace sono estremamente attuali e calzanti.
Non sapevo ancora che la pace irrita gli uomini, che accumulano rabbia impaziente al suo perdurare e che, persino quando pregano i poteri per la pace, lavorano contro di essa e fanno in modo che si infranga e ceda il passo a battaglie, massacri, stupri e sprechi
È interessante anche come viene raccontato il ruolo degli eroi.
"Chi è l'eroe?"
"Lo sai"
"Uccide come un macellaio. Perché lo chiami eroe?"
"Perché fa quello che deve fare"
"Perché deve uccidere un uomo indifeso?"
"Perché è così che si fondano gli imperi"
E anche:
Senza guerra non ci sono eroi
È un prospettiva diversa da quella dell'epos antico, ma anche di letteratura più recente che non solo inneggia alla guerra, ma anche ai suoi (presunti?) eroi. Qui non ci sono generali e condottieri che giganteggiano sulla popolazione, ma uomini chiamati a combattere e che lo fanno con qualità, difetti e debolezze molto umane e molto poco eroiche anche quando compiono imprese. E così c'è il furore di Enea, ma anche la mediocrità di Ascanio.
La seconda parte a mio parere è un po' sotto tono, più lenta e molto meno interessante. Sarà un caso che è anche la parte non direttamente ispirata all'Eneide? Chissà. Il libro però recupera nel finale che ho trovato delicato e appropriato.
Complessivamente, per quanto con qualche alto e basso, è una lettura che consiglio.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,379 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.