Points out that lots of ideas about how to live optimally are mostly opinions.. but the author often fills out the gaps with his own opinions instead of 'hard science' (which might just not exist for most things in life).
Very agreeable content! Confirms my inner thoughts about a lot of the self-help/self-improvement industry. No doubt there's important knowledge in such fields but a lot of the books hold people back from actually doing things. Also a lot of pop-psych is replete with questionable studies and overly certain conclusions. Dr. Briers entreaty to look outside of ourselves, not be so serious, have fun and enjoy the moment seems very healthy advice.
Trudna to by艂a lektura i ostatnie 50% przeczyta艂am pobie偶nie. Autor od pocz膮tku ksi膮偶ki wydawa艂 si臋 bardzo poirytowany wszystkimi publikacjami o pozytywnej psychologii.
Przeczyta艂am kilka ksi膮偶ek tego typu i rzeczywi艣cie, nie wszystkie pozycje mi si臋 podoba艂y, nie wszystkie dla mnie mia艂y sens. Gdy czytam fragment, gdzie jest napisane, 偶e musz臋 powiedzie膰 wszech艣wiatowi, 偶e chcia艂abym pojecha膰 na fajne wakacje to nie czekam, a偶 wszech艣wiat wy艣le mnie na t臋 wycieczk臋 tylko bior臋 sprawy w swoje r臋ce. Autor m贸wi czytelnikom, 偶e potrzeba ci臋偶kej pracy, 偶eby osi膮gn膮膰 marzenia i 偶e czasem si臋 nie udaje mimo wszystko. Nie jest to dla mnie wielkie odkrycie. Ale warto pr贸bowa膰, je艣li chce si臋 co艣 zmieni膰. Warto w to wierzy膰.
Uwa偶am, 偶e ka偶dy kto czyta ksi膮偶ki o pozytywnej psychologii ma tyle rozumu, 偶eby nie bra膰 wszystkich rad dos艂ownie i nadal wie, 偶e s膮 pewne granice, kt贸rych nie przeskoczymy. Moim zdaniem dobrze jest przeczyta膰: 鈥濵o偶esz to zrobi膰! Jeste艣 warto艣ciowa! Zadbaj o siebie! 艢wiat stoi przed tob膮 otworem!鈥�
This book contains one clinical psychologist's perspective on 23 pervasive self-help sayings. For those who easily get hypnotized by the big promises the self-help genre makes, as I was, this book gives a more sobering approach to what we can really do to improve our lives. Through some scientific evidence, but mostly opinions, Briers makes compelling cases that show another side that I hadn't thought of myself.
For the cases of some of these 'myths', such as MYTH 13 (You'd better get yourself sorted) and MYTH 16 (There is no failure, only feedback), I strongly disagree. Not because I believe they're 'true', but because they are practical and empowering in a realistic way, which is what the self-help genre should provide one with.
Myths that were enlightening to me were MYTH 3 (Emotional intelligence is what really matters) and MYTH 11 (Your inner child needs a hug). In the case of myth 3 I bought into the idea that EQ is more important than IQ. Briers brought scientific evidence, or showed the lack thereof in Goleman's case, which made the point more nuanced to me. In the case of myth 11 I wasn't aware of the frame this saying puts one in. If you believe that there's an inner child that has been unavoidably hurt from childhood on there'll always be a rationalization that this is the root of any misery one is feeling at the moment.
All in all I liked the book. It serves as a self-help book disguised as an anti self-help book. It provided interesting tidbits of information only a professional mind-worker can know about.
Offered new self-help after debunking the old - I wasn't sure whether to just blindly take this advice or see it as just as flawed as the old stuff - but it was a fascinating insight into how complicated our minds really are, and how ridiculously over-simplified the self-help industry has become. It helped me in a lot of ways I didn't expect: forge your own way, make mistakes, don't dwell on failures too much and good can become bad in excess. But obviously that's oversimplified...
I understood a lot of this book and what it offers. While there is not a lot of scientific evidence to support Brier's claims, at least there is enough, at least in my opinion, scientific evidence being used and not the word of a big shot "self-help guru" who expects us to take his/her word for it. This book shows us that in life there are no shortcuts, not everything is sunshine and rainbows (perky is annoying as f*** anyway), and that even as a work in progress, you are where you need to be regardless of what wannabe "experts" (at least Briers has credentials) say or want us to do. To me, anything that makes you want to improve yourself is just another way of saying there is something wrong with you. And that is very damaging to the mind. I agree with Briers that the self-help craze needs to stop. If it really worked, we would all be billionares, now wouldn't we?
Very enjoyable read. I was already familiar with most of the counter arguments, but it was good to get a reminder.
I would recommend this to so many people... But I bet few will change their minds, because the allure of self-help, with its easy and straight forward solutions, offers a hard to give up on comfort.
The premise of book is shooting down various ideas and teaching in applied psychology. Well, criticising is a cheap entertainment, but at least this book is reasonably scientific. Don't expect to find answers here though, it's all about multiplying your questions.
While I agree with the basic thrust of the book, Briers is at times himself a bit pschobabbly, quoting studies whose findings seems questionable at best. In general, highlights the limits of self-help and the limits of psychology as a science.
Wa偶ne, 偶eby nie potraktowa膰 tej ksi膮偶ki, jako ostateczn膮 wyroczni臋, ale zawiera wiele cennych spostrze偶e艅. W popkulturze terapii, w kt贸rej tonie coraz wi臋cej os贸b, my艣l臋, 偶e to cenna przeciwwaga, cho膰 nie zawsze si臋 zgadzam z autorem :).
Dr Stephen Briers is a British clinical psychologist who has taken a good long hard look at the self help industry and blown it apart. His argument is that the various self help philosophies are making us anxious. Anxious that how we are now is just not good enough, that we should be striving for perfection, that if we just visualise things hard enough we can all be rich and famous and that we all have needs that 'need' to be met by our partners. Not only are these self help myths making us anxious and disappointed, for the most part there is no scientific evidence to back up their claims.
Briers urges us, in his very readable and entertaining book, to stop and think and that maybe we aren't that bad after all.
The self-help industry is a big business. This industry is exploitive, it usually overpromise and under deliver. The author does a good job debunking the myths of this industry.
We've all hear some stories about cancer patients who, by visualizing imploding malignant cells, find themselves tumor-free. However, according to studies, psychotherapy and meditation don't affect the disease progression or survival rates. Studies show that a patient's chances of recovery are completely unaffected by the mood or attitude.
"Positive thinking, while not inherently bad, isn't always healthy, helpful or rational. Sometimes it's the grumpy pessimist who is more realistic than all those Pollyannas (an excessively or blindly optimistic person) out there."
Snabbl盲st inf枚r eventuellt bokprat. Jag har l盲st den tidigare. Briers tar en massa popul盲rpsykologiska sanningar och motbevisar dom. Jag 盲r inte s盲rskilt bra p氓 k盲lllkritik s氓 jag vet inte om han har r盲tt, men boken ger mycket att fundera p氓. Liksom Sven Brinkmans bok St氓 Fast 盲r detta en anti sj盲lvhj盲lpsb枚cker, som dock trillar dit och blir just det. Problemet med Briers 盲r kanske att han tar bort en massa illusioner, eller kanske 盲r det bra. Men jag som l盲sare l盲mnas i sticket, vad ska jag g枚ra nu liksom?
A provoking and reassuring read at the same time. Far from perfect, I'm not even sure the point he is trying to make in some chapters actually gets through. Still, it is an interesting book to get back to when someone promise you shortcuts to understanding yourself or others.
Entertaining and quick read. It hardly "explodes" anything, and some of the chapters are slightly contradicting. I enjoyed the chapter on the "know yourself" myth.
Really an Eye-opener and makes you think. AWESOMEEEEEEE But not really like fun unless u like psychology la. But if you like psych you will love this book!!!!