ŷ

Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

RoseBlood

Rate this book
Rune Germaine moves to a boarding school outside of Paris, only to discover that at this opera-house-turned-music-conservatory, phantoms really do exist. RoseBlood is a Phantom of the Opera–inspired retelling in which Rune’s biggest talent—her voice—is also her biggest curse.

Rune, whose voice has been compared to that of an angel, has a mysterious affliction linked to her talent that leaves her sick and drained at the end of every performance. Convinced creative direction will cure her, her mother ships her off to a French boarding school for the arts, rumored to have a haunted past.

Shortly after arriving at RoseBlood conservatory, Rune starts to believe something otherworldly is indeed afoot. The mystery boy she’s seen frequenting the graveyard beside the opera house doesn’t have any classes at the school, and vanishes almost as quickly as he appears. When Rune begins to develop a secret friendship with the elusive Thorn, who dresses in clothing straight out of the 19th century, she realizes that in his presence she feels cured. Thorn may be falling for Rune, but the phantom haunting RoseBlood wants her for a very specific and dangerous purpose. As their love continues to grow, Thorn is faced with an impossible choice: lead Rune to her destruction, or save her and face the wrath of the phantom, the only father he’s ever known.

432 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 10, 2017

642 people are currently reading
25.1k people want to read

About the author

A.G. Howard

20books9,028followers
#1 New York Times and International bestselling Author of gothic / fantasy & paranormal tales, mystical & romantic with a side of horror. A.G.'s dark Alice in Wonderland inspired Splintered series has been published in over a dozen languages.

Young adult, Adult, and literary romance. Repped by Jenny Bent.

How A.G. Howard rates books on GoodReads:

"I only rate or review books I enjoyed reading, and won't give any rating below 4 stars. Please don't consider every high rating a personal endorsement / recommendation from me. My ratings here are subjective to me as an individual.

I don't rate books solely on style. Every writer's voice is individual and unique; I've come to respect this truth during my own personal journey. As long as a story takes me to another place and is well edited, I'm going to give it a good rating. And if, for some reason, a book doesn't entertain me or I don't finish it, I won't leave a rating or review at all.

If you're considering a book I've reviewed/rated, be sure to read other reviews/ratings alongside mine to help you decide if it's a read you might enjoy personally.

Happy book hunting!"

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2,195 (23%)
4 stars
2,452 (25%)
3 stars
2,532 (26%)
2 stars
1,417 (14%)
1 star
927 (9%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,105 reviews
Profile Image for Melissa Rose.
82 reviews113 followers
July 27, 2021
My feelings while reading this book:
description

GUYS THIS BOOK WAS AMAZING!!!!!

OH MY GOD. I have never read a book like this in my life. Seriously guys this is like The Room or Troll 2 of books. It was so poor in its execution so horribly bad and offensive at times that it was actually good. The book takes itself so seriously that it's just hilarious to laugh at. It's truly amazing how wrong it is.

The characters were wrong. The plot was wrong. The setting was wrong. The romance was wrong.
Every single detail was WRONG. The book failed on possibly every level and in a way I'm glad I read this book (although my dead brain cells are not thanking me) because it's literally a guide of how not to write a YA book.

I usually don't write reviews this scathing but how the author treated the source material is just wrong. In fact some parts are insulting even. I never read a retelling this BAD.

Okay deep breath....here we go. There is gonna be a lot of swearing so if you don't like it too bad. Obviously big spoilers ahead but who really gives a shit.

So we got our protagonist Rune-and holy shit here we go right out of the fucking gate we got a stupid ass name. She's going to school at the Roseblood academy for musical talent and boy do we get an info dump about Roseblood. The first two chapters are just one info dump about Rune's power and information about the school. A more talented author would slowly reveal information about Rune's power and the secrets about the school but nope right away we get a lecture about the history of the school.

Oh and did I mention the school has no wi-fi and cell phone reception. A SCHOOL. A school has no computers. Wow. SO realistic. I can buy a phantom living in the fucking sewers but a school with no cell phones and computers is plain fantasy man.

Another problem that really grinds my gears and YA authors do it a lot is when the protagonist is going to some super cool location and she doesn't wanna go!!!!!1!!!@@#!! Like she's going to a fucking boarding school in France to learn opera and gets to go to Paris on the weekends and this bitch has the audacity to complain to her mother that she doesn't wanna go!!!!! Like shut up with your first world problems already Christ. And I hate when YA mothers are like "you have to go sweetie!!!" Ugh parenting skills are non-existent in the YA world.

We also find out in the first two chapters that Rune is the most special snowflake in the entire world. Her dad tragically died when she six years old and of course she's not over it. I barely have any memories when I was six but I guess YA protagonists have perfect memories. Anyway her grandma tried to drown her when she a little girl and set her classroom on fire (???? not really explained well) because she's a demon for bursting out in song. Seriously that's her power. She bursts out in songs uncontrollably. It's pretty lame if you ask me. But you know what she hit all the marks for the YA protagonist trope. But to be sure let's play the game:

Is our protagonist a typical YA protagonist???

Let's evaluate our character Rune...

-weird ass name
-Has an ability she can't control
-tragic backstory (bonus points if someone tried to kill her because of her power)
-Has dreams about her love interest before she even meets him
-At least one parent dead
-Forced to go to some exotic/fantastical location that she doesn't want to go to
-Beautiful (Ten extra points if she doesn't KNOW it)
-Green eyes
-white (twenty points if she has white people problems)
-Nobody UNDERSTANDS her
-Says she doesn't want to make friends but everyone wants to instantly be friends with her
-Very talented but doesn't want the attention (fifteen points if she has no training for her power)
-Has mean girls who hate her for no reason just to make her look better
-Not like OTHER girls
-Secret family history
-Falls in love with love interest immediately
-Life revolves around love interest (bonus points if she puts up with his shit)

Ding Ding Ding!!!! We got a winner!!!! Congrats Rune you are a basic bitch!!!

Okay so I'm skipping ahead because the book goes into excruciating detail about her new friends at Roseblood and her classes which I don't really give a shit about and let's get to what I've been waiting for-THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA!!!!

So is he going to be her love interest??????

Nope. His son is instead.

You heard me right. The phantom adopted a son and he also wears a mask and is Rune's love interest. His name is Thorn (I'm fucking serious) he wears a mask even though he's beautiful and has no deformities. He stalks Rune and visits her in her dreams and stuff like the stalker he is. Erik (the phantom) and Thorn live in the sewers of the academy and haunt it.
description

Wow fucking wow. You had one job and you screwed it up. Wouldn't it be so much more interesting if Thorn had a deformity? Instead he wears a mask like a douche (fucking Kylo Ren over here) and is charming in every way in spite of the fact he lives in the fucking sewers with no friends expect for his psycho father. Of course he's a handsome love interest. We can't have ugly love interests can we??? Physical beauty and beauty of the soul itself were core themes of the original book and by extension the musical. Like fuck off I'm tired of bland ass love interests who look absolutely perfect-this was such a missed opportunity.

And like all creepy YA love interests he says stuff like:

"We are destined to be lovers Rune."

UGHHHHHHH

So here's where the book gets fucking hilarious like so funny I burst out laughing while reading it. Okay are you ready??? Are you sitting down???? Okay okay here we go....

The reason why the phantom is still alive is because he's a psychic vampire.

PSYCHIC VAMPIRE

Oh my fucking God i can't breathe I'm dead. I'm literally dead. And the best part is that Rune and Thorn are also psychic vampires (because why the fuck not) and their voice lures people to them. They don't drink blood but they suck the energy people from their song (how???? don't ask) and that's how they feed. Oh my God its so fucking stupid I'm dead. So you are probably wondering "Hmmm how do they feed from people?????"

Well folks it only gets stupider from here. Okay are you sitting down again??? Not drinking anything??? Okay here we go again....

The phantom owns a rave and he uses the people in there to feed off their energy.

The phantom owns a rave.

The phantom of the opera owns a rave.

THE PHANTOM OF THE FUCKING OPERA OWNS A GODDAMN RAVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
description

yES Folks its true the phantom owns a nightclub and theres a rave inside that people go to and he feeds off their fear by exposing his face (??????) and using giant tubes (??????????????) to suck up their energy. What the fuck. What the fucjkdkfkkdk. WHT THE FUKKKKKKK

The Phantom of the Rave is there inside my MINDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

I can't. It can't possibly get any stupider. Please for the love of God please don't make it stupider.

Oh but just you wait people it gets better. We find out that Rune and Thorn are "twin flames" which means that they have the same soul. So one soul separated into two parts into two different bodies. The author says in her author notes section that she wanted a better name than "soulmates" which sounds cheesy. Sorry you aren't fooling anyone. They are ~destined~ soulmates.

Why I find this cliche terrible
-They fall in love right away since they are meant to be. There is no tension no "will they?" or "won't they?" It's already decided
-It's a dangerous concept to teach YA readers that there is only ~one~ person destined for you. That shit ain't true.
-It's just so dang boring. There is no getting to know each other. It's just hey i just met you and this is crazy but we are destined to be soulmates so marry me maybe???
-It's overdone and I seen it a million times in other books and actually in way better ways. See Claudia Grey's Firebird series.

Oh but my friends it get better. Whose soul was split between Rune's and Thorns????? Okay make sure you aren't eating anything okay I mean it this time. Are you ready????? Kay

It's Christine Daae's

Or otherwise known as Christina Nilsson a real life opera singer. She was the phantom's twin flame and she died before they could have a bonding ritual (???? not really explained well) so her soul reincarnated into Thorn and Rune.
description

WHAT
THE
FUCKKKKKKK

My sanity is gone. Call me Padme Amidala because I lost the will to live. This is so stupid I can't. I just can't. It makes no Goddamn sense. First of all why his Christine the phantom's twin flame??? The phantom is a tragic character because he's never been loved and tries to force Christine to love him and when she refuses he thinks its because of his deformity. But that's not the reason at all. It's because he's a psychopath, stalker, kidnapper and murderer. They were never soul mates. The book even has the audacity the very NERVE to say:

"She [Christine] wasn't ready for the selfless, soul-deep level of love he required."

"They had a passionate emotional affair, although sadly, she was young and immature."

description

Are you for real? Really. We are really blaming Christine here. The victim. We are blaming the victim here. Oh but wait it gets better. You didn't think it would happen again but here we fucking go. The icing on the shit cake. Are you ready??? No are you truly ready for this stupidity???? This is the REAL history of the phantom and Christine:

Christine returns to the phantom years later after the death of her husband and she falls in love with him because they are ~soulmates~ (twin flames are just so stupid to type out) and they have a child together. The baby girl dies and the phantom tries to resurrect her and Christine gets angry and leaves him forever. The phantom then spends the rest of his life to resurrect the baby by finding Thorn and Rune because they have Christine's soul. The whole plot of this book is the phantom trying to capture Rune so he can cut out her voice (how???? idk) and give it to his dead daughter to resurrect.
description

OH
MY
GOD

There are no words. There are no words to describe this. Am i Dead??? Did I land into some alternate reality where books like this are allowed to exist??? This can't be real. Someone wrote this. Wrote this into the world. People bought this book (thank God for the library but I placed a hold for it for 25 cents that 25 cents I will never get back). People paid money to read this. This is a twelve year old girl's fanfic. This can't be a published book. This can't.

So you can guess the ending from here. Thorn saves the day by releasing a lever that floods the sewers (deus ex machina much??? not that i care i just wanted the book to end) and he lives of course and Rune and him live happily ever after. Oh and the phantom is alive too and goes to live with other psychic vampires in Canada (????) Why Canada???? I know Justin Trudeau is good looking but come on there's no explanation why he would go there!!! And the phantom doesn't take any revenge against them and is chill. Awesome. Straight in Character.

Oh and they let a teacher take the blame for the phantom almost killing everyone in the academy. I forgot to mention the phantom got mad and locked everyone in the main hall and dropped chandeliers on them and shit (just like the book and musical!!!!!!! wow so accurate) and land mines around the academy (yes the phantom is arms dealer too just roll with it) and some teacher died and even though he was working with the phantom they let him take the fall. Great protagonist we have here folks.

So the end. Everyone ends up happy, nobody dies all in the spirit of the original source material amiright??????

My favorite character hands down was Kat. She was the bitchy mean girl who hated Rune and to be honest I really don't blame Kat at all. Rune has no opera training just is born with a magically good voice and steals the spotlight and opera role from Kat. Kat trained all her life for this and Rune just steals it but gives the staring role to her friend Aubrey because shes a NICE PERSON.

Fuck you Rune. Kat deserved it. And Kat has a best friend Roxie who's in love with her. I'd rather hear about the adventures of two girls in love at an opera academy than a boring ass love story between two ~soulmates~. Ugh. Missed opportunity.

Also there is so much disrespectful gypsy references in here.

Here I quote: "I might be under a gypsy curse."

"After our encounter, I realized why I was enchanted by the spider's feeding rituals, that there was something in my gypsy blood-something tainted and wrong...just as Grandma said."

Wow. Did the author not know how INSULTING that is??? She put the words "gyspy blood" and "tainted" and "wrong" in the same sentence. They are called Romani-not gyspy. Gypsy is a slur. And they were literally persecuted in WWII for having what is called "tainted blood" and not pure Aryan blood. Saying that gypsy blood is tainted and wrong is so demeaning to the Romani people. And saying that they invent curses is bullshit. My jaw dropped when I read that. That alone deserves one star.

What also bugged me is the pacing in the story is off and some parts were literally Rune describing every single detail. For example when she goes to garden she has to describe her process of doing it and I want to bash my head against the wall. 100 pages could have been trimmed from this book. There was no tension, no build up, barely a climax and the twists were pathetic.

I would give this book zero stars if I could. The only redeeming thing is that it's so bad, so horrifying that sometimes its actually hilarious. I laughed at the parts where i wasn't supposed to laugh at and laughed at how seriously this book took itself when it's just another bland YA love story that we seen a million times. But this one really got under my skin because it used source material that I love and disrespected it just like that shitty Last Airbender movie did.

0/5 stars. Only read it if you want a guide of what not to do in a YA book and if you want a good laugh. Excuse me while I go wash out my brain and regain my sanity.
Profile Image for Emily May.
2,157 reviews317k followers
February 10, 2017

TWO AND A HALF WEEKS. I gave this book two and a half weeks. I literally do not remember the last time it took me this long to read a book. And I'm including 1000+ page classics in that.

I wanted to like this book so much. I kept forcing myself to continue to the end, trying to find excuses to bump up the rating and justify buying a finished copy to look gorgeous on my bookshelf. I love . I wanted to love this, but it was just one cliche after another.

Maybe if you're completely new to paranormal YA then you'll enjoy this more, but most readers will recognize all the familiar elements. Howard has done nothing new here. How many times have we read versions of this:

1) Mary Sue protagonist (Rune) with special abilities moves to new school.

2) Despite being bland as all hell, she is the SPECIAL one that is key to everyone's plans.

3) A mysterious HOT guy keeps appearing and disappearing. Rune thinks he seems familiar.

4) Rune instantly becomes enemies with the resident beautiful, popular blonde girl and her friend (literally called the "diva duo" by Rune).

5) Said beautiful girl is bitchy, evil for no reason, and characterized by her overt sexuality as she attempts to seduce a hot male student (how dare she?!) In contrast, Rune refers to her own single lusty encounter as "degrading".

6) Rune soon discovers that her eccentricities are linked to a - oh my, who saw that one coming?

This whole set of tropes might be inserted into a retelling, but I felt just like I was reading the exact same story that I've read a thousand times before. The use of Erik, the phantom, was just window dressing on yet another cliched YA romance with forgettable characters.

Also, it's really obvious what Rune's deal is, right? I won’t spoil it, but to give a similar example: if a character doesn’t go out after dark and needs to drink human blood to survive� ooh, what could they be? I'm pretty sure anyone at all versed in paranormal creatures will know what’s going on here. The clues have all the subtlety of flying bricks.

So disappointing. If you haven't already, just read instead - a dark tale of obsession, beauty and ugliness.

| | | | |
Profile Image for A.G. Howard.
Author20 books9,026 followers
Read
December 13, 2016
Update 1-22-16: FINISHED WRITING IT! I fell in love so hard with this world and these characters. <3 Can't wait to share it with everyone in January 2017!

Update 6-21-16:
ARCs are around the corner! For info on how to request one, follow this link:

Here are a few quick RoseBlood FAQs:

(1) What's the book about?

Much like Splintered was for Alice in Wonderland, this is a modern day spin-off / continuation of the original Phantom of the Opera, that follows a high school senior who is sent to RoseBlood Academy—a French boarding school for musical arts inside a renovated opera house rumored to have ties to the classic opera—only to discover a very real danger lurks within that has awaited her for over a century.

(2) Is Erik in the story?

Well, there is an elusive, masked, tortured hero/anti-hero with an agenda and a violin, who might just be the infamous disfigured Phantom. You'll have to read to find out.

(3) Is Christine in the story?

She kind of plays a role. And that's meant to be cryptic. ;) But RoseBlood's heroine is someone else entirely. Like Christine, she has the voice of an angel. But unlike Christine, every time my heroine sings, she's left physically drained and ill, as if the songs overpower her. Which is why she's sent to the academy, in hopes she can learn to master the music.

(4) Is there a love triangle?

There are several different kinds of love in the book: platonic, romantic, and familial. There's also the passionate love a composer has for his music. Taking each of them into consideration, it's safe to say there is a triangle. But you'll have to read the story to find out which kind of love it involves. One thing to note, though: The original story had a romantic love triangle, and I don't like to just rehash what's already been done. So you can safely assume there won't be a romantic one. ;)

(5) Is this a fantasy?

Yes, there are both fantasy and paranormal aspects to this retelling. There's also a touch of horror.

(6) Is this a contemporary setting?

The opera house has an old world Gothic atmosphere, so although the story is set in the modern era, there are dark Victorian elements woven throughout.

(7) Is this a standalone or a series?

It's a standalone. :)

(8) What color will the text be?

I haven't heard yet from my publisher if it *will* have colored text, but I'm hopeful! I'll let you know as soon as I do!

(9) Will it be the same sort of "milder" YA content like the splintered series, or is this for an older YA group?

In the product details, my Splintered books are listed as appropriate for ages 14+ by my publisher. RoseBlood will be listed for the same ages.

But there is one major difference: where my Wonderland series is based on what has often been considered a children's story, RoseBlood is based on The Phantom of the Opera -- a romantic horror/ drama about the obsession to be accepted and loved, and unrequited passion turned to madness. So the mood is different.

RoseBlood is very character-driven, as opposed to plot-driven, which makes it a slower, more complex unwinding of twists and turns than the Splintered books. There also aren't any *whimsical* underpinnings in this one. Instead, it's darkly romantic and Gothic with subtle elements of horror, and the relationships involve more tortured/sensual depths. For these reasons, it will appeal to teens who like richer character-driven stories, but also to an older more mature demographic, as well.

As for how graphic the sensuality or language aspects are, those are still comparable to the Splintered Series.

(10) What were some of your musical inspirations for this novel?

Other than the passing mention of Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical, both Sergei Prokofiev's Russian opera, "The Fiery Angel" and "Rusalka", a Czech opera by Antonín Dvořák, play roles in the story line.

As far as outside of the story world, to inspire my writing stints, I created/listened to a playlist that consists -- as you might expect -- of violin and operatic pieces, but also ranges from gothic metal to rock, electronic indie pop to trip hop, and alternative metal to pop-noir .

It's a very eclectic playlist, with myriad moods, emotions, lyrics and instrumental/vocalist stylings. I can't say for sure which songs will make it onto my official playlist once the book comes out, but I had lots of fun getting inspired as I wrote! :)

(11) What did you do for research?

I've read Gaston Leroux’s novel twice and made copious notes. I was determined to honor the atmosphere, setting, and Erik's backstory, but at the same time, bridge them to the modern world.

I watched both the musical and movie; although they don't play hefty roles in the book, they are mentioned as part of everyday culture.

I also researched the opera singer, Christina Nilsson, who was rumored to have "possibly" inspired Leroux's naive young ingenue, Christine Daaé. Even Leroux himself has merited research, because his serialization of Phantom in a French newspaper influenced part of my plot. And I've studied image after image of the Palais Garnier which Leroux drew upon when fashioning his " Opera Populaire," to refine the setting.

And lastly, I read Susan Kay's "Phantom" twice, because in my opinion, her prequel to The Phantom of the Opera beefs-up Erik's early life with emotional depth, historical details, and insight, while still honoring Leroux's original vision.

All that to say, although I twisted things here and there to fit my adaptation -- similar to how I did with Splintered and Alice in Wonderland -- I stayed very true to Erik's original characterization and history while expanding upon it.

(12) Will you be offering ARCs of RoseBlood?

Yes. For info on how to request one, visit my blog:

Good luck!

For a look at my visual inspirations for the book, check out the RoseBlood pinterest board:
Profile Image for Natalie Monroe.
618 reviews3,812 followers
May 6, 2017
A single spotlight flicks on. Cynical Natalie sits in the middle, blinking at the glare.

Cynical Natalie: What the hell is this? Where's my annoying twin?

A disjointed voice booms out of the darkness: Are you ready to play How Mad Can We Make Cynical Natalie?

Applause reigns. Cynical Natalie tries to protest, but her voice is masked by the immediate rumble, The rules are simple. Characters, quotes, plot points, anything of note are listed from a novel called Roseblood and we will see how—long—it—takes—for—Cynical Natalie—to—blow—her—TOP!

The cheers are deafening.

Cynical Natalie: Now wait just a minute�

Offering #1: A school in contemporary times is called RoseBlood, like the founder never grew out of his/her emo phase

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #2: Located in France, Roseblood only accepts American students because logic

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #3: Nothing in this book suggests it's set in France. The school is deliberately organized as such to have an "American atmosphere" so students won't get homesick, but we all know that's an excuse to skip research.

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #4: Info-dump. All the fucking info-dump.

In the first chapter, Audrey and her mom word-vomit through conversation why she's being sent to school, her decreased dad, her impulse to sing, her mom's new marriage, her grandma's superstition, etc. After she meets Sunny, there's more word-vomit on the school's history

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #5: Mean Popular Girl is blonde, gorgeous, and sexually forward

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #6: Rune faints on her first day and a hot guy carries her to the infirmary

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #7: Hot guy also happens to be Mean Popular Girl's crush.

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #8: The name Rune

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #9: The writing

"The music brightens our synchronized footsteps, as warm and honey yellow as the sun, flooding our surroundings, relaxing me until there's no strain anywhere on my body. Though the aria rages from my throat--the mood dark, mad and melancholy--I'm unaffected. Bubbles of serenity encapsulate every I staccato, trill and glissando, then lift them from my vocal cords and roll them off my lips, effortlessly."


Cynical Natalie:



Offering #10: More writing

"His lips part and our tongues meet, lighting up my insides with voltaic pulses of emotions, auras that burst in my mind on explosions of color flavored with caramel, midnight flowers and singed spices—dark, tempestuous, and succulent."


Cynical Natalie:


Offering #11: The fucking writing

"An expression of sympathy and supplication deepens his brows his brown, hawkish eyes before they fluctuate to that shimmery, coppery gaze I saw in the garden upon my arrival."


Cynical Natalie:



Offering #12: Special Rune thinks she's cursed and dark. This time, with a dash of racism in the form of "gypsy blood"

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #13: Just this.

"Rune's light. The purest white he'd ever seen... incarnate, rare... the essence of an angel."


Cynical Natalie:



Offering #14: Insta-love

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #15: Twilight parallels

-Rune's Mom abandons her like Bella's mom because of her new husband

-The scene where she unmasks Thorn is similar to when Edward shows off his diamond-encrusted chest. Rune is mesmerized, awed, some other adjective.

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #16: More quotes.

"Logic tells me I should be afraid. But I can't stop thinking about all the hours I've spent with my maestro, how I no longer fear what he hides beneath his mask. How I've seen his soul written upon the pages of his past and it's beautiful."


Cynical Natalie:



Offering #17: Disgusting treatment of sex workers.

Thorn's mom had him out of wedlock and so she considers herself a whore. When Thorn's powers awaken at 14, Erik leads him to a whorehouse to suck energy out of the women working there.

They're treated as less than dirt. In contrast, Rune is encased by a pure white light. Her voice is purity incarnate. She finds her first ever sexual encounter "degrading." You can't not notice these comparisons

Cynical Natalie:



Offering #18: All. The. Clothes. Descriptions. Sweater and leggings. Jeans and tunic.

Cynical Natalie:



We've done it, folks! Cynical Natalie is now a frothing vortex of rage. Please show yourselves out and remember NOT to pick up your copy of Roseblood by the door.
Profile Image for Hailey (Hailey in Bookland).
614 reviews84.8k followers
April 7, 2017
*Reread December 2016*
So I have now read this book twice and twice and twice now I have struggled to get through it. I wanted so badly to love it because I was really looking forward to it but while there were things I enjoyed, overall I did not really care for it. I loved the writing, the descriptions are incredible. The atmosphere was awesome. But, I was so bored and that just ruins it for me. So unfortunately my rating remains to be 3 stars.

*First read October 2016*
3 stars for now, I really think I just wasn't in the mood for it so I'm hoping to give it another shot at a later date.
Profile Image for Melissa ♥ Dog/Wolf Lover ♥ Martin.
3,621 reviews11.4k followers
February 7, 2017
My January Owlcrate Box! Don't look if you haven't gotten yours yet. Although, my picture wasn't all that great this time!

 :

At home, I have a poster on my wall of a rose that's bleeding. It's petals are white, and red liquid oozes from its heart, thick and glistening warm. Only, if you look very close, you can see the droplets are coming from above, where a little girl's wrist--camouflaged by a cluster of leaves--has been pricked by it's thorns as she reached inside to catch a monarch.


 :

This book was so bizarre and so good! I didn't understand all that was going on but I loved it. The reason is that it had a very creepy vibe, everything about it had creepsville all over it.

Rune is sent to Roseblood in France because of issues she has with her beautiful singing. I won't go into all of that because some of it is confusing and it would be a spoiler.

Roseblood is/was . . . the home of The Phantom of he Opera. The place seems creepy enough without all of that added to it.

Rune makes some enemies <--the mean girls of course and she meets some good friends as well. She also meets a mysterious boy named Thorn. Who is he and why is he not in any classes? Is he even real? Why do the animals on the property have different voices. Who is it Rune sees behind the glass in the school, moving through the walls. Is she going crazy?

There are so many things to this book and I loved it. I can't say enough how creepy and weird I thought it was and that's why I like it. There really are some things I wished I understood but maybe it will sink in or I can read it a few times until it does. lol

There is a history with Rune's family, the phantom and other people and things. Read the book and find out, then tell me what you think so I know for sure. =)

AND THE COVER IS AMAZING! I DON'T CARE, IT JUST ROCKS!

 :

I also felt this was a great stand alone book! But I want more books like this so go and write some more and make sure they have pretty covers! � �

MY BLOG:
Profile Image for Sarah.
237 reviews1,212 followers
June 10, 2018
Sixteen-year-old Rune Germaine has synesthesia, a perceptive phenomena (which really exists) where stimuli for one sense triggers other senses too. For example, sounds have colors to Rune.

But Rune’s synesthesia is connected to another condition, of which she appears to be the only possessor. Whenever she hears an operatic soprano aria, she has to belt it out, even if it kills her. Even as a toddler who could barely speak her native language, she could flawlessly sing along, with an apparently adult set of pipes, in perfect Italian or Russian, to whatever her violinist father was listening to on the classical radio station.

Then Rune’s father passed away from a terminal illness. The girl was six years old then, and her grandmother claimed she was cursed and started trying to murder her. In very practical ways, such as drowning the child in a wooden crate filled with water. Or setting fire to her second-grade classroom with the class inside a year later. It never worked, and Grandma went to jail in her native land of France. (Howard keeps insisting that Granny Germaine is imprisoned in Versailles. I think she means the Bastille).

We rejoin Rune in the present, driving through the countryside surrounding Paris with her practical-minded mom, who can’t wait to drop the kid off at her new school so she can get back stateside and have some quality time with her new fiancé. What do you mean, you've heard this one before?

Bella and her cactus

Rune’s new school is an arts academy in a rehabilitated historical opera house, called RoseBlood. With the capitalized B in the middle. This is a bizarre name for any establishment, let alone a school, but it’s far from the most macabre, contrived, or ridiculously emo thing in this story�

Rune is scared to attend RoseBlood because she’s Done Research on The Internet—complete with “chat rooms”—and her findings suggest that RoseBlood is the self-same building wherein the events of The Phantom of the Opera took place in the late nineteenth century. Her mom tries to calm her down by insisting that “Leroux’s book is just fiction.� This whole dialogue sounds more like a Wikipedia entry than a conversation between an angsty girl and the mom who can’t wait to get rid of her for a few months, a problem which will run throughout the book.

As they enter the grounds of the remote school, Rune spots a tall, lithe male figure in a cape and half-mask pruning the rosebushes that edge the road. She tells her mom, and her mom promptly dismisses it.

Eventually, Rune settles into school life, at this school with an improbably huge budget and minimal academic program. She makes a quick group of friends, who are diverse and likeable but none of whom are given much development. Also, all of these kids break into her room and snoop on a regular basis, which is not supposedly in character for any of them, and this does not bother Rune. Interestingly, this school is in Paris, but every student there is American.

But she also experiences embarrassing flare-ups of her “need to sing.� And creepy things keep happening on campus…and the masked man keeps appearing in her mirrors, in the corner of her eye. She hears mysterious violin music.

Eventually she gets lured into an underground chamber where she meets the shadowy presence. At first she believes him to be the Phantom, but it turns out that he’s actually Etalon, called Thorn, the adopted son of the Erik from the story. The original Opera Ghost—the O.G.O.G., if you will—is still kicking, and he needs both Rune and Thorn as part of his latest evil scheme.

How is Erik still alive? Why do Rune and Etalon have this powerful instant connection, despite not knowing each other? How did Rune put a college boy in a coma back in the States?

Buckle up, because things are about to get really stupid at record speed.

Content Advisory
Violence, Sex, and Nightmare Fuel, because they’re all entwined here:

Miscellaneous: Rune’s grandmother kept saying that the girl had “cursed gypsy blood� that caused her bizarre and destructive behavior, and references to “gypsy� wildness and curses are scattered throughout. The correct term is Romani. Grandma can be a racist character and believe in all manner of horrible arcane stereotypes, sure, but someone should really point that out.

It could have been done easily at the beginning of the book and never brought up again:

Rune: Grandma always said that my cursed gypsy blood caused all this trouble.
Rune’s Mom: We’ve had this discussion before, Rune! Your grandmother is a homicidal version of Archie Bunker. Don’t pay any mind to her bigoted nonsense. Of course your dad’s Romani ancestors didn’t curse you. Nor did your Irish ancestors from my side of the family give you the ability to talk to leprechauns. The end.


In the “small comfort� department, there’s no cussing or drug content to speak of in this book.

Conclusions
I noticed a lot of references to The Phantom of the Opera in A.G. Howard’s Splintered trilogy, which was a retelling of Alice in Wonderland set in the modern day. The Splintered series had one awful character who marred everything he touched, but it also featured great prose, a marvelously weird fantasy world, and a wonderful antihero who reminded me a bit of Erik, among many other variations on the Death God/Trickster archetype. So naturally I was excited to see Howard’s take on POTO ٲ�

I don’t even know if she and I read the same book, or watched the same musical.

Andrew Lloyd-Webber wrote a sequel to his musical called Love Never Dies, which takes place ten years after the original. Erik has moved to New York in disguise, where he has made a name for himself as the owner of a freak show and/or amusement park on Coney Island. Using an alias, he lures Christine to the place, and she drags along Raoul (who has somehow turned into a ne’er-do-well alcoholic) and her ten-year-old son, a musical prodigy named Gustav. She tells Erik that Gustav is his child, conceived the night before she married Raoul. Erik and Raoul fight again, Meg Giry shoots Christine and wounds her fatally, and after Christine dies in Erik’s arms, the Phantom says (I paraphrase) “Gustav, I am your father.�

NOOOOO

While the show has some nice music in it, the plot and characterizations have been rightly reviled by critics and audiences alike. Lloyd-Webber showed himself to be spectacularly out-of-touch, not only with Leroux’s characters, but with his own treatment of those characters.

1. Christine was always represented as naïve, childlike and sometimes childish, and pious. Even though many stagings of the musical strongly suggest that she really loved Erik more than Raoul, she did care for Raoul. To cheat on him at all would go against everything we know about her. To cheat on him the night before his wedding would just be cruel.

2. Erik finally changed at the end of the original story. He repented of terrorizing the opera house. He realized that Christine didn’t care about his deformity, but she did care about his habit of strangling people. He realized that he couldn’t give her any kind of life at all, lurking in the catacombs and hiding from society, and he let her go. We don’t know where he went at the end, but he left behind both his comfort objects—the monkey music box and the mask—symbolizing a break with the toxic past. If he lapses right back into villainy, there’s no point to the original story. The only way a POTO sequel can work is with a reformed Erik.

RoseBlood is like Love Never Dies combined with Twilight (boring girl gets dumped at gloomy new town/school by her mom, who wants to remarry, girl meets mystery boy with glowing orange eyes, insta-love ensues, stupid vampire lore that has nothing to do with actual vampire mythology) and that one Mystery Science Theatre 3000 episode that my extended family made me watch one time, where the movie was about an elderly woman who met up with a mad scientist to transplant her brain into the body of a pretty young girl. The scientist also had a wolf-man creation who fell in love with the girl, and the whole thing was a creepy, incoherent mess. There was a cat in it, and the cat was the only decent character in the group. Same goes for RoseBlood.

So the idea of Christine Daeë cheating on her husband is laughably absurd, but nowhere near as much as the idea of Christine Daeë being a Psychic Vampire �. While Erik always had a spectral quality (hence his nickname), both Leroux and Lloyd-Webber make clear than in the end, he was just a man who was good at magic tricks, so the characterization of him in this book is equally ridiculous. Also, while he was certainly a menace to society in the original, neither that nor any of the other adaptations that I know of said anything about “mad scientist.� Howard is thinking of Dr. Victor Frankenstein, whom I sincerely hope is not the subject of her next emo fan fiction.

The idea of “twin flames� or soul mates as shown here actually has potential, but what makes such pairings compelling when they work is that there is friction between these two characters. They are usually portrayed as opposites of some kind, separated by ideology and/or moral conviction. Mr. Rochester tells Jane Eyre that he feels a “cord of communion� exists between them, that would break, weakening him, if she left, but her principles compel her to leave him even though it grieves them both. This is also why Christine had to leave Erik in the original POTO. Sometimes the two start out open enemies, like Nick Burkhardt and Adalind Schade on NBC’s Grimm (a rare example with a male hero and female monster), or Kylo Ren/Ben Solo and Rey in the Star Wars sequels.

What makes all these relationships worth investing in is that the two characters will have to work like heck to start that relationship, let alone maintain it. Chances are one or both of them are going against their better judgment even by starting a friendship with the other. Insta-love, on the other hand, is the exact opposite of this trope. It kills tension and makes it hard, if not impossible, for the reader to care about the relationship.

Also, lines like “We were destined to be lovers, Rune� (verbatim from Etalon shortly after meeting her) sound a little creepy and more than a little pathetic:

[image error]" width="500" height="323" alt="Nick and Lindsay"/>

In conclusion, this was a retelling with no grasp of the original material, and a weak, pointless, ridiculously lurid story in its own right. The characters are either non-entities or hideous parodies of what they ought to be. There’s no plot, the world-building is all over the place, and nothing that happens makes sense. I’ve praised Howard’s writing style before and I still like it. But man�

…for all my gripes with the Splintered series, this made that look like Lord of the Rings.

A buddy read with @Geeky.com.
Profile Image for Nenia ✨ I yeet my books back and forth ✨ Campbell.
Author59 books20.9k followers
February 10, 2017

|| || || ||


ROSEBLOOD is about three of my favorite things: The Phantom of the Opera, the Comte de Saint-Germain, and vampires. All three together? Oh, heck yes. Set in a gloomy boarding school/converted opera house in the middle of France, I was certain that this neo-Gothic, ROSEBLOOD, would be able to do one of my favorite classics justice in a new and interesting way.



I was wrong.



It kills me to say this, because the writing in ROSEBLOOD is so beautiful that it actually almost convinced me that ROSEBLOOD was a better book than it actually was. A.G. Howard can write. However, her characters and story-telling choices are odd. Like, campy 80s horror movie odd. There were so many moments in here that had me blinking, and going, "Did that really happen?" Towards the end of the story, it happened more and more.



**WARNING: THAR BE MAJOR SPOILERS**



First, let me get something out of the way that really bothered me. I hate this new YA trend of taking the "ugly" characters in classic stories and making them beautiful. Sarah J. Maas did this in A COURT OF THORNS AND ROSES, taking the "beast" and making him a gorgeous fairy prince cursed to wear a mask. A.G. Howard does this in ROSEBLOOD, with the "phantom" love interest being not the tortured, disfigured genius, but the tortured, disfigured genius's adopted (but gorgeous) son, Thorn. Coincidentally enough, Thorn also wears a mask, just like Tam Lin, only for fun. When you do this, it takes all the original meaning out of the story. Part of what made Beauty and the Beast such a powerful story was that the beast was a horrible man when he was attractive and human; it took being ugly and monstrous to make him realize how lonely and awful it is to be despised when your exterior matches your interior, and it took a love that was based on more than looks (well, you can argue about that, since, you know, "Beauty" and the Beast) to redeem him. Likewise, part of what makes Phantom of the Opera such a tragic story is that Erik's genius and artistry goes unappreciated because of his lack of looks; what draws him to Christine isn't just her ethereal beauty and innate talent, but also because he sees her as his soulmate; the beautiful foil to his hideous appearance.



STOP MAKING THESE CHARACTERS GORGEOUS AND SHALLOWING EVERYTHING UP.



Anyway, to the plot of the story. Our heroine is named "Rune." She has a tragic history. She doesn't want to go to this special school because she has a special ability: she is compelled to sing at certain moments, and always does it beautifully. Naturally, she is "compelled" to do this while the resident Queen Bee is auditioning, before pretending to pass out. Her mother sticks around for a while but is about to go on honeymoon with Rune's new stepfather, so like Bella Swan's mom, or Mindy from Animaniacs, she goes, "Okay, I love you, bye-bye," and swans off, leaving Rune to her own devices. Luckily, Rune makes a whole bunch of friends, immediately, who are so fascinated by her lack of personality and her special secrets that they see absolutely zero problems about sneaking into her room and snooping into her belongings. This happens several times.



Rune meets a boy named Thorn who appears around the Opera House. He always wears a half-mask, but is super attracted to the half of the face that she can see. He tells her that they're "twin souls." No, literally, they are two halves of the same soul: incarnations of the Christine from the Phantom of the Opera myth. Only, Thorn can't sing because when he was young, he was kidnapped by sex traffickers, and his voice scared them so much that they poured lye down his throat. So instead of singing, Thorn plays the violin, and when he plays, Rune no longer feels sick after she sings.



This is because Rune, Thorn, and the Phantom (Erik), are all PSYCHIC VAMPIRES who use their magical abilities to draw out people's life force.



Psychic. Vampires.



Erik even owns a themed club in Paris. A rave club, where he picks off victims when he's so inclined. This is one of many moments, when I was just shocked and could only mumble, "Phantom...of the Rave? Phantom...rave...huh? Rave...phantom...rave..."



PHANTOM OF THE RAVE.



I'm sorry, I can't let that go. Erik doesn't belong anywhere near a rave. I refuse to believe that his artistic integrity would allow him to tolerate dub-step.



If you're wondering where Rune fits into all this, it ties back to the Phantom. Apparently, he and Christine got together at one point and had a baby (YESSSSSS). The baby was stillborn, but Erik has been keeping it alive in a Frankenstein-style incubator for all these years, waiting for Christine's reincarnation so he could kidnap that person, cut out their vocal chords, and implant them in the baby...because this will bring the baby to life again for some reason. All his attempts to get to Rune have been to activate her power, have Thorn seduce her, and then basically cut out her throat.



What.



The.



Fork.



I've seen and read several Phantom of the Opera adaptions, and this was one of the worst because it was so weird. It reminded me, actually, of that bad Italian remake, (1998), which features Julian Sands looking less like the Phantom of the Opera and more like a reject from Interview of the Vampire since a) he's not disfigured (and is actually pretty hot), and b) the movie is less about him pursuing Christina for his sensually artistic purposes and more about sex (if I recall correctly, it actually features an orgy scene) and countless violent murder sprees. Not that ROSEBLOOD was gratuitously violent or needlessly sexual - it wasn't; it's similar because, like Il fantasma dell'opera, it was so over the top that in its attempt to differentiate itself from the work it was paying homage to, it pretty much lost sight of the original's purpose and become something totally and completely different. For better or for worse.



P.S. I'm disappointed to say that the Saint-Germaine connection basically goes nowhere, which is a shame, . For another story about Saint-Germaine and vampires that's actually pretty good, I suggest you check out Chelsea Quinn Yarbro's Saint-Germaine series.



2 to 2.5 stars.
Profile Image for Korrina.
193 reviews4,074 followers
August 11, 2016
Yup, I adored this one. Loved the setting, loved the characters, loved the romance, loved the twists and turns, loved the mystery, loved the atmosphere. Loved the writing.

This was my first A.G. Howard book and now I'm very tempted to pick up more!
Profile Image for Tracy .
569 reviews196 followers
December 12, 2016
Me when I realize this book doesn't come out until 2017...



Read more of my reviews at !

Two things drew me to RoseBlood. First, it's written by A.G. Howard who has literally never disappointed me. I adored her Splintered series and am already in love with the Haunted Hearts Legacy. Second, I am HUGE Phantom fan. I've read the book and its unofficial sequel and I've seen the broadway show and its official sequel. When I saw that one of my favorite authors was writing a retelling of one of my favorite stories, I knew I would have to read it as soon as possible!

The very first thing I realized about RoseBlood was that it wasn't actually a retelling, but more of a modern day continuation of the original story. Of course, the Phantom is still a key figure in this story. If you're asking yourself how that's possible in a modern-day continuation of his story from the 1800s, just trust me when I say it all works out. Apart from Erik, there are two main players - Rune, a gifted singer and RoseBlood's newest student, and Thorn, who regards the Phantom as his father.

Both Rune and Thorn were fantastic characters and this really was their story. On their own, each of them are strong, talented characters with their own tragic pasts to contend with. I loved Rune and found her to be extremely easy to sympathize with, more so as the story went on. I liked that she was independent while still reacting believably to danger, unlike some of the "strong women" that often show up in fantasy. Thorn was an amazing love interest who made Rune's safety his priority while always acknowledging that she was fully capable of taking care of herself. Their romance was entirely swoon-worthy! The unusual, soul-deep connection they shared gave me all the feels and honestly I would love to have seen even more of them together! (Maybe we can get novellas like we did with the Splintered trilogy?)

While the Phantom was a part of this story, he certainly wasn't the center of attention and I feel as if he was less developed than the other characters because of it. I think this was mostly okay though, since Erik is such a well-known character already. We already know his backstory and this just builds on it, often in very unexpected ways. I'll admit the additions to his story threw me off a bit, but I can definitely appreciate the originality. This Erik has a bit more to him than the one you already know.

As always, A.G. Howard has crafted a totally unique and immersive world. I felt like I could perfectly picture the gorgeous, gothic surroundings she painted from the opera house to the Phantom's lair to the chapel and the graveyard. I loved trying to work out exactly what the secret passageways would look like and how they'd work. My absolute favorite was the aviary, which you definitely want to know more about (trust me).

I did have a bit of a hard time getting going with RoseBlood. The story was extremely interesting, but it starts off very slow. A good chunk of the story is just Rune settling into her new school, meeting new friends, and facing off with the resident mean girls. Once things finally picked up after Rune and Thorn met, I couldn't put it down! I loved that I never quite knew what the big picture was and new things were constantly being revealed. While it ended up being much different than what I expected, I really did love it!

My biggest gripe about RoseBlood is that it started so slow. The elements that surprised and confused me were also the bits that made this such a unique continuation of the Phantom's story. If you go into RoseBlood without too many preconceived ideas about what you're going to read, chances are you're going to love it! A.G. Howard has created a gorgeous world with amazing new characters to integrate with the old and the romance is to die for! If you're a fan of retellings or Phantom of the Opera, this is one you definitely shouldn't miss.

Actual rating: 4.5 stars

//I received this book from the author in exchange for an honest review//
Profile Image for Alyssa.
1,069 reviews855 followers
December 15, 2016
4.5 stars.


*

RoseBlood by A.G. Howard
Publisher: Amulet Books
Publication Date: January 10, 2017
Rating: 4 stars
Source: ARC sent by the publisher

Summary (from ŷ):

In this modern day spin on Leroux’s gothic tale of unrequited love turned to madness, seventeen-year-old Rune Germain has a mysterious affliction linked to her operatic talent, and a horrifying mistake she’s trying to hide. Hoping creative direction will help her, Rune’s mother sends her to a French arts conservatory for her senior year, located in an opera house rumored to have ties to The Phantom of the Opera.

At RoseBlood, Rune secretly befriends the masked Thorn—an elusive violinist who not only guides her musical transformation through dreams that seem more real than reality itself, but somehow knows who she is behind her own masks. As the two discover an otherworldly connection and a soul-deep romance blossoms, Thorn’s dark agenda comes to light and he’s forced to make a deadly choice: lead Rune to her destruction, or face the wrath of the phantom who has haunted the opera house for a century, and is the only father he’s ever known.

What I Liked:

I'll admit - I don't know too much about The Phantom of the Opera. I think I've seen a movie version at some point in elementary school, but I don't remember that well. I know the basics of the story, but it has never really intrigued me. Still, knowing the basics of the story made me curious about this book, because The Phantom of the Opera has an interesting romance. I didn't like Howard's debut trilogy (well, the final book, anyway), but I loved this standalone.

Rune has an immense operatic talent, but she feels like she's cursed - she's always left drained and exhausted after singing. What's more, she did something awful, and she's pretty sure it's related to her singing ability and the exhaustion she experiences afterwards. Her mother and aunt pulls strings and get her into RoseBlood, a French arts conservatory, located in an opera house. Rune notices strange things at the academy; her uniforms go missing, she hears strange noises in the vents, and she keeps seeing a masked man dressed in Victorian-era clothes, but no one else seems to notice him. Everyone insists that the Phantom isn't real... but what if he is? He wants something from Rune, and Rune will have to understand her past in order to control her future.

This is a Gothic contemporary novel, set in modern-day France, but obviously with fantastical elements. There is a paranormal side to this book that I won't reveal, but it has everything to do with Rune's extraordinary singing ability, and her crippling exhaustion after singing. I loved the world-building of this story; I don't think I've read a story with a setting like this. I happen to adore boarding-school-esque settings, and this one did not disappoint. Plus, it's set in France! Close to Paris (though I'm not really sure where exactly). That was cool!

I liked Rune almost from the start. She didn't want to move all the way to France and go to RoseBlood, and she doesn't even want to sing. Her singing bursts forth and then leaves her exhausted, and there is nothing she can do about it. My heart ached for her, because it was almost as if her singing was controlling her. Rune is kind and almost innocent, though she is riddled with guilt over the terrible thing that she did. Throughout the book, we also see that she is compassionate and even selfless; she lets others think badly of her when really, she is trying to help them.

This book is told from Rune's first-person POV, but also Thorn's third-person POV. While I would have loved to read Thorn's POV in first-person, I certainly appreciated having both POVs to read from. Both voices were strong and distinct, and both were extremely necessary in telling the story. This isn't just Rune's story - it's Thorn's too.

Thorn is a mysterious occupant of RoseBlood. I don't want to say too much about him, because he is not who you think. Just as my heart ached for Rune, my heart broke for Thorn. His past is heartbreaking and cruel, and even his present life isn't joyful. He is stuck, and when Rune arrives, it's like something shifts. Thorn's story is so important, both past and present.

There are many secondary characters in this book, many of whom I absolutely adored. Sunny, Rune's mentor and peer, was hilarious. Jax, Quan, and Audrey were good friends to Rune. Kat and Roxie were cliche "mean girls", but they had their roles. I liked that Rune developed a better relationship with her Aunt Charlotte, towards the end of the book.

But mostly, I loved the relationship between Thorn and Rune. Their romance is seductive and thrilling and dreamy. I don't even know how to describe it. Rune has been seeing a boy with copper-colored eyes in her dreams, serenading her with a violin. It turns out that that is Thorn (and there is a reason, don't worry). They have been linked in dreams for quite some time, and meeting in person is... quietly explosive. I love their initial connection, and then the connection they form as they see more of each other, at RoseBlood. The romance is gently formed, but entrancingly so.

AND, there is no love triangle in this book! I was afraid that there would be, because there is potential for a love triangle, given the original story. Also, let's not forget the atrocity that was Howard's debut trilogy, in terms of a love triangle (atrocity to me, that is). But there was NO love triangle in this book. None!

I love how everything comes together, all the pieces and parts that Howard drops as the story progresses. Everything from Rune's father to her crazy grandmother, from Thorn's sad history to his and Rune's connection, makes sense as the end of the book gets close. It was interesting to put everything together and finally understand. I wouldn't say there was a huge mystery to solve or anything like that, but the author sets up the story so that you'll be wondering about this or that, until things are gradually revealed towards the climax of the book. Very well done.

I adored the ending of the book (though I wouldn't mind an epilogue). This ends perfectly, and exactly as a standalone should. I was so satisfied with the ending, I wanted to reread the book immediately upon finishing. I feel like many books these days (especially series enders) have ended so disappointingly. I'm glad this book did not.

What I Did Not Like:

This book easily could have done with more swoony scenes from Thorn and Rune. Swoony... or steamy. Don't get me wrong, the romance is plenty swoony (in a subtle way), and seductive, but there many physical, ah, interactions between them (please read between the lines and read "physical" as "kissing"). For a romance that was so seductive, there needed to be more kissing. And in any case, more is always good.

Other than that, meh. I don't have any complaints.

Would I Recommend It:

I definitely recommend this book! It's worth the buzz, that's for sure. I was indecisive about this one, because I didn't have a great experience with Howard's last book (Ensnared), but this book really worked for me. If you like the Phantom of the Opera (this is a retelling), or Gothic fantasy/paranormal/contemporary, then give this one a chance. Plus, there is lots of singing, and even some dancing. And again, no love triangle!

Rating:

4.5 stars -> rounded down to 4 stars. I will definitely be rereading this one, and recommending it to friends. It lives up to the hype (well, it's been hyped at least for me, in terms of the people I interact with and follow). I am curious to see what the author will come up with next!
Profile Image for Stacee.
2,948 reviews748 followers
November 16, 2016
I absolutely loved this book. I’ve always been a fan of Phantom {I’ve seen it several times in San Diego, LA, and Chicago} and never mind the fact that it was Anita’s words, I didn’t even know I wanted a Phantom retellling until I learned about RoseBlood.

Rune is an interesting character. She’s got this amazing talent that has made her withdraw a bit. She’s still grieving for her father and as she learns things about herself, she is constantly second guessing things that happened in the past. At times, Rune appears to be a fragile and meek kitten, but then she’ll surprise you.

I’m not sure how much I want to share about Thorn. He’s a complex character and I loved getting his story in pieces. And with him being a creation of Anita’s, you know there will be swoons. There is also a heartbreaking backstory and perhaps some redemption.

I definitely can’t leave The Phantom out of the list of main characters, but I’m also not going to tell you a thing about him. If you’ve read the book or seen the play, discard what you know about him. Anita’s Phantom takes those incarnations and makes something completely unique and hers. He’s dark and disturbing, but also sweet and charming.

This is another slow burn and I’m starting to think that Anita thrives on torturing her readers. There are so many intricate details and layers and twists and each piece is sloooooowly revealed. We get Rune and Thorn POV and I loved being in both of their heads. It’s maddening and delicious and I wouldn’t have it any other way.

Overall, between the atmospheric setting and the imaginative plot line, RoseBlood will satisfy any reader, even if they don’t know the chandelier’s lot number.

**Huge thanks to Anita for providing the arc free of charge**
Profile Image for Victoria Resco.
Author6 books29.1k followers
September 9, 2021
¿Qué les puedo decir? Es una autora que no decepciona.

Realmente, a pesar del inicio lento de la historia, me mantuvo enganchada el aura Dark Academia, el fondo oscuro de este retelling del fantasma de la ópera y la belleza de las descripciones de A.G. Howard. A partir del 60% encima hay un cambio de ritmo que te mete metafetamina en las venas, yo lo juro. No lo podía soltar.

Encontró una forma de hacer que el insta-love fuese fluido y tuviese una explicación, que fuese tétrico y oscuro y artístico y atrapante todo a la vez. Si sos fanático de la fantasía y el romance, vas a querer leer esto.
Profile Image for Cindy.
523 reviews129k followers
March 14, 2017
The fact that the author wrote “I sucked his face� unironically should tell you enough why this book has a 1 star rating.
Profile Image for booknuts_.
817 reviews1,803 followers
February 10, 2017
I next to never feel guilty about writing a review on a book I didn't like. But with this one I do. I wanted to love this book so much, I REALLY enjoyed Splintered and so I had such high hopes for this one especially since it was a YA retelling of The Phantom of the Opera.

mifi8q7dqxwus
I may very well be a minority when it comes to my thoughts on this book. It's not all bad I promise, so let's get too it.

I think Howard is a great writer, I think she really knows how to twist and turn a story to completely make it her own and a story that is unique.

f438fcb893108eef49c83fa827829a7a.jpgThe main character is not the phantom, it's Rune who is very much the Christine we want her to be or are familiar with when it comes to the musical. She is musically inclined with curly hair! HA! However she has an ability that has almost become a curse. Once she hears music she must sing otherwise she literally becomes physically ill. She has no idea where this gift/curse came from or why she has it. So after a tragedy hits someone in Runes life she is transferred to a musical private school. As a character I had a hard time connecting with her, there wasn't really anything wrong with her I just couldn't connect.


I had a hard time getting into the story and it took me HALF THE BOOK to finally be like...okay now I'm feelin' it! The writing constantly flipped back and forth between past and present and switching points of view in the story telling as Howard tried to give us a 360 view of each important character. There isn't necessarily anything wrong with that in general but for this I just wanted to MOVE ON with the story.
The ONE person that kept me going was...Thorn. His tragic past and how he came to be, mwleto2bjgvfchis creepy/gothic self was interesting and I found myself catching onto the story because of him.

There were also many other side characters that are involved thathelp make this retelling completely the author's own which was fun.


Overall: I think many will find this one very much that suernatural/gothic read that Howard does so well at from her other books.

bekah

Profile Image for Rebecca.
631 reviews502 followers
January 14, 2017
Halle-fucking-lujah I made it.

This book is just.....honestly I don't have the words. So I'm going to do what this book couldn't and be succinct.

1. Way too many words. Like WAY TOO MANY. Descriptions and events that could take a paragraph or maybe two would go on for pages. The writing was unnecessarily intricate and sometimes it just plain didn't make sense.

2. Racist. Continued use of a racial slur (g*ps*). The author is not Romani, she is not taking back the word for her people. She has no business using the word, especially in the racist and demeaning way it was used over and over - Rune's "cursed, g*ps* blood".

3. Psychic. Vampires. I can't make this shit up.

4. Romanticises the relationship between the Phantom and Christine (which lbr is abusive as fuck).

5. One of her (teenage) friends has a bird tattoo underneath her eye. On her FACE.??

6. Boring MC. Creepy love interest.

Honestly, there was nothing I liked.
Profile Image for Irena BookDustMagic.
702 reviews878 followers
December 7, 2016
I rarely feel guilty about writing my reviews, but this one is one of those rare cases when I do.
Why?
Because I was so excited for Roseblood. I even sent my review request to the publishing house Amulet Books, and, since so many book bloggers wanted to read this book, I know how privileged I am to have recieved a physical proof copy.

You can probably guess that my expectations for this novel were high. I read Howard’s Splintered and really enjoyed it, so when I found out about her retelling of Phantom of the Opera, one of the best musicals out there (which is based on the book I haven’t read), I was so excited. Roseblood quickly became one of my most anticipated new releases.

I am sad to say that this book wasn’t the best book I read this year. It wasn’t as excellent as I wanted for it to be. It was just good. And that is it. I can’t even say I loved it, I can only say that I loved some parts of it (like amazingly described images) and the rest I found to be confusing, boring or mediocre.

The story follows Rune who transfers to new school after a tragedy that happened.
On the very few pages we already can read one of tropes in ya fiction: a new girl finds herself opposite a school diva and becomes her rival.
I don’t mind tropes, they are tropes for a reason after all, and it is on the author how the certain story will develop, and how he/she is going to approach to a situation that most readers have already read about in some other story.
The reason why I’m mentioning it here is simply because I wanted to tell you that in that certain situation, I found myself on (school diva) side.

Rune was hard to connect with.

In whole honesty, it was really hard for me to connect with any of characters.
Thorn
was too mysterious at first (although as we get to know his story the whole book becomes so much better).
Side characters were intersting, but weren’t explored enough. Rune said she was friends with them, but we got to see them so rarely that when Rune was worried about their friendship, I couldn’t be concered. I just didn’t feel it.

The story itself is very confusing and it takes 150 pages for the story to become somewhat interesting.
150 pages is simply too long, and because I was confused most of the time troughout the whole book, I couldn’t help but wonder if I’m confused because I simply don’t understand the story (because English is not my first language, or maybe my brain cells just don’t work fast enough), or maybe the writer didn’t describe the world in a way to bring it closer to the reader, to make reader understand it better�

Also, I didn’t like how succubus/incubus thing was replaced with the word vampire at times, when these are two (or three if you want) words that mean totally different creatures, so there was no need to add more confusion to already confusing story.

My favorite book character was Diable. He was the ghost cat. Smart little guy! The way author described him made me imagine him as devon rex, so now I wonder what kind of cat breed was he.

description

The best part of the story is Legend about Phantom. I read it couple of times just to observe everything.

Last 80 pages are the most interesting and where everything starts to make sense.

I feel like, if I ever decide to reread Roseblood, I would enjoy it more.
I am still debating whether I would reread it, because it took me forever to finish it the first time around.
Profile Image for Mlpmom (Book Reviewer).
3,146 reviews402 followers
February 10, 2017
4.5 Stars!

With Howard's imaginative take on Alice in Wonderland with her Splintered series, it wasn't a surprise that I would want to see what she could do with another classic like Phantom of the Opera. A classic already riddled with dark intent, mystery, and an obsession that bordered the line of love and hate and most of all one that transcended time.

I wouldn't of expected anything short of fabulous and anything less than the strange, unusual, and the fantastical.

Howard has a skill to not only recreate a classic but completely twist it up and give it not only a darker edge but one that makes it feel completely new. She never fails to create something almost unimaginable and yet so very believable all at the same time. Something beautiful and almost poetic in execution and design.

This was a beautiful story that held true to the classic but still managed to hold up as its own story and was every bit as enchanting as the classic.


*ARC copy provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
Profile Image for Maria.
121 reviews32 followers
Want to read
January 18, 2017
really REALLY want this book. I love the Phatom of the Opera! akdnsinwks. the cover is really cool too. I just hope I am really on the mailing list for the ARC...she said I was but who knows xD.


the ARCS Either haven't been made yet or I haven't gotten mine #GiveRiaaARCofthisbook2016 lol

UPDATE: I read the original and yesterday I saw the broadway show- I AM READY FOR YOU ROSEBLOOD....ARE YOU BASED OFF THE BOOK OR THE PLAY ?! LOL They were different from each other I just kind of wanted to know.

UPDATE AGAIN: Messaged Abram and they told me the ARCs haven't been printed yet. If this is wrong can someone please tell me because I am getting mixed messages from others.

update: *sees pictures on twitter with people with them- twitches*

UPDATE: well got declined for an eCopy of this book- still don't have the physical copy that they promised me. oh well what can you do, I am not going to rant about this book not being with me....a little upset that's all..

UPDATE: I might be getting this today or tomorrow i'm super excited bring on the Phantom!!!

UPS IS OPENED TODAY GUYS I THINK IM GETTING IT TODAY OMG IM SUPER EXCITED GIVE ME GIVE ME *grabby hands*

When you find out only the U.K. Branch got their ARCs....*cries* nooooooo!!!



----- my actual reaction to just the beginning --

UHM IM CONFUSED. Can anybody tell me how this book is a retelling...this is my honest opinion thus far. A lot of this book is too fantasy for the retelling it is showing. Eric is the phantom- that is a known fact set in stone he made crazy things happen. If you read the original tale however he dies a couple of months after the events of the tale. Only in the musical is where there might be some hope he disappeared. When talking to Anita she told me she based it off the novel however and I am rather confused. Christine was not cursed- she was practicing a lot that's how she became good at singing. Rune is somehow cursed with the power to...sing randomly? Like perfect pitches ? UHM WHAT. Thorn is interesting- he is adapted by Eric the original phantom...but if this is based in modern day France this can't be possible because Eric was born in the 1800s...this makes no sense. The names are weird for this era I have no idea if this is modern day or 1800s France. The the whole thing is a mesh match mess so fair and I didn't even get to the romance or the teen drama they have in store...what do you guys think I had this book for a while now and I'm just picking it up because it got released recently I'm confused..
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Carrie.
3,521 reviews1,671 followers
January 10, 2017
Rune Germaine has always had a beautiful voice but feels a pull towards singing that she doesn't quite understand and can even feel sick or drained at the end of a performance. Now Rune's mother has talked Rune's aunt into pulling a few strings to get Rune bumped to the front of the line to attend Roseblood, a boarding school outside of Paris at an opera house that's been turned into a music conservatory.

Rune knows the history of the opera house and shortly after arriving she sees a mystery boy that vanishes as quickly as he appears which has her questioning whether the stories are real or not. But Rune doesn't have time to dwell on whether something otherworldly is in play quite yet when her pull to sing interrupts auditions being held much to the dismay of others.

RoseBlood by A.G. Howard is a young adult fantasy retelling of the Phantom of the Opera. First with the good about this book, I really felt that the author did a wonderful job taking the well known story of the Phantom and incorporating it into a young adult fantasy read. The story moved along quite nicely and while there were some of the normal young adult tropes involved I think it go creative enough with a well known story as the basis to make the story interesting.

But there were a couple of things with the book that brought my rating down a bit to finally setting on giving this one 3.5 stars. First, not really a big deal but something that bugged me while reading was the use of O.G., now this probably wouldn't stand out but I had just had to explain that O.G. stood for original gangster no more than a week before reading this so every use had me thinking that version in my head. Also, hopefully without saying anything spoilery here I'll just say that for me I think the explaining what was going on in the story as far as the fantasy/paranormal explanation felt a bit off with the wording being used.

I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley.

For more reviews please visit
Profile Image for beautyliterate.
348 reviews1,361 followers
February 7, 2017
4/5 stars

Video Review:

This book. Wow. The writing is beautiful, the story is haunting, and the characters are memorable.

I am a huge fan of the Phantom of the Opera, so I was ecstatic to hear there was going to be an inspired retelling. I have to say A.G. Howard writes so effortlessly beautiful. I felt each word she wrote had some importance. Also, the story itself although is an inspired retelling is entirely her own tale, with it being a modern continuous of the original story.

As some people said the pacing is slow, looking back I didn't mind it overall but there were some places (the beginningish mostly) that left me confused and wanting more. When the plot picked up though I began to fall deep into this story.

The characters were something I didn't expect to love as much as I did. This book is written in third person going back and forth between our two main characters. Both characters had my heart and I realized truly how I cared about them when at one moment in the story I started crying over one of the characters past.

A.G. Howard did an amazing job with taking the original tale's tone and building from it to make her own book. I think if you are a fan of the Phantom of the Opera you should definitely pick this up. I would also recommend it even if you don't know anything about the Phantom of the Opera since A.G. Howard does a great job at staying true to the original story enough to go back to it throughout the book.

*Was sent an ARC from the publishers in exchange for an honest review*
Profile Image for Aila.
911 reviews32 followers
December 15, 2016
You can check this review out on One Way Or An Author!

Thanks so much Abrams for a review copy!

Being a fan of The Phantom of the Opera and knowing Lloyd’s works for the broadway play on piano, I was super enthusiastic on picking this book up. Yet probably because of all the hype building around this book when the blurb first came out, combined with the author’s popularity with her previous book series, I was a bit wary. Quite honestly though, this book surprised me in the best of ways. I ended up falling in love with it � from the descriptive writing to the haunting setting to the extraordinary characters and their passion of music, all of which touched my heart. Roseblood is a superbly written tribute to The Phantom of the Opera that fans will no doubt be delighted to read. I know this fan was.


We begin with the main character Rune’s arrival from Texas to Paris to RoseBlood Academy, which bears a strange connection to the opera house in The Phantom of the Opera. Rune knows this, and even tells her mother about her misapprehensions. But a scary event that happened to her in the states had made her stuck in this haunting building that may or may not have entities lingering in it underground. The only problem is that RoseBlood is a music conservatory for students with musical abilities. Rune’s singing is so glorious, so ethereal that she can’t control it, and in the first chapters of the book we see her let go of it, ruining a play audition in her very first day at the academy and experiencing the toxic consequences of letting herself go like that.

“Up until recently, I’d never had a voice lesson in my life. Yet, ever since I was small, opera had been a living, breathing part of me. The problem is that as I’ve grown, it’s become more demanding� an entity that controls me. Once a song speaks to my conscious, the notes become a toxin I have to release through my diaphragm, my vocal chords, my tongue. The only way I can breathe again is through a binge and purge of music.�

This poses a problem, as well as the fact that she ruined the play auditions. That still doesn’t faze her new friends though, and soon enough she becomes a part of a friend circle who seem normal enough � that is, they don’t notice the signs of someone watching them. While we are getting this narration from Rune’s first person POV, we also read from a third person limited POV of the mysterious Thorn, who is for some reason watching over Rune. Who for some reason is torn between his attraction to her and the duty he has towards his father.

Thorn was such a mysterious figure in the beginning of the story, but readers slowly get to know and emphasize about his past. He is a violinist and ex-singer, with his voice being ruined after an incident when he was younger. One of the biggest things that really stayed with me after reading this book was Howard’s description of music, and the passion the characters have for it. They are lush, enchanting, and her lyrical writing just creates a gorgeous melody without the embellishment of notes on a staff. I had to stop reading twice to just catch all the feelings in me � just because the way Howard writes about music just captured my soul at times. Not only is this book a memorable retelling of The Phantom of the Opera, but a tribute to the opera � and music � in general.

“My plain floral dress transforms into a red opera gown, flowing and lush. He latches his fingers to mine and draws my chest against his, my cheek nestled between his sternum and collarbone. His free hand skims to my lower back, and we fold into one another like rose petals, so close we move as one. We dance. The violin becomes his voice, serenading me as I serenade him back.�

You can really tell that the author spent a lot of research on The Phantom of the Opera and is passionate about the subject herself. The story she weaves just fits, and the way she incorporates all the elements of the phantom into it is just perfect. There’s a surprising amount of supernatural stepping into the story, and I loved every aspect of it. It’s a mix of fiction and reality, myth and truth � a mix that also gives a satisfying conclusion that stayed with me even after reading the end.

The characters were all so three-dimensional, diverse, and real. Whether it’s the gifted yet cursed main character, her new eclectic circle of friends, or the mysterious “phantom� that haunts the school, everyone was written with such authentic voice. The antagonist is as empathetic as he is underhanded, and readers will definitely appreciate what Howard has done to his character. There’s never a boring moment in the story, yet the plot slowly unfurls like an exploration you never want to stop discovering.

Maybe a complaint people will have is the “insta-attraction� that goes on in the book. That is not necessarily true, as readers will find out that the attraction between the love interest and Rune stem way beyond their first physical meeting. It may be cheesy at times (although let’s be real, having the concept of soulmates is never easy to pull off without some cheese), but wholeheartedly passionate and romantic. Despite the lack of proximity of the couple during the majority of the book, their interactions still left me fanning myself and the burning chemistry is palpable. It’s a romance where the characters understand each other, help each other out, while still respecting each other to give the other space. It’s a romance that left my heart pounding in accented, staccato beats.

“All those night we climbed the stars and rearranged the planets with our songs, we were complete and invincible when we stood together.�

Music, magic, and a spellbinding romance makes Roseblood a scintillating read that I can’t wait to get ahold of in physical form. Howard writes an enchanting tale with gorgeous prose and such passion � from both author and characters � that readers will never get enough of. Fans of The Phantom of the Opera must grab a copy of this YA retelling (or is it really a retelling?). Words can’t describe how much I adore every aspect of this story, and the brilliant and heart-wrenching feelings it left me as I read the last page, and ever after closing the book. Roseblood is romantic, daring, and passionate � features that captivates an audience as much as a stellar singer does in her solo.

10/8/16:

Five reasons for the five star before writing my review:

1. Absolutely fucking STUNNING writing. I haven't read the author's previous books but I'm sold. The way she describes music was just... I have no words. Twice I had to stop reading to just FEEL the words touch my soul in how she expressed the characters' devotion to music. It was utterly enchanting and I couldn't tear my eyes off the screen.

2. Music. I'm drawn to books about music, being a musician myself (before reading this book I played some of Lloyd's Phantom of the Opera pieces on the piano because I was so excited). Like I said above, Howard's writing about music just captured my soul and almost made me tear with how accurate the descriptions were. This book was truly a wonderful tribute to not only the broadway play but also the opera - and music in general.

3. Research that just makes everything FIT. You can tell how much research the author did on the author of the Phantom of the Opera and the background behind it. The way she incorporated it into the story was pretty much perfect. It's a mix of fiction and reality, myth and truth. A mix that also gives a satisfying conclusion that stayed with me even after reading the end.

4. Three-dimensional characters that you can't help but love. Whether it's the gifted yet cursed main character, her new circle of friends, or the mysterious "phantom" that haunts the school, everyone was written with such voice. It's also a nice diverse cast, and an antagonist (not exactly villain) that has a role that readers are empathetic towards. There's never a boring moment in the story, yet the plot slowly unfurls like an exploration that you never want to stop discovering.

5. A burning romance riddled with chemistry. The weirdest thing is that despite the lack of proximity of the love interest and MC for the majority of the book, their scenes were still extremely super duper romantic. Maybe cheesy at times (yet, having the concept of soulmates is never easy to pull off), the romance just made my heart pound out of my chest in staccato bursts. It's a romance where the characters understand each other, help each other out, while still respecting each other to give the other space. Damn. It was a good one.

There is also a slight twist that goes onto the magical/supernatural side. I loved it. Music, magic, and a spellbinding romance makes for a delish read that I can't wait to hold in my hands when it comes out.

------
[sings] Wishing this book were somehow here again...



Me (phantom) @ this book
Profile Image for Jaime (Two Chicks on Books).
825 reviews395 followers
September 19, 2016
Such a beautiful, haunting, dark, but romantic story! I love what A.G. fid with the Phantom of The Opera story! It's not a retelling but taken from Phantom and built upon so that it's in the modern world with new characters and it's absolutely spellbinding and gorgeous! You will all fall for Rune and Thorn oh and Diable I adored that damned cat lol
Profile Image for Brittney Andrews (beabookworm).
148 reviews293 followers
July 24, 2018
I have FINALLY finished the Phantom of the Opera retelling and LET. ME. TELL. YAH:

description

Some Thoughts.
Unfortunately, this book a bit of a disappointment. It had so much potential to be a beautiful retelling of a well-known classic; however, the author just didn't give its young readers enough credit. Let me elaborate. I understand that this is marketed as a YA book, but when are authors going to learn that you can write a YA book that is sophisticated, with mature and complex characters etc. AND market it as YA. Books like this one are the reason why the YA genre has a bad stigma.

Look, young readers can handle a swear word, they can even handle a scene that mentions the "s" word, give them some credit. I felt like this book was contradicting though. On one hand, the characters' immaturity was unbearable, and on the other, the author included demon sex in her "YA" novel, without actually using the "s" word... sooo I am not really sure who the heck this book was supposed to be marketed towards because the two just don't coincide with each other.

I will give the author some credit for doing a lot of research, including some cool quotes at the start of every chapter, and attempting to retell such a famed story.

Tropes & Cliches.
Alright, it's no secret that I enjoy them, but even for me, this book was just too much. I think authors need to carefully select which ones they want to include with consideration. How many is too many? Which ones really "enhance" the story, and which ones take away from it? (To be honest, it should be illegal to have more than three in a stand-alone.)

The Pacing.
SoOOoOOo the first 50 pages take place in a limo, and luckily for the author: I am a dedicated bookworm that kept pushing through those 50 long-ass pages. But too anyone else who isn't an avid reader, you would have lost them within the first 15. Either give your readers an incentive to keep reading or at least stimulate our brain a little because the first 50 pages was comparable to watching someone that can't open those stupid plastic produce bags at the grocery store.

The Writing.
IT WAS A LYRICAL MESS. Honestly, if you aren't able to transition POVs with ease randomly throughout a chapter, then you should introduce a new POV at a chapter break. Some have praised the writing style in this book, but I found myself developing a headache from it. The chapters flowed together about as nicely as Campbell's® Chunky® Chicken Noodle Soup.

The Characters.
I don't always expect in-depth characters for a stand-alone. Most of the time the author just scratches the surface of them--however, the only character that really peaked my interest was Thorn. The rest were generic meat bodies.

The Deal Breaker.
As a reader, I am only willing to suspend my disbelief so far. You can't just make the Phantom an owner of a club that hosts rave parties, throw in some physic vampires to the mix and call it a day. It was too far-fetched. Had the author made this book into a duology, given the readers more information, then maybe, JUST MAYBE I would have been okay with the aforementioned. But she didn't, and alas, I mentally checked out after learning the Phantom owned a goddamn club.

Final Verdict.
Would I recommend this book?

description
Profile Image for Vivianne.
489 reviews70 followers
November 15, 2019
It hurts my heart to do this :(
DNFed at about 50%

I was soooo excited about this book! I’ve grown up loving the music of this opera and have seen the movie several times (still wishing the play would be reproduced so I can see it with my own eyes). So I was super curious when I read the premises, but also a little worried. How is one off my favorite childhood stories translated in a book? This book came in my February Booklybird box.

But unfortunately I just couldn’t finish this. The writing style was too detailed and things just took forever, the pacing was off, things got revealed in the wrong order and the plot was strange, I just hated the supernatural that was mixed with it. I couldn’t fight through it right now but I think that I will pick it up in a few months and try again!


I absolutely love the cover (and that’s about the only thing I like about this book), it’s gorgeous! I love the reference to the original story and to this one. The girl looks exactly like I pictured Rune. It’s so mysterious and beautiful. And also the first few pages have gorgeous designs. I love the thorns on every chapter and I really liked that the fond was in red (Howard’s books all have another color text). It’s so original and it fits this book perfectly!

The beginning was a little.. overwhelming. I felt like Howard was trying to tell Runes whole childhood in 10 pages AND tried to tell what they did that morning AND also where they were going and why. The story kept switching to different time periods and memories and I just wanted to know what this school was. My other problem was that it was soooo slow and dragging. It took forever for Rune to arrive at the school and for the story to become interesting. What I did really like was that this book had me already tearing up on page 20.

The story took quite a while to become interesting. The beginning is quite ordinary and I kept mixing up story’s like the series ‘Fallen� with this one. It was really like any other YA story; one mysterious guy, one or two rivals, one best friend, mix that with a spooky surrounding and Rune being the chosen one everyone has been looking for, for years and having a talent like no other. AND TADAA an ordinary YA story.. Sigh, I’m so bored and I wanted so much more from a Phantom of the Opera retelling!
I didn’t like that the whole plot was about bullying Rune and letting her believe she was crazy. That had nothing to do with The Phantom of the Opera and it actually was done really poor and boring. I felt sorry for Rune, and I actually really liked her, and I hated to read about what Thorne was going to do to her next. I found Rune easy to connect with from the beginning (maybe because all her childhood memory’s got forced on me). I didn’t really know what to think about her ‘tԳ� though.. I just felt bad for her most of the time because I felt that it was forced on her and she couldn’t help herself. I didn’t find the aspects about aura’s and the supernatural things fitting in this concept. The Phantom of the Opera is dark and spooky but everything about that story is still realistic and could have happened and for me that was the power of that story! So I was a bit surprised to find supernatural beings in this book. I didn’t find it suiting in this concept and wasn’t expecting fantasy aspects in this book. This supernatural stuff was stayed super vague and weird. I don’t like that and I kept thinking JUST TELL ME ALREADY!! AHHH But man that was weird these creatures that sucked live out of people. And voices that make you confess your darkest sins. It was all just a bit weird and incoherent. When the cat picked locks Howard completely lost me. With his nails??? What?? HOW??

I wasn’t a fan off the literal reference to the phantom of the opera. And I mean that Rune read about the academy in a book about the Phantom of the Opera. I would have rather just have the phantom twist be a surprise for the reader and Rune and then pick up clues as the story line continued. Now it was just so predictable and literally. For her to find the mirrors scary and the guy with the cape. I didn’t like that Erik, the actual phantom played a part in this story. And I hated how my original memory of him got destroyed. It was more like a sequel and a follow up on the Phantom of the Opera then an retelling.

Howard is a very descriptive writer. And that could be wonderful (and I understand if some people really enjoyed reading this), but I would rather have things left to my imagination than page after page full off descriptions. There is a chapter in this book where like five teachers walk in and there are literally four pages written about how they look and what Rune’s impression off them is. I’m not going to remember who is who if you bomb me with that many information! It started to get annoying after a while because I think without those this book wouldn’t even been 300 pages, (and I would have much rather had that because this made it so slow and unpleasant to read). But where the descriptions where really handy was with the music and when Rune got taken over. It was so vivid and alive, I felt like I could hear every note and every word though there never was one note written down in this book. My compliments to Howard for this. However the downside was that I couldn’t always follow what was happening, a lot of times it was super unclear. I get that Rune also don’t get what’s happening, but I’m a reader so I need to know! I also was really annoyed with the word; ‘feeling�. Rune always had this “feeling�. What do you mean? Is this good or bad, what are you feeling????

I was just really switching between liking it and not. There where chapters that where just so good, vivid and emotional, that I couldn’t stop reading. They mostly where memories or flashbacks. One of them was the story about how Thorne ended up with Erik. That story just broke my heart! This was so emotionally and tear-jerking. And that’s mainly why I didn’t rate this book 1 star. So I don’t get that if Howard can write a flashback like THAT, that the writing style of the whole other book needed to be soo� terrible.

Thorne was also awful and super flat.
I didn’t know much about him besides that he liked to bully Rune, did everything Erik said and had a terrible youth. Maybe later in the book his personality shows a bit more, I really hope if I’m going to give this another shot because it was really something I missed. The first 180 pages he just creeps around and bully’s Rune. That made me REALLY dislike him, his chapters are sooooo slow and boring. In the Phantom of the Opera, the phantom is creepy but he is also mysterious and enigmatic. That was a thing that I really missed with Throne, he was just this stalker that I knew nothing about, and that really made me dislike him. And after reading 200 pages of a book I need to know what someone’s deal is, especially when there are so many useless pages about him.

So I felt like a book where I disliked one of the main characters, I found the writing style awful and the plot terrible, wasn’t worth it to keep reading. I just couldn’t handle one more page!
Profile Image for Lexie.
227 reviews196 followers
Want to read
March 11, 2016
Oh, no big deal, and now A.G. Howard is writing one!

RIGHT IN THE FEELS

Profile Image for Sophie.
1,327 reviews551 followers
February 10, 2017
I received an Advance Reader Copy from the publisher. This in no way impacted on my view.

Unfortunately, this review is not going to be positive. I first read Howard's Splintered a few years ago, and wasn't a fan, but was hoping Roseblood would be better - it wasn't. Basically, I found the story long and boring, and, tbh, should've DNFed it and not wasted any more of my time.

Roseblood is a retelling of The Phantom of the Opera, one of my favourite musicals, with a twist. It's somewhat of a sequel, with the original phantom still playing a large part, but the main characters are Rune and Thorn. Rune arrives at Roseblood school, hoping she would manage to get over her affliction when it comes to operatic music, when, really, there's an ulterior motive for her being there. The Phantom has drawn her to the school, because he believes her to be a reincarnation of Christine, and he wants her. Thorn, the adopted son of the Phantom, has a central role to play in this, but he falls in love with Rune, for himself.

I'm sorry, but I can't really say anything positive for this book. The writing was confusing at times, and unnecessary at others. So much was drawn out, as if it would make it more dramatic, but it only made it tedious. You could see all the twists and turns a mile off. Nothing was exciting, and it would have saved me a lot of grief if I dropped the book when I had the chance.

The romance was cringy, and I didn't see the attraction between them. It was more forced than natural, and sometimes creepy. Rune was an awful MC, and I sometimes found myself wishing that the Phantom succeeded in his wish.

All in all, there was nothing I liked about this book, and I couldn't recommend this at all, without feeling bad. I don't think I'll read anymore of Howard's books in the future.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,105 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.