What do you think?
Rate this book
The Queen of Sugar Hill: A Novel of Hattie McDaniel
Bestselling author ReShonda Tate presents a fascinating fictional portrait of Hattie McDaniel, one of Hollywood’s most prolific but woefully underappreciated stars—and the first Black person ever to win an Oscar for her role as Mammy in the critically acclaimed film classic Gone With the Wind.
It was supposed to be the highlight of her career, the pinnacle for which she’d worked all her life. And as Hattie McDaniel took the stage in 1940 to claim an honor that would make her the first African-American woman to win an Academy Award, she tearfully took her place in history. Between personal triumphs and tragedies, heartbreaking losses, and severe setbacks, this historic night of winning best supporting actress for her role as the sassy Mammy in the controversial movie Gone With the Wind was going to be life-changing.
Or so she thought.
Months after winning the award, not only did the Oscar curse set in where Hattie couldn’t find work, but she found herself thrust in the middle of two worlds—Black and White—and not being welcomed in either. Whites only saw her as Mammy and Blacks detested the demeaning portrayal.
As the NAACP waged an all-out war against Hattie and actors like her, the emotionally conflicted actor found herself struggling daily. Through it all, Hattie continued her fight to pave a path for other Negro actors, while focusing on war efforts, fighting housing discrimination, and navigating four failed marriages. Luckily, she had a core group of friends to help her out—from Clark Gable to Louise Beavers to Ruby Berkley Goodwin and Dorothy Dandridge.
The Queen of Sugar Hill brings to life the powerful story of one woman who was driven by many passions—ambition, love, sex, family, friendship, and equality. In re-creating Hattie’s story, ReShonda Tate delivers an unforgettable novel of resilience, dedication, and determination—about what it takes to achieve your dreams—even when everything—and everyone—is against you.
It was supposed to be the highlight of her career, the pinnacle for which she’d worked all her life. And as Hattie McDaniel took the stage in 1940 to claim an honor that would make her the first African-American woman to win an Academy Award, she tearfully took her place in history. Between personal triumphs and tragedies, heartbreaking losses, and severe setbacks, this historic night of winning best supporting actress for her role as the sassy Mammy in the controversial movie Gone With the Wind was going to be life-changing.
Or so she thought.
Months after winning the award, not only did the Oscar curse set in where Hattie couldn’t find work, but she found herself thrust in the middle of two worlds—Black and White—and not being welcomed in either. Whites only saw her as Mammy and Blacks detested the demeaning portrayal.
As the NAACP waged an all-out war against Hattie and actors like her, the emotionally conflicted actor found herself struggling daily. Through it all, Hattie continued her fight to pave a path for other Negro actors, while focusing on war efforts, fighting housing discrimination, and navigating four failed marriages. Luckily, she had a core group of friends to help her out—from Clark Gable to Louise Beavers to Ruby Berkley Goodwin and Dorothy Dandridge.
The Queen of Sugar Hill brings to life the powerful story of one woman who was driven by many passions—ambition, love, sex, family, friendship, and equality. In re-creating Hattie’s story, ReShonda Tate delivers an unforgettable novel of resilience, dedication, and determination—about what it takes to achieve your dreams—even when everything—and everyone—is against you.
432 pages, Paperback
First published January 30, 2024
6,188 people are currently reading
17.9k people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 737 reviews
February 21, 2024
4 solid stars. Historical fiction based on the life of McDaniel, the first person of color to get an Oscar (for Gone with the Wind) and her struggles with all that systemic racism & the patriarchy threw at her. She also had to fight against “Old Hollywood� and the studio system, colorism, several bad husbands and she also successfully fought LA’s infamous “red-lining� segregation to keep her & her neighbors in their Sugar Hill/West Adams homes. Her drive & perseverance really stand out and this one’s a real eye-opener, even if you think you know her story.
April 1, 2024
Historical fiction of a black American tragedy. Academy award, 1940. Lifelong victim of racism and being female. Strong willed fighter against a deck stacked against her.
March 18, 2024
The Queen of Sugar Hill: A Novel of Hattie McDaniel by ReShonda Tate.
Hattie McDaniel as the first black person to win an Oscar for her role as “Mammy� in Gone With The Wind. Hattie’s life and career should have soared after her Oscar win. The racism and societal prejudices stemming from the studio and the white audiences wanted her to continue be portrayed as “Mammy�. But the black community hate what it represented and often accused her of being racist herself. Hattie often felt like she was pulled back and forth, never able to make anyone happy. I really enjoyed this book. It was so depressing. One heart wrenching crisis after another. I fell in love with Hattie. She genuinely seemed to be a loving, hard working and caring woman. She attracted men that wanted to use her.
Hattie McDaniel as the first black person to win an Oscar for her role as “Mammy� in Gone With The Wind. Hattie’s life and career should have soared after her Oscar win. The racism and societal prejudices stemming from the studio and the white audiences wanted her to continue be portrayed as “Mammy�. But the black community hate what it represented and often accused her of being racist herself. Hattie often felt like she was pulled back and forth, never able to make anyone happy. I really enjoyed this book. It was so depressing. One heart wrenching crisis after another. I fell in love with Hattie. She genuinely seemed to be a loving, hard working and caring woman. She attracted men that wanted to use her.
March 20, 2024
4.5 Stars!
Hattie McDaniel was an African American actress in classic Hollywood. Her most famous role was as Mammy in Gone with the Wind. She was the first African American to win an Academy Award in 1940. She was a controversial person in her lifetime and she continues to be controversial over 70 years after her death. Hattie played slaves and housekeepers. Her characters were stereotypical portrayals of Black people. Within the Black community there were those who celebrated her but she also received lots of criticism especially from the NAACP. The NAACP would be the bane of Hattie's existence until the day she died.
The Queen of Sugar Hill is a fictionalized account of Hattie's post Oscar win life. I didn't know much about Hattie McDaniel and according to the author of this book most of the info on the internet is false. I like most Black people also have a complicated relationship with Hattie and actors like her. Mammy is the best character in Gone with the Wind but she's also a stereotype of the happy smiling slave who loves her masters. Mammy like all of these characters were written by white people who often had very little personal contact with Black people. The characters Hattie played weren't written to be people they were cartoon characters but Hattie made them real. I can now as an adult who has experienced things, see Hattie McDaniel's work for the greatness that it was. While reading this book it was clear that white racism was the least of her problems. Her biggest enemy was as I said before the NAACP. They blamed her for setting Black people back. For the reasons that Black people hadn't gotten more advances. She was called an Uncle Tom and accused of Coonin'. But she was doing more to uplift Black actors than the NAACP could have ever done.
This book is over 400 pages but it doesn't feel that long. I now want to read a real biography about her. Hattie McDaniel should be celebrated for doing something that Black people have had to do for centuries...she took chicken shit and made a delicious chicken salad. She took stereotypical roles and gave them humanity. She was a sweet and kind woman who had many friends both Black and white. And who like all these classic Hollywood actresses had terrible taste in men.
I can't recommend this book enough.
A Must Read!
Hattie McDaniel was an African American actress in classic Hollywood. Her most famous role was as Mammy in Gone with the Wind. She was the first African American to win an Academy Award in 1940. She was a controversial person in her lifetime and she continues to be controversial over 70 years after her death. Hattie played slaves and housekeepers. Her characters were stereotypical portrayals of Black people. Within the Black community there were those who celebrated her but she also received lots of criticism especially from the NAACP. The NAACP would be the bane of Hattie's existence until the day she died.
The Queen of Sugar Hill is a fictionalized account of Hattie's post Oscar win life. I didn't know much about Hattie McDaniel and according to the author of this book most of the info on the internet is false. I like most Black people also have a complicated relationship with Hattie and actors like her. Mammy is the best character in Gone with the Wind but she's also a stereotype of the happy smiling slave who loves her masters. Mammy like all of these characters were written by white people who often had very little personal contact with Black people. The characters Hattie played weren't written to be people they were cartoon characters but Hattie made them real. I can now as an adult who has experienced things, see Hattie McDaniel's work for the greatness that it was. While reading this book it was clear that white racism was the least of her problems. Her biggest enemy was as I said before the NAACP. They blamed her for setting Black people back. For the reasons that Black people hadn't gotten more advances. She was called an Uncle Tom and accused of Coonin'. But she was doing more to uplift Black actors than the NAACP could have ever done.
This book is over 400 pages but it doesn't feel that long. I now want to read a real biography about her. Hattie McDaniel should be celebrated for doing something that Black people have had to do for centuries...she took chicken shit and made a delicious chicken salad. She took stereotypical roles and gave them humanity. She was a sweet and kind woman who had many friends both Black and white. And who like all these classic Hollywood actresses had terrible taste in men.
I can't recommend this book enough.
A Must Read!
May 20, 2024
Hattie McDaniel was the first black female to win an Oscar for her role in "Gone with the Wind" in the early 1940's. Her studio contract afforded the income to purchase a home in the Sugar Hill district of Los Angeles, hence the title.
In spite of her achievement, being 'colored' remained a major factor due to rampant racism across the nation. While close with Clark Gable and other celebrities, she battled with Walter White, president of the NACCP, media, Sugar Hill neighbors, husbands, friends and others. When added to her string of unsuccessful marriages, her life was anything but pretty.
In terms of reader engagement, I felt the dialog was amateurish and overused and was tempted to quit in the early stages. Having loved the depth and skill used with this book pales in comparison.
That said, if the premise is of interest, add it to your list, though I wouldn't recommend it otherwise
In spite of her achievement, being 'colored' remained a major factor due to rampant racism across the nation. While close with Clark Gable and other celebrities, she battled with Walter White, president of the NACCP, media, Sugar Hill neighbors, husbands, friends and others. When added to her string of unsuccessful marriages, her life was anything but pretty.
In terms of reader engagement, I felt the dialog was amateurish and overused and was tempted to quit in the early stages. Having loved the depth and skill used with this book pales in comparison.
That said, if the premise is of interest, add it to your list, though I wouldn't recommend it otherwise
November 2, 2023
I received a copy of "The Queen of Sugar Hill" by ReShonda Tate from NetGalley. The author writes this book as fiction but based on the life of Hattie McDaniel. The book is seen through Hattie McDaniel's narrative. Although this book is fiction it includes some real life things that were in the Oscar Winning actresses life.
The book starts in 1940. It is the night of the Oscars and Hattie McDaniel is nominated for best supporting actress for her role as "Mammy" in Gone With the Wind. she becomes the first African American woman to win an Oscar.
This book starts from that night and ends at her death in 1952. The author gives Hattie McDaniel a voice of what she could be thinking over these 12 years. She has faced many obstacles. White people see her as "mammy" and expects her to continue in the same kind of roles. She also is pressured and judged by fellow black people who hate the "mammy" and maid type roles she is force to perform. She is also unlucky in love. Over her life she is married four times. The first marriage ends when the love of her life dies. Her other husbands in her life only use her and treat her badly. she also is treated badly when she is the first black person to move into the all white "Sugar hill" neighborhood and she is pressured to move. I think the author has written a pretty good book on what it must have been like for the talented actress. She did a lot of research on the actress. I enjoyed reading the book but also found myself feeling outraged for the obstacles that Hattie Mcdaniel faced in her life. I would give this book a 4.5.
The book starts in 1940. It is the night of the Oscars and Hattie McDaniel is nominated for best supporting actress for her role as "Mammy" in Gone With the Wind. she becomes the first African American woman to win an Oscar.
This book starts from that night and ends at her death in 1952. The author gives Hattie McDaniel a voice of what she could be thinking over these 12 years. She has faced many obstacles. White people see her as "mammy" and expects her to continue in the same kind of roles. She also is pressured and judged by fellow black people who hate the "mammy" and maid type roles she is force to perform. She is also unlucky in love. Over her life she is married four times. The first marriage ends when the love of her life dies. Her other husbands in her life only use her and treat her badly. she also is treated badly when she is the first black person to move into the all white "Sugar hill" neighborhood and she is pressured to move. I think the author has written a pretty good book on what it must have been like for the talented actress. She did a lot of research on the actress. I enjoyed reading the book but also found myself feeling outraged for the obstacles that Hattie Mcdaniel faced in her life. I would give this book a 4.5.
January 2, 2024
I’ve been a fan of Hattie McDaniel since I saw her in “The Little Colonel� , on late-night t.v as a kid. I didn’t know about racism and stereotypes; I just thought she was sweet to Lloyd and funny with Bill Robinson’s character.
So, when I saw this book on Netgalley, I was interested, and hoped it would contain information about Hattie’s work with 20th Century Fox, as well as details about her work in “Gone With the Wind.�
It was a bit disappointing. The novel began with Hattie receiving her Oscar for her “Mammy� role, and continued with details about difficult it was for her to get parts other than domestic help in movies, and how her friendship with Clark Gable really helped her through discouraging times.How Hattie became “The Queen of Sugar Hill� and lived her life until 1952 was the main premise of this book. It was interesting, just not what I was hoping for.
So, when I saw this book on Netgalley, I was interested, and hoped it would contain information about Hattie’s work with 20th Century Fox, as well as details about her work in “Gone With the Wind.�
It was a bit disappointing. The novel began with Hattie receiving her Oscar for her “Mammy� role, and continued with details about difficult it was for her to get parts other than domestic help in movies, and how her friendship with Clark Gable really helped her through discouraging times.How Hattie became “The Queen of Sugar Hill� and lived her life until 1952 was the main premise of this book. It was interesting, just not what I was hoping for.
February 12, 2024
fascinating main character and premise but it read like someone embellishing the main character’s wikipedia page; slow, repetitive and too long
March 23, 2024
"I would rather play a maid and make 700.00, than be a maid, and make 7.00"
March Bookclub Selection
I fell in love with Hattie McDaniels after reading the book and watching the movie Gone with the Wind.
I understood she was giving the best performance she could with the best role she was given, and I was here for it.
The first black woman to win an Oscar, what an honor.
I did not know much about her personal life, but after reading this book, I love her even more. Her perservance throughout racism, bad marriages, financial issues, poor health, etc. She kept her head up and fought with grace until she died.
This book gave insight on so many black and white actors/ actresses that were involved in Hatties' life. Some good and some not so good.
Thank you, Reshonda Tate, for giving life to Hattie McDaniels' story.
Rest in peace, Mammie!!
Highly Recommend to all my historical fiction readers!!
March Bookclub Selection
I fell in love with Hattie McDaniels after reading the book and watching the movie Gone with the Wind.
I understood she was giving the best performance she could with the best role she was given, and I was here for it.
The first black woman to win an Oscar, what an honor.
I did not know much about her personal life, but after reading this book, I love her even more. Her perservance throughout racism, bad marriages, financial issues, poor health, etc. She kept her head up and fought with grace until she died.
This book gave insight on so many black and white actors/ actresses that were involved in Hatties' life. Some good and some not so good.
Thank you, Reshonda Tate, for giving life to Hattie McDaniels' story.
Rest in peace, Mammie!!
Highly Recommend to all my historical fiction readers!!
December 2, 2023
I received an advanced copy from Harper Collins in exchange for my review.
This is an historical fiction based on Hattie McDaniels life. Hattie was the first black female to win an Academy Award for her role in Gone With the Wind.
While the book is beautifully written and extremely hard to put down it still incorporates many important topics, many still seen today. Race, gender roles, the construct of marriage, racism, death and friendship are all themes throughout.
We see Hattie struggle in her marriages, often speculated to result from her success. We see her discover her true friends, we stay with Hattie as she moves into Sugar Hill, a predominantly white neighborhood.
The only thing that was hard for me was one of the main characters was Walter White and his full name was always used. This was difficult for me to not associate with Breaking Bad.
I'd say this is one of the best books I've read this year! Great for bookclub.
This is an historical fiction based on Hattie McDaniels life. Hattie was the first black female to win an Academy Award for her role in Gone With the Wind.
While the book is beautifully written and extremely hard to put down it still incorporates many important topics, many still seen today. Race, gender roles, the construct of marriage, racism, death and friendship are all themes throughout.
We see Hattie struggle in her marriages, often speculated to result from her success. We see her discover her true friends, we stay with Hattie as she moves into Sugar Hill, a predominantly white neighborhood.
The only thing that was hard for me was one of the main characters was Walter White and his full name was always used. This was difficult for me to not associate with Breaking Bad.
I'd say this is one of the best books I've read this year! Great for bookclub.
November 28, 2023
I am a "First Reads" winner. Thank you to the author and publisher.
"We reminded them of their mothers and grandmothers. We reminded them of the parts of their lives they'd rather forget. They were ashamed of us. So we were regulated to our stories only being inside the magazine - if we were covered at all" (307).
What a great read!
I thoroughly enjoyed 'The Queen of Sugar Hill.' I found Tate's writing and storytelling absolutely engaging and very immersive. Tate's narrative style and ability to evoke emotional responses - the good, the shocking, the how-could-this-have-happened - were rendered with every page.
Thank you - and great work! 'The Queen of Sugar Hill' - a recommended read.
"We reminded them of their mothers and grandmothers. We reminded them of the parts of their lives they'd rather forget. They were ashamed of us. So we were regulated to our stories only being inside the magazine - if we were covered at all" (307).
What a great read!
I thoroughly enjoyed 'The Queen of Sugar Hill.' I found Tate's writing and storytelling absolutely engaging and very immersive. Tate's narrative style and ability to evoke emotional responses - the good, the shocking, the how-could-this-have-happened - were rendered with every page.
Thank you - and great work! 'The Queen of Sugar Hill' - a recommended read.
January 26, 2024
"The Queen of Sugar Hill" by ReShonda Tate is a mesmerizing journey through the remarkable life of Hattie McDaniel, a name familiar to many but often not fully understood. At the heart of the narrative is Hattie McDaniel's groundbreaking achievement as the first African-American woman to win an Academy Award. Known for her iconic role as Mammy in "Gone with the Wind," McDaniel's victory marked a pivotal moment in the history of cinema. Yet, Tate moves beyond that moment to unveil the layers of Hattie McDaniel's life, painting a vivid portrait of her struggles, triumphs, and the indelible mark she left on the entertainment industry. Readers also come away with a deeper understanding of the challenges Ms. McDaniel faced in a racially segregated Hollywood and even backlash from groups like the NAACP.
What sets "The Queen of Sugar Hill" apart is its ability to transform Ms. McDaniel from a recognizable name into a three-dimensional, inspiring figure. As readers delve into the pages of this novel, they witness the strength, resilience, and unwavering determination that fueled her ascent to the pinnacle of success.
I also enjoyed learning about the socio-cultural landscape of Sugar Hill in Los Angeles which provided a backdrop that enhances the narrative. As a reader who appreciates delving into the lives of extraordinary women through historical fiction, "The Queen of Sugar Hill" has rightfully earned its place on my #31titleswomeninhistory list. This book serves not only as a celebration of Hattie McDaniel's accomplishments but also as a testament to the resilience of women who defy societal norms to pave the way for future generations.
What sets "The Queen of Sugar Hill" apart is its ability to transform Ms. McDaniel from a recognizable name into a three-dimensional, inspiring figure. As readers delve into the pages of this novel, they witness the strength, resilience, and unwavering determination that fueled her ascent to the pinnacle of success.
I also enjoyed learning about the socio-cultural landscape of Sugar Hill in Los Angeles which provided a backdrop that enhances the narrative. As a reader who appreciates delving into the lives of extraordinary women through historical fiction, "The Queen of Sugar Hill" has rightfully earned its place on my #31titleswomeninhistory list. This book serves not only as a celebration of Hattie McDaniel's accomplishments but also as a testament to the resilience of women who defy societal norms to pave the way for future generations.
February 13, 2025
wish i had just read her biography instead 😵�
November 2, 2023
I’m a ReShonda Tate (Billingsley) fan, so I’m most always going to give anything she writes a chance. When I read the synopsis I was even more interested in the story because—oddly enough—Gone with the Wind is one of my favorite movies. I have to admit that when I began the story I was a little bit disappointed, as I thought the story would begin with her youth, but it started very much into her adult life. Despite the initial disappointment, I decided to keep reading and I’m very glad that I did. This was such a great weaving of fact and fiction. Many times I found myself reaching for my phone so that I could look up different people, places or experiences. It made the book come alive for me and I really enjoyed that aspect. The writing style was very engaging and easy to follow—a hallmark of this author’s work. All in all, a really good and informative read.
February 23, 2024
Author Reshonda Tate, along with narrator Lynnette R. Freeman made me fall in love with Hattie McDaniel! This was such a good book and I’m in awe of the amount of research that must have been done.
. if you are a fan of classic cinema, you will love this one. So many many things I didn’t know. For example, did you know Hattie McDaniels and Clark Gable were great friends and he was always ready to � go to war � for her! Who knew???
There is also so much about black actresses and actors, the roles they were offered,
the decisions they had to make, and the ultimate pushback they received. Truly fascinating!
. if you are a fan of classic cinema, you will love this one. So many many things I didn’t know. For example, did you know Hattie McDaniels and Clark Gable were great friends and he was always ready to � go to war � for her! Who knew???
There is also so much about black actresses and actors, the roles they were offered,
the decisions they had to make, and the ultimate pushback they received. Truly fascinating!
August 5, 2024
Carole Lombard was killed in a plane crash on January 16, 1942. Ms. Tate states that Clark Gable enlisted in the U.S. Army Air Corps as a tail gunner. First of all no one enlists by declaring what job he will perform in battle. He was never a tail gunner. In the time between the attack on Pearl Harbor and her death, Carole Lombard had sent a telegram to President Franklin Roosevelt on Gable’s behalf. The President responded that her husband could best serve the country by making promotional films and selling war bonds. After Lombard’s death, however, a distraught Gable enlisted in the US Army Air Forces. Gable was eager to do more in the service than other actors. Despite being 41 years old at the time, he expressed an interest in attending officer candidate school. Upon completing his training there, he worked to become an aerial gunner, enlisting in bomber training school. In January 1943, the actor took off for England to train and accompany the 351st Bomb group. Gable’s six-man unit was made up of people involved in the film industry. As its leader, he was promoted to the rank of captain. He spent most of the year in England at Royal Air Force Station (RAF) Polebrook. He also flew five combat missions, including one as an observer-gunner in a B-17 Flying Fortress. Clark Gable received instructions to make a film about aerial gunners flying in the war. While he didn’t necessarily need to do so, he flew operational missions to get footage for the movie, titled Combat America. After news of the flights reached MGM Studios, its executives began to badger the US Army about removing Gable from combat missions, meaning his days in the skies were over. He was filmed as a side gunner on the planes. On this same date in January of 1942 the author states that the Tuskegee Airmen were doing a great job flying in the European war. The first mission of this fighter pilot group took place on June 2, 1943 in action over Italy. I want to stress that I am in no way disparaging the record of this African American fighter pilot unit which had one of the best records for protecting bombers on their missions. ** My point is that I found the facts of the author's "untruths" in 10 minutes. If you are writing "historical" fiction it should be accurate. Finding these gross errors destroys the credibility of the author on other "facts". Now I have finished the book..... Authors of historical fiction sometimes make small changes to help the narrative, but at the end of the audiobook Ms. Tate went on and on about all the things she changed. 1 1/2 stars perhaps. I wanted to like the book as I have been a fan of Hattie McDaniel for many years. The book begins when she accepts her Oscar and there are a few references to her childhood, but I would have liked to know more about her early life. She was a strong Black woman yet she was vulnerable to worthless men. Her background may have helped to explain this contradiction. I got tired of the bickering with the head of the NAACP and studio people. Should have been edited. Might have been a fascinating book, but instead it missed the mark. Kristi & Abby Tabby
February 27, 2025
The Queen of Sugar Hill by Reshonda Tate
I’m not a big historical fiction girly but this story was so captivating and interesting. I loved learning Hattie’s story being the first black person to win an Oscar. I loved learning about her, its heartbreaking to see what she had go to through being the only black women in the room but it was also empowering. She shows so much strength and perseverance. Follow your dreams no matter what. PERIOD. This book should be a school reading in theatre class. This book was a great read.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
I’m not a big historical fiction girly but this story was so captivating and interesting. I loved learning Hattie’s story being the first black person to win an Oscar. I loved learning about her, its heartbreaking to see what she had go to through being the only black women in the room but it was also empowering. She shows so much strength and perseverance. Follow your dreams no matter what. PERIOD. This book should be a school reading in theatre class. This book was a great read.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Want to read
March 23, 2025If you have a Libby Account, definitely check and see if they are participating in a National Book Discussion and Allowing this Book and also Audiobook with No Wait and Anyone can get it Right Away.
March 27, 2024
“Anyone that knew Hattie McDaniel (Mammy from Gone With The Wind) knew there wasn’t a box on the planet to confine me. I’d let the world, both coloreds and whites occasionally rob me of the joy I felt in life. No one was going to rob me of my joy on the brink of death.�
This book y’all. THIS BOOK!!
Hattie McDaniel was “fiercely private and yet an open book. Historical fiction takes the facts and merges them with the authors own creativity done with precision and care of the one the story is about.�
The research this author did was insane. Clark Gable and Hattie’s friend ship was chefs kiss. The speculation about Clark being “colored� I’d actually heard before and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised. This has been going on since the beginning of time. The contribution Hattie made for Black people in film, Black women especially was astounding. She was the first AA woman to win an Academy Award in 1940. What a remarkable woman she was! She desperately tried to show HW that Black people could portray more than just slaves and servants, but unfortunately at that time that was all there was. I love what she said about how she’d “rather play a servant or maid and earn $700 then be a real one and earn $7.�
I love how Hattie hit colorism head on within the NAACP and how she loathed the organization until the day she died. They accused her of being an “Uncle Tom� when in all actuality they were only promoting the light skinned “white type� of Negro. Reading this book made me so proud and my heart so full of gratitude. The audiobook was perfectly narrated and I just want to applaud this author and thank her for sharing her great talent.
This book y’all. THIS BOOK!!
Hattie McDaniel was “fiercely private and yet an open book. Historical fiction takes the facts and merges them with the authors own creativity done with precision and care of the one the story is about.�
The research this author did was insane. Clark Gable and Hattie’s friend ship was chefs kiss. The speculation about Clark being “colored� I’d actually heard before and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised. This has been going on since the beginning of time. The contribution Hattie made for Black people in film, Black women especially was astounding. She was the first AA woman to win an Academy Award in 1940. What a remarkable woman she was! She desperately tried to show HW that Black people could portray more than just slaves and servants, but unfortunately at that time that was all there was. I love what she said about how she’d “rather play a servant or maid and earn $700 then be a real one and earn $7.�
I love how Hattie hit colorism head on within the NAACP and how she loathed the organization until the day she died. They accused her of being an “Uncle Tom� when in all actuality they were only promoting the light skinned “white type� of Negro. Reading this book made me so proud and my heart so full of gratitude. The audiobook was perfectly narrated and I just want to applaud this author and thank her for sharing her great talent.
March 31, 2024
Thank you Bibliolifestyle and William Morrow for my #gifted copy.
Knowing little about such an icon in the black community pulled me towards this story.
Although this is a fictional tale based on real-life events, it is a story of resilience in the face of racism, misogyny, colorism, fatphobia, and many more themes that tie into this black woman's real life. It is a story of the odds constantly being against someone, and they keep fighting through the depression, mistreatment, and barriers set at every turn.
There were so many things I hadn't known that happened in the 1940s and 1950s as far as the advancement of black actors, the black community in LA, and, of course, Ms. Hattie McDaniel's personal life. One event the author highlighted were the restricted covenants, which I came to learn were things set in place to bar black people from living in West Adams Heights (also known as Sugar Hill). Homes set in the area that were only permitted to be sold to white people. Hattie and the NAACP organized together and won the case against the covenants, which led to Ms. Hattie holding the moniker "The Queen of Sugar Hill" in the book.
This novel had me reflecting on how Hattie had to fight against people boxing her into one role, just because, at the time, it was so controversial for both sides. On one side of the coin, white people praised her for her role in Gone with the Wind, while on the other side, they blamed her for bringing down the black community as a whole. That’s a lot of weight for one person to carry, and Hattie didn’t want it at all!!
Through it all, Hattie still carried her head high. She didn’t let the Walter Whites of the world bring her down, nor did she let a man stay around her once she knew he was no good! How all these events translated to the page was very theatrical, informative, and at times funny. I would attribute this to the narrator Lynette R. Freeman and, of course, the pen of ReShonda Tate.
I would recommend this story with the additional recommendation that you look into the events and people mentioned because I believe it’s a novel that is a gateway to more history and vital information.
4.5/5⭐️
Knowing little about such an icon in the black community pulled me towards this story.
Although this is a fictional tale based on real-life events, it is a story of resilience in the face of racism, misogyny, colorism, fatphobia, and many more themes that tie into this black woman's real life. It is a story of the odds constantly being against someone, and they keep fighting through the depression, mistreatment, and barriers set at every turn.
There were so many things I hadn't known that happened in the 1940s and 1950s as far as the advancement of black actors, the black community in LA, and, of course, Ms. Hattie McDaniel's personal life. One event the author highlighted were the restricted covenants, which I came to learn were things set in place to bar black people from living in West Adams Heights (also known as Sugar Hill). Homes set in the area that were only permitted to be sold to white people. Hattie and the NAACP organized together and won the case against the covenants, which led to Ms. Hattie holding the moniker "The Queen of Sugar Hill" in the book.
This novel had me reflecting on how Hattie had to fight against people boxing her into one role, just because, at the time, it was so controversial for both sides. On one side of the coin, white people praised her for her role in Gone with the Wind, while on the other side, they blamed her for bringing down the black community as a whole. That’s a lot of weight for one person to carry, and Hattie didn’t want it at all!!
Through it all, Hattie still carried her head high. She didn’t let the Walter Whites of the world bring her down, nor did she let a man stay around her once she knew he was no good! How all these events translated to the page was very theatrical, informative, and at times funny. I would attribute this to the narrator Lynette R. Freeman and, of course, the pen of ReShonda Tate.
I would recommend this story with the additional recommendation that you look into the events and people mentioned because I believe it’s a novel that is a gateway to more history and vital information.
4.5/5⭐️
February 12, 2024
This Biographical - Historical Fiction is about Hattie McDaniel, the first African American to win an Academy. Once winning the Oscar, Hattie McDaniel thought that her acting career would take-off, but shortly she learned that the very award that heightened her notoriety was the same award that was the catalyst to a lot of struggle, pain, and trauma. Though being a recipient of this award was a major accomplishment, her elation was short lived. Ms. McDaniel quickly realized that winning the Oscar caused much unrest in Hollywood as it related to Black actors, caused strife in her community, and adversely collided with her relational life.
Ms. McDaniels talent and experience did not preclude her from the onslaught of hatred, racism, colorism and layers of abuse. She endured so much in her life, but like many Black women who've given their all to relationships, careers, to life, whether deciding to fight or acquiesce, Hattie McDaniel's life included never-ending struggle, pain and trauma. Through all of this, I still saw a woman of strength, courage and triumph!!!
This book was the epitome of a well written historical-biographical piece of fiction. The author, with fidelity thoroughly researched McDaniel's life which brought the characters to life. Many times I found myself clutching my pearls, yelling at characters, throwing the book across the room- because I was mad, and simply walked away from the pages for days.
After collecting myself, and experiencing raw emotions learning about the life of Ms. Hattie McDaniels, this book was so well written and is a MUST read. This book will likely be one of my top reads by the end of 2024!
Netgalley, William Morrow (Harpers Collins Publishing) and Ms. ReShonda Tate thank you so very much for providing me with this ARC, for my honest review. I love this book so much and am grateful to have read it and to provide my honest thoughts.
Great job Ms. ReShonda Tate - very well captured and written.
Ms. McDaniels talent and experience did not preclude her from the onslaught of hatred, racism, colorism and layers of abuse. She endured so much in her life, but like many Black women who've given their all to relationships, careers, to life, whether deciding to fight or acquiesce, Hattie McDaniel's life included never-ending struggle, pain and trauma. Through all of this, I still saw a woman of strength, courage and triumph!!!
This book was the epitome of a well written historical-biographical piece of fiction. The author, with fidelity thoroughly researched McDaniel's life which brought the characters to life. Many times I found myself clutching my pearls, yelling at characters, throwing the book across the room- because I was mad, and simply walked away from the pages for days.
After collecting myself, and experiencing raw emotions learning about the life of Ms. Hattie McDaniels, this book was so well written and is a MUST read. This book will likely be one of my top reads by the end of 2024!
Netgalley, William Morrow (Harpers Collins Publishing) and Ms. ReShonda Tate thank you so very much for providing me with this ARC, for my honest review. I love this book so much and am grateful to have read it and to provide my honest thoughts.
Great job Ms. ReShonda Tate - very well captured and written.
April 3, 2024
I read QOSH with some book friends last month and it was pretty eye opening. The book details the life of Hattie McDaniel, a Black actress and the first Black actress to win an Oscar Award back for her role in Gone With The Wind.
Honestly, I hadn’t heard much about Hattie before reading the book, but her story and legacy were quite interesting. What I found alarming is that the very struggles she faced as a Black actress back in the 𝟏𝟗𝟑𝟎𝐬-𝟏𝟗𝟓𝟎𝐬 are 𝐒𝐓𝐈𝐋𝐋 being fought in present day Hollyweird(i.e. Angela Bassett, Taraji Henson, +++). It is an absolute disgrace!
She had so many obstacles in her path, making the road bumpy, and destined for failure, but she persevered and reached many goals. I love learning about courageous women like Hattie who overcome all of the odds.
Some things that mystified me was Hattie’s inability to find work AFTER winning an Oscar, the pressure that she faced trying to balance being “safe� for popular audiences, while facing backlash from her own community for the “mammy� roles she took on. She took the jobs she could get, even though the stereotypical roles often made her feel like a mockery. I cannot even imagine the immense pressure this woman faced trying to be everything to everyone, while still dealing with romantic woes.
Reshonda is one of my favorite authors and this book is very different from her traditional works. I am glad that she stepped outside her box and tried something new, giving life and awareness to Hattie’s life, success and legacy.
Honestly, I hadn’t heard much about Hattie before reading the book, but her story and legacy were quite interesting. What I found alarming is that the very struggles she faced as a Black actress back in the 𝟏𝟗𝟑𝟎𝐬-𝟏𝟗𝟓𝟎𝐬 are 𝐒𝐓𝐈𝐋𝐋 being fought in present day Hollyweird(i.e. Angela Bassett, Taraji Henson, +++). It is an absolute disgrace!
She had so many obstacles in her path, making the road bumpy, and destined for failure, but she persevered and reached many goals. I love learning about courageous women like Hattie who overcome all of the odds.
Some things that mystified me was Hattie’s inability to find work AFTER winning an Oscar, the pressure that she faced trying to balance being “safe� for popular audiences, while facing backlash from her own community for the “mammy� roles she took on. She took the jobs she could get, even though the stereotypical roles often made her feel like a mockery. I cannot even imagine the immense pressure this woman faced trying to be everything to everyone, while still dealing with romantic woes.
Reshonda is one of my favorite authors and this book is very different from her traditional works. I am glad that she stepped outside her box and tried something new, giving life and awareness to Hattie’s life, success and legacy.
February 11, 2025
DNF at 52%
I was pretty excited to read this - love Hattie McDaniel and was looking forward to learning more about her life. This books starts with her academy award win and details her struggles following her role in GWTW. And therein lies my problem with this book and why I just can’t bring myself to finish it - too many details, too much unnecessary dialogue, too much fluff. It was slow and long (and with 7.5 hours left on the audiobook I’m cutting my losses).
On top of that, there seemed to be a lot of liberties taken with historical accuracy which is disappointing for a historical fiction novel.
I was pretty excited to read this - love Hattie McDaniel and was looking forward to learning more about her life. This books starts with her academy award win and details her struggles following her role in GWTW. And therein lies my problem with this book and why I just can’t bring myself to finish it - too many details, too much unnecessary dialogue, too much fluff. It was slow and long (and with 7.5 hours left on the audiobook I’m cutting my losses).
On top of that, there seemed to be a lot of liberties taken with historical accuracy which is disappointing for a historical fiction novel.
September 27, 2024
As a life long fan of GWTW, even now when it has become an awkward favorite, Hattie McDaniel has ever been a hero I admire. Her power is eternal and present. Just keep on going, no matter the weather, the battle, or the stupidity and cruelty of others.
Finding this read was an unexpected pleasure, and a wonderful reminder that she is still one of my heroes, and wherever she is I hope she's kicking up her heels and having a grand time. So many of us have wider horizons due to her efforts. Every crack in the firmament counts for the next one to break it open.
Kudos to ReShonda Tate for this opportunity to think about Hattie McDaniel!
*A sincere thank you to ReShonda Tate, William Morrow, and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.*
Finding this read was an unexpected pleasure, and a wonderful reminder that she is still one of my heroes, and wherever she is I hope she's kicking up her heels and having a grand time. So many of us have wider horizons due to her efforts. Every crack in the firmament counts for the next one to break it open.
Kudos to ReShonda Tate for this opportunity to think about Hattie McDaniel!
*A sincere thank you to ReShonda Tate, William Morrow, and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.*
January 28, 2024
I felt an overwhelming wave of sadness throughout this book. Not a sadness that made me cry, but one that made me feel empty and upset often at the same time. We all know Miss McDaniel to be the first Black woman to win an Oscar, but what happened to her after that historic moment is a series of events that we unfortunately can relate to in 2024.
While several liberties were taken throughout the book, it is quite believable that The Queen of Sugar Hill closely resembles the time period. Being Black (especially dark-skinned), being woman, being overweight, and being outspoken were seen as threats in 1940 and still are to this day. ReShonda Tate has taken the woman who was a “first� and humanized her, made us see that while she was fighting the establishment that she also had to defend her choices with her own community, that her decision making with men mirrors some of the stupid choices we too have made, and what stood out the most, that through it all Miss McDaniel focused on the good & kept pushing.
I recommend this book to all that want a fictionalized account of old Hollywood from the lens of a woman who tried her absolute best to break barriers.
While several liberties were taken throughout the book, it is quite believable that The Queen of Sugar Hill closely resembles the time period. Being Black (especially dark-skinned), being woman, being overweight, and being outspoken were seen as threats in 1940 and still are to this day. ReShonda Tate has taken the woman who was a “first� and humanized her, made us see that while she was fighting the establishment that she also had to defend her choices with her own community, that her decision making with men mirrors some of the stupid choices we too have made, and what stood out the most, that through it all Miss McDaniel focused on the good & kept pushing.
I recommend this book to all that want a fictionalized account of old Hollywood from the lens of a woman who tried her absolute best to break barriers.
March 22, 2024
Thank you @bookclubgirl and @williammorrow for gifting #ANovelBunchBookstaClub with this months pick. We had a great discussion and I love catching up with these women every month!!
We start the book seeing Hattie McDaniel win an Oscar in 1940 - the first black actor to ever win. And from there, we see the struggles and the triumphs she goes through within her life. Hattie is one against many with the world against her it is her time to make people notice her and her accolades.
I thought this book gave a very accurate depiction of both life in America in the 1940s-50s, Classic Hollywood, and the life of Hattie McDaniel. However, it felt almost too stilted and as though I was reading a biography - which is fine just not the book I thought I was going to read. Overall, we appreciated the historical accuracy but it wasn’t a fave for us.
We start the book seeing Hattie McDaniel win an Oscar in 1940 - the first black actor to ever win. And from there, we see the struggles and the triumphs she goes through within her life. Hattie is one against many with the world against her it is her time to make people notice her and her accolades.
I thought this book gave a very accurate depiction of both life in America in the 1940s-50s, Classic Hollywood, and the life of Hattie McDaniel. However, it felt almost too stilted and as though I was reading a biography - which is fine just not the book I thought I was going to read. Overall, we appreciated the historical accuracy but it wasn’t a fave for us.
March 25, 2025
This book introduces to some and educate others about the life of Hattie McDaniel, the first black woman to win an Oscar for her role of Mammy in Gone With The Wind. It focuses on her friendships (including Clark Gable, Dorothy Dandridge and Louise Beavers), failed marriages, racism, criticism from the NAACP and her attempted suicide.
Personal struggles aside, she continued to fight for the actors and crew that followed behind her. Often referred to as the Queen of Sugar Hill (named after the prominent black neighbor in Harlem), Hattie’s parties were infamous. Several actors refused to attend, until they found out her good friend Clark Gable often attended.
There was so much that I learned while reading this book. I lost plenty of sleep in fear of missing something. I’ve read plenty of books by @reshonda_tate, but this by far is her best work yet.
GO GET THIS BOOK!
Personal struggles aside, she continued to fight for the actors and crew that followed behind her. Often referred to as the Queen of Sugar Hill (named after the prominent black neighbor in Harlem), Hattie’s parties were infamous. Several actors refused to attend, until they found out her good friend Clark Gable often attended.
There was so much that I learned while reading this book. I lost plenty of sleep in fear of missing something. I’ve read plenty of books by @reshonda_tate, but this by far is her best work yet.
GO GET THIS BOOK!
May 6, 2024
139th Pick, March 2024 ~ Chosen by Robin.
Average rating 2.1 stars.
Knowing that this book was the story of Hattie McDaniel and old-time Hollywood attracted our attention. The book shed light on a time when Hollywood offered only very limited roles to minority actors and actresses. We learned about parts of Hattie McDaniel's life but wanted to know more and found some of the incidents in her life could have been expanded with more explanation. At the end, we felt we knew about her life after the academy award but would have liked to know more about her whole life, especially the early parts of it.
Characters: Hattie McDaniel.
Meeting Notes: We met at P.F. Chang’s Restaurant on April 28, 2024. In attendance: Pam, Robin, Marilyn, Kimber.
Average rating 2.1 stars.
Knowing that this book was the story of Hattie McDaniel and old-time Hollywood attracted our attention. The book shed light on a time when Hollywood offered only very limited roles to minority actors and actresses. We learned about parts of Hattie McDaniel's life but wanted to know more and found some of the incidents in her life could have been expanded with more explanation. At the end, we felt we knew about her life after the academy award but would have liked to know more about her whole life, especially the early parts of it.
Characters: Hattie McDaniel.
Meeting Notes: We met at P.F. Chang’s Restaurant on April 28, 2024. In attendance: Pam, Robin, Marilyn, Kimber.
February 18, 2024
A really fascinating, well written historical biography about the life of Hattie McDaniels, the Oscar winning actress who played Mammy in Gone with the wind. I didn't know much about Hattie's life at all and this book was such an interesting look at her love life (she was married four times), her Hollywood career and her tragic death from breast cancer. Great on audio narrated by Lynnette R. Freeman and definitely worth a read for anyone wanting to know more about 1940s and 50s America for Black people and especially Black entertainers!
February 16, 2025
What a fascinating read. I hadn’t heard of The Queen of Sugar Hill: a novel of Hattie McDaniel nor Hattie McDaniel. So I was delighted @momadvice picked it for her monthly Bookclub pick on her patreon.
The Queen of Sugar Hill is a fictional take on Hattie McDaniel� the first black person to win an Oscar for her role as Mammy in Gone with the Wind. You witness Hattie face setbacks as well as comebacks. Her strength and determination was inspiring during a time and industry that was not accepting of her. Though fictional this read like a memoir and you get a glimpse at a remarkable woman and her journey she paved in Hollywood.
Midway through I called my Mom and asked if she knew Hattie McDaniel and of course she had� remembering other significant rolls she has been in. Which got me thinking about how Hollywood names from long ago may get forgotten. I’m glad I learned about Hattie and will definitely share her story with my girls.
Follow me on Instagram:
The Queen of Sugar Hill is a fictional take on Hattie McDaniel� the first black person to win an Oscar for her role as Mammy in Gone with the Wind. You witness Hattie face setbacks as well as comebacks. Her strength and determination was inspiring during a time and industry that was not accepting of her. Though fictional this read like a memoir and you get a glimpse at a remarkable woman and her journey she paved in Hollywood.
Midway through I called my Mom and asked if she knew Hattie McDaniel and of course she had� remembering other significant rolls she has been in. Which got me thinking about how Hollywood names from long ago may get forgotten. I’m glad I learned about Hattie and will definitely share her story with my girls.
Follow me on Instagram:
Displaying 1 - 30 of 737 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.