From the Bookshelf of forever and evermore swifties…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

wow i don't know how to feel right now.
3 stars. [lowered from 4 stars to 3 stars]
lowering my rating because foolish me reading this last year was too emotional to understand all the things wrong with this book. this review by gloria helped me understand the major issues with this book.
if you're reading this book, i highly encourage you to read the author's note once you have finished the book.
also! please do look up the trigger warnings for this book before reading it, because for some reason th ...more
3 stars. [lowered from 4 stars to 3 stars]
lowering my rating because foolish me reading this last year was too emotional to understand all the things wrong with this book. this review by gloria helped me understand the major issues with this book.
if you're reading this book, i highly encourage you to read the author's note once you have finished the book.
also! please do look up the trigger warnings for this book before reading it, because for some reason th ...more

Dec 15, 2021
Hannah Aronna
rated it
did not like it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2021-reads,
2022-reads
January 22, 2025
I'm looking back at a couple of the reviews I've written in the last couple of years, and PLEASE IGNORE THE PARTS IN THE REVIEW FROM 2021-22!!!!
While yes, I admit I really enjoyed this book when I read it the first and only three times, I am now a changed person. I first read it when I was 16, and now at almost 20, I learned the importance of discerning what is good for you and what isn't. This book left a really distorted view for me of what a romance novel is. Quite clearly, t ...more
I'm looking back at a couple of the reviews I've written in the last couple of years, and PLEASE IGNORE THE PARTS IN THE REVIEW FROM 2021-22!!!!
While yes, I admit I really enjoyed this book when I read it the first and only three times, I am now a changed person. I first read it when I was 16, and now at almost 20, I learned the importance of discerning what is good for you and what isn't. This book left a really distorted view for me of what a romance novel is. Quite clearly, t ...more

What I enjoyed most about this book are the lessons and meanings behind it. It shows you a new perspective into toxic and abusive relationships, shows you the how’s and why’s and offers you insight into the “naked truths� into why the partner wouldn’t leave the other. It highlights the struggles one faces mentally when put in a situation like lily’s and lily’s mother. It describes how it’s not easy for one to immediately leave, and describes the mental struggles facing those issues.
I didn’t car ...more
I didn’t car ...more

3.6
perdon
no, no llore, ni un poquito, que me disculpe toda la comunidad de lectores pero no es el libro mas “desgarrador� que haya leido en mi vida.
es verdad que es precioso, lo llene de post its y lo marque muchisimo, pero hay muchas cosas que no me cierran.
no se si decir que me decepcionó, tenia muchas expectativas y realmente esperaba llorar a mares en el final, y eso que yo lloro con casi cualquier libro, pero no pasó.
mis partes favoritas son definitivamente las cartas a Ellen, siento que m ...more
perdon
no, no llore, ni un poquito, que me disculpe toda la comunidad de lectores pero no es el libro mas “desgarrador� que haya leido en mi vida.
es verdad que es precioso, lo llene de post its y lo marque muchisimo, pero hay muchas cosas que no me cierran.
no se si decir que me decepcionó, tenia muchas expectativas y realmente esperaba llorar a mares en el final, y eso que yo lloro con casi cualquier libro, pero no pasó.
mis partes favoritas son definitivamente las cartas a Ellen, siento que m ...more

3.5 stars*
ummmmmmm. I thought this book was supposed to destroy me mentally. It did nothing of the sort. It wasn’t bad, like, I enjoyed reading it. But it wasn’t amazing. Personally there were way too many smut scenes, as in, I was so bored of them having sex all the time. I also found that lily repeated the same stuff so many times. It just felt like I kept on reading the same ‘deep� quotes again and again, slightly re phrased. That being said I still liked this book.
edit-2 stars� i’ve been thi ...more
ummmmmmm. I thought this book was supposed to destroy me mentally. It did nothing of the sort. It wasn’t bad, like, I enjoyed reading it. But it wasn’t amazing. Personally there were way too many smut scenes, as in, I was so bored of them having sex all the time. I also found that lily repeated the same stuff so many times. It just felt like I kept on reading the same ‘deep� quotes again and again, slightly re phrased. That being said I still liked this book.
edit-2 stars� i’ve been thi ...more

"Fifteen seconds. That's all it takes to completely change everything about a person. Fifteen."

...more

...more

Jul 01, 2021
(k)
marked it as to-read

Aug 22, 2021
vivian
marked it as to-read

Jan 24, 2022
luna.loves.books
added it