Strange Flowers in Constant Reader

From the Bookshelf of Constant Reader…

Strange Flowers

Donal Ryan

Start date: October 15, 2023

Finish date: November 15, 2023

Discussion: Reading List

Discussion leader: Barb

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 421 topics — 16,780 comments total

Reading List

* Nominations list for July - December 2025
By Lynn · 9 posts · 22 views

last updated May 09, 2025 02:18PM

* The Schedule for January through June 2025
By Lynn · 13 posts · 77 views

last updated Mar 21, 2025 05:14AM

showing 4 of 4 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Oct 28, 2021 Sheila rated it really liked it

Shelves: book-groups

From 1970s Ireland Moll Glandey suddenly runs away. Her parents Kit and Paddy don't know why, neighbours gossip, dead or pregnant are the only options, her parents try hunting for her in backstreet clinics in the city to no avail. She is gone 5 years before just as suddenly she returns.

Donal Ryan releases her story slowly, draws his readers in with a great sense of time and place, rural Irish life defined by community, land, class, and above all religion. The family are tenants on the land of t From 1970s Ireland Moll Glandey suddenly runs away. Her parents Kit and Paddy don't know why, neighbours gossip, dead or pregnant are the only options, her parents try hunting for her in backstreet clinics in the city to no avail. She is gone 5 years before just as suddenly she returns.

Donal Ryan releases her story slowly, draws his readers in with a great sense of time and place, rural Irish life defined by community, land, class, and above all religion. The family are tenants on the land of the Jackmans and we have the inclination that Moll's disappearance has something to do with them and we suspect what it will have been especially after a shouting match between Mrs Ellen Jackman and Moll soon after her return. Beautifully paced, the story of Moll's sojourn in England is revealed only after Alexander Ellwood follows after her from England in search. The novel flows over into the next generation and young Joshua's escape also to England and his eventual return home to his grandmother's cottage and his mother. Ryan tinges his story with the bigotry of the times but with memorable characters and the unconditional love of one, and the warm comforts, smells and safety of home hearth. Yet this is not an oversentimental portrait of love, it is not nostalgic for a lost rural idyll, as it is gritty in places, callous in others, deadly on others.

SPOLIER ALERT**** whilst many will criticise the novel for its flaws in making Alexander a black man, as well as an Englishman, in an overlong reading in London to Honey of Joshua's creative reworking of the blind man Lazarus' story, I can forgive the author these because he writes so well. This was a most enjoyable read.

The first time I have read one of his novels, although I have read some of his short stories - My Boy Jack ( ) , The Fall of Man ( ). The BBC used to have more of his stories up but these seem to be the only two now on their Short Works site. There is also The Wise Man ( ) and All we shall know ( ) but you may need to be a subscriber for that one. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review