Sherlock Holmes And The Lyme Regis Horror in David Ruffle's Sherlock Holmes group

Aug 22, 2012 Leah rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: sherlock-holmes, blog-review, from-the-tbr-pile, 2012

This book is divided between a novella (The Lyme Regis Horror) and several short stories. First, the novella:

Ruffle knows Holmes and Watson very well; canon devotees will find plenty of insider references and familiar-sounding (though not verbatim) phrases. The Watsonian voice is decently done and witty; Ruffle stays in his narrator鈥檚 head the entire time. Holmes is mellower than he is often portrayed; he also seems to know more about Jane Austen than one would suspect of a man who sneers at so This book is divided between a novella (The Lyme Regis Horror) and several short stories. First, the novella:

Ruffle knows Holmes and Watson very well; canon devotees will find plenty of insider references and familiar-sounding (though not verbatim) phrases. The Watsonian voice is decently done and witty; Ruffle stays in his narrator鈥檚 head the entire time. Holmes is mellower than he is often portrayed; he also seems to know more about Jane Austen than one would suspect of a man who sneers at softer emotions. On another interesting note, Holmes (using his impossible/improbable line of reasoning) is convinced early on that the culprit in the first story is supernatural, while the two physicians take some convincing. I never felt, however, that either Holmes or Watson was veering out of character.

One of Ruffle鈥檚 great strengths is his ear for dialogue; it rarely rings false, and is often quite funny such as when Watson informs Mrs. Jacobs that his writing is not for children, or the Inspector advises everyone not to 鈥渜uibble with small details.鈥� If a little too much time is spent delineating incidents in local history which don鈥檛 relate to the plot, it can be forgiven; Watson does like travel guides.

When it鈥檚 time to bring the suspense, Ruffle delivers as well. The atmosphere changes perceptibly when Sarah Jacobs opens the door to the Count. The following confrontation is electrifying, and reminds the reader that Holmes is truly master of the 鈥渁nd the horse you came in on鈥� speech. The feeling of dread continues as Holmes, Watson, and Jacobs ready themselves for battle; they don鈥檛 know whether or not they鈥檙e coming back, and neither do we. In fact, as they walk towards the manor in dark of early morning, Ruffle鈥檚 description is so skillful, the chills are palpable.

Ruffle鈥檚 ability as a writer is, finally, evident in his deceptively simple denouement. In it, he takes up a thread I had thought dangling and superfluous, using it to pull the physical and emotional parts of the story together. I won鈥檛 divulge any more except to say that, as a writer, I admired the skill with which he accomplished this, and found myself thinking about it all day.

鈥淭he Trumper Affiar鈥� (previously published as an e-pub on Amazon) is a solid story, written along more traditional lines than 鈥淗orror.鈥� Ruffle provides accurate historical details, both in the setting and characters (actual cricket players), and his end notes are a nice touch for history aficionados. Holmes and Watson are also nicely in character and we鈥檙e treated to some nice running jokes as Watson continually bores the Great Detective (and occasionally the reader) with lengthy explications of cricket matches, and Holmes finds that the doctor鈥檚 novelistic touches have given him some unexpected anonymity. The story is not as atmospheric as 鈥淗orror,鈥� but Ruffle performs a very nice sleight-of-hand in concealing the villain, the denouement is darker for its realism, and the ending is quite poignant.

Ruffle takes us back to the supernatural in 鈥淭he Mystery of Loch Ness鈥� and 鈥淭he Runes Affair.鈥� In the former, a gruesome death forces the reader to apply Holmes鈥� famous maxim, 鈥渢hat when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.鈥� In 鈥淭he Runes Affair,鈥� three highly nervous paranormal researchers ask Holmes to help them fend off what seems to be an evil author鈥檚 attempt to exact vengeance for poor reviews and rejection slips through supernatural means. Holmes and Watson take on the case to assuage the mens鈥� fears and meet with unexpected results; one has to wonder whether they might have been manipulated into unwittingly carrying out revenge themselves.

Other stories have a supernatural bent as well. Set in more modern times (the 1930鈥瞫 and the recent past, respectively), 鈥淔orever 1895鈥� and 鈥淎 Lyme Ghost Story鈥� suggest that Holmes dislikes partiers and inappropriate over night guests, but has a soft spot for pastiche writers. 鈥淭imeless in Lyme鈥� is not about phantoms鈥t least from one perspective. In each of these pieces, Ruffle mixes past and present with the deft touch essential for a satisfying ghost tale.

Christmas is another favorite topic. In 鈥淐hristmas at Baker Street,鈥� Holmes explains to Watson the very best reasons for refusing a knighthood. He exposes even more of his heart in the incredibly charming 鈥淗enrietta鈥檚 Problem,鈥� giving credence to Jeremy Brett鈥檚 view that 鈥淗olmes loved children.鈥� My personal favorite in this collection, however, is 鈥淐hristmas with Holmes,鈥� which has an aging Holmes and Watson spending the holiday together in Sussex in 1916. The end scene is beautiful and while I realized, upon a third reading, that it could have a darker interpretation, I鈥檒l go with my first, sad-but-fitting one. Ruffle ends the book with a lovely poem dedicated to his son, Duncan.

So, my final conclusion? Sherlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Horror is a well-written collection with 鈥渢he charm of variety,鈥� deserving of a place on your bookshelf or in your e-reader. I look forward to reading more of Ruffle鈥檚 work.

...more

3 likes · Like · see review

Nov 07, 2012 Mike Hogan rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: sherlock-holmes

Sherlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Horror. I read the first story in this compilation with great enjoyment; it has a strong plot, well-drawn minor characters and above all a believable relationship between the two main protagonists, Holmes and Watson. I very much like the fact that Watson is given time to develop not only an affection for the town of Lyme Regis (which the author clearly shares), but a sensitively-portrayed love interest. For me, although Holmes deploys his intellect and other re ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Sep 28, 2012 Philip Jones rated it really liked it · review of another edition

This book is an anthology that consists of a short novel, a novella, nine short stories/fragments and a poem, all related, more or less, to Lyme Regis. This is the second edition and it contains additional material to the first edition as well as a number of editing changes.

The main story violates Holmes鈥� dictum, that 鈥渘o ghosts need apply.鈥� If that is overlooked, what is left is a lively and engaging tale about a picturesque village and time. The Watson telling the tale is one of the most enga This book is an anthology that consists of a short novel, a novella, nine short stories/fragments and a poem, all related, more or less, to Lyme Regis. This is the second edition and it contains additional material to the first edition as well as a number of editing changes.

The main story violates Holmes鈥� dictum, that 鈥渘o ghosts need apply.鈥� If that is overlooked, what is left is a lively and engaging tale about a picturesque village and time. The Watson telling the tale is one of the most engaging I have met. He has the loyalty, the manners and the honesty all Sherlockians have come to revere along with a knowing twinkle in his eye. Holmes is Holmes, a bit older than we are accustomed to, but with the keen eye and lack of pretense, inhibition or tact we all associate with him. The other characterizations in the story are well-done, producing sharp images and clear impressions.

The basic premise of the tale has a supernatural element that is alien to the Canon, with no scientific justification. It requires a 鈥榳illing suspension of disbelief鈥� and it strained my reserves of such disbelief. However, if we can gloss over and forget Doyle鈥檚 descent into Spiritualism, we can surely forgive The Master a reaction to events that reach beyond the science of his time and place. It is evident that Holmes reacts reasonably and effectively to the circumstances he faces. The question is whether those circumstances could ever occur. 鈥淔urther deponent sayeth not.鈥�

The novella, 鈥淭he Trumper Affair,鈥� is engaging and well-written. Holmes solves a minor mystery and Watson鈥檚 love of Cricket is fully indulged. A number of 鈥榯urn of the Century鈥� Cricket personalities are featured and the Twentieth Century British Empire is introduced.

The new collection of short pieces is expanded and 鈥榩unched up鈥� a bit, but it remains incomplete and fragmentary. The items included are all emotional and interesting, but most are only glimpses of Holmes and Watson or of their lasting impressions. Time wanders in and out of the narratives and impressions are more important than details.

The results of reading this book are a desire to visit Lyme Regis and a hope to see more of this comforting Watson, who is just what one always felt Watson should be.

Re-reviewed by: Philip K. Jones, August, 2012.
Published in 鈥淒octor Watson鈥檚 Formulary,鈥� [#21, 09/2012]
...more

Like · see review

May 08, 2013 Pamela rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: paranormal-fantasy, victorian-mystery

This was a book about Sherlock Holmes and his adventures from the narrative of DR. Watson. The story takes place in a small costal town, on what should be a holiday. Then there is a murder, and the game is afoot. This has a supernatural tone to it, and I did not mind that at all. I found the book very interesting, and look forward to book 2 of this trilogy.

Like · see review

Aug 07, 2011 Kat rated it it was amazing

Like

Jul 11, 2012 Joe Riggs marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Shelves: sherlock-related

Like

Aug 17, 2012 Steve Emecz rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Like

Aug 19, 2012 Charlotte Smith rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: sherlock-holmes-books

Like

Sep 01, 2012 Amy Evans marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Like

Oct 07, 2012 Michele marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Shelves: historical-mysteries, sherlock

Like

Dec 27, 2012 Jeanette marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Like

Jan 03, 2013 Marie-Louise marked it as to-read

Shelves: owns

Like

Jan 25, 2013 Tina marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Shelves: mystery, thriller, sherlock

Like

Jan 26, 2013 Angie marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Like

Feb 14, 2013 Jan C is currently reading it · review of another edition

Shelves: england, mystery

Like

Feb 15, 2013 Carrie marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Like

Feb 18, 2013 Victor Gentile rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

David Ruffle in his new book, 鈥淪herlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Horror鈥� published by MX Publishing gives us an untold story of Sherlock Holmes, The Lyme Regis Horror.

From the back cover: The year is 1896. Doctor Watson is invited to the Dorsetshire coast by an old friend. To Watson鈥檚 surprise he manages to persuade his good friend, Mr Sherlock Holmes to accompany him. This hitherto unknown tale of Watson鈥檚 involves romancing, dancing, occasional glasses of cider, but the holiday turns into a n David Ruffle in his new book, 鈥淪herlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Horror鈥� published by MX Publishing gives us an untold story of Sherlock Holmes, The Lyme Regis Horror.

From the back cover: The year is 1896. Doctor Watson is invited to the Dorsetshire coast by an old friend. To Watson鈥檚 surprise he manages to persuade his good friend, Mr Sherlock Holmes to accompany him. This hitherto unknown tale of Watson鈥檚 involves romancing, dancing, occasional glasses of cider, but the holiday turns into a nightmare as the two old friends encounter an unimaginable evil which threatens their very souls.

Can they triumph?

If you are anything like me then you grew up with Sherlock Holmes as well. When I was a kid I read everything that Arthur Conan Doyle wrote about the master sleuth and, of course, watched all the movies with Basil Rathbone. Now I do not believe in channeling. Having said that let me tell you that David Ruffle writes just the way that Arthur Conan Doyle wrote and it is like reading one of the originals. There really is a place called Lyme Regis, it is a coastal town that, after reading this book, I would like to visit. It seems to be such a nice place that even Holmes decides to visit without much persuasion from Watson. However, despite all the peach and tranquility, it doesn鈥檛 take long before Holmes and Watson are up to their necks in serious trouble and it takes quite a bit of effort to break this case. Keep in mind this is Sherlock Holmes we are talking about here and, of course, I am not giving anything away here, he is going to break it. The clues are given for us to solve the case. I confess I did not, Holmes did it for me. Let me assure you if you like Sherlock Holmes then you are going to really enjoy this. Not only is there the title story but eleven more short stories that are equally challenging and great fun. I recommend it highly!

If you would like to listen to interviews with other authors and professionals please go to where they are available On Demand.

To listen to 24 hours non-stop, commercial free Christian music please visit our internet radio station

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from MX Publishing. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission鈥檚 16 CFR, Part 255 : 鈥淕uides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.鈥� ...more

Like · see review