ŷ

Dolors's Reviews > Shakespeare's Sonnets

Shakespeare's Sonnets by William Shakespeare
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: best-ever, getting-to-know-shakespeare, poetry
Read 2 times. Last read April 12, 2015 to May 27, 2015.

Less notorious than his plays, Shakespeare’s sonnets assimilate a secret map with hidden clues that lead to precious treasures. The intimate, even confessional tone of the 154 rhymes urges the eager reader to believe that the poetic voice is The Bard himself, who playfully volunteers the key to unlock the mysteries of his heart.
And yet� Do the sonnets tell a coherent story? If they do, is this story real or fictional? The fact that Thomas Thorpe, a poet, editor and admirer of Shakespeare, and not the author himself published this collection casts a shadow over the present order of the sonnets and their ostensible story line. Are they the product of literary artifice or the purest expression of the poet’s sentiments and his personal experiences?
Allow me to reply with another question.
Does it really matter?
The audacious imagery, the staggering metaphors, the musical alliteration, the ironic polysemies, the utter mastery of the language bursting into florid fireworks and the universality and relevancy of paramount themes such as the passage of time, the impending oblivion that comes with death and the convoluted nature of love constitute the invaluable legacy of the poet on their own. Everything else is mere speculation, but as per usual, Shakespeare teases with ambiguous piquancy as shown in Sonnet 144, which summarizes the main “plot� of the anthology in 4 stanzas:

“Two loves I have of comfort and despair,
Which like two spirits do suggest me still;
The better angel is a man right fair,
The worser spirit a woman colour'd ill.�


A love triangle that consists of a “fair man�, a “dark woman� and the poet himself divides the sonnets in two noticeably different sections and presents a subversive approach to the foundations of courtly love employed by medieval troubadours because the “Muse� that stimulates inspiration seems to possess an adrogynous essence. Personal pronouns shift from verse to verse and the poet’s self-awareness plays an active role in the exulted display of emotions that becomes a faithful mirror for the complex gradation of the affairs of the heart. A prolongued meditation on the ethos of beauty and platonic love is interwoven with anguished cogitation about the inexorable passage of time that might wither the beloved’s blooming youth but never his é-ٲ, which is immortalized in the poet’s writing:

“So long as men can breathe or eyes can see,
So long lives this, and this gives life to thee.�

Sonnet 18.

Whereas the “fair knight� awakens tenderness, blind adoration and the purest expressions of affection in stanzas that are replete with natural imagery and astute analogies of daily life scenes, the “dark lady�, addressed only in the last 28 sonnets, disturbs the poet with her unchaste promiscuity and adulterous love. The transcendental undertone of the former sonnets fades away leaving space only for satire, sexual lust and aggrieved reproaches. The harmonic features of the male lover contrast with the sensuously dark eyes of the woman, which lure the poet into debauchery and temptation against his wishes. Lies, deception ad cynical rebuffs are the highpoints of the puns and wordplays in the last sonnets. The language becomes merely explicative, if also prodigiously lucid and accusatory, and loses the hiperbolic flamboyance of the opening sonnets.

“The expense of spirit in a waste of shame
Is lust in action; and till action, lust
Is perjured, murderous, bloody, full of blame,
Savage, extreme, rude, cruel, not to trust,
Enjoy'd no sooner but despised straight,
Past reason hunted, and no sooner had
Past reason hated, as a swallow'd bait
On purpose laid to make the taker mad;
Mad in pursuit and in possession so;
Had, having, and in quest to have, extreme;
A bliss in proof, and proved, a very woe;
Before, a joy proposed; behind, a dream.
All this the world well knows; yet none knows well
To shun the heaven that leads men to this hell.�

Sonnet 129.

Ironically enough, both lovers, fair man and dark woman, remain anonymous while the true identity of the poet has created havoc for centuries and his works continue to unleash passions among all kind of readers around the world. Shakespeare lives on in his words. In their suggestive rhythm, in their polifacetic meanings, in their musical texture.
Shakespeare’s poetry delves deep into the abysses of the human psyche, into the labyrinthine jumble of irrational, desperate love, into the stinky gutters of conscience, jealousy and betrayal, and still, he winks back with a lopsided smile and restores the magic of humanity in a single couplet:

“For nothing hold me, so it please thee hold
That nothing me a something sweet to thee:
Make but my name thy love, and love that still,
And then thou lovest me for my name is 'Will.'

Sonnet 136.

Miracles do not seem mambo-jumbo after reading Shakespeare’s sonnets, and art becomes magic, for divine providence is evinced stanza after stanza and my will submits to Will’s power...Subjugation was never sweeter!
81 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Shakespeare's Sonnets.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 12, 2015 – Started Reading
April 12, 2015 – Shelved
April 12, 2015 –
page 43
8.81% ""Yet, do thy worst, old Time: despite thy wrong,
My love shall in my verse ever live young."
Sonnet 19"
April 19, 2015 –
page 134
27.46% ""Take all my loves, my love, yea, take them all;
What hast thou then more than thou hadst before?
No love, my love, that thou mayst true love call;
All mine was thine before thou hadst this more."
Sonnet 40."
April 28, 2015 –
page 176
36.07% ""For thee watch I whilst thou dost wake elsewhere, From me far off, with others all too near." Sonnet 61"
May 1, 2015 –
page 226
46.31% "In me thou see'st the glowing of such fire That on the ashes of his youth doth lie, As the death-bed whereon it must expire, Consumed with that which it was nourish'd by. This thou perceiv'st, which makes thy love more strong To love that well which thou must leave ere long."
May 8, 2015 –
page 352
72.13% ""But if that flower with base infection meet,
The basest weed outbraves his dignity:
For sweetest things turn sourest by their deeds;
Lilies that fester smell far worse than weeds.""
May 27, 2015 –
page 488
100.0% "Will playing with words:
"So thou, being rich in Will, add to thy Will
One will of mine, to make thy large Will more.
Let no unkind, no fair beseechers kill;
Think all but one, and me in that one Will.""
May 27, 2015 – Finished Reading
September 2, 2020 – Started Reading (Hardcover Edition)
October 2, 2020 – Shelved (Hardcover Edition)
October 2, 2020 – Finished Reading (Hardcover Edition)

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lynne King Dolors, How can one even attempt to make a comment on Shakespeare. How ever did he do it? His works are incredible."A Lover's Complaint" follows in my battered book and it's lovely!


Dolors I have no idea Lynne, I asked myself the same question over and over again with every sonnet I read. A collection I will revisit many times in the future to come... My edition didn't include the narrative poem, but I will make sure to get it at some point.


message 3: by David (new)

David Gustafson A very professional review. Amazing insights considering that English is not your native language.


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

Lynne wrote: "Dolors, How can one even attempt to make a comment on Shakespeare. How ever did he do it? His works are incredible."A Lover's Complaint" follows in my battered book and it's lovely!"

Great review, Dolors. I agree that it shouldn't matter what poet's intentions were. Infact, I actually would prefer not to know such things where I can help, it makes reading more personal.

Sonnets seems to bring a unique feel from amongst all live poetry; a feeling you captured so well. Once, again a great review.


message 5: by Tristan (new)

Tristan Brilliant review. I will have to find the time to read my copy of the sonnets.


message 6: by Jibran (new)

Jibran The ease with which you have taken us through the subcutaneous layers of Shakespearean sonnets, their substance, their imagery, the language, esp your fascinating thematic comparisons of the transcendental overtones of earlier sonnets with the biting satire of the later ones, make for a splendid reading experience in itself, Dolors! I'm intrigued by this break between themes, if I may call it so.

Thanks for this review; I have been quietly waiting for you to write something on the Sonnets and I'm so glad you did. Till I read them, I can only imagine the pleasures of discovery and enlightenment that await the reader in those bezels of poetry.

Allow me to reply with another question.
Does it really matter?


Ah there. Thanks for replying to your question with this one! As I read your previous questions I felt a bit iffy and a question of my own descended quietly into my mind: Can the two, poet's artifice and his purest expression, be reasonably delineated? Like Flaubert said to an interviewer, All answers to your questions are inside the novel; stop asking me! Indeed, as you said, Everything else is mere speculation.


message 7: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl I love when subjectivity opens pathways to different modes of analyzing creative work. Bravo to how you illuminate this! The passage of time, as you put it, is indeed an alluring aspect of this work. Thanks for sharing such elegant thoughts and a review layered with contemplative complexity, Dolors.


message 8: by Deea (last edited Jul 08, 2015 02:48PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deea And if last year you were ashamed to say that you were not introduced enough to Shakespeare's work, I think that now you would easily be able to write a whole thesis on his work. You are an amazing reader dear Dolors and an amazing reviewer. Anyone who attempts to tackle Shakespeare's sonnets in a review and can do it so easily and with such charm as you did above understands literature in its depth.


Dolors David wrote: "A very professional review. Amazing insights considering that English is not your native language."

David, thank you very much for your kind words, you just paid me the best compliment I could expect to receive. My edition of Shakespeare’s sonnets was bilingual in English-Spanish and it enclosed comprehensive annotations that made the reading a much more approachable task…glad you liked the result!


Dolors Sidharth wrote: "Great review, Dolors. I agree that it shouldn't matter what poet's intentions were. Infact, I actually would prefer not to know such things where I can help, it makes reading more personal."

I definitely agree with that thought Sidharth, but the tone of the sonnets is so intimate that one can’t help but wonder about the Bard’s intentions when he composed them. Ultimately though, what really matters is his incredible mastery in language and the meditative reflections on the nature of love vs sexual passion and the ongoing paradox between the inevitable passage of time and the everlasting quality of the written word. Thanks for stopping by to read and for your generous comment and spot-on insights, they are much appreciated.


Dolors Tristan wrote: "Brilliant review. I will have to find the time to read my copy of the sonnets."

Thanks a lot Tristan! Thrilled that you liked it. Seeing your recent reviews on poetry I bet you would be transfixed by Shakespeare’s versatile sonnets. I will be looking forward to your thoughts when you get around to reading them.


Dolors Thanks for this magnificent post, Jibran! Your insightful remarks on “the break between the themes� � great expression by the way � are incredibly accurate. Not only the thematic content of the sonnets differs noticeably, but also the tone, which is wistful, tender and melancholic in the first section and increasingly dark and cynical in the second one, and even the writing style; soaked with natural imagery in the sonnets addressed to the “fair man� and aimed to deceive with the double meanings of words in the ones dedicated to the “dark lady�. It’s a feast for all the senses and I can’t wait to read your intake of The Bard’s display of psychological insight and humorous acuity.
Fernando Pessoa, one of my favorite writers of all times, portrayed the idea of the poet as a master of deception that is more authentic than reality in his poem Autopsychography. The artist might transfigure, invent or exaggerate when he creates, but the result acquires a meaning of its own that transcends moral categorization. Thus, Shakespeare’s ambiguity contributes into making his sonnets timeless masterpieces that convey multiple truths to every reader.
Enclosing Pessoa’s stanza as a return gift for a comment that made me soar cloud high. Thank you again, Jibran!

“The poet is a faker
Who’s so good at his act
He even fakes the pain
Of pain he feels in fact.�



Dolors Cheryl wrote: "I love when subjectivity opens pathways to different modes of analyzing creative work. Bravo to how you illuminate this! The passage of time, as you put it, is indeed an alluring aspect of this wor..."

Thanks so much Cheryl! There were so many angles from where to approach the sonnets that I was overwhelmed with the countless interpretations. The contrast between the mysteries of procreation and the mundane, almost utilitarian metaphors of daily life blended the mystical with the skeptical with incredible ease, yet I couldn't help being invariably perplexed by the unexpected turn brought by the last couplet in every single sonnet. Such dexterous versatility with the use of language! And so never did sobering themes such as time, flesh decay and death so full of hope and wistfulness... This collection has completely changed my outlook of poetry!


Dolors Deea wrote: "And if last year you were ashamed to say that you were not introduced enough to Shakespeare's work, I think that now you would easily be able to write a whole thesis on his work. You are an amazing..."

Why, thanks so much for such lovely comment Deea! You just managed to make my night, my month and probably my whole summer with your invigorating words. I have to confess that the fact that my edition was bilingual � early modern English and modern Spanish � and that it also enclosed informative footnotes and a comprehensive introduction was of invaluable help to my better grasp of the poems. I think this is a work that any reader can tackle, the only advice I would give is not to rush through the sonnets and to bask in their musicality and wordplay. They are “word problems�, aphorisms that should be savored in small quantities like exquisite delicatessen. I hope you decide to taste Shakespeare’s literary feast some day so I can get to read your impressions. Thanks again for your supportive presence, it's greatly appreciated, Deea.


message 15: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Wow this review is fantastic. Excellent depth and love of the Sonnet master! I must confess that aside from a select few plays (Lear, Macbeth) I'm don't really like Shakespeare much, but his sonnets are fabulous. Great work, Dolors, always a treat to discover a new review from you!


message 16: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Subjugation was never sweeter indeed! To your delicate stream of thoughts that not only knows its way through the dense poetic foliage of The Bard but also sews a simultaneous trail of indigenous sonnet by its own multifarious dimensions of observations and wisdom, I absolutely, joyously surrender! What a feast to see the mesmerizing world of Shakespeare through your masterful eye, Dolors! His sonnets, as you right put, were a guiding tome to life's base bricks and in your otherworldly rearrangement, you have erected a new house with the same soul! Oh it does matter when Dolors reviews Shakespeare! :)


message 17: by Cristina (new)

Cristina Una anàlisi fantàstica, nena! El to dels primers sonets a diferència dels darrers, la reflexió del principi sobre l'autor i sobre si l'obra és expressió de les seves experiències o no i de si això realment importa i finalment el "recommended for" que m'ha acabat de matar. No em cansaré mai de repetir-ho, Shakespeare forever!!!!


Dolors s.penkevich wrote: "Wow this review is fantastic. Excellent depth and love of the Sonnet master! I must confess that aside from a select few plays (Lear, Macbeth) I'm don't really like Shakespeare much, but his sonnet..."

I didn't like Romeo & Juliet very much, but have enjoyed the other plays I have read. King Lear is probably my favorite. Othello and Hamlet follow close. I think I had been wary of the renowned complexity of Shakespeare's plays that I was positively surprised when I realized how modern, open-minded and subtly humorous they were. The sonnets were tougher work but fortunately for me I had a bilingual (English-Spanish) edition that was truly helpful. Glad you liked my musings on the collection, Spenks... Your presence here is a gift I never take for granted! :)


Dolors Seemita wrote: "Subjugation was never sweeter indeed! To your delicate stream of thoughts that not only knows its way through the dense poetic foliage of The Bard but also sews a simultaneous trail of indigenous s..."

Haha Seemita, this is the sort of comment that provides fuel to keep the motor of my imagination running, and running wild! I have spent a great deal of time with Shakespeare this year and I have been rewarded with the most delightful of surprises: apart from him being a genius, he and his multifaceted selves are fun to be around! And so imagine how well your humorous words sit with me on this sunny morning. Also, your reference to the structural foundation of Shakespeare's sonnets brought back one of Emily Dickinson's stanzas that addresses poetry as "a fairer House than Prose, More numerous of Windows, Superior - for Doors". And indeed, poetry is the genre that gives wings to the purest expression and feelings, becoming a straightway to heaven...which is where I am right now thanks to your comment...you rule, Seemita! ;P


Dolors Cristina wrote: "Una anàlisi fantàstica, nena! El to dels primers sonets a diferència dels darrers, la reflexió del principi sobre l'autor i sobre si l'obra és expressió de les seves experiències o no i de si això ..."

Crec que l'edició en aquest cas va fer molt, Cris. Tenir els sonets traduïts al costat en castellà modern va ser molt útil. Un regal insuperable que m'ha entusiasmat. El dia que els vulguis llegir, m'ho dius i te'l baixo. Ahir estava rellegint "La Tempestad", l'última obra de teatre (que se sàpiga, perquè tot són suposicions) de Shakespeare arrel d'un llibre del Banville (Eclipse) que feia referència a la seva protagonista femenina i vaig tornar a flipar. Tots els misteris de la humanitat estan condensats en les obres d'aquest home. Jo tampoc em cansaré de repetir que Shakespeare és Déu! Gràcies per llegir i pel comentari, nena. Que sigui ja divendres...


message 21: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Shakespeare lives on in his words.

I was thinking the other day that almost every book I've read in the past while has had some echoes of Shakespeare, however faint. He lives on not only in his own words but in the words of others too - and this excellent tribute is further testimony of that, Dolors.


Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "Shakespeare lives on in his words.

I was thinking the other day that almost every book I've read in the past while has had some echoes of Shakespeare, however faint. He lives on not only in his ow..."


A very timely remark Fio... I was starting to have concerns about seeing Shakespeare's influence everywhere. Saw him written all over Banville and now Stendhal. Proof of his divine omnipresence! Thanks as always for reading.


message 23: by Cristina (new)

Cristina Dolors wrote: "Cristina wrote: "Una anàlisi fantàstica, nena! El to dels primers sonets a diferència dels darrers, la reflexió del principi sobre l'autor i sobre si l'obra és expressió de les seves experiències o..."

Osti, el Banville referint-se a un personatge femení de La Tempesta de Shakespeare? No he llegit La Tempesta ni el del Banville, interessant en qualsevol cas. A veure si recupero la lectura de Shakespeare. Com mola que t'hagin agradat els sonets!!!! Ja et diré quan vulgui llegir-los :)) De moment he d'acabar el del Rushdie i crec que després em posaré amb Nabokov (diu el Maurici que m'agradarà...ja veus que sondejo tothom...li vaig dir que si odiaria el H.H i saps què em va dir? que ell no és dolent, que és ella la dolenta en tot cas perquè el sedueix!!! I perquè diu que ella no és una nena ja, en fi...homes!!! L'hauré de llegir per treure'n l'entrellat. Que sigui ja divendres, sí: i anant tatxant dies!!!!!!!!!!! :D


message 24: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Dolors...I never have anything intelligent to say after I read your reviews....They are sooooo bloody gorgeous.


Dolors Cristina wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Cristina wrote: "Una anàlisi fantàstica, nena! El to dels primers sonets a diferència dels darrers, la reflexió del principi sobre l'autor i sobre si l'obra és expressió de les seves..."

Ohhh...aquesta cançó em porta records d'insti, quant de temps i que poc que hem canviat, jejejeje.
El Maurici té part de raó, com sempre aquí entra el component subjectiu de cada lector, i he de dir que el H.H. evoluciona com a personatge al llarg de la història. Estic segura que el Bigas Luna es va inspirar en Nabokov per rodar "Las edades de Lulú", amb això ja t'ho he dit tot, la perspectiva de tio però juga un paper transcendental en com s'entén la història. M'agradarà saber què penses del llibre...potser em faràs rellegir-lo i tot!


Dolors Jaidee wrote: "Dolors...I never have anything intelligent to say after I read your reviews....They are sooooo bloody gorgeous."

I adore your enthusiastic comments Jaidee, they never fail to draw a huge smile on my face and to send incredibly good vibrations my way. Thank your for being here, so glad you enjoyed the review! :)


reading is my hustle heading to Ashland, Oregon this Saturday for the Shakespeare festival- what a timely review! :)


message 28: by Carol (new)

Carol Ditto what Jaidee said, Dolors! Your reviews are absolutely amazing!


message 29: by Nicole~ (new)

Nicole~ Dolors, so accurate that Shakespeare was a master at "delving into the abysses of human psyche" , peeling away layer by layer with eloquence. Love this review and more eager to get to the Sonnets, which would be after Antony and Cleopatra...still on war themes.


message 30: by Jibran (new)

Jibran Dolors wrote: "Thanks for this magnificent post, Jibran! Your insightful remarks on “the break between the themes� � great expression by the way � are incredibly accurate. Not only the thematic content of the son..."

Oh thank you so much for the gift of Pessoa's sonnet and your illuminating commentary specially on poetic conceits and exaggeration. I have been thinking on these lines with respect to a book I read and it helps me see this phenomenon more clearly.
Thanks again :)


Agnieszka There's nothing like Dolor's review to warm ugly morning ...


message 32: by Dolors (last edited Jul 10, 2015 12:17AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Agnieszka wrote: "There's nothing like Dolor's review to warm ugly morning ..."

And there's nothing like an Agna's comment to start off my day on the right foot. Thanks for reading Agna...glad you also enjoyed the Bard's sonnets! :)


Dolors Elizabeth wrote: "heading to Ashland, Oregon this Saturday for the Shakespeare festival- what a timely review! :)"

Oh really? I am green with envy Elizabeth... do you want to trade the festival for a weekend on the beach, we could swap places? ;P
I am looking forward to an adaptation of "Hamlet" in the National Theater in Barcelona for next season, it just seems so far away! Enjoy your weekend and report back to us when you can! :) And thanks for reading.


Dolors Carol wrote: "Ditto what Jaidee said, Dolors! Your reviews are absolutely amazing!"

Thanks so much Carol! I am so glad you like the reviews and truly grateful for your consistent validation and kindness, which I hold in high esteem.


message 35: by Dolors (last edited Jul 10, 2015 12:18AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Nicole~ wrote: "Dolors, so accurate that Shakespeare was a master at "delving into the abysses of human psyche" , peeling away layer by layer with eloquence. Love this review and more eager to get to the Sonnets, ..."

I still have to plunge into his historical plays, but I mean to do so as the year advances. "Julius Caesar" is my next play. Glad you enjoyed my musings, Nicole. I had a bilingual edition, modern Spanish-Old English with a good explanatory introduction that was of much assistance to better grasp the sonnets. I will definitely be on the lookout for your insights when you get around to reading them! :)


message 36: by Dolors (last edited Jul 10, 2015 12:19AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Jibran wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Thanks for this magnificent post, Jibran! Your insightful remarks on “the break between the themes� � great expression by the way � are incredibly accurate. Not only the thematic con..."

Oh, I will be waiting for the result of that pondering with bated breath, Jibran... Hopefully a review might follow presently! :)


Lynne King Dolors, I'm just so, so pleased that you decided to read these wonderful sonnets!

I've been looking at them again myself and my... That's all one possibly say!


Dolors Lynne wrote: "Dolors, I'm just so, so pleased that you decided to read these wonderful sonnets!

I've been looking at them again myself and my... That's all one possibly say!"


This is a collection to read and re-read countless times through a lifetime only to discover new angles every time. Glad the review urged you to revisit the Bard's sonnets, Lynne!


message 39: by Samadrita (new)

Samadrita ...Allow me to reply with another question.
Does it really matter?


Nope. Not one bit. Especially when the Bard was a convention, a genre unto himself. How meticulously you detail the imagery, the thematic implications, the playfully done subversion of literary traditions and stereotypes of the time, and the inexpressible delight of savoring the essence of Shakespeare's verses! Thank you for taking me along your pleasurable exploration of these sonnets and motivating me to pick this one up soon. You never fail to move me with your eloquent evocation of anything you read, Dolors.


Lynne King How beautifully put Samadrita!


message 41: by Dolors (last edited Jul 10, 2015 12:22PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Samadrita wrote: "...Allow me to reply with another question.
Does it really matter?

Nope. Not one bit. Especially when the Bard was a convention, a genre unto himself. How meticulously you detail the imagery, the..."


Couldn't agree more with Lynne, Sama. Your comments is the personification of taste, intellect and perceptiveness. Indeed, Shakespeare's genius relays not only in the form (Shakespearean sonnet, right?) but mostly in the disruptive, even defiant, content of his verses, which lures the reader into a frame of mind that is dexterously flipped over with the last couplet. And as if by magic, despair turns into adoration, death into legacy, allure into menace, and both hell and heaven coexist in the skeptical universe that the poet creates with ambiguous meaning. Reading your comments and reviews provokes a similar effect on me Sama, and so the prospect of re-visiting the sonnets through the prism of your prose sounds like an irresistible treat to me. Thanks for your supportive words, I know time is scarce of late and so your presence is the most treasured of gifts!


message 42: by [deleted user] (last edited Jul 12, 2015 07:36AM) (new)

Hello, great reader and reviewer, Dolors. You have successfully done what I have failed to do. You have read (in short order) all of Shakespeare's sonnets and then you have written a masterful review that teases me with all that I had missed or failed to appreciate or articulate. Though I have loved his plays and re-read the major tragedies, Shakespeare's sonnets continue to intimidate me. I recall when I was 17, back in my last year of high school, Ms. McFarland, my literature professor, assigned me a Shakespearean sonnet upon which to write a 5-page essay. It was a fearful and agonizing experience-- from which I may not yet have recovered. :) I was so traumatized that, even now, I could cannot identify the problematic sonnet, but I spent a weekend in panic and fear that I could not complete my assignment. I even drove to the library of a nearby university to see if I could find commentary that would provoke an idea. I spent an entire Sunday flailing about. (I wish I could have read your review in 1983.) Then, I read some critical essays and gained a foothold on a different sonnet. The following Monday, I went to my teacher and she allowed me to change sonnets. Trauma has erased the identity of original and successor sonnets, but you entice me back into this mysterious and scary realm. Dolors, your perceptive analysis is persuasive proof that Shakespeare's works might be profitably delayed until maturity in life. The catastrophe of Love must pound our hearts into submission first. My reading of Shakespeare's plays warns me that Shakespeare was a universal and androgynous writer, and your analysis of the sonnets are like a secret map that hints at the atomic structure of what it means to be human and a reader. Dolors, your gorgeous and perceptive review convinces me that Art, Magic, and Divinity await if I brave the unknown and face my previous failures.


message 43: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo The mystical sweetness that hides behind his lines,
Matches the music and emotion her prose combines.
Look at the sky of melody and colors.
Words are magic, her name is Dolors.

Yeah... tough name to rhyme for my little mind :P But I'm an teetotaler getting drunk with poetry now.
This is a gem of a review. A wave of evocative and engaging language just hit me and left me floating in the air, impressed. For I have witnessed that inspiring transformation. When art becomes magic.
A truly remarkable work about one of the most brilliant minds that ever existed. I need to revisit this author. I really do.


Dolors Steve wrote: "Hello, great reader and reviewer, Dolors. You have successfully done what I have failed to do. You have read (in short order) all of Shakespeare's sonnets and then you have written a masterful revi..."

Hello Steve. I truly adored your comment, which is a perfect example of how our fears, most of the time irrational, most of the time even unfounded, prevent us from doing getting the best of ourselves and of those who surround us. I wish you could have remembered the tricky sonnet because, even now, I bet I would have been incapable of writing no more than two sentences without the help of the Spanish translation that my edition included. As per usual, your words contain wisdom and invite me to reflect. That Shakespeare found the route to connect with the 17 year-old-Steve is revealing about the versatility of language and the incredibly wide scope of his poetry. It also says a lot about your spirit, because many years after that moment of panic, you have found joy in the act of reading any of The Bard’s works and have made of literature one of the founding pillars of your life. And so that memory is also proof of your willpower to overcome fear. It’s fascinating to see the long journey we make through life and how much we evolve as readers and as human beings. And last but not least, it also shows the kind of reader and writer that you are. Empathic, discerning and generous. I haven’t the slightest shadow of a doubt that were you to re-visit the Bard’s sonnets, you would find wonders in his playful stanzas that would send me straight to paradise, even in his most despairing of poems. “Failure� is a word that can’t be used in relation to your literary abilities Steve, as in other aspects of your life. Perseverance, self-demand and boundless kindness sound more accurate to me. I won’t even try to mutter my appreciation for this post, which humbles and honors and makes me feel fortunate to have you as my friend. Words, most of the time, fail me� life is ironic, isn’t it? You know that…and so did Shakespeare! ;)


Dolors Florencia wrote: "The mystical sweetness that hides behind his lines,
Matches the music and emotion her prose combines.
Look at the sky of melody and colors.
Words are magic, her name is Dolors.

Yeah... tough name ..."


Florencia, the poetess! This is the first poem that was dedicated to me, to the sound of prose! WOW! How more fortunate can one get in life? Sobriety is overrated, particularly when one can get intoxicated with words…and with the infinite kindness of the best friends. And so I am drunk with happiness to hear from you and for your display of wit, your playful undertone, which matches the Bard’s so well, and your invaluable presence in the page. I know time is scarce at your end and so I am even more grateful for this comment that sends me off into this Sunday with a smile brighter than the shinning sun that blinds those who dare to look up at the clear skies! :)


message 46: by Shaikh (new) - added it

Shaikh Mustak fantastic review .


Dolors Shaikh wrote: "fantastic review ."

Thanks!


Emma Louise Sivertson Your words, powerful, and straight to the heart, 💜💜💜


Dolors Thanks so much Emma! I could use the precisely same words about your comment :))


back to top