Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Wagatwe Wanjuki's Reviews > Lucky

Lucky by Alice Sebold
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2791488
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: sexual-violence

** spoiler alert ** It was...okay. I think the reason why this memoir got so much acclaim and so much attention because she was the "perfect victim" - white virgin, raped by a stranger- a BLACK stranger, no less. Once I realized this, I knew I was going to read through this with resentment. I knew that most survivors, like myself, would not be able to relate to her experience. Everything fell into place for her: she got the conviction, she went to the hospital, she was complimented on her testimony. There was nothing groundbreaking about it. This is the scenario that most people want you to think is the norm, but this rarely happens. I was disappointed after reading all the rave reviews to read this sorta interesting memoir that brought nothing new to the table when a survivor speaks out.

I am most pissed off, however, at those weird 5 lines or so that dealt with her racism after being raped. Her friend's black friend hugs her like some apology on the behalf all black men?? Really? It's like she brings up how she (and her father) are racist, but hey it's okay it's because of the rape!! I mean, come ON, is it any more excusable for her to center on that person's race because her rapist happened to be a part of a racial minority? I think it was in very poor taste to bring up something that loaded without addressing it properly. The "so many black men are raping our white virgins" myth is rampant and I'm annoyed that this was perpetuated with the lack of proper analysis or clarification.

Whatever. I didn't really like her or her family. Never reading again.
31 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Lucky.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 1, 2011 – Shelved
January 1, 2011 – Shelved as: sexual-violence

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sammie (new)

Sammie Zenoz I agree.


message 2: by Ay (new)

Ay Es Well, it turns out that the supposed "rapist" was wrongfully sentenced to jail for a crime he didnt commit. 16 years of his life taken away by our flawed justice system, corrupt police, and a white woman whos paranoid at black people. Good job!


Amara M. Ay wrote: "Well, it turns out that the supposed "rapist" was wrongfully sentenced to jail for a crime he didnt commit. 16 years of his life taken away by our flawed justice system, corrupt police, and a white..."

I am so furious.


¸é³Ü²¹»å³óá²Ô McElroy He didn't even match the description she gave for the police sketch —except for his skin colour! She picked the wrong guy (the dude who stood next to Anthony) in the police line-up —who *also* looked nothing like the man she helped to wrongfully convict, except for skin colour! Like, goddamn, that whole "memoir" is more an unwitting exposé of misconduct and the systemic racism of the Syracuse justice system, and Sebold's own unexamined personal racism, than it is anything else.


back to top