ŷ

Scott's Reviews > The Road

The Road by Cormac McCarthy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
921134
's review

it was amazing

I really feel compelled to write up a review of McCarthy's The Road as this book really worked for me (for those of you who haven't read it, there are no real spoilers below, only random quotes and thematic commentary). I read it last night in one sitting. Hours of almost nonstop reading. I found it to be an excellent book on so many levels that I am at a loss as to where to begin. It was at once gripping, terrifying, utterly heart-wrenching, and completely beautiful. I have read most of McCarthy's other books and am already a big fan, but this one is different, perhaps his best in terms of lean, masterful prose, plot presentation, and flat-out brilliant storytelling.

Take this passage for example: "The blackness he woke to on those nights was sightless and impenetrable. A blackness to hurt your ears with listening. Often he had to get up. No sound but the wind in the bare blackened trees. He rose and stood tottering in that cold autistic dark with his arms outheld for balance while the vestibular calculations in his skull cranked out their reckonings. An old chronicle." Happy times! The word choice and imagery is classic McCarthy yet is leaner and more honed, tighter and in turn more intense. The whole book follows this pattern. No word, not a single one, is extraneous. This is perhaps my favorite single sentence in the book: "By day the banished sun circles the earth like a grieving mother with a lamp." I just love that.

Clearly this book struck a chord with me due to the two protagonists and their predicament, a father and his young son struggling in a post-apocalyptic world. To say I could identify with their interactions would be a huge understatement. McCarthy absolutely nails their dialog, making me marvel at how well he has mastered presenting on a page the way we communicate (it isn't exactly how we talk, of course, it just seems that way. Through some sort of magic, he writes dialog that comes across more realistically than actual dialog. Witchcraft for sure.). The young son was especially well done and was most certainly the most complicated character in the book. McCarthy presents him as a sort of supernatural being (Christ figure?), of only the best sort, full of goodness, a thing not of the world in which he finds himself. He is effortlessly drawn down the path of the righteous throughout the book, as if he is God's right hand man. The reward appears, at least superficially, to be key moments of luck.

It almost wouldn't work from a literary standpoint if it didn't serve so well as a vehicle to reinforce the central theme of the book: the undeniable power of love over all else. The theme of love, mostly presented through the bond of the father and son, is so well done as to evoke strong emotions, even now, as I consider how to present its keen development throughout the novel. To be so desperate, in every way and at all times, and yet to survive and at times thrive, to persevere through terrible events of unbelievable horror (think Steven King's The Stand on steroids) would strike feelings of great, sad compassion in even the most tempered soul. But it is much more than that of course. Consider this passage, a speaking passage from father to son, spoken during one of the most tense and horrifying scenes in the book: "You wanted to know what the bad guys looked like. Now you know. It may happen again. My job is to take care of you. I was appointed to do that by God. I will kill anyone who touches you. Do you understand?" In this one passage, McCarthy shows the great contradiction in this theme of love, the idea that violence and beauty can spring fourth from the same well, can come from the same fountainhead. Interestingly, the father often resorts to violence in his role as a servant of love (he sees it as his duty, in a religious sense, as stated in the quote). Yet the boy never does and appears better for it, in so many ways, even in that terrible place. He is the embodiment of pure goodness, and sets up the other, better side of love, the side that is unsullied by the world, that never resorts to baseness and violence, that finds beauty in even to most unlikely of places. Like seeing a picture better when you hold it up to the light, the contrasts between these two sides is masterfully provided, page after page, in only the most well written and considered prose.

The often repeated promethean phrase "carrying the fire," agreed upon by the two protagonists as pretty much the whole point of their continuing, embodies this central theme. The boy is carrying the fire for us all, and is perhaps the most important survivor in that shattered world, bearing the torch of love for humanity to share when it is again ready. Not to belabor the point, but the way McCarthy handles this, all the way until the end, is nothing short of genius. Can you tell I liked the book yet? I am amazed that I missed this book for so long, me being a huge McCarthy fan and placing him squarely at the top of the "big four" (with DeLillo, Roth, and Pynchon). The book is so "it's own" that as soon as I felt myself feeling an influence (for example, I swore I smelled Hemmingway's Old Man and the Sea in terms of prose/theme, and the more terrifyingly cruel parts at times rang so much like Kosinski's The Painted Bird ), McCarthy would insert the perfect McCarthyism, solidly planting the flag (so to speak) of a phrase or sentence into the passage to claim it forever for himself, like a prosaic explorer figuratively pushing out into the unknown through deft assemblages of words and phases impossible to all but him (ok, that metaphor was way too much�.time to wrap it up). Of course I have more to say but am beginning to risk (actually have already thoroughly risked) repeating myself and sounding like some deranged, McCarthy stalker-type. Check this one out. It is superior literature.
1179 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Road.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
February 19, 2008 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mary (new)

Mary E Scott loved your review! Our book group just finnished the Road last week and it was our best book talk ever in the 8 years I've been attending . We have 4 teachers and they all hated the fact there was no punctuation. Plus some of them flat out hated it! But I loved it and I was the one who asked the book be read for our group. This was way before it became an Oprah pick. I seem to be ahead of her on that! One of our teachers is 92 and she was so worked up that I was worried for her! But I loved what you wrote and since I work at the library I have to ask do you work at a library also? Mary


message 2: by Jon (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jon I just finished The Road and like you, loved it. I haven't read any other McCarthy but I sense myself headed for a Cormac bender. Blood Meridian is next.
I'm looking forward to the movie being made of The Road but only as a curiosity, nothing could touch the way the book played out in my imagination.
Jon


message 3: by KFed (new) - added it

KFed I can't stop thinking about this book.

I finished it last night and now am walking around like a zombie, completely unsure of what to do with my life. I try to pick up and start other books and I can't, because I'm still enmeshed in McCarthy's world.


message 4: by Nimble (last edited Jul 21, 2009 12:57PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nimble Knitter Great review! You hit all the right points. This is one of those books that I'll carry with me for the rest of my life.

I listened to the audio version (Audible.com) and it was very well done. However, I missed the fact that it was written in such a sparse style until I was discussing it with a friend who had read the book.

I feel that I need to read the print version now.


Kathryn Awesome Review! You put together all that I wanted to say but couldn't explain.


William Keats I was going to recommend the book, but I think I’ll recommend your write up..

Great review to a benchmark in writing and in a hidden way, a salute to life itself.



Katie Lowry KFed wrote: "I can't stop thinking about this book.

I finished it last night and now am walking around like a zombie, completely unsure of what to do with my life. I try to pick up and start other books and I ..."


I finished it ten minutes ago and am still crying and had to come here to read what others had to say so that I could more easily figure out what's in my brain. You said exactly what I'm feeling. I can't figure out what to do with my life. Thank God I'm off tomorrow, I'm a mess lol


message 8: by KFed (new) - added it

KFed Poor thing!

I don't even remember writing that, but I can say with authority that I was eventually able to read other things, mostly more cheerful things, and move out of the dusk of McCarthy's world. Stay strong!


Katie Lowry KFed wrote: "Poor thing!

I don't even remember writing that, but I can say with authority that I was eventually able to read other things, mostly more cheerful things, and move out of the dusk of McCarthy's wo..."


I think I need to read some Gabriel Garcia Marquez or something. Something where only impossibly old people die, or people so in love that they don't care. Geez oh man, I'm exhausted!


message 10: by Dave (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dave Well-said Sir. I'm about 30% done with my third reading of this one. Love this man's mastery of the English (and ocassionally Spanish!) language.


message 11: by Ryan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ryan Emmert Great great review. Clearly a very vivid novel, but also full of beauty. Never a lack of excitement either. Just like the characters in the novel, we are on the lookout for what lies ahead.


message 12: by Lorrie (new) - added it

Lorrie Well, I can say with certainty that this book will stay with me. McCarthy writes with a richness and depth that eludes many writers. His descriptions leave no doubt as to the desolation of the land and waning strength and drive of the main characters. I really was waiting for them to find the "good guys" in one of the houses that they came upon, the absence of any other goodness or love along the way is rather disturbing. My son believes the ending was good - I am left wanting.. This is a well written book, but I can't really say that I loved it. Perhaps the mark of a good writer is simply that a story stays with the reader?


Missy I didn't read your whole review, but you summed it up VERY well for me in the first paragraph. I've never read the authors work before, but this! THIS!!!


Esther One of the best reviews I've read. You captured the essence of the book - bravo! I loved it.


Sarah Excellent review of a work of art!


Cindy Lee loved this book so much so glad to read these reviews


Jessaka I loved that same quote about the sun being a grieving mother.


Linda Holding Great review Scott! Just finished reading it today. It's the first book Cormac book I've read & it's unforgettable, simultaneously harrowing yet beautiful.


Linda Holding Great review Scott! Just finished reading it today. It's the first book Cormac book I've read & it's unforgettable, simultaneously harrowing yet beautiful.


message 20: by Gary (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gary I read this wonderful book in just over a day and really didn't want it to end. It has been a long time since I've found a story so captivating. This work by McCarthy a foreboding I think.


message 21: by Gary (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gary I read this wonderful book in just over a day and really didn't want it to end. It has been a long time since I've found a story so captivating. This work by McCarthy a foreboding I think.


A.Witt I was thinking of writing a review, but you covered all of the best points I would wish to convey about this novel.


message 23: by Liam (new) - rated it 4 stars

Liam Great review. I read this book probably over 2 years ago now (during my post apocalyptic stage) and found it utterly heart wrenching. Every now and then it'll pop into my head and I'll have a little 5 minutes to myself. He's a fantastic author.


Nilesh Bahir Very good review . I felt reading your review was like reading the last page in the book itself :)


Ravia what an absolutely perfect review. It feels as if you have written what was going through my mind after reading The Road and now I am confused as how to word my review of this book as it will look as if I have copied you. :-). The passages and dialogues from the book, copied above, are exactly the ones which made the deepest impression in my mind.


midnightreadingg Very good review! I love how you interpret it


message 27: by Mala (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mala Naidoo Brilliant review that has compelled me to sit up reading it tonight. Thank you for an inspirational review.


message 28: by Ida (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ida Came to write a review of this book myself, without knowing where to begin. But you said it all for me. Thank you.


message 29: by Carl (new) - rated it 3 stars

Carl Very good review, brought back some of the emotions I felt when reading it a year ago.


Kristine  Henshaw Great review! I'm new to ŷ and am looking at reviews of books I loved. This was such a painful!y beautiful book. I have lately been hearing of the large percentage of Americans who think we should mix it up with North Korea. Wish they would read "The Road."


Robert Zimmer No character development or reasonable plot? I modern book needs these things.


Susan Awesome review. I read the book because my high school son needed it for school. I was curious about what the teacher was having them read. I was pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed reading this. My son is encouraging me to see the movie too. I'll be watching on Netflix comparing the two.


message 33: by A.J. (new) - rated it 4 stars

A.J. Saktiana absolutely the perfect review. you covered all the best point about this magnificent work :)


Jodie Stunning review. You’ve said it all and done it justice!


message 35: by F.D. (new) - rated it 5 stars

F.D. Gross One of my favorite books. PERIOD.


Ollie Agreed


Jackie Jameson Just finished the book and feeling like someone punched me in the stomach. Absolutely brilliant novel.


Lisa Longoria-Cusick Beautifully written review. I am obsessed with this book. I will be following you just for the books you read and the reviews to follow.


message 39: by Kath (new)

Kath Wilkinson Your review absolutely nailed it! I read this incredible work a few months ago, and unlike so many works it has remained printed (seared?) on my memory. It depressed and uplifted me in equal measure. Somehow, despite the bleak devastation there is a gleam of hope - the boy. There is still love and compassion and courage in the father/son relationship. Is this what the world is facing? Superb writing, evenly paced and impeccably sustained.


message 40: by Deb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deb I am with Scott. Read half in a few hours. I'm not good at reviews. I tried to explain to my daughter why she should read a book with such a grim setting, and was not very successful. Scott nailed it.


Birdbath Birdbath 'cold autistic dark," I've been trying to figure out what he means by that. Anyone?


message 42: by ryal (new) - added it

ryal menot I could have read more if you deigned to keep writing. Absolutely elegant and I’m putting this one on the top of my next read list.
Loved the quotes and what you said about being influenced. Going to check it out and the other authors you mentioned. Thanks!


Rachel Moore Your review encouraged me that this book wouldn't be too depressing to read. Like you, I finished in one night. Wow! Thanks for the review. It was so so good.


Susan Houpt Scott,
Your review is beautiful! Thanks for your love of writing and telling us about your joy!


message 45: by Ivan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ivan believe this review perfectly sums up this novel beautifully. How excellent McCarthy's writing is, from the dialogue between The Man and The Boy, too how they are being depicted throughout the novel. I love how you highlight the importance of the "carrying of the fire" phrase being repeated, really emphasizing how important it is to the overall them of the story. The Road really is an excellent book and I believe this review does it justice.


message 46: by S.B. (new) - rated it 2 stars

S.B. Harrison Can you please explain what he means by “autistic� there? It makes absolutely no sense, does not decor what the word means in any way, and is very offensive. Plus, what exactly is so special about that paragraph? It’s boring and pointless, like the rest of the book. But seriously, why is your take on the autistic thing?


message 47: by Mary (new)

Mary Toelke A great read! Finished it in a little over a day. Beware America. This is what we may become if we don’t take care of this earth and buckle down on wrong-doers.


Brian Kitson I love this book so much and the negative reviews I’ve read on here stung a little. Thank you for writing this review.


message 49: by Maandeeq (new) - added it

Maandeeq I made this everybody.


Michael Simsa To each their own, but it’s funny to me that the first quote you listed is a big reason why I dislike this book. What does “…while the vestibular calculations in his skull cranked out their reckonings. An old chronicle.� even mean? And why say that when you can say “he waited a moment until he regained his sense of balance�?


back to top