欧宝娱乐

Turhan Sarwar's Reviews > Midnight's Children

Midnight's Children by Salman Rushdie
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
114875
's review

it was amazing

Midnight's Children is not at all a fast read; it actually walks the line of being unpleasantly the opposite. The prose is dense and initially frustrating in a way that seems almost deliberate, with repeated instances of the narrator rambling ahead to a point that he feels is important--but then, before revealing anything of importance, deciding that things ought to come in their proper order. This use of digressions (or, better put, quarter-digressions) can either be attributed to a charmingly distractable narrator or a vehicle for (perhaps cheaply) tantalizing the reader... or both.

I'll admit that at first I didn't appreciate being so persistently manipulated. Many times in the first few chapters I found myself closing the book in anger, thinking to myself "If the story is worth it, this tactic is utterly unnecessary."

The tactic, it turns out, is unnecessary. The book--the story--is stunning. It's stunning enough that the frustrating aspects of the telling are forgivable and actually retrospectively satisfying (which I suspect is what the author wanted). While the fractional digressions, on the one hand, can have you groping around for a lighter--they, on the other hand, work to accustom you to the novel's epically meandering pace. Also, they effectively allow you to feel a certain urgency near the end of the book, as the narrator "runs out of time."

The imagery is lush; the characters are curiously, magically lopsided; the language is complicated and beautiful; the chapters are nicely portioned despite the initial plodding pace; the narrative is deliberately allegorical, which perhaps suggests an enhanced enjoyment of the work after studying a bit of Indian history. Elements of the story's frame (the narrator writing in a pickle factory with sweet Padma reading along) are particularly amusing, and the chapter entitled "In the Sundarbans" is nothing short of breathtaking.

The book will go slow in the beginning; the book means to; give it patience--it's worth it, I think.
854 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Midnight's Children.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

June 4, 2007 – Shelved
Started Reading
June 10, 2008 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-42 of 42 (42 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Mandke "In the Sundarbans" was my favorite chapter, it absolutely makes up for the frustrations of getting into the book in the beginning.


message 2: by Ally (new)

Ally The brand new group - Bright Young Things - is nominating books to read in January & Midnight's Children is among them. Its the perfect place to discuss your favourite books and authors from the early 20th Century, why not take a look...

http://www.goodreads.com/group/invite...


K.D. Absolutely Nice review, Turhan! I also felt the the digressions are necessary. Rushdie's playful use of words is brilliant.


message 4: by Aaditya (new)

Aaditya Mandalemula I think you can try writing Book Reviews for some News paper. This is a superb review. Very thorough and very insightful. And saying the words of deBono - You used the Blue hat superbly well.


Anna Thanks, I'm still at the beginning and I came out here trying to figure out if this story was "worth it". Thanks to yoir review I'm going to keep reading!


Tanaya Thanks for this insightful review,now I know that I should carry on undeterred.I am at the beginning of the book and the tedium of the first few pages made me come here to see what others think about it.


message 7: by Mosca (new) - added it

Mosca Thank you, I've just started this book; and you are right this is initially frustrating.

I needed an articulate voice, such as your's, to motivate me further.


Bernadette Puleo You articulated some of my thoughts regarding the writing of this unique story in a way that I couldn't myself. Thanks.


Linda I had just given up in frustration halfway through but came here to read what others thought. i will read another book and come back to this one after reading the comments. I still feel meanly manipulated by the author though.


Kumar Just a side note: remove the "I think" at the end for a stronger emphasis


Kelly Moriarity Absolutely perfect review...and although I disagree with you o. the book being "worth it" (I was still thoroughly annoyed when I closed it, and found the ending deeply unsatisfying), you are still spot on with your disection of the writing! Lovely review.
Also, I 100% loved the chapter "In the Sundarbans"...I wish every section was as intense and flowed as nicely!)


Jmegan "Retrospectively satisfying" - that's exactly how I felt, but couldn't articulate it. Thanks for sharing this review!


Sister Boom Having just finished it and finding the whole experience unnecessary, I just wish I'd reached for that lighter.


message 14: by Meghana (new) - added it

Meghana Rajeshwar Excellent review!


Herrholz Paul I echo your thoughts here. Funnily, my reading of this book coincides with distractions in my personal life which is drawing out the reading experience even more! Bizarre!!


message 16: by Avani (new) - added it

Avani I have recently started the book and first few chapters made me wonder whether the hard way was worthy. Thanks to your review I came to know many people have undergone same doubts. I will now continue with the book.


message 17: by Theresa (last edited Jun 23, 2019 12:36PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Theresa Excellent review. But disagree that "The book--the story--is stunning. It's stunning enough that the frustrating aspects of the telling are forgivable and actually retrospectively satisfying (which I suspect is what the author wanted). " It was a 3 star read for me. Perhaps, what diminished this story for me, is that since it was written many others have related aspects of this story, so it no longer seems novel in 2018 and deserving of all the attention it has received.


Chloe Wajs Couldn鈥檛 write a better review


Rebecca I agree! Such an amazing story and I actually think the way it is written really adds to it (as difficult as it is as first), seeing as it's Saleem's diary and he is getting caught up in the story! It's got the fragmented quality of the human mind! It kept me reading and reading and reading!! Absolutely loved it.


message 20: by Erin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Erin Bennett "it actually walks the line of being unpleasantly the opposite" I could not agree with you more! But that makes it all the more lovable in my opinion.


message 21: by B (new) - rated it 3 stars

B Strangely enough, I felt that the story was much more interesting in the first half than in the second. Maybe it was because I was getting tired with the style but the story and the scenes themselves seemed to lack the force, creativity and humour of the early parts.


Namrata I agree with this comment 100%.


Laura Thank you for putting this into words.


Selena well said! I totally agree!


message 25: by Kate (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kate Fitzgerald Great review. By about Page 77, unable to read more than 13 pages an hour, I stopped reading, so you absolutely captured the way I felt! It sounds like it's worth it to keep going, but I had so many other books to read, I couldn't do it. :)


message 26: by Shirish (new) - added it

Shirish Kirtiwar please explain: when Salim Sinai was actually exchanged by the Hospital Nurse, how did he get the olfactory super-power? He defined his Grand father as his own, when his biological grandfather is actually not in the picture. and the Original Grandson have different superpower but not the same as the grandfather mentioned.


Sourabh Bansal I dont think the ramblings were unnecessary, the ramblings created the magical effect of listening to the old man who is narrating the story. It added to the genius of this novel


Kathleen Suess I agree, though I almost gave up several times throughout the book. It is an extremely dense read, and one you constantly wonder about while reading. Yet the imagery, the unfolding of developments and the ability to weave nonsensical humor into incredible moments of pain and pathos, in nothing short of brilliant.


message 29: by Donny (new) - added it

Donny Stiling


Vonia Great review. Reading this right now. I was questioning giving up but you have encouraged me to continue.


Molina The Sundarbans chapter truly blew my mind. I have never ever read anything that has ever come close to what Rushdie did in that chapter. Amazing. I will definitely re-read that passage time and time again.


message 32: by Alexandra (new) - added it

Alexandra Chase This review perfectly captured everything I felt about this book. Thank you.


message 33: by Carolyn (new)

Carolyn Polley-Peters Thank you for this review because I am struggling. I am only at the start and I will persevere


message 34: by Fedeffi (new) - added it

Fedeffi Just finished the book, I was鈥檛 able to rate it until I found this review. Thank you so much: now I understand what it really annoyed me. The repetition and the digressions that, at the end, weren鈥檛 necessary. Otherwise I really appreciated how the big events of Salim鈥檚 life are depicted in an oniric and magic way, more often a nightmare


message 35: by Jo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jo I鈥檝e just reread and listened to this as part of the jubilee list. Last read for a degree in the 80s when it was seminal. Still just as demanding and irritating at times but magnificent. I don鈥檛 think it鈥檚 a group book more seminar level. Hopefully the jubilee list will get more people reading it


message 36: by Tweetybird (new) - added it

Tweetybird I鈥檓 not usually a reader of 鈥渄ense鈥� writing, and am quite unfamiliar with Indian history (I have no idea who/what is [a] 鈥渟weet Padma鈥�. Would this novel be easier to get through as an audiobook?


message 37: by Elise (new) - added it

Elise Spekschoor I haven't read the book yet, and I probably would've put it away very quickly after a few chapters hadn't I read this comment. Thanks for the heads up.


message 38: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam Johnson I agree completely. This book is 100% worth the work required near the beginning. Super rewarding read.


message 39: by Tracy (new) - added it

Tracy Telle Great review. Since I was disappointed in the meandering of another of his books, I was debating about reading another. But his writing is beautiful, so I will be sure to read this one soon. Thank you for your thoughts


message 40: by Suzanne (new) - added it

Suzanne Est茅vez Thanks, I needed this. I鈥檓 only 56 pages in and feel like giving up. After reading your post I will persevere!


message 41: by Ken (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ken Will Perfectly written review and I completely agree.


础苍诲谤茅 It appears that just when I finished the chapter "In the Sundarbans" I read this review. Coincidence or Magic? Or both?


back to top