欧宝娱乐

Brooke's Reviews > Ysabel

Ysabel by Guy Gavriel Kay
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
126262
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2007, fantasy, ya

A bit of warning: Guy Gavriel Kay is only my most favorite author in the entire world. Given how many different authors I admire and follow, that's a pretty big honor for me to bestow. His novels evoke a certain range of emotions that no other author has ever been able to achieve, and without a doubt makes it impossible for me to honestly critique any of his books' weaknesses. Ysabel is no different, and if you take one thing from this review, it's that you should read it. Now.

Kay has mostly written historical fantasy books; he chooses a historical conflict or time period and then weaves a fantasy novel out of his lengthy research. Sometimes the 'fantasy' tag indicates the use of mystical elements, and other times it simply allows him to twist fact into fiction without being admonished for being historically inaccurate. Ysabel is a slight departure from this; the historical elements smash head-first into modern-day France when 15-year-old Ned stumbles upon a 2,500-year-old love triangle.

Ysabel is written very informally and much more simply compared to Kay's previous novels. This is due to the main character being a teenage boy, as well as the fact that it takes place in a modern setting and has a far less epic scope than his other books. I had some problems with the dialogue feeling a little forced and insincere in a few places (most notably when large groups of characters were talking with each other), but for the most part, it still retains the elegance of Kay's voice. The only word I can summon to describe his prose is "beautiful," as trite as that might be.

One of the touches that Kay adds to his novels are the subtle "grace notes" that nod to his past works and suggest that his stories are all part of a shared history of one world. I'd been wondering how he was going to do that in Ysabel, since it clearly takes place in our world, not a world where there are two moons in the sky. To my surprise, Ysabel is nearly a coda to one of his earlier books. As I was reading, I started musing to myself, "Why is Kay re-using character names? This is only his tenth book, he has plenty of names to pick from." At one point, the realization struck me rather forcefully that the name was not being reused, and was in fact referring to the same character. Ysabel is still a fully stand-alone novel, and can be understood and appreciated without reading any of Kay's other works, but knowing the history of the reused characters makes it even deeper.

For those who haven't read Kay's other novels, this untold back story simply folds into another of the author's signature touches: the hints that there is far more to the world than the current story can show. It's as if Kay is saying, "There are many, many stories in this world, and they often collide with each other, but this is the one I'm telling right now." This is illustrated in Ysabel, particularly when the members of the love triangle insist repeatedly, "This is only about the three of us," while everyone else replies, "No, it's not." There are many things in Ysabel that are left untold and unexplained, but it's done purposely and leaves the reader imagining those stories as he or she feels they might be told.

I always feel depressed when I reach the end of a brand new Kay book far too quickly and realize I have roughly a three-year wait until the next one. At the same time, I'm thankful that he doesn't crank them out at the high frequency that publishers often demand when the author is a mainstream hit who guarantees massive sales. I highly, highly recommend any of his books, although Ysabel might be the best starting point for a Kay newbie, since its prose is the least dense out of all of them.
14 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Ysabel.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Started Reading
February 1, 2007 – Finished Reading
June 12, 2007 – Shelved
December 4, 2007 – Shelved as: 2007
December 7, 2008 – Shelved as: fantasy
January 14, 2017 – Shelved as: ya

Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Liza in general, I don't agree with people who say they love Kay and hate this book. It is a wonderful YA book and I loved it. It is less complex than his earlier work but it is also less dark. I can appreciate the brilliance of his other work (except Arbonne which is returned to the library without finiahing.) It is true there is a lot about familiar interactions and no death by wheel (the whole family down to the youngest - tigana) not other evidence of the incredible ugliness of war. Posibly it is why I didn't get through Thones n-logy (Martin) - too bleak. This is not bleak and makes a wonderful YA contibution. I welcome what I get from this writer and wish for more. I have order Finovar which somehow I missed (I think I thought it was part of Arbonne which I disliked).


Steve R Loved your point in the second last paragraph about 'many stories in this world, and they often collide with each other, but this is the one I'm telling now.' It beautifully captured the interplay between Ned and his family/friends and the triangle of Ysabel, Phelan and Cadell! I too am a big Kay fan, and am currently working my way through a re-read of all his works.


back to top