Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

A solid 3.5.

I didn't really understand the point of this book until I read the foreword (and, as an aside, I'm glad I waited because, as is usually the case with forewords, it's replete with spoilers. Why not make it an afterword?) which is written by Morrison.
A book with a name as its title is usually indicative of a character-driven narrative and this is no exception. The problem is that all of these characters are absolutely batshit.
(view spoiler)[
Two children playfully swing a third child into a body of water and when they see he doesn't surface don't immediately jump in after him?! The idea that both of these girls had absolutely zero empathy felt so unrealistic.
I also don't buy that later, when Sula sleeps with Jude, that she is totally shocked at Nel seeing this as betrayal. I don't care how free you perception of love is, if you're actively hurting someone because it's their ideal and not yours, you're an asshole. And she's meant to be somewhat perceptive, intelligent even, so how can she not even fathom that this would destroy their friendship.

And about that lack of emotional intelligence. We're meant to believe that because she once heard her mother say that she doesn't like her that Sula becomes a total sociopath?
(hide spoiler)]
I couldn't rationale the behaviour of any of them, apart from the occasional WWI veteran struggling with PTSD.
Another thing that bothered me is that this book should be called Bottom or Medallion but not Sula. Sula features very little in it. It's more a potrait of the town and its people than of one strange character.

That's not to say there aren't things to like about the book though. The writing has an excellent pace and each chapter has different tones and styles of narrative voice. For example, around two thirds of the way through the book Nel goes through a difficult experience and the narrative immediately switches from the third person to the first person. That choice forces the reader to feel her hurt and struggle. It's one of the most powerful passages in the book.

I have to admit too that after reading the Foreword I sympathised with the book a little more and what it was trying to accomplish.
Ultimately though, much of it is too incredible to enjoy.