欧宝娱乐

Max Ostrovsky's Reviews > Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West

Wicked by Gregory Maguire
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
151055
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: contemporary, fantasy, fiction, satire

From the first page, I couldn't put the book down. I loved it! And as my love for the book Wicked and the Wicked Witch of the West grew, my hatred for George Lucas grew in direct proportion. How could he have gotten it so wrong?
I never pretended to like the new trilogy. It could have been a new story. It could have really delved into the character of Darth Vader, or rather Anakin Skywalker and truly made him tragic.
Instead of trying to fool the audience into liking Anakin by hiring cute kids and bad actors, George Lucas could have created an interesting character. He could have told an actual story.
With Wicked, we get that.
Either a person has read the book or since we live in a culture of anti-reading, most likely has seen the movie. Regardless of which one, the Wicked Witch of the West is a pretty clear cut character.
She is evil. She is green. She is scary.
What Wicked does is take this evil, green and scary witch and turn her into a person we can like and love. And it doesn't do it in a cutesy way where we say to ourselves, "oh what a cute green baby."
She is born a freak. She was not only green, but she had teeth like a shark. And used them! Lost fingers, oh boy! And forget breast feeding!
She had a severe allergy to water.
Her upbringing wasn't too much better. She was outcast. She had to help raise and take care of her beautiful and crazily religious armless sister (who would eventually become the Wicked Witch of the East).
She was ostracized in school. Her roommate Galinda, who would eventually become Glinda, the good witch, could barely stand her.
And despite all that, we grow to like her. She's smart as a whip. She's funny and witty. She's sarcastic and actually quite fun. And she cares for all living creatures. Can you believe that? She even gets involved in a cause to help protect the capital A Animals (like the Lion, those that can talk), who are being rounded up, Nazi like, by the real bad guy of the story: The Wizard.
We see her take a lover and fall in love. We see her lose her lover.
The progress that leads to her becoming the Wicked Witch of the West is natural and logical. And even at the end, crazy as she became, we understand her and pity her, making her that much tragic.
What a treasure trove George Lucas could have used to truly show us a young Anakin Skywalker.
How about this (and I know I'm pilfering from Wicked a bit): What if Anakin Skywalker wasn't a cute kid? What if he was born disabled? What if to be mobile, he needed prosthetics to begin with? Oh sure, we'd still have that battle with Kenobi where he loses a whole lot more to become that scary guy in the black suit, but maybe he had to suffer his entire life being part machine. That'll make Kenobi's later line of "He's more machine now than man" even more poignant.
And maybe he's just a little angry about having mechanical parts? Maybe his first awareness of the force is through his anger. Of course, the beginning would be about how, on his own, through his own strength and integrity, he overcomes the anger and the dark, and chooses the light side of the force.
And he comes to grips with his deformity. And works on his charm and personality to such a degree that he wins a princess (or a queen, whatever).
He could even have a cause that he fights for. Anakin built C3PO, so why not take up for droid rights or some such? After all, he is part machine.
Why, oh why George, did you give us such crap?!
It could have been possible. And then we could have had a sci-fi examination and analysis of the origins of evil. We could have brought more depth and substance to a classic space opera.
221 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Wicked.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Started Reading
April 1, 2007 – Finished Reading
June 27, 2007 – Shelved
September 17, 2008 – Shelved as: contemporary
September 17, 2008 – Shelved as: fantasy
September 17, 2008 – Shelved as: fiction
April 12, 2010 – Shelved as: satire

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Carrie The George Lucas comment cracked me up. So true!


My work is never done My friend, I like the way you think! Only I dont agree with you on Anakin being deformed and such from the begining.You'll find that sometimes it is the Deformed people with the most love in theyre hearts and the Handsome seemingly perfect with the most Evil.Look at Lucifer, what made him Evil? His own Vanity from being the most handsome of the Angels.I think Anakin's Attractiveness is what made him as vain as he was to an extent,besides his overall Mastery of the Force where he was able to do things even Obi-Wan couldnt have done.Anyway, there is a Book I recomend you to read, it isnt the besrt book in the Universe, but I think James Luceno at least helped in fixing the problems you speak of with Anakin.He does something kind of similar with this book.Where Anakin after having been deformed in the Mustafar System was still having trouble staying Evil because of the Remanents of Anakin in him.The Book Dark Lord : The Rise of Darth Vader shows Anakin's slow but steady transition towards fully becoming Vader.Not to mention a special surprise Guest at the very end of the Book.I wont tell you that part because it will ruin it for you.It also interestingly enough shows his Rise in the Emperor's new World, in the begining people saw him as an arrogant neusance but then as he demonstrated his capability at being a great Leader even those who sought to be his Rivals in the Empire shut up and made way for Lord Vader.It also shows what his relationship with Emperor Palpatine is like.A Strange Mix of Master/Mentor and perhaps just a tint bit of Father in it.I strongly recomend it for you.Though I thoight it was too short and Luceno could have expanded it more and the Characters I wasnt too attracted to except for the Jedi Master Roan Shryne who is funny and cool, kind of General O'Niel from Stargate Smart Ass kind of person and the Padawan Olee Starstone.I kept imagining her looking like Lilee Sobieski but with Black hair (total babe)you should read it.


Jaime I would have preferred this to be a review about Wicked, but it seems like there are two reviews here. George Lucas? Try sticking to one point at a time.


Samantha Umm....one question: How are you combining Star Wars with Wicked? The story lines are completely different and everyone knows Star Wars beats almost anything hands down. George Lucas is a much better writer than Maguire. You can't compare Wicked to Star Wars. It's like comparing The Simpsons to Lord of The Rings. Wrong angle.


Topaz Goold love. great review. fantastic book- despite the endless criticism it seems to be attracting, and love the George Lucas commentary. :)


Robbie i dont care what everybody else thinks.. i liked the book.. loved it even..


E.jane I rated wicked two stars, but after reading this review, I might move it up to a three. Nice job! But I actually thought the beginning of the book was kind of boring.


message 8: by Watt (new)

Watt Defalk From the musical "You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown:"
The name of the book about which
This book report is about is
Peter Rabbit, which is about this... uh, rabbit
I found it very... I liked the part where... It reminded me of:
ROBIN HOOD! And the part where Little John jumps from the rock to the Sherrif of Nottingham's back,
And then Robin and everyone swings from the trees in a sudden surprise attack...
...Peter Rabbit was sort of that kind of thing, too."


Julie Great review, George Lucas should have read both Wicked and your review before making those atrocities! But I really disliked Wicked, mainly because


message 10: by Julie (new) - rated it 1 star

Julie Whoops! Let me finish that sentence! Mainly because I could not relate to or empathize with Elphaba. The closest I came to liking her was when she was at university and she had found a cause to fight for. After the disaster of her terrorist cell and the loss of her lover, she just became as uncaring and absurd as any of the other characters. She lost me. Then I could only read on out of curiosity to see how she dealt with Dorothy.


David Sarkies I just love how you connected Wicked with Star Wars. While I did not think the first trilogy was that bad (okay, now I think of it, it was), it certainly could have been done a lot better.


Aubrey I don't see how Wicked and Star Wars connect or why you chose to make the connection. Seems kind of strange. (I'm 150 pages in and bored. I'm giving it a few more pages but this book may end up being tossed as it is weird and hard to get into)


message 13: by [deleted user] (new)

I totally get the connection with wicked and star wars. I liked star wars much better until I read your analysis, and you are so right on. he could have done so much more with the character of anakin. hopefully JJ Abram's will do right by the last three.


message 14: by Iris (last edited Aug 11, 2014 06:51AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Iris This review was...interesting...You kind of meandered into different territory there a bit (Cough Star Wars Cough) but it all ultimately made sense, so no harm done. Great review.


message 15: by Christina (new)

Christina I'll admit that I am not a Trekkie follower. Jk you were talking Star Wars .
BUT, I do love the story of Wicked, I felt for Elphaba in that she was misunderstood. And in those crazy times that they lived in, it was hard to trust anyone.


message 16: by Christina (new)

Christina I'll admit that I am not a Trekkie follower. Jk you were talking Star Wars .
BUT, I do love the story of Wicked, I felt for Elphaba in that she was misunderstood. And in those crazy times that they lived in, it was hard to trust anyone.


message 17: by Zell (new)

Zell Hey, Good Day! You have written a great article. I am happy to drop by and gain more information's about this article.




message 18: by Yaelle (new) - added it

Yaelle Glenn It's wild that you made this comparison between the two defining entertainment series of my life - I have read 40 some SW books & they're ALL infinitely better than anything ever touched by Lucas's dumb butt.
I'm very, very obsessed.

At the same time, Oz has been major, major force haha in my life from the time I was around 8 ... long stories.
People who don't know should be aware that the musical Wicked is Excellent, definitely more palatable than the book.


message 19: by Molly (new) - added it

Molly Mortensen I was all set to donate this book to the library but your review convinced me to give it a chance. Also, the new Star Wars would've been SO much better if it was written your way!


message 20: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana | The Phoenix Flight I would not, in a million years, would've remembered to make a comparison between Wicked and Star Wars. That was brilliant! XD


message 21: by Rod (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rod Your comments about sta wars seem to be based on the movies, which aren't great. They aren't horrible, but not great. The star wars books do a much better job of the tale of Anikin and his loss of humanity and redemption by his son.


Jaimee kalinko i tots agree with u (not about the star wars thing.) but i loved the book to


back to top