Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Gerry's Reviews > Tao Te Ching

Tao Te Ching by Lao Tzu
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
149353
's review

it was amazing

I'm an unbeliever and have been since the first time I played hooky from Sunday services and the Eye in the Sky didn¡¯t say boo. So it may seem strange that I¡¯m reviewing the Tao Te Ching, the widely known and influential Taoist text, written by Lao-Tzu and poetically translated in this edition by Stephen Mitchell. For me, the Tao Te Ching is more folk wisdom than religious treatise and is more useful than a million sermons.

Where the Tao Te Ching parts company with religious attempts at morality such as the 10 Commandments is in its inclusiveness. Seven of the 10 Commandments don¡¯t mention God and are sound advice designed to facilitate peaceful community relations: respect your elders, don't kill, don't cheat on your spouse, don't steal, don't tell lies, and don't lust after another's spouse or his belongings. For me, the tragedy of the Great List is that the three that top it serve only to divide the world into believers and nonbelievers: regardless how closely you follow the last seven, if you don¡¯t believe in God you¡¯re not worth a fig. In doing so the first three create division where the last seven seek harmony. With Taoism, even if you don¡¯t believe in the Force-like nature of the Tao¡ªand in case there¡¯s any question, I don¡¯t¡ªyou can still consider yourself a Taoist.

Taoism seeks harmony by freeing the individual from the caustic effects of judgmental thinking, desire, and greed, and its fulcrum is the concept of ¡°non-action,¡± or literally ¡°doing not-doing.¡± Non-action, Mitchell writes in his introduction, is not the act of doing nothing but instead is the purest form of action: ¡°The game plays the game; the poem writes the poem; we can¡¯t tell the dancer from the dance.¡±

This slim book is both a quick read and a long study. Mitchell¡¯s lyrical rendering of the Tao Te Ching might read to some like silly hippie clich¨¦s, but there¡¯s more to it than that. Take chapter 9, a photocopy of which hung on my office corkboard for years:

Fill your cup to the brim and it will spill.
Keep sharpening your knife and it will blunt.
Chase after money and security and your heart will never unclench.
Care about people¡¯s approval and you will be their prisoner.

You can almost see the hacky sack and smell the patchouli. But there¡¯s a truth to it that, if grasped, will change the way you think.

As chapter 1 states: ¡°The tao that can be told is not the eternal Tao./The name that can be named is not the eternal Name.¡± Analogy, then, plays an important role in understanding the Tao Te Ching, and the reader has to do quite a bit of work¡ªthe long study part¡ªto fathom the book¡¯s richness. Take chapter 11 in its entirety, where non-action is discussed:

We join spokes together in a wheel, but it is the center hole that makes the wagon move.
We shape clay into a pot, but it is the emptiness inside that holds whatever we want.
We hammer wood for a house, but it is the inner space that makes it livable.
We work with being, but non-being is what we use.

There is more to the book than philosophical abstraction. In fact, common sense pervades the Tao Te Ching. Take these lines, which discuss the roots of crime: ¡°If you overvalue possessions, people begin to steal¡± (chapter 2) and ¡°If you don¡¯t trust the people you make them untrustworthy¡± (chapter 17). Or these, from chapter 38, which describe the toll of illusory thought:

When the Tao is lost, there is goodness.
When goodness is lost, there is morality.
When morality is lost, there is ritual.
Ritual is the husk of true faith,
The beginning of chaos.

Therefore the Master concerns himself with the depths and not the surface,
With the fruit and not the flower.
He has no will of his own.
He dwells in reality, and lets all illusions go.

I¡¯m telling you, had I been born into Taoism I might actually believe in something.

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Tao Te Ching.
Sign In ?

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 28, 2007 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Janet Still FNP For me the Tao is not about belief, but rather about living one's private truth within the outer duality.


message 2: by Dalek (new)

Dalek Matheson You've simply misread or overlooked - "I know not whose son it is; it images the forefather of god."

This is the earliest statement of strong atheism I've seen. It's speaks directly to the nature of the consideration of infinite regresses, which is exactly what makes atheism a thing opposed to the popular scientific/ probabilistic agnostic-atheism.


Ahood Great??


Ahood Great??


message 5: by L (new) - added it

L R. It's so great that you got to read this. So many people become atheists simply because western religion was not for them, and books of eastern religion (which have a different style) were not readily available.


message 6: by Thomas (new) - added it

Thomas Great review!


message 7: by Patrick (new)

Patrick Thanks for your great review!


message 8: by Lance (new) - added it

Lance Hoffman This is a review of a Great Book.
Mitchell has translated a number of important
Text. He is also a First Rate Poet . He has wisdom of a first rate mind!
Lance Hoffman


message 9: by Sidney (new) - added it

Sidney Clouston The translstion by Stephen Mitchell resonates with me


message 10: by Max (new) - added it

Max Jarman Religion is ruining us. It¡¯s about having a sense of spirit and invigoration not reciting lines and memorizing passages. In my opinion religion takes most people further from God (save the few prominent believers). Much is the same for education. In modern day education it is becoming harder to enjoy learning which is the exact point of it in the first place. Kids grow up hating school and dread taking tests and lessons. And, save for the few people who become doctors and engineers, it isn¡¯t necessary for a life of wisdom and knowledge. The real point of school and education is to problem solve and love to learn while the real reason of religion is to have a sense of spirituality and feel one with yourself in nature. We shouldn¡¯t strive to memorize the verses but to love the world.


message 11: by Yasmin (new)

Yasmin Allithy If you believe in the word of God . Why not believing in him


message 12: by Jeer (new) - added it

Jeer So true , we have already forgot what learning is what is enjoyment of knowledge, even when we hear such expression we still don't know what it rally stands for


message 13: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg The thing I like about the Tao, is it urges you to merge and not to keep forcing and striving something all the time. "Keep filling you bowl to the top.
and it will overflow. keep sharpening your life and it will blunt, seek other peoples approval and you will become their prisoner, do your work then step back " The Tao Teh Ching


message 14: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg What does your comment mean ?


message 15: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg What ?


message 16: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg You don't make sense


message 17: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg You make no sense


message 18: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg whatever


Janet Still FNP Anyone else seeing only 'wwwww' or occasionally things like 'weqrwrwretwrwtfeteetwrqrwrwrwew' in the comments rather than actual meaningful writing? I am starting to see it in friends' comments not in this group too. Like I cannot read most of the comments above.
I am pondering whether this a virus? or what?
Thanks.


message 20: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg Thanks Janet--This is extremely irritating


message 21: by Janet (last edited Mar 01, 2022 09:42AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Janet Still FNP Yes, I contacted goodreads support about it. There were no threads in the help section on this issue.
I noticed you were one of the affected accounts.
As soon as I hear anything from them, I will share it here... even if it is not helpful.


message 22: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg Thank You....


message 23: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg Here we go again with this nonsense


Janet Still FNP Uh oh.... They asked me to let them know if this started up again....
I will screenshot this and send it off...


Janet Still FNP Alright, I sent off the message to support again.


message 26: by Tg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tg Thanks


message 27: by Jolinda (new) - added it

Jolinda If this review is a sample of your writing, and your philosophical oversight, I¡¯d really love to read your whole story. Somehow you helped me understand the perspective of a nonbeliever, which has always existed outside of the range of possibility for me. While I¡¯m not tethered to any religion, especially one that claims to be the only one and to know the true way, from my earliest memory I have felt a connection with all that IS and I have never doubted it or needed to be acknowledged by the great Eye-in-the-Sky. I see, and know that I am seen and for me that¡¯s more than enough.
But I could truly feel how it is for you a bit and for that insight I am grateful. And I very much enjoyed reading your words and thank you for your excellent review!


Maelen Stephen Mitchell's version of the Daodejing may be inspiring to you, but if it is, the credit should go to Stephen Mitchell. It has only the vaguest relation to the original Chinese text. I don't even think that he can read Classical Chinese. He should have published it as "Musings inspired by the Daodejing" or something like that; in that case, there would have been nothing to object to. But as a translation, it's a complete fake.


Brian Gerry¡¯s review provides such insight and pretty much sums it up for me & likely multitudes of others fortunate enough to read his review. After several major crisis in my life & then the loss of my wife to cancer I was certainly at a major crossroads in life & no longer a believer in God. I found a copy of this book and with much study it made meaningful sense to me. Where is Gerry now ? He obviously has a gift and I hope he is using it to reach out to others.


message 30: by Tina (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tina I¡¯m atheist but wondering what you think the Tao is, that you don¡¯t believe in it. I figured it was the laws of nature. Not physics and math, which are the Tao that can be told, but the way things work, that physics and math attempt to describe. It seems like an obvious thing to believe in, for modern people who accept science. But it may have been a surprising idea thousands of years ago, that the universe follows rules, and if we go with that flow, things will be easier.


message 31: by Velavan (new) - added it

Velavan V He is bogar from india who lived in china for some period in name of Bo-Yang modified as loazi , he is from India tamil nadu


message 32: by Áõ³© (new)

Áõ³© Hello! I am a graduate student of Journalism and Communication from Shanghai Normal University in China, and I am writing my thesis on the overseas dissemination of Tao Te Ching. My research includes users' videos on YouTube platforms and readers' comments on book review platforms, and I red your views on the content of Tao Te Ching posted on social media platforms, and I found what you have written very informative, so could you spare some time for my interview? The results of the interview will only be used for the writing of my thesis and not for any other purpose. Thank you very much for your help!

1. In what way did you first come across the Tao Te Ching? What was your first impression of it?
2. What do you hope to gain most from reading or understanding the Tao Te Ching (e.g. cultural knowledge, emotional comfort, practical guidance, etc.)?
3. What philosophical ideas in the Tao Te Ching appeal to you the most? Why?
4. Do you feel that the translation standard and presentation of the translations have an impact on your understanding of the Tao Te Ching?


message 33: by Emilia (new) - added it

Emilia Have you read The Dispossessed by Ursula Le Guin?


back to top