Fups's Reviews > Dakota: A Spiritual Geography
Dakota: A Spiritual Geography
by
by

It took me awhile to read this book. It isn't the kind of book to read fast- it's almost like reading a lot of little books at once.
Kathleen Norris writes about the Great Plains - "Dakota" (she kind of throws both Dakotas together) and her experiences living there- and she interweaves this with her experiences of the monastic life- visiting monasteries, interacting with monks, readings of ancient monks. There are 44 chapters, or sections, and some of these are very short: some are weather reports. Or journal entries. Moments/memories she jotted down while not being able to sleep. Excerpts of poems.
It's refreshing to read this- I've never been to that part of the US- so reading about the extreme weather there, the deprivations, the hardships of farmers and ranchers was interesting and new to me. Norris draws a parallel between the farmers' experience and monk life. One of my favorite quotes was at the beginning of the book:
"I had stumbled onto a basic truth of asceticism: that it is not necessarily a denigration of the body, though it has often been misapplied for that purpose. Rather it is a way of surrendering to reduced circumstances in a manner that enhances the whole person."
There are Dakotan farmers who choose to remain there, despite the unpredictability of the rains and crop harvest. There are desert monks who choose to live a life in community with other monks, thereby giving up their freedom to choose other things, "learning to love what you find there... to care less for amenities than for that that which refreshes from a deeper source."
I love the idea of living simply. Of 'making do'. And so the parts where Norris describes this mentality delighted me!
I did sense a bit of negativity in this book, though. And it made me wonder how residents from the Dakotas would react to her characterizations of them. She talked at length of their wariness of outsiders, their reluctance to adopting new philosophies, or new ways of thinking. Their mistrust of professionals. Norris made Dakotans out to be kind of hostile, backwoods types who effectively keep out 'foreigners' .. it gave me pause to think of visiting that area!
I don't agree with all of Norris' views, but I enjoyed her writing and will look for more of her books to read.
Kathleen Norris writes about the Great Plains - "Dakota" (she kind of throws both Dakotas together) and her experiences living there- and she interweaves this with her experiences of the monastic life- visiting monasteries, interacting with monks, readings of ancient monks. There are 44 chapters, or sections, and some of these are very short: some are weather reports. Or journal entries. Moments/memories she jotted down while not being able to sleep. Excerpts of poems.
It's refreshing to read this- I've never been to that part of the US- so reading about the extreme weather there, the deprivations, the hardships of farmers and ranchers was interesting and new to me. Norris draws a parallel between the farmers' experience and monk life. One of my favorite quotes was at the beginning of the book:
"I had stumbled onto a basic truth of asceticism: that it is not necessarily a denigration of the body, though it has often been misapplied for that purpose. Rather it is a way of surrendering to reduced circumstances in a manner that enhances the whole person."
There are Dakotan farmers who choose to remain there, despite the unpredictability of the rains and crop harvest. There are desert monks who choose to live a life in community with other monks, thereby giving up their freedom to choose other things, "learning to love what you find there... to care less for amenities than for that that which refreshes from a deeper source."
I love the idea of living simply. Of 'making do'. And so the parts where Norris describes this mentality delighted me!
I did sense a bit of negativity in this book, though. And it made me wonder how residents from the Dakotas would react to her characterizations of them. She talked at length of their wariness of outsiders, their reluctance to adopting new philosophies, or new ways of thinking. Their mistrust of professionals. Norris made Dakotans out to be kind of hostile, backwoods types who effectively keep out 'foreigners' .. it gave me pause to think of visiting that area!
I don't agree with all of Norris' views, but I enjoyed her writing and will look for more of her books to read.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Dakota.
Sign In »
Quotes Fups Liked

“True hospitality is marked by an open response to the dignity of each and every person. Henri Nouwen has described it as receiving the stranger on his own terms, and asserts that it can be offered only by those who 'have found the center of their lives in their own hearts'.”
― Dakota: A Spiritual Geography
― Dakota: A Spiritual Geography

“When you come to a place where you have to left or right,' says Sister Ruth, 'go straight ahead.”
― Dakota: A Spiritual Geography
― Dakota: A Spiritual Geography
Reading Progress
September 26, 2008
– Shelved
(Other Paperback Edition)
Started Reading
(Other Paperback Edition)
2020
–
Finished Reading
(Other Paperback Edition)
June 5, 2020
–
Started Reading
June 5, 2020
– Shelved
July 21, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
booklady
(new)
-
added it
Jul 28, 2020 04:38PM

reply
|
flag