欧宝娱乐

Roddy's Reviews > Tortilla Flat

Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
214318
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: literature

I learned from this book that I continue to love Steinbeck. I despise the idea that he (like hemmingway for that matter) is sometimes considered a "simple" writer. Here's my opinion: Using flowery prose to add weight and impart meaning on a vaporous story is not great literature. A substantive story, containing meaning and moral, simply told IS great literature. This is what I run into every time I read Steinbeck. Hemmingway too. Simple construction - departing every so often to show off that yes, they know EXACTLY what they're describing - for the most part just recording the story as they would an event that really happened. They don't need a $2 word every couple paragraphs, they need maybe three per book. Besides, none of the characters would know the word, so why would you use it to describe them? What are you, better than your subject? I think the point Steinbeck constantly makes is - no, you're not. The characters are interesting and simply made, archetypes almost. I've heard its a Camelot tale and I can see it. They even use "Thou" and "Thee" in some parts. But it never seems heavy handed, you can almost see the characters realizing they're playing a part and stepping up to do it. Like Cannery Row, its about a lot of down on their luck guys, and the people of the town about them. Some richer, some poorer, all with their own little story. And Steinbeck seems to love the little side stories. Thankfully, he's so quick with his pen they're like brief tangents that come, then go once you've gotten the point of them. He never departs from our subjects for more than a couple pages, never spends 5 pages describing a rock or a particular tree, or even any of the men or the home they live in. A story that makes your throat tighten at the end, and makes you wish...well, you're supposed to read it. But the desire to keep things as they are is a very strong one in real life, Steinbeck makes you feel that desire and sense of loss in the little world he creates, and it takes him less than 200 pages to do it.
293 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Tortilla Flat.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Started Reading
July 1, 2007 – Finished Reading
July 23, 2007 – Shelved
July 23, 2007 – Shelved as: literature

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Becky (new)

Becky Lynn i also like Steinbeck better than Hemmingway...


Shovelmonkey1 Totally right. There is an elegance in the simplicity of the language that should be commended not condemned!


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Too right! Great review.


Sreeja Kondeti This is such a great review. Steinbeck's style is simply amazing


Clare Grov茅 Agree completely. Thank you for putting words to my thoughts.


Patti Overholt Agree!


message 7: by Wrenegade (new) - added it

Wrenegade I am putting this on my list of books to read.


message 8: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Very well said. I'll have to check out this book now.


Tiffany Great review. Still coasting through the book, and loving every moment.


Lucio d鈥橝mico Hi I really enjoyed your review and will def look for the coming up and old ones!
Could I kindly ask you to express - if any - your interpretation on Jesus Maria anecdote of Petey鈥檚 story?
Though I tend to avoid translator note or introductory essays, I just can鈥檛 get my head out of it, as I believe there鈥檚 a valuable reference I am not quite getting


message 11: by Sam (new) - added it

Sam I鈥檓 reading this book starting Monday and your review was a segway into it


Ishan I read it late, but I loved the fact that i read this review. Completely agree!


message 13: by Iman (new) - added it

Iman Amazing review


message 14: by Johannes (new)

Johannes Bols You are absolutely correct! I was thinking last night that he is my favourite American author. Truman Capote is another one, but his work is uneven. Steinbeck has the talent Somerset Maugham had of describing something in simple terms but using words so vividly that the picture is complete. To do this for a few sentences is OK. But to be able to write an entire novel like this is true talent.


message 15: by Eva (new) - added it

Eva Wallgren Me and my best friend, 13 year swedish girls got The pastures of heaven from my brother. We started reading, and from then on we read it backwords and forwards absolute blown away of all the stories of the characters in the book. Its more than 50 years ago. Now it's time to take on him again.


message 16: by Jean (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jean Gilis I love reading Steinbeck, and you just described amazingly the reason why. Thank you


Steven Elmes Great review and you're bang on. This is where American writers shine, in their simplicity. I think it may go back in time through to frontiersmen telling stories at the campsite resting from a day on the wagon. I find European writers to be far more complex, but what I adore about American writers is that I find them simply relaxing to read. Less is more.


Tiara Ulfah this is the best review i've ever read!


back to top