Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

David's Reviews > Outliers: The Story of Success

Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
M 50x66
's review

liked it
bookshelves: culture-society

** spoiler alert ** Malcolm Gladwell's new book reads like a series of cocktail-party anecdotes. Whether the book is a mere fluff piece or something more is open to debate. At its heart, it has two themes: (1) That success depends not just on talent but opportunity, and (2) that success (and failure) also depend on the cultural legacies we inherit from our forebears. Boiled down, here are his essential ideas:

OPPORTUNITY

1. Luck matters. Hockey players who happened to be born between January and March were disproportionately represented in professional hockey leagues. From an early age, these players were the oldest in their age bracket, and therefore bigger and more coordinated. Coaches selected them for better training and playing opportunities, and overtime, success bred success. Likewise, students who happened to be older for their class scored higher on math and science tests than their younger classmates, and were more likely to be picked for "gifted" and other advanced programs.

2. Even smart people need 10,000 hours of practice before they master a skill. Those that can get those 10,000 hours during childhood are a step ahead. Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, and The Beatles all had unique opportunities to have lots and lots of practice in their specialties at an early age before becoming successful.

3. After 120, increases in IQ are less important than creativity and "practical intelligence" -- knowing what to say to whom, knowing when to say it, and knowing how to say it for maximum effect. A lifelong study of geniuses showed they were no more successful than the average population. Nobel laureates are just as likely to come from City College of NY, Augsburg College, or Gettysburg College as they are from Harvard.

LEGACY

4. Rural Americans in backcountry states -- Kentucky, Tennessee, North & South Carolina -- inherited a "culture of honor" from their Scotch-Irish forefathers. These herdsmen warriors brought with them a willingness to fight in response to the smallest slight. This led to a pattern of bloody and violent feuds between families across the Appalachian states. (Think Hatfields vs. McCoys.)

5. Korean Airlines had an unusually high rate of plane crashes because of the Korean culture's extreme deference to superiors. Junior pilots were reluctant to directly contradict their Captain on a flight, even in the face of grave error. This explains, for instance, the Korean Air Flight 801 crash in Guam in 1997. When the airline hired a specialist from Delta to retrain the pilots to speak more transparently, their safety record went up dramatically.

6. Asians are good at math and science because their ancestors planted rice paddies. Rice farming was more labor intensive than Western agriculture. Asians have inherited this stick-with-it-ness that allows them to excel in math and science, where perseverance is mandatory.

7. Unlike rice paddies, wheat or corn fields need to be left fallow every few years. Early American educators adopted this principle toward schooling - that students must not be exhausted. Hence, the long summer vacation, a distinctly American legacy. But this legacy is counterproductive, because kids tend to forget things over the summer. Kids who go to schools with shorter summer breaks tend to have higher test scores.
170 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Outliers.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 14, 2008 – Shelved
November 14, 2008 – Shelved as: culture-society
Started Reading
November 22, 2008 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ben (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ben This is a fantastic review: broken down precisely with no subjective bullshit involved.


Katie It is a good summary. But what made the book much more than just cocktail party anecdotes for me was the fact that if we / governments / business acted on the findings of some of these studies that Gladwell describes, we could transform lives. In too many cases the response has been, 'well, that's the way we've always done things so we're not changing now'. I've a good mind to send a copy to Ed Balls!


Sigurdur Good summary - I kinda liked the book but it was a bit aimless.


Amm. this is dead on accurate on how the book flows. perfect summary!


Rachel I wish I had read this review before I read the book.


Burt Baguma Good motivation to go read the book now. Thanks David.


message 7: by Keith (new)

Keith C. Major omissions: The rag trade in Brooklyn. The role of language in Chinese math skills.

Although the Italian village was a bit of an outlier itself, I thought it was instructive for other reasons.


Serge Kurenkov I'd rather read this review than reading the whole book. It has it all.


Stephanie Tan This was a spot on summary of the book. To me, only the earlier part made an impact but I felt that it got a little wearisome towards the end. Wished I had read this earlier on. Thank you for this!


back to top