欧宝娱乐

Paithan's Reviews > Dionysus: Myth and Cult

Dionysus by Walter F. Otto
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
77569720
's review

really liked it

This book is primarily two things. On one hand it is a great resource for detail concerning the rites of the Cult of Dionysus. On the other hand it is a look into the mindset of ancient people. Too often, the author claims, we look at old religions through our modern lense. Modern people always need to find a reason for something to exist. Everything has to have a purpose that gives us some advantage in the world.

Yet the author claims this was not the mindset of ancient people. When we endeavor to understand ancient gods, we start with the concept of the god; god of war, of smithing, of agriculture, of love and romance. What we really need to be doing is, according to Otto, is start with the natural phenomena.

One great example; when a woman gives birth she is bringing new life into the world. Yet the action of giving birth is incredibly dangerous, for the woman and the baby. This was something that ancient people were aware of. They were struck by the thin line between life and death in such an important action. Such an observation led to the idea of a god who embodies such a paradox; Dionysus. He is both life and death. In no other god is life so vibrant than the Master of the Vine, who gave wine to humanity. And because of that, in no other god is death so horrible than in Zagreus, the hunter who rends the flesh of his prey.

It is in paradox that gods are born.

Another interesting point is that Dionysus is unlike any of the other Greek gods, who inhabit the summit of Mount Olympus. They exist above humanity, separate from the world and looking down on it. Like Apollo, who is the sun in heaven, they exist in the spiritual world. But not Dionysus. He is a chthonic deity, who exists in the world with us; life and death can be seen everywhere we look (or could, before modernity made life so easy to ignore death).

Apollo is order and discipline, a far flung look into the future and the planning for it. Dionysus is life, the here and now that must be enjoyed because death is always around the corner. That is why Apollo and Dionysus were sometimes housed in the same temple; they are opposites, but essential halves of the same universal truth. You have to plan for the future, but you must also enjoy your time here on earth.
5 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Dionysus.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

October 2, 2021 – Started Reading
October 2, 2021 – Shelved
October 2, 2021 –
page 24
8.33% "Author starts out with interesting argument; religious rites don't follow myth. Myth follows religion. And religion follows concrete human experience.

Also the author argues that gods are not born as concepts; God of Fertility, God of War, God of Death, ect. Instead they are almost like modes of being in existence."
October 3, 2021 –
page 30
10.42% "Author makes a really interesting point by saying that religion is like a work of art. A true work of art starts with a moment of creativity, not a concept. The artwork then takes on a life of its own and flourishes, growing seemingly with a mind of its own.

From God comes all creative spirit, for all mediums. Movies, books, paintings and music all come from God. Therefore religion does as well."
October 3, 2021 –
page 46
15.97% "Modern scholars can only reconcile religious rite by trying to find some utilitarian aspect to it.

Example; in Greece a handsome youth carries a ram around the perimeter of the city. Ram is then slaughtered. Modern scholars claim it is to draw evil out of the city and purge it.

True meaning; Hermes once carried a ram around the city. Ritual is repeated because it supplies spiritual rejuvenation to believers."
October 6, 2021 –
page 78
27.08%
October 12, 2021 –
page 142
49.31%
October 16, 2021 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.