Rachel's Reviews > The Rattle Bag
The Rattle Bag
by
by

A confident, hearty stew of an anthology.
Arranging the poems alphabetically by first line results in some lovely serendipities - strange and refreshing pairings which might have been missed if they’d gone for a thematic or chronological structure.
The title is drawn from a slightly eerie poem about (perhaps?) interrupted ecstasy - not quite sure of the significance of this. As a whole the scope needs tightening - this could be an excellent anthology of poems originally written in English; instead they’ve included a sprinkle of marvellous (razor-sharp and salty) poems in translation - Serbian, Chinese, Navajo. They’re amazing - but either incorporate these fully and give them equal weight, or not at all?
There’s also a heavy emphasis on nature - no surprise when Heaney and Hughes are involved - though far too much cloying William Blake and tepid Robert Frost for my taste (and unfair on the other poets who don’t get such preferential treatment).
Overall a varied, admirable selection.
Arranging the poems alphabetically by first line results in some lovely serendipities - strange and refreshing pairings which might have been missed if they’d gone for a thematic or chronological structure.
The title is drawn from a slightly eerie poem about (perhaps?) interrupted ecstasy - not quite sure of the significance of this. As a whole the scope needs tightening - this could be an excellent anthology of poems originally written in English; instead they’ve included a sprinkle of marvellous (razor-sharp and salty) poems in translation - Serbian, Chinese, Navajo. They’re amazing - but either incorporate these fully and give them equal weight, or not at all?
There’s also a heavy emphasis on nature - no surprise when Heaney and Hughes are involved - though far too much cloying William Blake and tepid Robert Frost for my taste (and unfair on the other poets who don’t get such preferential treatment).
Overall a varied, admirable selection.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Rattle Bag.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Christian
(new)
Mar 27, 2022 01:09PM

reply
|
flag