Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

WK's Reviews > Quicksilver

Quicksilver by Neal Stephenson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
U 50x66
's review

it was amazing

4.0/4.0

It's the Moby-Dick question.

The plot's about an angry guy chasing a whale. There's not a lot of variation on this theme: he catches it, or he doesn't. Maybe he catches it and wishes that he didn't, maybe he doesn't and regrets that he failed. But this basic plot, a straightforward quest for revenge, is such thin gruel that you'd have to be on the lower end of the intellectual spectrum to fail to realize that the book's about something a little bit more than hunting a big fish.

Even so, there's no guarantee that you're going to tolerate 20 pages about rope. At the end of the digression, you're either going to respond in one of two ways. You might be of the sort to go, "Hmm, that was some fascinating rope discourse. I had no idea that rope could be used in such multifaceted ways, and having read that, I am now a different and slightly more rounded person." Then again, you could respond with a "JESUS FUCKING CHRIST, enough with the stupid rope already! For fuck's sake, where's that son of a bitch whale? The white sea mammal is the TITLE of the book, and I'm reading about some shitty rope?! Christ, I need some vodka."

You should know what sort of reader you are before picking this book up, because The Baroque Cycle is about 3,000 pages long, and Neal Stephenson digresses like an ADHD kid on speed. Melville's focus is a goddamn space laser in comparison. Quicksilver has economics, mining, mathematics, piracy, slavery, early Puritan philosophy and I forget what else.

It is genius, pure and simple.

This is one of the first great works of the 21st century, and I can't recommend it highly enough. But odds are great that you'll hate it mightily if your concern is the destination instead of how you get there.
195 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Quicksilver.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 13, 2009 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

SharonBBD Brava!


Jeffrey Greek Great review.


Costacoralito Excellent review.


Jeremy Armer Probably the best Stephenson synopsis I've seen. Know what kind of reader you are, indeed. The Baroque Cycle may very well be my favorite set of overlapping stories ever, but I rarely even mention it to most much less recommend it.


message 5: by Meghan (new) - added it

Meghan One of the best reviews I've read.


Peggy I cant tell. Did you like Moby Dick or not? I did but am well aware that most do not


Oriol Fantastic


Tbidster Can's stop laughing!


message 9: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Clingan I have read the Baroque Cycle multiple times and this review is spot on. It's one of my favorites ever. The ride is glorious, but don't get on if you want the direct route.


message 10: by C (new) - added it

C Cowell That's exactly what I love. The journey! Sounds like a plan!!


message 11: by Bruce (new)

Bruce Coe "Neal Stephenson digresses like an ADHD kid on speed."

oddly enough - they treat ADHD with stimulants - used to use amphetimines. Nice review BTW!


message 12: by Eric (new)

Eric Well done.


message 13: by Douglas (new) - added it

Douglas Mulvaney I love Moby Dick.. Perhaps I'll love the Baroque Cycle. The only Stephenson book I've read is Seveneves, and I thoroughly enjoyed that one too! Thanks for the review. You've sold me on at least giving it a go.


message 14: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali This is an amazing review. Thank you so much!


message 15: by Tony (new)

Tony Douglas, I hate Moby Dick, all that stuff about whales and whaling went on and on and was way too much. In contrast I loved Quicksilver as the digressions were more varied and Stephenson didn't allow them to bring the book to a grinding halt as Melville all too frequently did.


message 16: by Katharine (new)

Katharine Noble Trying to find a book that my brother will like and he *loves* Hugo's description of Waterloo in Les Miserable, eats up Melville's rambling so.... a chapter dedicated to rope might be right up his alley!!


凱 This review is spot on, and I loved this book


back to top