ŷ

Jon Reading Books's Reviews > The Storyteller: Tales of Life and Music

The Storyteller by Dave Grohl
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
21807813
's review

it was ok

Grohl's prose is surprisingly effective. If this was written without a ghostwriter, it's an admirable effort. However, I found the overall work to be a bit scattered and shallow. Grohl jumps back and forth through time a bit too often, and grants entire chapters to episodes of questionable interest. I'd have appreciated a bit more of a deep dive into some of the things that have made Grohl's life so special; his jump from high school student to international touring drummer of the band Scream seemed so abrupt that I almost felt I had skipped a chapter.

In one moment, Grohl is talking about his first girlfriend. Then, it seemed, in the next, he was playing a show with Scream in the Netherlands. How did such a jump change a teenager? How did this new perspective alter his worldview, cause him to grow as a human being? These sorts of engaging questions are abandoned for amusing, though ultimately disposable anecdotes about being chased through European alleyways by junkies and skinheads. This issue is exacerbated by Grohl's questionable inclusion of chapters on seemingly disposable events, such as being hit in the head as a child and the claims that Grohl does not feel physical pain.

The Nirvana chapters are also comparatively light. Grohl and Cobain lived together in the pacific Northwest during their time in Nirvana, but very little of Cobain is shared beyond what everyone already knows: that he was a brilliant songwriter, that he was a depressive, that he was staunchly anti-establishment. So desperate for Cobain crumbs was I that I found Grohl's mention of Cobain's endless love of strawberry milk to be one of my favorite tidbits in the book.

Too much of this reads as a surface-level description of Grohl's life, and the man—although undoubtedly having lived an incredibly interesting, eventful life—seems to lack the insight as to what, exactly, makes his life so incredible and eventful. Thus we're regaled with pitter-patter, here-and-there stories which seem scattershot and don't dive into any real meaning or cohesive theme which drives Grohl's experience, and seem more instead like a smattering of unrelated tidbits from an old-but-gold rocker. Which is fine, if that's what you're looking for. But Grohl has been there for such monumental events in recent music history that I'd hoped for a bit more.

Foo Fighters and Grohl fans will undoubtedly enjoy this, but those of us on the outside of those descriptors will likely be left wanting more. A solid effort nonetheless, but there's nothing profound to be had here.
287 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Storyteller.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
October 29, 2021 – Shelved
October 29, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Camilla Haynes Wow, that is the first review I've read of this book where I completely agree and felt the same way.. the only difference is that I am a huge Foo Fighters and Dave Grohl fan so maybe made me feel a little more disappointed. I agree that it does come across as shallow in some parts and also felt like there were "missing chapters". I think Anthony Kiedis' Scar Tissue ruined any other music biographies for me!


message 2: by Jen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jen He was equally reticent about all of his romantic relationships (excluding the adorable puppy love of junior high), and I'm hopeful that was intentional. Some things should be kept personal, and his love life is not for our entertainment.


Maria Sanchez YES! I felt the exact same way!


Ylanda Hathorne byrd Almost done and feel the same, but it was what I was expecting, to be honest. I generally feel the same way about his lyrics—some songs/lines are really vapid and seem written in a swirl of recycled sounds, but then there’ll be the one or two songs that really hit that’ll make me continue to root for him. As far as his storytelling, the strawberry milk and tapping turtle details really “hit,� as did the Iggy Pop moment.

He’s a rocker, not an esteemed writer. That said, I, too, hope he wrote most of the book himself because if he did, he is a decent writer, given that writing books isn’t his profession.

The other thing that he is still up against is Cobain’s shadow. Grohl’s bubbly personality and supportive upbringing (for the most part, based on this book) is so different from Cobain’s that I found it hard to accept Dave as a separate entity from what grunge/alt rock (whatever we are calling it now) and Nirvana have represented for me for all these years, grunge being so intricately intertwined with Cobain’s suicide and his rejection of the mainstream. Denting the mythical hold of the genre is one reason, honestly, that I have continued reading Grohl’s book. For Gen. X’ers who came of age at a time when the genre was at its height and who were also fans, it is nearly impossible to imagine that Cobain would be able to stomach Grohl’s level of zeal for pomp-and-circumstance celebrities, crowded arenas, and Pantera-owned strip clubs. Nevertheless, the two were friends then—and maybe even would be now, were Kurt alive. And in whichever direction Grohl might have veered had we not lost Kurt Cobain, I have a feeling Grohl would still have been this upbeat—Cobain’s opinion he damned. While Grohl is eagerly starstuck and grossly romantic, he also strikes as authentic, which I can appreciate. I am not going to say that I love when he geeks out over McCartney, but I do understand it, and I believe that he probably did geek out that hard.

In writing all of this, I still agree with the original poster. As a reader, I wanted more emotional reflection and smoother & more intriguing transitions. As a supporter of Grohl’s career and persistence and authenticity, though, what Grohl has written will work.


Mitchell Loman I agree with your review of the book. I like Dave and he comes across as a good guy, and he truly is a music fan of a broad range. I relate to this part of him and am also a fan of many bands he likes. I also respect that he is a good father. That said, he pisses nobody off, loves everybody and gets to play and hang with everyone cool. The Foo Fighters are just an ok band, sort of one dimensional. How does he kick it with Sir Paul? Induct and speak for The Who? Very surface info without any deep dive into the good, bad and ugly. The turtle and strawberry milk were of the most interesting parts. Not much personal other than daughters. Little about his marriage. The book was about as shallow as a Foo Fighters song. Doesn’t suck, but not a stand out. I’d love to drink a beer with him and talk music though.


Karin Hopper I gave it a better rating, but I agree with your point about being scattered. I kept feeling like there were gaps in important periods that I wanted to know more about.


message 7: by Tara (new) - added it

Tara I felt the same way and gave up listening to this less than half way in. For a book called Storyteller the story is not told very well.


Sherif Karama I see your point but I'm pretty sure the things left behind were left behind on purpose. His family life, precious marriage, and especially his understandably mixed feelings about the Nirvana period are all things he's always been private about, and one can imagine that he only included what little he did because he *had to*, and only because he had to. He skimmed right over the harder, not so glamorous part of Nirvana's short existence, and probably for a reason. I'm pretty sure this book his the first time of him addressing Kurt's suicide at all, and I'm sure that he felt capable of telling us more, he would have!


Fiona Jane Yes, agreed. I couldn't finish his book. It bugged me too much


Lawaysha Agree 100%.


Shannon Your review articulates my impression better than my own. Although I am a big fan of him, he's a fantastic performer!


Anissa Spot. On.


Angie I agree with your review. I found the book to be a struggle to finish, it was sporadic.


Jennifer Feel the same and I am a big fan of him.


Frida Hultgren yeah feel the same and I am 80% through. this is like night and day from the Scar Tissue book by Anthony Kiedis. That book is so wonderful.


message 16: by Gina (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gina McDonald Agree. What’s up with the lack of info on his marriage? All of a sudden there were kids??


Jamie This review is spot on.


Graham Lacey I thought there was something wrong with me (which, of course, there may still be) when I just didn't find this book reflected the near-5 star reviews it has. I was disappointed by the surface-level detail on creating his many records, especially the most important ones which I'd say was everything from 1991 to 1997.

And the last third of the book - after he'd become one of the biggest rock personalities in the world - was a parade of stories about his kids (which is fine), and all the amazing musicians that he couldn't believe gave him the time of day. Half-way through I ddin't expect I'd get much more information about his troubled relationship with his father, so I was pleased to get as much as I did in the end.

Dave has nothing bad to say about anyone - even his fall out with William Goldsmith (the Foo Fighter's Pete Best) was detailed briefly, but in a kind way without dragging anyone through the dirt. I listened to the audiobook and Dave was an excellent narrator. I'm not sure I'd have gotten through the paperback.


Susan Jolly After listening to the Audible version of the book, I have become a Grohl fan! Appreciate his optimistic attitude throughout and his decision not to talk ill of anyone. Imho, he was very intentional to point out Cobain's great impact on his life; however, providing where he came and is today on his own merits. I love how his children are a big part of his story and addiction is not. So many people assume alternative rockers are lonely stones. Also, I appreciate his thankfulness for his mother, other musicians, every fan, and everything life has given him. His music weaved into the Audible version helped to bridge the disconnects in the book version. Ironically, I knew very little about him or his music beforehand and now have added multiple of his songs to my playlist. To me, it was a 4 star listening experience. 🎶


message 20: by Elizabeth (new) - added it

Elizabeth I didn’t understand why his mother had to struggle so much financially. His father seems to have had a successful career as a journalist and political consultant. Did he not pay child support?


message 21: by Liam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Liam Fell Excellent review, i am battling my way through, was not expecting it to be so painful to read. So much exaggeration, hype and lack of depth throughout


Keith B Totally agree, great review


Felicity You've articulated exactly how I felt about this book


message 24: by Gary (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gary Baysinger Your review is spot on.


Marianna Zelichenko Agreed. I love his music, but the book? Meh..


Katie Kourakos Agree with your review completely


Heather Cornwell Agree with your review. Surface-level is the best way to describe it. Decent writing, though.


Kristie This is a great review! It was very shallow. I enjoyed reading it- his stories are entertaining- but when it was done I felt like, “that’s it?� It was like he wanted to share fun exploits that made for good stories but simultaneously built a wall up between himself and the reader not allowing us into anything more than being a spectator at a concert.


Sylvy Exactly this! Didn't feel like I connected with him at all - superficial seems the right word.


Marilee You put your finger on what was missing from this read.


back to top