Andrea Blythe's Reviews > Duel
Duel
by
by

I loved I am Legend, which was an amazing twist on the vampire genre and had an ending that wasn't happy, per se, but had me grinning from ear to ear. This collection of short stories, however, was not so great. At best I will say they were okay. Most of the stories were written in the late fifties through the sixties, which explains the old fashioned style of the stories, most particularly the reliance on withholding important information to deliver a "surprise," which is not so surprising because you're looking for it. The stories rely heavily on idea, rather than character, which is not so much my cup of tea.
The title story, "Duel," is interesting because it was made into Stephen Spielburg's first film of the same title. The story itself, about a saleman driving cross country and getting into a life threatening situation with a nameless truck driver, was just okay. I haven't seen the movie, but I am curious about and want to see it so I can make the comparison with the story.
"Return" was the first story in the collection I really enjoyed. It involves time travel, and a man who desperately wants to return to his own time and his pregnant wife. The twist ending works here, because of its emotional impact (as opposed to intellectual impact).
"Lover When You're Near Me" was a disturbing tale about a man managing work on an alien planet. An alien woman is assigned to help him as a kind of maid. She communicates via telepathy and becomes like a grasping leech, trying to dominate the man's mind and make him her lover. While this story is sufficiently disturbing to be entertaining, one of the most disturbing aspects of the story for me was not what happens to the poor man, so much as it's the way the female aliens have turned the men of their planet into mindless drones. The female aliens are seen as grasping, desperate, manipulative, man-devourers, sucking out a man's freewill to make them theirs. And while these are alien women, there is no doubt that this is a not so subtle commentary on women in general, which I find unsettling.
"SRL AD" was a funny story about answering personal ads from aliens. It made me smile.
"The Last Day" was great. It was a bitter sweet story of returning hom before the end of the world.
The last story in the book, "Steel," was kind of fun and reminded me a bit of the movie "Real Steel," mostly because they both have fighting robots with an owner desperately trying to make just a tiny bit of money from whatever fights he can. The similarities story and movie end there, however.
There were many other stories interspersed with the ones I mentioned, and none of them stood out in my mind for particular note. I am not put off Matheson, however. I think I just shy away from his short stories and stick to his longer works. I'm rather interested to read Hell House, or What Dreams May Come, or A Stir of Echoes, for example.
The title story, "Duel," is interesting because it was made into Stephen Spielburg's first film of the same title. The story itself, about a saleman driving cross country and getting into a life threatening situation with a nameless truck driver, was just okay. I haven't seen the movie, but I am curious about and want to see it so I can make the comparison with the story.
"Return" was the first story in the collection I really enjoyed. It involves time travel, and a man who desperately wants to return to his own time and his pregnant wife. The twist ending works here, because of its emotional impact (as opposed to intellectual impact).
"Lover When You're Near Me" was a disturbing tale about a man managing work on an alien planet. An alien woman is assigned to help him as a kind of maid. She communicates via telepathy and becomes like a grasping leech, trying to dominate the man's mind and make him her lover. While this story is sufficiently disturbing to be entertaining, one of the most disturbing aspects of the story for me was not what happens to the poor man, so much as it's the way the female aliens have turned the men of their planet into mindless drones. The female aliens are seen as grasping, desperate, manipulative, man-devourers, sucking out a man's freewill to make them theirs. And while these are alien women, there is no doubt that this is a not so subtle commentary on women in general, which I find unsettling.
"SRL AD" was a funny story about answering personal ads from aliens. It made me smile.
"The Last Day" was great. It was a bitter sweet story of returning hom before the end of the world.
The last story in the book, "Steel," was kind of fun and reminded me a bit of the movie "Real Steel," mostly because they both have fighting robots with an owner desperately trying to make just a tiny bit of money from whatever fights he can. The similarities story and movie end there, however.
There were many other stories interspersed with the ones I mentioned, and none of them stood out in my mind for particular note. I am not put off Matheson, however. I think I just shy away from his short stories and stick to his longer works. I'm rather interested to read Hell House, or What Dreams May Come, or A Stir of Echoes, for example.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Duel.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
October 18, 2012
– Shelved
November 21, 2012
–
Started Reading
November 26, 2012
–
23.0%
""Return" is the first story in the collection so far that I really loved."
page
92
November 28, 2012
–
30.0%
""F---" was also good. Had the same characters as "Return." A lot of these stories (many written in the '50s) rely on the with holding of specific information in order to offer a surprise. It's a rather old fashioned style."
page
120
December 1, 2012
–
30.0%
""Lover When You're Near Me" was a disturbing tale about an alien woman trying to dominate a man with telepathy. Mixed feelings about it. Mixed feelings about most of this book."
page
120
December 3, 2012
–
51.0%
""SRL AD" was a funny story about answering personal ads from aliens. "Death Ship" was just okay."
page
204
December 8, 2012
–
55.75%
""The Last Day" was great, a bitter sweet story of the end of the world."
page
223
December 17, 2012
–
93.5%
"Almost finished this last night, but I was falling asleep sitting up. Finishing the story won't change my preliminary review that the book was just okay."
page
374
December 17, 2012
–
100.0%
"The last story, "Steel," reminded me a bit of the movie "Real Steel," mostly because they both have fighting robots with an owner desperately trying to make just a tiny bit of money from whatever fights he can. But the similarities there."
page
400
December 17, 2012
–
Finished Reading
December 18, 2012
– Shelved as:
fic-horror
December 18, 2012
– Shelved as:
fic-scifi
December 18, 2012
– Shelved as:
fiction