欧宝娱乐

Howard Olsen's Reviews > City of Quartz: Excavating the Future in Los Angeles

City of Quartz by Mike  Davis
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
311643
's review

really liked it

My favorite song about Los Angeles is 鈥淟.A.鈥� by The Fall. It鈥檚 got an ominous synth line, a great guitar riff, and Mark Smith鈥檚 immortal lyrics: 鈥淟.L.L.A.A.A.L!L!L!A!A!A!鈥� It鈥檚 the perfect soundtrack for reading this excellent book. Davis has written a social history of the LA area, which does not proceed in a linear fashion. Instead, he picks out the social history of groups that have become identified with LA: developers, suburb dwellers, gangs, the LAPD, immigrants, etc. By the end of the book, you have a real grasp on how LA got to be the way it is today.

If you鈥檝e ever read any of Davis鈥� other books, you know he has an agenda, just like Howard Zinn or Ann Coulter. Davis鈥� information is not suspect; this book is well-sourced. However, it puts across a worldview, for which the reader must adjust accordingly. Davis writes in the post-structuralist style that was in fashion at the time. Politically, Davis is a doughy bourgeois leftist, who harbors the progressive鈥檚 Walter Mitty fantasy that he is a Bad Ass Street Rebel. If you can read past this, you can learn some absolutely fascinating info.

The longest chapter is Davis鈥� discussion of LA鈥檚 intellectual and cultural life. Don鈥檛 laugh. By the time you are finished with this, you will have a strange new respect for the Wasteland down south. Davis traces the groups of thinkers drawn to LA: creative people hired by Hollywood, PhD鈥檚 and engineers hired by the aerospace & defense industries; the noir novelists who created the modern detective story, cutting edge musicians, &c.

Davis also has long chapters about LA鈥檚 underlass. He traces the history of LA鈥檚 Catholic diocese, and uses it to discuss LA鈥檚 immigrant community. He also has a long discussion about LA鈥檚 gangs, and the LAPD鈥檚 campaign against them. His history of the Crips is very compelling. Davis unflinchingly details the bloody rise of the Crips, and their connection to the Black Power movement, a connection most commentators are loath to explore. Davis also gives us the rise and fall and rebirth of the town of Fontana, an honest-to-God LA steeltown that was so bluecollar that the Hell鈥檚 Angels were founded there, but which eventually became a chaotic blend (due to corrupt planning) of junkyards, truckstops and high end 鈥渟econd homes.鈥� These chapters alone make this book worthwhile. Not coincidentally, they are the ones least infected by Davis鈥� po-mo cant.

Davis鈥� only false note comes in the chapter titled 鈥淔ortress L.A.鈥� It's so filled with semiotic clich茅s and cultural referents as to reach the saturation point. It will be virtually unreadable by 2050. The theme is also weak. Davis argues that LA architects are creating buildings and public spaces that are intentionally meant to drive the poor and oppressed out of the city. He practically calls Frank Gehry a fascist Speer clone. He becomes especially exorcised over a South Central mini-mall, which the developer would build only after the city agreed to install an LAPD substation on the premises. Before the mall was built, ghetto folks had no place to buy food in the neighborhood, but no business would move in without some way to protect its investment. Davis finds something untoward in all of this, & rumbles darkly about the alienating design of the substation and the machinations in the mayor's office. But, the mall was so popular with the neighborhood that it made twice as much money as the equivalent suburban mall, so the people shopping there did not feel particularly oppressed by the architect. I'd say it was win-win for everyone. Davis鈥� worst qualities come out in this discussion, He comes across as one of those liberals who says they want to 鈥渉elp鈥� the ghetto, but then throws up every possible procedural and philosophical roadblock in front of the police, developers, and bureaucrats who would have to be involved. You can easily skip this chapter, and I would suggest that you do so.
16 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read City of Quartz.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
September 16, 2007 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Jennifer I am just starting the "panopticon" chapter now, and having just finished reading "There Goes the 'Hood" on gentrification in NY, I think lame timing is no small part of what leads this chapter astray. In 1990 there was rightful fear and dread directed toward (what turned out to be known as) gentrification forces that were from "outside the community"-- developers, planners, and politicians all included. In 1990, urban renewal was a fresh wound, and community development practices were yet to be further refined and proven.

Nearly 20 years later(!) there's much more acceptance that better amenities and services can be a boon to formerly disinvested neighborhoods, IF poor people aren't displaced and IF opportunities continue to be created for new/future low-income residents to access them. (Otherwise you're just shifting the problem around.)

Basically under community development, urban liberals don't so much "throw up every possible procedural and philosophical roadblock" against those evil forces of planning and development -- they become those forces themselves!


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review.

My favorite L.A. song is "Los Angeles" by X. Or "It Never Rains in Southern California." Same difference.


message 3: by Jessica (new) - added it

Jessica This review is so great that I don't know if I'll bother finishing the book.


message 4: by Ruth (new) - added it

Ruth Another native Angeleno here. I'll have to check this one out.


message 5: by Matthieu (new)

Matthieu Hmm, looks good. I'll definitely check this one out. I reckon that it'll be a nice change from all the French literature that I've been reading for the past few years.


message 6: by brian (last edited Jan 05, 2009 10:22PM) (new)

brian

here's my favorite l.a. song. -- the fake band is kind of perfect, eh?


message 7: by CW (new)

CW I've only just discovered Mike Davis in his "Ecology of Fear," and have never encountered anything like him, so I much enjoyed it, and now have his 'Panet Slums' in hand.
Thanks for your informative review of "Quartz," and your insights into "WHO is this MIKE DAVIS fellow? (who cuts his own hair, looks like, why not).
And thanks for the the Fall reference.


John Frank Gehry is awful. Like George Lucas, he hasn't had a good *new* idea since the late '70s; he just keeps cashing in again and again and again on the same garbage that people wondered at when it was new.


back to top