欧宝娱乐

Debbie Petersen Wolven's Reviews > The Guardian

The Guardian by Nicholas Sparks
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1079398
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: absolute-drek

** spoiler alert ** Sometimes, belonging to a book club (or two, or in my case, three) means that you are introduced to something that you would have never read on your own, that turns out to stretch your mind and lead to interesting discoveries...and other times, you are so aghast by someone's favorite that you avoid the discussion of the book so as not to hurt the person's feelings who suggested it. Here on 欧宝娱乐, I will pull no punches. This book reads like a Hallmark card, or a serial in a woman's magazine, or worse yet--a Lifetime movie. The premise is lame and unbelievable...how many dying husbands make pre-death arrangements for a dirty puppy to be delivered to the grieving widow on Christmas--in a cardboard box, no less? Why was the pup in such sad shape? Was the husband so ill that he ordered the pup from a substandard puppy mill? Ah, but with the wisdom that people about to die seem to have, he has chosen well, and she is thrilled to have the responsibility of training and caring for an enormous dog instead of being able to choose for herself if she wants to take this on, or perhaps choose a nice low maintenance goldfish instead. The rest of the story is so much like others of this genre that you may feel like you've already read it. The charming, handsome man who turns out to be psychotic, the man she thinks of as a "friend" who is really in love with her (and, of course, ends up being her savior at the end and she loves him too...yawn.) In stories like this, good people rarely die, even after being beaten to a pulp and left for dead in a ditch for two days (slutty hairdresser who isn't very bright); a cop found shot in the head, lying face-down with his head in a pool of blood near the end of the story is out of the hospital in a few days instead of being six feet under; a dog who has been poisoned with enough rat poison to kill six dogs, who moments before was gasping his last breath on the ground and unable to stand, suddenly flies through the air and attacks psycho dude, saving his owner, only to finally die of gunshot wounds inflicted by psycho dude. Weepy dog death scene follows, but psycho dude is dead and doggie has fulfilled being her guardian as in the book title, and everyone else goes off happily into the sunset. This is basically the song "My Life Will Go On" by Celine Dion mixed with a touch of "Old Yeller."
24 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read The Guardian.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Started Reading
July 8, 2009 – Finished Reading
July 12, 2009 – Shelved
July 12, 2009 – Shelved as: absolute-drek

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by K (new)

K Great review! I haven't read this book, but I've feel like I have; it sounds like a few others I've closed in disgust. How ironic that you stumbled on it via a book club!


Laura Debbie,
Where's your sense of romance? C'mon now, very little is new under the sun, cut Mr. Sparks some slack; it's hard to churn out quality books year after year. Some people really only produce one in a lifetime!
hugs, Laura


Olivia I agree completely, especially the Lifetime movie comment. haha!


Books Ring Mah Bell PERFECT review!


Phantomphiljt I thought the book was really good! The trick is to read only one spark book every once in a long while, and they will remain interesting- too much, and it drones.


Lauren Thank you for this. Describing this book as a "Lifetime Movie" is perfect. I agree completely with your description of Singer, how he's almost dead and suddenly is able to come flying across the beach to save Julie. I mean, I believe in miracles, but not when they're so unrealistic as that!


message 7: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Thank you for saving me the time I would ha e wasted on this book. Much obliged!


Rebekah The police officer was hit in the head with a tire iron, not shot in the head. Of course, it's okay if you still hated it.


message 9: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly K Thanks for saving me the time! Our library is closed so I grabbed this off of my shelf to bring to the beach. Sparks is sappy but I thought it might be an okay beach read. Yeesh, I already figured the dog was the guardian and the nice guy would be a nightmare and she was meant to be with the best friend in the first chapter or two. Plus who can鈥檛 tell that there is a live animal in the box they鈥檙e holding? Such drivel!


message 10: by L (new) - rated it 2 stars

L Yes and thanks! I looked up reviews at Chapter 4 wondering if it was just me. Thanks for sparing me...


back to top