ŷ

flo's Reviews > The Book of Disquiet

The Book of Disquiet by Fernando Pessoa
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
21575078
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites, pessoanism, brazilian-portuguese

If I write what I feel, it’s to reduce the fever of feeling. What I confess is unimportant, because everything is unimportant. I make landscapes out of what I feel. I make holidays of my sensations. (42)

He who does not know how to populate his solitude, does not know either how to be alone in a busy crowd.
- Charles Baudelaire, Crowds

Some dreams want to transcend our minds. They want to feel alive, be outside and become reality. We all have dreamed about things that, even after we woke up, we are not sure if they actually happened or never left the secure yet claustrophobic mind of ours. And so, while those dreams are trying to abandon that place, magic can happen. When they realize they can't, tragedy awaits.
This is the story of a man who lived a thousand lives and wrote about the fragile boundary between reality and dreaming with the most beautiful and heartbreaking prose I've ever encountered.

I wanted to read this book for a long time. When I found it, I did something I try not to do: I skimmed it. I wanted to see something before my better judgment had control over my literary anxiety. Before I knew, I found myself reading a mesmerizing passage that I couldn't leave until I finished it.
Lucid Diary
My life: a tragedy booed off stage by the gods, never getting beyond the first act.
Friends: not one. Just a few acquaintances who imagine they feel something for me and who might be sorry if a train ran over me and the funeral was on a rainy day. The logical reward of my detachment from life is the incapacity I’ve created in others to feel anything for me. There’s an aureole of indifference, an icy halo, that surrounds me and repels others. I still haven’t succeeded in not suffering from my solitude. It’s hard to achieve that distinction of spirit whereby isolation becomes a repose without anguish... (579)

From that moment, I just knew it was going to be an extremely emotional experience. Whoever said that reading is a passive activity, never found a book with the power of taking his soul out for a ride.
What a book. I could relate to almost every word. Every yearning for something that could never happen. Every loss that did happen. Every thought made by a restless mind. And every feeling conceived by an isolated heart longing for an endless dream. A cure. Redemption. Or nothing.

The melancholic beauty of his prose and the heartbreaking honesty of his sorrow made me feel too small. And relieved. Suddenly, many of my thoughts and feelings were exposed in those pages that I was never able to write. And he did it. Pessoa did it with the most exquisite language you could ever hope to find.

The atmosphere is filled with an overwhelming sense of failure and frustration.
I envy � but I’m not sure that I envy � those for whom a biography could be written, or who could write their own. In these random impressions, and with no desire to be other than random, I indifferently narrate my factless autobiography, my lifeless history. These are my Confessions, and if in them I say nothing, it’s because I have nothing to say. (42)

Each drop of rain is my failed life weeping in nature. There’s something of my disquiet in the endless drizzle, then shower, then drizzle, then shower, through which the day’s sorrow uselessly pours itself out over the earth.
It rains and keeps raining. My soul is damp from hearing it. So much rain... (177)

Solitude.
Solitude devastates me; company oppresses me. (80)

Again, fluid and uncertain, the rain pattered. Time dragged to its accompaniment. My soul’s solitude grew and spread, invading what I felt, what I wanted, and what I was going to dream. The room’s hazy objects, which shared my insomnia in the shadows, moved with their sadness into my desolation. (285)

Uncertainties.
And so, not knowing how to believe in God and unable to believe in an aggregate of animals, I, along with other people on the fringe, kept a distance from things... Could it think, the heart would stop beating. (30)

I've never had anyone I could call ‘Master�. No Christ died for me. No Buddha showed me the way. No Apollo or Athena, in my loftiest dreams, ever appeared to enlighten my soul. (533)

And many other displays of human nature. Devastating situations that contrast themselves with the lyrical beauty of this man's writing.
His crude words are still little sunbeams that could enlighten the obscure depths of our souls, only if we let them. In that so human selfishness of ours, we always think nobody is suffering more than we do. We are the only ones struggling to survive in this world that we never asked for. Well, we are not; that is not an extraordinary epiphany. But reading the words of a man whose thoughts are so familiar to us always represents an inspirational experience. We feel like we just found the necessary balm to soothe our pain. That is the healing power of understanding. Of empathy.
We are not alone. We never were. Like Soares in this book, I am acquainted with isolation more than I would have wanted to. I breathe it. I am made of it. And still, somehow, I am not alone.
A breath of music or of a dream, of something that would make me almost feel, something that would make me not think. (57)

Being fatally sensitive can be exhausting and a perpetual cause of sorrow. But the so-desired inability to feel resembles to being dead inside a living body. Human existence doesn't limit itself to some functional organs. Feeling nothing is not the answer. You might as well be truly dead.

So, yes. This book is my newest treasure. My diary and sanctuary. I can't help but to be grateful. It filled my head with many questions that I wish I could find the answers by myself.
What to do when we are forced to leave the safe place our dreams represent? Can they make us do it? Will we ever find the strength enough to face the world? Do we have to?
Do we dare?
I sleep when I dream of what doesn't exist; dreaming of what might exist wakes me up. (179)

Life should be about finding a sane balance between reality and fantasy. That reminds me of something I found the other day. I don't know if the following words really belong to Pizarnik—they sure sound like her—and since I couldn't find them in English, I kind of translated them. Trust me, they are too beautiful in Spanish. So, I apologize in advance.

I am simply not from this world... I frenziedly dwell in the moon. I am not afraid of dying; I am afraid of this foreign, aggressive land...
I cannot think about specific things; I am not interested. I cannot speak like everybody else. My words are foreign, they come from far away... What will I do when I plunge myself in my wildest dreams and cannot ascend? Because that is going to happen, eventually. I will go and I won't know how to come back. Moreover, I will not know that there is a "coming back". I will not want it, perhaps.


No. Pessoa was not alone.

According to this book, Soares was not a pessimist. He was sad. He suffered and dreamed. And he complained without knowing if suffering was the norm, if he deserved it for some reason. However, he rejoiced in the fact that he could play with his complaints and made them musical because he was an artist. He could give beauty to his complaints and dreams.
But, if you can't do that, if you are not an artist... well. What then?




Note: I read the English (Zenith) and Spanish (Crespo) translations at the same time. I prefer the English one.
Apr 27, 14


* Also on
** Other reviews:
A Little Larger Than the Entire Universe: Selected Poems
The Selected Prose of Fernando Pessoa
The Education of the Stoic
El Banquero Anarquista (written in Spanish)
135 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Book of Disquiet.
Sign In »

Quotes flo Liked

Fernando Pessoa
“I wasn’t meant for reality, but life came and found me.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet

Fernando Pessoa
“My past is everything I failed to be.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet

Fernando Pessoa
“I'd woken up early, and I took a long time getting ready to exist.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet

Fernando Pessoa
“Literature is the most agreeable way of ignoring life.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet

Fernando Pessoa
“I feel as if I'm always on the verge of waking up.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet

Fernando Pessoa
“There are ships sailing to many ports, but not a single one goes where life is not painful.”
Fernando Pessoa, The Book of Disquiet


Reading Progress

July 11, 2013 – Shelved
February 7, 2014 – Started Reading
February 7, 2014 –
page 42
7.72% "Besides, what can I expect from myself? My sensations in all their horrible acuity, and a profound awareness of feeling... A sharp mind that only destroys me, and an unusual capacity for dreaming to keep me entertained... A dead will and a reflection that cradles it, like a living child... -- Oh my. And this is just the beginning. I LOVE IT."
February 9, 2014 –
page 73
13.42% "I like the English translation and the Spanish structure. I'm in trouble."
February 11, 2014 –
page 134
24.63% "Life, would you give me a couple of minutes to read what I want?!"
February 15, 2014 –
page 179
32.9% "We inhabit dreams, we are shadows roaming through impossible forests, in which the trees are houses, customs, ideas, ideals and philosophies.
Never finding God, and never even knowing if God exists! Passing from world to world... forever coddled by illusion, forever caressed by error. Never arriving at Truth (...) Never completely at peace but always with a hint of peace, always with a longing for it!"
February 20, 2014 –
page 200
36.76% "I have to choose what I detest � either dreaming, which my intelligence hates, or action, which my sensibility loathes; either action, for which I wasn't born, or dreaming, for which no one was born. Detesting both, I choose neither; but since I must on occasion either dream or act, I mix the two things together."
February 27, 2014 –
page 235
43.2% "Tired, I close the shutters of my windows, I exclude the world, and I have a few moments of freedom. Tomorrow I’ll go back to being a slave, but right now � alone, needing no one, and worried only that some voice or presence might disturb me � I have my little freedom, my moment of excelsis.
Leaning back in my chair, I forget the life that oppresses me. Nothing pains me besides having felt pain."
March 17, 2014 –
page 258
47.43% "To write is to forget. Literature is the most agreeable way of ignoring life. Music soothes, the visual arts exhilarate, and the performing arts (such as acting and dance) entertain. Literature, however, retreats from life by turning it into a slumber."
April 17, 2014 –
page 265
48.71% "Peace at last. All that was dross and residue vanishes from my soul as if it had never been. I’m alone and calm. It’s like the moment when I could theoretically convert to a religion. But although I’m no longer attracted to anything down here, I’m also not attracted to anything up above. I feel free, as if I’d ceased to exist and were conscious of that fact."
April 19, 2014 – Finished Reading
December 22, 2018 – Shelved (Kindle Edition)

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


message 1: by Dolors (last edited Apr 21, 2014 10:26AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Taking a seat on the first row not to miss your review, Florencia. Can't wait to read what you make of this tormented poet and his multiple personalities who led an isolated life of frenetic mental activity but little action. And a lot of tedium! :)


message 2: by flo (new) - added it

flo Oh my, in that short comment you described him so beautifully. I should quote you and that's it. Same thing with TBK.
Probably during the weekend I'll be able to write something coherent. Thank you for always being present to give words of encouragement :)


Agnieszka Excellent review , Florencia!
I could relate to almost every word. Every yearning for something that could never happen. Every loss that did happen... I absolutely agree with everything you've written. For me Pessoa with this book was a real eye-opener .


Rakhi Dalal A heartfelt review,Florencia.


message 5: by Dolors (last edited Apr 27, 2014 02:24PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors "Like Soares in this book, I am acquainted with isolation more than I would have wanted to. I breath it. I am made of it. And still, somehow, I am not alone."
People who manage to extract the essence of a book, process and make it their own and then pour their soul down in their unique voice, like the way you did with this review, won't ever be alone. Specially when tackling a writer who contained multitudes! :)
Florencia, I think you have outdone yourself with this superb piece of writing. Pessoa's crowded soul reverberated in each of your pulsating words. An isolated, restless and uncertain man paralized in inaction for fear of disillusionment, yet a genial dreamer, a mystical poet, a multifaceted wordsmith who lived thousands of lives in his mind and who gave meaning to his own existence through writing.
You capture the dichotomy of the man and the myth coexisting in Pessoa with your review, giving them an inimitable tonality with your lyrical voice. You managed to extract the beauty of Soares' sadness and transform it into a melodious song of hope and redemption for those who dare to dream, even if those dreams only materialize in their minds. Absolutely magnificent review, Florencia. Congratulations.


message 6: by flo (new) - added it

flo Agnieszka wrote: "Excellent review , Florencia!
I could relate to almost every word. Every yearning for something that could never happen. Every loss that did happen... I absolutely agree with everything you've wr..."


Thank you, Agnieszka! I'm glad you agree. This is a very special book that I wish everyone could read at least once in their lifetime.


message 7: by flo (new) - added it

flo Rakhi wrote: "A heartfelt review,Florencia."

Thank you for your comment, Rakhi! And for taking the time to read this. Nice to meet you also :)


message 8: by flo (new) - added it

flo Dolors wrote: ""Like Soares in this book, I am acquainted with isolation more than I would have wanted to. I breath it. I am made of it. And still, somehow, I am not alone."
People who manage to extract the esse..."


Oh, Dolors. I can't think of anything to respond to your beautiful and encouraging comment. Nothing but a huge and heartfelt thank you. I was never able to write about a book without mixing a bit of myself. I'm not familiar with "objectivism", heh. Something I regret but I can't change. This book is a new safe place to where I can come back every time I feel an aimlessly sorrow. Or an immense joy, why not? :P
You defined Pessoa perfectly. Like Whitman, he contained multitudes. Meeting such a person through his books is an indescribable experience. Thank you very much for your words, Dolors. This was a wonderful way to start this Monday :)


Giedre "Whoever said that reading is a passive activity, never found a book with the power of taking his soul out for a ride."
You are close to entering the list of my favourite quotes, Florencia! And what an amazing review. I have not read the book, but by sharing so openly your own feelings when reading it you infused it with life and "took my soul for a ride" even before the book reached my hands.


message 10: by flo (new) - added it

flo Giedre wrote: ""Whoever said that reading is a passive activity, never found a book with the power of taking his soul out for a ride."
You are close to entering the list of my favourite quotes, Florencia! And wha..."


Thank you, Giedre! You are too kind. I believe this is really a must-read. If you liked these little notes of mine, I'm sure you'll love this man's brilliant writing. Thank you, again :)


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Florencia you have written an exquisite review that gives us a touch of the sadness; the uncertainty and the Solitude. You are right, Pessoa was not alone. Together we readers are trying to find that balance between reality and fantasy--though the boundary keeps changing and forcing us to continually recalibrate. I love how you describe this book as a sanctuary and a diary wherein we find parts of ourselves. Even as some dreams transcend our minds, this review transcends the of the thoughts of an ordinary reader. You show yourself as most perceptive and sympathetic reader--an ideal one about whom perhaps even the shy Pessoa dared to dream. Well done and superbly executed review, Florencia.


message 12: by flo (last edited May 02, 2014 06:28PM) (new) - added it

flo Steve Sckenda wrote: "Florencia you have written an exquisite review that gives us a touch of the sadness; the uncertainty and the Solitude. You are right, Pessoa was not alone. Together we readers are trying to find th..."

Well. I'm back. Kind of. Worst four days of my life. I'm sorry for the late reply but still, I wanted to express how grateful I am for receiving such a nice comment. Talented writers (not only reviewers, oh no) that actually find these things worth reading... I couldn't ask for more. Thank you so much for your kind words, Steve!


message 13: by Tej (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tej And so, while those dreams are trying to abandon that place, magic can happen. When they realize they can't, tragedy awaits.

You talk of 'relief' Florencia, in reading this poem of Disquiet, I would add to that that it is a great relief as well to find so many disquieted souls, wrenched hearts, who can appreciate and understand, strike a chord with this beautiful yet fearsome book... Fearsome because it feigns no mercy in laying bare the deepest recesses which hide in the veils of pretensions so meticulously developed by mere act of existing...
You have indeed embellished Pessoa with this heartfelt piece of writing that captures so well the 'feel' of Pessoa... And on the question you ask at the very end, I can only add my own voice and ask... what then indeed? Maybe that is what seperated mortals and eternal and that ought to remain so or else life has to be something else altogether :)
But with this beautiful review, you have accomplished the most or maybe also the least that anyone can attain... that is to strive for the artist in us and amplify the voice of the grand artists such as Pessoa...!


message 14: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue Wonderful review and I also love your comment 're taking the soul out for a ride. Perfect! I plan to read Pessoa this summer and you have given me such a great and ranging picture of what is ahead. He seems to express the human condition (if one is open to all possibilities). Thanks.


message 15: by Praj (new)

Praj Splendid!!Such a beautiful elucidation of Pessoa's prose. Thanks, Florencia!


message 16: by flo (new) - added it

flo Tej wrote: "And so, while those dreams are trying to abandon that place, magic can happen. When they realize they can't, tragedy awaits.

You talk of 'relief' Florencia, in reading this poem of Disquiet, I wou..."


Thank you for your kind, beautiful and accurate answer, Tej! This book touched every fiber of my being. I'm so glad that many people feel that way. And I truly appreciate the fact that you answered that question by the end of the review. I was a bit heartbroken because if you're an artist, you can embellish life with your talent. I don't feel like one, so, I asked that sad "What then?" in order to find... I don't know really. I don't know if it is safe to know the real answer.
Thank you for taking the time to read this, Tej.


message 17: by flo (new) - added it

flo Sue wrote: "Wonderful review and I also love your comment 're taking the soul out for a ride. Perfect! I plan to read Pessoa this summer and you have given me such a great and ranging picture of what is ahead..."

Thank you, Sue! I'm glad you're planning on reading this brilliant author's work. And yes, prepare for a heavy, beautiful and enlightening ride :)


message 18: by flo (new) - added it

flo Rajeev wrote: "In that so human selfishness of ours, we always think nobody is suffering more than we do. We are the only ones struggling to survive in this world that we never asked for. Well, we are not; that i..."

Heh, we're not fools, Rajeev. We're humans. I wrote that because I do that all the time. It's our nature. I might be aware of it but that doesn't mean I don't feel like that anyway. It's an everyday struggle. Literature and the possibility of exchanging our thoughts in this place is my cure. Thank you for reading these little notes of mine.


message 19: by flo (new) - added it

flo Praj wrote: "Splendid!!Such a beautiful elucidation of Pessoa's prose. Thanks, Florencia!"

Thank you, Praj! For taking time to read this and leave such an encouraging comment :)


Garima Devastating situations that contrast themselves with the lyrical beauty of this man's writing.

Beautiful! And there are many other quotable lines in your review. I'm yet to read any Pessoa's work and I'm surely missing out on a lot so your review was an exquisite reminder to do at the earliest.


message 21: by flo (new) - added it

flo Garima wrote: "Devastating situations that contrast themselves with the lyrical beauty of this man's writing.

Beautiful! And there are many other quotable lines in your review. I'm yet to read any Pessoa's work ..."


I'm so sorry, Garima; I missed your comment. It's been days since I stopped receiving all my email notifications. Thank you very much for your thoughts on this humble "review". I can't wait to read your opinion about this book :)


message 22: by Renato (new) - added it

Renato What an amazing and comprehensive review, bravo! This one is on my list to be read... I really need to make some time for it and your review certainly will help me with that!


message 23: by flo (new) - added it

flo Renato wrote: "What an amazing and comprehensive review, bravo! This one is on my list to be read... I really need to make some time for it and your review certainly will help me with that!"

Thank you for your kind comment, Renato. I hope you read it. This is the most perfect book to start with this writer's outstanding work!


message 24: by Jenny's (new) - added it

Jenny's  This is exactly the reason I love reading your reviews! You have a tremendous ability to capture the worth and beauty in books. I also admire your finesse at finding such beautiful books. Thanks Florencia


message 25: by flo (new) - added it

flo Jenny wrote: "This is exactly the reason I love reading your reviews! You have a tremendous ability to capture the worth and beauty in books. I also admire your finesse at finding such beautiful books. Thanks ..."

Thank you very much, Jenny! I'm glad you added this marvelous work. I appreciate your kind comment and hope you enjoy this book.


message 26: by Kastoori (new) - added it

Kastoori After reading your review I immediately ordered this book online and now I'm hooked to it ^_^


message 27: by flo (new) - added it

flo Kastoori wrote: "After reading your review I immediately ordered this book online and now I'm hooked to it ^_^"

I'm so glad you decided to read this, Kastoori! I'll wait for your thoughts on this :) Hope you enjoy it!


message 28: by Junta (last edited Dec 29, 2015 02:48PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Junta Beautiful review.


message 29: by flo (new) - added it

flo Junta wrote: "Beautiful review."

Thank you.


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)

"Could it think, the heart would stop beating. "
Brilliant. Awesome review, Florencia.


message 31: by Jibran (new) - added it

Jibran What a lovely review, Florencia. Makes me wonder why I still haven't read this one!


message 32: by flo (last edited Apr 11, 2016 10:47AM) (new) - added it

flo Sidharth wrote: " "Could it think, the heart would stop beating. "
Brilliant. Awesome review, Florencia."


That line expresses so much truth. What a statement! Breathtakingly beautiful and incredibly poignant. But above all, unusually honest.
Thanks so much for reading and commenting.


Jibran wrote: "What a lovely review, Florencia. Makes me wonder why I still haven't read this one!"

I'm surprised! I hope you read this gem soon, Jibran. I don't usually recommend books, but I have the feeling you will enjoy this one. Thanks for your comment. :)


message 33: by [deleted user] (new)

Such a passionate review, Florencia. Your unadulterated love for this book doubtless inculcates in us the essence of powerful literature, and wonders that come along.


message 34: by flo (new) - added it

flo Waqas wrote: "Such a passionate review, Florencia. Your unadulterated love for this book doubtless inculcates in us the essence of powerful literature, and wonders that come along."

I'm really looking forward to the time you get to this unique gem and captivate us all with your wonderful prose. I think you might enjoy it very much. Thank you for reading and commenting! :)


Matthias Very powerful review Florencia, which does justice to this treasure, this diary, this sanctuary, as you so aptly called it! I have the impression our reactions to this book are quite similar :)


message 36: by flo (new) - added it

flo Matthias wrote: "Very powerful review Florencia, which does justice to this treasure, this diary, this sanctuary, as you so aptly called it! I have the impression our reactions to this book are quite similar :)"

Apparently so. ;) Thanks for dropping by, Matthias. And for your kind words.


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

Oh, Flor, this was such a spritiual exercise! I cannot tell you how strongly every single word of your splendid review spoke to me... and I thank you for that with all my heart. Now I know I'm not alone. :)


message 38: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fabulous review, Florencia! The line on solitude and company - equally difficult - really rings true to me in all its absurdity.


message 39: by flo (last edited Mar 17, 2017 07:03AM) (new) - added it

flo Scarlett wrote: "Oh, Flor, this was such a spritiual exercise! I cannot tell you how strongly every single word of your splendid review spoke to me... and I thank you for that with all my heart. Now I know I'm not ..."

That's wonderful to hear, Scarlett. Many thanks for your lovely words.
Listening to the echo of one's voice and still thinking one is not alone. Literature can be quite comforting, that was one of the main themes of this review.


message 40: by flo (new) - added it

flo Lisa wrote: "Fabulous review, Florencia! The line on solitude and company - equally difficult - really rings true to me in all its absurdity."

As you so rightly put it, Lisa, "in all its absurdity." Thank you for your comment. :)


Vessey I could relate to almost every word.

Yes, this was how I felt while reading this astonishing book. I wanted it to end more quickly, because it was so harrowing. The deep pain there, a pain I could relate to so well, was too overwhelming. Yet, exactly for this very reason, exactly because it was something so close to me and because I always feel responsible for others� suffering, even if it’s about the suffering of someone long gone, I didn’t want it to end. Because of that and because of the incredible beauty in his prose that left me humbled and grateful. And you have more than done justice to him, Florencia. Yesterday I told my friend Matthias that his and one other friend’s were the best reviews of this book I had come across. However, you stole the first place from them. :) I can wholeheartedly say that this was IT. You have nailed it. :) Here are my most favourite lines, though the whole thing was amazing.

I am acquainted with isolation more than I would have wanted to. I breath it. I am made of it. And still, somehow, I am not alone.

A breath of music or of a dream, of something that would make me almost feel, something that would make me not think.

Being fatally sensitive can be exhausting and a perpetual cause of sorrow.


In regards of the first one, this is the way I have felt my whole life. And you have expressed it better than I could ever have. Thank you for that!

In regards of the second one, it reminds me of this passage from John Williams� Stoner

"It was as if from moment to moment his mind were emptied of all it knew and as if his will were drained of its strength. He felt at times that he was a kind of vegetable, and he longed for something - even pain - to pierce him, to bring him alive."

I know that feeling very well.

And in regards of the third one, yes, it can be exhausting and a perpetual cause of sorrow, but it can also have the opposite effect. Being that sensitive is a knife with two blades. You feel both the positive and the negative more deeply. It’s both weakness and strength. Luckily, when it comes to compassionate and talented people, like Fernando Pessoa and yourself, even pain is beautiful. Because people like you experience it in a way that gives it meaning, you manage to reach out to others and show that they are not alone in what they feel. Be it directly or through art. Some of the most incredible art creations are results of intense suffering. This reminds me of what I read once in an interview with a woman whose husband had died of cancer. She said that one of the things they both agreed on was that like is not about avoiding suffering, but about creating meaning.

Thanks again for this fantastic review! :)


message 42: by flo (new) - added it

flo Jean-Paul wrote: "I'm so happy that this review has resurfaced thanks to the recent praise and comments by Matthias, Scarlett and Lisa. I have already read all of Pessoa's poetic heteronyms and have been holding out..."

I did that also with some writers, I started reading other books by them and saved their masterpieces for last. In any case, I hope you enjoy this remarkable book, Jean-Paul. I look forward to hearing your thoughts on it. Thank you, as ever, for your kind words. And for quoting those words, it was nice to reread them.


message 43: by flo (last edited Mar 18, 2017 11:26AM) (new) - added it

flo Vessey wrote: "I could relate to almost every word.

Yes, this was how I felt while reading this astonishing book. I wanted it to end more quickly, because it was so harrowing. The deep pain there, a pain I could..."



Being that sensitive is a knife with two blades... It’s both weakness and strength.
Oh yes, we know.

I'm very grateful for such a thoughtful comment that one just don't see every day, Vessey. It's an honor to have a GR friend who reads one's nonsense and reflects that fact through a beautiful comment. I'm glad you also love this captivating book; a collection of thoughts which portraits an aspect of human nature we often (try to) hide. And I'm also glad because in this review you found some lines you were able to identify with. Thank you for including your own thoughts on said lines. No pressure, but this book needs your review.

To me, this is one of those special reviews one wants to delete, because it reveals too much - and anyone who's actually paying attention to this, may realize and decipher me in a heartbeat. Fortunately, not many people have read this, perhaps not even some of those who 'liked' it. :P So I feel safe for now. And the thought that I can't do otherwise, ironically, is comforting. I don't know how to write a somewhat objective analysis. So this will keep happening!

Thanks for quoting Stoner, a book I still have to read. That was a very powerful quote. From a certain perspective, being a vegetable could be one of Pessoa's dreams, when it comes to stop thinking. :)
...to be too conscious is an illness - a real thorough-going illness. Our Underground Man.

Heh, I just read your comment on Matthias' write-up, another fine analysis. He mentioned Junta's review, that's another one that does justice to this masterpiece. *clings to the first place on Vessey's list as hard as she can*

This might be the reason why I fight my impulse to edit or entirely delete this review: Luckily, when it comes to compassionate and talented people, like Fernando Pessoa and yourself, even pain is beautiful. Because people like you experience it in a way that gives it meaning, you manage to reach out to others and show that they are not alone in what they feel.
Words like yours; lovely, transparent words that put a big smile on my face, and that make me think that maybe not everything about out existence is futile. Thanks so much, Vessey.


Matthias Though this is by no means a contest, I just wanted to go on record by saying that I agree with Vessey's sentiment that this is the best, number 1 review, though I'd like you to consider to share your spot with Junta. And Vessey's comments could be called reviews in themselves for all the insight they show. The isolation you mentioned and that Vessey expounded upon, it made me think of this book as a means to bind us through our isolation, all the while respecting our need for it.


message 45: by flo (new) - added it

flo Matthias wrote: "Though this is by no means a contest, I just wanted to go on record by saying that I agree with Vessey's sentiment that this is the best, number 1 review, though I'd like you to consider to share y..."

Oh, must I? I don't like sharing such a precious spot. Alright, I can go as far as 70/30. And perhaps even 50/50 concerning people who I'm friends with.
Just kidding, of course. :) All reviews of this great book are incredibly special. Intimate pieces of writing which reflect how Pessoa's words made us feel. Including comments that, as you say, are reviews in themselves; Vessey's are a perfect example (but I still would love to read her review!)
Thanks for sharing more of your thoughts, Matthias.


message 46: by Gaurav (last edited Mar 24, 2017 08:10AM) (new) - added it

Gaurav Wow!! This is only what I can say about it, Florencia, I wish I could write so effortlessly yet so soulfully !
Really a heart-warming review which is filled with your own deep impressions, I think this is your best of all I’ve read yet; Pessoa really pulled out best of you. And how true the lines- I can very well relate to them-
We all have dreamed about things that, even after we woke up, we are not sure if they actually happened or never left the secure yet claustrophobic mind of ours. And so, while those dreams are trying to abandon that place, magic can happen. When they realize they can't, tragedy awaits.
- Aren’t those dreams impressions of our life, for more often than not we take refuse in those dreams (sometimes consciously, sometimes unconsciously) from struggle of our existential anxiety and it’s ironical that we also take inspiration from those impressions.
The lines- The logical reward of my detachment from life is the incapacity I’ve created in others to feel anything for me. There’s an aureole of indifference, an icy halo, that surrounds me and repels others. I still haven’t succeeded in not suffering from my solitude. It’s hard to achieve that distinction of spirit whereby isolation becomes a repose without anguish... - probably reflects human nature quite aptly, for man is always in this dilemma to be isolated from others � so that one can meet oneself truly- however time and again one feels longing for other- perhaps the psychological need of being a human being, the existence of being from ‘The Others� as propagated by Sartre; and the quote of Balzac comes to mind- ‘’Solitude is fine, but you need someone to tell you that solitude is fine.’�

Your lines- We are the only ones struggling to survive in this world that we never asked for. Well, we are not; that is not an extraordinary epiphany. But reading the words of a man whose thoughts are so familiar to us always represents an inspirational experience. We feel like we just found the necessary balm to soothe our pain. That is the healing power of understanding. Of empathy. - so perfectly portrays human condition perhaps it’s one of those qualities which differentiate intelligent beings from others (though man always cribs that human beings are the most ‘intelligent� species or the only: P).

Your last lines- According to this book, Soares was not a pessimist. He was sad. He suffered and dreamed. And he complained without knowing if suffering was the norm, if he deserved it for some reason. However, he rejoiced in the fact that he could play with his complaints and made them musical because he was an artist. He could give beauty to his complaints and dreams.
But, if you can't do that, if you are not an artist... well. What then?
- reminds me of Albert Camus who says human beings are condemned to exist but the very understanding and acceptance that life is absurd is the start of conscious existence. You’ve posed very interesting but a serious question in the end- that what if we can’t play with our sufferings, what if we don’t have distractions (like reading, movies, music, sports etc) would we be condemned to exist so forever, would we be labeled as ‘pessimists�; perhaps ‘The myth of Sisyphus� is required to keep us moving as we, human beings, are emotionally weak and always need the thin thread of hope to continue (perhaps that’s why concepts of God and religion exist), I feel it would one of the extreme situations either we would become totally absurd as in terms of Camus and thereafter live being conscious of it or as weak beings we are, we may go to other extreme. Sorry, I’ve this bad habit of firstly to poke my nose in things which interest me and secondly to digress while I write or talk and perhaps that’s why I, more often than not, end up with paragraphs rather than just a few lines.

Thanks for sharing this beautiful review of a wonderful book, though I’ve attempted it earlier but didn’t finish it, will be trying it out soon.


message 47: by flo (new) - added it

flo Gaurav wrote: "Wow!! This is only what I can say about it, Florencia, I wish I could write so effortlessly yet so soulfully !
Really a heart-warming review which is filled with your own deep impressions, I think ..."


Gaurav wrote: "Wow!! This is only what I can say about it, Florencia, I wish I could write so effortlessly yet so soulfully !
Really a heart-warming review which is filled with your own deep impressions, I think ..."


It's always a pleasure to read your comments, Gaurav. :) When I write something, I can be quite selfish; I don't write for others but for myself, to express something I need to express - triggered by the book, of course - and the whole process sometimes makes me feel rather relieved. But when someone actually reads my words and then writes such lovely and thoughtful comments, that process brings me comfort. It gives a sense of empathy and establishes some sort of connection, no matter how brief. Pessoa is the perfect writer to experience such connections.

I completely agree with your thoughts on dreams as manifestations of life. Those lines were inspired by something real. I remember the feeling of uncertainty when I was thinking about something. I started to doubt if that something actually had happened or it was my mind the one playing tricks on me, making me think that what I wanted and knew I could never get, it actually happened.
I mentioned that same quote by Balzac not long ago! I went through that phase myself, celebrating solitude only outwardly. But time passes and I'm trying to leave that unnecessary hypocrisy behind.

Your ability to connect ideas is astonishing. Camus and Sartre are very appropriate names to bring to the table. My views on that final question that ends this review were more pessimistic, I think. :P Considering I'm no artist. It was aimed at the active process of creation, rather than the slightly passive activity of absorbing entertainment. If you can't transform emptiness into something, if you're not an artist able to take chaos and transform it into beauty thanks to writing, painting, music... what then? That question reverberates even more powerfully when one doesn't have a divine concept to hold on to. Without it, the meaning of life seems even more elusive - in case there is one. But these doubts seem more genuine to me somehow, more connected to our weak nature. The notion of a meaningless existence is certainly appealing, now I'd like to meet someone who actually believes it and behaves without contradictions. I even wonder what Camus might have felt when his life was almost over.

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to write some more. :P I'm looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this captivating book; hopefully, you'll write something about it. *fingers crossed*


message 48: by Tara (new)

Tara A beautiful review for a beautiful book, and such an excellent choice to open with that Baudelaire quote. I couldn’t agree more that ”whoever said that reading is a passive activity, never found a book with the power of taking his soul out for a ride.� This haunting book was a much more breath-taking ride than I was expecting it to be. Your review so perfectly captures that lovely flavor of melancholy that permeated his prose, and I enjoyed reading your thoughts on isolation and sensitivity, sorrow and art, reality and fantasy. In Pessoa, for the most part, I too found a kindred spirit, and look forward to picking the book up whenever I need encouragement and a quiet place to rest, again and again. He’s remarkable!


message 49: by flo (new) - added it

flo Tara wrote: "A beautiful review for a beautiful book, and such an excellent choice to open with that Baudelaire quote. I couldn’t agree more that ”whoever said that reading is a passive activity, never found a ..."

Funny, sad or stupid, I'm still wondering the answer to the question that closes these rambling thoughts. I haven't read the entire review in quite some time. Things I dread, now. ;P But thank you for taking some time to read it and leave your words. I already have the Portuguese edition to enjoy "when I have some free time" to revisit his complex universe. Really looking forward to reading that gem with Pessoa's exact words.


message 50: by Tara (new)

Tara Florencia wrote: "Tara wrote: "A beautiful review for a beautiful book, and such an excellent choice to open with that Baudelaire quote. I couldn’t agree more that ”whoever said that reading is a passive activity, n..."

Hmm, complaints without beauty or musicality...well, on the humorous end of the spectrum, teenage diaries frequently qualify, my own included :p Reading him in Portuguese would be tremendous! It’s hard to imagine his prose being much better than it was in the remarkable Zenith translation—how do you improve on such consistently dazzling beauty?—but no doubt it will be even more powerful to read him “unfiltered,� so to speak.


« previous 1
back to top