ŷ

Layla Lozada's Reviews > Good Wives: Illustrated by Ella Bailey

Good Wives by Louisa May Alcott
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
102879860
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites
Read 2 times. Last read July 24, 2024 to October 17, 2024.

Louisa May Alcott has done it again with Good Wives. This is my second time reading Good Wives, however the magnitude of its writing will never cease to amaze me. Might I daresay this was an improvement on its predecessor, Little Women? While Little Women (the book itself and the book series) remains to be one of the greatest literary pieces of all time, I do believe that Good Wives was the book that solidified its position amongst the greatest of American literature.

Before reading beyond this, I'd like to issue a spoiler and lenghth warning. Long review ahead.

While many fans of Little Women often hate this book for its ending mainly relating with Jo and Laurie, I do think that Louisa May Alcott did a very fine job in writing Jo's and Laurie's ending. The March sisters are written beautifully and did very well in its portrayal of the joys and pains of girlhood and womanhood. While I did like Jo's ending, I think it would sent a more powerful message for her to not have ended up with anyone. I understand she didn't due to the restrictions of the publisher's on Alcott's writing. However, I happen to love Jo's story with Friedrich Bhaer. For a an intelligent and highly spirited person like Jo, love will always be "go big or go home", so I agree that she could only fall for someone whom she could challenged by and whom she adore and respect. The professor not only fits her standards, but goes above it. Many tend to ship Jo and Laurie due to their friendship and alikeness with both even initially starting their friendship to hide from a party, but as the saying goes, opposites attract. Jo and Laurie understood each other in the way only they both could, but this was the same reason that they both quarelled constantly. In this book, Jo even tries to change Laurie, in hopes that she'd fall in love with him, she however doesn't. I think Jo and Laurie's relationship written by Louisa May Alcott with it being rooted in reality, that while the whirlwind and passionate romance is as passionate as it is, this is the very reason why it can't work. Not only that, but Jo NEVER saw Laurie in any romantic sense. For Jo, there was only going to ever be one, and it was the person who could surprise and calm her fiery soul. As for Laurie, the same goes for him and needed the reciprocity and constant guidance that Jo would never have been able to provide had they married while Laurie would not have been able to same Jo either. Laurie and Amy are meant to be and Louisa May Alcott wrote their story in a way that made it so, likewise with Jo and Friedrich. Both Jo and Laurie also begin to recuperate from their depression and aimlessness once both had met their respective partners, because it was then that they were able to blossom into the best versions of themselves. Just as determined about their dreams, without the poor temper and sadness that afflicted them from achieving the things they can.

I can't write about Little Women without talking about all sisters. All of them were given very differing paths from each other, however their individual stories make this book what it is. Meg being the least discussed despite her having a very interesting yet normal ending. Meg's story was the most grounded of the four. Many don't agree with her marriage with John, her marriage seemed a happy one despite its highs and lows. Their love was genuine and of all the relationships seem the most united and stable. Meg and John communicate about their needs and its what keeps their marriage happy and stable. They were both good parents providing the required parenting and affection their children needed. At first, John had tried to avoid getting in Meg's way of parenting and in turn unwittingly neglected to notice how much help his wife needed. Once he saw this however he decides to be more involved and discipline their children when Meg didn't have the heart to do exactly that. Their marriage works because both have what the other lacks and needs, while simultaneously working to contribute in their respective ways to the marriage.

Amy has arguably the biggest development in the books and probably the most chapters in Good Wives. While she did have a temper much like Jo's, she grew out of it sooner than Jo and of the four is the most mature, gaining the most realistic and rational understanding of their society and her responsibilities to her family. Amy grows to be a very charming and beautiful young woman, and later thrives in the social circles they moved in as she tries to fit in while working towards her dreams of becoming the artist. Amy even gets sponsored by Aunt March to go with Aunt Carrol on her Europe trip, so that Amy can develop her artistic skills and find a suitable match for herself, in this Aunt March acknowledges the self-discipline that Jo never had and talent that both sisters did. During this trip to Europe, Amy begins to feel disenchanted with her dreams and begins to doubt her capabilities to reach her dreams. While Jo sets off to New York hoping to achieve her dreams as a writer, she too starts to feel the same. The similarities in Jo and Amy's progress as characters show their likeness to each other especially in regards to their artistic ambitions. This is further supported by the fact that Amy was based on Louisa May Alcott's sister, May, whom she had a very similar and closest relationship with like we see with Jo and Amy. Jo does sometimes compare herself to Amy as she views Amy as someone who she sees does everything effortlessly and successfully without struggling, but in reality Amy often hid her struggles and pains from her family the same way Jo does too with Amy even viewing Jo in the same way. However, Jo does at sometimes come off bitter towards Amy, because Amy wins more approval from others that Jo often hopes she does. Both Jo and Amy have the most intertwined stories and similar stories in the life, both ended up not being successful artists right away, but were able to do so when they've made peace with their so-called failings. They both end up in happy, fulfilling marriages to men that support and respect their dreams even after having children and are able to pursue them because they're given the space to do what they've always wanted.

Beth's story is so rarely analyzed simply for the fact that her death is quite tragic given how short lived and how gently she existed. Beth lived for family and from the first book that was made very clear. She had no interest beyond loving her family and helping other however she can. No rhyme or reason can explain why she died as most of who have lost family members know, but Beth died loving her family and at peace. She simply represented all the good in the world in one person and the sisters whom she held dearly in her heart live with her in mind for every good that happens to them and every good they achieve. Beth represented the impermanence of childhood, but she represented the good we experience despite the shortness of our lives.

This book is ahead of its time in so many ways, but in the most obvious is its emotional maturity and how it has some of the best writing rooted in realism. Good Wives leaves you with wisdom and bittersweet feeling that comes with finishing any great novel, and it remains a novel with a powerful and meaningful message that, for me, resonates with a every generation of women that have a chance to read it. Some people find this book preachy and I think that is valid, but this was written with the intention of providing insight and guidance into being a woman in that time period. Louisa May Alcott does this very well in my opinion while maintaining the quality of the writing, so I'm surprised that not everyone understood it that way. I'd like to elaborate a lot more of my thoughts regarding Good Wives and all its plot points, but I feel I've covered what is the most important and which are the March sisters, our Little Women.
flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Good Wives.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March, 2020 – Started Reading
March, 2020 – Finished Reading
July 16, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
July 16, 2024 – Shelved
July 24, 2024 – Started Reading
July 24, 2024 –
page 17
4.42% "I just finished reading the first chapter and I really love the time jump. I'm glad that the girls were given time to just enjoy and live their lives without any special happenings."
July 28, 2024 –
page 41
10.65%
July 30, 2024 –
page 53
13.77% "I'm still alive. Just slightly busy."
July 30, 2024 –
page 68
17.66% "Meg and John are so cute. Also, babies? The cutest way to end a chapter. 🥹"
July 30, 2024 –
page 74
19.22% "I'm always happy to read more Jo and Amy interactions. It's nice how they get along better in this book than they did when they were younger in Little Women. It reminds me of how me and my sister only started fully getting along when I got older, like Amy and Jo though, yet still occasionally clash swords."
August 6, 2024 –
page 99
25.71% "I was able to read a little yesterday and this is my analysis.

Okay so, having read the book before, I love noticing all these details that I barely picked up during my first reading. First thing being, Jo and Laurie's differences are made even more obvious with their diverging paths, and the second being Laurie and Amy's closeness becoming more developed possibly to hint at the eventuality of a relationship."
August 13, 2024 –
page 112
29.09% "Despite Amy deciding to marry for her family's security long before she had to, Jo still thinks that "Amy gets all the fun." 🙃"
August 19, 2024 –
page 116
30.13% "AIN'T NO WAY JO NOTICED HOW LAURIE FLIRTS WITH AMY CONSTANTLY 😭 AND PEOPLE STILL HAVE THE AUDACITY TO SAY LAURIE AND AMY WERE SO RANDOM AND OUT OF NOWHERE 😭😭😭"
August 19, 2024 –
page 125
32.47% "People: Jo and Laurie are meant to be together!

Literally Marmee: I don't think you're suited for each other and much too alike that you'd end up fighting a lot."
August 19, 2024 –
page 130
33.77% "I find it kinda cute how Jo was basically spying on Professor Bhaer and was basically crushing hard on him. She literally finds his accent nice, and is attracted to how kind and patient he is. I really love how Alcott set up their relationship. Very much like Laurie and Amy's as Jo is a lot like Laurie while Amy is much like Bhaer in demeanor."
August 23, 2024 –
page 143
37.14% "Jo and Frederick are sooo cute together. The fact that he had the patience to teach her German while she "spied" on him for weeks just because he seemed so interesting and kind. I'm so happy Jo has a cute love story although not as passionate or stubborn as some would like, I appreciate that her story with Frederick is as loving as it is fulfilling. I think because of time spent with him, she healed in so many ways."
September 13, 2024 –
page 175
45.45% "Laurie's proposal to Jo hurts regardless of the fact that he falls in love even harder with Amy. I do think he was in love with her in the sense that comes with childhood. Laurie was right when he said that Jo would fall in love with Frederick and live and die by him. It is after all, her. Laurie would know, and it's why Jo knew he would do the same, to live and die by Amy (though unknown to both in the present)."
September 15, 2024 –
page 189
49.09% "Reading a little today, and I'm obsessing over how beautiful the writing is in the chapter where they reunite in France. How they're practically gushing about each other is written so well that you can really picture it and feel how much love they hold for each other. 🥹"
September 22, 2024 –
page 211
54.81% "All the subtext regarding Laurie and Amy in this book is so cute. Especially the fact that it's hinted that Laurie would have been best friends with Amy or the closest to her first had they been the same age. This is why I love rereading! There's so much to unpack in books that one read just can't do thoroughly or with justice."
September 27, 2024 –
page 237
61.56% "I sometimes enjoy reading the Little Women book series so much that when I do, Louisa May Alcott manages to bring me back down to Earth and break my heart. It's always the ever so loving and gentle ones plucked too early from this garden called Life, and Miss Alcott will break your heart so gently to remind you so. 🥺"
October 13, 2024 –
page 253
65.71% "Kinda hard to feel bad for Jo while she's mourning the loss of Beth when she's constantly comparing herself to talking about how much harder she works than Amy. She's literally forgetting that Beth and Amy are sisters too, and Amy literally had to grieve ALONE just so she wouldn't jeopardise her and her family's future. Ik that Jo is a flawed character, but I hate how people deny that & keep defending her bad traits."
October 16, 2024 –
page 263
68.31% "JOOOOOOO YOU'LL FIND LOVE TOO 😭"
October 16, 2024 –
page 283
73.51% "THISSSS!! THIS IS WHY JO AND FREDERICK BELONG TOGETHER!! Not only are they well-suited, but he's one of the few people who can stand up to Jo and keep up with her. Also, he's everything Jo admires and respects and that's VERY important in a relationship lasting. Not only that but her whole family agrees including Laurie who also loves Frederick."
October 17, 2024 –
page 315
81.82% "JO AND FRIEDRICH FOREVER!!!!!!! RAAAAAHHH!!!! 👊🏽"
October 17, 2024 –
page 329
85.45% "Holy shit, I actually finished my second reading of Good Wives. It was a very hearty read, despite my own laziness to finish reading it. I think that because of that I enjoyed reading it all the more. Review to follow."
October 17, 2024 – Finished Reading
October 18, 2024 – Shelved as: favorites

No comments have been added yet.