ŷ

el's Reviews > The Savage Detectives

The Savage Detectives by Roberto Bolaño
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
75804048
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 3-stars, comedy, in-translation, latine-lit, literary-fiction

the girls that get it get it and i fear i am not one of those girls. what i will say about bolaño is that he's a true visionary and represents for me the best parts of latin american literature—particularly latin american literature in translation. he's unflinching and contentious, he takes risks in both content and form, he's not afraid to make enemies by bringing real writers and political figures + events into his work, his language is sprawling but ultimately accessible, and he has a polyvocal understanding of the novel that i think most anglophone writers (and readers) will find it difficult to navigate or even conceptualize, because we've grown up in such an individualistic culture + language.

that said, much of this was boring, it needed more gay sex, the garcía sections were laughably self-indulgent (part one reads a bit like self-insert Y/N fanfiction written by a 17-year-old boy, very authentically cringey, and maybe that's the point given garcía's existence is up for debate; his chosen one know-it-all role as a character would actually make this a very humorous writing choice), and the way bolaño writes women leaves a lot to be desired.

the ending of the savage detectives was extremely mid—you can barely call it a roadtrip interlude. there's very little sense of stakes during the third section, especially because we'd just gone through 40 odd newspaper-esque snapshots from other characters. now we're supposed to find our way back into caring about the original literary troupe, told through the eyes of a character we haven't seen or heard from in 300 or so odd pages. ultimately, the fate of a certain character pissed me off (iykyk) and confirmed my own feelings about the no stakes pacing.

this is a very "go forth and find meaning, then make literature while smoking and fucking and treading unfamiliar ground" male-coded novel, so i see why litfic bros regard it as their bible.

if you're a writer looking to tackle huge casts, bolaño is an excellent master to learn from on a craft level. if not, this may be a slog. never let it be said, however, that this man wasn't having the time of his life while writing—you can tell this project was a blast for him, full of heart and soul, and probably contains tons of (clandestine and not-so-clandestine) nods to his early life/experiences as a writer.
23 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Savage Detectives.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 12, 2024 – Started Reading
November 12, 2024 – Shelved
November 12, 2024 –
page 46
7.1% "third time’s the charm"
November 14, 2024 –
page 80
12.35% "i love the notion that our 17-year-old protagonist is in law school, too smart for his poetry workshops, and every girl he encounters wants to touch his dick immediately"
November 14, 2024 –
page 118
18.21% "is it every day garcía is having sex and writing 10 poems in one sitting ⁉️"
November 18, 2024 –
page 145
22.38%
January 4, 2025 –
page 176
27.16% "bolaño should’ve stuck to gay shit bc his m/f pairings are boring as HELL but all the m/m so far is full of chemistry and friction"
January 6, 2025 –
page 246
37.96%
January 10, 2025 –
page 280
43.21%
January 31, 2025 –
page 354
54.63% "this book is like a never-ending dream that makes little to no narrative sense, but that maintains its atmosphere nonetheless...."
February 28, 2025 –
page 383
59.1%
March 6, 2025 –
page 419
64.66%
March 10, 2025 –
page 464
71.6%
March 17, 2025 –
page 515
79.48%
March 22, 2025 – Shelved as: 3-stars
March 22, 2025 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
March 22, 2025 – Shelved as: latine-lit
March 22, 2025 – Shelved as: in-translation
March 22, 2025 – Shelved as: comedy
March 22, 2025 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.