欧宝娱乐

Nathan's Reviews > A Prayer for Owen Meany

A Prayer for Owen Meany by John Irving
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8104
's review

liked it

I gave this book three stars because I figure that's the average of five stars and one star. Some of the things about this book were great; others were really terrible.

Irving's strong-point is definitely his ability to draw interesting characters in vivid--sometimes painful--detail. Owen, of course, is the central and most interesting character. He's a little runt of a boy with a bizarre voice, a sarcastic wit, an iron will, and an unwavering faith in God and in the fact that he is an instrument of God's will. In stark contrast to Owen's miraculous life stands Owen's best friend and the narrator of the story, John. We get two views of John. Most of the book consists of John narrating his childhood and telling the story of Owen Meany. The childhood John is self-conscious, indecisive, and unmotivated. The other view comes from periodic scenes of the middle-aged, mundane John who now lives in Toronto and invariably launches into long and bitter rants against the United States and its foreign policy. The reason for the rants becomes clear by the end of the book, but that doesn't make them any more enjoyable.

Many of the supporting characters are also interesting. I really liked John's grandmother, Mrs. Wheelwright, who is a sort of New England, old-money royalty. John's sexually charged and extremely rambunctious cousins are usually comical, and Reverend Louis Merrill is sort of tragically lovable.

The plot, on the other hand, is incredibly long and wandering. Though parts of the narrative are moderately gripping, often the story drags along. Irving keeps you reading not with intense plot development, but rather with an intense curiosity to find out what the big deal is about Owen Meany. While the ending is good--very good, in my opinion--Irving has built up your anticipation so much, that by the time it finally happens, it almost doesn't have a prayer (pardon the pun) of meeting your expectations.

While there are several themes in the book, the most important, in my opinion, seems to be that of faith vs. doubt. Owen's incredibly strong faith is contrasted with John's lack of faith during his childhood, and his passive, "church-rummage" faith during his adult life (which, we are told on the first page, John credits to the "miracle" of Owen Meany). The Reverend Louis Merrill also seems to be a more important character than his relatively small role would suggest, and his self-admitted personal philosophy is the paradoxical "doubt as the essence of faith." In one of the more ironic passages of the book (slight spoiler warning...), Rev. Merrill's doubt is finally dispelled not through the miraculous events surrounding Owen Meany, but through a very mundane and spiteful prank.

The problem is that none of the book's myriad of themes and symbols was particularly interesting to me. The central theme discussed above seems to hold such potential, but in the end I didn't feel any more enlightened than I started. Often with books I find myself identifying with one particular character. That didn't happen with this book, and I think that impeded my ability to glean insight from the story.

Overall, I'm glad I read it. I'd be interested to hear what other's have to say about it.
116 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read A Prayer for Owen Meany.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

February 22, 2007 – Shelved
Started Reading
March 1, 2007 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by K (new) - rated it 2 stars

K I just finished this book, and you captured my feelings about it exactly (although I gave it two stars, not three). As good as the ending was, it felt almost anticlimactic after all that buildup (not to mention having to meander through so many long-winded and barely relevant passages). I also appreciated the characterization, but I needed a tighter, more interesting plot and would have appreciated the themes more had they been developed in a more parsimonious way.


Emma I totally agree with your review. I was tempted to give it up many times but I carried on purely to find out what the deal really was with Owen Meany. I also thought the end scene was fantastic- but the rest of the book was so without action and often - dare I say it- quite boring that by the end it did not leave an impact on me.
I appreciate it is a good story but it was not utilised to its best in my opinion. As you say, the book's themes and symbols did not interest me either- which on my part is usually what I love best about a book.

Great review!


Kristin "The plot, on the other hand, is incredibly long and wandering. Though parts of the narrative are moderately gripping, often the story drags along. Irving keeps you reading not with intense plot development, but rather with an intense curiosity to find out what the big deal is about Owen Meany. While the ending is good--very good, in my opinion--Irving has built up your anticipation so much, that by the time it finally happens, it almost doesn't have a prayer (pardon the pun) of meeting your expectations."

I couldn't agree more with you more!


Sarah You've really captured what I thought about the book in so many ways. Great characters (except for Johhny, whom I found lackluster and unsympathetic), a handful of hilarious scenes swallowed up by pages and pages of pages of meandering exposition.


Michael I wholeheartedly disagree with the entire tone of your review and most of the subsequent comments. But then again, I am not you. I come from what most would call an unusual background and found the places and the people in this story I be remarkably real and vividly drawn. To those who were bored, I lack any understanding of your difficulties and feel not a single word was placed without great care for furthering the story. While in the outside world I may not find myself befriending many of the characters in this book, I understand them and am glad for their existence.

This is one of my favorite books ever.


Suzanne Michael, I agree with you. I come from a traditional background,I'm a woman and not Christian,but I loved this book. I found the characters fascinating, the plot engrossing and I couldn't put this book down.
There were lots of parallels to the politics of today. John did his thesis on Hardy. I read Hardy all summer and I'm a retired English teacher. Anyway,IRVING USED TO BE A GREAT AUTHOR. That was a mistake,but maybe Owen was speaking through my Kindle.


message 7: by Mo (new)

Mo Holub A long and wandering narrative it was I agree. There were times when I found it to be boring and uninteresting, but it was overall a very good story.


message 8: by Amy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amy No way. This is the best book I've ever read. My father loved it too.


message 9: by Amy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amy No way. This is the best book I've ever read. My father loved it too.


message 10: by Rebekah (new)

Rebekah Mcnay ugh I read this in a VanDyke class. Maybe it was because I was working 2 jobs and taking 21 credit hours- but I couldn't get into it. As you know, I love VanDyke-led discussions but I found myself engaging in horrendous laughing fits while reading and discussing in class. Enjoyable but insufferable at the same time and annoying; just like the novel.


message 11: by Carly (new) - added it

Carly I agree 100% with your review! I was SO tempted to give this book up, but I really, really liked the ending so I'm glad I didn't. I want to recommend the book solely for the last 20% of it but I would never put someone through the first 80%!


Jaapo87 Couldn't have worded it better myself, exactly how I felt throughout and after reading this book


back to top