Olga's Reviews > Clear
Clear
by
by

Olga's review
bookshelves: novella, historical-fiction, scotland, nature-and-outdoors, lgbt, atmospheric, british, british-literature, existential, hidden-gem, marriage
Feb 28, 2025
bookshelves: novella, historical-fiction, scotland, nature-and-outdoors, lgbt, atmospheric, british, british-literature, existential, hidden-gem, marriage
Clear is such a unique novel: so quiet, so stripped of excess, that it feels almost elemental, like the land and sea that shape its characters. Carys Davies has crafted something astonishing here: a story that is both intimate and profound, a meditation on solitude, survival, and the unexpected bonds that form between people when language fails but the heart understands.
The premise is deceptively simple. In 1843, a minister named John Ferguson is sent to a remote Scottish island to evict its last inhabitant, a man named Ivar. It is the era of the Scottish Clearances, a time when landowners saw more value in sheep than in people, and Ivar, living alone with only his animals for company, is an inconvenient reminder of a past that the powerful are eager to erase.
But before John can even begin his task, an accident leaves him unconscious on the shore, and Ivar, unaware of his mission, takes him in, nursing him back to health. They do not share a language, but a fragile understanding begins to form between them. Meanwhile, back on the mainland, John’s wife Mary, alarmed by the nature of his task and the dangers he may face, sets out to find him. The novel unfolds like a slow tide, inexorable and deeply moving.
The prose is spare, yet every word feels deliberately placed, carrying the weight of something larger than itself. There is a Claire Keegan-like precision to Davies� writing—an ability to render landscape and emotion with a crystalline clarity. She does not waste words, nor does she need to; the spaces between them do just as much of the storytelling.
Ivar, in particular, is a marvel of character work. He is lonely but not broken, a man who has lived so long with the sea as his only companion that he seems half-wild, and yet, his kindness toward John is immediate, instinctive. There is no need for grand declarations between them—only gestures, food shared in silence, the slow and careful work of trust being built. Davies� use of Norn words adds another layer of authenticity to Ivar’s world, anchoring the novel even more deeply in its time and place.
And then there is Mary—perhaps the most unexpectedly compelling figure of all. Her journey to find John is not just a physical one, but an emotional and intellectual reckoning, a confrontation with the limits of duty and the shape of love. She is the kind of character who does not demand attention but earns it nonetheless, with quiet resolve and deeply felt emotion.
If I have one complaint, it is simply that I wanted more. The novel is brief—almost too brief for something so rich—and I found myself reading over passages, reluctant to leave the world Davies had so masterfully conjured. But perhaps that is the point. Some stories are not meant to be sprawling epics; some are best told like this, distilled to their essence, leaving space for the reader to sit with them, to let them settle.
Clear is a novel of remarkable restraint, yet it brims with meaning. It is about displacement, about kindness, about the human need for connection even in the most isolated of places. It is, in every sense, a stunning achievement. 4.5/5.
The premise is deceptively simple. In 1843, a minister named John Ferguson is sent to a remote Scottish island to evict its last inhabitant, a man named Ivar. It is the era of the Scottish Clearances, a time when landowners saw more value in sheep than in people, and Ivar, living alone with only his animals for company, is an inconvenient reminder of a past that the powerful are eager to erase.
But before John can even begin his task, an accident leaves him unconscious on the shore, and Ivar, unaware of his mission, takes him in, nursing him back to health. They do not share a language, but a fragile understanding begins to form between them. Meanwhile, back on the mainland, John’s wife Mary, alarmed by the nature of his task and the dangers he may face, sets out to find him. The novel unfolds like a slow tide, inexorable and deeply moving.
The prose is spare, yet every word feels deliberately placed, carrying the weight of something larger than itself. There is a Claire Keegan-like precision to Davies� writing—an ability to render landscape and emotion with a crystalline clarity. She does not waste words, nor does she need to; the spaces between them do just as much of the storytelling.
Ivar, in particular, is a marvel of character work. He is lonely but not broken, a man who has lived so long with the sea as his only companion that he seems half-wild, and yet, his kindness toward John is immediate, instinctive. There is no need for grand declarations between them—only gestures, food shared in silence, the slow and careful work of trust being built. Davies� use of Norn words adds another layer of authenticity to Ivar’s world, anchoring the novel even more deeply in its time and place.
And then there is Mary—perhaps the most unexpectedly compelling figure of all. Her journey to find John is not just a physical one, but an emotional and intellectual reckoning, a confrontation with the limits of duty and the shape of love. She is the kind of character who does not demand attention but earns it nonetheless, with quiet resolve and deeply felt emotion.
If I have one complaint, it is simply that I wanted more. The novel is brief—almost too brief for something so rich—and I found myself reading over passages, reluctant to leave the world Davies had so masterfully conjured. But perhaps that is the point. Some stories are not meant to be sprawling epics; some are best told like this, distilled to their essence, leaving space for the reader to sit with them, to let them settle.
Clear is a novel of remarkable restraint, yet it brims with meaning. It is about displacement, about kindness, about the human need for connection even in the most isolated of places. It is, in every sense, a stunning achievement. 4.5/5.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Clear.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 28, 2025
–
Started Reading
February 28, 2025
– Shelved
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
novella
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
scotland
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
nature-and-outdoors
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
lgbt
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
atmospheric
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
british
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
british-literature
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
existential
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
hidden-gem
February 28, 2025
– Shelved as:
marriage
February 28, 2025
–
Finished Reading