Mir's Reviews > The Stone Fey
The Stone Fey
by
I have no idea who decided to make this a picture book. It is a perfectly fine short story in McKinley's usual style; i.e. not decipherable by little kids. Even her YA novels I found more enjoyable as an adult. I can't imagine a younger child following sentences like, by its individual geography the land was a little more arable than much of what lay near it. The pages are mostly full text with only occasional "illustrations" between them, and the the illustrations were more like paintings inspired by the story than depictions of the narrative. I liked some of them (Clapp is good with color and landscape, not so much with people and animals) but didn't feel they added much. The titular Stone Fey wasn't very well developed. The sheep dog was the best character.
by

I have no idea who decided to make this a picture book. It is a perfectly fine short story in McKinley's usual style; i.e. not decipherable by little kids. Even her YA novels I found more enjoyable as an adult. I can't imagine a younger child following sentences like, by its individual geography the land was a little more arable than much of what lay near it. The pages are mostly full text with only occasional "illustrations" between them, and the the illustrations were more like paintings inspired by the story than depictions of the narrative. I liked some of them (Clapp is good with color and landscape, not so much with people and animals) but didn't feel they added much. The titular Stone Fey wasn't very well developed. The sheep dog was the best character.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Stone Fey.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 14, 2009
– Shelved
Started Reading
December 1, 2009
–
Finished Reading