Jessica's Reviews > The Four Agreements: A Practical Guide to Personal Freedom
The Four Agreements: A Practical Guide to Personal Freedom
by
by

I was surprised. I thought I would really like this book. A friend of mine told me the basic ideas were to be impeccable with your word, don't take things personally, don't make assumptions,and always do your best. To me, these sounded great: be honest, be forgiving, give others a chance to say what they think and try your best...or so I thought!
The ideas were actually more along the lines of: don't send out poisonous words that put spells on people, don't let others poison you with their spells (pretty strange, right?), don't have expectations of others, and yes, try your best.
My husband and I were going to read this together, but by page 16 he couldn't take it anymore! I needed to read it for our book group so I continued on solo.
I found the explanations for these ideas unnecessarily described as being from black or white magic, unnecessarily loaded with examples and I felt the author was talking down to me.
Also, by far the book's biggest flaw, the information, if it hadn't been so swollen by overexplaining EVERY single concept, could have been presented in half OR LESS of the length!!!! Really, an elementary student might need all the over-simplified explanations supported by numerous examples, but even a teenager would have felt that Ruiz is beating a dead horse! (As my husband and I did by page 16!)
Another friend told me that the ideas in this book reminded her of things she's heard before and gave as an example You Are Special, a great children's book by Max Lucado. I suggest reading that instead of this book.
The book's ideas felt religious and might be okay for someone who is without religion and looking for some principles to govern their life. But, for me, as a Christian, I felt that these concepts were not only familiar but succinctly summed up in "love one another" and "try to be like Jesus."
I really didn't like the book, but I suppose that I don't have to worry about the author taking it personally! :)
The ideas were actually more along the lines of: don't send out poisonous words that put spells on people, don't let others poison you with their spells (pretty strange, right?), don't have expectations of others, and yes, try your best.
My husband and I were going to read this together, but by page 16 he couldn't take it anymore! I needed to read it for our book group so I continued on solo.
I found the explanations for these ideas unnecessarily described as being from black or white magic, unnecessarily loaded with examples and I felt the author was talking down to me.
Also, by far the book's biggest flaw, the information, if it hadn't been so swollen by overexplaining EVERY single concept, could have been presented in half OR LESS of the length!!!! Really, an elementary student might need all the over-simplified explanations supported by numerous examples, but even a teenager would have felt that Ruiz is beating a dead horse! (As my husband and I did by page 16!)
Another friend told me that the ideas in this book reminded her of things she's heard before and gave as an example You Are Special, a great children's book by Max Lucado. I suggest reading that instead of this book.
The book's ideas felt religious and might be okay for someone who is without religion and looking for some principles to govern their life. But, for me, as a Christian, I felt that these concepts were not only familiar but succinctly summed up in "love one another" and "try to be like Jesus."
I really didn't like the book, but I suppose that I don't have to worry about the author taking it personally! :)
1369 likes · Like
�
flag
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Four Agreements.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 29, 2010
– Shelved
February 1, 2010
– Shelved as:
rr-book-group
February 3, 2010
–
Started Reading
February 8, 2010
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 128 (128 new)
message 1:
by
Melissa
(new)
Dec 16, 2012 03:08AM

reply
|
flag

Ruiz's definitions are bizarre, to say the least. Here are a few examples:
"All the magic you possess is based on your word. Your word is pure magic, and misuse of your word is black magic" (27).
"One word is like a spell, and humans use the word like black magicians, thoughtlessly putting spells on each other. Every human is a magician, and we can either put a spell on someone with our word or we can release someone from a spell. We cast spells all the time with our opinions" (28-29).
"Because the word is the magic that humans possess and misuse of the word is black magic, we are using black magic all the time without knowing that our word is magic at all" (34).
"Sometimes you hear a voice in your mind, and you may wonder where it came from. This voice may have come from another reality in which there are living beings very similar to the human mind" (54).
"The mind lives in more than one dimension. There may be times when you have ideas that don't originate in your mind, but you are perceiving them with your mind" (54).
"When we discover that the mind is controlled by the Judge and the Victim and the real 'us' is in the corner, we have just two choices. One choice is to keep living the way we are, to surrender to the Judge and the Victim, to keep living in the dream of the planet. The second choice is to do what we do as children when parents try to domesticate us. We can rebel and say 'No!' We can declare war against the parasite, a war against the Judge and the Victim, a war for our independence, a war for the right to use our own mind and our own brain ... choosing this path gives us, at the very least, the dignity of rebellion" (102-103).
Oooohkaaaay.
I think these passages speak for themselves.
This book is a waste of time and money. I also felt "talked down to," as if I were reading an elementary school primer. The definitions were repeated ad nauseam, and I couldn't wait for it to be over.
This book can be summed up like this:
Agreement #1: If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all.
Agreement #2: What other people think of you is none of your business.
Agreement #3: To ASSUME makes an "ASS" out of "U" and "ME".
Agreement #4: If something's worth doing, it's worth doing right.




You do not have to take literally, the statements about magic...they are metaphors, like much that is contained in the bible.







I thought the same of the book. The first part is hard to read as no good comes out of this world, everything is very negative.
This is self help book for someone that never read the Bible or went to Church.
It is also a good reminder of truth, goodness and beauty too...


Also, just a quick note, this is actually a religious book. It's often categorized as such, and it's main reviews even have references to spirituality on the back cover with the synopsis. I'm not sure what you were looking for, maybe something more psychological? Try Feeling Good by David Burns, if you haven't read that one.







Or we're gonna keep ourselves away from much wisdom.

But I also don't agree. When I judge a book, I judge also the words, how repetitive it is, when it states un-facts etc. So while the basic ideas would get my 5 stars, this version that contains so much more crap that makes it so boring to read, gets 1 star.



I found no scientific correlation between sleep paralysis (which is the proper term of what you're describing) and demons or this book.





I read your whole post and you should write for the Onion if you were aiming at satire. Too funny!








