Pick-a-Shelf discussion
Archive - POTS
>
POTS Cycle #4 Reporting Thread
date
newest »


I finished Cinder, and loved it. 4 stars. I'm WAY behind on writing my book reviews, so thought I shouldn't wait for that to happen before I post this.
Finished Three Cups of Tea: One Man's Mission to Promote Peace ... One School at a Time and gave it 3*. I would have rated it higher but I kept remembering something about it being a fraudful claim. I will need to research that.



And the Mountains Echoed - 3* - not as good as his first two books
So Cold the River - 3* - this read like a Stephen King book
Finished one -albeit short...
Proper Gauge (Wool #2)...Wow... really didn't expect the ending! 1 & 2 told from different perspectives so felt kinda different but it's getting very gritty and I think now I'm starting to see the what the hype it all about.
4 stars.
Proper Gauge (Wool #2)...Wow... really didn't expect the ending! 1 & 2 told from different perspectives so felt kinda different but it's getting very gritty and I think now I'm starting to see the what the hype it all about.
4 stars.




I love Christie, but I didn't enjoy this standalone title nearly as much as her Poirot mysteries, especially Murder on the Orient Express and The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. The ending felt implausible and a bit tacked on to me, and although I appreciate Christie's propensity to "break the rules" of the mystery genre, I felt she was deliberately trolling the reader (to use the vernacular) with some of her stunts here. Aside from the ending, there were a few too many convenient coincidences, characters (purported to be quite savvy) being dense and slow to catch on at the worst possible times, and some plot points I felt came across (at least to a modern reader) as just plain silly.
(One bit that particularly vexed me: Several men, at various points, become upset, agitated and escalated by fear, anger, etc., and this is fine with the rest of the company...seen as understandable under the circumstances. A woman becomes upset - while trying to actually convey important information about what is going on that might actually help the company defend themselves - and she is slapped by a man. And then she THANKS HIM for it. ARGH.)
I know this is many readers' favorite Christie, but I think I'll stick with Poirot and maybe give Miss Marple a try. :)
I finished So Cold the River on 10/14, but only just now got around to reviewing it. I enjoyed it, but only 3-stars worth. My review here .
My fourth of four. Done for this round.
My fourth of four. Done for this round.

Finished my second book... geez, I've been really slow the last few months!
Jasper Jones for 5 stars! It was amazing -really enjoyed the vibrant descriptive prose. The words he chose really brought the book alive to me. Loved it!
Jasper Jones for 5 stars! It was amazing -really enjoyed the vibrant descriptive prose. The words he chose really brought the book alive to me. Loved it!
Finished my third for the 3 book team - Aunt Dimity Down Under. Gave it 4*. A fun read on the order of a cozy mystery, although I did not think there was much mystery to the story. At least not a who-done-it mystery.


Will we be doing another cycle? And, if so, is the sign-up coming soon?
My vote is yes. I enjoy the chance to be involved, more one-one-one, with other group members.
My vote is yes. I enjoy the chance to be involved, more one-one-one, with other group members.
Susan wrote: "Will we be doing another cycle? And, if so, is the sign-up coming soon?
My vote is yes. I enjoy the chance to be involved, more one-one-one, with other group members."
You read my mind, Susan... I was about to message Lyn but since you've posted, I might as well post the sign-up and then Lyn can deal with the rest of it, ha ha ha ;p
My vote is yes. I enjoy the chance to be involved, more one-one-one, with other group members."
You read my mind, Susan... I was about to message Lyn but since you've posted, I might as well post the sign-up and then Lyn can deal with the rest of it, ha ha ha ;p
Books mentioned in this topic
Hold Me Closer, Necromancer (other topics)Aunt Dimity Down Under (other topics)
Jasper Jones (other topics)
Original Sin (other topics)
So Cold the River (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Agatha Christie (other topics)Lorraine Heath (other topics)
J.R. Ward (other topics)
Marissa Meyer (other topics)
Enjoy your books!
D.G.
Lover Mine by J.R. Ward
Texas Destiny by Lorraine Heath
Susan
Cinder by Marissa Meyer