The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
WINTER CHALLENGE 2013
>
Winter Challenge 2013: Questions/Problems in Completed Tasks
Mai post 486
For task 30.1, a die roll of 4 requires that you read a book with the letters A R G H found in the title. Daredevil Legends, Vol. 2: Born Again does not fit this requirement.
For task 30.1, a die roll of 4 requires that you read a book with the letters A R G H found in the title. Daredevil Legends, Vol. 2: Born Again does not fit this requirement.

Task 20.2 requires that the author be new to you and that you state this in your post.
Please do not repost task 20.4 - that has already been recorded."
Okay, thanks. Will repost 20.2 right now.
Dawn99
Task 20.2 requires that the author be a new author for you and that you indicate this in your post. Please repost with the required info.
Please do not repost the other tasks - they have already been recorded.
Task 20.2 requires that the author be a new author for you and that you indicate this in your post. Please repost with the required info.
Please do not repost the other tasks - they have already been recorded.
Rochella post 505
Attachments does not have "humor" listed as a main page genre. If you had this verified previously, please repost with a link to the verification post.
Attachments does not have "humor" listed as a main page genre. If you had this verified previously, please repost with a link to the verification post.
Jenifer post 517
Task 20.10 requires that you post in the group discussion thread, and I don't see a post from you in that thread. If I have somehow overlooked it, please just respond here with the post # - otherwise, please repost the task after you have commented in the group discussion thread.
Task 20.2 has been recorded.
Task 20.10 requires that you post in the group discussion thread, and I don't see a post from you in that thread. If I have somehow overlooked it, please just respond here with the post # - otherwise, please repost the task after you have commented in the group discussion thread.
Task 20.2 has been recorded.
Alllison I post 519
Task 20.10 requires that you post in the group discussion thread, and I don't see a post from you in that thread. If I have somehow overlooked it, please just respond here with the post # - otherwise, please repost the task after you have commented in the group discussion thread.
Task 20.10 requires that you post in the group discussion thread, and I don't see a post from you in that thread. If I have somehow overlooked it, please just respond here with the post # - otherwise, please repost the task after you have commented in the group discussion thread.

Task 20.10 requires that you post in the group discussion thread, and I don't see a post from you in that thread. If I have somehow overlooked it, please just respond here with th..."
Oh gosh, I'm not doing very well this season! I will post in the group reads thread and then repost.

For task 30.1, a die roll of 4 requires that you read a book with the letters A R G H found in the title. Daredevil Legends, Vol. 2: Born Again does not fit this require..."
Oh right... For some reason I mistook the 4th option for the 6th. Thanks!
Marty post 529
Task 5.9 requires that the book be labeled as a series on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ, with the (Series name, #) listed. The Egyptian Coffin is not listed as part of a series.
Task 5.9 requires that the book be labeled as a series on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ, with the (Series name, #) listed. The Egyptian Coffin is not listed as part of a series.

Task 5.9 requires that the book be labeled as a series on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ, with the (Series name, #) listed. The Egyptian Coffin is not listed as part of a series."
Okay. I just assumed since the Lord Ambrose Mystery was listed in parentheses like other series names are, that it would count as a series. I'll find something else.
Allison post 541
There is more than one person named Allison listed in the readerboard names. Please repost with your full readerboard name, so that the points can be credited to the right person.
There is more than one person named Allison listed in the readerboard names. Please repost with your full readerboard name, so that the points can be credited to the right person.
Elizabeth B post 575
Task 25.3, option 6, requires that the author's initials be "immediately adjacent reading from left to right." "CF" will not work, as that requires reading from right to left.
Task 25.3, option 6, requires that the author's initials be "immediately adjacent reading from left to right." "CF" will not work, as that requires reading from right to left.

The edition of The Help you've linked to has only 451 pages and is not eligible for a Big Book ticket. If you actually read an edition over 500 pages, please repost this book including a link to the edition you read. Indicate in your post that it is a repost to claim GRA tickets, so that it is clear that it is not a new task posting.

The edition of The Help you've linked to has only 451 pages and is not eligible for a Big Book ticket. If you actually read an edition over 500 pages, please repo..."
I'll just skip the big book tickets and goodreads authors for now on. Less hassle.
Donna Jo post 591
For task 5.9, the book must be set in one of the top 10 wine consumption countries, and China is not on that list. Perhaps you were looking at the list of wine producing countries, since China is on that one.
For task 5.9, the book must be set in one of the top 10 wine consumption countries, and China is not on that list. Perhaps you were looking at the list of wine producing countries, since China is on that one.


Attachments does not have "humor" listed as a main page genre. If you had this verified previously, please repost with a link to the verification post."
Ah, sorry. It was there when I read it. Should have verified it then :/

Hi Lindy-Lane. We are only awarded one GRA ticket per book no matter how many GRA's contributed to the book. There's a post here: /topic/show/...
It'll probably make more sense that I what I'm saying.

For task 5.9, the book must be set in one of the top 10 wine consumption countries, and China is not on that list. Perhaps you were looking at the list of wine producing countrie..."
Sorry, I'm sure i looked at the wrong list. I've been bedeviled by computer problems all month so I'll blame it on that.

thanks for clarification.
Donna Jo wrote: ". I've been bedeviled by computer problems all month so I'll blame it on that.
."
works for me!
."
works for me!
Bamaace83 post 618
Task 30.6, option 3, requires that you read the first full-length published book and the most recently published full-length book.
Starry Night: A Christmas Novel was first published 1/1/13. GR shows at least 2 books published by Debbie Macomber since then, including Summer Wedding Bells, published July 2013.
Points for the other tasks in the post have been recorded.
Task 30.6, option 3, requires that you read the first full-length published book and the most recently published full-length book.
Starry Night: A Christmas Novel was first published 1/1/13. GR shows at least 2 books published by Debbie Macomber since then, including Summer Wedding Bells, published July 2013.
Points for the other tasks in the post have been recorded.

Task 30.6, option 3, requires that you read the first full-length published book and the most recently published full-length book.
[book:Starry Night: A Christmas Novel|17910542..."
That is really just ugh! because the book wasn't released until October. I went to her actual website and tried to make sure I got the latest book. Blah! I will try to find the Summer Wedding Bells book or start all over with a different author. Thanks for the heads up. Back to the drawing board.


Dee wrote: "Could it be that someone screwed up the publishing dates on GR?"
It certainly could be - as we have pointed out many times, GR data is often inaccurate - it's entered by anyone who signs up to be a librarian, and while some librarians are careful and painstaking in researching the data before making changes, others are less so.
However, the only thing we can go by here is GR data - we simply cannot research everything beyond GR. If a participant is claiming a book, the GR data doesn't work for the task, and the participant believes that the GR data is wrong, it's up to the participant to do the research and have the data changed if appropriate. This should be done before posting the task.
It certainly could be - as we have pointed out many times, GR data is often inaccurate - it's entered by anyone who signs up to be a librarian, and while some librarians are careful and painstaking in researching the data before making changes, others are less so.
However, the only thing we can go by here is GR data - we simply cannot research everything beyond GR. If a participant is claiming a book, the GR data doesn't work for the task, and the participant believes that the GR data is wrong, it's up to the participant to do the research and have the data changed if appropriate. This should be done before posting the task.
Dee wrote: "Starry Night: A Christmas Novel per her website was first published Oct 8, 2013 - so i'm going to adjust the GR record - "
Thanks for doing this research, Dee.
Bamaace83, if you want to repost, the books will work now. If I were you, though, I'd do it fast - when I was wading through the list of her books to find the publication dates, looks like she cranks books out pretty fast!
Thanks for doing this research, Dee.
Bamaace83, if you want to repost, the books will work now. If I were you, though, I'd do it fast - when I was wading through the list of her books to find the publication dates, looks like she cranks books out pretty fast!

Talia post 620
This is not a problem, just an FYI.
We realized that the rule is not clearly worded, but the "floor" for regular SRC eligibility is 100 pages, not 101. So, your book for 5.1 works as a regular choice.
We'll reword the rule before the next challenge to make this clearer.
This is not a problem, just an FYI.
We realized that the rule is not clearly worded, but the "floor" for regular SRC eligibility is 100 pages, not 101. So, your book for 5.1 works as a regular choice.
We'll reword the rule before the next challenge to make this clearer.
Laurie ME post 660
For task 25.6, you claimed Missing in Mexico. This book appears to only exist in e-book form.
The rules of the challenge provide that
If you claim a book in Completed Tasks that exists ONLY in ebook format, you MUST provide a reference to the ebook verification document when you post ex."Approved @ line #" or provide the post number in the ebook verification thread where it was approved ex. "ebook Approved post #"
The print edition must show on GR. Please have a librarian add it if you want to claim it based on that print edition.
For task 25.6, you claimed Missing in Mexico. This book appears to only exist in e-book form.
The rules of the challenge provide that
If you claim a book in Completed Tasks that exists ONLY in ebook format, you MUST provide a reference to the ebook verification document when you post ex."Approved @ line #" or provide the post number in the ebook verification thread where it was approved ex. "ebook Approved post #"
The print edition must show on GR. Please have a librarian add it if you want to claim it based on that print edition.
Eepa post 697
Task 25.11, option 3, specifies "read a book by an author whose first name appears on this list of most popular male and female dog names."
You claimed A Boy and His Dragon by R. Cooper, using the name "Cooper." Unfortunately, Cooper appears to be the author's last name, not the first name.
Task 25.11, option 3, specifies "read a book by an author whose first name appears on this list of most popular male and female dog names."
You claimed A Boy and His Dragon by R. Cooper, using the name "Cooper." Unfortunately, Cooper appears to be the author's last name, not the first name.
Erin NY post 690
By the info you gave about your options, I'm assuming you meant task 30.7? No need to repost if this is correct - just change your own records to avoid confusion later.
By the info you gave about your options, I'm assuming you meant task 30.7? No need to repost if this is correct - just change your own records to avoid confusion later.

Task 25.11, option 3, specifies "read a book by an author whose first name appears on this list of most popular male and female dog names."
You claimed [book:A Boy and His Dragon|1640..."
Oh, it was that specific. Then I need to go hunting a new book. =)
Sam post 723
There is no task number or description for the second set of books that you posted. Please repost with complete information.
Please do not repost the other tasks in your post - those points have been recorded.
There is no task number or description for the second set of books that you posted. Please repost with complete information.
Please do not repost the other tasks in your post - those points have been recorded.
Jecca post 732
Task 20.3, option 1, requires that this be a collection of short stories, "identified as such in the book's title or GR description; novellas, essays, and poems are NOT included." The Druid Series, Volumes 1-3: Reapers, Bled & Harvest appears to be 3 separate novellas collected into one volume, not a collection of short stories.
Task 20.3, option 1, requires that this be a collection of short stories, "identified as such in the book's title or GR description; novellas, essays, and poems are NOT included." The Druid Series, Volumes 1-3: Reapers, Bled & Harvest appears to be 3 separate novellas collected into one volume, not a collection of short stories.
Nikki post 740
There is more than one Nikki on the Readerboard. The point total you list suggests that you are Nikki B - if so, please repost with your readerboard name included.
There is more than one Nikki on the Readerboard. The point total you list suggests that you are Nikki B - if so, please repost with your readerboard name included.
Amanda VA post 754
Please check your totals - I show you with 75 rather than 70. No need to repost - this is just so you can correct your records.
Please check your totals - I show you with 75 rather than 70. No need to repost - this is just so you can correct your records.
Nikki B post 757
It appears that Sunday Money: A Year Inside the NASCAR Circuit only exists in ebook form, at least on GR. Your post needs to include info about the ebook verification for length purposes.
Sorry not to pick this up before, but when I saw that the readerboard name was missing, I didn't go any further on the previous post.
It appears that Sunday Money: A Year Inside the NASCAR Circuit only exists in ebook form, at least on GR. Your post needs to include info about the ebook verification for length purposes.
Sorry not to pick this up before, but when I saw that the readerboard name was missing, I didn't go any further on the previous post.

It appears that Sunday Money: A Year Inside the NASCAR Circuit only exists in ebook form, at least on GR. Your post needs to include info about the ebook verificati..."
It is a paperback edition, the entry on GR has been edited by a GR librarian.
Nikki wrote: "Sandy wrote: "Nikki B post 757
It appears that Sunday Money: A Year Inside the NASCAR Circuit only exists in ebook form, at least on GR. Your post needs to include info about the eb..."
I see that you just edited the entry to include the paperback edition. In the future, please check this before posting.
It appears that Sunday Money: A Year Inside the NASCAR Circuit only exists in ebook form, at least on GR. Your post needs to include info about the eb..."
I see that you just edited the entry to include the paperback edition. In the future, please check this before posting.

Jecca post 732
Task 20.3, option 1, requires that this be a collection of short stories, "identified as such in the book's title or GR description; novellas, essays, and poems are NOT included." The Druid Series, Volumes 1-3: Reapers, Bled & Harvest appears to be 3 separate novellas collected into one volume, not a collection of short stories.
I guess I am confused about the difference. I had posted in the help board for the task but never heard back. It says three stories in one, so I thought it would work. I have another option but I will wait to hear from the task creator before I use it.
Thanks - Jecca


John Boyne, the author of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, is not a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Author. Please adjust your totals.
Kristi (Passion for the Page) wrote: "Delmy - post 764
John Boyne, the author of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, is not a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Author. Please adjust your totals."
Sorry, i don't know where i got that from! :)
John Boyne, the author of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, is not a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Author. Please adjust your totals."
Sorry, i don't know where i got that from! :)
Lindsey A post 837
Task 25.9, option 1, requires that you state that the author is new to you, since that is one of the requirements of the option.
Task 25.9, option 1, requires that you state that the author is new to you, since that is one of the requirements of the option.
Sue T post 846
The book you linked to, The Pursuit of Happiness: 21 Spiritual Rules to Success, only shows 2 ebook editions. If this also exists in paper, please post with the link to the paper version, or have the editions combined by a librarian. If it only exists as an ebook, please ask for length approval in the ebook verification thread.
The book you linked to, The Pursuit of Happiness: 21 Spiritual Rules to Success, only shows 2 ebook editions. If this also exists in paper, please post with the link to the paper version, or have the editions combined by a librarian. If it only exists as an ebook, please ask for length approval in the ebook verification thread.
Books mentioned in this topic
Take My Picture (other topics)Take My Picture (other topics)
The Complete Tales of Winnie-the-Pooh (other topics)
G'Day to Die (other topics)
Death du Jour (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Rick Yancey (other topics)Jennifer Chiaverini (other topics)
Maureen Ash (other topics)
Maureen Ash (other topics)
Maureen Ash (other topics)
More...
Task 20.5 requires a minimum page count of 250 pages. The book you linked to, Catacombs: A Tale of the Barque Cats has 236 pages. If you read a different edition with >250 pages, please repost, linking to that edition.