More than Just a Rating discussion
tips
>
Examples of superlative reviews
date
newest »

/review/show...
Beth /user/show/4... reviewed Mortal Fire
As I told her, I especially liked:
"It's so deliberately constructed - and the characters don't grow as much as experience events and advance the plot - that the characters feel like chess pieces, and the author's hand, moving them, is always visible."
Part of the reason I liked this was because I find it often in books I read. Beautiful writing, interesting ideas, but weak characters. I've been calling them 'iconographic' or 'cardboard' or 'shallow' instead of 'authentic' but I like Beth's metaphor much better, especially as it includes the author's hand bit.
Beth /user/show/4... reviewed Mortal Fire
As I told her, I especially liked:
"It's so deliberately constructed - and the characters don't grow as much as experience events and advance the plot - that the characters feel like chess pieces, and the author's hand, moving them, is always visible."
Part of the reason I liked this was because I find it often in books I read. Beautiful writing, interesting ideas, but weak characters. I've been calling them 'iconographic' or 'cardboard' or 'shallow' instead of 'authentic' but I like Beth's metaphor much better, especially as it includes the author's hand bit.
But do not steal their genius; do not plagiarize. And please, if you do like the excerpt, do follow the link, read the whole review, and hit *like* there. If you're up to it, comment to the reviewer why you liked their review, what was special about it.