UK Amazon Kindle Forum discussion
Group Challenges
>
Pam's 2017 Reading Self Challenge
message 1:
by
Pam
(new)
Jan 02, 2017 03:36PM

reply
|
flag

Read the first one: The Robber Bride





Not as good as other John Gordon spooky tales I've read.









I'm really surprised at the hype this book got. There's so many better books out there.

[bookcover:Year of Wonders: A Nov..."
Doesn't sound like a good one to pick up. Anachronism are irritating, but character flip flops are worse. Thanks for the review!


I'm reall..."
Just one of those unpredictable things as to what's popular and what isn't. I wouldn't have picked it up unless someone had given me their copy, but having read it can understand why people like it and I enjoyed reading it myself - it is a page turner. As I've just read an old how-to write book which cites a lot of very popular writers from the late 80s, it's been a reminder that a lot of books are very popular for a while and then sink without trace - some of the authors are still known now, some I know of from genres I read, and some of them who apparently sold millions of copies I've never even heard of.

[bookcover:Year of Wo..."
My pleasure Alicia. Went a bit to town on it but I tend to do that when I'm really annoyed and disappointed with a book. If I was disappointed but it was acceptable just not that enjoyable, I would give it at least a 2 and not do a rant!



[bookc..."
I admire you finishing it, more than anything else - I have never had that kind of dedication and patience. But it is fairer to evaluate a book on its whole.
I don't review very often (not enough brain cells, for one), but I dump more things than I finish because I have such limited reading time right now.
If I like something, I make the effort to review.
















Then finished The Pigman by Paul Zindel and reviewed it /review/show/1883148433.


23 so far Desley and I'm about to add another ;-)




23 so far Desley and I'm about to add another ;-)"
Wow!!



In some respects a tour de force of writing but also quite a slog - the character's disinterested alienation from her environment and passivity, although explained at the end in a rather strange infodump means that you don't feel involved with her especially as she is meant to be literally a superwoman.


Different vibe this time; the journey of self-discovery by the son of the character in book 1, but his and other men's attitudes and behaviour to women are repellent.



Books mentioned in this topic
The Flesh Eater (other topics)Fires of Azeroth (other topics)
Well of Shiuan (other topics)
A Highland Christmas (other topics)
Gate of Ivrel (other topics)
More...