Around the Year in 52 Books discussion
Weekly Topics 2018
>
24: A book with a map



I thought The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry was a wonderful book!


I wish I hadn't reread Unlikely Pilgrimage so recently, or I'd definitely use it for this one! I wish there was a list for non-fantasy books with maps, because that's a list I'd be interested in.
As it stands, I will be choosing between:
Shadow and Bone
Lord of the Flies
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
Finnikin of the Rock
A Game of Thrones
The Name of the Wind
The Bone Season
As it stands, I will be choosing between:
Shadow and Bone
Lord of the Flies
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
Finnikin of the Rock
A Game of Thrones
The Name of the Wind
The Bone Season






As someone who has read it... I would SO not read it before reading the Lord of the Rings. It is not an easy read, at all. I was a huge LOTR nerd when I read it and it was rough.
Lizzy wrote: "Also quite a few of the early Agatha Christie books have maps. If anyone has hard copies, they might be able to let people know."
Yes! I'd have to go check for others, but I know Murder on the Orient Express has a map of the train!
I hadn't even begun considering non-geographical maps!
Yes! I'd have to go check for others, but I know Murder on the Orient Express has a map of the train!
I hadn't even begun considering non-geographical maps!

As someone who has read it... I wou..."
Oh really? Darn..... guess I will look into other options

I think I’m going to go for either Across The Universe or The Girl of Ink and Stars. The latter I’m not entirely sure actually has a map in it, so I’m glad I’ve got a back up.




Fantasy is the easy option for this prompt, they usually have maps, but I think every book should come with a map - for real world stuff I'll often download the place on my map app so I can check it out as I read. I've even been known to Google Street View to have a virtual wander around the place I'm reading about.
- What are you reading for this category?
The Winner's Kiss
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
There are countries at war in this book, so the map is probably helpful to see where the troops are at different points in the story, but I was too caught up in the narrative to remember to flip back to the map. It also would have been easier to refer back to in a paperback book rather than the Kindle book (and audiobook) that I read.

- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
There are countries at war in this book, so the map is probably helpful to see where the troops are at different points in the story, but I was too caught up in the narrative to remember to flip back to the map. It also would have been easier to refer back to in a paperback book rather than the Kindle book (and audiobook) that I read.

These are both very good options!
Thanks Kenna, I didn’t know To The Bright Edge of the World has a map and was looking for a prompt to fit it!

There were several maps in the book, ranging from a map of their honeymoon trip to a map of the war in Europe.

Husdjuret by Camilla Grebe
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
It would probably make locations easier to place in relation to each other, if I remember to look at it.

Paper Towns by John Green
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? The actual picture of the map is just on the cover, but a paper town is a place on a map that doesn`t actually exist. So the "map" is an important part of the story.



Andrew Jackson and the Miracle of New Orleans: The Battle That Shaped America's Destiny
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
I have completed the book and the maps were absolutely essential to add to the enjoyment of the book. We are talking about a land and sea battle here and being able to SEE where the combatants were was indispensable.


Author :Hampton Sides
Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? Yes because the maps will help bring to life the story as well as help you fellow the trials that Kit Carson traveled on .As well as help you have a better understanding of how the land was back in that time period.

I'm reading 'Anzacs and Israel: A Significant Connection' by .
Kelvin Crosbie. It was a birthday present, so I thought I'd read it for this prompt.

Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
It will help put things in geographical context.

- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? Not really - I kind of only looked at it in the beginning of the book and at the end of the book.

- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? No, not really. There's one rather uninteresting b&w map.

I read A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas
Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
It definitely helps me to think of where all the different courts are located geographically and Feyre also talks about the maps a lot as well since she is also a stranger to the Prythian courts.


I am reading The Obelisk Gate by N.K. Jemisin. It is in the second in a series.
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
The map is the same as in the previous novel. It is somewhat useful, but isn't as detailed as I would have liked (many of the cities aren't placed on the map). It does aid with the world-buildiing.


Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? So far, at 100 pages in, I haven't come across any map in this book. However, in reading extensively about the many journeys taken by river, through the woods, etc., by the charming animal characters, a map would really be helpful.

/book/show/3...

Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience? So far, at 10..."
Stacey, I own a copy of this book and it has a map on the inside cover and flyleaf. It's a hardcopy. If you have a kindle or a paperback, there may not be a map. :(

Thanks, Cheri. Maybe it's the borrowed library edition I'm reading published in 2012? It's hardcover, with beautiful illustrations, but no map. I think I'll try to find an edition online where you can preview some pages. Hope to find it there! ;)

They do not really add to the book as you can get the idea of these without the maps.
The book is like reading a research paper and is not very interesting.

Palimpsest
I cheated in this slightly, because while the cover shows a body with a map tattooed on it, no depictions of the map actually are illustrated within the book. However the maps are very important, so I'm counting it.
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
The maps appearing on people's bodies is a fundamental part of the narrative, so yes.

I read Going Solo by Roald Dahl.
Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
The maps helped quite a bit as he was taking about places in Egypt/Africa/the Middle East that I had never heard of so it was nice to have a point of reference.

Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?
I have been in love with New York all my life, and the map brought back very happy memories. The map is helpful as Lillian's walk progresses...we can imagine where she is at all times.
I loved the book, and the writing was excellent. I loved getting to know Lillian through the unique writing style of the author.

Books mentioned in this topic
I Am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban (other topics)The Smell of Other People's Houses (other topics)
Gemina (other topics)
A Wizard of Earthsea (other topics)
The Writer's Map: An Atlas of Imaginary Lands (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Joshua Hammer (other topics)Shannon Hale (other topics)
Frank Delaney (other topics)
Julia Rochester (other topics)
Helen Scales (other topics)
More...
-----------------------------------
Suggestions:
Listopia: Fantasy Books with Maps
Oh, the Books! Bookish Guide: Books with Maps Inside
-----------------------------------
Optional questions:
- What are you reading for this category?
- Do you think the map will add to the narrative or reading experience?