Chicks On Lit discussion
Other Hot Book Discussions
>
At what point do you give up on a book?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Krys
(new)
Aug 18, 2009 03:26PM

reply
|
flag










But usually around 100 pages is my cut-off point.


I have about 5 of those books sitting on the shelf - I call it my 'some day I might try to read this again' shelf. ;)

I'd say fifty pages is a pretty good rule, although I just gave up on a book on page 28 when I was pretty sure I wasn't liking the way it was going (I did page ahead to be sure).
If I'm reading a book and the very thought of picking it up makes me sigh, roll my eyes, and race through the house looking for something, anything, else to read, I know it's time to give up on it.



I'm tough. If I'm not there within 20-50 pages at the max I put it down. I used to feel guilty but then I realized that the only thing I should feel guilty of is giving up my precious reading time to a book I dont enjoy when there are so many more out there that I would love.
My time is precious and books are many. I don't think the book is going to hold it against me so I put it down and move on to the next.
My time is precious and books are many. I don't think the book is going to hold it against me so I put it down and move on to the next.

Other times it is maybe 100+ pages into the book. There really is no set amount I guess. I just "know".
Sometimes I do stick it out like The Book Thief. I just didn't like how it was narrated originally but I'm so glad I stuck with it.
It's a gamble when I do stop reading a book.


I am ROTFL sooooo hard! That's EXACTLY what I do! I'm running out of bookmarks- tee-hee! :)

With The Time Traveler's Wife I tried reading it a year or so ago and gave up, then I picked it up again and was determined to get through it and I'm glad I did because I ended up really loving it. Now with The Post-Birthday World, I regret that I didn't just stop reading and move onto another book. It just never grabbed me and I didn't care about the characters at all. I guess it just all depends on the book and what I'm in the mood for!

That's what I'm reading now and i'm having a hard time getting through it, is it really worth it ??



but recently i started a new book, and 4 nights in a row it literally put me to sleep...and i realized i was only 24 pages in...at that point i was like, ok, i just need to put this back, and maybe pick it up in a few months to give it another shot...i've never experienced that before with a book by an author i love, and a book i've heard pretty good things about...

I'm finally over the 200 page mark. I'm reading the book with a friend and I'm simply determined to finish it. I finally had a breath of fresh air last night... they're having problems with the book too.



However, if I make it to the halfway point I almost have to finish it, especially if its a book about 300 pages because I read that far, I figure I should finish it. And I have sat there grumbling about the "dumb book" I am still reading.

Brenda -- Maybe that's why I'm somewhat drowning in Forgotten Garden. It's a similar writing style that I've read lately. Over and over. SIIIIGH.

I will say sometimes I put a book down not because I hate it but because I am simply not in the mood for that type of book at the moment. I might pick it up later because I know if I wanted to read that type of a book it would be a good choice. Sometimes I'm in the mood for popcorn sometimes I want a full meal.


Recently, I got Those Who Save Us out of the library and didn't feel I was in the right place to read it, but I picked it up at Paperbackswap and am confident that when the time is right I will love it.

I have started 2 different books I had to stop because they were disturbing Snow Flower and the Secret Fanand Millroy the Magician.
The footbinding was too graphic and Millroy was too weird. In these two cases I haven't given up on the author yet...
The other reason I give up is if I get into the story but find I don't care what happens to the protagonist.
Shelby, I recently finished The Historian and really liked it, try again!

I try to avoid ditching a book by, reading the first page, the middle page, and a paragraph on the last couple of pages....if it hooks you, chances are you will finish the book.
BTW, I could not finish the Barbara K. book that we read a month ago. Nor could I finish The Gift of Fear.

I try to avoid ditching a book by, reading the first page, the middle page, and a paragraph on the last couple of pages....if it hooks you, chances are you will finish the b..."
I heard once you should read the same amount of pages as your age plus 10 until you are 70, then just leave it at reading 80 pages. I seem to be able to tell within the first few pages and have so many other books I want to read I don't feel badly for moving on. I tried Olive Kitteridge and didn't care for it, but continually read good comments about it, so I may have not given it enough of a chance....and I may need to try it again.



My nemesis is Captain Corelli's Mandolin. I gave up at page 108. It still bugs me that it got to me like that...lol

Even I have a habit of coming back to unfinished books. It really depends on one's
moods. Sometimes I find a previously discarded book interesting, and even vice versa



Books mentioned in this topic
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan (other topics)The Historian (other topics)
Millroy the Magician (other topics)
The Time Traveler's Wife (other topics)
The Post-Birthday World (other topics)
More...